What the translation of tenses tells about the Septuagint translators

10
Ediiors: Knud Jeppesen (Aarhus. Denrnark). Niels Peter Lernche (Copenhagen. Denniark) Assistant editor: Frederick 1-1. Cryer (Copenhagen. Denniark) Ediiorial Board: John Sirange (Copenhagen. Denniark). Hans M. Barstad (Oslo. Norway). Inger Ljung (Uppsala. Sweden). Tryggve N.D. Mettinger (Lund. Sweden). Timo Veijola (Helsinki. Finland). Karl-Johan Iliman (Abo. Finland Edilorial Address: Department of Biblical Studies. University of Aarhus. DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denniark Publication InJi,rmation: Scandinavian Joumal of the Old Testarnent is published biannually by Scandinavian University Press. ISSN 0901 8328. Published with the support from the Nordic Publications Committee for Humanist Periodicals and the University of Aarhus Research Foundation. Subscriplion Rates: Volume 10, 1996 for institutions US$ 75.00, NOK 380.- in the Nordic countries. For individuals US$ 57.00, NOK 260,- in the Nordic countries. Air speed delivery included. Subscription Orders: Scandinavian University Press. P.O. Box 2959 Tøyen, N-0608 Oslo, Norway. Tel: ÷ 47 22 57 5400. Fax: + 47 2257 53 53. E-mail: [email protected]. U.S. office: Scandinavian University Press North America, 875 Massachusetts Ave. Ste. 84, Cambridge, MA 02139 USA. Tel 617 497 6515 Fax 617 3546875 Toll-free tel 800 498 2877. E-mail 75201 [email protected] Information about joumais and books from Scandinavian University Press is available on our honiepage on the world wide web. URL-address http:/Iwww.scup.no. AlI subscriptions in Japan should be ordered through Maruzen Co. Ltd.. 3-10 Nihonbashi 2-chonie. Chuo-ku. Tokyo 103. Japan. Back issues: Orders and inquiries ahout prices and availability should be sent to Scandinavian University Press. Norway. Articles in Scandinavian Joumal of the Old Testameni are covered by the following indexing and abstracting services: Old Testament Abstracts. Relig. Theol. Abstracts. Zeitschrift flr alttestamentliche Wissenschaft and Intertiationale Zeitschriftenschau flr Bibelwissenschaft und Grenzgebiete. © 1996 Scandinavian University Press. AlI articles published in Scandinavian Joumal of the Old Testament are protected by copyright. which covers the exclusive rights 10 reproduce and distribute the article. No material in this journal may be reproduced photographically or stored on microfilm. in electronic data bases, vi4eo or compact disks etc. without prior written permission from Scandinavian University Press. Special regulation for photocopies in the USA: Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use. or the internal and personal use of specific clients. is granted by Scandinavian University Press for libraries and other users registered with the copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that the fee of US$ 9.00 per article is paid 10 CCC, 27 Congress Street. Salem. MA 01970. USA. 0901 8328/96/US$ 9.00. This authorization does not include copying for general distribution. promotion, new works. or resale. In these cases specific written permission must he obtained from Scandinavian University Press. Typesetter: Lemche Texts. Gurre. DK Printers: Galliard (Printers) Ltd.. Great Yarmouth. U.K. Raija Sollamo, The Origins of LXX Studies in Finland Seppo Sipilä, The Tetrapia Is It Ali Greek to Us? Anssi Voitila, Whar the Translation of Tenses Telis About the Sepruagint Translators Staffan Olofsson, The Septuagint and Earlier Jewish Interpretative Tradition Especially as Retlecred in the Targums Staffan Olofsson, Studying the Word Order of the Septuagint. Questions and Possibilities Mogens Muller, Die Abraham-Gestalt im Jubiläenbuch. Versuch einer Interpretation Benedikt Otzen, Das Probiem der Apokryphen Knud Jeppesen, Biblia Hebraica et Septuaginta. A Response to Mogens Muller Klaas A.D. Smelik, Letters to the Exiles. Jeremiah 29 in Context Stereotypes SJOT Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament Volume 10 1996 Number 2 159-168 169-182 183-196 197-216 217-237 238-257 258-270 27 1-28 1 282-295 296-308 309-312 Mark Sneed, The Class Culture 0/ Proverbs: Eliminating Book Reviews: T. Muraoka (ed), Studies in Ancient Hebrew Semantics (Abr-Hahrain Supplement 4) Loren D. Crow, The Songs 0/ Ascents (Psalms 120-134). Their Place in Israelite History and Religion (SBLDS 148)

Transcript of What the translation of tenses tells about the Septuagint translators

Edi

iors

:K

nud

Jepp

esen

(Aar

hus.

Den

rnar

k).

Nie

lsP

eter

Ler

nche

(Cop

enha

gen.

Den

niar

k)

Ass

ista

nted

itor

:F

rede

rick

1-1.

Cry

er(C

open

hage

n.D

enni

ark)

Edi

iori

alB

oard

:Jo

hnS

iran

ge(C

open

hage

n.D

enni

ark)

.H

ans

M.

Bar

stad

(Osl

o.N

orw

ay).

Inge

rL

jung

(Upp

sala

.S

wed

en).

Try

ggve

N.D

.M

etti

nger

(Lun

d.S

wed

en).

Tim

oV

eijo

la(H

elsi

nki.

Fin

land

).K

arl-

Joha

nIl

iman

(Abo

.F

inla

nd

Edi

lori

alA

ddre

ss:

Dep

artm

ent

ofB

ibli

cal

Stu

dies

.U

nive

rsit

yof

Aar

hus.

DK

-800

0A

arhu

sC

,D

enni

ark

Pub

lica

tion

InJi

,rm

atio

n:S

cand

inav

ian

Joum

alof

the

Old

Tes

tarn

ent

ispu

blis

hed

bian

nual

lyby

Sca

ndin

avia

nU

nive

rsit

yP

ress

.IS

SN

0901

8328

.P

ubli

shed

with

the

supp

ort

from

the

Nor

dic

Pub

lica

tion

sC

omm

itte

efo

rH

uman

ist

Per

iodi

cals

and

the

Uni

vers

ity

ofA

arhu

sR

esea

rch

Fou

ndat

ion.

Sub

scri

plio

nR

ates

:V

olum

e10

,19

96fo

rin

stit

utio

nsU

S$75

.00,

NO

K38

0.-

inth

eN

ordi

cco

untr

ies.

For

indi

vidu

als

US

$57

.00,

NO

K26

0,-

inth

eN

ordi

cco

untr

ies.

Air

spee

dde

live

ryin

clud

ed.

Sub

scri

ptio

nO

rder

s:S

cand

inav

ian

Uni

vers

ity

Pre

ss.

P.O

.B

ox29

59T

øyen

,N

-060

8O

slo,

Nor

way

.T

el:

÷47

2257

5400.

Fax:

+47

2257

5353

.E

-mai

l:su

bscr

ipti

on@

scup

.no.

U.S

.of

fice

:Sc

andi

navi

anU

nive

rsity

Pres

sN

orth

Am

eric

a,87

5M

assa

chus

etts

Ave

.S

te.

84,

Cam

brid

ge,

MA

0213

9U

SA. T

el61

749

765

15Fa

x61

73546875

Tol

l-fr

eete

l80

049

828

77.

E-m

ail

7520

1.5

7l@

com

puse

rve.

com

Info

rmat

ion

abou

tjou

mai

san

dbo

oks

from

Sca

ndin

avia

nU

nive

rsit

yP

ress

isav

aila

ble

onou

rho

niep

age

onth

ew

orld

wid

ew

eb.

UR

L-a

ddre

ssht

tp:/

Iww

w.s

cup.

no.

AlI

subs

crip

tion

sin

Japa

nsh

ould

beor

dere

dth

roug

hM

aruz

enC

o.L

td..

3-10

Nih

onba

shi

2-ch

onie

.C

huo-

ku.

Tok

yo10

3.Ja

pan.

Bac

kis

sues

:O

rder

san

din

quir

ies

ahou

tpr

ices

and

avai

labi

lity

shou

ldbe

sent

toS

cand

inav

ian

Uni

vers

ity

Pre

ss.

Nor

way

.

Art

icle

sin

Sca

ndin

avia

nJo

umal

ofth

eO

ldT

esta

men

iar

eco

vere

dby

the

foll

owin

gin

dexi

ngan

dab

stra

ctin

gse

rvic

es:

Old

Tes

tam

ent

Abs

trac

ts.

Rel

ig.

The

ol.

Abs

trac

ts.

Zei

tsch

rift

flr

altt

esta

men

tlic

heW

isse

nsch

aft

and

Inte

rtia

tion

ale

Zei

tsch

rift

ensc

hau

flr

Bib

elw

isse

nsch

aft

und

Gre

nzge

biet

e.

©19

96S

cand

inav

ian

Uni

vers

ity

Pre

ss.

AlI

arti

cles

publ

ishe

din

Sca

ndin

avia

nJo

umal

ofth

eO

ldT

esta

men

tar

epr

otec

ted

byco

pyri

ght.

whi

chco

vers

the

excl

usiv

eri

ghts

10re

prod

uce

and

dist

ribu

teth

ear

ticl

e.N

om

ater

ial

inth

isjo

urna

lm

aybe

repr

oduc

edph

otog

raph

ical

lyor

stor

edon

mic

rofi

lm.

inel

ectr

onic

data

base

s,vi

4eo

orco

mpa

ctdi

sks

etc.

wit

hout

prio

rw

ritt

enpe

rmis

sion

from

Sca

ndin

avia

nU

nive

rsit

yP

ress

.

Spe

cial

regu

lati

onfo

rph

otoc

opie

sin

the

US

A:

Aut

hori

zati

onto

phot

ocop

yit

ems

for

inte

rnal

orpe

rson

alus

e.or

the

inte

rnal

and

pers

onal

use

ofsp

ecif

iccl

ient

s.is

gran

ted

byS

cand

inav

ian

Uni

vers

ity

Pre

ssfo

rli

brar

ies

and

othe

rus

ers

regi

ster

edw

ithth

eco

pyri

ght

Cle

aran

ceC

ente

r(C

CC

)T

rans

acti

onal

Rep

orti

ngS

ervi

ce,

prov

ided

that

the

fee

of

US

$9.

00pe

rar

ticl

eis

paid

10C

CC

,27

Con

gres

sS

tree

t.S

alem

.M

A01

970.

US

A.

0901

8328

/96/

US

$9.

00.

Thi

sau

thor

izat

ion

does

no

tin

clud

eco

pyin

gfo

rge

nera

ldi

stri

buti

on.

prom

otio

n,new

wor

ks.

orre

sale

.In

thes

eca

ses

spec

ific

wri

tten

perm

issi

onm

ust

heob

tain

edfr

omS

cand

inav

ian

Uni

vers

ity

Pre

ss.

Typ

eset

ter:

Lem

che

Tex

ts.

Gur

re.

DK

Pri

nte

rs:

Gal

liar

d(P

rint

ers)

Ltd

..G

reat

Yar

mou

th.

U.K

.

Rai

jaS

olla

mo,

The

Ori

gins

ofL

XX

Stu

dies

inF

inla

nd

Sepp

oSi

pilä

,T

heT

etra

pia

—Is

ItA

liG

reek

toU

s?

Ans

siV

oitil

a,W

har

the

Tra

nsla

tion

ofT

ense

sT

elis

Abo

utth

eS

epru

agin

tT

ransl

ators

Sta

ffan

Olo

fsso

n,T

heS

eptu

agin

tan

dE

arli

erJe

wis

hIn

terp

reta

tive

Tra

diti

on—

Esp

ecia

lly

asR

etle

cred

inth

eT

argu

ms

Sta

ffan

Olo

fsso

n,S

tudy

ing

the

Wor

dO

rder

ofth

eS

eptu

agin

t.Q

uest

ions

and

Pos

sibi

liti

es

Mog

ens

Mul

ler,

Die

Abr

aham

-Ges

talt

imJu

bilä

enbu

ch.

Ver

such

eine

rIn

terp

reta

tion

Ben

edik

tO

tzen

,D

asP

robi

emde

rA

pokr

yphe

n

Knu

dJe

ppes

en,

Bib

lia

Heb

raic

a—

etS

eptu

agin

ta.

AR

espo

nse

toM

ogen

sM

ulle

r

Kla

asA

.D.

Smel

ik,

Let

ters

toth

eE

xile

s.Je

rem

iah

29in

Con

text

Ste

reot

ypes

SJO

TS

cand

inav

ian

Jour

nal

ofth

eO

ldT

esta

men

tV

olum

e10

—19

96—

Num

ber

2

159-

168

169-

182

183-

196

197-

216

217-

237

238-

257

258-

270

271-

281

282-

295

296-

308

309-

312

Mar

kSn

eed,

The

Cla

ssC

ultu

re0/

Pro

verb

s:E

lim

inat

ing

Boo

kR

evie

ws:

T.M

urao

ka(e

d),

Stu

dies

inA

ncie

ntH

ebre

wS

eman

tics

(Abr

-Hah

rain

Sup

plem

ent

4)

Lor

enD

.C

row

,T

heS

ongs

0/

Asc

ents

(Psa

lms

120-

134)

.T

heir

Pla

cein

Isra

elit

eH

isto

ryan

dR

elig

ion

(SB

LD

S14

8)

wha

tth

eT

etra

pia

actu

ally

was

.M

yth

eory

isth

atth

eT

etra

pia

ison

lya

syno

nym

for

the

Hex

apla

.

Abs

trac

t

Iii

this

pape

r1

shal

lex

amin

eth

ean

cien

tso

urce

sm

entio

ning

the

Tet

rapi

a.T

radi

tiona

llyth

iste

rmre

fers

toO

rigen

’sse

cond

editi

onof

the

Hex

apla

,bu

tth

etr

aditi

onal

inte

rpre

tatio

npo

ses

som

edi

ffic

ultie

s.O

urpr

imar

yso

urce

sar

eE

useb

ius’

sE

ccle

sias

tica

lH

isto

ry,

Epi

phan

ius’

sD

em

ensu

ris

eipo

nder

ibus

and

som

eno

tes

inth

eco

loph

ons

ofva

rlou

sbi

blic

alm

anus

crip

s.T

hese

sour

ces

are

not

easy

toin

terp

ret

and

duri

ngth

eIa

st50

year

sva

riou

sat

tem

psto

unde

rsta

ndth

eir

mea

ning

has

publ

ishe

d.N

ever

thel

ess,

orju

stbe

caus

eof

this

,w

edo

not

have

any

com

mon

scho

lary

oppi

nion

abou

tth

eT

etra

pia

toda

y.O

neth

ing

isqu

itec1

ear

the

trad

ition

alin

terp

reta

tion

isno

tth

eon

lypo

ssib

lew

ayto

unde

rsta

ndan

cien

tso

urce

sw

ekn

ow.

vvtIA

11ur

1K

AP

LA

’11

0IN

01’

‘1F

.J’S

ES

TE

LL

SA

BO

UT

TH

ES

EP

TU

AG

INT

TR

AN

SL

AT

OR

S

An

ssi

Voit

ila,

Dep

artm

ent

ofB

ibli

cal

Exe

geti

csP.

O.B

ox33

,F

IN-0

0014

Uni

vers

ity

otH

elsi

nki

Inhi

spa

per

“Tra

nsla

tors

’H

andl

ing

ofV

erb

Ten

sein

Sem

anti

call

yA

mbi

guou

sC

onte

xts

”1

Pro

f.Ja

mes

Bar

rha

sst

ated

that

the

tran

slat

ors

ofth

eL

XX

had

succ

eede

dw

ell

inre

nder

ing

the

verb

tens

e.A

cco

rdin

gto

hirn

,“t

hetr

ansl

ator

sha

vefo

und

the

mos

tsu

itab

leG

reek

tens

ean

dth

atno

oth

erw

ould

have

done

.T

hus

inhi

stor

ical

narr

ativ

e,w

efi

ndlo

ngst

ring

sof

aori

sts;

infu

ture

prop

heci

es,

long

line

sof

futu

res;

inci

rcum

stan

tial

phra

ses,

ofte

npr

esen

tsan

dir

nper

fect

s;in

subord

inat

ecl

ause

s,of

ten

subj

unct

ives

and

othe

rap

prop

riat

eco

nst

ruct

ion

s.”

2P

rof.

Bar

rde

erns

that

this

isdu

eto

the

fact

that

the

mud

dlin

gof

the

verb

tens

esw

ould

have

resu

lted

inan

unus

able

text

.F

urt

her

more

,he

stat

esth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

sdi

dno

tha

vegr

amm

atic

alru

les

ofho

wth

eH

ebre

wve

rbsy

stem

wor

ked,

and

that

they

carr

ied

out

thei

rw

ork

byth

eco

nten

tan

dth

ein

dica

tion

sof

the

cont

ext

they

tran

slat

ed.

Inth

efo

llow

ing

pape

r1

inte

ndto

ques

tion

the

posi

tion

ofP

rof.

Bar

rby

pres

enti

ngso

me

case

sof

wha

tw

em

ayca

llth

e“m

uddl

ing

ofth

eve

rbte

nses

”.H

ism

ain

stat

erne

nts

—th

etr

ansl

ator

did

not

have

any

“pre

cise

orco

mpr

ehen

sive

theo

ryof

how

the

Heb

rew

tens

esw

ork

ed”

3an

dth

ushe

foll

owed

the

indi

cati

ons

give

nby

the

cont

ext

requ

ire

that

ther

ear

eno

verb

forr

nsin

the

tran

slat

ion

whi

chdo

not

fit

into

thei

rco

ntex

tbu

tar

ene

vert

hele

ssin

acco

rdan

cew

ith

the

norm

aleq

uiva

lent

ofth

eH

ebre

wve

rbtr

ansl

ated

.B

arr

give

sa

hypo

thet

ical

exam

ple

ofan

unsu

itab

lere

nder

ing

ie.

supp

ose

that

atG

en2,

6

1P

rese

nted

duri

ngth

eIO

SCS

mee

ting

inJe

rusa

lem

1986

and

publ

ishe

din

Sep

tuag

inr

and

Cog

nate

Siu

dies

23(A

tian

ta19

87),

381-

403.

2B

arr

1987

,38

1.3

Bar

r19

87,

385.

Sca

ndin

avia

nJo

urna

lof

the

Old

Tes

tam

ent

vol.

10no

.2

(199

6)©

Sca

ndin

avia

nU

nive

rsit

yPr

ess

184

Ans

siV

oiti

laW

hat

the

Tra

nsla

tion

ofT

ense

ste

lis

185

yiqt

ol&

‘ha

dbe

entr

ansi

ated

inth

efu

ture

tens

ein

stea

dof

the

im

perf

ect.

Inad

diti

onto

the

case

sw

here

past

and

futu

rear

eco

nfus

ed—

the

ques

tion

rais

edby

prof

.B

arr

—1

wili

put

forw

ard

exam

pies

ofcon

fusi

ngpr

esen

tan

dpa

st.

1kn

owth

atth

ere

are

also

case

sw

here

the

pres

ent

mig

htha

vebe

enin

tend

edby

the

Heb

rew

auth

or

but

the

fu

ture

has

been

used

inth

etr

ansl

atio

nor

even

the

oth

erw

ayro

und.

The

seca

ses

how

ever

are

very

diff

icul

tsi

nce

itis

aim

ost

impo

ssib

ieto

prov

eth

ein

tent

ions

ofth

eau

thor

ofth

eso

urce

text

asw

eli

asth

ose

ofth

etr

ansl

ator

.T

hepr

esen

tan

dth

efu

ture

are

sore

late

din

both

lang

uage

sth

atth

ere

isal

way

sth

epo

ssib

ilit

yth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

has

inte

rpre

ted

the

cont

ext

diff

eren

tly

from

us.

Act

uall

y,th

eH

ebre

wdi

d

not

have

afu

ture

inth

ew

ayG

reek

does

.4

The

mat

eria

lre

sear

ched

incl

udes

only

nar

rati

ve

sect

ions

inth

e

Pen

tate

uch

—of

cour

sein

ciud

ing

dire

ctdi

scou

rse.

Due

toth

ela

rge

amou

ntof

mat

eria

lin

Gen

,E

xan

dN

uon

lyce

rtai

nse

ctio

nsar

ein

clud

ed,

nam

ely

Gen

2,1-

8,21

;12

,1-2

0,18

;37

;39

-50;

Ex

1,1-

11,2

0;

13,1

7-19

,25;

24;

32,1

-34,

9.28

-35;

Lv

7,37

-10,

20;

24,1

0-14

.23;

Nu

1;

9,15

-23;

10,1

1-14

,45;

16,1

-17,

28;

20,1

-25,

19;

Dtn

1-3,

29;

9-10

,11;

31,1

-

8;34

,1-1

2.

QA

TA

L

Fir

stof

ali

1w

iIl

disc

uss

som

eca

ses

ofth

eqa

tai

inw

hich

the

cont

ext

wou

idha

vere

quir

eda

tran

slat

ion

othe

rth

anth

epa

stte

nse.

Gen

44,2

0:K

PK

x’

V’?

KI

inm

na

flR

—K

ajs3

tcL

.Lv

...

Kaj

3tc

LL

60V

io

vrJn

r.Qov

ai

6å8

q,

6ato

i3åit

9av

sv,ctt

66

i6vo

ssp

Or

tijn

tgj

a9oi

5,6

öa3ta

tfQa6t6v

&Jt

wje

V.

Inth

ispa

rtic

ular

case

the

qata

i,be

ing

ast

ativ

e,do

esno

tde

note

anai

read

yco

mpl

eted

acti

onbu

ta

cont

inou

sst

ate.

Thi

sco

uld

aiso

hecon

clud

edfr

omth

eia

rger

cont

ext.

Bot

hpe

rson

sun

der

disc

ussi

on,

the

youn

ger

bro

ther

who

isio

ved

and

the

fath

erw

holo

ves,

are

stii

lve

ry

muc

hal

ive.

Nev

erth

eles

sth

eao

rist

indi

cati

vein

stea

dof

the

pres

ent

is

4T

heG

reek

futu

reex

pres

ses

time

and

pres

ents

the

actio

nas

afa

ct.,

see

Rap

hael

Kuh

ner

-B

ernh

ard

Ger

th,

Aus

fuhr

iche

Gra

mm

atik

der

Gri

echi

sche

nS

prac

he.

11:1

-2S

atzl

ehre

(Dri

tteA

ufla

ge:

Han

nove

r-L

eipz

ig18

98-

1904

).T

heH

ebre

wyi

qtol

,on

the

oth

erha

nd,

may

beus

edal

soas

apr

esen

tor

past

tens

e.Y

iqto

lha

sal

sova

riou

sm

odal

uses

,se

ePa

ulJo

uon,

Gra

mm

aire

de1’

hbre

ubi

bliq

ue(E

ditio

nph

olom

echa

niqu

eco

rrig

e[R

ome

1923

],G

raz

1965

).

used

.O

ther

corr

espo

ndin

goc

curr

ence

sap

pear

inG

en1,

21an

d2

2,2

.

Gen

46,3

2:bi

,uji

r’,y

ij

T‘W

KZ

ir

b—

oiö

&V

6Q

Sstr

nv

itotisv.

av6Q

Bya

Kt1

V0tQ

O(0

tfl

QY

Kai

taK

tflV

flK

ai

tOU

c6a

aj

st&

vta

t&ati

Sv&

yE

t6X

aaiv

.

The

nom

inal

and

the

foll

owin

gve

rbal

clau

sear

ebo

thtr

ansl

ated

into

Gre

ekby

the

verb

e.t

t.E

ven

thou

ghbo

thex

pres

sion

spi

ctur

eth

esa

me

stat

eof

affa

irs

inth

epr

esen

tof

dire

ctdi

scou

rse

—M

yso

ns,

the

bro

ther

sof

Jose

phar

esh

ephe

rds

and

catt

lebr

eede

rs—

,th

epr

esen

tin

dica

tive

appe

ars

asan

equi

vale

ntin

the

nom

inal

clau

sebu

tin

the

verb

aicl

ause

the

qata

lof

the

verb

alro

ot‘i

isre

nder

edby

the

impe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

ofth

esa

me

verb

.P

rovi

ded

that

the

nom

inal

clau

seis

tran

slat

edby

ave

rb,

the

equi

vale

ntus

edis

usua

llyth

epr

esen

tm

di

cati

ve.

Ren

deri

ngs

ofth

iski

ndin

dica

teth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

does

not

alw

ays

pay

atte

ntio

nev

ento

the

mos

tim

med

iate

cont

ext

heha

sju

sttr

ansl

ated

but

tran

slat

eson

lylim

ited

segm

ents

ata

tim

ean

don

lyac

cord

ing

toth

ein

dica

tors

ofth

atpa

rtic

ular

segm

ent.

Inth

isve

rbal

ciau

seth

ein

dica

tor

isth

eqa

tal

whi

chac

cord

ing

toth

eno

rmal

man

ner

oftr

ansl

atin

gis

the

past

tens

e.P

rof.

Ilm

ari

Sois

alon

-Soi

nine

nha

sde

velo

ped

the

idea

oftr

ansl

ator

sw

orki

ngon

lyon

shor

tse

gmen

tsat

ati

me.

6A

sa

proo

fhe

has

pre

sent

edva

rlou

ssy

ntac

tica

lph

enom

ena

that

beco

me

unde

rsta

ndab

ieon

lyif

the

segm

enti

zing

man

ner

oftr

ansl

atin

gis

pres

umed

.T

hese

type

sof

phen

omen

aar

eap

odot

icK

Ui,

repe

titi

onof

the

corr

elat

ein

the

rela

tive

clau

se,

cond

itio

nal

clau

ses

wit

hout

am

ain

clau

se,

ap

arti

cipi

umco

niun

ctum

-str

uctu

rei.e

.a

conn

ecte

dpa

rtic

iple

the

subj

ect

ofw

hich

does

not

agre

ew

ith

lism

ain

verb

and

oth

eran

acol

utha

econ

5F

ried

rjch

Bla

ss-

Alb

ert

Dcb

runn

er,

Gra

mm

atik

des

Neu

tesi

amen

tlic

hen

Grie

chis

ch(B

earb

eite

tvo

nF

ried

rich

Reh

kopf

;16

.durc

hges

ehen

eA

ufla

ge;

Göt

tinge

n19

84),

(33

3.2.

Anm

.5)

cons

ider

sth

ese

case

sas

the

per

fect

ive

aori

st. T

hegr

amm

arm

entio

nsas

anex

ampl

eG

en22

,2:

A&

Ilst6v

ui

6vno

ot6v

åyas

nyr6

v,6v

&it

r)0w

.T

hew

ayof

com

prch

endi

ngis

natu

rally

due

toth

ela

ckof

the

gene

ral

pict

ure

ofth

ere

nder

ings

ofve

rbfo

rms

inth

eSe

ptua

gmnt

.6

Ilm

ari

Sois

alon

-Soi

njne

n,“B

eoba

chtu

ngen

zur

Arb

eits

wei

sede

rS

eptu

agin

ta-U

bers

etze

r”,

Isac

Leo

See

ligm

ann

Vol

.II

I(J

erus

alem

1983

),31

9-32

9,al

sopu

blis

hed

inS

tudi

enzu

rS

eptu

agin

taS

ynta

x(H

erau

sgeg

eben

von

Ann

eli

Aej

mel

aeus

und

Rai

jaSo

llam

o;H

elsi

nki

1987

),28

-39.

Fur

thcr

stud

ies

onse

gmen

tati

onas

acri

teri

on

oftr

ansl

atio

iite

chni

que,

see

Rai

jaS

olla

mo,

Ren

deri

ngs

of

Heb

rew

Sem

ipre

posi

tion

sin

the

Sep

suag

ini

(AA

SF

BD

iss

19;

Hel

sink

i19

79),

136

n1;

Jam

esB

arr,

“The

Typ

olog

yof

Lite

ralis

min

Anc

ient

Bib

lical

Tra

nsla

tion”

,M

SUX

V(1

979)

,29

4-30

3;A

nnel

iA

ejm

ela

eus,

Par

atax

isin

the

Sep

tuag

int

(AA

SF

BD

iss

31;

Hel

sink

i19

82),

30.

186

Ans

siV

oiti

la

stru

ctio

nsan

dso

on.

The

seph

enom

ena

show

that

the

tran

slat

ors

wer

e

seid

omco

nsci

ous

ofth

efo

llow

ing

cont

ext,

whi

chha

dno

tye

tbe

en

tran

slat

ed,

and

wer

ebe

tter

info

rmed

onth

epa

rtof

the

text

they

had

just

tran

slat

ed.

Itm

ay,

how

ever

,be

conc

lude

dfr

omm

yex

ampl

esth

at

they

wer

eno

tal

way

saw

are

ofth

epr

evio

usco

ntex

tei

ther

.

Ex

1,18

:b

’T

1,’fl

flK

“fl

fl1

imiflfl2

ri

V1L)

I1ZK

1h*1)

D’1

D—

aK

&O

EV

6aats

Ay6

3nou

t&ic

’tcu

ccii

stsv

ata

tT

ibt

titotat

t62t

Q&

Wa

t&3t

oic

a*xry

ovT

tct&

&av

a.

The

acti

vity

ofth

em

idw

ives

had

sure

lyco

ntin

ued

unti

lP

hara

oh’s

prev

enti

veac

tion

and

wou

ldst

iliha

vebe

engo

ing

onw

itho

utit,

but

the

tran

slat

orus

eshi

sus

ual

equi

vale

ntfo

rqa

tal.

(Con

trar

yto

the

pre

viou

sex

ampl

esin

Gen

,th

etr

ansi

atio

nis

suit

able

for

the

pres

ent

con

text

.)

Nu

9,23

:

i1’

mr’

‘D1

riew

IirI

’h’

)ZZ5

1zfl

KW

Dfl

lVD

‘nii

IVfl

51

D7

—it

töt

&

tOaty

).L

atO

c)c

uQ

OU

&3

tap

o3

atv

,tT

VpucL

KT

V)C

UQ

LO

U.w

v)&

.avt

o&

&3tQ

OG

t&W

cLtO

cK

IJQ

1OU

VX&

tQiM

uaij

.

Thi

sex

ampl

eis

part

ofla

rger

sect

ion

begi

nnin

gw

ith

vers

e16

,th

at

cont

ains

seri

esof

iter

ativ

e-ha

bitu

alyi

qtol

and

weq

atal

form

sin

nar

rati

ve.

Thi

sse

ctio

nde

scri

bes

how

the

Isra

elit

esw

ere

led

onth

eir

jour

ney

from

Sina

ito

Can

aan.

Des

pite

the

iter

ativ

ean

dab

ove

ali

nar

rati

veco

ntex

tth

eau

thor

ofL

XX

-Num

bers

has

mai

nly

used

the

fu

ture

indi

cati

veas

aneq

uiva

lent

inth

ese

chap

ters

,bu

tin

this

part

icul

ar

case

qata

i,w

hich

atth

een

dof

this

sect

ion

seem

sm

erel

yto

stat

eth

e

prec

edin

gac

tion

sas

orde

red

byG

od,

istr

ansl

ated

wit

hth

eno

rmal

equi

vale

nt,

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

.T

his

rend

erin

gde

mon

stra

tes

that

the

tran

slat

orw

orke

don

ash

ort

unit

ata

tim

ean

dth

athe

noti

ced

the

chan

geof

verb

form

:th

ere

was

qata

l,qa

tal

ispa

stte

nse,

and

henc

ehe

rend

ered

itw

ith

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

wit

hout

cons

ider

ing

itssu

itab

ilit

y

toth

eco

ntex

t.

Nu

25,1

8:T

I10

51

,1IL

YXD

flD

’—

iht

axeQ

cLiv

ouc,

tvcL

otO

LL

!V

vot6

utt

,6oa

öo.to

i5c,

tvi[

L&

6L&cIo

7()Q

.

Thi

sis

also

ast

rang

eca

se.

As

isin

dica

ted

byth

eco

njun

ctio

n,

this

is

anex

pian

ator

ycl

ause

,th

eex

plan

atio

nco

nsis

ting

ofa

past

acti

on.

Wha

tpr

eced

es,

isac

tual

lya

narr

ativ

eof

how

the

oppr

essi

onw

aspu

t

toan

end.

Wha

tha

sIe

dth

etr

ansl

ator

toth

ink

ofa

pres

ent

verb

form

isth

eH

ebre

wpa

rtic

iple

,th

em

ost

usua

leq

uiva

lent

ofw

hich

isth

e

Wha

tth

eT

rans

latj

onot

Ten

ses

teli

s18

7

presen

tin

dica

tive

.T

here

nder

ing

ofqa

tai

byth

esa

me

equi

vale

ntdc

mon

stra

tes

that

the

auth

orof

the

LX

X-N

umbe

rsw

as

stil

iaw

are

ofhi

spr

evio

uscl

ause

,bu

tth

ese

two

Gre

ekve

rbfo

rms

toge

rher

show

the

tran

slat

or’s

inab

ilit

yto

keep

inm

md

iarg

erun

itsof

the

text

.W

em

ayco

nclu

defr

omth

epr

eced

ing

case

sth

atat

leas

tin

thes

eve

rses

“the

cont

ext

has

not

sele

cted

the

Gre

ekte

nse

for

itse

lf”,

7bu

tth

atth

etr

ansl

atio

nsar

eba

sed

onth

eH

ebre

wte

nses

ofth

eV

orla

ge.

The

foil

owin

gex

ampl

esal

iof

them

from

Num

bers

wiii

stre

ngth

enth

isob

serv

atjo

nev

enm

ore.

Inal

ith

ese

exam

ples

the

qata

iap

pear

sin

the

hist

oric

aina

rrat

ive

and

ispr

eced

edby

the

conj

unct

ion

we.

Acc

ordi

ngto

trad

itio

nal

Heb

rew

gram

mar

sw

e+

qata

iw

hich

foll

ows

apa

stte

nse

verb

form

and

whi

chdo

esno

tin

dica

teit

erat

jve

orha

bitu

alac

tion

inth

epa

stsh

ould

beta

ken

asqa

tal

wit

hth

eco

pula

tive

we,

and

not

asco

nsec

utiv

ete

nse

.8

Nu

14,1

3:x

i-ii

(14)

,-m,

hK‘h

••

ILh

‘1?X

1ui

eui

nm

flK

n—

lcai

B!t

sv

Mw

uai

3tQ6

K6flov

KcLj

&K

o6cJB

tat

Ar’

ytji

ttoit

&vct.

va6t

aouu6v

cåv

to3t

ovcutv,

14&

J&ic

aj3

t&V

tSO

iI(U

TotIc

o3vT

Et3Iitj7ij

icz6tr

cL

KT

pC

6cW

LV

0tt

.

The

larg

erco

ntex

tis

evid

ent:

the

Egy

ptia

nsm

ust

aire

ady

have

hear

dw

hat

God

had

done

for

the

Isra

elit

es,

but

the

tran

slat

ordo

esno

tcon

cern

him

self

wit

hth

eco

ntex

tbu

tre

nder

sac

cord

ing

toth

eH

ebre

wve

rbfo

rmw

hich

heha

sun

ders

tood

asw

eqat

ai.

Nee

dles

sto

say,

for

the

tran

slat

orw

eqat

alis

used

for

the

futu

re.

He

rend

ers

itw

ith

the

futu

rein

dica

tive

.T

hefo

ilow

ing

qata

iw

ith

copu

iati

vew

eha

sno

tre

ceiv

edan

equi

vale

ntin

Gre

ek,

but

aire

ady

the

thir

dqa

tal

now

wit

hou

tth

eco

njun

ctio

nha

sbe

enre

nder

edby

the

perf

ect

indi

cati

ve.

Thi

ssh

ows

agai

nho

wm

uch

the

tran

slat

oris

boun

dby

the

form

and

the

deta

iis

ofhi

sso

urue

text

.

Nu

14,2

4:n1

L’r

’uri

niz

K2

WK

1R

fl‘K

Y’h

X’m

‘iri

cV

iIv

,roc

im77P

I‘7

tcti

IIou

Xa,6tt

yEvi

lOfl

itvs

5iato

vv

atS

ai

ico

.o6

-O

ricjv

iot,

cti

cti

h6

vtf1v

‘yij

v,E

flvaO

sv

ais,ai

i:6rn

tQJI

cIa6to

i3)C

.T)Q

OV

OU

icJtct

6tiv

.

inth

isse

nten

ceth

efi

rst

qata

lan

dth

efo

ilow

ing

way

yiqt

oiar

eas

usua

lly

tran

siat

edby

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

,ai

thou

ghth

eid

eaof

the

Heb

rew

text

issu

reiy

tode

scri

beth

epr

esen

tst

ate

ofC

aleb

.T

heth

ird

7Se

eB

arr

1987

,38

5.8

See

for

exam

pie

S.R

.D

rive

r,A

Tre

atis

eon

the

Use

ofth

eT

ense

sin

Heb

rew

(Oxf

ord

1892

),§

133.

r

188

Ans

siV

oiti

laW

hat

the

Tra

nsla

rjon

ofT

ense

ste

lis

189

qata

iho

wev

er,

wit

hco

puia

tive

we,

isgi

ven

itsus

ual

equi

vale

nt,

not

beca

use

itno

wsu

itsth

ela

rger

cont

ext

but

rath

erbe

caus

eth

etr

ansi

a

tor

inte

rpre

ted

itas

weq

atal

and

tran

slat

edac

cord

ingl

y.

InN

u10

,11-

25w

ear

eto

ldho

wth

eIs

raei

ites

for

the

firs

tti

me

left

thei

rca

mp-

site

inth

ew

iider

ness

.T

heex

pres

sion

“for

the

firs

tti

me”

is

expl

icit

lyst

ated

inve

rse

13.

Inve

rses

11to

16th

eqa

tai

and

way

yiq

toi

form

sar

eus

edan

dth

eyar

etr

ansi

ated

byth

eao

rist

indi

cati

ves

into

the

Gre

ek.

Aft

erth

atse

quen

cefr

omve

rse

17on

war

dsth

ere

are

six

case

sof

w+

qata

i.In

ali

thes

ew

+qa

tai

case

sth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve

isus

edas

aneq

uiva

lent

desp

ite

the

past

tim

ena

rrat

ive

cont

ext

that

is

tell

ing

ali

alon

gab

out

the

sam

eev

ent.

Thi

ski

ndof

chan

gein

tens

esis

unco

mm

onin

the

Heb

rew

.T

hegr

amm

aria

nsha

vetr

ied

toex

piai

nit

inva

riou

sw

ays.

9It

isve

rydi

ffic

uit

tobe

liev

eth

atit

sim

ply

indi

cate

s

ash

ift

from

the

sim

pie

narr

ativ

eto

the

desc

ript

ion

ofw

hat

usua

liy

happ

ened

.F

orth

epu

rpos

esof

our

pres

ent

disc

ussi

onit

does

not

mat

ter

wha

tth

eri

ght

answ

eris,

but

we

may

bece

rtai

nth

atth

etr

ansi

ator

noti

ced

the

chan

geof

verb

aifo

rms

and

proc

eede

din

his

wor

kac

cord

ingl

y.F

orth

etr

ansl

ator

the

verb

form

sw

ere

tobe

take

nas

weq

atal

s

and

the

equi

vale

ntw

asna

tura

lly

the

futu

rein

dica

tive

.

Nu

10,1

7: UJ

‘T

’7D

Ipuie

fl]fl

—Kc

LK

a8E

)Oi5

UL

Vti

1vcviv

ai

,aøoik

jtv

oiuo

iF

s&

vic

aio

uioi

MSQ

LQ

icL

QovtB

tiv

cjK

TIv

jv.

Nu

10,2

1:On

?pu

hzi

flKY

2i!f

l)hpen

‘w‘nip

i—

caiaoatv

otooi

Ka&

9

aQ

ovtr

.t&

&yt

aK

ai

ar6cournv

rvaK

flv

v,iw

&v

itapa’y

Vow

tat.

Nu

10,2

5:bflK

’fl

11?z

fl‘‘

7‘D

Kr

p‘

mfl?

z7

7Dfl

—K

cLL

EE

.UD

OU

GtV

twy

LcL

3cL

QE

LJ3

0-

?i

u&iv

I&v

£aK

atot

itcw

&iv

t&iv

ita

tpoX

&v

ciiv

&)V

&L

EL

cL&

t(O

V.

Itse

ems

that

atie

ast

inth

eex

ampl

esab

ove

the

cont

ext

has

not

infi

uenc

edth

etr

ansl

ator

’sde

cisi

onbu

tbe

caus

ehe

wor

ked

only

on

shor

tun

its

ata

time,

hew

asbo

und

byth

eac

tual

wor

ding

ofhi

s

sour

ceto

such

anex

tent

that

the

resu

itw

asno

tai

way

ssu

cces

sfui

.

The

oppo

site

also

occu

rs.

The

futu

rein

dica

tive

isai

sous

edco

rrec

tly

asan

equi

vaie

ntof

qata

lin

conn

ecti

ons

whe

reqa

tai

indi

cate

sac

tion

,

the

com

piet

ion

ofw

hich

isth

ough

tto

happ

endu

ring

the

acti

onof

9Se

eD

river

1892

§14

8f;

W.

Ges

eniu

s-

E.K

au

tzsc

h,

Ges

eniu

sH

ebre

w

Gra

mm

aras

edit

edan

den

larg

edby

the

late

E.

Kau

tzsc

h(E

nglis

hed

ition

byA

.E.

Cow

ley;

Oxf

ord

1910

).§

112

e,kk

;B

oJo

hnso

n,H

ebrä

isch

es

Per

fek

tun

dIm

per

fekt

mi

vora

ngeh

ende

mw

e(C

BO

TS

13;

Lund

1979

),

42ff

.

spea

king

even

thou

ghit

isac

tual

lyre

aiis

edon

lyin

the

futu

re.

Ver

ses

Gen

14,2

2;15

,18

and

Le

9,4

cont

ain

the

qata

ifo

rms

ofth

isty

pe.

Thi

sty

peof

qata

lis

som

etim

estr

ansi

ated

byth

epe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

orev

enby

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

,th

eid

eabe

ing

tost

ress

the

com

plet

ion

duri

ngth

esp

eaki

ng.

Ren

deri

ngs

ofth

iski

ndar

eno

tto

beta

ken

asd

emo

nst

rati

ons

ofth

etr

ansl

ator

’sin

abii

ity

toun

ders

tand

the

use

and

mea

nin

gof

the

Heb

rew

tens

es,

but

rath

eras

evid

ence

ofhi

sca

refo

rth

ere

quir

emen

tsof

the

cont

ext.

On

the

basi

sof

the

foii

owin

gex

ampi

esit

mig

htal

sobe

clai

med

that

the

cont

ext

has

infi

uenc

edth

etr

ansl

atio

npr

oces

s,so

not

only

the

verb

form

sbu

tal

soth

eco

ntex

tm

ayha

vebr

ough

tth

eid

eaof

iter

ativ

ity

toth

etr

ansi

ator

sm

md.

Ex

16,2

1::D

?iue

u5n

nrn

‘½K‘

W’K

Ij

ip

inc

1ujL

Y—

Kai

GuvE

avat6

JtQ

0)t

itQw

i,K

czcrto

t6K

aGij

KoV

cL

t&.

ivic

cz6

&9p

Wxt

vBv

6j)

.to,

tiii

sto

.B

oth

ofth

ese

qata

ifo

rms

are

prec

eded

byth

eco

puia

tive

we

and

the

tran

slat

orof

Exo

dus

may

have

inte

rpre

ted

them

asw

eqat

alfo

rms,

thus

heha

sco

nsid

ered

them

asit

erat

ive-

habj

tual

inth

ena

rrat

ive

con

text

and

tran

siat

edth

emac

cord

ingi

yby

the

impe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

.T

hese

qata

lfo

rms

may

not

bein

terp

rete

das

cons

ecut

ive

beca

use

they

are

prec

eded

byw

ayyi

qtol

.F

urth

erm

ore

the

Ip

“eve

rym

orn

ing”

whi

chm

aype

rhap

sbe

caile

dan

iter

ativ

ein

dica

tor

appe

ars

inth

efi

rst

part

ofth

eve

rse.

Fur

ther

evid

ence

that

the

tran

siat

orha

ndie

sth

een

dof

the

vers

eas

aw

hoie

isth

ere

nder

ing

ofth

epa

rata

ctic

con

stru

ctio

nw

ith

the

conj

unct

ion

jvca

&.

Sim

ilar

sequ

ence

sof

qata

lfo

rms

conn

ecte

dw

ith

copu

lati

vew

ear

efo

und

inN

u11

,8.

The

ym

ayno

tbe

inte

rpre

ted

asw

eqat

alfo

rms

be

caus

eth

eyar

ein

turn

prec

eded

byth

esi

mpl

eqa

tai.

But

inth

isca

seth

efi

rst

qata

lw

itho

utth

eco

puia

tive

we

isai

read

yre

nder

edby

the

impe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

and

anot

her

prec

eded

byin

the

mid

dle.

Inth

etr

eati

ses

ofD

rive

r’°

and

Ges

eniu

s-K

autz

sch”

itis

stat

edth

atw

eqat

aim

aybe

foun

dal

soaf

ter

past

tens

esan

dth

atth

iski

ndof

sequ

ence

shou

ldhe

unde

rsto

odas

iter

ativ

e.It

coul

dal

sobe

mai

ntaj

ned

that

inth

isve

rse

weq

atai

isus

edin

the

iter

ativ

ese

nse

afte

rpa

stte

nse

verb

form

s.T

heco

ntex

tm

akes

itev

iden

tth

atth

ese

verb

sin

dica

tean

acti

onth

atis

repe

ated

ever

yda

y.H

owev

er,

inth

eH

ebre

wla

ngua

geqa

tal

isof

ten

used

whe

nac

cord

ing

toou

rIi

ngui

stic

inst

inct

the

acti

on

10D

rive

r18

92,

§11

4a.

11G

esen

ius-

Kau

tzsc

h19

10,

§11

2h.

190

Ans

siV

oiti

laW

hat

the

Tra

nsla

tion

otT

ense

ste

lis

191

shou

ldbe

unde

rsto

odas

repe

ated

.So

intu

itiv

ely,

bym

eans

ofth

eco

n

text

,th

etr

ansl

ator

coul

dha

vego

tth

eid

eath

atth

isve

rse

need

edan

iter

ativ

ere

nder

ing.

Nu

11,8

:t3

Dfl

mx

5Z“

1111

‘‘

222

1t91

112i

Z2

—w

ai

g9

EU

EtO

6)a6

Kai

Uuvt0

Y,

Kai

2fl0V

cn

’rt

6v

ti

1IQ

11I9

31L

Vtf

lO

osut

,K

aifl

PY

cwco

LV

tflX

QL

JtO

tOU

V

at

6y

KQ

Uq

Rw

,K

ai

TV

iio

vjct

6tO

ii

()G

Bi

yE

icL

&yK

QU,

cL

LO

U-.

Tra

nsla

tion

tech

nica

lly,

the

initi

alse

ven

men

tion

edca

ses

ofqa

tal

dif

fer

from

the

rest

byap

pear

ing

alon

ein

thei

rco

ntex

ts,

mos

tof

them

wit

hout

the

addi

tion

alco

njun

ctio

nw

e,w

hile

the

rest

ofth

eex

ampl

es

are

foun

din

chai

nsof

mor

eth

anon

eqa

tal

form

conn

ecte

dby

con

junc

tion

s.If

we

cons

ider

the

tran

slat

ion

proc

ess,

the

diff

eren

cein

mea

ning

and

inti

me

ism

uch

easi

erto

perc

eive

whe

nth

eve

rbfo

rm

appe

ars

ina

seri

esm

arke

dby

the

addi

tion

alco

njun

ctio

n,w

hich

may

sign

ify

ach

ange

inm

eani

ng,

than

whe

nth

eqa

tal

appe

ars

alon

esu

r

roun

ded

byot

her

verb

form

sw

ith

diff

eren

tm

eani

ngS

and

times

.

WA

YY

IQT

OL

The

way

yiqt

olm

ayal

sobe

foun

din

aco

ntex

tw

here

the

norm

alpa

st

tens

eus

eof

way

yiqt

olan

dth

em

eani

ngof

the

cont

ext

are

inco

nfli

ct

wit

hea

chot

her.

But

asth

isph

enom

enof

lis

very

rare

,it

may

beco

n

clud

edth

atth

ew

ayyi

qtol

does

not

appe

aras

ofte

nin

diff

icul

tan

din

terp

reta

tive

conn

ectio

nSas

did

the

qata

l.W

ayyi

qtO

lis

alm

ost

excl

us

ivel

yth

eve

rbfo

rmof

nar

rati

on

.12

Intw

oof

thes

eca

ses,

whi

chap

pear

inE

xodu

s,th

ew

ayyi

qtol

is

form

edfr

omth

ero

ot

Ex

3,17

:‘1

yiK

?Kw

aD

flK

&33

,x,z

x,

17...n

x‘f

l1D

72

UK

7—

yw

v

‘Euo

KoJ

tjjtcJK

Liat

...

17K

ctt

‘Av

aj3

tf1&

LT

iEic

Ktia

K()

cLuM

t&iv

Ai’

yutT

i(i)

Vsi

ctf1v

‘y?j

vtv

Xav

avai

wV

.

Thi

sve

rse

isa

part

ofla

rger

spee

chin

whi

chG

odad

dres

ses

Mos

esin

orde

rto

libe

rate

Isra

elfr

omE

gypt

.In

vers

e17

God

telis

wha

the

has

just

deci

ded,

zvi

Thi

sw

ayyi

qtol

has

alm

ost

the

sam

em

eani

ngas

qata

l“t

oex

pres

sac

tions

whi

chal

thou

ghre

ally

only

inpr

oces

s

ofac

com

plis

hmen

t,ar

ene

vert

hele

ssm

eant

tobe

repr

esen

ted

asal

read

yac

com

plis

hed

inth

eco

ncep

tion

ofth

esp

eaker

”,’

3w

hich

no

r

mal

lyis

tran

slat

edby

the

pres

ent

indi

cati

ve.

Itw

ould

have

been

mor

e

12F

orth

eus

ean

dm

eani

ngof

way

yiqt

olse

eJo

uon

1923

118.

13G

esen

ius-

Kau

tzS

Ch

§10

6i.

appr

opri

ate

here

asw

ell.

The

text

asII

now

stan

dsm

akes

the

read

erth

ink

ofso

met

hing

that

issa

idea

rlie

rin

the

text

.T

here

nder

ing

ofth

epr

evio

usqa

tal

byth

epe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

stre

ngth

ens

this

inte

rpre

tati

on.

Ex

4,23

: “3

nK&?

ILY

,?K

‘5D

K23

?K1W

”0

Kn

n1rl

Kfl

PK

—a

psu

tijS

Iapa

(x,

T&8eet

KU

QL

O(

Y6

3tQ

(O

t6t0

K6

L0

U‘l

aQcL

Tl)

..23

cmi

‘Ew

toar

et).

ovt6va6v

piou

,va

ioi).atps

6ali.

Thi

sw

ayyi

qtol

isus

edin

the

sam

em

anne

ras

the

prev

ious

one.

God

isag

ain

orde

ring

Mos

eson

how

hesh

ould

perf

orm

and

spea

kbe

fore

the

Pha

raoh

inth

eim

med

iate

futu

re.

Ver

se22

begi

nsw

ith

weq

atal

whi

chis

prec

eded

byth

eH

ebre

wim

pera

tive

and

weq

atal

form

sal

iha

ving

the

sam

eim

pera

tive

mea

ning

.T

hew

ayyi

qtol

seem

sun

usua

lin

this

cont

ext.

The

tran

slat

orfo

llow

sth

eH

ebre

wve

rbfo

rms

and

rend

ers

the

weq

atal

form

byth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve—

whi

chha

san

impe

rati

vem

eani

ngin

Gre

ek—

afte

rth

atth

efo

llow

ing

qata

lis

give

nth

ep

rese

ntin

dica

tive

asan

equi

vale

nt.

Itis

all

the

mor

esu

rpri

sing

that

the

way

yiqt

olis

then

rend

ered

byth

epa

stte

nse,

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

.T

hetr

ansl

atio

nw

ould

have

been

corr

ect

ifM

oses

had

aire

ady

spok

ento

Pha

raoh

.In

tere

stin

gly

enou

gh,

the

vers

eis

cont

inue

dby

the

Heb

rew

imp

erat

ive

and

copu

lati

veyi

qtol

,w

hich

has

been

unde

rsto

odas

afi

nal

clau

seby

the

tran

slat

or.

Aft

erth

isse

quen

ceth

ere

appe

ars

inth

eM

Tan

othe

rw

ayyi

qtol

whi

chin

turn

has

rece

ived

the

pres

ent

indi

cati

veas

aneq

uiva

lent

,fu

rthe

rmor

eth

eH

ebre

wpa

rata

xis

has

been

rend

ered

wit

ha

cond

itio

nal

clau

se.

The

prob

lem

isw

hyw

eha

vehe

reth

epr

esen

tin

dica

tive

whe

nth

epr

evio

usw

ayyi

qtol

was

tran

slat

edas

past

tens

e?T

heus

eof

aco

ndit

iona

lcl

ause

and

pres

ent

indi

cati

vehe

rem

ayin

dic

ate

that

the

tran

slat

orre

ada

copu

lati

veyi

qtol

into

his

tex

t.14

Itm

ayho

wev

eral

sobe

unde

rsto

odas

ade

mon

stra

tion

ofth

etr

ansl

ator

’sab

ilit

yto

hand

leam

bigu

ous

cont

exts

like

this

one

whe

reth

ein

terp

reta

tion

ofm

eani

ngof

the

verb

whe

ther

past

orpr

esen

t,is

not

goin

gto

obsc

ure

the

inte

ntio

nof

the

sour

cete

xt.

The

tran

slat

orre

nder

edth

ese

clau

ses

asa

who

le,

hedi

dno

tsi

mpl

ytr

ansl

ate

indi

vidu

alw

ords

.T

hew

ayyi

qtol

case

inE

x9,

15co

ntai

nsan

exam

ple

ofth

etr

ansl

ato

r’s

free

inte

rpre

tati

onof

this

norm

ally

past

tens

eve

rbfo

rm.

The

seve

rbfo

rms

are

incl

uded

ina

long

dire

ctdi

scou

rse

whe

rein

vers

e14

God

isth

reat

enin

gP

hara

ohw

ith

futu

repu

nish

men

t,in

vers

e15

the

14“T

heSe

ptua

gint

tran

slat

ion

wit

ha

cond

ition

alse

ncen

ceis

inke

epin

gw

ithth

eco

ntex

t,th

epre

seni

tens

ebe

ing

base

don

the

unvo

caliz

edH

ebre

wte

xL”,

Ann

eli

Aej

mel

aeus

,P

araa

xis

inth

eS

eptu

agin

t,76

192

Ans

siV

oiti

laW

hat

the

Tra

nsl

atjo

not

Ten

ses

teli

s19

3

qata

lan

dw

ayyi

qtol

are

mea

ntto

beun

ders

tood

aspa

stte

nse

irre

al

form

s“1

wou

ldha

vedo

neth

isan

dth

atif

1w

ere

not

goin

gto

do

som

ethi

ngel

se”.

The

tran

slat

orha

sta

ken

thes

eve

rbfo

rms

tom

ean

the

futu

rebe

caus

eof

the

prec

edin

gco

ntex

t.H

eha

sno

tta

ken

into

acco

unt

the

foll

owin

gte

xtth

atm

akes

his

inte

rpre

tati

ons

aIi

ttle

bit

prob

lem

atic

alth

ough

not

impo

ssib

le.

The

qata

lat

the

begi

nnin

gof

the

vers

em

akes

itha

rdto

clai

mth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

read

copu

lati

veyi

qtol

form

sin

tohi

ste

xt.

Ex

9,15

:yK

np22

1flK

1]f

l1)

‘‘fl

Knnvi

nn

—v5v

y&

p&

toats

icu

tijv

Xr.i

QcL

1tc

Lt&

.(i)

GE

Kai

tOV

GO

)B

cLV

cLt(

,),

KcL

LK

tJt1

1G

flait

ot

yi.

YIQ

TO

L

Onl

yin

Nu

and

inD

tnth

eyi

qtol

ofna

rrat

ive

cont

exts

istr

ansl

ated

by

the

futu

rein

dica

tive

whi

chis

the

mos

tfr

eque

nteq

uiva

lent

ofyi

qtol

inth

eL

XX

.T

his

kind

ofyi

qtol

isco

mm

only

used

toin

dica

tere

peat

edi.e

.it

erat

ive

orge

nera

lisi

ngm

eanin

g.

15

The

foll

owin

gtw

oex

ampl

esar

eto

heun

ders

tood

asge

nera

lisi

ngin

ana

rrat

ion.

Nu

21,2

7:‘u

hzn

iz’

p—

6t&

To5t

oo5

nvo

aiv

tyL

att

ata

i“E

)Ott

t

icE

a&fk

v.

Wit

hth

iscl

ause

the

Heb

rew

narr

ator

wan

tsto

teli

his

read

ers

that

ther

est

iilex

ists

apo

emco

ncer

ning

thes

eev

ents

.T

heco

rrec

ttr

ansl

a

tion

wou

ldha

vebe

enth

epr

esen

tin

dica

tive

.A

nex

ampl

eof

aco

rrec

t

rend

erin

gof

the

yiqt

olco

uld

befo

und

inN

u21

,14

whi

chis

anin

tro

duct

ion

toth

equ

otat

ion

ofth

eB

ook

ofth

eW

ars

ofth

eL

ord.

The

yiqt

olin

trod

ucin

ga

paea

nof

triu

mph

that

ispr

esen

ted

once

duri

ng

the

narr

atio

nis

rend

ered

wit

hth

eao

rist

indi

cati

vein

Ex

15,1

and

Nu

21,1

7;in

thes

eca

ses

the

yiqt

olis

prec

eded

byco

njun

ctio

nfl

,m

arke

r

ofth

epr

eter

ite

form

.O

ther

weI

Ire

nder

edge

nera

lisi

ngyi

qtol

form

s

are

foun

d,fo

rex

ampl

e,in

vers

esG

en2,

10an

d50

,3w

here

the

pre

sent

indi

cati

veis

used

.T

hesa

me

sort

oftr

ansl

atio

nsar

eal

sofo

und

inD

tn.

Dtn

2,20

: xp’

b’R

DI

xi;

ipc

n•n

‘xei

y-i

—rii

Pw

pav

)oyl

cJ8a

ET

cuK

‘y&

pit

’atj

icm

icouv

oiP

apct

tvtItQ6tE

QO

V,K

O

Aav

Ttc

LL

vO

L&

Courn

vato

Zoov.

Fro

mth

ese

cond

clau

seof

this

sent

ence

we

may

conc

lude

that

the

situ

atio

nna

rrat

edis

past

t?,

Jt96

teQ

ov),

the

yiqt

olof

the

seco

ndcl

ause

isre

nder

edw

ith

the

impe

rfec

t.T

heyi

qtol

ofth

eth

ird

clau

sem

aybe

also

unde

rsto

odas

itis

tran

slat

ed,

inth

epr

esen

tin

dica

tive

.T

his

man

ner

ofre

nder

ing

dem

onst

rate

sag

ain

that

the

tran

slat

oris

not

awar

eof

the

foll

owin

gco

ntex

t.T

hetr

ansl

atio

nm

ight

even

beunder

stan

dabl

e,if

itis

take

nas

apa

rtof

the

prec

edin

gdi

rect

disc

ours

e.T

his

way

vers

e20

coul

dbe

divi

ded

into

two,

may

beev

enth

ree

seg

men

ts,

the

bord

erlj

nebe

ing

betw

een

the

firs

tyi

qtol

and

the

conju

nc

tion

&T

hetr

ansl

ator

noti

ced

whe

nre

nder

ing

the

seco

ndcl

ause

that

the

who

lese

nten

cesh

ould

have

been

unde

rsto

odas

past

and

hetr

ans

Iate

dth

ese

cond

yiqt

olby

the

impe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

.A

very

sim

ilar

situ

atio

nis

met

with

inD

tn2,

11an

da

slig

htly

diff

eren

ton

ein

(the

xis

age

nera

lisi

ngyi

qtol

rend

ered

byth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve)

3,13

.E

arli

erin

this

pape

rw

est

udie

dca

ses

inw

hich

the

qata

lat

tach

edto

the

copu

lati

vew

ew

astr

ansl

ated

byth

efu

ture

indi

cati

vein

narr

atio

n.A

gain

inN

u9,

16-2

3iri

narr

atio

nth

ere

appe

arit

erat

ive/

habj

tual

yiq

tol-

form

sth

atar

ere

nder

edw

ithth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve.

The

sequ

ence

begi

nsw

ith

‘n

mv

‘tr

ansl

ated

byoto

c‘y

vto

tavt6

mea

ning

“so

itw

asco

ntin

uall

y”.

Th

etr

ansl

ator

,ha

ving

noti

ced

this

,co

rrec

tly

uses

the

impe

rfec

t.In

the

next

vers

eth

eyi

qtol

form

sar

ere

nder

edw

ith

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

,w

hich

isus

eful

Gre

ekal

tern

ativ

efo

rth

etr

ansl

atio

nin

the

cont

exts

ofth

isty

pe.

Beg

inni

ngfr

omve

rse

18th

etr

ansl

ator

uses

asan

equi

vale

ntth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve.

Evi

dent

lyhe

does

not

pay

any

noti

ceto

his

prec

edin

gtr

ansl

atio

n,he

has

com

piet

ely

forg

otte

nth

eco

ntex

tan

dtr

ansl

ates

acco

rdin

gto

the

Heb

rew

verb

s.A

ndas

we

have

aire

ady

noti

ced

inth

eIa

stve

rse

ofth

isse

quen

ce,

vers

e23

,th

etr

ansl

ator

retu

rns

toth

ena

rrat

ive,

tran

slat

ing

verb

form

sin

the

past

tens

e,no

tbe

caus

ehe

sudd

enly

rem

embe

rsth

eco

ntex

tbu

tbe

caus

eth

ere

isal

soa

chan

gein

the

verb

form

inth

eso

urce

text

.

Nu

9,16

-18:

1T

1’

1D

1n

?lf

lw’

W1’‘

18..

WX

a?fl

?Yl

IDY

’pvr

Pa1

1fl

’p

rP‘7

p3fl

pui’

flV?C

9’

—O

T(i

)iveto

öt&

itav

i6.

vtpi•-

atv

i’jp

aK

ai

EZ

öoJtU

Qti

jvv6ta

...

18&

&lt

Qoat&

’yato

OU

Oi

‘Iaai,

Kai

ÖI&

itQ

OG

t&7.L

aT

oK

UQ

100

wta

poj5

cjtv

.it

&aa

t&1’j

Qa,

Vat

cU

KL

&S

tV

EpaT

JEiT

GK

TIV

ii,

Ot

UO

i‘1

GQ

a1.

15Se

eJo

uon

1923

, §11

3e-h

(dan

sla

sphre

dupa

ssle

yiqt

olex

prim

eac

tion

rpt6

eou

dura

tive)

and

§11

9u-

v(a

ctio

nrp

&e

oudu

rativ

e).

194

Ans

siV

oiti

laW

hat

the

Tra

nsl

atio

not

Ten

ses

teli

s19

5

Nu

9,23

:nu

,‘

mv

VDW

OO

flO

OO

flC

UD

flKW

D’1V

‘D71

1)11’

flfl

’‘

—it

t6t

&

JtQ

oat&

’yII

ato

(K

opio

’)åY

tao

oiv

tv(p

u).

aiT

lvK

opio

’)vto

Öt&

tQO

GtU

7IL

Ctt

o(

I(U

QiO

UV

XEtQ

LM

ooai

tj.

Exa

mpl

esof

long

stri

ngs

ofit

erat

ive/

habi

tual

yiqt

olfo

rms

are

infr

eque

ntin

the

Pen

tate

uch

atle

ast

inth

em

ater

ial

stud

ied

inth

is

pape

r.T

heyi

qtol

used

toin

dica

teit

erat

ive/

habi

tual

mea

ning

istr

ans

late

dco

rrec

tly

byth

eim

perf

ect

indi

cati

vein

Ex

33,7

-11.

The

yiqt

olin

dire

ctdi

scou

rse

isin

som

era

reca

ses

tran

slat

edby

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

.E

xam

ples

ofth

isph

enom

enon

may

befo

und

inG

en

47,2

5an

dE

x4,

11.

Inbo

thco

nnec

tion

sth

eyi

qtol

conc

erne

dis

pre

cede

dby

the

qata

lth

atis

rend

ered

wit

hth

epa

stte

nse

verb

form

,in

the

form

erth

epe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

and

inth

ela

tter

the

aori

stin

dica

tive

.

Thu

sth

eco

ntex

tis

inte

rpre

ted

aspa

stby

the

tran

slat

or.

Gen

47,2

5::1

1rI

‘-oi,

u”m

‘ro

‘y7

‘)fl

’r,r

IY

ve’

—K

ai

Eii

tav

ZaK

w

EiSQO

tLSV

X&QI

VV

cLV

tiOV

to3

Kop

io’)

ii&

vK

cLLG6I.

LE

9cL

3tcL

t&;

t&ct

cIQ

cL()

Ex

4,11

:..

uh

nK

D1K

flDDi

v—

Ti

WK

BV

(JT

6IC

Lavepw

It()

,K

ai

ti(

tOiW

Y6

)oK

o)(

poV

)(cLL

K()

(po

v..

.;

Am

ore

prob

lem

atic

case

isfo

und

inN

u16

,5w

here

the

Heb

rew

text

begi

nsw

ith

ano

min

alte

mpo

ral

clau

se“t

hem

orni

ng[is

]”in

the

foll

owin

gcl

ause

the

copu

lati

veju

ssiv

eap

pear

s,th

entw

om

ore

yiqt

ol

form

sfo

llow

.T

hebe

ginn

ing

ofa

dire

ctdi

scou

rse

isre

nder

edso

that

the

nouni

isse

emin

gly

cons

ider

edas

aqa

tal

verb

(the

perf

ect

in

dica

tive

used

)an

dth

efo

llow

ing

juss

ive

wit

hth

eco

pula

tive

conj

unC

tion

we

asw

ayyi

qtol

(the

aori

stin

dica

tive)

.T

his

tran

slat

ion

proc

ess

dem

onst

rate

sth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

does

not

know

wha

tth

efo

llow

ing

cont

ext

isan

dth

athe

take

sth

ew

hole

sent

ence

asa

narr

ativ

e,he

nce

heis

able

tore

nder

the

foll

owin

gyi

qtol

form

sw

ith

the

sam

epa

st

tens

eve

rbfo

rms.

Thi

ski

ndof

sequ

ence

,ie

.th

eno

min

alte

mpo

ral

clau

se—

this

tim

e“e

veni

ng”

—pl

usw

e+

yiqt

olis

corr

ectl

ytr

ans

late

dag

ain

inE

x16

,6.

Nu

16,5

:“x

i,io

i”c

‘-ip

mU

frT

,h

Ki

1T,,w

nm

n’r’i

rnpc

-ovi

xai

&).W

JSv

itp

6K

6ps

...

‘E3tg

KE

1tt

ctL

KaiY

6O

EO

(to

6vtc

o

cL&

tou

Ka’

tt0

&)‘

iooc

,K

ai

JtQ

0cJ

Tiy

&yE

t0tp

ictut

6V,

Kaio3

Et.

atO

cL

ut)

Jtp

ocnry

ayE

tOJt

QO

ccn

it

6V.

The

rear

eca

ses

whe

rein

stea

dof

the

past

tens

eth

efu

ture

isus

edan

d

the

past

inst

ead

ofth

epr

esen

t.N

atur

ally

,in

the

Gre

ek,

the

pres

ent

may

beus

edin

stea

dot

the

past

,si

nce

wit

hth

eso

calle

dhi

stor

ic

pres

ent

ther

eis

noun

ambi

guou

sw

ayto

reco

gnis

eth

eco

nfus

ion

of

pres

ent

and

past

.C

onse

quen

tly

thes

eca

ses

are

not

deal

tw

ithhe

re.

**

*

The

case

sst

udie

dab

ove

dem

onst

rate

that

the

cont

ext

did

not

alw

ays

sele

ctth

esu

itab

leG

reek

tens

efo

rits

elf.

Itm

ayno

tbe

argu

edth

at

the

cont

ext

did

not

have

any

effe

cton

the

tran

slat

ion

proc

ess

ofth

e

tens

es,

but

itsin

flue

nce

was

limite

dbe

caus

eof

the

habi

tof

tran

slat

ing

only

shor

tse

gmen

tsat

ati

me

and

acco

rdin

gto

the

so-c

alle

d“e

asy

tech

niqu

e”—

the

conc

ept

intr

oduc

edby

Barr

t6

—w

hich

mea

ns

tran

slat

ing

byth

eus

ual

equi

vale

ntw

itho

utan

exha

usti

vest

udy

ofth

e

con

tex

t.O

fco

urs

e,th

ein

flue

nce

ofth

eco

ntex

ton

the

tran

slat

ion

vari

esw

ithth

edi

ffer

ent

tran

slat

ors.

The

tran

slat

orof

Nu

and

toso

me

exte

ntal

soth

atof

Dtn

foll

owed

mor

ecl

osel

yth

efo

rmof

thei

r

sour

cete

xtth

anth

etr

ansl

ator

sof

Gen

and

Ex,

the

latt

erbe

ing

the

mos

tfr

eeal

soin

this

resp

ect.

Nat

ural

ly,

the

mat

eria

lis

too

limite

dfo

r

deta

iled

desc

ript

ions

ofev

ery

tran

slat

or’s

abili

ties

orin

abil

itie

sin

this

mat

ter.

For

exam

ple,

inth

est

udie

dpa

rts

ofG

enth

ere

are

noIo

ng

stri

ng

sof

itera

tive/h

abit

ual

yiq

tol/

weq

atal

form

sin

the

hist

oric

al

narr

ativ

e.B

ut,

judgin

gfr

om

the

mat

eria

ldi

scus

sed,

itis

obvio

us

that

the

tran

slat

orof

Nu

had

diff

icul

ties

inhan

dli

ng

ver

bfo

rms

that

did

not

occ

ur

inth

eir

usu

alen

vir

onm

ent.

He

was

able

tore

nd

erth

em

co

rrectl

yw

hen

they

wer

em

ark

edw

ith

suff

icie

nt

indic

ators

of

the

itera

tiv

ity

but

ifth

est

ring

s,in

whic

hth

eyap

pea

red,

wer

eto

olo

ng,

he

lost

the

pre

cedin

gco

nte

xt

com

ple

tely

,an

dtr

ansl

ated

them

inco

rrec

tly

byth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve.

The

fact

that

the

tran

slat

ion

was

usab

lede

pend

edto

ala

rge

exte

nt

onth

efa

ctth

atth

eH

ebre

wte

nses

wer

eus

edac

cord

ing

toth

eir

for

mal

usag

e;th

ere

are

long

stri

ngs

ofw

ayyi

qtol

and

qata

lfo

rms

inn

ar

rati

än,

and

indi

scou

rses

yiqt

olan

dw

eqat

alfo

rms

are

foun

d.W

hen

the

qata

lap

pear

edin

disc

ours

e,th

etr

ansl

ator

was

norm

ally

able

to

deal

wit

hit

corr

ectl

y,bu

tyi

qtol

and

weq

atal

caus

edoc

casi

onal

dif

fi

cult

ies.

Acc

ordi

ngto

Bar

r,th

eli

tera

lism

may

not

becl

aim

edto

conc

ern

the

tran

slat

ion

ofve

rbte

nse.

Nev

erth

eles

s,1

wou

ldus

eth

ete

rmst

ere

o

typi

ngte

nden

cyin

conn

ecti

onw

ith

the

man

ner

oftr

ansl

atin

gdis

cuss

edab

ove,

whe

nw

eqat

al,

yiqt

olor

w+

qata

lin

hist

oric

alna

rrat

ive

are

rend

ered

wit

hth

efu

ture

indi

cati

ve,

asw

eII

asw

hen

the

qata

lus

ed

16J.

Bar

r,“T

heT

ypol

ogy

ofL

iter

alis

min

Anc

ient

Bib

lica

lT

rans

lati

ons”

,26

.

196

Ans

siV

oiti

la

toin

dica

tepr

esen

tac

tion

,is

give

nth

eao

rist

indi

cati

veas

aneq

ui

vaje

nt.

Fur

ther

mor

ew

hen

inth

esa

me

imm

edia

teco

ntex

tth

eno

min

al

clau

seis

rend

ered

wit

hth

epr

esen

tin

dica

tive

ofth

eve

rbe?it

but

in

the

verb

alcl

ause

with

the

qata

lof

the

verb

r’r,

the

equi

vale

ntus

edis

the

impe

rfec

tin

dica

tive

ofth

esa

me

Gre

ekve

rb.

The

segm

enti

zing

man

ner

oftr

ansl

atin

gde

mon

stra

tes

also

that

the

tran

slat

ors

did

have

aba

sic

unde

rsta

ndin

gof

the

use

and

mea

ning

of

the

tens

es,

even

ifth

eydi

dno

tha

veth

ehe

lpof

our

gram

mat

ical

and

lingu

istic

hist

oric

alkn

owie

dge.

Whe

nth

eydi

dno

tor

coul

dno

tre

sort

toth

eco

ntex

t,th

eyre

nder

edac

cord

ing

toth

ete

nses

and

the

know

ledg

eth

eyha

dof

them

—in

this

resp

ect

the

poet

icpa

rts

are

anex

cept

ion

but

they

are

anex

cept

ion

aire

ady

atth

ele

vel

ofth

eso

urce

text

.

TH

ES

EP

TU

AG

INT

AN

DE

AR

LIE

RJE

WIS

HIN

TE

RP

RE

TA

TIV

ET

RA

DIT

ION

—E

SP

EC

IAL

LY

AS

RE

FL

EC

TE

DIN

TH

ET

AR

GU

MS

Sta

ffan

Olo

f sso

nT

eolo

gisk

a!n

stit

utio

nen,

Box

1604

,S-

751

46U

ppsa

la,

Sw

eden

1

The

term

Sep

tuag

int

isus

edno

wad

ays

for

aco

liec

tion

oftr

ansl

atio

nsan

dor

igin

alG

reek

wor

kspu

tto

geth

erov

era

peri

odof

seve

ral

hund

red

year

s.T

hus

itw

illno

tdo

tosp

eak

abou

tth

ere

lati

onbe

twee

nth

eS

eptu

agin

tan

dea

riie

rJe

wis

hin

terp

reta

tive

trad

itio

nin

asi

mpl

ew

ay.

Infa

ctth

etr

ansl

atio

nte

chni

que

isno

tat

ali

one

and

the

sam

efo

rth

een

tire

Sep

tuag

int;

the

met

hods

oftr

ansl

atio

ndi

ffer

radi

cail

yam

ong

the

vari

ous

book

s.C

erta

intr

ansl

atio

nsar

eex

trem

eiy

lite

ral,

asfo

rex

ampl

eL

amen

tati

ons,

Eze

kiel

,P

salm

san

dJe

rem

iah.

Oth

ers

such

asE

sthe

r,Jo

b,P

rove

rbs

and

Isai

ahar

eco

nsid

erab

lyfr

eer.

The

refo

reon

eca

nnot

refe

rto

the

Sep

tuag

int

inth

esa

me

way

asca

nbe

done

with

othe

rG

reek

tran

slat

ions

,as

Sym

rnac

hus,

The

odot

ion

and

Aqu

ila,

each

ofw

hich

disp

lays

itsow

npe

culi

arun

ity.

Afu

rthe

rco

mpl

icat

ion

whi

chsh

ouid

also

beta

ken

upin

this

connec

tion

isth

aton

em

ust

dist

ingu

ish

betw

een

the

orig

inal

tran

slat

ion,

usua

llyde

sign

ated

aspr

oto-

Sep

tuag

int

orth

eol

dG

reek

text

,an

dth

eal

tera

tion

san

dre

visi

ons

whi

chth

eor

igin

alun

derw

ent

over

the

cour

seof

time,

evid

ent

inev

ery

sing

leS

eptu

agin

tm

anus

crip

t!U

sual

lyit

isth

eor

igin

alw

hich

one

wou

ldlik

eto

com

pare

wit

hth

eJe

wis

hin

terp

reta

tive

trad

itio

n,w

hich

init

self

isfa

rfr

omun

ifor

m,

e.g.

the

tar

gum

s,pe

rhap

sth

ebe

stre

pres

enta

tive

ofea

rlie

rJe

wis

hin

terp

reta

tive

trad

itio

n,ha

vese

vera

ldi

ffer

ent

anon

ymou

sau

thor

s.L

ast

but

not

leas

r,w

eca

non

lyde

term

ine

whi

chin

terp

reti

vem

odel

was

bein

gem

ploy

edby

com

pari

ngth

eS

eptu

agin

tw

itha

Heb

rew

Sca

ndin

avia

nJo

urna

lof

the

Old

Tes

tam

ent

vol.

10no

.2

(199

6)©

Sca

ndin

avia

nU

nive

rsit

yPr

ess

1

Abs

trac

t

Inhi

spa

per

read

atth

eIO

SCS

mee

ting

inJe

rusa

lem

1986

,Pr

of.

Jam

esB

arr

has

stat

edth

atth

etr

ansl

ator

sof

the

LX

Xha

ssu

ccee

ded

weI

lin

rend

erin

gth

eve

rbte

nse.

His

mai

nst

atem

ent

—th

etr

ansl

ato

rdi

dno

tha

vean

y“pre

cise

orco

mpr

ehen

sive

theo

ryof

how

the

Heb

rew

tens

esw

orke

d”an

dth

ushe

follo

wed

the

indi

catio

nsgi

ven

byth

eco

ntex

t—

requ

ire

that

ther

ear

eno

verb

form

sjn

the

tran

slat

ion

whi

chdo

not

fit

into

thei

rco

ntex

tbu

tar

e

neve

rthe

less

inac

cord

ance

wit

hth

eno

rmal

equi

vale

ntof

the

Heb

rew

verb

tran

slat

ed.

1in

tend

toqu

esti

onth

epo

siti

onof

Pro

f.B

arr

byp

rese

nti

ng

som

e

case

sof

wha

the

may

call

the

“mud

dlii

igof

the

verb

tens

es”

whi

chd

emo

n

stra

teth

atth

eco

ntex

tdi

dno

tal

way

sse

lect

the

suit

able

Gre

ekte

nse

for

itse

lf.

ILm

ayno

tbe

argu

edth

atth

eco

ntex

tdi

dno

tha

vean

yef

fect

onth

e

tran

slat

ion

proc

ess

ofth

ete

nses

,bu

tli

sin

flue

nce

was

lim

ited

beca

use

ofth

e

habi

tof

tran

slat

ing

only

shor

tse

gmen

tsat

ati

me

and

acco

rdin

gto

the

so

call

ed“e

asy

tech

niqu

e”w

hich

mea

nstr

ansl

atin

gby

the

usua

leq

uiv

alen

t

wit

hout

aoex

haus

tive

stud

yof

the

cont

ext.