Review of Integrated Mental Health and Substance Abuse Treatment for Patients With Dual Disorders
Substance Abuse Written Assign 1
-
Upload
independent -
Category
Documents
-
view
2 -
download
0
Transcript of Substance Abuse Written Assign 1
INTRODUCTION
Substance abuse has become a major health problem in and
around the world. Substance abuse permeates all levels of
society. Substance use, misuse, and dependence are among the
most prevalent causes of adolescent morbidity and mortality in
most countries. Substance of all types is being widely used or
misused by teens and emerging adults in the United States
(Steve Sussman, 2008). Among older teens, some studies have
found alarmingly high substance use and dependence rates.
Adolescent substance misusers experience numerous social,
economic, physical, and legal consequences, for example,
truncated development. Substance use-related disorders are
associated with such problems as poor academic performance,
job instability, teen pregnancy, and the transmission of
sexually transmitted disease. Crime such as stealing,
vandalism, and violence are associated with “heavy drug use”
in adolescence. Adverse consequences occur like overdose and
accidents. In fact, the incidence of drinking and driving
among older adolescents and emerging adults is double that of
general populations. Drug using individuals are more likely to
develop disorganize thinking and unusual beliefs that may
interfere with problem-solving abilities and emotional
functioning and may lead to greater social isolation and
depression. Substance dependent adolescents (Sussman S, 2001)
endure consequences of additional problems such as drug
tolerance effects, withdrawal symptoms, and preoccupation with
using a drug to the exclusion of other activities.
Using substances by injection can cause serious health
problems no matter which substance is injected. Injecting any
drug is significant risk factor for contracting blood-borne
diseases such as HIV and Hepatitis B and C (WHO, 2003). People
who inject drugs have a higher risk of dependence and are
likely to have more severe dependence than those who do not
inject.
Newcomb and Bentler (1989) provide information on the
etiology, or cause, of substance use and abuse. These authors
note that use is prompted most by peer influence, whereas
abuse stems from internal psychological distress. They also
identify risk factors associated with substance use and abuse,
including a personal history of drug use, use by peers, a
lower socioeconomic level, family dysfunction, a family
history of abuse, poor school performance, low self-esteem,
lack of abidance with law, need for excitement, stress life
events, and anxiety and depression.
Substance abuse refers to the harmful or hazardous use of
psychoactive substance, including alcohol and illicit drugs.
Psychoactive substance (Organization, 2001) use can lead to
dependence syndrome – a cluster of behavioural, cognitive, and
physiological phenomena that develop after repeated substance
use and that typically include a strong desire to take the
drug, difficulties in controlling its use, persisting in its
use despite harmful consequences, a higher priority given to
drug use than to other activities and obligations, increased
tolerance, and sometimes a physical withdrawal state.
The reasons people use drugs include obtaining pleasure, joy
and euphoria; meeting social expectations, giving in to peer
pressure, dealing with or escaping stress, anxiety, and
tension, avoiding pain and achieving altered states of
consciousness.
Psychoactive drugs (Plotnik, 2008) are chemicals that affect
our nervous systems and, as a result, may alter consciousness
and awareness, influence how we sense and perceive things, and
modify our moods, feelings, emotions, and thoughts.
Psychoactive drugs are both licit (legal) such as tobacco,
coffee, and alcohol and illicit (illegal) such as marijuana,
heroin, cocaine and LSD. Although all psychoactive drugs
affect our nervous systems, how they affect our behaviours
depends on our psychological state and other social factors.
Etiology Of Drug Dependency
Addiction or dependency (Sherry Wasilow - Mueller, 2001) may
be viewed as a subset of brain and behaviour disorders, which
include all psychiatric diagnosis (such as schizophrenia,
bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, and obsessive-
compulsive disorder). Current recognition of addiction,
acceptance of it as a medical disorder by the public, and
treatment options for it roughly mirror conditions for
schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder
some 20 years ago.
Although addiction usually (but not always) begins with a
conscious decision to use a drug, changes that occur in the
brain at some point can turn drug use and then abuse into a
chronic, relapsing illness. Some genetically predisposed
individual, however become “addicted” almost immediately, with
very little progression from use to abuse to dependency. Two
events must occur for the addictive process to be initiated.
First, there is an addictive process to be initiated. First,
there is an activation of the brain’s “pleasure pathway”. This
occurs in the medical forebrain bundle, which runs from the
brain stem and midbrain through the hypothalamus to a variety
of sites in the forebrain that are concerned with emotion,
motivation, reward, and decision making.
Second, for the addictive response to be initiated, the neural
response to the drug exposure must have a rapid onset and must
also rebound below the initial baseline of neural activity
before returning to it.
Content
Early Use
An individual uses drugs freely in order to feel better.
First-time drug users often are just experimenting or
succumbing to peer pressure to try a substance. Others are
thrill-seekers who try any new option that comes along. Other
people are looking for a way to deal with stress or mental
disorders and seek relief through self-medication.
Drugs primary influence the pleasure centre in the brain,
which are responsible for the feeling of being high. Many
chemicals mimic the neurotransmitter in the brain and serve to
help people feel better and achieve a sense of well-being.
Dopamine levels are increased by most illegal chemicals and
add to the pleasurable sensations. In doing so, the physical
neurotransmitters in the brain become altered. Human evolution
created the dopamine structures to reward humans for survival
behaviour, such as sex and eating. Following the initial burst
of dopamine and the unnatural release of additional dopamine,
drugs continue to create the pleasurable sensation much longer
than natural behaviours. Those levels of well-being are
difficult, if not impossible, to reach without the use of
drugs, setting up the brain to seek more of the pleasurable
sensations.
Risks
Studies by the NIDA (Ray, 2009) show that 67 percent of people
who try marijuana for the first time are teenagers between the
ages of 12 and 17. Between the peer pressure, undeveloped
decision-making skills and immature brain development of this
group, prevention can be difficult for educators and parents.
While environmental pressures play a big role in causing
substance abuse, researchers believe that genetics play a
larger role. The NIDA found that 40 to 60 percent of the
reasons a person will become addicted is attributable to
heredity. Additional risks associated with probability that
someone will become addicted after trying dope include mental
illnesses, drug availability, past traumatic stress and
personality.
Diagnosis
Substance abuse problems can be diagnosed by using DSM-IV-TR
which recognizes two mental disorders associated with
substance abuse, substance abuse and substance dependence. A
diagnosis of substance abuse applies to a client with an
impairment in social or occupational functioning. ( continue
from page 441 counselling book )
Exploring Adolescent and Emerging Adult Problems
The Bio-Psycho-Social Approach
Biological, psychological, and social factors have been
proposed as cause of problems that adolescents, emerging
adults, and others can develop. The bio-psychological approach
emphasizes that problems develop through an interaction of
biological, psychological, and social factors.
The Development Psychopathology Approach
In the developmental psychopathology approach, the emphasis is
on describing and exploring developmental pathways of
problems. One way of classifying adolescent and emerging adult
problems is an internalizing (for example, depression and
anxiety) or externalizing (for example, juvenile delinquency).
Resilience
Three sets of characteristics are reflected in the lives of
adolescents and emerging adults who show resilience in the
face of adversity and disadvantage: (1) individual factors –
such as good intellectual functioning; (2) family factors –
such as a close relationship with a caring parent figure, and
(3) extrafamilial factors – bonds to prosocial adults outside
the family. Resilience in adolescence is linked to continuing
to be resilient in emerging adulthood, but resilience can
develop in emerging adulthood.
Problems and Disorder
Drug Use
Understanding drug use requires an understanding of physical
dependence and psychological dependence. Alcohol (Santrock,
2010) acts as a depressant and is the drug most widely used by
U.S adolescents and emerging adults. Alcohol abuse is a major
problem, although its use in adolescence has begun to decline.
There is an increase in alcohol use and binge drinking during
emerging adulthood. Binge drinking by college students is a
continuing concern. Use of alcohol and drugs typically
declines by the mid-twenties. Risk factors for alcohol use
include heredity and negative family and peer influences.
Other drugs that can be harmful to adolescents include
hallucinogens (LSD and marijuana), stimulants (such as
nicotine, cocaine, and amphetamines), and depressants (such as
barbiturates, tranquilizers, and alcohol). A special concern
is cigarette use by adolescents.
An alarming trend has recently occurred in the increase use of
prescription painkillers by adolescents. Use of anabolic
steroids has been linked with strength training, smoking, and
heavy use of alcohol. Parents and peers can provide important
supportive roles in preventing adolescent drug use. Being born
in a high-risk family, having conduct problems at school, and
being rejected by peers were factors related to drug use by
12-years-olds (Santrock, 2010). Early educational achievement
by adolescents have positive influence in reducing the
likelihood of developing problems with drug and alcohol abuse.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
The classification of substance-related disorders in DSM
system is not based on whether a drug is legal or not, but
rather on how drug use impairs the person’s physiological and
psychological functioning.
Substance use disorders are patterns of maladaptive use of
psychoactive substances. These disorders, include substance
abuse and substance dependence.
Substance abuse – concept and process as opposed to misuse
involves accumulation of negative consequences. Substance
abuse as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders, fourth edition, text revision (DSM-IV-TR)
(APA, 2000), is a maladaptive pattern of substance use leading
to clinically significant impairment or distress as manifested
in a 12-month period by at least one of four criteria : (1)
recurrent substance use resulting in failure to fulfil major
obligations at work, school, or home such as poor performance
at work or school, neglect of children or young siblings; (2)
recurrent substance use in hazardous situations such as
driving while intoxicated; (3) recurrent substance-related
legal problems and (4) continued substance use despite having
recurrent interpersonal problem related to substance use such
as arguments with family members about consequences of
intoxication. These criteria were primary conceptualized for
application to adult population.
Physiological and psychological effects of drugs
Substance dependence (Derigne, 2010) has been defined by the
DSM-IV-TR as being a severer disorder, consisting of a
maladaptive pattern of substance use leading to clinically
significant impairment or distress as manifested in a 12-month
period by three or more of the following :
1. Tolerance means that with repeated use, a person will no
longer achieve the same degree of pleasurable effect
experienced in the past and the person has to use
increasing amounts of the substance to get the same
pleasurable effect.
2. Withdrawal symptoms mean when physically dependent on a
substance, individuals will develop withdrawal symptoms,
which cause distress or impairment when use stops or the
amount is cut down; the person will continue to use the
substance to avoid the withdrawal symptoms.
3. The substance is taken in larger amounts or over a longer
period of time then intended.
4. The person experiences a persistent desire or
unsuccessful efforts to cut down or control substance
use.
5. A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary to
obtain the substance, use it, or recover from its
effects.
6. Important social, occupational, or recreational
activities are given up or reduced because of substance
use.
7. Substance use is continued despite knowledge or having a
persistent physical or psychological problem that is
likely to have been caused or exacerbated by the
substance.
Psychological Dependency – occurs when the user feels and
behaves as if the substance is necessary for their
wellbeing. Use of the drug is continued despite knowledge of
its negative health or social consequences, despite efforts
to reduce consumption, and even despite remission of
physical dependency (it thus provokes relapse).
Relapse – when substance use begins again after a
period of abstinence or remission.
While these criteria also were created primarily for an
adult population, one may speculate that dependence symptoms
encompass people at any developmental period.
Theoretical Perspectives
People began using psychoactive substances for various
reasons. Some adolescents start using drugs because of peer
pressure or because they believe drugs make them seem more
sophisticated or grown up. Some use drugs as a way of
rebelling against their parents or society at large. People
continue to use drugs because drugs give them pleasurable
effects or people find it difficult to stop. Most
adolescents drink alcohol to “get high”, not to establish
that they are adults. Many people smoke cigarettes for the
pleasure they provide. Some people smoke cigarettes to help
them to relaxed when they are tense and paradoxically, to
give them a kick or lift when they are tired in which all
these leads to addiction. Some may want to quit this
addiction but find it difficult to break their addiction.
People who are anxious about their jobs or social lives may
be drawn to the calming effects of alcohol, marijuana,
tranquilizers and sedatives. People with low self confidence
and self-esteem may be drawn to the ego-bolstering effects
of amphetamines and cocaine. Many poor people attempt to
escape the poverty, anguish, and tedium of inner-city life
through using heroin and similar drugs. More well to do
adults may rely on drugs to manage the transition from
dependence to independence and major life changes concerning
jobs, and lifestyles.
Biological Perspectives
Many drugs of abuse, including nicotine, alcohol, heroin,
marijuana, and especially cocaine and amphetamines, produce
pleasurable effects by increasing the availability of the
neurotransmitter dopamine, a key brain chemical involved in
activating the brain’s reward or pleasure circuits.
Neurotransmitters (APA, APA Concise Dictionary Of
Psychology, 2009) are any of a large number of chemicals
that released by neurons to mediate transmission or
inhibition of nerve signals across the junctions between
neurons. Neurotransmitters include amines, such as
acetylcholine, norepinephrine, dopamine, and serotonin, and
amino acids, such as gamma-aminobutyric acid, glutamate, and
glycine.
For addicts, the steady influx of dopamine from using drugs
makes it difficult for them to focus on anything other than
attaining and using drugs, even if the drugs no longer
produce feelings of pleasure. Over time, regular use of
drugs such as cocaine, alcohol and heroin may sap the
brain’s own production of dopamine. Consequently, the
brain’s natural reward system, the “feel good” circuitry
that produces states of pleasure associated with the
ordinarily rewarding activities of life, such as consuming a
satisfying meal or engaging in pleasant activities. Without
drugs, an addict life may not seem worth living.
Changes in the dopamine system may help to explain the
intense cravings and anxiety that accompany drug withdrawal
and the difficulty people have in maintaining abstinence,
refraining from the use of drugs.
Genetic factors (Doweiko, 1993) are link to various forms of
substance use and abuse, including abuse / dependence on
alcohol, amphetamines, heroin, and even tobacco in the form
of cigarette smoking. Environment factors, such as family
influences and peer pressure, play a more important role in
accounting for the initiation of drug use in early
adolescence, whereas genetic factors play an increasing role
in explaining continuation of drug use through early and
middle adulthood.
Alcoholism tends to run in the families. The closer the
genetic relationship (Ray, 2009), the greater the risk.
Familial patterns provide only suggestive evidence of
genetic factors, because family share a common environment
as well as common genes. More definitive evidence comes from
twin and adoptee studies. For example, a twin is twice as
likely to become an alcoholic if an identical rather than
non-identical twin is one, and adopted children are around
four times more likely to become problem drinkers than other
adoptees if their biological parents were alcoholics,
regardless of the drinking habits of their adoptive parents.
Alcoholism, nicotine dependence, and opioid addiction are
linked to genes that determine the structure of dopamine
receptors in the brain. In effect, good parenting can reduce
the influence of bad genes. Multiple genes act together with
environment and psychological factors in contributing to the
development of substance-related disorders.
Learning Perspectives
Learning theorists (Hill, 2001)propose that substance-
related behaviour are largely learned and can in principle,
be unlearned. Learning theory can be applied to addiction in
many ways, which focus on the roles of operant and classical
conditioning and observational learning. Substance abuse
problems are not regarded as symptoms of disease but rather
a problem habits. Even though genetic and biological factors
may increase susceptibility abuse problems, the role of
learning in development and maintenance of these problem
behaviours are the main concern in learning perspectives.
Emotional stress, such as anxiety or depression, often sets
the stage for the development of substance abuse.
Drug use may become habitual because of the pleasure
(positive reinforcement) or temporary relief (negative
reinforcement) from negative emotions, such as anxiety and
depression, which drugs can produce. With drugs like
cocaine, which appear capable of directly stimulating
pleasure mechanisms in the brain, the positive reinforcement
is direct and powerful.
Classical conditioning present in the environment during
drug taking may become associated with the pleasure and
physiological changes caused by substance (e.g a bar may be
associated with the pleasure from alcohol). These cues may
thereafter act as prompts by creating a craving for the drug
in its absence and are key factors in psychological
dependence and relapse (e.g walking back into familiar bar
or seeing a friend with cigarette after giving up alcohol or
nicotine).
In operant conditioning situation, once drugs are taken, the
short term pleasure they provide is obviously a major
positive reinforce of drug seeking and taking behaviour,
compared to the longer-term negative effects (punishment).
Avoidance of unpleasant withdrawal symptoms act as potent
source of negative reinforcement for these behaviours. In
terms of more psychological negative reinforcement, drugs
may help escape stress or fear arousal (e.g of social
situations by reducing inhibitions).
In social learning theory, children may see many influential
role models in parents, peers and media celebrities taking
drugs like alcohol and, because they often selectively see
the positive consequences of enjoyment rather than negative
ones, they develop positive expectations and wish to use
them too.
Cognitive Perspectives
Cognitive perspectives focus on roles of attitudes, beliefs
and expectancies in accounting for substance use and abuse.
Expectancies support the role of cognitive factors in
substance abuse and dependence. Holding positive
expectancies about drug use, such as believing that drinking
alcohol will make one popular or outgoing, increases the
likelihood of using these substances. Outcome expectancies
in teens in what they expect a drug’s effects will be, are
strongly influenced by the beliefs held by others in their
social environment, including friends and parents. Alcohol
or other drug use may also boost self-efficacy expectation,
personal expectancies we hold about our ability to
successfully perform tasks. If we believe we need a drink or
two (or more) to “get out of our shell” and relate socially
to others, we may come to depend on alcohol in social
situations.
Effective Treatment of Substance Abuse and Dependence
Treatment has often been a frustrating endeavour. There is a
vast array of nonprofessional, biological, and psychological
approaches to substance abuse and dependence. In many and
perhaps most cases, drug-dependent people may not be ready
or motivated to change their drug use behaviour or may not
seek treatment on their own. Motivational interviewing may
be used by substance abuse counsellors to first increase the
clients readiness to make changes in their lives. In a
supportive manner rather than confrontation manner,
counsellors help clients recognize the problems caused by
their drug use and risks they face in continuing to use
drugs. Counsellors focus on raising client’s awareness of
the differences between their present circumstances and how
they want their lives to be and the steps they need to take
to make these changes.
When drug-dependent people are ready to break free of drugs,
the process of helping them through the withdrawal syndrome
is usually straight forward. Helping them pursue a life
devoid of their preferred substances is more problematic.
Treatment taking place in a setting such as the therapist’s
office, a support group, a residential center or a hospital
is where abstinence is valued and encouraged. The individual
returns to work, family, or street settings in which abuse
and dependence were instigated and maintained. The problem
of relapse can be more troublesome than problems involved in
initial treatment.
Another complication is that many people with substance
abuse problems have other psychological disorders as well.
Most clinics and treatment programs focus on the drug or
alcohol problem, this narrow focus results in poorer
treatment outcomes including more frequent rehospitalisation
among those with these dual diagnoses.
Specific treatment for substance abuse / chemical dependency
will be determined by the physician based on the age of the
patient/ abuser, overall health, medical history, the extend
of the symptoms and of the dependency. Type of substance
abused, the tolerance for specific medications, procedures,
or therapies, the expectations for the course of condition
and the opinion or preference of the patient.
A variety of treatment programs (Psychiatry, 2004) for
substance abuse are available on an inpatient or outpatient
basis. Programs considered are usually based on the type of
substance abused. Detoxification and long-term follow-up
management are important features of successful treatment.
Long-term follow-up management usually includes formalized
group meetings and developmentally age-appropriate
psychosocial support systems, as well as continued medical
supervision. Individual and family psychotherapy are often
recommended to address the developmental, psychosocial, and
family issues that may have contributed to and resulted from
development of a substance abuse disorder.
Conclusion
Our society (Plotnik, 2008) is flooded with psychoactive
substances that alter the mood and twist perceptions.
Substances that lift us up, calm us down, and turn us upside
down. Many young people start using these substances because
of peer pressure or because their parents and other
authority figures tell them not to. For many others who
become addicted to drugs, the pursuit and use of drugs take
center stage in their lives and become even more important
than family, work, or their own welfare.
Changing our behaviours, including substance use, can seem
scary or difficult but it is possible. If adolescent or an
individual wants to change his substance use problem, they
should look at the risk that they have put on their health,
social, legal, psychological, work and family. They must
look at ideas to change.
Whether legal or illegal, psychoactive drugs alter one’s
consciousness, emotions, and thoughts by affecting the
brain’s communication network.
A low to moderate consumption of alcohol has benefits,
including improved cholesterol profiles, improved platelet
and clotting function, and improved sensitivity to insulin
according to Dr Milton Lum (Lum, 2013). Moderate alcohol
consumption may also protect against cerebrovascular disease
with the antioxidants in wine. However heavy and long-term
alcohol consumption leads to alcohol abuse and dependence,
impaired memory, contributes to neurodegerative disease, and
hinders psychosocial functioning. The Food and Drug
Administration of the United States has defined “moderate
alcohol consumption” as up to one drink for women, and up to
two drinks for men daily.
The Future of Treatment for Substance Abuse
The need to develop additional modalities (Bukstein, 1995),
particularly in the inpatient programs where the trend is
towards much more severely affected youth, has resulted in
more behavioural-focused treatment, an increased emphasis on
family issues (including parent management training), and
more attention to psychopathology and the specific treatment
of coexisting psychiatric disorders when indicated. The
future of substance abuse treatment is uncertain. Severe
restrictions in the type and length of treatment may
significantly limit the efficacy of treatment. Ultimately,
treatment planning will have to be backed by research
demonstrating the effectiveness of various type of treatment
for various populations of adolescents who differ on a
variety of demographic, social, behavioural, and
psychological characteristics.
There are the differential effects of various modalities,
either alone or together when administrating treatment. At
times it is very difficult to know the effects of certain
types of treatment on certain subgroup who vary on racial or
ethnic status or some special characteristic such as
hopelessness, pregnancy, or HIV-positive. Treatment should
be proceed with caution, asking questions of what type of
treatment will apply for which group and the effects of the
treatment whether it will lead to positive or negative
results for substance abuse patients that is being treated.
Prevention treatment can work, provided a comprehensive
study is done and the important and impact of socioeconomic
conditions. Prevention does not involve doing a little, but
doing a lot to produce the greatest effect possible on the
many risk factors for adolescent substance use or abuse.
Adolescents are training to be adult. They copy adults and
reflect the choices that adults must also make. It is hardly
(Amy Wachholtz, 2011) surprising that both culturally
sanctioned substance use in the forms of alcohol and tobacco
and illicit use of other substances is prevalent in adults,
as well as youth. Our society is struggling to deal with the
negative consequences of our involvement with psychoactive
substances. Asking clients and patients to break through
their denial, all counsellor and psychiatrist must identify
what the problem of substance abuse patient is and how it
can best be dealt with.
We can also look at some complementary and alternative
treatments such as acupuncture to treat chronic pain and
substance abuse patients to help overcome their needs for
addiction and abuse. Integrating spirituality (Arnold R. M,
2002) into treatment as an additional therapeutic resource
is common in addiction treatment program particularly those
that use the 12 step approach for the treatment of
addiction. The majority of participants in addiction
treatment programs report that they view spirituality as a
positive coping mechanism and they appreciate the inclusion
of spirituality into treatment.
Meditation techniques (Amy Wachholtz, 2011) vary widely in
their form and function. Still or sitting meditations may
include mantram, transcendental, loving-kindness, but we
should also include moving meditation techniques such as