Sports mega events and Islam: An introduction
-
Upload
leedsbeckett -
Category
Documents
-
view
0 -
download
0
Transcript of Sports mega events and Islam: An introduction
Sports mega-events and Islam: An introduction
Karl Russell, Noelle O’Connor, Katherine Dashper and Thomas
Fletcher
In Sports events, society and culture. Edited by Katherine Dashper,
Thomas Fletcher and Nicola McCullough. Routledge, 2014.
Introduction
Events are embedded within the socio-cultural milieus of their
host communities (Ferdinand and Shaw, 2012; Getz, 2012). Many
of the world’s international sporting events, staged since the
Second World War, have predominantly emerged and been hosted
within Europe, North America, Japan and Australia. This is, in
part, due to the success and growth within these post war
nations’ economies. These regions of the world, collectively
known as the ‘developed’ or ‘western’ world, have largely
adopted or have acknowledged Christianity as their main
religion. As such their societies have developed a series of
value systems which are based upon Christian-led beliefs
witnessed in the worship of Jesus Christ, the adherence of
Sunday as a day of worship, modest dress codes, traditional
gender roles in both domestic and working situations, and the
acknowledgment of Christian significant religious dates and
holidays (Weber, 1992). International sports governing bodies
for the majority of ‘major’ sports, such as football, rugby
and tennis, were founded in western states and so were also
loosely based around Christian values. As Gupta (2009: 1779)
argues “Because western nations were the founder members of
1
most international sporting associations they dominated these
bodies and set the rules for a sport, dominated its finances,
and determined the location of major international events”.
However, recent global changes, such as shifting economic
power, have seen a trend towards many ‘emerging’ regions
outside of the western world hosting, and/or actively seeking
to host, international sporting events.
One such emerging region is the Middle East. The Middle East
is largely composed of Islamic countries. It is the
geographical home to economically powerful nations such as the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA, a member of the G20), United
Arab Emirates (UAE), Qatar and Bahrain, where “wealth,
economic growth and diversification, based on the sale of
natural resources such as oil and liquefied gas that ‘continue
to drive the Gulf Economy’ (O’Sullivan, 2008: p.1), has seen
their global profiles raised dramatically in terms of their
political, economic and socio-cultural influence” (Russell and
O’Connor, 2013: 206).Today the region plays host to many
international sporting events, such as Formula One motor
racing staged in Bahrain and Abu Dhabi, international golfing
and tennis events staged in Qatar and Dubai, and international
cycling road racing staged in Oman. A review of the current
literature has focused on examining the economic suitability
of Islamic countries in relation to hosting international
sporting events (Scharenberg, 1999; Randeree, 2011). However,
to date, little attention has been given to examining the
socio-cultural beliefs and values within Islam - many of which
are fundamental to everyday life within non-secular Islamic
countries - and the challenges these may present (to both the
2
host nation and the event) when an international sporting
event is staged in a non-secular Islamic country.
In this chapter we begin to consider some of the complexities
of hosting major international sporting events in non-secular
Islamic countries. We begin by considering the historical
relationship between religion and sporting events. We then go
on to identify emerging sports events markets, focusing
particularly on the Middle East, and consider various ways in
which event managers need to be culturally sensitive to the
teachings and practices of Islam when staging major sports
events in non-secular Islamic countries. We suggest that, due
to the imperatives of global sport and the need to attract new
audiences and investors, there is a need to expand sporting
events into hitherto uncharted territories. This will require
a reconsideration of many of the hegemonic ideological
assumptions around which international sports events are
currently conceptualised. As Maguire (1999) has long argued,
the globalisation of sport has led to the domination of the
west over non-western countries. However, recent tendencies to
award the hosting of major international sports events to non-
western nations suggests that the tide is now turning.
Therefore, this chapter is a timely introduction to some of
the issues and complexities associated with hosting major
international sports events outside of the traditional power
block of the western world.
Religion and sporting events
3
The popularity of modern day large scale international
sporting events can be traced back to the inter-war period
after the First World War (Riordan and Kruger, 1999). During
this period (within Europe and the USA) public interest in
sport increased, resulting in growth in the popularity and
prominence of sporting tournaments. This period also
witnessed the expansion of sport as a commercialised product,
leading to greater participation and more sporting
competitions, as well as growth in the number of international
sporting tournaments. This era became known as the period of
the ‘universalisation of sport’ (Riordan and Kruger, 1999). As
sport and sports events became more popular and prominent,
divisions along the lines of class, gender, ‘race’, and -
importantly for our discussion here - religion, became
increasingly apparent.
The contemporary events literature is dominated by examples of
international sporting events staged within the developed
(western) world (Riordan and Kruger, 1999; Pfister 2000; Getz,
2008; Randeree, 2011). A contributing factor towards this
relates to the Cold War era when the capitalist west and the
communist states of the east used sport, sporting events and
sporting victories to emphasise their political ideologies,
social dominance and religious right; a propaganda campaign
which the west arguably won (Wagg and Andrews, 2006). This
politicisation of sport placed it at the top of political and
economic agendas (Riordan and Kruger, 1999). During the post-
Second World War period, sport and sporting events became
increasingly commercialised throughout the western world.
Historical accounts of the emergence and development of modern
sport and sporting events are strongly rooted in western
4
societies and cultures (e.g. Holt, 1990). As such, the
emergence and initial development of international sporting
events took place within capitalist states based (sometimes
loosely) on Christian ethics and beliefs. It is within this
context that popular sport first took shape and developed
(Riordan and Kruger, 1999; Scharenberg, 1999). This context
shaped the development of sport and sporting events in a
number of ways, including: the observance of Sunday as the day
of worship and rest throughout most of the twentieth century;
the avoidance of Christian dates of celebration, such as
Christmas and Easter, within the sporting calendar; and,
widespread sex-segregation in the organisation of most
sporting activities and competitions to reflect western
Christian value systems related to traditional gender roles
and expectations (Pfister, 2010a, 2010b).
Over the last hundred years the centrality of the Christian
church to many western states has diminished, resulting in a
number of social changes that have impacted on sport and
sports events. The sanctity of Sunday as a day of worship and
rest has been called into question, and sporting events are
now regularly scheduled on Sundays and close to Christian
religious holidays. For example, Formula One, tennis (e.g.
the French Open, Wimbledon), FIFA World Cup games, Olympic and
Paralympic events, all take place on Sunday, the traditional
Christian day of worship. The role of women in society at
large and sport in particular has changed dramatically and,
although still lagging far behind that of male sports and
athletes, this has resulted in increased female sporting
participation and increased visibility and celebration of
female athletes (Pfister, 2010a; Dashper, 2012). In addition
5
there has been an increase in sports and sporting governing
bodies making rules that ban participants from performing any
acts related to ‘shows of faith’ or secularism (Amara, 2012).
All of these changes have contributed to increases in sports
participation and attraction of global media audiences.
International sporting events have become increasingly
commercialised, and (predominantly) western sponsors now use
these events to target global audiences. The Olympic Games and
FIFA World Cup global sponsors, for example, include companies
such as Adidas, Coca Cola, McDonalds, Visa and Kodak; all of
which are major western companies. However, recent ‘shifts’ in
the world’s economic power bases are arguably changing this
status quo. The rising prominence of India in sports such as
cricket are a prime example of this (see Gupta, 2004; Rumford,
2007).
Emerging markets and international sporting events
Major international sports events have been staged in non-
Western countries for some time. For example: Tokyo Olympics,
1964; Mexico Olympics, 1968; Seoul Olympics, 1988; FIFA World
Cup in Uruguay 1930, Brazil, 1950, Mexico 1986, Japan/South
Korea, 2002, and South Africa, 2010. However, for many, the
Beijing Olympics set in motion a new social and political
agenda for considering the role of non-Western nations on the
major international sports events circuit (Palmer, 2013: 114).
Russell and O’Connor (2013) suggest that Beijing 2008 can be
regarded as a major turning point in Olympic history. To
iterate this they identify how the Games attracted over 10,000
6
athletes and millions of ‘cultural sports tourists’ in person,
in addition to billions via many media sources. Moreover, an
estimated 4.3 billion people (63% of the world’s population)
in 220 territories are thought to have viewed the event
(Russell and O’Connor, 2013: 207). They also argue that the
‘success’ of Beijing has encouraged other ‘Eastern’
nations/cities to announce to the IOC their credentials,
willingness and readiness to ‘bid’ to be host cities for
future Olympics.
Indeed, emerging nations from Asia, South America and the
Middle East are now actively seeking, and are being courted by
event owners and organisers, to be potential future hosts and
venues for all types of international sporting events; many of
which attract global media audiences. Countries such as China
(Beijing Olympics and Paralympics,2008; Shanghai Diamond
League (track and field), annual), India (Commonwealth Games
2010), Bahrain (Formula One - annual), and Russia (UEFA
Champions League Final, 2010) have all recently staged major
sporting events. Brazil will also host future mega sporting
events with the FIFA World Cup in 2014 and the Olympic and
Paralympic Games in 2016 being staged there.
While the debate is ongoing as to what benefit the staging or
hosting of an international sporting event can actually bring
to a country or a city, especially one in the ‘emerging’
world, it is clear that in playing host to such sporting
events, countries and cities are seeking to elevate their
global image (Matheson, 2006; Rein and Shields, 2006; Konrad-
Adenauer-Stiftung, 2011). Cornelissen (2012: 78), for example,
argues that sporting events are increasingly “seen as
7
opportunities to project or ‘show-case’ [a country’s] achieved
levels of modernity to the outside world”. Referring
specifically to the Global South, Darnell (2012: 105) argues
that, “sports mega-events … are used to showcase successful
development, particularly for states struggling for legitimacy
within competitive globalisation”.
This global shift in the hosting of international sporting
events outside of the west is set to continue. Bang (2011: 1)
suggests that “the biggest events are leaving Europe and North
America”. Evidence of this dramatic shift can be provided by
the Danish Institute for Sports Studies Research which
demonstrates that only 23% of major international events, such
as the Olympic and Paralympic Games and world championship
tournaments in football, athletics and swimming, will be held
within western countries after 2010. The remaining 77% of
these events will be held within countries from the Middle
East, Asia, Africa (south of the Sahara Desert) and
Central/South America (Bang, 2011).
This shifting pattern can be conceptualised through the idea
of ‘post-westernisation’ (Rumford, 2007). For Rumford this
shift is not simply about the decreasing salience of the idea
of the west as a reference point for political identification
and global leadership, rather, it can be characterised through
a series of processes. Firstly, he suggests that post-
westernisation signals the increasing “lack of unity within
those countries formerly considered to have a common ‘Western’
world view” (Rumford, 2007: 205). Secondly, post-
westernisation signifies the co-existence of multiple
‘modernities’ – western, post-communist, Islamic – as opposed
8
to an assumed dominance of the west over the rest. Finally,
post-westernisation involves recognition of a ‘new East’
capable of “shaping global affairs previously seen as the
preserve of the West” (Rumford, 2007: 206). For example,
cricket has witnessed a shift in decision-making power from
the west – England in particular – to non-western former
peripheries of the game, principally India. It is our
contention here that power shifts within global sport are
becoming increasingly visible, which necessitates further
consideration and exploration of potential issues arising when
events are staged in these regions.
Middle Eastern countries and international sporting events
Some Islamic states are actively pursuing opportunities to
host international sports events. Today, Bahrain, United Arab
Emirates (UAE), Oman, Qatar and Iran are proving to be
attractive hosts for staging a range of international sporting
events. The financial case can be easily made for staging an
international sporting event within economically wealthy
Islamic countries such as Bahrain, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
(KSA), Qatar and the UAE (Randeree, 2011). However, socio-
cultural factors are also important to the success (or
otherwise) of international sporting events, and have not
hitherto been examined in this context. Arzt (1996: 140) notes
that the above mentioned Middle Eastern states have officially
proclaimed Islam to be the state religion. Therefore, the
value systems and everyday lives of citizens within these
countries are influenced by Islamic values and beliefs, and
not by Christianity. The beliefs and values of Islam, which
9
are reflected in the social and cultural practices of Islamic
nations, differ in many respects from the Christian-influenced
social and cultural environments of western nations which have
traditionally staged international sporting events. Thus, as
we argue in this chapter, staging international sporting
events in different social and cultural contexts, such as
those offered by non-secular Islamic states, may expose
conflicts between the Christian-based ethics and values that
underpin the ethos of those events, and the Islamic values of
host nations.
Some of the social and cultural challenges of hosting
international sporting events within non-secular Islamic
countries are already coming to the fore and receiving
attention within the general media. Recent examples of this
are: negative coverage of issues surrounding the availability
of alcohol during the Qatar 2022 FIFA World Cup (Wilson,
2010); the use of rose water and not traditional champagne at
the celebration of the winners of the Bahrain Grand Prix; the
use of inappropriate language as witnessed by Formula One
drivers at the end of the 2013 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix (Duncan,
2012); and the participation of female Muslims and the mixing
of men and women at international sporting events
(Scharenberg, 1999; Pfister, 2000; Pfister, 2010b). On all of
these issues there appears to be something of a west-east
dichotomy. Many of these examples are, effectively, ‘non-
issues’ in the west, but require a certain amount of cultural
sensitivity when events take place outside of western
contexts. Writing specifically about mega-events in BRIC
countries, Palmer (2013: 114-115) argues that research is only
now “registering the social, symbolic, political and policy
10
import of these ‘other’ events in ‘other’ countries.” In the
next section we begin to consider some of the key elements of
Islam that event managers should consider when staging major
international sporting events in non-secular Islamic
countries.
The socio-cultural implications of hosting international
sporting events within non-secular Islamic countries
Middle Eastern countries such as Bahrain, Iran, KSA, Oman,
Qatar and the UAE, are all Islamic non-secular states. Islamic
beliefs and values are regarded as a way of life for
practicing Muslims. As stated, most international sporting
events have evolved from within the western world, where
athletic dress codes are quite relaxed, dietary rules provide
for all, alcohol is often served and men and women regularly
interact in public. In addition, many of these sporting events
observe the Gregorian calendar and are loosely structured
around Christian holidays and celebration. Therefore, when
these sporting events are hosted by non-secular Islamic
countries, it may be that a process of social and cultural
understanding and evolution is required to preserve the
integrity of the host country and the appeal of the sporting
event to both existing western markets and new markets from
within the Islamic world. The question needs to be posed: what
potential issues could arise when international sporting
events are staged within non-secular Islamic countries? To
examine this issue more closely, a brief examination of
certain Islamic beliefs and values is required as a basis for
understanding what adaptations (if any) may be needed for the
11
hosting and staging of international sporting events within
non-secular Islamic countries.
The religious life of Muslims is based on adherence to the
Five Pillars of Islam. These are considered to represent the
obligations and responsibilities of all Muslims towards God
(Allah) and also towards their fellow men. Adherence to the
Five Pillars of Islam should be at the forefront of a Muslim’s
thoughts and actions at all times. The Five Pillars of Islam
are:
Shahadah (declaration of faith)
Salah (daily prayers)
Saum (fasting during the lunar month of Ramadan and other
important Islamic important)
Hajj (the pilgrimage to Makkah)
Zakah (a share of one’s surplus wealth given to those in
need of it) (Uddin, 1991).
In accordance with these Five Pillars, Muslims should also
adopt a set of beliefs, values and principles in accordance
with the teaching of the Qur’an. While many Islamic religious
beliefs, values and principles are related to personal (and
private) life, some apply to the behaviour of Muslims in
public life. Islamic religious beliefs, values and principles
that have relevance to international sporting events include
(though are not restricted to): gender segregation, dress
codes and female modesty, and dietary rules.
It is the combination of three of the Five Pillars - (1)
Shahadah, (2) Salah, (3) Saum - and the three Islamic cultural
12
beliefs and values related to gender segregation, dress code,
and dietary rules, that present particular challenges when
international sporting events are hosted and staged within
non-secular Islamic countries. Space does not allow for an
exhaustive appraisal of the intricacies of Islam and its
teachings, and we acknowledge that our discussion is only
preliminary and that there is much more research to do on this
topic. However our aim here is to signpost some key areas for
future research, and so our analysis is necessarily succinct.
Shahadah (declaration of faith)
The first of the Five Pillars is the profession of faith, or
Shahadah, which is a testimony demonstrated through prayer, to
the belief that there is no God other than Allah, and Muhammad
(pbuh) is the messenger or prophet of Allah (Uddin, 1991;
Hattstein, 2006).
Salah (daily prayers)
The second Pillar is traditionally regarded as prayer (Salah)
to be performed five times a day. These prayers are to take
place at prescribed times: 1) before sunrise (Fajr); 2) after
the sun has passed its zenith or highest point at noon (Zuhr);
3) after mid-afternoon (Asr); 4) after sunset (Maghrib); and
5) after the onset of night (Isha). The community is summoned
to prayer by the Muezzinm who calls from a tower of the
mosque. Prior to prayer, the worshippers must perform a series
of ritual ablutions called ‘Wudu’, the purpose of which is to
prepare the worshipper to approach God in a state of external
and internal purity (Hattstein, 2006). Prayer can be
13
performed by Muslims wherever they happen to be at the time.
However, crucially, wherever they are in the world, a Muslim
must face Makkah – the spiritual home of Islam - and the
prayers involve both body and mind in a series of bows and
prostrations that are performed together with recitations of
the Qur’an and praises to Allah. The Friday midday prayer,
which in Islam is the Holy day of the week, is regarded as the
most important prayer time.
Saum (fasting during the lunar month of Ramadan and other important Islamic
dates)
The ritual of fasting (Saum) is the third Pillar. Fasting is
to be observed by Muslims during the Islamic month of Ramadan.
This is a lunar month and is the ninth month of the year.
During the month of Ramadan Muslims must fast from sunrise
until sunset (Uddin, 1991). This fast is an abstinence from
eating, drinking, consumption of tobacco, or having sexual
relations (Hattstein, 2006). However, certain groups are
exempt from fasting, including, for example, the sick, and
pregnant women, or those who undertake heavy labour, as well
as Muslims who have travelled or are travelling. The Islamic
calendar and its important dates differ to the Gregorian
calendar of western societies and countries. Key dates and
holidays are related to such occasions as Ramadan, Hajj, Eid
and the Islamic New Year; all of which are lunar events, and
so do not take place on the same calendar dates each year.
In addition to the three aforementioned Pillars, we have
decided to focus on three key issues influenced by Islamic
values and beliefs. We acknowledge that there are many more
14
important aspects of Islam, but due to space constraints we
have limited our discussion to three issues that have most
relevance to sports events.
Gender segregation
Islam holds that men and women are equal in the sight of God
(Badawi, 2011). Some forms of Islam require men and women to
maintain their own social groups and gatherings, segregated by
gender (Bleher, 2009). Within Islam, in accordance with
Sharia Law, the head of the household (the husband) decides on
all major issues pertinent to the family. His duty as head of
the family extends to economically maintaining his wife or
wives and, in return, his wife or wives are committed to
obedience (Pfister, 2010b). One of the main points regulated
through female deference to the male head of the household is
the regulation of sexuality, which is controlled by gender
segregation. The degree of segregation may differ between
different Muslim societies and countries, and their
interpretation of the Qu’ran (Russell and O’Connor, 2013). In
some interpretations this can prevent women from having any
contact with males from outside of the family. The head of the
household can also determine what the other members are
allowed and not allowed to do outside of the home. This can
include sporting participation or being a spectator at
sporting events. Sport has long been a masculine-dominated
institution and many women have struggled for greater female
sporting participation, inclusion and recognition (Hargreaves,
1994). Whilst many people celebrate the gains made by female
sports and athletes, for some Muslim women sport can be an
unappealing environment that conflicts with religious,
15
cultural and social preferences for female modesty and gender
segregation (Zamin, 1997; see also Bains, this volume).
Dress code and female modesty
The London 2012 Olympic Games witnessed for the first time
participation of female Muslim athletes from Qatar, Saudi
Arabia and Brunei. Their participation illuminated a number of
underlying tensions between the IOC (and other sporting
bodies) who promote mass participation, and ‘home’ politics,
which had, even in the run up to the Games, actively
discouraged participation of females in sport. There is a
growing body of literature into Muslim women’s experiences of
and participation in sport (Hargreaves, 2007; Kay, 2007). This
has focused on the following areas: religion; patriarchy and
male power; and, veiling and the body. Islam advocates that
women and girls should adopt a modest dress code when seen in
public and to maintain this they may have to cover their
bodies; something that works to guarantee gender differences
and social hierarchies (Pickthall, 2011). The extent to which
female modesty is regulated through dress is a complex issue
and beyond the scope of this chapter. However, issues to do
with dress code and female modesty may have implications for
staging international sports events in non-secular Islamic
countries in the following ways: clothing of female athletes;
mixing of male and female athletes; spectators – dress and
segregated viewing areas; and, media images and sponsorship
messages associated with the event.
Dietary rules (food and alcohol consumption)
16
Islamic religious beliefs and values related to food and drink
dictate what food can be lawfully consumed by Muslims (Bachok
et al., 2012). Referring to readings from the Qur’an,
Pickthall (2011: 64) states, “Forbidden to (for food) are
carrion and blood and swineflesh, and that which has been
dedicated to any other than Allah”. Muslims will only eat
meat where the blood of the animal has been allowed to drain
fully from the animal’s body (Bleher, 2009). This is known as
Zabiha (halal) method where the food has been prepared,
stored, manufactured, slaughtered and served in a manner
prescribed by Shariah Law. Islam also forbids the consumption
of anything which might interfere with the perception of the
senses or blurring of judgment, like alcohol or mind altering
drugs (Bleher, 2009; Bachok et al, 2012). Some more liberal
Muslim countries adopt a more relaxed approach to the sale and
consumption of alcohol, while in other non-secular Muslim
countries like the KSA and Iran it is illegal to possess and
to consume alcohol, both by Muslims and non-Muslims (discussed
further below).
Discussion
International sporting events cost millions - and in some
cases billions - of pounds to host and stage (Horne and
Whannel, 2012). The global economic crisis which started in
2008, and the resulting lack of financial liquidity in much of
the western world, means that western governments are finding
it increasingly hard to justify the spend needed to host and
stage major international sporting events. The recent world
global shift in political influence and economic power, and a
17
greater tolerance towards socio-cultural differences, has
created a situation where many emerging nations are regarded
as financially lucrative potential host cities for
international sporting events. Islamic countries such as KSA,
Qatar, Bahrain, and the UAE, are economically wealthy and have
the financial liquidity to stage major international sporting
events. According to Russell and O’Connor (2013: 209), “The
financial liquidity available to the emerging countries of the
Middle East and East Asia have put these nations, with their
mainly Muslim populations, at the forefront of those seeking
to stage mega-events, becoming active participants within such
events and the opening of new media audiences and markets that
have often been untapped”. This has brought into focus a
number of potential social, cultural and political challenges
and issues associated with non-secular Islamic nations staging
major international sporting events.
Many international sporting events, such as those associated
with international tennis, athletics, golf, cycling, and
Formula One, are currently being staged in Qatar, UAE and
Bahrain. Most recently, the economic and financial strength of
many non-secular Islamic countries has led to the decision to
award the FIFA 2022 World Cup to Qatar. This will be the
first time that a mega sporting event will be hosted and
staged within a non-secular Islamic state. Mindful of this
fact, international sporting events may well need to take into
account and, in some cases, adapt, elements of the event as a
result of some significant issues related to the Islamic
world’s beliefs and values, as outlined in this chapter. These
include: Shahadah (declaration of faith), Salah (daily
prayers), Saum (fasting), gender segregation, dress codes and
18
dietary rules. We will now spend some time unpacking each of
these.
Today it is common place for athletes, especially successful
ones, to demonstrate signs of their religious faith and
beliefs in public. Lionel Messi, when he scores a goal, points
towards the sky and offers a prayer in a religious gesture.
Mohammed Farrar is often witnessed going to his knees after a
race victory to give praise, and Usain Bolt is often seen
after a race victory pointing to the sky and mouthing the
words ‘thank you God’. Other actions by sports participants
include: athletes touching the ground, followed by crossing
themselves; pointing to the sky; and openly praying. In many
sports, such as football and judo, shows of religious faith
and the wearing of garments determined by religion (such as
the head scarf or hijab) are banned (Ferris-Lay, 2012).
However, pressure from many quarters has forced some sporting
federations to re-visit their rules and regulations. The
International Judo Federation (IJF) is one organisation that
has recently made changes to its policies. In this instance,
the Federation revised its policy towards the Muslim head
scarf to allow Saudi Arabian female Judo competitor, Wojdan
Ali Seraj Abdulrahim Shaherkanim, to wear one of an approved
design during competition at the London 2012 Olympic Games.
Originally, the IJF had banned the head scarf on the basis of
athlete safety, despite the fact that the Asian Judo
Federation has previously allowed Muslim women to wear the
head scarf during major competitions (Magnay, 2012). However,
such revisions are not necessarily welcomed by all. Some
sports bodies have suggested for instance, that sporting
attire, designed to maintain the modesty of female Muslim
19
athletes, may in fact give a competitor an unfair advantage
over their rivals. This was the case when Muslim female
swimmers began to wear a full body suit, which the swimming
federations subsequently banned (Pfister, 2000). These
decisions can have significant consequences. FIFA’s decision
to ban the hijab in 2007 led to the Saudi Arabian women’s
football team missing out on qualification rounds for the 2012
Olympic Games. Notably, FIFA have changed this rule and now
allow female players to wear approved hijabs, although this
was too late for the Saudi women’s team (Reuters, 2012). As a
result, pressure is mounting from both the athletes themselves
and concerned governing bodies for rule changes to allow for
such garments to be worn in other competitions to preserve the
modesty of Muslim females in accordance with their religious
beliefs and values.
Certain international sporting events may also offend some
Muslims and it would be deemed culturally unsuitable to not
only take part in, but also to watch those events. Here we are
referring specifically to the attire of athletes within those
sports. Examples of such sports are female beach volleyball,
female tennis and female swimming events, which may, due to
the dress codes often associated with the sports and worn by
athletes taking part in these events, expose certain parts of
the body that may cause offence to Muslim viewers. It is not
unreasonable to assume that Muslims would boycott such events
if they took place in non-secular Islamic countries, thereby
discrediting these events, and creating an uneasy atmosphere
for athletes and spectators
20
In respect of the Islamic call to daily prayers, event
organisers have to ensure mosques or multi-faith prayer rooms
are available for worship. This will allow Muslim athletes the
opportunity to join communally to conduct their five daily
prayers while taking part in the event itself. However, the
call for prayer need not hold up an event. The call does not
mean athletes have to pray at that particular moment, as long
as they manage to find a time to pray before the next call to
prayer goes out. Sports event organisers would thus need to
ensure that competition programmes were organised in such a
way that allows Muslim competitors sufficient time for prayer,
in addition to their sporting activities.
International sporting events that conform to the Gregorian
calendar may have to be re-scheduled in accordance with the
Islamic calendar and important Islamic dates. This is not
necessarily a simple task because many of these ‘important’
dates are dependent upon the sighting of the moon and are
therefore not fixed dates from one year to the next. In
addition, important Islamic dates related to holidays, birth
celebrations and New Year all differ to the calendar used in
the west and could present logistical problems if sports event
organisers are not aware of them. The practice of Ramadan is a
case in point. Ramadan is a traditional period for fasting and
any attempt to host an international sporting event during
this holy Islamic month may meet with some resistance. This
consideration is particularly relevant for non-secular Islamic
states, as hosting during this time could be interpreted as a
clear disregard of important Islamic dates that are to be
respected as holy and as times for religious reflection and
practice. Mindful of this, members of the sports and the
21
sports events industry(ies) need to become acquainted with
Islamic beliefs and values, and must reflect (and encourage
others to reflect) critically on the challenges these present.
As numbers of Muslim female athletes and female spectators are
growing, some other aspects of international sporting events
may prove problematic. Gender segregation in terms of sport,
accommodation, eating areas and within spectating and
socialising areas, may have to be tolerated and implemented,
in accordance with the teachings of Islam. Practically this
would require areas for females and males only, and family
areas being implemented in respect of some of the beliefs and
values of Islam. Attempts to force gender integration at
sports events within non-secular Islamic states could create
tensions and frictions, and could be considered offensive and
a clear breach of Islamic teaching and practices. This could
result in (Muslim) females playing no part in the sporting
event.
In the history of the Western world, modern sports cultures,
leisure and alcohol have been intimately linked (Fletcher and
Spracklen, 2013). Some sports, for example football, rugby and
cricket, are closely associated with alcohol, both in terms of
their leisure culture and sponsorship. In Western countries,
where alcohol is permissible by law and tradition, and a part
of popular culture, the consumption of alcohol is seen as
crucial to human interaction and sociality (Fletcher and
Spracklen, 2013). Indeed, the drinking of alcohol is a key
leisure ritual, and in sport, as in any other part of leisure
where sociality is important, drinking and buying drinks is an
accepted part of the subcultural practice. It is common, for
22
example, for spectators to consume alcohol (often to excess)
within grounds and stadia where events are staged (Collins and
Vamplew, 2002). However, this ritual is not, and cannot, be
enjoyed by all. Within non-secular Islamic countries where
alcohol is not tolerated this culture of drinking may present
conflicts; between spectators in and outside the venues and,
in some cases, with sponsors, such as Budweiser which has
traditionally used sports events like the FIFA World Cup to
showcase its products. The lack of availability and tolerance
of alcohol in non-secular Islamic countries is an important
issue to consider in that it may discourage some (western)
fans from travelling to an Islamic country to actually attend
the event. Moreover, there is evidence of western travellers
getting into difficulty – some have been heavily fined and
even jailed – for consuming alcohol in non-designated areas
(dba, n.d). Some Islamic countries have relaxed their policies
towards alcohol consumption. For example, some have
established designated areas to allow non-Muslims to enjoy
alcohol in public places – events for example - and in some
international hotels. However, general public consumption,
i.e. in the streets or outside licenced designated bars, will
likely not be encouraged, and would result in trouble for
western travellers not necessarily accustomed to local
cultural expectations (Widen, 2013).
This debate is timely given the current discussions over the
legitimacy of Qatar as host for the 2022 FIFA World Cup
(alongside concerns for the staging of the event during the
Qatar summer months). While various forms of non-alcoholic
products can be used, consumed and promoted, event organisers
face challenges from a number of places over how to deal with
23
the questions of alcohol consumption and alcohol sponsors when
staging international sporting events in non-secular Islamic
countries. In addition, event organisers would have to be
mindful not to offer Muslims non-halal foods, and halal foods
would have to be clearly signed with suppliers checking to
ensure only halal products are used as ingredients.
Thus, some adaptations may be needed when major sports events
are hosted in non-secular Islamic countries. There is some
evidence to suggest that international sports events rights
holders, e.g. FIFA, are willing to make such changes to
accommodate Islamic beliefs and values in relation to matters
such as public shows of faith, worship, respect of the Islamic
calendar and important dates, dress codes and the public
consumption of alcohol, in order to ensure international
sporting events can be hosted and staged within non-secular
Islamic countries. This is important if event organisers,
rights holders and partners are seeking greater participation
of Muslims in international sporting events, as well as
greater spectator bases from within the Muslim world.
Furthermore, as the first mega-sports event to be staged
within a non-secular Islamic state (FIFA Qatar World Cup,
2022) approaches, factors associated with Islam that may clash
with the culture of the event will need to be raised and
discussed. Suitable solutions and compromises may need to be
found to ensure both the integrity of the host nation and that
of the event itself are maintained.
We acknowledge that the content of this chapter is
preliminary. As we have stressed throughout, a critical
appraisal of the many intricacies within Islam, and of
24
sporting events too, are beyond the scope of this chapter. Our
intention was not necessarily to provide answers to our
observations. Rather, our intention was to provoke others to
engage in work on this topic. At the very least, our aim was
to shed light on some of the ‘back stage’ (Goffman, 1959)
‘anticipatory concerns’ (Palmer, 2013) that surround hosting
major sporting events in non-Secular Islamic countries. In so
doing, we hope these are now ‘front stage’ (Goffman, 1959) and
ready for further interrogation.
Palmer (2013: 150) summarises our main contention by arguing
that “as new countries appear on the mega-event circuit,
systems, policies and regimes that were previously ‘closed’
become subject to scrutiny . . . [meaning that] what were once
largely domestic policy concerns are now situated within a
wider milieu of exogenous policies, politics and pressures
that circulate globally.” Therefore, it is important that
individuals and organisations involved in major international
sports events become more culturally aware, thus ensuring they
can anticipate challenges brought about by local traditions,
customs, beliefs and lifestyles of host communities.
Adaptations and compromises on the behalf of both the host
community and event rights holders may be necessary for the
future success and development of major international sporting
events, within and beyond non-secular Islamic countries.
25
References
Amara, M. (2012) Veiled women athletes in the 2008 Beijing
Olympics: Media accounts. The International Journal of History of Sport.
29(4): 638-651.
Artz, D.E. (1996) Religious human rights in Muslim states of the Middle East
and North Africa religious human rights in the world today: A report on the 1994
Atlanta conference: Legal perspectives on religious human rights. Emory
International Law Review. Georgia, USA.
Bachok, S., Chik, C.T., Arsat, A., Jamil, J. and Ghani, M. A
(2012) Detection of non halal ingredients for halal
verification in bakery and confectionery in Malaysia. In A.
Zainal, S.M. Radzi. And R. Hashim (eds) Current issues in hospitality
and tourism research and innovations. Proceedings of the International
Hospitality and Tourism Conference. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 3-
5 September.
Badawi, J. (2011) The position of women in Islam. Birmingham: Islamic
Dawah Centre International.
Bang, S. (2011). Western countries are losing the race for major sporting
events [Online] Available from
http://www.playthegame.org/news/detailed/western-countries-
are-losing-the-race-for-major-sporting-events-5156.html
[Accessed May 7, 2013].
Bleher, S.M. (2009) Islam: A brief guide. Birmingham: Islamic Dawah
Centre International.
26
Collins, T. and Vamplew, W. (2002) Mud, sweat and beers: A cultural
history of sport and alcohol. Oxford: Berg.
Cornelissen, S. (2012) A delicate balance: Major sports events
and development. In R. Levermore and A. Beacon (eds) Sport and
international development. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan: 76-97.
Darnell, S. (2012) Sport for development and peace: A critical sociology.
London: Bloomsbury.
Dashper, K. (2012) Together, yet still not equal? Sex
integration in equestrian sport. Asia-Pacific Journal of Health, Sport and
Physical Education. 3(3): 213-225.
dba. (n.d) ‘Dos and Don’ts’ for business visitors to the UAE [online]
Available from
http://www.dba.org.uk/aboutdba/newsarticles/documents/DosandDo
nts.pdf [Accessed November 6, 2013].
Duncan, P. (2012). Raikkonen and Vettel turn the air blue on
live TV, forcing BBC's Coulthard to apologise. [Online]
Available from
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/formulaone/article-2227827/Ki
mi-Raikkonen-Sebastian-Vettel-swear-Abu-Dhabi-live-TV-forcing-
BBCs-David-Coulthard-apologise.html [Accessed March 3, 2013].
Ferdinand, N. and Shaw. S.J. (2012) Events in our changing
world. In N. Ferdinand. and P.J. Kitchen (eds) Event management:
An international approach. London: Sage, 5-22.
27
Fletcher, T and Spracklen, K. (2013) Cricket, drinking and
exclusion of British Pakistani Muslims? Ethnic and Racial Studies.
DOI:10.1080/01419870.2013.790983. Published online April 29.
Ferris-Lay, C. (2012). British MP slams Saudi ban on female
Olympic athletes [Online] Available from
http://www.arabianbusiness.com/british-mp-slams-saudi-ban-on-
female-olympic-athletes-447330.html [Accessed March 25, 2012].
Getz, D. (2008). Events tourism: Definition, evolution and
research. Tourism Management. 29: 403-428.
Getz, D. (2012). Events studies. In S.J. Page. And J. Connell
(eds) The Routledge handbook of events. Oxon: Routledge, 27-46.
Goffman, E. (1959) The presentation of self in everyday life. New York:
Anchor Books.
Gupta, A. (2004) The globalization of cricket: The rise of the
non-West. International Journal of the History of Sport. 21(2): 257-276.
Gupta, A. (2009) The globalisation of sports, the rise of non-
western nations, and the impact on international sporting
events. The International Journal of the History of Sport. 26(2): 1779-1790.
Hargreaves, J. (1994) Sporting females: critical issues in the history and
sociology of women’s sport. London: Routledge.
Hargreaves, J. (2007) Sport, exercise and the female Muslim
body: Negotiating Islam, politics and male power. In J.
28
Hargreaves and P. Vertinsky (eds) Physical culture, power and the body.
London: Routledge, 74-100.
Hattstein, M. (2006). Islam: Religion and culture. Germany: Konemann.
Holt, R. (1990) Sport and the British: A modern history. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Horne, J. and Whannel, G. (2012) Understanding the Olympics.
London: Routledge.
Kay, T.A. (2007) Daughters of Islam: Family influences on
Muslim young women’s participation in sport. International Review for
the Sociology of Sport. 41(3-4): 357-375.
Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung. (2011) Sustainable mega-events in developing
countries: Experiences and insights from host cities in South Africa, India and Brazil
[online] Available from http://www.kas.de/wf/doc/kas_29583-
1522-2-30.pdf?111209095524 [Accessed July 23, 2012].
Magnay, J. (2012) London 2012 Olympics: Saudi judo competitor will not be
allowed to wear headscarf due to safety concerns [online] Available from
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/olympics/judo/9430190/London-
2012-Olympics-Saudi-judo-competitor-will-not-be-allowed-to-
wear-headscarf-due-to-safety-concerns.html [Accessed November
15, 2013].
Maguire, J. (1999) Global sport: Identities, societies and civilisations.
Cambridge: Polity.
29
Matheson, V.A. (2006) Mega-Events: The effect of the world’s biggest sporting
events on local, regional, and national economies [online] Available from
http://casgroup.fiu.edu/pages/docs/2744/1277904942_matheson_ev
ents.pdf [Accessed March 2, 2013].
Palmer, C. (2013) Global sports policy. London: Sage.
Pfister. G. (2000) Doing sport in a headscarf? German sports
and Turkish females. Journal of Sport History. 27(3): 497-525.
Pfister, G. (2010a) Women in sport: Gender relations and
future perspectives. Sport in Society. 13(2): 234-248.
Pfister, G. (2010b) Outsiders: Muslim women and Olympic Games:
Barriers and opportunities. The International Journal of the History of
Sport. 27(16-18): 2925-2957.
Pickthall, M.M. (2011) The glorious Qur’an: An explanatory translation.
Birmingham: Islamic Dawah Centre International.
Randeree, K. (2011) Islam and the Olympics: Seeking a host
city in the Muslim world. International Journal of Islamic and Middle
Eastern Finance and Management. 4(3): 211–226.
Reuters. (2012) FIFA lifts ban on hijab for women footballers [online]
Available from http://tribune.com.pk/story/404321/fifa-lifts-
ban-on-headscarves-for-women-footballers/ [Accessed November 5
2013].
Riordan, J. and Kruger, A. (eds) (1999) The international politics of
sport in the 20th century. London: Routledge.
30
Rein. I. and Shields, B. (2006) Place branding sports:
Strategies for differentiating emerging transitional,
negatively viewed and newly industrialised nations. Place
Branding and Public Diplomacy. 3(1): 73-85.
Rumford, C. (2007) More than a game: Globalization and the
post-Westernization of world cricket. Global Networks. 7(2): 202-
214.
Russell, K.A. and O’Connor, N. (2013) The London 2012 Olympic
Games: The cultural tourist as a pillar of sustainability. In
R. Raj., K. Griffin. and N. Morpeth (eds) Cultural tourism.
Wallingford, UK: CABI, 204-211.
Scharenberg, S. (1999) Religion and sport. In J. Riordan. and
A. Kruger (eds) The international politics of sport in the 20th century.
London: Routledge.
Uddin, R. (1991) It’s about Islam. London: Islamic Awareness
Project.
Wagg, S and Andrews, D.L. (eds) (2006) East plays west: Sport and the
cold war. London: Routledge.
Weber, M. (1992) The Protestant ethic and spirit of capitalism (translated
by T. Parsons). London: Routledge.
Widen, E. (2013) Qatar in clampdown on alcohol sales in hotels, pools and
beaches [online] Available from
http://www.arabianbusiness.com/qatar-in-clampdown-on-alcohol-
31
sales-in-hotel-pools-beaches-525708.html [Accessed November
10, 2013].
Wilson, J. (2010) Qatar’s hosting of the 2022 World Cup finals is FIFA’s most
dangerous move yet [online] Available from
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/international/817696
6/Qatars-hosting-of-the-2022-World-Cup-finals-is-Fifas-most-
dangerous-move-yet.html [Accessed March 12, 2012].
Zamin, H. (1997) Islam, well-being and physical activity:
Perceptions of Muslim young women. In G. Clarke. and B.
Humberstone (eds) Researching women and sport. Basingstoke:
Macmillan Press, 50-67.
32