..

:/

Search for Conceptual Frameworkin Architectural Works of Muzharullslam

111111111 11111111111111111111111111191725#

Mohammad Foyez Ullah

This thesis is submitted to the Department of Architecturein partial fulfilment of the requirements for

the degree of Master of Architecture

August, 1997

Department of ArchitectureBangladesh University of Engineering & Technology

Dhaka. Bangladesh .

•

•

.'

II

DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTUREBANGLADESH UNIVERSIlY OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGYDhaka 1000

On this day, the 14'h August, Thursday, 1997, the undersigned hereby recommends tothe Academic Council that the thesis titled "Search for Conceptual Framework inArchitectural Works of Muzharul Islam" submitted by Mohammad Foyez Ullah,Roll no. 9202, Session 1990-91-92 is acceptable in partial fulfilment of the requirementsfor the degree of Master of Architecture.

Dr. M. Shahidul AmeenAssociate Professor and SupervisorDepartment of ArchitectureBangladesh University of Engineering & Technology

Professor Faruque A. U. KhanDean, Faculty of Architecture and PlanningBangladesh University of Engineering & Technology

Professor Khaleda RashidHead, Department of ArchitectureBangladesh University of Engineering & Technology

Md. Salim UllahSenior Research ArchitectHousing and Building Research InstituteDar-us-Salam, Mirpur

~Member ----------

*-/.~<1 ';;5Member~n(External)

To my Father

III

IV

Acknowledgements

I would like to express my sincerest thank to Dr. M. Shahidul Ameen for supervising the

thesis and for his intellectual impulses that he offered in making the thesis a true critical

discourse. lowe my sincerest thank to Professor Meer Mobashsher Ali for his

commitment to make the research on this eminent architect a reality. I am extremely

grateful to Muzharul Islam. who even at his age of 74 showed his ultimate modesty by

sharing his experiences and knowledge with me, which helped me to see his enterprises

in a truer enlightened way. My special thanks to Mustapha Khalid for his insightful

criticism and effective support during the course of the thesis. I wish to thank architect

Saiful Haq of Chetana for his valuable support in providing me with some rare

documents on Muzharul's work. I would also like to extend my thanks to architect K.

Iftekhar Ahmed for thoughtful criticism and M. A. Riyaad and Atiq for their support in

many occasions. My sincerest thanks to my family, especially to my wife and daughter,

whose warmth and attachment gave me the strength and mental support, that I needed

most to complete this thesis.

Contents

DedicationAcknowledgementsAbstract

Prologue

Defining the Conceptual FrameworkList of Case StudiesOutline of the Thesis

Chapter 01Muzharul Islam: thoughts and practice

Selected Thoughts of Muzharul IslamProfessional Career: an overview

1- Early Phase (1955-64)11- The IntelVening Phase (1964-70)111-The Late Phase (1971-to date)

Chapter 02

Architectural Vocabulary:Selected Buildings and Projects

Chapter 03

Representation onElemental Laws of Architecture

Chapter 04

Roots and Relevancein Modernist Inspiration

Probing the underlying principles of Le CorbusierSearch for Regional Expression'Context'Redefined:Focus shifted to Kahn From CorbusierEpilogue

Appendix

Bibliography.

IIIIVVI

1-6

7

8-1111-16

17

18-57

58

59-70

71

72-7475

76-7979-81

82-87

88-90

v

VI

Abstract

The thesis originated from the intention to examine a key architect of this country and his

practical enterprises in the light of investigations whether his philosophies and practical

endeavours have any bearing on contemporary thought and influence current theory and

practices of architecture. Work of Muzharul Islam as case studies, it tries to explore the

conceptual framework bearing on his own quest for relevancy and roots in architecture. In

conclusion, the thesis shows that, despite the shorter period of his active involvement in

the profession, the work of Muzharul Islam demonstrated an advancement of framing

concepts derived from the vocabulary of certain contemporary western masters towards a

more personal style. At the most abstract level, this advancement can be stated as a

resultant effect of a dialectic process reflected through a progression of experiments

carried out from his earlier work to the work of the late phase. This dialectic process can

be summarised as a philosophical devise of 'causality' theory: having two factors acting

together as a 'cause', and its 'effect' as a resultant phenomenon. The 'cause' factors are:

1) the knowledge of Modem Architecture in his formative period in the western countries

and 2) the knowledge of adaptive techniques, he contrived in the practical application.

The resultant 'effect' of the 'cause' shows that the architectural value in Muzharul Islam's

work exists in the synthesis of modernist inspiration and the inspiration emanating from

his attitude towards the creation of a unity in mediating the conflicts and contradictions

between modernist and traditionalist rules of expression.

Prologue

Following the partition of India in 1947, new context was set for revival of a new counhy

within a new socio-political and geographical entity of East Pakistan. The then East

Pakistan observed a period of some new architectural events that has not been seen since

the era of Indo-European architecture of early 20s. Being trained in the West, Muzharul

Islam, was believed to be entrusted with an opportunity to explore and initiate new

approaches to design, as well as develop a profession, capable of articulating the needs of

his counhy. Hence he assumes crucial significance in the architectural history of the then

East Pakistan and consequently Bangladesh, for his contribution in the developed notions

of architecture which recognised and celebrated the fact that no other architect of this

region has ever attracted so

much attention both locally

and internationally

beginning with his Art

College, Dhaka University

(1955). (Fig.!.)

Flg.1. Muzharullslam: ArtCollege and Public Dbrary.

published in the Architectural '.. .' •.....•.Review, April 1960. ~~~,~!t~~~~~~~it?T.l~~

In Bangladesh, since after its emergence in 1971, much has not been written or talked on

architectural precedents set by its predecessors, the implication being, that the last fifty

years of its architectural history were an aberration within a continuity of an overall study

and practice of architecture. It is perhaps, for this reason that one denies the very lessons

of those years, without which one would hardly be in a position to appreciate and, so to

speak, rediscover one's own.!

One of the problems of examining the architectural precedents of Bangladesh lies in the

prevailing lacuna in study and documentation of its architectural history as an intellectual

I KaziAnisuddin Iqbai, (ed.); Portrait of Muzharui Islam based on an intelView, in Sthapattya 0 Nirman, vol..2, issue 1. Dhaka. Janua1}'-March, 1992. pp.14-15., In the intelView, Muzharul Islam referred to historicalreferences to reinvigorate tradition and identity. The deepest concern for 'identity', for which Muzharulstressed in the interview, suggested that true architecture can only be a reality when it originates from its longcherished 'roots'. Also see Stanley Tigerrnan, pp. 63-64., to uncover Muzharul's insight regarding his owntradition.

2

discipline. The question that comes up in any discussion on our local architectural history

always fails to ascertain the proper influence bearing upon the ongoing development of

architecture. Therefore, to interpret the history or to rediscover in the past in a truer

critical discourse, major architects should be studied thoroughly assimilating the larger

concerns of theory and practice framed within a comprehensive understanding of

architecture. 2

To create a critical discourse on architectural works of an architect entails appreciation of

the coexisting architectural trends, relevancy of a particular context of a particular period.

This would in tum encourage the students and professionals the very basis of evolution of

their own architectural tradition. Perhaps for this, the thesis would contribute to the

existing knowledge in architecture and will provide an opportunity to explore issues

related to the theory and practice in a critical way. Record and analysis of an eminent

local architect would be a source of inspiration and intellectual exercise to the younger

generations. Architectural precedents are placed as durable symbols that remain in the

cultural history as a testament to the lives of people, their spirit and aspirations3, and their

civilisations. This thesis, in a way by examining some of those symbols contrived by a

major architect, would help explore new patterns of pursuit and practice to meet the

challenges of an evolving society with changed expectations. Then, there is the manifest

debate between modem movement and 'contextualism' in architecture,4 which, in the

present 'single entity' global context results in deepest ambivalances,5 related to cultural

roots and relevances. A level of resolution of this international debate as contrived in the

conclusion would allow this thesis to be related to a wider architectural milieu.

2 Romi Khosla; Including Iconography and Images in Architecture, in the Techniques & Architecture:Architecture in India, Paris, September, 1985. p. 97. In search for architecture that links to the 'ethos' of aparticular culture or tradition, Khosla suggested that the broad basis of architecture of a country entailsdetailed study of its major architects to reveal diachronic images and associations. In our local context too, thesame implies when we go for studying one of the leading architects of this region - Muzharul Islam. Also seeColquhoun 1991, pp. 129.151, to comprehend the need for studying architects of a particular region toreveal the broad basis architecrure is suggested.3 Ibid., p. 97.4 See, Sarayu Ahuja; Roots of ContemooraIV Style, in the Indian Architect & Builder, Raju! Shah (ed.),Business Press. Bombay, India; vol. 5 no. 5, January, 1992. p. 8-16. Probably it is one among the mostcrucial debates (acing developing countries in the present days., Ibid., pp. 8-16.

3

The thesis thus attempts to make a comprehensive study on architecture on the need to

reinvent the local tradition and possibilities by examining one of its most influential

architects - Muzharul Islam. Through this research, the existing information of

architectural history, theory and criticism can be extended in an unexplored direction by

investigating the ways in which the architect has thought about and studied architecture,

the kinds of values and meanings he thought his works embody, and the extent to which

his ideas have changed with the varying intellectual climate of successive generations.

Defining the Conceptual Framework

Before you study the history, study the historian ... Before you study the

historian, study his historical and social environment. The historian, being an

individual, is also a product of history and of society; and it is in this twofold light

that the student of history must learn to regard him.6 (Watkin 1983)

The implication of Watkin's statement lies in tune with the basic purpose of this research,

in which it is engaged to identify the theories/concepts that underlie the architect's part in

the making of architecture and to provide analysis of the contextual relationships between

the architectural product and the historicaVcultural development. Therefore, in the

sequence of identifying Muzharul's conceptual framework, it is intended to build upon

and develop an understanding of architectural vocabulary as a whole, framed within a

thorough investigation of larger implications of his architectural design. The implications

entail Muzharul's ability in the creative synthesis in the search for architecture within the

boundaries of this region, the clarity of purpose in the making of architectural form,

materials and construction techniques, and his ultimate sense of architectural judgements

and actions. Finally, it is intended to explore the conceptual framework that underlie

Muzharul's work through the critical juxtaposition of those invesigated information in an

attempt to draw upon his personality in the development of the architecture in particular,

and the intellectual atmosphere in general.

The research is largely based on case studies, supplemented by systematic documentation

of Muzharul's buildings and projects and review of relevant literature and treatises on

him. A background research on available literature and discussion with the architect

6 See, David Watkin; The Rise of Architectural HistoN; The Architectural Press, London, 1983. p. ix.

4

reciprocated the case studies. Specific emphasis is placed on a critical inquiry of the

architect's different projects on the basis of architect's skills in architectural form-making

and representation against certain basic architectural tenets, such as:

i. Spatial organisation (attitude to space making through layers, from

outside to inside, from profane to sacred etc.)

ii. Ordering ideas (whether it accepted complexity and vibrant resolution of

divergence or an apparent easy resolution of reducing them to singular

unity)

iii. Elemental laws concerning massing, circulation, structure and services and

space definition etc.

iv. Relationship between fundamental elements of architecture.

In this regard, these design precepts can be considered as the major criteria for analysing

and evaluating whether his works are built upon those precepts and brings about a

conceptual framework based on relationships between culture/context and general theory

of ideas.

List of Case Studies

The projects taken as case studies are listed below:

Art College (now Fine Arts Institute, Dhaka University, Dhaka.Public Library (now Centra! Library, Dhaka University, Dhaka.The Council for Scientific and fndustrial Research Laboratories (CSfR), Dhaka.The National fnstitute of Public Administration (NIPA), Dhaka.The Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation office, Dhaka.EFU Building, Dhaka.Five Polytechnic Institutes (Rangpur, Pabna, Barisal, Bogra and Sylhet). 7

Own Residence, Dhaka.New Campus for Chittagong University, Chittagong.Campus for Jahangimagar University, Savar.Housing for Limestone Mining and cement Works, Joypurhat.National Library and the National Archives, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka.

The case studies selected cover almost all the representative works of Muzharul Islam. The

projects not listed or taken as case studies for the thesis for the following reasons:

7 This project was done in collaboration with Stanley Tigerman, a dose-friend of Muzharul and classmate atYale.

5

Arst, the architect does not want to 'own' those projects due to his personal

dissatisfaction. which probably resulted from the professional complications he

encountered throughout his career.8 Second, the unlisted projects have deficiency related

to availability of information.

Outline of the Thesis

'The search for tradition, culture. architecture and art in newly independent and once-

colonised countries is a continuing struggle. In architecture this task is extremely

perplexing. especially when there exists in a country a contemporary trend of modernism

which blindly follows Western models.'9 Probably, the main reason for the task to be

perplexing is the predominant lacuna endemic to Bangladesh in all-intellectual discipline

in the search for identity and the transition from colonial to independent rule. Despite this

never-ending debate on the role of British colonialism on the Indian sub-continent, it is

almost proved to be true that we can not leave out the 'overwhelming spectre,jO of

colonialism even in contemporary times.

The analytical methodology adopted, first takes an overview of Muzharul's career in a

non-conceptual observation and then authenticates it against the critical findings from the

detailed study of case studies. Second, the investigation ends with arriving at a synthesis

by dialecticallyjuxtaposing those observations.

The first chapter of the thesis provides an overview of Muzharul's professional career

through his thoughts as textual productions and chronological information about his

projects. This chapter acts as a tool to examine the issues related to Muzharul's notions

and practices in the light of inquiring the being of consistencies and dilemma in his

outputs.

8 Kazi Anisuddin Iqbal, (ed.); Portrait of Muzharullslam based on an interview, in Sthapattya 0 Nirman,1992. p. 15., The fact is, Muzharul enjoyed only twelve years of his calculated thirty-six years of professionalcareer and rest of the time he was deliberately barred from designing for p:Jlitical reasons.

9 Saif-ul-haq; Architecture within the folk tradition: a representation from Bangladesh, in TraditionalDwellings and Settlements Review, vol. v, no. ii, , IASTE, University of California Berkley, California, Spring,1994. p.72. Referred to Bangladesh situation while explaining the 'neglect of tradition'.

6

The second chapter deals with the case studies. The individual cases are studied to

explore the underlying concept Muzharul framed up in dealing with broad-based issues of

architecture. The issues are identified as 'expressive languages' Muzharullodged to fonn

his architectural territory. The case studies are thus analysed critically to interpret the

underlying meaning of fonnal elements, order and their relationships coherently

expressed in the expressive territory of Muzharul Islam.

The third chapter deals with more representative projects short-listed from the broad-

based case studies to render a more coherent image or reflection of the expressive

vocabularies of Muzharul Islam. The analysis technique employed, to show the fonnalities

and their consistencies in the projects, is based on a recognised tool developed by the

School of Design, North Carolina State University at Raleigh (Utsey 1982).

The fourth chapter is the concluding chapter. It tries to bring about a synthesised opinion

fonned on the basis of studies and observations of the earlier chapters. However, this

chapter also portrays Muzharul's conceptual framework in a dialectic interpretation, which

establishes the theoretical relationship between Muzharul Islam and the contemporary

paradigms. It also provides an epilogue suggesting the inmost abstracted lessons of

Muzharul Islam in contrast to any conclusive statement of polemical stance.

10 Kazi Khaleed Ashraf; Muzharul Islam, Kahn and Architecture in Bangladesh, in Mimar: Architecture inDevelopment, Hasan-Uddin Khan (ed.); Concept Media, Singapore, March, 1989. p. 55. (hereafter cited as"Muzharul, Kahn and Architecture".)

7

Chapter 01Muzharul Islam: thoughts and practice

II

.fr:>' ,- C:,i,~::',)1.(~;~\;~,("'~>"""

~

~..•..N-~;~,c0'J12li"\'<,>~\./ G'(" t,\.,,{ ~ -,~, •• 8 "\.;. \;

: ~ \ I. J/ 9';7 ft l!\~. (1. \. cn.::t~.:.•.~_ ) <; :('. -'>... J -''''I' .~ ~ ,""'=-- .....~....., '!. ~//,t.,~c;rtr"i:. -;;,.,;'. ,,/./

'~ ... ~-;:;r..r.-~~"~~-<:r-:::- _,,_~. __,__~/.,r:,"

Selected Thoughts of Muzharullslam

For more than forty years, Muzharul Islam (1923-) has fought his lonely yet committed

strugglell in the resistance of what he called 'domination of Western ideas and Western

culture' 12. Except for a short period in the early phase of his professional career, it is

evident through his works that he has strongly believed and acknowledged the need for

the 'sensibilities' of tradition and culture to be incorporated in buildings. There are two

opposing views observed on Muzharul Islam. One has been accusing Muzharul Islam, and

still is, of being 'modernist, romantic, controversial' and to the other, he has been praised,

and still is, for his belief in 'contextualism', humanism, individualism, and appropriate

technology. The fact still remains that Muzharul has created the nascent architectural

culture of Bangladesh, carrying out a struggle against government bureaucracy, against

political domination by engineers, and against academic sterility. Moreover, he has

incarnated ethical architectural practice in Bangladesh (and Pakistan before 1971) and

'progressively' enlightened architectural endeavour!3. In his own words Muzharul Islam

has been always persistent in formulating a Bengali sense of identity in architecture14 His

interpretation of tradition and the spirit of roots lies in an unconventional understanding

of architecture and identity. The essential point of this understanding puts it to be

'untraditional' and 'progressivist'. In summary form, his views on 'progressivist ideology'

in architecture are expressed as:

, To clearly visualise the forces which shaped the fonn and content of architecture

in Bangladesh, it is necessary to examine the buildings from ancient times to

present day. Unfortunately, due to the destructive activities of man and the

ravages of nature very few ancient buildings survived upto the present day. For

example, no traces can be found of the cities, which flourished, in ancient Bengal,

II Ibid, p. 55. The scenario of the then Bangladesh when Muzharul virhlally launched a lonely struggle todevelop a true architectural environment is depicted in Ashraf's article.

12 Muzharul Islam, Kazi Khaleed Ashraf and Saiful Haque; Introducing Bangladesh - a case for Regionalism,in Participants' Paper of?d Regional Seminar on Architecture and the Role of Architects in Southern Asia,lfthekhar M. Khan, Meer Mobashsher Ali,Mahbub Rahman and Habibullah Hemani (ed.l: The Aga KhanAward for Architecture, Institute of Architects Bangladesh and Bangladesh University of Engineering andTechnology, Dhaka, December, 1985. p. 9-9.8. (hereafter cited as "A Case for Regionalism".)

13 Muzharul, Kahn and Architecture, p. 58.

14 Stanley Tigennan, An American Architect's Alternatives Versus Stanley Tigennan, Rizzoli, pp. 59-65.

9

such as Gange. Tamralipti,Kamasubama, Kotibarsa, Panchanagari, Rampal, etc.

The British cultural domination (during the British Period, 1757-1947) was so

thorough and devastating that it completely severed the continuity of Bengal

socio-cultural and economic life, including the development of regional

architecture. They (British) put up their first buildings as exact facsimiles of

buildings in Europe, visually executed in the neo-classical manner popular in

Europe in those days. Examples include Calcutta Govemment House, Serampore

College, Dhaka Old State Bank Building, etc. These buildings, in white plaster

with their Graeco-Roman visual features, bore no sympathy to the site, the

landscape or existing milieu of the region. [}pto the advent of the Mughals

whatever happened was ultimately Bengali with the root deep in the tradition and

culture of the country. The Mughals came with an imperialist outlook and created

the first disturbance in the continuity in the field of architecture. And the coming

of the British saw a total severance of all ties with the existing culture of the

country"lS. (Islam 1985)

Muzharul portrayed British rule much as a cultural holocaust in the continuity of historical

development of this region. Muzharul Islam not being superficial, categorically and

chronologically showed how the cultural and geographical overtones of this region have

been neglected and ignored. He was quite aware of the fact that the immense gap

between various periods of development through the past is a reality and thus we are set

to face this as an actual context of architecture. He acknowledges explicitly by saying that

probably it may not ever be possible to bridge the gap in a real sense between the

Sultanate period and present day Bangladesh.

Muzharul Islam, as a thinker, always expressed his concern over the 'contradiction'

inherent in our current educational system modelled on Western curricula and the urge to

react to actual context. His view on this dilemma affirmed that 'there is no reason why

any architect in our countries should have a view limited by the boundaries of our

countries. It is obvious that technologically and culturally nobody can live in isolation. But

then there is the question of pride in one's own work. And that work can be the product

l' Ibid .•p. 9.8. Reading this article would provide oneself with Muzharul's discretion in the detailed study ofhistory of this region.

10

of one's own creative activity', Muzharul turned immediately to the 'regional

manifestation of architecture' and said that 'without deep roots in one's own culture and

the heritage of the people it is not probably possible to sustain a creative life. In this

context, the regional manifestation of architecture and other art forms is inevitable.

Regionalism can only enrich the idea of world cultures- without it the world becomes very

drab indeed!'!6 (Islam 1985)

Muzharul's forethought on patronising great architects of the world has proved to be

worthwhile in liftinga nation's pride and esteem. Shangshad Bhavan (Fig,2,) designed

',~,:" ',:,.

-_? •....- ..::--:.

Fig.2. Louis I. Kahn: Shangshad Shaban Complex (1962-83), Dhaka.

by Louis I. Kahn, now stands for our 'genuine national aspiration,l7. His inclination of

conceiving buildings that symbolise human dignity and aspirations, and where such

aspirations can lead to achievements, guided him to comment on Kahn's work; he

believed that' there are projects which due to their importance in national life can afford

to be slightly extravagant.' Kahn's Shangshad Bhaban, which triggered controversies and

objections centred on cost, Muzharul, who actually was responsible for contacting Kahn,

averted the 'critics' understanding of the project' by saying:

'... They became extra sympathetic with our so-called predicament (cost-author).

They shed tears about the poverty of Bangladesh, and-the unwise squandering of

money over the project and so on. But the irony of it is that those who object to

16 Ibid., p. 9.8. Reading this article would provide oneself with Muzharul's discretion in the detailed study ofour history.

17 Muzharul. Kahn and Architecture, p. 58.

II

the spending of 40 million dollars for the construction of the National Assembly

Complex would gladly sell us refrigerators worth at least that much in a year, or

100 million dollars worth of automobiles. We wanted a building all can be proud

of, and, we think we got that at quite a modest price.,jS (BaneIji, 1988)

Professional Career: an overview

Muzharul Islam was the first formally trained Bengali architect after 1947 in this region.

He is arguably the leading architect in Bangladesh. He was educated in India, England

and the U.S. in science, engineering and architecture.

Muzharul's professional life can theoretically be classified into three distinctive

chronological periods:

- ,{a;.;:=-.-;: "~;"'~-"~"!i- __ ••••.•..i ••••• "t., f"I! rw;ft~

•• &:,:.1f.••..:::.~'T~;:; i'~ :'-":1 .,.~" :,.~ 1.~.'O;:'~ 1;,•••• ~..If'rfMli•• 4 • • .

;;: t:.T:l~~"",,'-'~ .••.•.•wUolIlld-e,1••!I-lit ••,.•.•..•.":•.••••••.1.:..:E~r."'!'l;n-lrJ'Illlttr fj';~

• .• •• I .

~t~fi':..:_~~.~~l~_~.!'~'~.~"; :F~_}~._ ,_ .. , {" " ' ." -." '.!';' ~ t~. •

_ .• <r'l"'" ~ _- ,

Fig.3. Muzharul Islam: Public Libraty(l953-55). Dhaka.

I. Early Phase (1953-64):

Being trained as a civil engineer, Muzharul preferred to study architecture and attended

the University of Oregon in the U.SA and Yale University for post-graduate level

education. Muzharul Islam joined the Communications and Building Department (C & B)

of the government in 1953. There did not exist any private architectural offices at that

time. He established his own office

'Vastukalabid' - more of a studio,

the springboard for passionate

movements by committed young architects (Ashraf, 1989) and began his design activities

as a private practitioner in 1964. The construction of the Public Library (now Dhaka

University Central Library) (Fig.3.) and the Art College (Fig.4.) in 1955 in Dhaka marked

a particular and explicit shift in the architecture of the then East Pakistan. His early

18 Banerji, Anupam; A Recent Conversation with Architect Mazharullslam in Dhaka. Bangladesh, inEnvironments, Anupam Bane~i (ed.); University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, vol. 19, no. 2, 1988. p.58.The conversation reveals that Kahn's Assembly Project is imprinted in Muzharul as a major phenomenon ofadmiration in the contemporary world of architecture.

12

projects from the late 1950s to works like NIPA (Fig.5.) and his own house (Fig.6.)

constitute the first phase where, within his own experimentation, an unmistakable

continuation of certain Corbusian-Rudolphian19 devices are legible (Ashraf 1989).

Fig. 4. Muzharul'slam: Art College(1953-55). Dhaka.

Fig.5. Muzharul1slam: The Nationallnstilute 01Public Administration (N1PA).Dhaka University, (1963-64)Flg.6. Muzharui Islam: Own Residence, (1969), Dhaka.

His academic training, which was mainly based on a modem-classical education at

Oregon and Yale, is copiously demonstrated in his early practice. Throughout this period,

his main elements and ideas stemmed from the then nonconformist International Style in

the West. His work during this period, such as the Public Library and Art College in

Dhaka, can be considered as evidence of his awareness of contemporary Western trends

in the architectural profession. Nevertheless, one can easily recognise the young

architect's growing concern for enriching his designs contextually, which is 'evident in the

19 Paul Rudolph was his direct teacher at Yale.

13

innovation of climate control20 and, finally, in the manner the artefacts confronted the

setting, more as an assertive and self-referential stance than a mediative one (Ashraf

1989). Even if some of those attempts actually refer to Corbusier, such as white cube on

pi/otis, sun-breakers and approach ramps in the Public Library and the Council for

Scientific and Industrial Research laboratories (CSIR) (Fig.7.), yet the Art College remains..£lg.7. Muzharul Islam: Council forScientific and Industrial Research

Laboratories (CSIH), (1969), Dhaka.

essentially an explicit endeavour to the solution of a real 'place

and programme responsive architecture'. The use of jali in the

east and west side of the Public Library building, and also in

the CSIR, reflects a personal and unique locally-adaptive

approach to design.

11- The Intervening Phase (1964 .71):

This phase is characterised by Muzharul himself as 'interesting years', because to him,

Dhaka (1964 to 1970) changed at that time and there were intense discussions, clashes of

opinions and various meetings (Banetji 1988). Although he referred to this interesting

phase to the three American architects Louis I. Kahn, Paul Rudolph and Stanley

Tigerrnan, who were engaged in designing some of the large architectural projects in

Dhaka, yet it does qualify a significant shift in the works of Muzharul Islam from his early

phase. The international atmosphere that surrounded him considerably influenced him,

and consequently, his designs began to attain a more internationalised direction; at the

same time, he tried to relate to his own articulations that marked a distinct departure from

accepted norms. Materials and construction, architectural elements of formal expression

like planes, geometry, mass, shape and volume, all were experimented with his fine touch

of personal vocabulary and finally appeared as a distinguished and definitive statement

offered to the architectural realm of Bangladesh.

20 Muzharul. Kahn and Architecture, p. 61. The umbrella roof of his own house .t. in the sculptural animationcreated by varying reliefs, deep shadows and juxtaposition of materials; in the spatial composition as in themulti-levelled organisation of his own house.

14

It is in this phase that Muzharul was commissioned in large-scale projects, including five

Polytechnic Institutes (Flg.S.) in collaboration with Stanley Tigerman in different parts of

" . :.-Fig.a. Muzharullslam and Stanley T1german:Polytechnic Institute, (1965-71).

Bangladesh. Tigerman was his classmate at Yale and both had Paul Rudolph as their

teacher. To some critics, education at Yale and with Paul Rudolph there, influenced him

greatly and turned him to enter into a new phase of design career characterised by the

greater use of exposed brick and concrete work, and the manipulation of volumes and

planes to achieve a play of light and shade which clearly shows the influence of the New

Brutalist Language of Paul Rudolph. (Haque 1988)

In this phase, Muzharul took on the task of two university projects (Fig.9 & 10.). These

Flg.9. Muzharullslam: Chiltagong University, (1965-71), Chiltagong.Fig.l0. Muzharullslam: Jahangir Nagar University. (1965-71), Savar.projects consisted of large-scale formality, and he indicated an interest in applying

geometric design solutions. The preference for geometry probably stemmed from the

concern to generate an 'urbanised order' by the formation of communal spatial

enclosures, streets and continuous facades (Ashraf 1989). The diagonal geometry that

15

was utilised probably allowed him to achieve the desired 'order', not possible within

conventional axial planning. The brick veneered individual buildings, where he played

with carved-out voids in the huge masonry solid sutfaces, the geometric coherence, all

marked a clear shift from his two early works, which Saiful Haque described:

'In the design of the campus for Jahangimagar University ... one sees another

shift in Muzharullslam 's design philosophy with the introduction of the planning

principle of the tilted square in the north-south axis, which he considers a more

appropriate layout for the climate of the region. In the use of materials, Muzharul

Islam henceforth moves completely to exposed brick. His work in the sixties

exhibits a constant search for a creative expression in the regional context,

remaining at the same time faithful to the tenets of Modernism.' (Haque 1988)

During this period the large-scale gesture he showed seemingly did not conform to the

same features of his earlier phase, but on deep observation it can be related to Muzharul's

redefined modernism threaded into his continual search for an 'international level of

awareness and enquiry 10cally'21.

III. The Late Phase (1971 to date):

This is the most unrecognised period of Muzharul's professional career. He was

repeatedly confronted witr. incomplete or rejected projects in this phase. This led him to

ultimate isolation and almost brought him to the end of his career. During this period, he

was engaged in the Housing for Joypurhat Cement (Fig.n.) and Limestone Factory and

the National Library and Archives (Fig.12.) at Dhaka. In the first project he again opted

Fig. 11. Muzharullslam:Limestone Mining and Cement

Works Housing (1980-84),Joypurhat

21 Ibid., p. 58, MuzharuJ took the initiative to invite the American trio - Kahn, Rudolph and to expose theexisting nascent form of architecture in the then East Pakistan to an intemationallevel of production. Indeed,the impact is discernible even in the works of MUlharul Islam that is marked by some distinct changes in thevocabulary of his later projects.

16

for geometry as a reminiscence of Jahangimagar, thereby showing his continued interest

In using brick veneer and a layout he opinioned that was best suited to the climate. It was

In the second project, where he

encountered the physical presence ,

of Kahn's capitol, the so-named

'citadel of institutions', and

attempted to relate to it by using

Kahn's own primordial geometry

FIg.12. Muzharullslam: National DbraIY(1980-84). Dhaka.

of the 'square', or in fact, twin squares. This project, perhaps, authenticates Muzharul's

decisive statement of 'contextuality'; the ultimate artifact acknowledges more explicitly the

conditions of the 'place' - the context and the contradlctlons22•

22 Ibid., p. 62. The statement of Ashraf acknowledged the fact that the National Library stands as the mostresolved work by Muzharul, which dealt with one of the most contemporary concerns of architecture -contexhJality. Also see Azim 1991, p. 29 for enhanced understanding on phiiosophicaVhistorical search for'context'.

17

Chapter 02Architectural Vocabulary:

Selected Buildings and Projects.

18

Art College (now Fine Arts Institute, Dhaka University, Dhaka, 1953-55)

Public Library (now Central Library, Dhaka University, Dhaka, 1953-55)

The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research Laboratories (Dhaka, 1962)

It was upon his return to East Pakistan, and as part of his responsibilities within the

ubiquitous Public Works Deparbnent (as no private architectural offices existed at that

time) that he designed two edifices which are landmarks in terms of the recent history of

the local profession: the Public Library (Fig.13.) and the College of Arts and Crafts,

Dhaka (Fig.14.). The former was clearly organised in a Corbusian mode -a cubic volume

on stilts, complete with ramps, sun-breakers and pristine white colour - but at that time it

Fig.13. Muzharullslam; Public Library,extenorlrom the south. (1953-55).

Fig.14. Muzharullslam: east elevation,Art College (1953-55

indicated for Dhaka fresh qualities of urbanism and environment (Ashraf 1989).23This is

probably the best statement by Ashraf on an architect of this region in a way that suggests

Muzharul as a great initiator of 'renaissance' in contemporary architecture for the then

East Pakistan. Saiful Haque identified the dominant features in the Public Library are

stated as: flat-roofed rectangular volumes lifted from the ground on cylindrical pilotis, a

simple arrangement of masses, free-flowing and interpenetrating spaces (Fig.15 & 16.),

sunbreakers (Fig.17.), horizontal protection device on the eastern facade (Fig.lS.) for

cutting glare from the sun. (Haque 1988)

23 Ibid., p.55.

Flg.15. Muzharullslam: plans of PublicLibrary. (1953-55).

]9

Fig.16. Muzharullslam:elevations and secb'on of

Public Library. (1953-955).

, ' ~-'-:--• _ ~ l;.. :.....-'.=.-~--_... : ~-' .. - •...

• • • ~. _',l..'

"-':. '1'_." ..••: .. .'

Flg.l7. MuzharulIslam: sun breakerson the south of west

wing of PublicUbrary, (1953-1955).

Flg.18. MuzharulIslam: jaJis on south

andhorizonlalprotection device onthe eastern facade 01

Public Ubrary, (1953-1955).

17

W..,..... ",..• -j:'" .••••."."•. ' ,;.jf~.,'1~"-"".~ ." N~ ~. '. ".' .'"':"' .~..jf>....... . '/. .'.,~.~. . . .'::-'~j:

•• ~, .:.1.

18

20

Fig.19. Muzharullslam: westwingolPublic Ubrary, (1953-55).

The western wing (Fig.19.) of the Library stands

in contrast to the main block of Corbusian genre

with its crude brick louvered openings, with

concrete frames and shell roofs. This project thus

recalls the 'dramatic'24 contrast portrayed by Corbusier himself in his projects of Masions

Jaol in Neuilly-sur-Seine (Fig.20.) and Petite Maison de Weekend (VillaFelix) (Fig.21.).

,.

Flg.20. Le Comusier: Masions Jao/, (1951).Fig.21. Le Corbusier: VillaFelix, (1935).

Although the fonnal expression of the west wing of the

Library may have a kind of similar elemental

relationship with that of the Masions Jaol. yet it was

definitely an original articulation by the architect'''. It

may be supposed that Masions Jaol and Villa Felix

influenced Muzharul, but obviously not the construction of brick walls supporting concrete

24 William J. RCurtis; Modem Architecture Since 1900. 1987. p.275. Curtis suggested the 'effeel' of mixingconcrete with brick as an attempt to explore a new way of expression in built fonn.

25 In conversation with the author, Muzharul expressed that he did not know about Corbusier's experimentsat that time.

21

lintels and concrete vaults based on Catalan brick vaults; the 'merit' of the projects which

might have had influenced Muzharul was 'the intrinsic value of materials', 'the structural

system, the choice of materials, the method of ventilation'26,

Muzharul Islam was entrusted with responsibility for designing the Art College (FIg,22,)

the day he joined the architectural department of the government 'The area allotted for

Fig,22, MuzharulIslam: Art College.

exterior from the east.(1953-55).

the project was a very beautiful wooded tract of land with a large open maidan on the

east, which was used as a horse-racing course. The access road to the site is one of the

main roads of central Dhaka connecting the University campus with the city. It also

physically separates the college site from the racing-course maid an' (Haque 1988).

Considering the structure of the project, the front block. standing on round columns

supporting a flat slab and the rear block of classrooms are designed with load bearing

walls. (FIg.23, 24 & 25) The proportional handling of Corbusier is easily discernible in

the design and culminated with the aim of producing some flexibility and softness by

using curvilinear walls enclosing the library and boys common room, resembles the

derived articulation from the 'Golden Section'. There are also rhythmic contrasts between

the materials and structures used in front and rear block, the free plan in the front block

26 Corbusier's own view on Masions Jaol and Villa Felix., cited in Arts Council of Great Britain and authors(ed.); Le Comusi., Architect of the Centurv. London. 1987. pp. 65-67.

22

;

6

.'

...;.:....\\.

, ".'4 .. ,/.

~,,~~ !

FIRST FLO<'>a

GROUND FLOOR

•./

.f

.• lflf.A'":V~.2.~y:::'(;0~jt"~)~"'(,:(:Mj -O"ILCTt.•• CLP..:">t.fllX:t."5 cn#on~'lOOt,..!j ~A~.~.; Sli;1-'J::<IV!.-lAM1,t.91 if:;: ~~!.Ily:.c:Xl~J

'(11-lIrlUPlll(lN t. ">.1>(;[- 1:)1"1',:":1-.',lTr.,'.C-II-H:.;' :.c:..•~l\~

13~IRI.S.f.f)W/CM H(,;t';Ml-i T[:"f"\~,C•.

Fig.23. Muzharullslam: plans 01Art College. (1953-55).

,cmafF?@ I .__,:

~~..b~~~~

'-". ~:I([ ur_~. I .. '.'" I I' I '; .'. ; =.- '." ' .

• . . I - 2&.

Fig.24. Muzharullslam: south elevation of Art College, (1953-55).Fig.25. Plan 01Art College: west elevation, (1953-55).

and cellular plan in the rear. The contrasts (Fig.26.) he created in this project hints the

genesis of a new vocabulary of his own, probably the theme he conceived showed a great

deal of concern with traditions and with ways in which it ultimately came out as a modem

expression. An arc of craftsrooms holds the linear block of classrooms stretching away

Flg.26. Muzharullslam: Art College,exterior {rom the south-east. (1953-55)

Fig.27. Muzharul Is/am: Art College. transitional courtbetween the front block and rear block. (1953-55).

from the front block - depicts the architect's intention to introduce a simple traditional

typology (Fig.27.) developed from the response to climate - the device that associates in

tune with the conventional classroom arrangement. At the rear 'wrench-like' block of

terra-cotta coloured brick, individual classes (Fig.27a.) and craftsrooms (Fig.27b.) are

linked at the gound and upper level by means of a continuous 'verandah' (circulation

space) on the south (Fig.28.). The principle demonstrates a concern for exploration of

(both) the aesthetic possibilities of indigenous building materials and for means to ensure

protection from the climate. (Haque 1988)

24

Fig.27a. MuzharuJ Islam:c1assrooms.Art College.

(1953-55),

Fig.27b. Muzharu/ Is/am:craftrooms, Art Co/lege,

(1953-55)

Fig.28. Muzharu/ Is/am:verandah on the south of theclassroom block, Art College.

(1953-55).

The approach of designing these three projects may almost go as far as to suggest that

solidarity with the 'neutral box' was prompted by 'form-consciousness027 as it was a

world-wide phenomenon of the period. The spirit of rationalised expression of masses

initiated by Muzharul Islam in the Public Library

and Art College persisted with greater intensity

in the BCSIR (1962) designed by him (Fig.29

& 29a.). (Haque 1988)

Fig.29 & 2911Muzharul Islam: BCSIR lromthe enUy court, (1962)

Yet varied in their types of functions articulated within. the three projects of Library.

College and BCSIR expressed the power of architecture. the way they were linked and

synthesised within a clear and simple overall form. The precision in the relationship of

plane and volume. of the dense and transparent. the heavy and the light in these early

projects of his career hypothetically carried him to a more modernist 'expressionist' role

27 Expression of box~likemasses on stilts as a predominant feature of the 50s and 60s gained a popular nameto be called 'neutral boxes'. Also see Le Corbusier in India, Jean-Louis Veret (commissioneerl; in Architecturein India, Exhibition publication by the Association Francaise d'Action Artistique, Paris, 1985. pp. 70.105.

25

in the future. Much of the necessary experimentation for an 'architecture of local

manifestation' followed in Muzharul's successive years to come and the use of old

'Corbusian theme of the box on stilts' (Fig.29b.) (Curtis

1987, p.275) had gone on at these early projects and

succeeded in extending the personal territory of expression in

the projects to come.

Fig.29b. Le Corbusier: Cuitural Centre, Ahnledabad (1958).

Fig.30. Muzharullslam: exterior ofHousing for the ClassN Employees.

AzimpurEslate, (1963-64)

synonymous with architecture.'28 This

department was responsible for most of the

devastatingly,and

Housing for Class IV Employees, Azimpur Estate (Dhaka, 1963-64)

This housing for lower income group of employees of the government (fig,30,).

represents another landmark in the history of Dhaka's housing - the Ajab Bali (funny

building) designed by Muzharul in Azimpur, Dhaka. The 'Funny Building' was like a

cultural shock to the local people since they were not acquainted

with such a non-stereotyped housing. The introduction of spatial

quality with internally split-up levels probably prompted them to

call it in local term ajab or funny. Historically as well as

conceptually this project altered the precedent. The precedence

was 'the Public Works Department, manned primarily by

engineers and draftsmen. became the exclusive authority for

construction-

2R C&B (now PWD) built housing for the government staffs in the 50s and 60s were a drab formulation ofplanning and architecture that resulted in unreasonable density of masses lacking essential community spirit.Examples are Motijheel Colony, Azimpur Colony and others.

20

Fig.31. Muzharullslam: Housing fort7e Oass IV Employees, Azimpur Eslate,dou6le-heighted far;adefrom verandah.

(1963-64).

novel way. His concept called for the creation of a linear

(Fig.32.) is given a new translation.

contemporary government housing projects of Azimpur Colony. Motijheel Colony and so

on. The Ajab Bari enabled Muzharul to realise a conceptual scheme and vocabulary.

which the country needed to express with its aspiration for modernisation. In it he actually

opted for Corbusier's long and narrow house concept in a "r"I:c.~I

,'~t\, U'/~II~.~t.1'1.;j

block laterally arranging double-height blocks of flats

opening to the southern verandah. (Fig.3!.) Here, Le

Corbusier's double-storied long and narrow apartment units

as best exemplified in the Unite d- Habitation, Marseille

Fig.32. Le Corbusier: Unite d' HabitationMarseille, (1945-1947).

-_._ .•

27

The National Institute of Public Administration (NIPA) (Dhaka, 1963-64)

EFU Building (Dhaka, 1965-71)

Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation Head Office

(Dhaka, 1965-71)

The entrance to the building of NIPA (Fig.33.) is guided by a convergent series of spaces

at the peripheries. The ground floor accommodates activities of a general nature, the first

floor houses the classrooms arranged on both sides of a corridor, while the second floor

consists of larger classroom facilities.The final roof was extended in all directions to

Fig.33. Muzharol Islam: exterior 01the Nalional/nslilute of PublicAdministration (N/PA). Dhaka

University. (1963-64).

protect the interior spaces

from sun and rain. Climatic

consideration was the main

guiding factor in the

adoption of the simple

rectangular form of the building which provides for more air and minimum solar heat, as

the longer sides of the building run in an east-west direction. The first floor was built as an

'inside cantilever' over the walkways at ground level and to contain classrooms. In tum it

was supplied with a deep verandah to protect it from the sun. The second floor projecting

out over the entrance level distinctly expresses

the upper part of the building as finding its

footing on the ground. However the overall

idea was blended with Le Corbusier's principle

of the 'concrete parasol' (umbrella roof) evident

in Sodhan Villa, (Fig.34.)

Fig.34. Le Corbusier:Sodhan Villa.Ahmedabad. (1953-1956).

26

. ;... .•..tt..

Fig.31. Muzharul Islam: Housing forthe Gass IV Employees, Azimpur Estate.double-heighted faqade from verandah,

(1963-64).

£/g.32. Le Corbusier: Unite d' Habitation,Marseilie. (1945-1947).

contemporary government housing projects of Azimpur Colony, Motijheel Colony and so

on. The Ajab Bari enabled Muzharul to realise a conceptual scheme and vocabulary.

which the country needed to express with its aspiration for modernisation. In it he actually

opted for Corbusier's long and narrow house concept in a '" >"

~"';;.:.;"-novel way. His concept called for the creation of a linear ~'. :'-..',.

block laterally arranging double-height blocks of flats

opening to the southern verandah. (Flg.31.) Here, Le

Corbusier's double-storied long and narrow apartment units

as best exemplified in the Unite d' Habitation, Marseille

(Fig.32.) is given a new translation.

28

and the floor levels projecting over each other evident in the Monastery of Sainte-Marie

de La Tourette. (Flg.35.) As one recognises La Tourette as an extended attempt in the

principles of Corbusier's earlier ventures, NIPA and EFU (Flg.36.) buildings similarly

Fig.35. Le Corbusier:Monastery ofSainte-Marie de La Tourette, (1956).

Fig.36. MuzharuJ Islam: exterior view of north-west comer ofEFU(nowJibanBima Corporation), (1963-64).

/

reflect Muzharul's departure from the initial 'Corbusian boxes' to a newer approach, using

new elements in his architecture. Instead of cylindrical pi/otis, there were now directional

concrete pillars; instead of the thin planes of ja/is, there were planes deep into the

perforated planes of rows of pillars and instead of climate devices such as vertical wooden

panels, there were concrete panels inserted into the fenestration membrane. It is certain

that Muzharul attempted these deep-verandahs, projections and rows of pillars as an

attempt to define architecture appropriate to our climate on the basis of a contemporary

structural system - the concrete frame. Then again the EFU, NIPA and BADC (Flg.37.)

buildings attempted to pull together modem methods of component standardisation with

a re-statement of old elements. The'slab-like concrete pillars' (Fig.38.) is a type of the old

29

order of pi/otis, while the structural ribbed ceiling (Flg.39.) is reminiscent of coffering.

These devices were firm reminders of the fact that the thin skins and slender pi/otis of the

(Fig. 40.)

Fig.38. Muzharullslam: an arcade offree-standing pillars of £FU. (1963-64).

Flg.39. Muzharullslam: SlructuralribbedceifingofBADC. (196S-71).

30

The EFU building was composed of an

overall form of considerable simplicity; at the

top levels there was a marked horizontal

emphasis which gave some contrast to the

lower level of verticality. The lower level was

conceptualised as public spaces in an

important commercial node, penetrating a

lower storey of arcades and suggesting a

strong contrast to the nearby tall structures.

FJg.40. MuzharuJ Is/am: exterior showing thelransfonned pi/otis,Em. (1963-64).

However, this vital juxtaposition of layers in the urban scene is less coherent and

probably not articulated in the BADC office building. The basic morphology of the BADC

office is based on offset-slab type organisation. (Fig.41.) The mass above ground floor

level is supported on square pi/otis of concrete. The structure is a reinforced cement

concrete frame with strings of concrete in the ceiling has impacted on the features of the

.•.. -", .

,." ...., '__ '•• - . ~:l:;, t\"

.. :~~~:~ •••..••••.•• '-' !2 '" '" ::_.~ .!.... ~;._.:..... --1 .•-_.-

Fig.41. Muzharul/slam: plan0/ BADC, (1965-7/).

;Ii

.-:J.

31

fa~ade. The rectilinear facades of the north and south forms a vast canvas of square grids

of crates (Fig.42.) and slabs cantilevered with the ribs beneath, which dominate the

whole feature (Fig.43.). The solid walls on the east and west reflects and consistent

loyalty to his climate, consistent with the 'problem solving' disposition of modernism.

Fig.42. MuzharuJ Is/am: northe/evationofBADC. (1965-71).

wiir ~.. . ..... o.rr-, .,.-, i........ !--,._..-- ._". :~ "1-- . - 1._- .....

j i

I .

Fig.43. Muzharu/ Is/am:section of BADC, (1965-71).

Residences (1960s)

His house designs of the 50s and 60s were unexceptional extensions of the International

Style. Most of Muzharul's works of single family houses are located in the planned

neighbourhood of Dhanmondi and Gulshan, in which in some ways he fulfilled the basic

modernist principles. The house for Ispahani in Gulshan showed a stronger assertion of

-'?'".,,;,-" ~tq :I•... . --- .'.:,,~- - ~ 0.li, "'. "Ii" ._ _ II

""'. . '.r~.~1./.-// /

I' rrJ', .-/"./ ,r

Flg.44. (right)Muzharul Islam: residence of A. R Mallick at Gulshan. (19605).Flg.45. Muzharul Islam: a house at Dhanmondi. (19605).

Muzharul's confidence in problem-solving attitudes in tune with modernistic rationalism,

which he had amassed since graduating from Oregon in 1947. The Matlick's house in

Gulshan and a house in Dhanmondi (Fig.44 & 45) reflected the idea of Frank Lloyd

Wright, where the plans were articulated within an architectural 'L'. These 'L-shaped'

residences arose from respect to the local context, demonstrated by the creation of a

court for the occupants to enjoy outdoor activities, typically as in traditional houseforms

practised in this country. The 'L' shaped houses, that wrapped around a green court of

almost a quadrant of the site were given an unconventional treatment by establishing an

ingenuous rationalist rule in the facades which embodied an interplay of simple panels of

masonry walls and strips of horizontal concrete slabs. The residences for the architect's

family and prototype houses for executive engineers (Fig.46) of the Roads and Highways

Department decisively marked the shift in his prevailing ideas more towards a honed

philosophy in tune with the level of expertise of the contemporary masters. His own

residence and the engineers' residence seemed to suggest his capability of handling

complex problems, while comprehensively scrutinising the nature of problems in

architecture that underlines the need for bringing harmony in function and aesthetics. The

engineers' houses showed a moderate shift in the manner of communicating with the

facade treatment as in his earlier projects. Only in the mid.80s the visual language of

33

: r.

:~

.~: .Flg.46. Muzharul Islam:plan. elevation andaxonometric view of prototype house lor theExecutive Engineers' of Roads and Highways ..

:",

Bank Local Office reminds us of dealing with brick-arches attempted in the engineers'

houses. (Flg.47) The World Bank project seems not to be totally a resolved work and the

sources although loosely resembles engineers' houses are still not absorbed sufficiently to

suggest a coherent personal

style. His basic pam in the

design of his residence as

reflected in the section and

plan (Flg.48 & 49) was

articulated by dramatic

interpenetrations of spaces in

the interior and simple

overall form in exterior with

considerable contrast in

planes and voids.Fig. 47. Muzharul Islam: exterior of World Bank Local

Office from the south-west. Dhaka. (1987).

The residence originally designed for his family in 1969 at Dhanmondi is clearly of the

basic Corbusian typology, probably a long-range descendant of the Shodhan Villa,

Ahmedabad. The building's cubic form was carved out with voids to form terraces

34

;,~.: ,

..-.-d-+. 1 ,Lk:'o('P".,i.laf'. -."I :;

= , :'.r •• "JH ,. .:.~ I

\. I

. .1-I :.\ :

.! :---1'c Lt1J. ..

.J J

Fig. 48. Muzharullslam: plans 01own residence, Dhaka. (1969).

Flg.49. Muzharullslam: seciions 01own residence, Dhaka. (1969).

Fig. 50. MuzharuJ Is/am.- exterior, own residence.Dhaka. (1969).

,

35

and the whole capped by a floating siab (Fig. 50) on RCC columns recalls the Corbusian

parasol (umbrella roof) against rain and sun. Saiful Haque indicated this umbrella roof to

be in consistent with his major guiding principle in the design of this building. The idea

was to create an interior environment that would be habitable, with minimum help from

mechanical contrivances throughout the year (Haque 1988). Muzharul may have thought

that this should be one of the central themes of any architecture of this region, variants on

Fig. 51. Muzharul Islam: own residence, elevations reflects the response to climate, Dhaka. (1969).

such theme had recurred in contemporary Indian architecture by Doshi, Correa and

others33• In the design of the residence he has been conscious of the formal character of

interior spaces and to create such formality he arranged the rooms articulated within the

structure but separated from the roof and thereby attaining the predetermined heights

and proportions of interior spaces. Internal rooms always held precedence over the

exterior, allowing the facades to be more contextual in response to climate (Fig.5I). The

house shows a definite Modernist logic and rationality in the treatment of its massing,

formal organisation and material, but in the visual language that embodies the building,

however, follows his 'owned' principles, evident in the sculptural animation made by

varying reliefs, deep shadows and juxtaposition of materials, (Fig.5Ia) in the spatial

composition (as in the multi.levelled organisation of the house). This illustrates a more

assertive and a self.referential stance of Muzharul than a meditative one34.

33 see Arls Council of Great Britain and authors (ed.); Le Corbusier Architect of the CentuMJ, London, 1987,pp.70-105.34 see Muzharul. Kahn and Architecture, p.61.

36

Fig. 5111. MuzharulIslam: exterior. oum

residence. Dhaka.(1969).

In this way, the residence clearly reflects his interest in both the notions of basic modernist

idioms and personal formulation, possibly because of his 'own' residence had offered him

with a great productive ground for experimentation. Much of Muzharul's attention over

the following years would be devoted to the university projects, housing and National

Library and Archives, in which he allowed his ideas on 'monumental expression' and

'contextuality' focusing on climate, building materials, social aspects, derived from

experience with Kahn from working on the Shere BangIa Nagar project, so he saw the

principles operating from within.

37

, ..'

Five Polytechnic Institutes

(Rangpur, Pabna, Barisal, Bogra and Sylhet, 1965-71)

In the mid-1960s, considering the diversification and expansion of technical education in

the country, the World Bank came forward with assistance to prepare a scheme for

establishing five polytechnics at Rangpur, Pabna, Barisal, Bogra and Sylhet. In 1966, the

Directorate of Technical Education of the then Government of East Pakistan specified the

academic programme for 2,000 students in each campus, primarily residential in nature,

and awarded the consultancy services to the collaboration team of Vastukalabid, whose

principal was Muzharul and

Stanley Tigerman in 1966.

The responsibilities for the

architects included surveying

the sites, the preparation of

master plans, (Fig.52 & 52a

in p.44} design of individual

buildings and utilities and,.'-

supervision of the projects. As

the sites were located all over

the country the research work

for the preparation of master

plans took more than a year.35

".", ,':"

-. . .

;~ .~..-

.~:'"'~~::.~:.:.. .':'~., "'~;:C>: ,: .'

.'

..'.

. -.'- ':.'..::.".I:~

.._' ',"

Fig.52. Muzharullslam and StanleyTigerman: Site Plan 0/ Polytechnic

Institute, Bogra (1965-71).

..•".1' 11. I.'HI • 11. \. , •., 'I.. ~~..,"

35 Information referred in Saifut Haque,~ Tawards a Regional Identity: the evolution of contemooraruarchitecture in Bangladesh, in Architecture +Design, Razia Grover (ed.); vol. iv, no. 4, Bombay, May-June,1988, p. 30. (hereafter cited as "Towards a Regional Identity".)

38

r ."._- I F~_il ••••~. I.r ,II•.,,, ..• l I •

I. I • i" I •-,.. , •• "-r:- u

~:.,..".,-- ~ ., J'"._, I -I ~1•••• w _ •.-.~ -. • .

• ...... iii OJ-~ ,,... .'.'. &.~i

""..

t7n r-"1 RE - - ",l- 0 ••

•"I •• , ~~-'~ bI......J....1"L ..C ....J

Fig.53 & Flg.54 Muzharul Islam and Stanley Tigerman: Plan. section and exterior 01 stalf housing.Polytechnic Institute, Bogra, (1965.71).

The architects realised that

climatic considerations were of

primary importance36 for the

building designs and overall

planning to be achieved. The

architects decided upon a \:t~"":'::.',' '::'".. ". ~"simple structure of parallel 1':t:'4+:::~2(;",'"~;,"i~,:.;:X:.":;/::';>::'>:'~> .....

brick walls, concrete floors, a system that was extendable and easy to maintain. (Fig.53 &

54) They wished to maximise the flow of air while cutting down the impact of sun, while

36 Stanley Tigerman, Versus, p. 59. The following remarks by Muzharul's principal associate Tigerman revealshow differently they looked at the problems: The work of this fifteen year phase generally illustrates problem-solving interpretations of the 1960s and specially that of Chicago pragmatism. One atypical project spansalmost the entire phase - the Bangladesh Polytechnic Institutes. Style, Structural Expression - all my earlierinterests - do not {ann a part of the thought process of this stage. They somehow seemed inappropriate to anarchitecture emanating from post-Team-Ten attitudes and other problem-solving postures of the time. Alsosee p. 60 to understand the problems of climate and environment that concerned Stanley during the designphase.

39

Fig.55. Muzharu/Islam and Stanley

Tigennan:exterior,

PolytechnicInstitute. (1965-

71).

Flg.56. MuzharulIslam and StanleyTigennan:exmrior •of Administrativebuilding showing ~the crates. Bogra •

Polytechnic, ~(1965-71) "

.'

. ..•.. .':. I,.,,".' "' ..", ,~

in Muzharul's other 'brick projects' they decided upon a north,south orientation of

parallel bays. The emerging formal language of juxtaposing deep-cut ledges of concrete

floors and rows of parallel masonry walls in the southern and northern facades, (Flg,55)

may be a result of same reaction Muzharul showed to the deep-cut ledges and row-pillars

of concrete's in NlPA and EFU buildings. The academic buildings' north-south linear

facades were composed of dramatic vertical masonry walls and horizontal concrete slabs

to create the 'crates', (Flg.56) At one stage the idea of one large, all encompassing form

was considered, under which all activities could take place37 - probably as a concept of

parasol against rain and sun, but the idea was abandoned due to unknown reasons. If it

were the ultimate physical reality of the academ ic buildings, then it could in the long run

be referred to as another offspringof Corbusian mode.

37 Saiful Haque,~"Towards a ReqionalldentiW" p. 31.

40

I,.,'"'--- If

.,~~.;

,"

'i8. "'._.~.~~_J

1""'-! I .--'..

.:i "

. "::,L' . ,"-r.r-: '-- ,. ",.~.-,.. ~,........:::' ~,.."

.e'''''..)~),.

I:[,nL.,J

I;;1

...•...

,.- .,.•..•~..-" ...•

l~::::--- I.j i'. fI i .• ~

'.

" .. .'

'Uf," ,,,. " , " Il,-~J

Flg.52". MuzhaTTJ/Is/amand Slan/ey ngerman: masler plan of live Polytechnic fnslitu/es at Rangpur. Pabna.Barisal, Bogra and Sylhet, (1965-71)

41

New Campus for Chittagong University (Chittagong, 1965-71)

Campus for Jahangirnagar University (Savar, 1965-71)

If the work of Limestone Mining Works Housing illustrates a great synthesis of the

Modernist idiom and the traditional notion of space, the two big university projects form a

major shift of sorts and illustrates a transition in the mode of planning. The synthesis of

different building typologies and the resulting open spaces within creates volumes that are

varied and stretch out from enclosed courtyards to large, loosely defined greens. The

various parts of the campuses, the student dormitories, the academic blocks, the staff

quarters, etc., are all organised along a main artery of 'urbanised' street, where the

articulated street facade defines different proportion of street volume. Their

interrelationships at the level of the campus, however, are structured as part of the overall

landscape with 'romantic urban street' and dynamic in-between spaces, more in the

language of the Modem Movement.

Located in a relatively quiet and scenic suburb of Chittagong City, amidst moderately

rolling hills, the Chittagong University has a sprawling campus on a huge 1600 acres.

However, of the 1600, approximately 1220 acres are hills. To bring about visual order to

the mutilated and chaotic landforms, a number of four to five buildings were erected on

top of the hills by means of approximate earthwork operations. But this experiment could

not avoid the sporadic erosion of land during monsoons. This also resulted in increased

approach roads to be constructed. Although the experiment was aimed at enhancing the

use of exterior spaces and a meaningful visual pattern, yet it could not regulate the

wearing away of the surface slopes of earth in the site. Finally the decision was taken to

build the buildings on the plateau which anticipated to prevent soil erosion on hills caused

by the numerous water run-offs. However, the dispersed plateau frequently interrupted by

hills necessitated an intensive master planning exercise where both the distinction and

cohesion within a varied functional relationship could be achieved. Originally the plan

was prepared to accommodate 7,500 students but flexible enough to keep up with an

expansion of 15 to 20 thousand. The natural setting around the buildings were of a

sloping or stepped character, which was manifestly complemented by the pervading

terraced form of the buildings. (Flg.57) Location of individual buildings reflects the

emphasis put on the need to maintain the environmental qualities of the sloping profile of

42

the site. The administrative building, faculty housing, student donnitory buildings,

(Fig.58) staggeringly grouped along the bottom edge of the hillsand all their strong

Fig.57. Muzharullslam: exterior andsections of Administrative building.Chiltagong University. Chiltagong.

(1965-71).

fonns, obviously unconstrained by the site, (Fig.59 & 60) generated from a clear

geometric concept, acquired extra

vigour from the straightfolWard use

of the crude and rough local

materials. Although the intention

may have been to integrate the

stepped character of hills, the plans

of individual buildings were

simplified to the extent that local

Flg.58. Muzharullslam: exterior 01 students'dormiloIY bUilding.Chiltagong University. Chiltagong. (1965-71).

J.; "I I,. .

"."- ....~-.

~n_•••••_ •.~..•••••'•••<.~

•• •• •• •• a, •••

':::~~ .. '.",...~.i~}.~.:f=:........ - --

. i~. '~_.. . . - i-"i~r.-,,;' 'I' i

~

:l , ..__ 0'

0... I::.::I--!. .. ~

i ..

~!:J

. '" --

.M~(.1.,_••.••.••'.;.1

43

Fig.59.Muzharul/sJam:pJanoff acuityhousing,ChillagongUniversity,Chillagong.(1965-71).

Fig.60. Muzharul !slam:Eevaiions of faculty housing, Chillagong University, Chillagong. (1965-71).

Material could be used for structural requirements, The plan of each building is a simple

rectangle with all walls parallel in north-south direction, whether they are staggeringly

grouped or laterally juxtaposed. The buildings are designed to exclude the sun, with the

deep windows in masonry walls.

In the late 1960s, the physical presence and personal contact with Kahn probably may

have had motivated Muzharul's major design project of Janhangir Nagar University

Campus and led him to engage with 'type forms' based on primary geometries - the

square and the triangle. This strategy behind his planning of Jangimagar may have a

deep connection with Oregon's Bauhaus training. The circulation direction along a

44

primary axis and the strict geometric form-making recalls his Bauhaus training at Oregon

and obvious conviction in Kahn's idealistic position in this regard. His plan for the

Jahangimagar University envisaged the institution as a network of streets, open spaces

and the environment of living, which is expressed in a way- so that architecture and

urbanism are fused. In this connection the master plan is supplied with strong axes along

the north-south two-mile long site. (Fig.61) The overall planning can be interpreted in a

simplified version as an evolved order generated from a basic 'tilted square' the same

principle employed in Joypurhat later. It can be inferred that the Joypurhat was further

invigorated from the

experience gathered in the

exercise in Janhangimagar

University (Fig.61a). The

strong axis 01 the master

plan is terminated at either

end by students'

dormitories and teachers

housing and the in-fill

block of academic and

adm inistrative buildings

.'-:...

~:~7i€~~i~i;;;;,~~:marks the focal point where the main entry to the campus, perpendicular to the axis, was

designed. However, the original design is hardly evident from the present situation. Only

a student dormitory, (Fig.62. & 63.) Readers' Quarters (Fig.64) and class IV employees'

housing were built according to the proposed plan of the Vastukalabid. In the student

dormitory as named to be the M. H. Hall, he employed triangular courts (Fig.65) as an

••••

45

automatic outcome of the tilted square can be referred to the memories of Kahn's Bryn

Mawr project (Flg.66) where the tilted square of the plans suggested the possibilities of

vast diverse schemes.

Fig.62. Muzharullslam: plan ofStudents'donnitolJl, Jahangir NagarUnivelSily,5!lVar, (1965.71). the wallplanes are arranged parallel to north.south in the 45 inclined blocks of the

hiangular shape plan and whichcontinued to be a major referentia!

stance {or Muzharul in the projects tocome.

Fig.63. Muzharullslam: exterior of Students .dormitory. Jahangir NagarUnivelSily.

savar, (1965-71).

Flg.64. Muzharullslam: exterior of ReadelS'quarter, Jahangir Nagar University. &var.

(1965.71).

Flg,65, Muzharullslam: showing the court of Students'dormitory from different angles. Jahangir Nagar UnivelSity,

savar. (1965.71).

F/g.66. Louis I Kahn: BIJI,n Mawr dormitories.

(1964)

, ,

, ,~.'

. '! ;;,

46

•,Flg.51. Muzharullslam: Masterplan, Jahangir Nagar University. £lVar. (1965.71).

47

Housing for Limestone Mining and cement Works (Joypurhat, 1980-84)

The discovery of Limestone deposits just outside the limits of the town of Joypurhat led

to an extensive development programme in both infra-structural and service sectors for

mining workers in the region. Oil and Mineral Exploration Development Corporation

acquired an area of 3 Lac square meter for this purpose. Besides the housing facilities for

2,000 employees, the programme as a whole included a clinic, 25-bed hospital, two

primary schools, one high school, two clubs, play fields, a bazaar and a mosque.3S The

site, is located near the two famous brick ruins of Paharpur and Mahasthangarh. From

the beginning Muzharul thought of this housing project as a ground for experimentation

in the field of climate peculiar to this country and extended the experiment of 'tilted

square' he took on in Jahangir Nagar. (Fig.67) The solution to the problem of ventilation

Fig. 67. Muzharul/slam: Site plan, Limestone Mining and Cement Work>'Housing. Joypurhat. (/980-84).

and heat insulation in Bangladesh has always been the primary task for architects, which

entails the proper orientation of a building that would allow both ventilation and

insulation where required. (Flg.68) The prevailing wind direction in the summer months

is from the south and this suggests the buildings to be oriented in the north-south

direction and the large openings to be placed on both these sides. Again this constraint

also presupposes short walls in the north-south direction and long walls in the east-west

direction. 39

38 Towards a Reg\onalldentity., p. 36. -3?lbid .• p. 36.

48

Fig.68 ..MuzharnlIslam:plan of staff

quartelS, LimestoneMining and Cement

Works Housing,Joypurhat,(1980-84).

Yet the problem of creating internal open space within the building remains unresolved,

since an elongated building can not offer to create such spaces. If four buildings are

placed perpendicular to each other and parallel to cardinal directions, it results in an open

space with a definite sense of volume.

But it is not possible to have ventilation

in the north-south direction, and heat

load due to sun insulation of the two

buildings facing east-west would be

disproportionately high (Haque 1988}.'o

Muzharul examined these problems and

had achieved, with maturity and

confidence, to solve the problem by

leaning the squares of four building

blocks at 45" and arranging the wall

planes parallel to north-south. (Flg.69)'~

Fig.69. MuzharuJ Islam: blow up 01site plan showing housing quarters showing the resolved composition,Limestone Mining and Cement Works Housing. Joypurhat. (1980-84).

40 Ibid., p. 36. Haque expiains how Muzharul involved himself in the search for geometry to deal with localclimate.

49

The result of the experiment has contributed to credit Muzharul with a virtual authority on

how to build in this climate.

The housing scheme clearly shows a shift in Muzharul's alignment with Modernist idioms,

It is significant in that he denied essential

fragmentation and individual expression of

modernistic image of urbanism in this

project, in a bid to link the parts to a

whole. Thereby not only defining a

collective character clear in its site plan and

facade composition, but also developing a

hierarchy in creating open spaces that

recognises the individual. The joining

together of domains is achieved in a

variety of ways and has been an important

compositional device in his quest to define

architecture in terms of traditional

'.'~~.~r .,FIg.70. (lop) Muzharo!Islam: inte';lal court of staff " .,l'n" , rl ~ III tquarters reflects 'essenualquahtyofourlradluon. #' 'tl~\:~ .,~ ; ~ "111\ I <vumeslone Mining and Cement Wooo Housing, ,i, 41_,:'111" t .." (~ IlIlil'I'~'

Joypurhat. (1980-84). ..1,);1. ,j 11 Hi ~. t\".- d 1. "'1'111~. '1 .,¥ 'r- ~ I

F/g.71. Muzharo!Islam:exteriorof ~~;t._;,~' J!~ " "'..;i}.I"1.. ~ •. :camerol the type 'C'quarters. ~.:.:..:-.;..."."~"'~!:..;-.i.~~.:~.-} .--.. -:"!;!,~

)10 -~.. t- ~ '''.Limestone Mining and Cement Works Housing, ~.....'. .r... .~_:::t•."i-:.t"';...:i* . . _1Joypurhat (1980-84). •• ~ "'," , •.:•. -.•..~-~-~'" •..,•••.•~-

morphology. (Fig.70) However, unlike the traditional introverted courts, the inner open

space at the tilted square flow into one another by means of a 'walled-way' (Fig.71)

created by placing the adjacent buildings disconnected at the comers and culminates with

a long vista suggesting the direction of the High School. Thus a distinction between the

open spaces and their respective hierarchy is suggested and the resultant effect again is of

a continuous and surprisingly dynamic and moderately Modernist in nature. The visual

language, on the other hand, is static, almost like sculpture within the surrounding fields.

In keeping with the locale of neighbouring 'brick ruins' and local tradition, the project was

so

made of locally manufactured hand-made bricks. The overall effect of the silhouetted

rooflines and rough exposed brick

facades cany the eye further and I,beyond the edges. It may be right

to say that light and shade have

been employed as a texture

integral to the buildings, Muzharul

tried to create this by confronting

the rational fa"ade treatment with

massive work of local masonry.

(Fig. 72)

Fig. 72. Muzharullslam: exterior 01club house,limestone Mining and Cement Works Housing, Joypurhat, (1980-84)

5]

National Library and the National Archives

(Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka, 1980-84)

In the project for the Minishy of Cultural Affairs of the Government of Bangladesh,

Muzharul had to design the National Library and the National Archives in a site of 4.16

acres in Kahn's Sher-e-Banglanagar, located at the northern end of what was to be

Kahn's designed Citadel of Institutions. The National Library completed in 1985, sits

alone without its twin, the National Archives. Viewed from the road, one is overwhelmed

with the experience of ultimate austerity in the fa~de treatment yet 'imposing and heroic

Fig. 73. Muzharul Islam:view hom the main road,Naoona! LibralJl,Dhaka,

(1980-84).

in scale' (Ameen 1987) (Fig.73) Two blocks of idealised square geomehy were planned

apart from one another, one to house the Library and the other for Archives, sits parallel

as if they were twins. (Fig.74) The two parallel blocks of different functions required

Flg.74. Muzharullslam: Site Plan, Naoonal Libratyand Archives. Dhaka, (1980-84).

identity as well and the architect decided to express the distinction between the buildings

not with varying their form or shape but by monumentalising and treating them as almost

attached blocks with a common facility of cafeteria in between. As the site is besides the

52

main road through the Citadel of Institutions, not far from the existing ensemble of Kahn

with the deep cuts of shadow, the glaring force of the sun and the rudeness of the

material4l (Fig.75) it may be that Muzharul was responding to the context in making his

Fig.75. Louis 1 Kahn: Shangshad BhabanComplex, Dhaka, (1962-83),

reactions in exposed brickwork, geometry (Fig.76) and monumentality. 'Solidity of the

wall as a major part of architecture' on the exterior is expressed manifestly which clearly

owes debts to Louis I. Kahn. Kahn's ability for effective monumental expression is

• • M

Fig, 76. Muzharullslam: Plan. National Libra'Y. Dhaka. (1980.84)

41 Curtis William J. R.; Modem Architecture Since 1900. p. 315. Curtis" remark on Kahn"s Dhaka projectproves relevant when examined against Muzharul's created 'silhouette' of Library project.

53

revealed in this project with its full potential. (Flg.77) The colossal solid facades of

exposed brick also remind one of Kahn's admirations for ruins, but it takes over one's

Flg.77. Muzharol/slam: exterior showingthe monumental gesture. National LibralJl.

Dhaka, (1980-84).

Flg.78. Muzharollslam: exterior,National LibralJl. Dhaka, (1980-84).

.',"

.'

j

fJ. ~I.~.,mind easily with its austere poetry of simple cubic shape. (Fig.78) The north, east and

facades stand without meeting at the comers is carved

diagonally into the building and the openings to these

sides are protected by a system of flanking brick walls

and overhangs. (Flg.79) The .diagonal incisions serve to

bring light into the 210 feet by 210 feet disordered

square plan of the buildings and also divide the building

into four functional components. Other openings tended

Fig. 79. Muzharollslam: exterior showing thediagonal incisions, National LibralJl, Dhaka, (1980-84).

/'/

,-. j.IIf

f

to be on the enclosures of the facades to bring light into the building and high vertical

openings on the southern and eastern facades (Fig.SO) through their deep-cut ledges and

flanking walls allow sufficient light and air to the individual, large open offices and reading

rooms. Openings of the western facades (Fig.81) tended to be reduced to

54

Fig.BO. Muzharullslam: elevations and view showing the openings on the southern and eastern facades.National Ubrary, Dhaka, (1980-84)

Flg.Bl. MuzhatuJIslam: elevation

showing the type 01openings on thewestern facades.Nabonalljbrary,Dhaka, (1980-84)

Vertical slits cut deep through the outer skin allowing indirect light and thereby protecting

direct heat gain to the spaces behind. Its consummate regularity and symmetry distinguish

the composition of the plan. The axis is clearly expressed with the sequence of spaces

from the exterior to the different areas of the interior that begins axially at the porch.

Reading rooms and display areas on the two halves of the southern block flank the entry

lobby of double-storied height along the main axis and meets directly with the stack

volume. The resultant eastern and western components are supplied with the functions to

55

Flg.82. Muzharollslam: Section north-south. National Library. Dhaka. (1980-84)

'.

. .•

contain the administration, processing and storage facilities respectively. The entry loft,

although relatively darker, accentuates the height of the stack mass located at the point of

convergence of the building, 'brushed by light grazing its wall surface from skylights all

along its periphery'42. The interior (Fig.82) is dominated by the presence of this mass of

stack area that the architect decided to express by distinguishing it by separating its solid

walls from the rest of the functions by means of a space rising the height of the building.

Muzharul probably created this deep zone of transition in the interior between the outer

layer of functions and the stack to allow for circulation perpendicular to the main axis

wrapped around the stack component and to create an all-pervading presence of this

massive element throughout the library. The seven-storied component of the stacks forms

the focal point of the library where he employed reinforced concrete, openings tended to

be smaller and more protected. The outer three-storied components of load-bearing

structure wrap around this mass, except the north that allows the study carrels to be

supplied with natural light along the walls.

Muzharul had been working gradually towards the idea of 'layers', 'monumentality' and

geometries in his immediate past schemes of Joypurhat and Universities. His design for

the National Library and the Archives is clearly indebted to Kahn's First Unitarian Church

and School, Rochester, New York (1959-69) although the geometry of the Library is

quite rigid. In the Library project Muzharul probably received stimulus from the 'Unitarian

Church which reflected Kahn's continued study of openings that moderated light'

(Fig.83) Kahn's design of the church is reflected in the Library in at least two ways: firstly

56

in establishing the central focus of stack area in a similar manner to the square sanctuary

(Flg.84) and secondly in the deliberate attempt on the outer facades of the Library which

recalls Kahn's concept of 'enclosing walls in terms of a perceivable, faceted thickness,

infusing ... building with a quality of exaggerated mass'. (Brownlee 1991,pp. 106-107)

, ["" ~{;~:':. l'r"'~J'~."r.:;..~I'.;':!1'.: :~J-~~ .

I,,";;.;ir 1\.~.'. .Fig.83. Louis I Kahn: elevalion study for the Unitarian Church and School. Rochester, New York (1959,

1969).

However, this project, at the finale of his career, has also to be understood in Muzharul's

accumulated knowledge which he gained throughout his career, which stretches back to

his formative period to professional maturity.

Muzharul probably wished to re-invigorate his deep

feeling for the definition of institutions and reacted to

'a good plan would be one, which found the central

meaning, as it were, of the institution housed' .

Muzharul, on the basis of preparing 'a good plan',

Fig. 84. Louis I Kahn: plan showing the centra! posiaon 01 the sanctualJl 01 theUnitarian Church and School, Rochester,

New York (1959-69).

avoided any creation of mere shape-making and derived a plan from the square, where

the symbolic central space of 'a concentrated social character' (Curtis 1987, p. 313)

dithered hierarchically to the surroundings by axes. The secondary spaces tend be set out

as a fringe around the primary generator - the existence of a library around a stack. The

form and the interior organisation of the Library express the response to climate directly.

The building dramatises the natural elements of light and air in the interaction with the

brick veneers and the resultant impervious quality of its visual language (Flg.85) .suggests

42 Farooq Ameen; National Library: Sher-e-Banglanagar. Dhaka, in Chetana: Architecture and the Am,Mohaimen, Abdul and Saiful Haque (ed.), vol. 2, Dhaka, February. 1987~p.l8.

57

Fig.8S. (below right) MuzhaTUllslam: National Library. Dhaka. (1980-84)

Fig.86. MuzhaTUllslam: Western facadeof National Library. Dhaka. (1980-84).

its association to local context. The obvious concluding quotation in this regard is that the

'distortion' of the idealised form (of the Library) itself become the generator of

architecture; the ultimate artefact acknowledges more explicitly the conditions of the

'place' - the context and the contradictions. The building by its geometry, solidity and

spatial order, makes a convincing dialogue with the neighbouring ensemble of Kahn,

which has by now formed an important context or fabric in the north of Dhaka. While

geometric abstraction (Flg.86) and a consummate skill for physiognomic articulation

provide a continuity in all his work, the urbanity of National Library is a world removed

from the Public Library of 1955. (Ashraf 1989)

58

Chapter 03

Representation onElemental Laws of Architecture

59

It is clear from the works of Muzharul that he has amassed a great deal of competence

from the elemental lessons and ordering ideas of Kahn and Corbusier. In his formative

period his teacher Paul Rudolph influenced him as well. Stanley Tigerman, a close friend

of Muzharul and classmate at Yale, played an important role in widening his social

vision43 when working in collaboration in the polytechnic projects. Muzharul explored the

common ground between the primary geometries of modem architecture and certain

schemata from his own formulation. In the later works of his career he had gradually

pulled away into expressive territories of his own which probe monumental qualities in

the architecture of Louis I. Kahn. It is clear from Muzharul's career that he struggled to

synthesise the lessons of Corbusier and Kahn sometimes in a way by becoming

'reformist-modem' (relate to early phase) and sometimes by becoming a 'late-modernist

contextual' (relate to intervening and late phase). It would be useful to analyse the

influences in Muzharul through some basic idioms followed in architecture. These are

Elements, Context (Relationships) and Order, which would help to understand the

process that constituted the conceptual framework of an architect." The buildings

selected for the analysis are based on typological and chronological reference so that they

meet both the varieties in expression and 'time' that would reflect the sequence of his

career.

43 Stanley Tigerrnan. An American Architect's Alternatives Versus Stanley Tigennan, p. 59. Stanley himselfcalled his stay in Bangladesh as 'Advocacy/Socially Conscious Phase'.

44 Adapted from the methodology employed in the book by Kevin Utsey (ed.); Analysis of Precedent: aninvestigation of elements, relationships, and ordering ideas in the work of eight architects, The StudentPublication 01 the School 01Design. North Carolina State University at Raleigh. (first print in 1979), secondprint 1982.

1

4

5

---Ij,1~! .....

60

Elemental LawsEntrance and Circulation

Entrance generally characterises twofeatures: one is to keep free the lowerlevel of a dominant volume or m'assand the other is to have a recess inthe wall plane preceded by an entryporch. Circulation follows the generalorganisation of built form evocativeof Kahn's practice.

1, Art College2, Public Library3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National Library

61

Elemental LawsMassing

~J~jjj]:I]Ir" ',.' ,.~1

2

3

In the Art College and Public Librarythe dom inant form is expressed as a. simple cubic mass with a mixture ofsubdued forms. Such resolvedexpression of Muzharul recallsCorbusian principles. The BADCoffice building is monolithic inexpression. The residence is anapparent cube articulated withcomplex combinations of solids andvoids. The National Library is aseries of vertical walls against abackdrop of monolithic cube, Allthethree examples are closely related toKahn's pedigree.

4

1. Art College2. Public ubrary3.BADC .4. Own Residence5. National ubrary

1

2

3

4

---ITI~l ....

i

,-

.1, i i

br-r

62

Elemental LawsStructure

Two types of structure are utilised inMuzharul's work. The first phase ofhis practice resembles the Corousianmodular system, but reflects his ownvocabulary when a columnar arrayis mixed with a walled system ofstructure. The residence andNational Library on the other handreflect the articulated manner ofKahn, which in turn contribute totheir spatial organisation.

51. Art College2. Public Ubrary3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National Library

1

2

3

4

5

I

l! r-r

63

Elemental LawsSpace Definition

Spaces in earlier works are definedby a collection of the major spacesand the implied spaces containedwithin, often linked by circulation.The later works formed spaces bydefining with structural boundaries,major and implied spaces oftenexpressed by distinguishingstructuralarticulation, which recall Kahn'sExeter Library and Kimball ArtMuseum.

1. Art College2. Public Library3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National Library

64

Relationship betweenElementsBuilding to context

~.r---.r I \ ~lV, 1.1 )f 'I. /.\~' f\- ~,~, j !~. .

3

,i

oc--'

The primary relationship betweenI Muzharul's buildings and theirf:;iiI!iE!ill surroundings is focused on creating;;:.. . . 'silhouette' effect with buildings

'" .. 'J:• against the surrounding landscape,But his primary focus on 'context' interms of reaction towards adjacentsituations, form language andgeometry is expressed manifestly inseveral projects including NationalArchives, Joypurhat Housing andJahangimagar buildings. Thus itcanbe suggested that, conceptually, the

:: ,;;[l' essential meaning of 'context' asexpressed inKahn's projects can alsobe found in Muzharul's work.

4

1. Art College2. Public library

3.BADC. Own Residence

5. National library

65

Relationship between ElementsPlan to section

"'1.....~

-_ .....••..

,..._.._-' r

f1i

i - - ~

Occasionally a section is developed in a manner similar to articulations in plan and oftenderived from similar geometric organisations. And, sometimes the plan is more finelyarticulated than its section. In the projects of National Library and the residence, strongsense of similarity is expressed in both the plan and section but one being very much formaland the other being the inform~ spontaneous. ~~~~_

(91J~)==. ..1L.I]~~].il.1iiiJiIITEICny;m:~ ,c. ~ "'-~ "."__ m.,~~'l':..' \.

~~'?~.._----~'~-~''::1 ~y~, I:. i.' '\.\ ~ ;r •••• ;

'~ --.."r:-"~

if::~P; r tl~"';IJ."

, .: .fI l( "]' f-j" ',:". ~F1') !:.,,' i~fN."1'1,,:' ,'; .J.< /, •

. rl;! "'L ":;.::...;:..:\''1":"":' :'[".c.;ii,. ,--- "~~-it.;. I ~ • . if' ~'fI

L L...j ..:.:F;';.[:~',\9,t;i2 k: ($:~,;~:;.~:ii.:'(ri,~"l : 911~---....I.._~ •..•""""'rE:::"] ~ :'-')

tm!!I: ~ .

3 ~~,C3r-,-I"j I, "'.fo.:I"",.

~4 i

5

.-~~-~,;

. 'i:..~ ••--.---~.1.".10~iiaii:I.- e2. Public Library

3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National LibralJ/

1

2

3

4

5

~:f"'3.~

. ,1" ~''::7=.

",IC" . .,' ~ ".• __ ~~~tt. \.

- .._!;~., '..• C I •

14

•••• .- I-~slr ~ ;•••• . \ I

,:t~., ~~ ;~\, .-',: "/' --..".~.•..•...

~oI!

,li!"': . .;~. (t

..,1,. <: \(.' ' .• ,;.ii<.._. . ~ ..

.. ' .. . .. ,.... ..I .S"'.

66

Relationship betweenElementsInterior versus exterior

Consistency with interior andexterior in his projects is expressedthroughout his whole career. Thetransparency in the lower level 01form is a primary feature in his workexcept in the National Library wherethe mass seems to hug the groundand thereby expresses itssolidityandfirm foothold.

1. Art College2. Public Ubrary3BADC4. Own Residence5. National Ubrary

67

Ordering IdeasSymmel:1y/Balance

Apparent symmetry is visible in theexteriors of all projects. Although allhis projects are not symmetric byreflection or about 'x' and 'y' yet theoccasional presence of axiality ingeometry attributes a balancedcharacter to his buildings.

II rIII

2

3

1

4

5

II

--of-I

1. Art College2. Public lJbrary3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National lJbrary

1

2

3

.'t\ltil, .., rl;Jt.'~':

68

Ordering IdeasGeometry/Grid

Rectilinear geomeby is dominant inaimost all the projects and the plansare' based on orthogonal gridscoincident with the structural system.In the earlier projects the apparentgolden section geometry isperceptible. In large-scale planningdevelopment, the overall planconfiguration is generated from atilted square and is best exemplifiedin the JU campus and JoypurhatHousing .

4

5

..... -

" ,IiI I I I Iii

, • "0

, ,i I

1. Art College2. Fubltc Library3.BADC4. Own ResidenceS. National Library

1I,---'

J....//

69

Ordering IdeasLayering

A series of relationships in anorthogonal geometry is expressedmanifestly in consistency with thestructure, exterior enclosures andinterior spaces. The layering ofinterpenetrations in the spaces of thebuilt forms in general reflects simplejuxtaposition.

2

3

5

1. Art College2. Public Ubrary3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National Library

1

. -.

Ordering IdeasParti

70

If,~T,.rl;!t;~;

2

3

4

5

[' .. ,\

._~.,lL..

1. Art College2. Public Library3.BADC4. Own Residence5. National Library

71

Chapter 04Roots and Relevance in Modernist Inspiration:

,

72

Probing the underlying principles of Le Corbusier

In any discussion of the modem movement, Muzharul Islam's College of Arts and Crafts

(1953) (Fig.87.) is notable for introducing a truly modem piece of work in this region. It

can be stated that modem architecture started in Bangladesh with this project. In addition~.

FIg.87. Muzharullslam: Art College,(1953-1955).

to this, seen in the context of Modernism in this part of this world, what Muzharul was

able to achieve with the College of Arts was an architectural expression of inevitable

modernisation facing the country, It was, in other words, an experimental use of the

universal vocabulary of modem architecture developed by Mies van der Rohe and Le

Corbusier, fused with the traditional style of architectural expression known as Uthans

typified as domains of different practical uses, and the use of other local elements such as

jaiis, Similar experiments were carried out in the Public Library and in the BCSIR (Fig.88)

but the College of Arts

exemplifies the ultimate

development of this style. It

was among the first

buildings, which could

unmistakably be identified

as modem in Bangladesh.

Fig,88. Muzharullslam: detailsofia/is and honzontal screeningdevice is shown, BCSIR, Dhaka,

(1962).

73

In this way he became a lone architect who led post-partition Modernism in Bangladesh

in a comprehensive way, with skill, aptitude and expression. Nevertheless, why is it that

Muzharul in Bangladesh can not be considered as a 'forerunner of notion' in the same

way that Doshi or Correa of India are? This may be because he was the architect who

built up a body of actual work rather than a collection of theories and ideologies.

However, it is clear in the Art College that he intended to create a new piece of

International Style of architecture blended with personal articulation of elemental

principles and organisation and the final building was quite a resolved one. Probably, this

'Bengal' variant of Modem Architecture was not the result of his conscious methodology

at that time, but the result of unconscious inspiration emanating from his Bengali mind.

The formal language, which he used, was of course the same formal language of

Modernism he learned when studying Bauhaus pedagogical methods at Oregon, and

under the direction of Paul Rudolph at Yale. Modernism actually provided him with a set

of morals, democratic values and methodologies like the established rules of formalisation

and abstraction. Nevertheless, he gradually realised that it would be possible to be a

'Bengali' by filtering his own inherent Bengali sensibility and adapted by a deliberate

attempt to the process of architecture. Such adoption of traditional sensibilities by

Muzharul can be justified according to the observation of Curtis. Curtis notes (Curtis

1987, p.307):

" - Ie Corbusier's forceful late style could prove useful as a starting-point for

more sensitive talents who took over not only the external effects, but also the

intellectual strategies for the transformation of precedents. "

Fig.89. (left)Muzharullslam: The NIPA.Dhaka. (1963-64).Fig.90. (middle) Muzharullslam: BADe office.Dhaka. (1965-71). Fig. 91. Muzharul !slam: The EFU. Dhaka. (1965-71).

His own residence, The NIPA, BADe office and EFU (Flg.89. 90. & 91.) are examples

of such valid extension of earlier experiences and practices in tune with more contextual

74

appropriate character to suit the identities of different building typologies ranging from

residential building to institutional and commercial buildings. The residence he once

owned, exemplified marked shift from his other residential projects, the climate became

one of the decisive factors in bringing the vital juxtaposition between the interior and

exterior spaces. All the interior spaces were confronted with an essential exterior climate-

control device of verandah or terrace, which in tum gave the building a formal character

that proves to be one of his own expression of architecture. The NIPA was given a

character of a true institutional building, whose identity implied both compactness and

openness, which he achieved in a freer plan suggesting a coherent compactness of the

classroom arrangement and an apparent quality of openness devoted to the circulation

and service areas. The BADC and the EFU buildings offered a design, which showed a

greater concern for their urban settings by being given the massive visual quality and

perforation from the surroundings to blend the buildings with the existing 'urban

landscape' .

While Niemeyer in Brazil, BV. Doshi in India and Sert in Spain while being the direct

followers of Le Corbusier, developed their own expressive territories to enrich the

collection of 'Corbusian Works'. Characteristically Muzharul, not being the direct disciple

of Le Corbusier, deepened the diversity of the 'Corbusian Pedigree' by fusing his own

notions of context, adaptation and technology. In fact, Muzharul Islam was able to make

his own statement because his sensibility was open to his own 'roots' and its implicit

'order'. He believed in reacting to the peculiarities of his own culture and identity and he

was able to understand its 'true spirit' not in elemental law but in 'essence'. Muzharul thus

became successful in transcending Corbusier, by investigating the inherent principles of

his tradition and history and attempting to adopt them for the service of modem

aspirations. For Muzharul, it seems that the relevance of Modem inspirations has not

changed, as has the 'ethos' which was considered as a means to evolve appropriate

architecture.

75

Search for Regional Expression

One can see that Muzharul's strength and importance lies mainly in his practical

professional work and not in his theories. Unlike the great influential architects of the

world, Muzharul hardly wrote anything, let alone a manifesto. One of the few things he

wrote, clearly expressing his own thoughts excludes anything concerning Modernism, a

text which is discussed in the chapter 01, included his views on only 'Regionalism'. As

one can see from this discussion on his theories, Muzharul uses important terms that are

pre-loaded with very important notions; one such term is 'regional manifestation of

architecture'. In it he talked on history, culture and regional manifestation of architecture

but interestingly avoided any issues relating to Modernism versus Regionalism. What

does this mean to Muzharul? And how does his understanding fit into his modem

principles? Although his view on 'regionalism' drew attention among many of the young

architects of this country yet there is no record of his actually speaking against

Modernism. From this, it may be discerned that Muzharul's true disposition towards

modem architecture was discontinued at the time he wrote this text on 'Introducing

Bangladesh: A Case of Regionalism'. One important phenomena that may have direct

connection to his apparent shift in disposition towards architecture is, during this period of

mid-1980s, he was almost deeply involved with the 'Aga Khan Award for Architecture'

group, most of its members were engaged in the polemics of regional implications in

architecture. However, at t,",eprima facie Muzharul never seemed to be regional as far his

works are concerned. Probably, the idea of 'regionalism' in him flourished from his

association with the 'regional movement' by Aga Khan Award for Architecture. Muzharul,

interestingly enough, throughout his article on 'regionalism' suggested avoiding the

orthodox approach to regionalism that implies that tradition is only the only issue to be

resolved in 'true' architecture. He finds it to be a probability that 'can only enrich the

idea of world cultures'''. In this angle, this aspect of Muzharul could even be seen as a

simple personal effort to try to incorporate something more humanistic or 'owned

vocabulary' to add to the Modernist maxims. However, the most significant speculation

on this particular leaning of Muzharul would be to consider it as a latent possibility of

transcending Modernism.

45 This is described earlier in chapter 1 on Muzharul's selected thoughts.

76

'Context' Redefined:

Focus shifted to Kahn From Corbusier

As we have seen that the first phase of his career reflected his increasingly confident use

of the Le Corbusian vocabulary of slabs supported on slender pi/otis and curvilinear walls

that exploited the possibilities for free planning within the structural systems used in Art

College, Public Library, CSIR and NIPA etc. The architectural expressions of this period

show distinct approaches and sets of influences derived from

FIg.92. Muzharullslam: Limestone Mining and Cement Wooo Housing. Joypurhat, (1980-84)FIg.93. Muzharul Islam:National libraI}'. Dhaka, (1980-84).

Corbusier, filtered with sensitivity to harmonise with the local micro-environment which is

best reminiscent in Arts College. Muzharul gradually exposed himself to a new way of

handling old materials and thus brick and concrete were re-defined as man-made

construction materials capable of expressing the innate craft skills of our construction

workers. The Housing for Limestone Mining and Cement Works (Fig.92) and The

National Library and Archives (Fig.93) showed the evidence of growing familiarity with

the range of Louis I. Kahn's recent works. The most convincing contemporary

transformation of Kahn's ideas is found in the National Library and Archives at Dhaka,

virtually the last major work of his career so far. This crystallisation seems to have begun

in his formative period at Yale University and to be prompted by Kahn's stay in Dhaka

during the Assembly project and through close interaction through Kahn's repeated visits

to his Vastukalabid office 46, Such collaboration with Kahn deepened into a friendship

that had a great impact on his frame of mind and concepts in the later phase of his

career.

46 In COWJersat1on with the author~Muzharut referred to Kahn's visits to Vastukalabid.

77

In the mid-1960s when the apparent dissolution of the International Style was clearly

perceptible, Muzharul Islam then was engrossed with improving his vocabulary as relating

to the issues of climate, indigenous material and construction techniques. He was deeply

involved with the handling of geometry in search for the universal in modem form but

without neglecting the essential essence of 'context'. 'Contextuality'47, became one of his

prime concerns at the peak of his professional career. Similar to Kahn's, he was also able

to read the 'context' in its 'intrinsic being'. He was capable of understanding the

implications of 'context' which underline the involvement of intellectual exercise in the

broader scope of 'time', 'place', and condition (climate, technology etc.) and ultimately

the achievement of 'context' through re-inventing reality, to make all new48.

The spirit in Kahn's work with regard to transcending mere functional diagrams to a

higher meaning of architecture (Curtis 1987) seemed to prompt Muzharul to take an

idealistic stance towards re-defining his architectural vocabulary. His architecture tended

to be more idealistic than ever expressing new aesthetic possibilities by extending ideas

absorbed in his deep-rooted study of indigenous material, climate, social implications and

overall 'context'. This led him to clarify his basic pam of 'tilted geometry' employed in

Joypurhat, Jahangir Nagar campus and National Library and Archives, in which the

primary meaning of climat2 is expressed in an attempt to contain the ultimate aesthetic

possibilities by universalising abstractions. The intrinsic value of materials, as expressed by

Kahn with a broader aim of respecting culture and aesthetics, National Library, Jahangir

Nagar Buildings, (Fig.94) Polytechnics (Fig.95) and Joypurhat Housing reflect the same

inspiration in which brick is exploited with its maxim urn potential through tectonic and

tactile quality. In campus planning, the priori geometry as growing with a series of

triangles and changing its direction proves his capability of expanding the basic 'type

forms' of Kahn into a more coherent personal style. Muzharul transformed 'geometry' to

his own purpose and blended with his experience gathered in earlier practices over the

years. He explored common ground between the geometric restrictions imposed by

47 Brownlee, Louis I. Kahn: In the Realm of Architecture p.13. in the Introduction, Vincent Scully bestdescribed the implied meaning of 'contextuality' for which Kahn strived throughout his career.

4& Brownlee, Louis I. Kahn: In the Realm of Architecture p.13. see Vincent Scully's introductory notes.

78

modem architecture and certain priorities that were set when adaptation assumed

importance. Although this may be loosely evocative of Kahn's admiration for geometric

forms, yet this should be regarded as Muzharul's finest contribution offered from his 'own'I,

vocabulary translated into a modem expression.

Fig.94. Muzharulislam: M H Hall.Jahangir Nagar University. Dhaka. (1965-71).

Flg.95. Muzharulislam and Stanley Tigennan: Polytechnic instilute. Bogra. (1965-71) .

.,

r..~~.':.'- .'.••..

Monumentality, to name an important concern in the work of both Kahn and Corbusier,

is expressed in Muzharul's work not by a mere formalist's manner of form-making but by

a broader agenda to satisfy 'honorific themes and moods'. (Curtis 1987, p.310)

Monumentality to Corbusier as was exhibited in Chandigarh was an achievement by

expanding his pre-existing rules of architecture (the 'five points, the brise-soleil. etc.) withcertain devices from classical tradition - the 'grand order', portico etc. (Curtis 1987,

p.277) On the other hand, Kahn evolved monumentality from the aspiration of giving

architecture a spiritual quality inherent in structure and conveying the feeling of eternity.

(Brownlee 1991, p. 43) In Muzharul's works, the early phase of 'Corbusian resemblance'

in the large-scale commissions of the 1960s onwards, expressed his manifested quality of

monumentality without degenerating into pastiche of the masters and reflected his

ultimate sensibility which avoided any superfluous grandiosity or mere formalist

exhibitionism. Muzharul in fact proved his talent and restraint at the same time while

dealing with monumental expression. He seemed to be quite articulate regarding the

techniques to fuse together modem constructional means with traditional methods. In the

projects of Art College, Public Library and BCSIR, he employed simple geometric plans

79

to create pure mass or volume of petforated veneers (walls and suspended horizontal

shading devices of jalis), use of cylindrical columns carefully proportioned and the

hovering mass above, which recall the idea of strong expressive rules as strongly

manifested by the contemporary masters. All the 'brick projects' of the intervening and

late phases manifest his clarity in evolving monumentality, the punctuation by solid brick

panels and the deep-cut layers of openings fused in the architecture his maximum

austerity and respect for 'indigenous origins'. This ultimately suggests that he knew how

to incorporate tradition and modernity and fuse then together to simulate architecture

with an essential quality of 'context' and in abstraction to be called monumental.

Epilogue

Muzharul's formation took place after Modem Architecture had established a firm

foothold in the overall scene of world architecture. He was trained in the Bauhaus system

at Oregon where he had undergone an extensive and rigorous training on the 'Bauhaus

idea' of basic design, climatic and technology studies and studio projects. In Yale

University, under Paul Rudolph, he had intensive design exercises with devices of

rationalist principles of element, proportion. order and geometry. But the abstract lessons

of great architects such as Le Corbusier and Louis I. Kahn have been imbibed by him

during his professional endeavours and showed a great deal of improvisation in dealing

with issues of climate and expressed the aspiration of a modernising traditional society.

The projects of the intervening and late phases of Muzharul's work offer examples of this

tendency.

After a few attempts during his early works to incline his concepts and ideas to

contemporary masters of international style, Muzharul seemed to realise the excessive

self-confinement to a particular style and consequently decided to do somewhat his own

devising, especially when dealing with climate. The following decade, the Intervening

Phase, is the most productive phase of his life. Ranging from his own residence to the

campuses for two universities, he applied more of his honed philosophy with the

amalgamation of already established modem principles. Muzharul, at that time, had

nearly developed his architecture to a state of petfection. His designs of this period show

a high level of maturity in dealing with 'context' (Kahn's ensemble), ranging from

confronting Kahn's 'citadel of institutions' to housing the mining workers. Also, at that

80

time, he became veIY involved with the idea of 'monumentality', where he began to tIY

to impose this idea on both the Housing project and the National LibraIYand Archives.

Not to be' conclusive or being moved by making any final statement on Muzharul's

philosophical construct, some significant features can be identified in tune with his

continuous struggle for making something more than just architecture49 and the critical

investigation the research pursued. These are:

He has been engaged in the search for roots and relevance in the abstract principles

of design of the 20h century. To Muzharul, the relevance of Modem inspirations has

not changed but the means with which to give expression to the 'ethos' of a country

assumed more importance.

Materials and 'response to climate' as key elements of cultural identity. However, the

most significant contemplation on place-responsive architecture of Muzharul can be

understood as his quest for the possibility of transcending Modernism.

A democratic approach to architecture to uphold the society's ultimate aspiration. All

of his buildings in a project whether they were a VC's house or a staff's residence,

were treated consistently with similar elemental laws, order, materials and

relationships. This is one of his unique ways of responding to the creation of 'context'

probing the underlying inspiration of Kahn's attitude towards social vision.

The spirit in Kahn's work with regard to transcending mere functionality to an abstract

realm of architecture, where 'spiritual' insight for time-place transfonns the

architecture to attain a timeless aesthetic value, prompted Muzharul to take an

idealistic stance towards redefining his architectural vocabulary. 'Monumentality;

intrinsic value of material and 'contextuality' to name, became the genesis of his

newly-defined and probably the most matured phase of his career.

Muzharullslam can be regarded as a leading architect for two reasons: firstly, for his

concern for the fundamental tenets of modem architecture which imply the gamut of

4') MuzharuL Kahn and Architecture, p. 59.

81

'rationalist' approaches and secondly, for his concern for tradition and regional

'ethos; and the search for an evidently democratic and humanistic approach to

architecture.

Muzharul's career progressed with his continuous struggle for understanding the 'existing'

(firstphase) 'probabilities' (intervening phase) and 'prospects' (late phase) in architecture

and synthesising them at a higher level of ordering ideas. At times we find him aligned

with pure 'modernism' to studying the 'local probabilities' of materials and climate and

then experimenting on the synthesis of conflicts and contradictions of 'modernism and

regionalism'. The resultant synthesis in Muzharul's architecture may not seem as resolved

as his fundamental quest implies but can be understood in the long run when the psyche

has transcended the dilemmas and contradictions of identity; his architecturEi will then

find its own natural expressionso. But most importantly, Muzharul's architecture provided

a creative spark to his followers in this region and this is the concern that proves to be

seminal in inspiring conscientious architects today and this is where the true significance

lies, which Muzharul Islam endeavoured for throughout his career.

so Ashraf, "Muzharul. Kahn and Architecture". p. 59.

82

Appendix

83

Biography

Muzharullslam, son of late Professor Omdatul Islam and late Zakia Khatoon, born in 25th

December, 1923; served the Communications and Building Department of the

Government of East Pakistan from 1953 to 1964; his own firm Vastukalabid was formed

in 1964 and tillto date has been working as principal of Vastukalabid; lives in 3 Paribagh,

Ramna, Dhaka.

--:/& ....;-~ ;~4;., ,

•I 'l" tt ~ ••T, t.. i

Academic Qualifications:

- "

-_!_ ."

I\

- ., ..,... .

1942:

1946:

1952:

1957:

Bachelor of Science, Calcutta University, India.

Bachelor of Engineering, Calcutta University, India.

Bachelor of Architecture, Oregon University, USA.

Post.Graduate Certificate in Tropical Architecture. AA School of

Architecture, London. UK.

1961: Master of Architecture, Yale University, USA.

84

Scholarships:

1950-52: Scholarship under Post-War Development Scheme.

1956-57: British Council Scholarship for Studying Tropical Architecture.

1961: RockfellerFellowship for Studying Contemporary Architecture in Europe.

Special Honours:

1980 to date: President Institute of Architects Bangladesh.

1997:

1993:

1989:

1980:

1978-80:

1970-75:

1972-75:

1972:

1970:

1968-69:

Member, Jury Board for the Selection of the Best Design for Victory

Monument at Suhrawardy Udyan, Dhaka.

Gold Medal by the Institute of Architects Bangladesh.

Citation by the Indian Institute of Architects, West Bengal Chapter.

Member. Jury Board, First Aga Khan Award for Architecture.

President, Institute of Architects Bangladesh.

Chairman. Advisory Panel on Building Construction, Housing,

Architecture and Physical Planning, Fourth Five-Year Plan, 1970-75,

Pakistan.

President Institute of Architects Bangladesh.

Member. Jury Board for the Selection of the Best Design for the

Monument at Savar.

Member, Master Jury for the Selection of Design for the Grand Mosque,

Islamabad.

President Institute of Architects Pakistan.

1953-55:

85

Chronology of Some Selected Works

Art College (now Institute of Fine Arts, Dhaka University), Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

Public Library (now Central Library, Dhaka University), Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

1962: The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research Laboratories

(CSIR), Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

1963-64: Plan for Khilgaon Railway Rehabilitation Zone

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

Plan for New Rangamati Town

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

Housing for Class IV Employees, Azimpur Estate.

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

The National Institute of Public Administration (NIPA),

Dhaka University

Architect: Muzharul Islam

Consultant: Communications and Building Department

1965-71:

86

Head Quarter Building, Bangladesh Agricultural Development

Corporation, Motijheel Commercial Area, Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

EFUBuilding (now Jiban Bima Corporation), Motijheel CIA, Dhaka

Architect: Muzharullslam (Vastukalabid)

Five-Polytechnics at Rangpur, Pabna, Barisal, Bogra and Sylhet (1966-

71)Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid) in collaboration with

Stanley Tigerman

Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

1980-84:

Chittagong University

Master Plan and Designs of Students' Hostel, Humanities Building,

Science Building, VC's Quarter, Professors' Quarters, Storage Godowns.

(1968-71)

Architect:

Jahangimagar University

Master Plan and Designs of Students' Hostel, Readers' Quarters and Class

N Employees Quarters (1968-71)

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

Architect's Own Residence, Dhanmondi RIA,Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

Joypurhat Limestone Mining and Cement Works Project:

Master Plan, Housing for 200 Officers, Housing for 1700 Employees,

Club Houses for Officers and other Employees, Clinic and Hospital, Bazar

and mosque, Joypurhat

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

National Library, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

National Archives, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka

Architect: Muzharul Islam (Vastukalabid)

87

88

Bibliography

Ahuja, Sarayu; Roots of ContemporatV Style, in Indian Architect & Builder, Business

Press, Bombay, India; vol. 5, no. 5, January, 1992.

Ameen, Farooq; National LibratV: Sher-e-Banglanagar, Dhaka, in Chetana:

Architecture and the Arts, Mohaimen, Abdul and Saiful Haque (ed.), vol. 2, Dhaka,

February, 1987.

Architecture in the Tropics, in Architectural Review, Richards, J. M. (ed.); volume

142, number 782, Westminster, London, April, 1960.

Arts Council of Great Britain and authors; Le Corbusier Architect of the Century,

London, 1987.

Ashraf, Kazi Khaleed; Muzharul Islam, Kahn and Architecture in Bangladesh, in

Mimar: Architecture in Development, Hasan-Uddin Khan (ed.); Concept Media,

Singapore, March, 1989.

Attoe, Wayne; Architecture and Critical Imagination, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., The

Gresham Press, Surrey, 1978.

Azim, Firdous; Bangladesh: Building the Nation, in Architecture + Design, Razia

Grover (ed.); Architecture of SAARC Nations issue, Media Transasia (I), New Delhi,

December, 1991.

Banerji, Anupam; A Recent Conversation with Architect Mazharul Islam in Dhaka,

Bangladesh. in Environments. Anupam Banerji (ed.); University of Waterloo, Waterloo,

Ontario. vol. 19, no. 2, 1988.

Brownlee, David B. and David G. De Long; Louis I. Kahn: In the Realm of

Architecture, Rizzoli.New York, 1991.

89

Colquhoun, Alan; Essays in Architectural Criticism: Modem Architecture and Historical

Change, The MITPress, Massachusetts, 1991.

Curtis William J. R.; Modem Architecture Since 1900, Phaidon Press Limited, Oxford,

1987.

Haque, Saiful: Towards a Regional Identity: the evolution of contemporarv architecture

in Bangladesh, in Architecture + Design, Razia Grover (ed.); vol. iv, no. 4, Bombay,

May-June, 1988.

Iqbal, Kazi Anisuddin (ed.); Portrait of Muzharul Islam based on an interview, in

Sthapattya 0 Nirrnan, vol. 2, issue 1, Dhaka, January-March, 1992.

Islam, MuzharuI, Kazi Khaleed Ashraf and Saiful Haque; Introducing Bangladesh

- a case for Regionalism, in Participants' Paper of 2'd Regional Seminar on Architecture

and the Role of Architects in Southern Asia, Ifthekhar M. Khan, Meer Mobashsher Ali,

Mahbub Rahman and Habibullah Hemani (ed.); The Aga Khan Award for Architecture,

Institutes of Architects Bangladesh and Bangladesh University of Engineering and

Technology, Dhaka, December, 1985. p. 9-9.8.

Islam, MuzharuI, Kazi Khaleed Ashraf and Saiful Haque; Government vis-a-vis

Architecture, in Participants' Paper of 2'd Regional Seminar on Architecture and the Role

of Architects in Southern Asia, Ifthekhar M. Khan, Meer Mobashsher Ali, Mahbub

Rahman and Habibullah Hemani (ed.); The Aga Khan Award for Architecture, Institutes

of Architects Bangladesh and Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology,

Dhaka, December, 1985. p. 15.15.4.

Khosla, Romi; Including Iconography and Images in Architecture, in the Techniques &

Architecture: Architecture in India, Paris, September, 1985.

Le Corbusier in India, Jean-Louis Veret (commissioneer); in Architecture in India,

Exhibition publication by the Association Francaise d'Action Artistique, Paris, 1985. p.

70-105.

90

Rudolph, Paul; Regionalism in Architecture, in Environments, Anupam Banetji (ed.);

University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, vol. 19, no. 2,1988.

Saif.UI.Haq; Architecture within the folk tradition: a representation from, in the

Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review (vol. v no. ii), Nezar AISayyad (ed.),

IASTE, University of California Berkley, California, Spring 1994, pp. 61-72.

Saini, Balwant, B.; Regionalism Vs Cosmopolitanism, in Earth, Mahbubur Rahman

(ed.) a quarterly journal on Environment, Architecture, Research, Technology and

Human Settlement; Dhaka, Winter, 1995.

Tigennan, Stanley; An American Architect's Alternatives Versus Stanley Tigerman,

Rizzoli,pp. 59-65.

Utsey, Kevin (ed.); Analysis of Precedent: an investigation of elements, relationships,

and ordering ideas in the work of eight architects, The Student Publication of the School

of Design, North Carolina State University at Raleigh, (first print in 1979), second print

1982.

Watkin, David; The Rise of Architectural Historv; The Architectural Press, London;

1983.

Zahiruddin, Shah Alam, Abu H.\mamuddin, and M. Mohiuddin Khan, (edJ;

Contemporarv Architecture Bangladesh, Institute of Architects Bangladesh, Dhaka,

March,1990.