Recruitment & Selection
Transcript of Recruitment & Selection
Contents RECRUITMENT....................................................1 SELECTION......................................................2
NEPOTISM HISTORY AND DEFINITION................................3ADVANTAGE........................................................4
DISADVANTAGE.....................................................4 EMPLOYMENT OF CHILDREN.........................................5
EMPLOYMENT OF OLD WORKERS......................................71. AGEISM’S DOUBLE STANDARD......................................7
2. JOB SKILLS HAVE BEEN RENDERED OBSOLETE........................73. OVERQUALIFIED.................................................8
4. AGEISM MYTH...................................................9 DISCRIMINATION................................................10
POSITIVE........................................................10NEGATIVE........................................................10
TYPE OF DISCRIMINATION..........................................10FIVE TOP EXAMPLES:..............................................11
AGE DISCRIMINATION-WORKPLACE..................................11BASED ON RACE/ ETHNICITY......................................11
BASED ON SEX..................................................12BASED ON RELIGION.............................................12
WITH DISABILITIES.............................................12THE EFFECT OF DISCRIMINATION....................................13
DISGRUNTLED EMPLOYEES.........................................13FINANCIAL.....................................................13
PHYSICAL EFFECTS ON EMPLOYEES.................................13LEGAL TROUBLE.................................................13
EXPATRIATE....................................................14EXAMPLE EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA..................................14
ADVANTAGE OF EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA.............................14
DISADVANTAGES OF EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA.........................14 SUGGESTION AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................15
Bibliography......................................................16
RECRUITMENT
RECRUITMENT: The process of attracting individuals on a timely
basis, insufficient numbers and with appropriate qualifications, to
apply for jobs with an organization.
Recruitment is about the process to attracting individuals on
timely basis. When HR planning indicates the need for additional
labor, organizations have a number of choices to make. This may be
the first step in a full-scale recruitment and selection process,
but sometimes hiring additional employees is not the best method to
obtain additional labor. It may be appropriate for an organization
to consider ternaries to recruiting, such as outsourcing or
contingent labor, instead of hiring regular employees. If this is a
temporary fluctuation in work volume, the simplest solution may be
part-time labor or overtime by existing employees. The costs of
recruitment and selection can be staggering; hiring new employees
should occur only after careful consideration and only when the
organization anticipates a long-term need for additional labor.
Estimates on the cost to replace supervisory, technical and
management employees run from 50 percent to several hundred percent
of employeesalaries.1 Careful HR planning must consider the overall
growth prospects of the organization and accurate forecasting of
future labor needs. Recruitment planning begins only when other
alternatives have been considered and eliminated.
SELECTION
SELECTION: The process of choosing from a group of applicants those
individual best suited for a certain position and organization.
The selection process consists of various steps. At each stage
facts may come to light which may lead to rejection of the
applicant. Steps involved in the selection are: -application
* Preliminary interview: - Initial screening is done to weed out
totally undesirable/unqualified candidates at the outset. It is
essentially a sorting process in which prospective candidates are
given necessary information about the nature of the job and the
organization.
* Application blank: - Application form is a traditional and widely
used device for collecting information from candidates. The
application form should provide all the information relevant to
selection.
* Selection test: - Psychological are being increasingly used in
employee selection. A test is sample of some aspects of an
individual’s attitude, behaviour and performance. It also provides
systematic basis from comparing the behaviour, performance and
attitudes of two persons.
* Employment interview: - An interview is a conversation between two
persons. In selection it involves a personal, observational and face
to face appraisal of candidates for employment.
* Medical examination: - Applicants who have crossed the above
stages are sent for a physical examination either to the company’s
physician or to a medical officer approved for the purpose.
* Reference checks: - The applicant is asked to mention in his
application form the names and addresses of two or three persons who
know him well.
* Final approval: - The shortlisted candidates by the department are
finally approved by the executives of the concerned department.
Employment is offered in the form of appointment letter mentioning
the post, the rank, the grade, the date by which the candidate
should join and other terms and conditions in brief. (Mifflin, The
Free Dictionary, 2009)
NEPOTISM HISTORY AND DEFINITION
The words nepotism is actually is an Italian words nepotismo,
which the root word is Nepos that refer to nephew. Nepotism refers
to the act of hiring worker based on feelings than qualification
that the person meets the job description. Nepotism can be found in
the politics, entertainment, business and religion. Politics
nepotism is about a leader choosing his favor person such as his
son, daughter, friends that have no qualification to take the
responsibility that acquire qualification and experience to do such
task as designing structure to maintain water safety. Due to the
increase of nepotism problem the worldwide nowadays create the
nepotism policy which concerning on the act of nepotism by applying
nepotism policy in all the government and non-government
organization. In this policy it says Relationship by family or
marriage constitutes neither an advantage nor a deterrent to
appointment by the university, provided that the individual meets
the appropriate standards for the position to be filled and provided
that the individual will not be in the chain of supervision of a
spouse, family member, or person with whom the individual is dating.
Employment will be denied under the following circumstances:
- Where one family member would have the authority or practical
power to supervise, appoint, remove, or discipline another;
- Where one family member would be responsible for auditing the work
of another;
- Where other circumstances exist which would place family members
in a situation of actual or reasonably foreseeable conflict between
the employer's interest and their own.
Applicants who are denied employment to a particular position for
one of the foregoing reasons will be considered for other vacant
positions for which they may be qualified. Failure to advise the
University of the Existence of one of these circumstances may result
in a withdrawal of an offer of employment or actual discharge from
employment.
Existing PLU employees who become involved in one of the foregoing
circumstances have an obligation to advise the university about the
conflict. Every effort will be made to resolve the conflict without
loss of employment to either employee; however, the university
reserves the right to transfer one or both employees, to discharge
one or both employees or to demote one or both employees to resolve
the conflict. Employees who fail to advise the University Existence
of a family, spousal or dating relationship under one of these
circumstances will be subject to discipline, up to and including
discharge. Nepotism also will cause job unsatisfied because,
nepotism decreases morale of all employees with the exception of the
individuals directly benefiting from the relationship. In a study of
nepotism in the hotel industry published in the International
Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, nepotism had a significant
detrimental impact on employees' overall job satisfaction, intention
to quit the job and likelihood of talking negatively about the job
for example, to other co-workers or potential customers. A
successful nepotism policy therefore has the potential to make a
significant improvement to the overall morale of the organization.
New employees may not fully qualify for the vacancy, however people
who can best meet the requirements of the job tend to be ignored in
substitution for relatives or friends of particular individuals
involved with the entity. This may cause conflicts at the workplace
and some employees within the business may look for promotion.
(FOWLER & EDQUIST, 2003)
ADVANTAGE Improved customer relations through family contact
Intergenerational continuity
Long-term stability
Shared values
Loyalty and commitment
Inherent trust
Willingness to sacrifice for the business
DISADVANTAGE Possible managerial incompetence
Lack of exposure to other businesses
Inability to separate family and work
Patterns of conflict rooted in early family experience
Communication breakdowns
Inability to retire and let go
Sibling rivalry (Myrna L. Gusdorf, 2008)
EMPLOYMENT OF CHILDREN
“Child” means a person who is not yet over compulsory school age ora person who is under 18 years of age.
“Employment” means an occupation which is carry on for profit.
An underage person cannot be employed. If a child is engaged to
carry out work, whether or not the child receives payment, or any
other kind of reward, the child is considered to be employed.
1. The age a child can be employed and the kind of work that a
child can do depends on a number of factors:
whether the work is in addition to full-time school,
part-time, casual or holiday work whether the work
is an alternative to full-time school
the type of work
certain conditions (e.g. parental supervision or
approval)
the hours of work.
2. Children of any age may work:
as part of a school program
in a family business where the business is carried out by
a parent or relative of the child
in a not-for-profit organization or situation
in a dramatic or musical performance or other form of
entertainment or in the making of an advertisement.
3. The working day:
6 days per week
not permitted to work between 8 p.m. to 7 a.m. ( but not
apply to any child engaged in any public entertainment.
A maximum of 3 consecutive hours with at least rest 30
minutes
4. The advantages:
For them, the salary high
Can gain confidence of working among the children
Also learning the basic of working
will have the opportunity to work towards qualifications
that will enhance children career
5. The disadvantages:
Get to paid them a little salary than taking an
experience person
taking the short lived time out of child's life when they
should be getting a good education
In most countries (not third world countries) it's
illegal
Often sexually or verbally abused (Marcy, 2013)
EMPLOYMENT OF OLD WORKERS
1. AGEISM’S DOUBLE STANDARD
When recruiting, many companies is taking a double standard
stand when dealing with elderly people who are applying for a
position that is advertised. This is because their judgement is
clouded with a stereotype about elderly people. Generally, not just
the companies that are recruiting, but normal people also have
stereotype about elderly people. As for example, elderly people are
often negatively stereotype in either physical or mental which is
the result of ultimate outcome of golden age, death.
Older workers are seen as incompetent and did not have the
required skills to keep up or compete with younger workers.
Especially if the company that are advertising for the position is a
rapidly growing company. This statement is strongly supported with
the fact that most old workers did not have the skills needed to
handle a new technology. However, this statement could be argued as
there are some elderly people who have the knowledge to handle new
technology. All they need is a given chance to prove their worth.
(Wikipedia, 2013)
2. JOB SKILLS HAVE BEEN RENDERED OBSOLETE
Usually older people are no longer needed to work after they
have reached their retirement age. But, maybe they need to deal with
their personal problems like settling their debt which requires them
to have a steady income which forced them out of retirement. They
have long rested and given their age and mental health they have
forgotten how to do their work efficiently.
This is the main point which companies did not want to hire
them. But the companies should look at the bright side. At least,
the elderly people have experiences on their side. The companies
could use their experience by implementing a “Mentor-Mentee”
programme. By implementing this program, the younger employee could
learn from their Mentor. While the young worker have amazing new
ideas that could be successful in the market, the older employee
have experience on how the idea should be done. So, the probability
of success is taken higher.
As for their skills, the companies could refer them to
training that coincides with their assessed skills and is relevant
to their career goals. If that did not work, the company could do
job redesign which makes the job more suitable for older employee.
3. OVERQUALIFIED
A Employers don't jump at the chance to hire someone who isn't
a perfect fit for the job,. Even if the applicant have qualification
and work experience, the employer will turn them away if they have
too many qualifications. While you may think employers should be
happy to have overqualified candidates to fill their positions, the
opposite is actually true: many employers won't even consider a
candidate with too much education or experience.
One of the many reasons is that they cannot afford to pay them
enough. Simply said, since the applicants have certificate
qualifications and a ton of experience the employer thinks that they
demanded a high salary. Since they have good qualification and
experience, the company think that they are desperate and are afraid
that they will leave after they got a better offer.
This is not true because older employee have their pension
money income. They are willing to work with less pay and benefit to
have a rewarding job where they can use their skills to interact
with others.
4. AGEISM MYTH
One of the most famous myths about older workers is that they
are less productive than younger workers. Productivity is not just
proved with quantity but also quality. Mature workers are known as
tend to produce quality work, which can help raise the company’s
name. This matter is often overlooked by the company as they try to
reach fresh new ideas without looking carefully about the quality
factor.
Most companies think those older employees are not as creative
or as innovative as the young employee. They have worked long enough
to see new approaches fail. They can accept new changes as long as
it is relevant.
Besides that, the employer thinks that the older employee
cannot learn as well as young workers especially in the aspects of
technologies. Older workers have superior study habits and their
accumulated experience lowers the training cost. They generally want
to keep pace with the change and are very eager to learn new skills.
DISCRIMINATION
Discrimination is prejudicial and / or distinguishing treatment
of an individual based on their membership in certain group or
category .in other words it is worse than people that usually
treated. It involves group’s initial reaction or interaction,
influencing individual behaviour towards group or group leader,
restricting members at one group firm opportunities or privileges
that available to another group, leading to exclusion of individual
or entities based on logical or irrational decision making
(Gorman, 2013)
POSITIVE
Positive discrimination is regarded as preferential treatment
members of minority group over majority group, either by
sex,race,age,maritial status or sex oreantation.it is generally
considered illegal and awful.
NEGATIVE
Negative discrimination is when less favourable treatment is given to these with a certain factor than to those without that factor.positive discrimination is when more favourable treatment is given to those with certain factor than to those without factor. (Lan, 2013)
TYPE OF DISCRIMINATION
Example:
• Age
• Disability
• Gender and Sexual harassment
• Industrial Activity
• Race
• Religion
• Maritial status
• Political Belief or Activity
FIVE TOP EXAMPLES:
AGE DISCRIMINATION-WORKPLACE
It against law to discriminate everyone in workplace because
of their actual or assumed age .stereotype and assumptions about
young people and mature workers can have big influence and decision
in workplace.
For example,
• Advertising for someone to join ‘ a dynamic young team’
• Not interviewing someone because too young or too old to fit
in with other staff
• Not providing training opportunities for mature workers
because ‘ it’s not worth it’
BASED ON RACE/ ETHNICITY
It is originally prohibited by law, but doesn’t mean it is not
exist. It may be experienced through harassment, for example having
derogatory remarks towards them regarding their skin colour or ethic
background. Other forms are including preferential or negative
treatment or being paid at different rate because of race or
ethnicity. Companies should not discriminate against job applicant
regarding race or ethnicity.
BASED ON SEX
It takes on many forms at work. Sexual harassment is one of
most obvious forms, may include unwanted sexual harassment,
propositions or crude remarks toward an employee. It may involve
preferential or negative treatment or being paid at different rate
of gender. Companies cannot discriminate against applicant based on
sex because it will give negative impact on employees on age
gender .both men and women may involve.
BASED ON RELIGION
It involves treating a person unfairly because of his
religious affiliation, and prohibited by law. By law, employees that
being employ must take reasonable accommodations for religious
employees, regardless their religion. For example, it’s including
flexible scheduling to follow employees worship off, allow employees
wear garments associated with their religion. A company cannot force
its employees to attend religious service or participate in
religious activities.
WITH DISABILITIES
This does not mean employees can hire or required to hire
person with disabilities but as long no undue hardship, employees
must make reasonable accommodations for employees with disabilities.
Harassment towards employees with disabilities prohibited by law
because its similar to negative treatment. When interviewing law
prohibited employers from asking applicants about their disabilities
.once job offered, company require applicants answer medical
question or past medical exam, but must be fair with all employees
either disable or not.
(Timmons, 2013)
THE EFFECT OF DISCRIMINATION
DISGRUNTLED EMPLOYEES
Getting unfairly passed up for promotions based on gender or sexual
orientation can lead to frustration and anger. For example, boss may
continuously send out an attractive female employee on new-business
meeting, instead seasoned salesperson. According to attorney silver
stein, these forms of devaluing discrimination can make employees
feel resentful and helpless, which can lead to friction with
management. (Harkin, 2012)
FINANCIAL
If employee quits escaping discrimination, then employers must
spend money to recruit fresh workers. Hiring new employees also
strain on company budget because administrating, educating, and
training employees on policies and technology can be time consuming
and expensive.
PHYSICAL EFFECTS ON EMPLOYEES
Employee may rack up or sick or being continuously late to
escape discrimination. For example of physical sign of
discrimination is someone who refuses to participate in friendly
conversation , look co-workers in eye, smile or keep grooming
habits. This especially detrimental to company if its salesperson or
receptionist representing the company.
LEGAL TROUBLE
An employee can bring legal action against the company in form
of compliant to government. For example the employees are forced to
pay back wages. Company that wrongly fired an employee may require
re-hiring person. If commission cannot resolve the issue or prove
discrimination, it will close the case without filling federal
lawsuit and give employee 90 days to fill personal lawsuit.
( Global post, america’s word new life , lisa finn )
EXPATRIATE
Expatriate is a person temporarily or permanently residing in
a country and culture. The word comes from the Latin terms ‘ex’
(out, of) and patria (country).An expatriate is any person living in
a different country from where they are a citizen. In common usage
the term is often used in the context of professionals sent abroad
by their companies, as opposed to locally hired staff.
EXAMPLE EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA
Usually, in Malaysia workers from India come to Malaysia to
open a shop. For example, Barber shop. Other than that, workers from
Bangladesh come to Malaysia to work as a construction worker. Or
maid from Indonesia.
ADVANTAGE OF EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA
One of the advantage is some of them are more skilful than
workers In Malaysia. For example Barber. Barber from India have
skill in cutting customer’s hair. Other than that, they do a work
that most people in Malaysia won’t do or apply the job.
DISADVANTAGES OF EXPATRIATE IN MALAYSIA
One of the disadvantages is crime in Malaysia Increase. They
do an illegal activity such as robbery, raping, kidnapping and
others. This will make Malaysian people scared. This also ruin
Malaysia’s image and name. (Cardy, 2013)
SUGGESTION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
When we all examine together about our assignment, we
found that there are positive and negative impact on each topic. So,
our suggestion is when we talk about nepotism, each company in
Malaysia cannot do it. For example, give the title CEO to his/her
son. But this can be accepted when his/her relative is really
qualified for the title. Furthermore, about employment of children,
it should not happen. Each company must follow that only a person
that age 18 and above can only take as a worker. This is because,
the person that age 18 and below are still studying in school. they
need to focus in their studying, thus making them hard to control
their timing when they are working. (House, 2010)
Next, employment of old workers is something that special. Old
people are usually have experience and their experience are very
valuable. But, they can’t work like young people that use a lot of
energy. Besides that, expatriate is not a bad thing to do. But when
there is no control at the law of this country, it will make a lot
of trouble such as the resident in this country hard to get a job
and a lot of crime related with the people that come to our country
because they lack of money. Last but not least, about
discrimination. There are a lot of thing that the government and the
company in Malaysia should thing before make a decision when take a
person to be their worker. This is to prevent discrimination.
(Mifflin, The Free Dictionary, 2009)
BibliographyCardy, R. (17 October, 2013). Wikipedia. Retrieved 2013, from Expatriate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriate
FOWLER, D., & EDQUIST, P. M. (8 6, 2003). The Business Journal. Retrieved2003, from Evaluate the pros and cons of employing family members: http://www.bizjournals.com/milwaukee/stories/2003/06/09/smallb6.html?page=all
Harkin, S. (13 March, 2012). Tom Harkin. Retrieved 2012, from Bipartisan Legislation Will Protect Older Workers from Discrimination: http://www.harkin.senate.gov/press/release.cfm?i=336287
House, R. (2010). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved 2010, from Selection: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/selection
Lan. (20 May, 2013). Gov.UK. Retrieved 2013, from Discrimination: your rights: https://www.gov.uk/discrimination-your-rights/discrimination-at-work
Marcy. (2013). Answers. Retrieved 2013, from What are the disadvantages of child labor?: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_disadvantages_of_child_labor
Mifflin, H. (2009). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved 2009, from Recruitment: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/recruitment
Mifflin, H. (2009). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved 2009, from Exptriate: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/expatriate
Myrna L. Gusdorf, M. S. (2008). Staffing Management. Recruitment and Selection: , 4.
Timmons, B. (2013). GlobalPost. Retrieved 2013, from Types of Discrimination in the Workplace: http://everydaylife.globalpost.com/types-discrimination-workplace-3279.html
Wikipedia. (23 July, 2013). Retrieved 2013, from Age Discrimination inEmployment Act: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_Discrimination_in_Employment_Act