This article was downloaded by: [the Bodleian Libraries of the University of Oxford]On: 16 January 2013, At: 10:11Publisher: RoutledgeInforma Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registeredoffice: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Visual CognitionPublication details, including instructions for authors andsubscription information:http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/pvis20

Focusing on fear: attentionaldisengagement from emotional facesGeorge Georgiou a , Cheryl Bleakley a , James Hayward a , RiccardoRusso a , Kevin Dutton a , Stacy Eltiti a & Elaine Fox aa University of Essex, Colchester, UKVersion of record first published: 07 Mar 2011.

To cite this article: George Georgiou , Cheryl Bleakley , James Hayward , Riccardo Russo , KevinDutton , Stacy Eltiti & Elaine Fox (2005): Focusing on fear: attentional disengagement fromemotional faces, Visual Cognition, 12:1, 145-158

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13506280444000076

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions

This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Anysubstantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.

The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representationthat the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of anyinstructions, formulae, and drug doses should be independently verified with primarysources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings,demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly orindirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.

!"#$%&'( "' )*+,- .//*'/&"'+0 1&%*'(+(*2*'/ ),"2

*2"/&"'+0 )+#*%

!"#$%" &' !"#$%(#)* +,"$-. /."01."-* 203"4 50-60$7*8(990$7# 8)44#* :";(< =)>>#<* ?>09- @.>(>(* 0<7 @.0(<" A#B

!"#$%&'#() *+ ,''%-. /*012%'(%&. !3

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

Q> ,04 K""< 6(7".- $"D#$>"7 >,0> >,$"0>M$".0>"7 4>(3).( ,0;" 0 4D"9(0. D$#D"<4(>-># 0>>$09> ;(4)0. 0>>"<>(;" D$#9"44(<% E"'%'* R(..(034* R0>>4* F09S"#7* GF0>,"64* HITT* HIIUJ' A#$ (<4>0<9"* VW ,30<* A.-1>* 0<7 @4>";"4 ENOOH0J ,0;"D#(<>"7 #)> >,0> 30330.4 ,0;" ";#.;"7 (< "<;($#<3"<>4 (< 6,(9, K#>,$"4#)$9"4 0<7 70<%"$4 6"$" )<D$"7(9>0K.- 7(4>$(K)>"7 (< 4D09" 0<7 >(3"'P,"$"C#$"* >," $"D$#7)9>(;" 4)99"44 #C (<7(;(7)0.4 604 7"D"<7"<> ># 0 .0$%""B>"<> #< >," 0K(.(>- ># $0D(7.- .#90>" D#>"<>(0..- 70<%"$#)4 ";"<>4 (< >,""<;($#<3"<>' Q< 4)DD#$> #C >,(4 <#>(#<* "<,0<9"7 7">"9>(#< #C >,$"0>M$".";0<>4>(3).( 4)9, 04 0<%$- C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 E@04>6##7* ?3(."1* G F"$(1."* NOOHXA#B* S"4>"$* 8)44#* /#6."4* Y(9,."$* G =)>>#<* NOOOX VW ,30<* S)<7Z;(4>* G@4>";"4* NOOHKJ 0<7 4<01"4 0<7 4D(7"$4 EVW ,30< "> 0.'* NOOH0J ,04 K""< C#)<7 (<

Y."04" 077$"44 0.. 9#$$"4D#<7"<9" ># =$' !"#$%" &' !"#$%(#)* ?9,##. #C 5)30<(>("4 0<7 ?#9(0.

?9("<9"4* Q<>"$9#.."%"* [\ F01"7#<(>(4404 &;"* Y'V' /#B N[OO]* HUOO ^(9#4(0* +-D$)4'

@30(._ %"#$%(#)'%`(<>"$9#.."%"'09'9-

P," $"4"0$9, $"D#$>"7 ,"$" 604 4)DD#$>"7 K- %$0<> <)3K"$ O\[NIOabaOHab C$#3 >," R"..9#3"

P$)4> 060$7"7 ># @.0(<" A#B 0<7 8(990$7# 8)44#'

! NOO] Y4-9,#.#%- Y$"44 S>7

,>>D_aa666'>0<7C'9#')1ac#)$<0.4aDDaHd]O\NT]',>3. =VQ_ HO'HOTOaHd]O\NTO[[[OOOOU\

eQ?f&S +V!^QPQV^* NOO]* HN EHJ* H[]gH]T

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

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

5#6";"$* D"#D." 6(>, ,(%, .";".4 #C 4".CM$"D#$>"7 0<B(">- 7# 4""3 ># K" 3#$".(1".- ># 0..#90>" >,"($ ;(4)0. 0>>"<>(#< >#60$74 >," .#90>(#< #C 0<%$- #$ C"0$C).C09"4 (< >0414 6,"$" >6# C09"4 0$" D$"4"<>"7 4(7" K- 4(7" E"'%'* A#B* NOONX F#%%G /$07."-* HIIIJ' P,)4* >,"$" (4 0 %"<"$0. >"<7"<9- ># 0..#90>" 4"."9>(;"0>>"<>(#< >#60$74 D#>"<>(0..- >,$"0>"<(<% 4>(3).(* 0<7 >,(4 30- K" C)$>,"$"<,0<9"7 K- ,(%, .";".4 #C 0<B(">- 0<7a#$ D,#K(9 C"0$' P,"4" $"4).>4 0$" 4)DMD#$>(;" #C 0< ";#.)>(#<0$- ,-D#>,"4(4 >,0> 0 4D"9(0.(L"7 <")$0. 0<7 K",0;(#)$0.3#7)." ,04 ";#.;"7 C#$ $"4D#<7(<% ># >,$"0>"<(<% 4>(3).( E"'%'* "3#>(#<0. C09(0."BD$"44(#<4X VW ,30< G F(<"10* NOOHJ' Q> (4 #C D0$>(9).0$ (<>"$"4> >,0> >,(4";#.;"7 3#7)." 30- K" ,-D"$4"<4(>(;" (< 0<B(">-'

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h("<7 G F0>,"64* NOOHJ'P,)4* >," D$"4"<9" #C C"0$M$".";0<> 4>(3).( (< >," "<;($#<3"<> 30- $"4).> (< 0<0<B(">-M$".0>"7 C0(.)$" ># $0D(7.- 7(4"<%0%" C$#3 >,$"0>"<(<% 4>(3).('

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

f4(<% 0 4(3(.0$ 4D0>(0. #$("<>(<% >041* ="$$-K"$$- 0<7 8""7 ENOONJ C#)<7 >,0>,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 (<7(;(7)0.4 >##1 .#<%"$ ># 7">"9> 0< )<9)"7 >0$%"> 6,"<D$"9"7"7 K- 0 >,$"0>"<(<% 9)"' P,(4 K(04 >$0<4D($"7 6,"< >," 4>(3).)4 #<4">

!"# $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

04-<9,$#<- E?V&J K">6""< >," 9)" 0<7 >," >0$%"> 604 N]O 34 0<7 <#> ]OO 34'P,(4 C(<7(<% (4 9#<4(4>"<> 6(>, >," .(>"$0>)$" 4,#6(<% >,0> >," 0>>"<>(#<0. K(04 (<0<B(">- #D"$0>"4 "0$.- 6(>,(< >," 4>$"03 #C (<C#$30>(#< D$#9"44(<%' F#$"(3D#$>0<>.-* ="$$-K"$$- 0<7 8""7i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

P01"< >#%">,"$* >,(4 $"9"<> $"4"0$9, 4)%%"4>4 >,0> >," 0K(.(>- ># $0D(7.- 7(4M"<%0%" C$#3 <"%0>(;" 4>(3).( 3(%,> K" C0($.- %"<"$0..- (3D0($"7 (< 0<B(">-' &47(49)44"7 K- A#B "> 0.' ENOOHJ* >,(4 >"<7"<9- 30(<>0(<4 9#%<(>(;" $"4#)$9"4 #<>," 4#)$9" #C 4>$"44 0<7 30- 4"$;" ># 30(<>0(< 0<7 "<,0<9" 0<B(">- 4>0>"4 E4""0.4# A#B* 8)44#* G =)>>#<* NOONJ' Q< 9#<>$04>* >," 0K(.(>- ># $0D(7.- 7(4"<%0%"C$#3 >,$"0>M$".0>"7 30>"$(0. #<9" (7"<>(C("7 30- K" 0 )4"C). 3"9,0<(43 ># 1""D0<B(">- .";".4 )<7"$ 9#<>$#.' 5#6";"$* 0.. #C >," D$";(#)4 $"4"0$9, E="$$-K"$$-G 8""7* NOONX A#B "> 0.'* NOOH* NOONX h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jj<"%0>(;"ii' 5#6";"$* (C >," C"0$M

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !"4

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

$".";0<9" (4 9$(>(90. >,"< 7".0-"7 7(4"<%0%"3"<> 4,#).7 #<.- #99)$ C#$ >,"C"0$C). "BD$"44(#<'

%/0%'(5%2* !

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

56789:

:6&(#1#86"('' Y0$>(9(D0<>4 6"$" \\ 4>)7"<>4 C$#3 >," f<(;"$4(>- #C @44"B903D)4 9#33)<(>- $0<%(<% (< 0%" C$#3 HT ># ]O -"0$4 #C 0%"* 6(>, 0 3#70. 0%"(< >," NO4' Y0$>(9(D0<>4 6"$" D$"4"."9>"7 C$#3 0< )<7"$%$07)0>" .0K#$0>#$- 9.044'P,($>-M>,$"" 49#$(<% [] #$ ,(%,"$ #< >," >$0(> 0<B(">- 490." #C >," ?D(".K"$%"$P$0(>g?>0>" &<B(">- Q<;"<>#$- E?P&QX ?D(".K"$%"$* !#$4)9,* S)4,"<"* e0%%* G209#K4* HITdJ 6"$" 044(%<"7 ># >," ,(%,M0<B(#)4 %$#)D* 6,(." >,($>-M>,$""49#$(<% d] #$ ."44 #< >," >$0(> 0<B(">- 490." 6"$" 044(%<"7 ># >," .#6M0<B(#)4%$#)D' ?9#$"4 #< >," /"91 ="D$"44(#< Q<;"<>#$- E/=QX /"91* R0$7* F"<7".4#<*F#91* G @$K0)%,* HI\HJ 6"$" 0.4# 0;0(.0K." C$#3 0 D$(#$ .0K#$0>#$- 9.044' @09,D"$4#< ,07 <#$30. #$ 9#$$"9>"7 ># <#$30. ;(4(#< 0<7 D0$>(9(D0>"7 (< #<""BD"$(3"<>0. 4"44(#< .04>(<% 0K#)> N] 3(<* C#$ 6,(9, >,"- $"9"(;"7 D0-3"<> #CkN'OO'

;6(%&#60' 6"4 6886&6(<'' P,$"" 7(CC"$"<> D,#>#%$0D,4 6"$" 4"."9>"7 C$#3>," @130< 0<7 A$("4"< EHIU]J 70>0K04" #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4' &.. >,"D,#>#%$0D,4 6"$" #C >," 403" (<7(;(7)0. EY@J K)> "09, "BD$"44"7 0 7(CC"$"<>"3#>(#< EC"0$* ,0DD-* 0<7 <")>$0.J' @09, #C >," K.091 0<7 6,(>" D,#>#%$0D,43"04)$"7 \'T 93 ! HO'd 93 (< 4(L" 0<7 >,"- 6"$" 30>9,"7 C#$ K$(%,><"44' Q< 0<(<(>(0. D(.#> 4>)7-* HN 4>)7"<>4 90>"%#$(L"7 >," "3#>(#< #C "09, #C >," C09"4 04

!"; $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

jj,0DD-ii* jj407ii* jjC"0$C).ii* jj0<%$-ii* jj4)$D$(4"7ii* jj7(4%)4>"7ii* #$jj<")>$0.ii' Q> 604 C#)<7 >,0> HOOl 90>"%#$(L"7 >," C"0$C). "BD$"44(#< 04jjC"0$C).ii* HOOl 90>"%#$(L"7 >," ,0DD- "BD$"44(#< 04 jj,0DD-ii* 0<7 TOl $0>"7>," <")>$0. C09" 04 jj<")>$0.ii* 6,(." NOl 90>"%#$(L"7 >,(4 C09" 04 jj407ii' P,">0$%"> 4>(3).( 6"$" >," 90D(>0. .">>"$4 m 0<7 Y 0<7 >,"- 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 (< !"<";0C#<> N[' P," >0$%"> .">>"$4 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 (< #<" #C C#)$ .#90>(#<4_ T 93 0K#;"*K".#6* ># >," ."C>* #$ ># >," $(%,> #C >," 9"<>$0..- .#90>"7 C09"' P,"4" .#90>(#<46"$" 0K#)> I" 7"%$""4 #C ;(4)0. 0<%." C$#3 >," 9"<>$" #C C(B0>(#< 6,"< ;("6"7C$#3 ]O 93'

&.. 4>(3).( 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 #< 0 Y#6"$ F091(<>#4, UNOOaIO 9#3D)>"$ 6(>, 0NI 93 ! NH 93 ?#<- P$(<(>$#< F).>(490< 49$""<' =0>0 D$"4"<>0>(#< 0<7 9#.M."9>(#< 6"$" 9#<>$#.."7 K- >," Y4-?9#D" D$#%$03 E+#,"<* F09R,(<<"-* A.0>>*G Y$#;#4>* HIIdJ 0<7 $"4D#<4"4 6"$" 9#.."9>"7 K- 3"0<4 #C 0 7"7(90>"7 Y4-M?9#D" K)>>#< K#B* 6,(9, "<4)$"4 099)$09- ># 6(>,(< H 34'

:&*1%4<&%' V< 0$$(;0. 0> >," .0K#$0>#$-* D0$>(9(D0<>4 6"$" 4"0>"7 (< 0 430..9)K(9." 9#<>0(<(<% 0 9#3D)>"$ 0<7 >," <0>)$" #C >," >041 604 "BD.0(<"7 ># >,"3'P,"- 6"$" >#.7 >,0> >,"- 6#).7 4"" 0< 04>"$(41 0> >," 9"<>$" #C >," 49$""< 0<7 >,0>>,"- 4,#).7 1""D >,"($ "-"4 C(B0>"7 #< >,(4 .#90>(#<' Q> 604 "BD.0(<"7 >,0> >,"04>"$(41 6#).7 K" $"D.09"7 K- 0 C09" 0<7 >,0> 4,#$>.- 0C>"$60$74 0 .">>"$ Em #$ YJ6#).7 0DD"0$ "(>,"$ 0K#;"* K".#6* ># >," ."C>* #$ ># >," $(%,> #C >," C09"' P,"-6"$" (<4>$)9>"7 ># 90>"%#$(L" >," .">>"$ 04 Z)(91.- 0<7 099)$0>".- 04 D#44(K." K-D$"44(<% >," $"7 K)>>#< C#$ 0< m #$ >," %$""< K)>>#< C#$ 0 Y* 6,(." 1""D(<% >,"($"-"4 C#9)4"7 #< >," 9"<>$0. C09"' @09, >$(0. K"%0< 6(>, 0< 04>"$(41 D$"4"<>"7 (<>," 9"<>$" #C >," 9#3D)>"$ 49$""< C#$ HOOO 34' V<" #C >," C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 604>,"< D$"4"<>"7 0> >," 9"<>$" #C >," 49$""< 0<7 0C>"$ \OO 34 0 >0$%"> .">>"$ E"(>,"$m #$ YJ 604 D$"4"<>"7 0> #<" #C >," C#)$ .#90>(#<4 C#$ ]O 34' P," C09" $"30(<"7#< >," 9#3D)>"$ 49$""< )<>(. >," D0$>(9(D0<> $"4D#<7"7 #$ )<>(. NOOO 34 ,07".0D4"7' P,"$" 604 0< (<>"$>$(0. (<>"$;0. #C ]OO 34'

@09, D0$>(9(D0<> 9#3D.">"7 0 D$09>(9" K.#91 #C N[ >$(0.4* C#..#6"7 K- NTT"BD"$(3"<>0. >$(0.4' P,"4" >$(0.4 6"$" 7(;(7"7 "Z)0..- (<># >$(0.4 6(>, >0$%">40DD"0$(<% 0K#;" EUNJ* K".#6 EUNJ* ># >," ."C> EUNJ* 0<7 ># >," $(%,> EUNJ #C >,"9"<>$0..- D$"4"<>"7 C09"' A#$ "09, >0$%"> .#90>(#<* >," 9"<>$0..- C(B0>"7 C09" 604"Z)0..- #C>"< C"0$C). EI\J* ,0DD- EI\J* 0<7 <")>$0. EI\J' S(1"6(4"* >," 09>)0.>0$%"> .">>"$ Em #$ YJ 0DD"0$"7 "Z)0..- #C>"< 6(>, "09, >-D" #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<0<7 (< "09, >0$%"> .#90>(#<' &.. 9#<7(>(#<4 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 (< 0 7(CC"$"<> $0<7#3#$7"$ C#$ "09, D0$>(9(D0<>'

=%'#5"' R" (<(>(0..- 90$$("7 #)> 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J !N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ 50DD- 0<7 <")>$0.J 3(B"7 &^Ve& ' QC >,(4 0<0.-4(4 604<#<4(%<(C(90<> >,"< ,0DD- 0<7 <")>$0. C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 6#).7 K" 9#..0D4"7 (<>#0 90>"%#$- .0K".."7 <#<C"0$' R" >,"< 90$$("7 #)> 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(>0<B(">-J! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ A"0$ 0<7 <#<C"0$J 3(B"7 &^Ve&' &<B(">- 604

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !"<

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

0 K">6""<M4)Kc"9>4 C09>#$* 6,(." C09(0. "BD$"44(#< 604 0 6(>,(<M4)Kc"9> C09>#$'P," 30(< 7"D"<7"<> ;0$(0K." )4"7 604 >," $"09>(#< >(3" E8PJ ># $"4D#<7 >#>0$%"> (>"34'

'6=>?7=

&4 4,#6< (< P0K." H* >," >6# %$#)D4 #C D0$>(9(D0<>4 7(CC"$"7 (< >"$34 #C >$0(>0<B(">- 0<7 (< >,"($ /=Q 49#$"4'

>%'8*"'% (#7%' 6"4 %&&*& &6(% 6"60)'%'' P," 3"0< D"$9"<>0%" "$$#$4 6"$"4)Kc"9>"7 ># 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_A"0$ 0<7 <#<C"0$J 3(B"7 &^Ve& E4"" P0K." N C#$ 3#$" 7">0(.4J'H P,(4 0<0.-4(47(7 <#> $";"0. 0<- 4(%<(C(90<> 30(< #$ (<>"$09>(#< "CC"9>4 E0.. 84 n 'HOJ' Q<9#$$"9>>$(0.4 0<7 8P4 ."44 >,0< HOO 34 0<7 %$"0>"$ >,0< H]OO 34 6"$" ".(3(<0>"7 C$#3>," 8P 0<0.-4(4' & D$".(3(<0$- N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! NEC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ 50DD- 0<7 <")>$0.J 3(B"7 &^Ve& 604 90$$("7 #)> >#7">"$3(<" 6,">,"$ 8P D"$C#$30<9" 7(CC"$"7 K">6""< >," ,0DD- 0<7 <")>$0.C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4' P," 30(< "CC"9>4 #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<* ?EH* \[J o N'dN* ;@, o

*+@,% !56AB =C9D6= 9B 786 1*+( *DAE7 +BFE67G 1CA?6 AB: 786 @6CH

36ID6==E9B (BJ6B79DG K@3(L M9D 786 8EN8 AB: ?9O 7DAE7PABFE9>=ND9>I= EB %FI6DEQ6B7= ! AB: R

A&*<8

;%6'<&% B#52 (&6#(96"-#*<' C*D (&6#(96"-#*<' (EFGH

@BD"$(3"<> H

" dd dd

P$0(> 0<B(">- ]['N E\'NJ NI'd E['OJ HI'[pp

/=Q HO'[ E['TJ N'I EN'TJ U'Tpp

@BD"$(3"<> N

" dd dd

P$0(> 0<B(">- ]d'T E\'UJ NI'[ Ed'[J HT'Upp

/=Q HH'T EU'TJ N'U Ed'OJ \'dpp

pp 8 q 'OOH'

H &< &^Ve& 604 90$$("7 #)> #< >," 3"0< 8P4 E(< 34J >,0> ,07 #<" K">6""<M4)Kc"9> C09>#$

E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J 0<7 #<" 6(>,(<M4)Kc"9> C09>#$ EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ 50DD-* <")>$0.*

0<7 C"0$J' P,(4 0<0.-4(4 $";"0."7 0 4(%<(C(90<> 30(< "CC"9> #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<* ?EN* HNTJ o ['\I*;@,

o IU]'T* 8 q 'O] EC"0$ o [TT 34* ,0DD- o [UN 34* <")>$0. o [U]J 0<7 0 4(%<(C(90<> &<B(">- %$#)D !A09(0. "BD$"44(#< (<>"$09>(#<* ?EN* HNTJ o U'\U* ;@, o IU]'T* 8 q 'OH' Q< @BD"$(3"<>4 H 0<7 N >,"

3"0< D"$9"<>0%" "$$#$4 6"$" 4)Kc"9>"7 ># 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! d EC09(0.

"BD$"44(#<_ 50DD-* <")>$0.* 0<7 C"0$a407J 3(B"7 &^Ve&' P,"4" 0<0.-4"4 7(7 <#> $";"0. 0<- 4(%M

<(C(90<> 30(< #$ (<>"$09>(#< "CC"9>4 E0.. 84 n 'HOJ'

!ST $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

H]O'N* 8 n 'HO* 0<B(">- %$#)D* ?EH* \[J q H* 0<7 A09(0. "BD$"44(#< ! &<B(">-%$#)D (<>"$09>(#<* ?EH* \[J o N'TN* ;@, o H]O'N* 8 o 'OIT* 6"$" <#> 4(%<(C(90<>*>,)4 ,0DD- 0<7 <")>$0. >$(0.4 6"$" 9#..0D4"7 >#%">,"$ E('"'* <#<C"0$J' & NE0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ A"0$ 0<7 <#<C"0$J3(B"7 &^Ve& 6(>, D0$>(9(D0<>4 04 0 $0<7#3 C09>#$ 604 >,"< 90$$("7 #)> E4""C##><#>" HJ' P,(4 0<0.-4(4 $";"0."7 0 4(%<(C(90<> 30(< "CC"9> #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<*?EH* \[J o ['TI* ;@, o Hd]H'H* 8 q 'O] EC"0$ o [TT 34* <#<C"0$ o [Ud 34J* 0<7 04(%<(C(90<> &<B(">- %$#)D ! A09(0. "BD$"44(#< (<>"$09>(#<* ?EH* \[J o T'HH* ;@,o Hd]H'H* 8 q 'OH E4"" P0K." NJ'N P," 30(< "CC"9> #C 0<B(">- %$#)D 604 <#>4(%<(C(90<>* ?EH* \[J q H E,(%, >$0(> 0<B(">- o [T[ 34* .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">- o [UT 34J'

*+@,% R56AB C9DD6C7 D6=I9B=6 7EQ6= EB QE??E=6C9B:= KQ=L AB:Q6AB 6DD9D I6DC6B7AN6= M9D 786 M6ADU B9BM6ADU AB: =A:U

B9B=A:U MACEA? 6FID6==E9B= M9D 8EN8 AB: ?9O7DAE7PABFE9>= ND9>I= EB %FI6DEQ6B7= ! AB: R

A&*<8

/*"4#(#*" B#52 (&6#(96"-#*<' C*D (&6#(96"-#*<'

@BD"$(3"<> H

" dd dd

A"0$

8P ]OO'd EI\'dJ [U['U EU]'TJ

@$$#$ d'\ Ed'O\J ['N E[']NJ

^#<C"0$

8P [\U'I EUd'OJ [UT'T EUI'dJ

@$$#$ d'T Ed'][J ['N EN'TIJ

@BD"$(3"<> N

" dd dd

?07

8P [UI'N ETT'[J [UO'T ETN'HJ

@$$#$ ]'[ Ed'IJ ['\ Ed'HHJ

^#<407

8P [UT'H ETT'NJ [UO'] ETd'NJ

@$$#$ ]'[ Ed'NNJ ['H EN'\NJ

?>0<70$7 7";(0>(#<4 0$" (< D0$"<>,"4(4'

N & N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ A"0$ 0<7 <#<C"0$J &^+Ve&

E/=Q "<>"$"7 04 0 9#;0$(0>"J 604 0.4# 90$$("7 #)>' P,(4 0<0.-4(4 4>(.. -(".7"7 0 4(%<(C(90<> &<B(">-

%$#)D ! A09(0. "BD$"44(#< (<>"$09>(#<* ?EH* \dJ o \'[O* ;@, o Hd\H'\* 8 q 'ON]* 4)%%"4>(<% >,0> >,"

#K4"$;"7 K(04 (4 0< 0<B(">-M$".0>"7 "CC"9>' 5#6";"$* 6" 6#).7 .(1" ># D#(<> #)> >,0> 0.>,#)%,

&^+Ve& (4 #C>"< )4"7 (< >," 9#%<(>(#< 0<7 "3#>(#< .(>"$0>)$" ># D0$>(0. #)> >," "CC"9> #C 7"D$"44(#<

#< >," 7"D"<7"<> ;0$(0K."* >,(4 >"9,<(Z)" 30- <#> K" 0DD$#D$(0>" K"90)4" >," 0;"$0%" .";". #C >,"

9#;0$(0>" (4 <#> "BD"9>"7 ># K" 9#3D0$0K." K">6""< ,(%, 0<7 .#6 0<B(#)4 (<7(;(7)0.4'

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !S!

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

Y.0<<"7 9#<>$04>4 $";"0."7 >,0> 8P4 6"$" 4.#6"$ C#..#6(<% C"0$C)."BD$"44(#<4 C#$ >," ,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 %$#)D 9#3D0$"7 6(>, <#<C"0$C). "BD$"4M4(#<4* (EdNJ o N'U* 8 q 'ON]' A#$ >," .#6 >$0(>M0<B(#)4 %$#)D* >,"$" 604 <#7(CC"$"<9" (< 8P4 C#..#6(<% C"0$C). "BD$"44(#<4 $".0>(;" ># <#<C"0$C)."BD$"44(#<4* (EdNJ o #H'H* 8 n 'HO' ^"(>,"$ #C >," K">6""< %$#)D 9#3D0$(4#<46"$" 4(%<(C(90<>'

3E=C>==E9B

P," $"4).>4 4,#6"7 >,0> ,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 D"#D." >##1 .#<%"$ ># 90>"%#$(L" 0>0$%"> .">>"$ (< D"$(D,"$0. ;(4(#< 6,"< 0 C"0$C). C09" 604 D$"4"<>"7 0> C(B0>(#<*$".0>(;" ># 0 <#<C"0$C). C09"' P,(4 D0>>"$< 604 <#> 0DD0$"<> (< .#6 >$0(>M0<B(">-D0$>(9(D0<>4'

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

%/0%'(5%2* R

@BD"$(3"<> N "B03(<"7 6,">,"$ ,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 D"#D." 6#).7 >01" .#<%"$ >#7(4"<%0%" C$#3 >," "3#>(#<0. "BD$"44(#< #C 407<"44* $".0>(;" ># <#<407 E<")>$0.0<7 ,0DD-J C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4' P," 7"4(%< 604 (7"<>(90. ># @BD"$(3"<> H "B9"D>>,0> 0 407 "BD$"44(#< 604 )4"7 (<4>"07 #C 0 C"0$C). "BD$"44(#<' ^# (<9$"04" (<76".. >(3" 604 "BD"9>"7 (< >,(4 "BD"$(3"<> K"90)4" >," "3#>(#<0. "BD$"44(#< #C407<"44 (4 <#> $".0>"7 ># >," C"0$ 7">"9>(#< 4-4>"3' Q> (4 (3D#$>0<> ># >"4> >,(49#<7(>(#< 4(<9" #)$ D$";(#)4 $"4).>4 6(>, 0<%$- EA#B "> 0.'* NOOH* NOONJ 0<7C"0$C). E@BD"$(3"<> HJ "BD$"44(#<4 30- K" 0>>$(K)>0K." ># <"%0>(;" 0CC"9> 3#$"%"<"$0..- 0<7 30- ,0;" .(>>." ># 7# 6(>, >," "BD$"44(#<4 (<7(90>(<% D#>"<>(0.70<%"$'

!SR $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

56789:

:6&(#1#86"('' &< 077(>(#<0. \\ 4>)7"<>4 6"$" $"9$)(>"7 C$#3 >," f<(;"$4(>-#C @44"B 903D)4 9#33)<(>- $0<%(<% (< 0%" C$#3 HU ># dT -"0$4 #C 0%"* 6(>, 03#70. 0%" (< >," NO4' P,($>-M>,$"" D0$>(9(D0<>4 49#$(<% [] #$ ,(%,"$ #< >," >$0(>0<B(">- 490." 6"$" 044(%<"7 ># >," ,(%,M0<B(#)4 %$#)D* 6,(." >,($>-M>,$"" 49#$(<%d] #$ ."44 #< >," >$0(> 0<B(">- 490." 6"$" 044(%<"7 ># >," .#6M0<B(#)4 %$#)D'@09, D"$4#< ,07 <#$30. #$ 9#$$"9>"7 ># <#$30. ;(4(#< 0<7 D0$>(9(D0>"7 (< #<""BD"$(3"<>0. 4"44(#< .04>(<% 0K#)> N] 3(<* C#$ 6,(9, >,"- $"9"(;"7 D0-3"<> #CkN'OO'

;6(%&#60' 6"4 6886&6(<'' P,$"" 7(CC"$"<> D,#>#%$0D,4 6"$" 4"."9>"7 C$#3>," @130< 0<7 A$("4"< EHIU]J 70>0K04" #C C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4' &.. >,"D,#>#%$0D,4 6"$" #C >," 403" (<7(;(7)0. E2FJ K)> "09, "BD$"44"7 0 7(CC"$"<>"3#>(#< E407* ,0DD-* 0<7 <")>$0.J' P," 4>(3).)4 7(3"<4(#<4 6"$" >," 403" 04 (<@BD"$(3"<> H' Q< 0< (<(>(0. D(.#> 4>)7-* [O 4>)7"<>4 90>"%#$(L"7 >," "3#>(#< #C"09, #C >," C09"4 04 jj,0DD-ii* jj407ii* jjC"0$C).ii* jj0<%$-ii* jj4)$D$(4"7ii*jj7(4%)4>"7ii* #$ jj<")>$0.ii' Q> 604 C#)<7 >,0> IU']l 90>"%#$(L"7 >," 407"BD$"44(#< 04 jj407ii* 6(>, >," $"30(<(<% N']l 90>"%#$(L(<% >,(4 C09" 04jj7(4%)4>"7iiX IU']l 90>"%#$(L"7 >," ,0DD- "BD$"44(#< 04 jj,0DD-ii* 6,(." N']l90>"%#$(L"7 >,(4 C09" 04 jj4)$D$(4"7ii' A(<0..-* UOl #C 4>)7"<>4 $0>"7 >," <")>$0.C09" 04 jj<")>$0.ii* NOl 04 jj4)$D$(4"7ii* ]l 04 jj,0DD-ii* 0<7 N']l 90>"%#$(L"7>," <")>$0. C09" 04 jjC"0$C).ii 0<7 jj7(4%)4>"7ii* $"4D"9>(;".-' P," >0$%"> 4>(3).(6"$" >," 90D(>0. .">>"$4 m 0<7 Y* 04 (< @BD"$(3"<> H* 0<7 >,"- 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 (<>," 403" C#<> 0<7 (< >," 403" .#90>(#<4' P," 9#3D)>"$ ,0$760$" 0<7 4#C>60$"604 >," 403" 04 (< @BD"$(3"<> H'

:&*1%4<&%' P," D$#9"7)$" 0<7 <)3K"$ #C >$(0.4 6"$" (7"<>(90. ># >,0> #C@BD"$(3"<> H* 0<7 >," 403" Z)"4>(#<<0($"4 6"$" 073(<(4>"$"7'

=%'#5"' &4 (< @BD"$(3"<> H* 6" (<(>(0..- 90$$("7 #)> 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7.#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ 50DD- 0<7 <")>$0.J 3(B"7 &^Ve& '&%0(<* >,(4 0<0.-4(4 604 9#<7)9>"7 ># 7">"$3(<" 6,">,"$ >," ,0DD- 0<7 <")>$0.>$(0.4 9#).7 K" 9#..0D4"7 (<># 0 90>"%#$- .0K".."7 04 <#<407' P,(4 0<0.-4(4 604C#..#6"7 K- 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_?07 0<7 <#<407J 3(B"7 &^Ve&' &<B(">- 604 0 K">6""<M4)Kc"9>4 C09>#$* 6,(."C09(0. "BD$"44(#< 604 >," 6(>,(<M4)Kc"9> C09>#$' P," 30(< 7"D"<7"<> ;0$(0K."604 8P ># >0$%"> (>"34'

'6=>?7=

&4 4,#6< (< P0K." H* >," >6# %$#)D4 #C D0$>(9(D0<>4 7(CC"$"7 (< >"$34 #C >$0(>0<B(">- 0<7 /=Q 49#$"4'

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !SV

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

>%'8*"'% (#7%' 6"4 %&&*& &6(% 6"60)'%'' &4 (< @BD"$(3"<> H* >," 3"0<D"$9"<>0%" "$$#$4 6"$" 4)Kc"9>"7 ># 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J !N EC09(0. "BD$"44(#<_ ?07 0<7 <#<407J 3(B"7 &^Ve& E4"" C##><#>" HJ' ^#4(%<(C(90<> 30(< #$ (<>"$09>(#< "CC"9>4 6"$" C#)<7 E0.. 84 n 'HOJ' P," 3"0<D"$9"<>0%" "$$#$4 0$" D$"4"<>"7 (< P0K." N' Q<9#$$"9> >$(0.4 0<7 8P4 ."44 >,0< HOO34 0<7 %$"0>"$ >,0< H]OO 34 6"$" ".(3(<0>"7 C$#3 >," 0<0.-4(4' &4 (<@BD"$(3"<>H* 0 D$".(3(<0$- N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0."BD$"44(#<4_ 50DD-* <")>$0.J 3(B"7 &^Ve& 604 90$$("7 #)>' P,"$" 6"$" <#4(%<(C(90<> 30(< #$ (<>"$09>(#< "CC"9>4 E0.. ?4 q HJ' P,"$"C#$"* >," 70>0 C#$ >,"4"<#<407 "BD$"44(#<4 6"$" 9#..0D4"7 0<7 >," 70>0 ED$"4"<>"7 (< P0K." NJ 6"$"0<0.-4"7 K- )4(<% 0 N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J ! N EC09(0."BD$"44(#<4_ ?07* <#<407J 3(B"7 &^Ve&' ^#<" #C >," 30(< "CC"9>4* <#$ >,"&<B(">- %$#)D ! A09(0. "BD$"44(#< (<>"$09>(#< 6"$" 4(%<(C(90<>* ?4 EH* \[J q H'

/*7I#"%4 6"60)'#'' P# 044"44 6,">,"$ 8P4 6"$" (<9$"04"7 C#$ ,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 D"#D." #< C"0$C). "BD$"44(#< >$(0.4 $".0>(;" ># 407 "BD$"44(#< >$(0.4* >,"70>0 C$#3 @BD"$(3"<>4 H 0<7 N 6"$" 9#3K(<"7' P," 7"D"<7"<> ;0$(0K." 604 >,"4#++%&%"1% K">6""< 8P4 #< C"0$C). #$ 407 "BD$"44(#< >$(0.4 $".0>(;" ># >," <#<C"0$E#$ <#<407J "BD$"44(#< >$(0.4 E('"'* >," 4#++%&%"1%J+%6& #"4%-* 0<7 >," 4#++%&%"1%J'64 #"4%-J' P,(4 $"4).>"7 (< 0 N E<"%0>(;" "BD$"44(#<_ A"0$C).* 407J ! N E0<B(">-_5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J K">6""<M4)Kc"9>4 &^Ve& 6(>, 4)Kc"9>4 04 0 $0<7#3C09>#$ E4"" A(%)$" HJ' P," 9$(>(90. (<>"$09>(#< K">6""< <"%0>(;" "BD$"44(#< 0<7

Difference–fear index Difference–sad index–15

–5

5

15

25

35

45

Diff

eren

ce In

dex

(ms)

High anxious

Low anxious

!&($,* 34 =(CC"$"<9" (<7"B C#$ C"0$ E7(CC"$"<9" K">6""< 8P4 #< C"0$C). 0<7 <#<C"0$C). "BD$"44(#<

>$(0.4J 0<7 407 E7(CC"$"<9" K">6""< 8P4 #< 407 0<7 <#<407 "BD$"44(#< >$(0.4J (< 3(..(4"9#<74 E34J C#$

,(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(#)4 D0$>(9(D0<>4' & D#4(>(;" 49#$" (<7(90>"4 4.#6"$ $"4D#<4"4 #< >," C"0$C).

E407J $0>,"$ >,0< <#<C"0$C). E<#<407J >$(0.4'

!S" $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

0<B(">- %$#)D 604 4(%<(C(90<>* ?EH* HNTJ o U'NN* ;@, o UN['T* 8 q 'OH'd P,"(<>"$09>(#< 604 30(<.- 7$(;"< K- 0 ,(%,"$ 7(CC"$"<9"gC"0$ (<7"B C#$ >," ,(%,*$".0>(;" ># >," .#6 >$0(>M0<B(#)4 %$#)D ErdN'[ ;4' #['H* $"4D"9>(;".-J* (E\[J oN'T* 8 q 'OH* 6,(." >,"$" 604 <# 4(%<(C(90<> K">6""<M%$#)D 7(CC"$"<9" C#$ >,%7(CC"$"<9"g407 (<7"B ErH'H ;4' rO'ddJ* (E\[J q H' P,"$" 604 0 4(%<(C(90<>7(CC"$"<9" K">6""< >," 7(CC"$"<9"gC"0$ (<7"B 0<7 >," 7(CC"$"<9"g407 (<7"B C#$>," ,(%, >$0(>M0<B(#)4 %$#)D4 ErdN'[ ;4' rH'HJ* (E\[J o N']* 8 q 'ON]' A(<0..-*>,"$" 604 <# 4(%<(C(90<> 7(CC"$"<9" K">6""< >," 7(CC"$"<9"gC"0$ (<7"B 0<7 >,"7(CC"$"<9"g407 (<7"B C#$ .#6 >$0(>M0<B(#)4 %$#)D4 E#['H ;4' rO'dJ* (E\[J q H'

3E=C>==E9B

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o '[\' &44)3(<% >,0> >,(4 (4 >,""BD"9>"7 "CC"9> 4(L" C#$ >," 407 ;"$4)4 <#<407 30<(D).0>(#<* @BD"$(3"<> N ,07 0D#6"$ #C 'Td E#<"M>0(."7J ># 7">"9> 0 4(%<(C(90<>.- 4.#6"$ 8P C#$ 407 >,0< <#<407C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 (< 0<B(#)4 D0$>(9(D0<>4' P,)4* >," $"4).>4 4)%%"4> >,0> 407"BD$"44(#<4 7# <#> ,#.7 >," 0>>"<>(#< #C 0<B(#)4 D"#D." ># >," 403" "B>"<> 04C"0$C). "BD$"44(#<4'

$%2%'+, 3(1W)11(&2

&9$#44 >6# "BD"$(3"<>4* (> ,04 K""< 4,#6< >,0> %-(%"4%4 4D%00 (#7% 604"B,(K(>"7 K- ,(%, >$0(> 0<B(#)4 (<7(;(7)0.4 ># C"0$C).* K)> <#> ># 407* C09(0."BD$"44(#<4' P,"4" $"4).>4* (< 9#<c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

d& N E<"%0>(;" "BD$"44(#<_ A"0$C).* 407J ! N E0<B(">-_ 5(%, 0<7 .#6 >$0(> 0<B(">-J &^+Ve&

E/=Q "<>"$"7 04 0 9#;0$(0>"J 604 90$$("7 #)> 0<7 $";"0."7 0 4(%<(C(90<> &<B(">- %$#)D ! A09(0.

"BD$"44(#< (<>"$09>(#<* ?EH* HNUJ o U'O\* ;@, o UdO'[* 8 q 'ON]'

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !SS

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

07;0<>0%" C#)<7 (< >," ;(4)0. 4"0$9, >041' A)$>,"$3#$"* VW ,30< "> 0.' ENOOH0J,0;" 0.4# C#)<7 >,0> 4>(3).( D#4(<% 0 4D"9(C(9 K(#.#%(90. >,$"0> ># #)$ "0$.-4)$;(;0. E"'%'* 4<01"4* 4D(7"$4J 0$" 7">"9>"7 3#$" $0D(7.- >,0< <#<>,$"0>"<(<%4>(3).(' Q> (4 .(1".- >,0> >," C04>"$ 7">"9>(#< #C 0<%$- 0<7 C"0$C). C09"4* >#%">,"$6(>, >,0> #C #>,"$ K(#.#%(90..- 40.("<> 4>(3).(* 9#<C"$$"7 0 4(%<(C(90<> ";#.)M>(#<0$- 07;0<>0%" #< #)$ "0$.- 0<9"4>#$4 (< 0 ,#4>(."* )<D$"7(9>0K." "<;($#<3"<>'

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d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

P,"$" 0$" 4";"$0. (44)"4 >,0> ,0;" <#> K""< 7($"9>.- 077$"44"7 (< >," 9)$$"<>4>)7- K)> 6,(9, 3"$(> C)$>,"$ (<;"4>(%0>(#<' P," C($4> $".0>"4 ># 6,">,"$ >," 7".0-

!S# $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

(< 0>>"<>(#<0. 7(4"<%0%"3"<> (4 "(>,"$ .#90>(#< #$ #Kc"9> K04"7' ?(<9" 0.. C09(0."BD$"44(#<4 6"$" D$"4"<>"7 9"<>$0..- (< >," 403" .#90>(#< (< >," D$"4"<> 4>)7-*6" 90<<#> (<;"4>(%0>" >,(4 Z)"4>(#<' 5#6";"$* 6,">,"$ 0<B(">-M$".0>"7 7(4"<M%0%"3"<> #99)$4 C$#3 >,$"0>"<(<% #Kc"9>4 #$ C$#3 >," .#90>(#<4 $"9"<>.- #99)MD("7 K- >,$"0> (4 0< (<>"$"4>(<% Z)"4>(#< C#$ C)>)$" $"4"0$9,'

& 4"9#<7 (44)" 9#<9"$<4 >," D#44(K(.(>- >,0> ,(%,.- 0<B(#)4 (<7(;(7)0.4 30-76".. .#<%"$ #< 0<- 0$#)4(<% 4>(3).( E"'%'* 4)$D$(4"7 C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4J 0<7 <#>c)4> 4>(3).( #C 0 >,$"0>"<(<% #$ C"0$C). <0>)$"' F#4> >,$"0>"<(<% 4>(3).( 0$"* #C9#)$4"* 0.4# .(1".- ># K" ,(%,.- 0$#)4(<% 04 (<7""7 0$" 4)$D$(4"7 C09(0."BD$"44(#<4' A)>)$" $"4"0$9,* )>(.(L(<% K#>, >,$"0>M$".0>"7 0<7 4)$D$(4"7 C09(0."BD$"44(#<4* 30- 7">"$3(<" 6,">,"$ (> (4 >," >,$"0>"<(<% #$ >," 0$#)4(<% 04D"9>#C 0 4>(3).)4 >,0> (4 D$(30$(.- $"4D#<4(K." C#$ 7".0-4 (< 7(4"<%0%"3"<>'

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

'%.%'%2W%1

/"91* &' P'* R0$7* +' 5'* F"<7".4#<* F'* F#91* 2'* G @$K0)%,* 2' EHI\HJ' &< (<;"<>#$- C#$

3"04)$(<% 7"D$"44(#<' K&12#$%' *+ A%"%&60 :')12*0*5)* G* ]\Hg]UH'

/-$<"* &'* G @-4"<91* F' R' EHII]J' P$0(> 0<B(">-* 0<B(#)4 3##7* >,$"0> 7">"9>(#<' /*5"#(#*" 6"4

,7*(#*"* L* ][Ig]\N'

+#,"<* 2' ='* F09R,(<<"-* /'* A.0>>* F'* G Y$#;#4>* 2' EHIIdJ' Y4-?9#D"_ & <"6 %$0D,(9 (<>"$09>(;"

"<;($#<3"<> C#$ 7"4(%<(<% D4-9,#.#%- "BD"$(3"<>4' M%26$#*&60 >%'%6&12 ;%(2*4'. N"'(&<7%"('.

6"4 /*78<(%&'* OP* N]UgNUH'

="$$-K"$$-* ='* G 8""7* F' &' EHII[J' P"3D"$03"<> 0<7 0>>"<>(#<_ V$("<>(<% >#60$7 0<7 060- C$#3

D#4(>(;" 0<7 <"%0>(;" 4(%<0.4' Q*<&"60 *+ :%&'*"60#() 6"4 @*1#60 :')12*0*5)* FF* HHNTgHHdI'

="$$-K"$$-* ='* G 8""7* F' &' ENOONJ' &<B(">-M$".0>"7 0>>"<>(#<0. K(04"4 0<7 >,"($ $"%).0>(#< K-

0>>"<>(#<0. 9#<>$#.' Q*<&"60 *+ KI"*&760 :')12*0*5)* RRR* NN]gNd\'

@04>6##7* 2' ='* ?3(."1* ='* G F"$(1."* Y' F' ENOOHJ' =(CC"$"<>(0. 0>>"<>(#<0. %)(70<9" K- )<0>M

>"<7"7 C09"4 "BD$"44(<% D#4(>(;" 0<7 <"%0>(;" "3#>(#<4' :%&1%8(#*" 6"4 :')12*82)'#1'* FS*

HOO[gHOHd'

@130<* Y'* G A$("4"<* R' e' EHIU]J' :#1(<&%' *+ +61#60 6++%1(' Y0.# &.>#* +&_ +#<4).>(<% Y4-M

9,#.#%(4>4 Y$"44'

A#B* @' ENOONJ' Y$#9"44(<% "3#>(#<0. C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4_ P," $#." #C 0<B(">- 0<7 060$"<"44' /*59

"#(#$%. K++%1(#$%. 6"4 M%26$#*&60 T%<&*'1#%"1%* O* ]Ng\d'

A#B* @'* S"4>"$* e'* 8)44#* 8'* /#6."4* 8' 2'* Y(9,."$* &'* G =)>>#<* :' ENOOOJ' A09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 #C

"3#>(#<_ &$" 0<%$- C09"4 7">"9>"7 3#$" "CC(9("<>.-s /*5"#(#*" 6"4 ,7*(#*"* RG* \HgIN'

.%+' %/0'%11(&21 +23 +**%2*(&2 !S4

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13

A#B* @'* 8)44#* 8'* /#6."4* 8' 2'* G =)>>#<* :' ENOOHJ' =# >,$"0>"<(<% 4>(3).( 7$06 #$ ,#.7 ;(4)0.

0>>"<>(#< (< 4)KM9.(<(90. 0<B(">-s Q*<&"60 *+ ,-8%&#7%"(60 :')12*0*5)U A%"%&60* RSV* \THgUOO'

A#B* @'* 8)44#* 8'* G =)>>#<* :' ENOONJ' &>>"<>(#<0. K(04 C#$ >,$"0>_ @;(7"<9" C#$ 7".0-"7 7(4"<M

%0%"3"<> C$#3 "3#>(#<0. C09"4' /*5"#(#*" 6"4 ,7*(#*"* RF* d]]gdUI'

F0>,"64* &' EHIIOJ' R,- 6#$$-s P," 9#%<(>(;" C)<9>(#< #C 0<B(">-' M%26$#*<&60 >%'%6&12 6"4

W2%&68)* OX* []]g[\T'

F#%%* :'* G /$07."-* /' Y' EHIITJ' & 9#%<(>(;"M3#>(;0>(#<0. ;("6 0<0.-4(4 #C 0<B(">-' M%26$#*<&

>%'%6&12 6"4 W2%&68)* SF* TOIgT[T'

F#%%* :'* G /$07."-* /' EHIIIJ' V$("<>(<% #C 0>>"<>(#< ># >,$"0>"<(<% C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 D$"4"<>"7

)<7"$ 9#<7(>(#<4 #C $"4>$(9>"7 060$"<"44' /*5"#(#*" 6"4 ,7*(#*"* RS* UHdgU[O'

VW ,30<* &'* A.-1>* &'* G @4>";"4* A' ENOOH0J' @3#>(#< 7$(;"4 0>>"<>(#<_ =">"9>(<% >," 4<01" (< >,"

%$044' Q*<&"60 *+ ,-8%&#7%"(60 :')12*0*5)U A%"%&60* RSV* [\\g[UT'

VW ,30<* &'* S)<7Z;(4>* ='* G @4>";"4* A' ENOOHKJ' P," C09" (< >," 9$#67 $";(4(>"7_ & >,$"0> 07;0<>0%"

6(>, 49,"30>(9 4>(3).(' Q*<&"60 *+ :%&'*"60#() 6"4 @*1#60 :')12*0*5)* XV* dTHgdI\'

VW ,30<* &'* G F(<"10* ?'F' ENOOHJ' A"0$* D,#K(04* 0<7 D$"D0$"7<"44_ P#60$7 0< ";#.;"7 3#7)." #C

C"0$ 0<7 C"0$ ."0$<(<%' :')12*0*5#160 >%$#%D* RVX* [Tdg]NN'

Y#4<"$* F' Q'* G Y">"$4"<* ?' @' EHIIOJ' P," 0>>"<>(#< 4-4>"3 #C >," ,)30< K$0(<' K""<60 >%$#%D *+

T%<&*'1#%"1%* RS* N]g[N'

?D(".K"$%"$* +' ='* !#$4)9,* 8' S'* S)4,"<"* 8'* e0%%* Y' 8'* G 209#K4* !' &' EHITdJ' ;6"<60 +*& (2%

@(6(%JW&6#( K"-#%() N"$%"(*&)' Y0.# &.>#* +&_ +#<4).>0<> Y4-9,#.#%(4>4 Y$"44'

R,0."<* Y' 2' EHIITJ' A"0$* ;(%(.0<9" 0<7 03K(%)(>-_ Q<(>(0. <")$#(30%(<% 4>)7("4 #C >," ,)30<

03%-70.0' /<&&%"( =#&%1(#*"' #" :')12*0*5#160 @1#%"1%* Y* HUUgHTT'

R,0."<* Y' 2'* ?,(<* S' F'* F9Q<"$<"-* ?' +'* A(49,"$* 5'* R$(%,>* +' Q'* G 80)9,* ?' S' ENOOHJ' &

C)<9>(#<0. F8Q 4>)7- #C ,)30< 03-%70.0 $"4D#<4"4 ># C09(0. "BD$"44(#<4 #C C"0$ ;"$4)4 0<%"$'

,7*(#*"* R* UOgTd'

R(..(034* 2' F' !'* R0>>4* A' ^'* F09S"#7* +'* G F0>,"64* &' EHITTJ' /*5"#(#$% 8')12*0*5) 6"4

%7*(#*"60 4#'*&4%&'' +,(9,"4>"$* f:_ R(."-'

R(..(034* 2' F' !'* R0>>4* A' ^'* F09S"#7* +'* G F0>,"64* &' EHIIUJ' /*5"#(#$% 8')12*0*5) 6"4

%7*(#*"60 4#'*&4%&' EN<7 "7'J' +,(9,"4>"$* f:_ R(."-'

R(.4#<* @'* G F09S"#7* +' ENOOdJ' +#<>$04>(<% >6# 099#)<>4 #C 0<B(">-M.(<1"7 0>>"<>(#<0. K(04_

?"."9>(;" 0>>"<>(#< ># ;0$-(<% .";".4 #C 4>(3).)4 >,$"0> (<>"<4(>-' Q*<&"60 *+ KI"*&760 :')9

12*0*5)* RRO* NHNgNHT'

h("<7* 2'* G F0>,"64* &' ENOOHJ' &<B(">- 0<7 0>>"<>(#< ># >,$"0>"<(<% D(9>)$"4' Z<6&(%&0) Q*<&"60 *+

,-8%&#7%"(60 :')12*0*5)* PGK* \\]g\TH'

!S; $%&'$(&) %* +,-

Dow

nloa

ded

by [t

he B

odle

ian

Libr

arie

s of t

he U

nive

rsity

of O

xfor

d] a

t 10:

11 1

6 Ja

nuar

y 20

13