A&W Decision Making
Transcript of A&W Decision Making
CONTENTS1.0 INTORDUCTION..............................................42.0 SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS.....................................5
2.1 External Environment Analysis..........................52.1.1 Political Factor.....................................5
2.1.2 Economic Factor......................................62.1.3 Environmental Factor.................................6
2.2 TOWS Analysis...........................................72.2.1 Justifications.......................................8
2.3 Market Analysis........................................112.3.1 Market Share........................................11
2.3.2 Potential Market....................................112.3.3 Fast food in Malaysia and Current Trend.............12
2.3.4 Generation Y and Fast Food..........................122.3.5 Generation X and Fast Food..........................12
2.3.6 Population of Generation X and Y in Malaysia........132.4 Competitive Analysis................................14
2.4.1 Marketing Mix of Carl’s Jr.........................142.4.2 Marketing Mix of McDonald..........................15
2.5 Product Life Cycle.....................................172.6 New Product Description................................18
2.6.1 Description of Product...............................183.0 OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES AND PROGRAMS.........................20
3.1 Brand Positioning......................................203.2 Market Segmentation....................................21
3.3 Marketing Objectives...................................223.4 Promotional Tools.....................................24
3.4.1 Advertising........................................24
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
3.4.2 Internet/ Interactive Marketing....................253.4.3 Public Relations...................................25
3.5 Pricing Strategy......................................263.5.1 Cost-plus Pricing....................................26
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
3.5.2 Odd Pricing..........................................26
3.6 Contingency Plans......................................274.0 FINANCIAL PLAN..........................................28
4.1 Gantt Chart..............................................284.1.1 Justifications.......................................28
4.2 Sales Forecast........................................304.2.1 Justifications.......................................30
4.3 Pro Forma Cash Flow 2015...............................324.3.1 Justifications.......................................33
4.4 Break Even Analysis....................................344.5 Return on Investment...................................35
4.6 Decision Tree..........................................364.6.1 Calculation of Expected Value for Both Outlets.......37
4.6.2 Justifications.......................................375.0 CONTROL AND EVALUATION...................................38
6.0 CONCLUSION...............................................397.0 REFERENCES...............................................40
8.0 APPENDICES...............................................43
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This marketing decision making plan outlines situation
analysis, objectives, strategies and tactics for A&W to
provide a consistent, cohesive brand message to introduce
A&W Collagen Burger in Malaysia within next twelve (12)
months. It is anticipated the marketing plan will play a
role a significant role in increasing sales, improving brand
image, changing customer perceptions and attitudes,
retaining current database of customers and attracting new
customers. A series of comprehensive measurement and
evaluation methods will be administered for marketing
implementation to provide valuable insight regarding precise
areas where all the budgets are allocated efficiently and
effectively. The overall goal of the marketing plan is to
improve the sale and increase the market share and A&W is
also planning to open new outlet at Sri Petaling.
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
1.0 INTORDUCTIONIn 1919, A&W was founded by Roy Allens from California,
United States. The A&W franchise was brought into Malaysia
1963 by Mr and Mrs Lie and they opened their first outlet in
Jalan Tunku Abdul Rahman, Kuala Lumpur, making it as the
first fast food outlet in Malaysia. A&W offers menu
featuring hamburgers, hot dogs, onion rings and fries,
distinguished by its draft root beer and root beer floats
(A&W, 2014).
In 2001, A&W was sold to KUB Malaysia Bhd, an investment
holding company (Public Limited Company) operating in a
range of industries, from energy to property, engineering
and construction. KUB followed up with an “aggressive
expansion drive” to widen A&W appeal and increase its sales
(Securities, 2014). According to the newly appointed Chief
Executive Officer (CEO) of A&W Malaysia Mr. Samad Mohd
Shariff, the brand only “turned a corner” in the last two
years after registering losses since 2001, managing to rake
in a profit of about RM1 million in 2013. Currently, KUB was
undertaking a corrective strategy and reviewing performance
of each outlet. As many as twenty-six (26) outlets were shut
down last year (2014) in order to help curb losses, leaving
the current count at twenty-one (21) operating stores
nationwide (Securities, 2014).
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
In the food sector of KUB, A&W records a decline in the
sector’s revenue by 11% as compared to the preceding year
was mainly due to the cessation of its hotel business at the
end of year 2013 (A&W, 2014). Despite the cessation, the
sector was affected by a one-off payment of RM1.33 million
for retrenchment benefits to the staff of KUB Singgahsana
(PJ) Sdn. Bhd, following the Group’s exit from the hotel
business. KUB foresees a potential for A&W to grow further,
hence its intention to increase the market share by opening
another five (5) outlets (A&W, 2014).
A&W corporate vision is to bring people together to share
great food, great root beer and friendly hospitality.
Meanwhile, the company missions are to build a stronger
brand identity and brand awareness level with the support of
advertising and promotion, to constantly improve and
optimizing the resources in existing outlets to better serve
its customers and to reinvent fresh new menus to attract new
market customers.
2.0 SITUATIONAL ANALYSISThis chapter outlines thorough examination of internal and
external factors affecting A&W business. Potential
customers, competitors and a realistic assessment are
presented to lead a better understanding of the factors that
will influence the business.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
2.1 External Environment Analysis Opportunities and threats are measured as part of an
external analysis. In this study, political, economic and
environmental factor are analyzed that may require a change
within the business.
2.1.1 Political Factor
According to Food Act 1983 and Food Regulations 1985, A&W
must ensure all imported and local manufactured food is safe
and hygiene-concerned. Meanwhile, the company should concern
about “hard policies” such as regulations or fiscal policies
(e.g. imposing tax, removal of subsidies), that may be used
to combat obesity in Malaysia (Ibrahim, 2012). This is
because obesity has doubled over the past decade in adult
Malaysian from 21% to 43% (1996-2006), high in adolescent
(19%) and children (16.4%). As Malaysia proceeds rapidly
towards a developed economy status, the health of its
population will probably continue to deteriorate (Charlotte,
Sandeep & Jean, 2001). Therefore, A&W should take note of
this regulation carefully.
In Malaysia, the reception of Halal logistics is very
welcomed as supported by Department of Islamic Development
Malaysia (JAKIM), and is known as Halal certification
(Muhammad et al. 2009). A&W should cover the Halal logistics
and supply chain (Tieman, 2011), training in Halal logistics
(Pahim et al. 2012), Halal transportation (Syazwan et al.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
2014), Halal packaging (Talib & Johan, 2012) and food supply
chain (Manzouri et al. 2013). Besides, special grants are
given to A&W to become Halal-compliant to enjoy double tax
deduction on expenditure for obtaining Halal certification
and accreditation (MII, 2006).
2.1.2 Economic Factor
The Malaysian government has laid out a vision for the
country’s economy. The vision is working to increase the
country’s Gross Domestic Products (GDP) eightfold helping
the country achieve “industrialized country” status by year
2020. The services sector is the largest section in
Malaysian economy, contributing almost 50% of the country’s
GDP. The food industry sector is growing quickly in
importance and now accounts for 40% of GDP (Ibrahim, 2012).
With economic success nationally comes rises in per capita
income. Thus, the consumers demand for high quality food,
but must be provided at affordable prices. More than 60% of
the population is within the middle or upper income group
(Charlotte, Sandeep & Jean, 2001). They are price-sensitive
as well. Almost 45% of women in Malaysia are employed. As
women enter the workforce, they have less time to prepare
family meals and, therefore, rely on convenience food more
often. Consumers between twenty (20) and forty (40) years of
age are most likely to rely on semi-prepared food or take-
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
away meals and can afford to do so (Charlottle, Sandeep &
Jean, 2001). Many consumers are willing to pay for products
that they regard as having high quality and value. A large
proportion of the population is below 15 years of age. This
group is increasingly exposed to global and western
influences and will be a driving force within Malaysia for
higher value products. Therefore, with the economic
opportunity, A&W can take consideration in offering value
and healthy meals to the consumers.
2.1.3 Environmental Factor
Environmental lobbyists and governments are pressuring the
fast-food firms to become more “green”. This initiative is
in tandem with Malaysia Environmental Quality Act 1974 for
environmental protection, conservation and control activity
(Chow et al. 2013). Rainforests are being destroyed to
increase the area of land for beef production to meet the
demand for beef-burgers. Recycling is a prominent global
issue and in response, A&W should adopt recyclable packaging
(Chow et al. 2013). This is because increasing environmental
awareness among consumers provides the company with a
significant opportunity to position them as “green” to a
garner customer loyalty.
2.2 TOWS AnalysisStrengths Weaknesses
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
TOWS
1. Strong corporateorange color imagein consumers’ mind
1. Not advertiseextensively inMalaysia
2. Strong supportfrom parent brand
2. Outdated websiteand social network
3. First drive-inrestaurant andentered The MalaysiaBook of Records
3. Inconsistentservice and foodquality
4. Commitment toproviding healthymenu items
Opportunities SO Strategies WO Strategies1.Growing healthtrends amongconsumers
S1O1: Penetrate intohealthy menu choices
W1O1: Introducehealthy lunch mealto target consumers
2. Growth of organicfood ingredients
S2O2: Combination ofamino collagen withhigh antioxidantsand food
3. Technologicaladvances forordering food
S3O3: Innovationssuch as apps andonline orderingsystems for ease ofacquiring food
W2O3: Highvisibility inFacebook and Twitterand create a websitefor online ordering
4. Diversificationof food concepts
S4O4: Shifts towardsnatural and beautyconcept
W3O4: The company isinexperienced indifferent foodconcepts and wouldneed to develop asound plan beforestarting a newconcept
Threats ST Strategies WT Strategies1.Perspective on“Rising food prices”due to GSTimplementation
S1T1: Increaseawareness of GST
W1T1: Expandingoperations andpromotions createsthe need for moresales
2.Ease of entry intothe market
W2T2: Intensiveresearch and
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
development (R&D)and market research
3.Impact of economicdownturn fromrecovering economy4. Change inconsumer tastes andpreferences
S1T4: Maintaincustomer loyaltywould increase sales
Table 1.0: TOWS Analysis
2.2.1 Justifications
A&W product’s image is the Great Root Bear with orange color
stated in consumer’s mind. With the strong support from
parent brand, Dr. Pepper Snapple Group, an American soft
drink company, and the entering Malaysia Book of Records, it
is believed that A&W can penetrate into healthy menu choices
by offering organic food to consumers.
SO Strategies
Over the past decade notions of beauty have been undergoing
significant transformation in Malaysia. Fair skin is also
idolized and equated with notions of beauty (Charlotte,
Sandeep & Jean, 2001). Since there is a demand from health
and beauty trend, the company can penetrate into wider food
industry, with a segment catering to the healthy food market
and, within this, a segment catering to the healthy fast
food market, developing meals that are easily accessible
(quick purchase), delicious and not harmful to health. One
of the primary proteins in our body that play role in
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
growth, health and maintenance is collagen. From age twenty-
five (25) onwards, the levels of amino acids used to
collagen and elastic fibers are reduced substantially; while
at the age of forty (40), our body stop produce collagen and
lead to formation of wrinkles, skin sagging, dryness and
skin aging problems (Mohamed et al. 2013). Therefore, with
the strong support from parent brand and growing of health
trends, A&W can shift towards and diverse in offering
healthy food to consumers.
WO Strategies
However, A&W is inexperienced in different food concepts as
it is a fast-food based restaurant. Studies showed that “90
percent of restaurants fail during the first year of
operation” that first stage is the most vulnerable (Parsa,
John & David, 2005). One reason for early failure is that
new segment businesses typically have limited resources that
would allow them to be flexible or adapt to changing
conditions. On the other hand, there is a fine line between
having a fresh perspective and being blinded by
inexperience. By offering lunch meal with collagen-
ingredients to the target customers that allows online
ordering and increase visibility on Facebook and Twitter for
promotion and enhance two-way communication with consumers,
it will help to improve business and expand market share.
One of the reasons of moving online is because the mass
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
media repeatedly emphasize the theme that people are busy
and are looking for ways to save time. Internet ordering is
profiled as a potential time saver, because consumers can
order any time, any place and dressed any way (Chow et al.
2013). Plus, social media tools like Facebook and Twitter
bring advantages of “flatter”, more democratic and
presumably more effective communication networks for
building long-term relationships with consumers.
ST Strategies
A&W may face the threats of consumers’ perception on “rising
of food prices” that will eventually cut costs on spending
after implementation of Goods and Service Tax (GST). To
consumers, this may represent an effect to the aggregate
prices of everyday goods and services. While most consumers
do not directly see the current 10% sales tax, many of them
experience the 6% service tax (Poskod Malaysia, 2014).
Therefore, A&W needs to educate the consumers about GST.
Figure 1.0 shows the effects of service tax abolished and 6%
GST.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Figure 1.0: Differences between Service Tax and GST
Source: Poskod Malaysia (2014)
Another threat may faced by A&W is changing of consumer
taste and preference. From the marketing perspectives, this
is a great signal because consumers demand on food quality
and choices in terms of value approaches, economics of
information approaches and satisfaction or dissatisfaction
approaches. Therefore, A&W can introduce various types of
loyalty programs such as membership cards, vouchers and
premiums to rewards the loyal customers. Once the loyal
customers get appreciated, they are easily to become
delighted customers (Chow et al. 2013). This is supported by
the previous studies that customer satisfaction influences
purchase intentions as well as post-purchase attitude.
Referrals program can be initiated to invite the loyal
customers to be part of the company by inviting their
friends and relatives to be the stakeholder. This will
increase the company sales as well as broadening market
share.
WT Strategies
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
To targeting more customers and to decrease barriers of
market entering, A&W should conduct extensive research and
development (R&D) and implement market research to
understand needs and wants of consumers. Meanwhile, consumer
behavior towards healthy fast-food can be examined to
determine their likeability and popularity (Mohammad, 2005).
In the era of globalization, a comprehensive market search
plays a significant role in order to achieve organizational
goals. Prior to that, A&W can target their customers more
precisely, for example, researchers have found that eating
out is becoming a trend especially for people who busy and
going through the hectic working life. Moreover, Mohamed et
al (2013) posited that saving time and eating healthy in
better environments are the reasons of people to dine-out.
These findings can help the marketers to segment their
market well and target the customers correctly.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
2.3 Market AnalysisThe goal of market analysis is to determine the
attractiveness of a market and to understand its evolving
opportunities and threats as they relate to the strength and
weaknesses of the firm.
2.3.1 Market Share
Total Revenue (In Terms of Percentage)
McDonaldCarls. JrA&WOthers
Figure 2.0: Difference of Total Revenue
Source: Ibrahim (2012)
From the pie chart, it is identified that McDonald has the
highest total revenue of 2 billion (38%) in Malaysia,
followed by other companies which dominated around 1.8
billion (33%) in Malaysia, then followed by Carls. Jr has
14.3million of total revenue (26%) in Malaysia and A&W has
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
1.5million of total revenue (3%) in Malaysia.
2.3.2 Potential MarketThe total population in Malaysia is at 30.07million people
(Indexmundi, 2013). As of 2013, Damansara claimed 613,977
residents living in the area of 51.4km per square fit
whereas Sri Petaling claimed 120,980 residents living in the
area of 20.9km per square fit (Indexmundi, 2013). Their
population is made up of 55% Chinese, 30% Malays and 13%
Indians. The transportation facilities and infrastructure
are well-developed in Sri Petaling and Damansara that
provides convenience to the residents and the business
around.
2.3.3 Fast food in Malaysia and Current TrendLooking at the trend of focusing on the healthy fast food in
United States sue to the consumer awareness on the
importance of healthy food, the fast food restaurants in
Malaysia must considerably change their current marketing
practices and focus on quality or healthy food, so that
consumers will not receive continuous encouragement to seek
out food that can damage their health (Harris, Schwartz &
Brownell, 2010). Also, healthy fast food products are
predicted to receive a higher demand from the consumers due
to the rapid increase in lifestyle diseases, the increase in
awareness towards overweight issues and change in eating
habits among consumers. According to Euromonitor (2010),
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Malaysians who are more health conscious started to switch
their food from unhealthy food to a healthier food options.
2.3.4 Generation Y and Fast FoodGeneration Y is a prime target for a food service business.
Generation Y refers to the members of the generation of
people born since the early 1980s to 2000. Generation Y are
who seen as being discerning consumers with a high
disposable income (ThreFreeDictionary, 2011). Harris et al.
(2010) reported that majority of fast food advertising is
targeted to Generation Y. In addition, past research from
the NPD Group (2009) shows that Generation Y orders more
fast food than any other age group during non-meal times,
after school and in the evening or midnight. The marketers
for fast food industry are targeting the Generation Y as
their main customers.
2.3.5 Generation X and Fast Food
The Generation X, which propelled fast food restaurants in
the 60’s and 70’s are now reaching its peak income levels
(myStarjob, 2013). It has considerably discretionary income
to spend on pleasure and leisure. The boomers view food
service dining as a form of recreation and take much of
pleasure in trying new restaurants and fresh menu ideas.
Moreover, they place a high emphasis on “food
sophistication” with greater attention to portion size and
variety. As one ages, taste buds tend to become less
sensitive, so aging generations are demanding bolder/ higher
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
impact flavors. A greater importance is also placed on
healthy diet options as the Generation X fight the realities
of health problems that come with age (myStarjob, 2013).
2.3.6 Population of Generation X and Y in Malaysia
Figure 3.0: Population in Malaysia
Source: myStarjob (2013)
Figure 2.0 shows the population in Malaysia. It shows that
the majority of Malaysian age group is from fifteen (15) up
to fifty-nine (59) years old. Therefore, with the evidence,
Generation X and Y are the ideal target group of consumers
for A&W.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
2.4 Competitive AnalysisThe purpose of competitor analysis is to obtain information
about important competitors and use the information to
predict competitor behavior. In this study, Carl’s Jr. and
McDonald are chosen as A&W competitors.
2.4.1 Marketing Mix of Carl’s Jr.
Product
Carl’s Jr. new core product, the Lot Burger, has a wide
gamut of benefits. The most distinctive feature of most
company’s products is quality. The new burger consists of
only healthy and natural ingredients, fresh lettuce leaves,
beetroots slices, tomatoes and onions, a slice of cheese,
bacon rashers and an egg. All of these attract people who
are concerned about healthy. Furthermore, nutrition value of
burger constitutes very large amount and a lot of energy.
This feature makes a sense giving a serious comparative
advantage in the fast-food chain market (Carlsjr, 2015).
Promotion
Carl’s Jr. uses famous sportsmen to influence target
audience who are concerned about the amount of a nutrition
value found in the Lot Burger. The slogan for the whole
advertising campaign is “It’s new. It’s bigger. And it’s
more delicious than ever before” (Carlsjr, 2015). In
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
addition, new burger is advertised using billboard at major
roads that by far attention to create comparative advantage.
People’s testimonials, especially from satisfied customers,
are included in press releases to promote the company.
Price
Carl’s Jr. looks at other niche where consumers would be
prepared to accept a higher price because people feel that
the company understand their needs better and what they
want. Thereby, the company follows the quality leadership
pricing strategy-placed price conveys the product quality to
the consumers. Prices for the regular, kid’s and combo will
use the product line and optional pricing strategy
corresponding to the quality leadership strategy (Carlsjr,
2015).
Place
Carl’s Jr. enters Malaysian market with seven (7) outlets
nationwide, and nowadays expended it to fifteen (15). All of
them are located at the biggest shopping malls due to the
trend of all Malaysian loves to shops in malls, allowing
them to enjoy shopping together with delicious food without
going to another place (Carlsjr, 2015).
2.4.2 Marketing Mix of McDonaldProduct
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
According to McDonalds (2015), the crucial thing to note
when offering menu items to potential customers is that
there is a huge amount of choice available to those
potential customers with regard to how and where they spend
their money. Therefore, McDonald’s places considerable
emphasis on developing a menu which customers want. There
are many situations where McDonald adapted the product
because of religious laws and customs in a country, for
example, McDonald’s restaurant in Malaysia offers bubur ayam
(chicken porridge) and Double Beef Prosperity burger whereas
McDonald’s restaurants in India serve Vegetable McNuggets
and a mutton-based Maharaja Mac (Big Mac). Such innovations
are necessary in a country where Hindus do not eat beef.
However, the structure of McDonald’s menu remains
essentially uniforms the world over: main course burger,
fries and a drink (McDonalds, 2015).
Promotion
Using these tools, McDonald looks to localize its marketing
communications strategy that includes newspapers, television
and magazine. The “I’m lovin’ it” campaign, launched in 2003
used celebrity endorsement to increase their appeal to
younger consumers in Malaysia. Justin Timberlake was used
for vocals and the campaign was launched in eighty-six (86)
in English-speaking countries. In addition, McDonald does
adopt global strategy that alliance with Walt Disney in
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
producing “happy meals” for films such as A Bug’s Life, Toy Story
and Tarzan (McDonalds, 2015). The company also enhances its
brand name with Olympic Games and the World Cup, the two
biggest sporting events in the global calendar. Due to the
promotional activities, McDonald achieved 6th position on
“Best Global Brands 2011” as a result of continuous
promotional activities.
Price
McDonald has come up with different pricing strategies for
different countries and has positioned itself as fast food
restaurants offering low-cost food and drink. The affordable
menu has been adapted worldwide while maintaining their core
goal of assurance. Ongoing innovation has allowed new
pricing strategies such as the “Saver Menu” that offers
value breakfast, lunch and dinner that is affordable by the
consumers. In response to increasing food costs, McDonald
opted to increase prices by less than 1% adopting the change
gradually to the menu in order to retain price-sensitive
customers (McDonalds, 2015).
Place
McDonald currently has over 24,500 restaurants in 116
countries across the world. McDonald realize the potential
for growth in international markets and plans to benefit
from the lessons that they learnt in the USA, for example,
they used to add 300-400 restaurants a year, every year in
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
Introduction Growth Maturity Decline
Sale
s
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Malaysia regardless circumstances. It was a strategy that
created a gap between them and the rivals (McDonalds, 2015).
2.5 Product Life Cycle
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
Carls.Jr
McDonald A&W
13
4
25
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Figure 4.0: Product Life Cycle
Source: self-made
From the graph, it is identified that Carls. Jr is in the
growth stage whereas McDonald is in the maturity stage. For
A&W, it falls under decline stage because A&W PJ Drive Thru
has been revamped and will only be shut for the next three
years till 2016 to facilitate the construction of the KUB
Tower project. Due to the increasing of competitors and lack
of advertising, A&W is losing its popularity against others.
Due to the lost profit, A&W is closing down their outlets
and replaced them in suitable venue.
To make the brand stand out from the competitors, A&W would
wish to reposition back their brand in the market. And to
give confidence to the consumers, A&W Malaysia also planning
to open two (2) new outlets to be located at Sri Petaling or
Damansara July 2015. This will provide alternative solutions
to the consumers in the fast food choices.
2.6 New Product DescriptionThe new product of A&W is illustrated as follows:
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
5
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Figure 5.0: Breakdown parts of new product
Source: self-made
2.6.1 Description of Product
No.
Breakdown Parts Explanation
1 Health-boosting PurpleTomatoes
A team from the John Centrein Norwich, United Kingdomhas engineered tomatoesusing genes from thesnapdragon flower to give anextra helping of pigmentscalled anthocyanins. Thesehave an anti-inflammatoryeffect in the body. Intests, the tomatoes slowedthe progression of soft-tissue carcinoma in cancer-prone mice (BBC, 2014).
2 Cultured Beef Muscle stem cells fromcattle have been cultured ina nutrient broth byresearchers at MaastrichtUniversity in Netherlands,and then mixed with collagenso they formed strips of
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
muscle tissue- the maincomponent of meat (BBC,2014).
3 Diabetes-treating Lettuce Dr. Henry Daniell, amolecular biologist at theUniversity of Pennsylvania,works on delivering drugsusing plants. He has createdlettuces geneticallyengineered to express aprotein that stimulates thepancreas to produce insulin(BBC, 2014).
4 Allergy-free Milk Milk allergies are oftencaused by a protein calledbeta-lactoglobulin (BLG),which is not present inhuman milk. A New Zealandteam has used geneticengineering to create a cowthat produces BLG-free milk(BBC, 2014).
5 Reinforced Bread In 2012, scientists from theUK, Germany and the USdeciphered wheat’s complexgenetic code, identify about96,000 genes. The work pavesthe way to breeding wheatvarieties with higheryields, more diseaseresistance and increasedability to cope with droughtand other climate-relatedstressed (BBC, 2014).
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
3.0 OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES AND PROGRAMSThis chapter will outline key objectives, target market,
positioning strategy, promotional tools and pricing strategy
that will be implemented by A&W Malaysia.
3.1 Brand Positioning Positioning Statement 1: Collagen Burger helps maintain and
promote health.
Unique Selling Point 1: The increase in non-communicable
chronic disease, stress in the workplace, lack of time and
other consequences of our everyday rapid pace of life will
force individuals to eat healthier food more regularly in
order to reduce negative effects of this fast-paced life of
their health. If we eat a balanced diet, our cells will beAsia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
properly fed and protected, which enable them to have
effective immune systems.
Positioning Statement 2: Collagen Burger is both health and
tasty for consumers.
Unique Selling Point 2: Many people think that burger is
not healthy, but this is not true. We choose from among many
high quality and fresh ingredients to make up a burger. To
ensure the original taste of the burger, we serve our
burgers within ten (10) minutes or otherwise free of charge.
Positioning Statement 3: Collagen Burger is crucial for
combating aging issues.
Unique Selling Point 3: An imbalanced diet can lead to
problems with old people. A wholesome balanced diet over a
long period provides better and healthier lifestyle.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
3.2 Market SegmentationIn fact, base on the market analysis above, A&W market
segmentation can be summarized by using demographic and
behavioral factors.
DemographicFactors
Criteria Explanation
Age Group 15-59 years old Majority ofMalaysians are GenX and Y.
Family Size 1-2, 3-4, 5+ A&W is suitablefor family unionand gathering.
Race Malays, Chinese andIndians
Malaysia is amulti-culturalnation.
Occupation Students, officeworkers, employed
people
They are thetarget group thatrequires healthymeals every day.
Income <RM1000 –RM4,000 andabove
The consumers canafford theproducts offeredby A&W
BehavioralFactors
Criteria Explanation
Benefits Quality products andservice
A&W will providehealthy productsto those lookingfor qualityproducts andservice.
Loyalty Status Medium and strong A&W targets allconsumers that areinterested to trythe new menuoffered.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Readiness Stage Unaware and aware A&W will utilizepromotional toolsto advertise thenew productoffered.
Table 2.0: Market Segmentation of A&W
Source: self-made
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
3.3 Marketing ObjectivesThe objective of this marketing plan is to recommend a
business proposition which is measurable and attainable by
firstly identifying A&W goals. The objective of the
marketing plan is to introduce a new product, Collagen
Burger in April 2016 by developing marketing strategies and
plan.
Objective 1: To create brand awareness of A&W Collagen
Burger to the consumers.
Goal 1: Obtain 15,000 “first-time” visitors to A&W outlet within six months of implementation.
Tactic: Implement new mobile app in webpage that allows
customer to interact with A&W “The Great Root Bear” in
order to create viral marketing.
Tactic: Offer special promotions such as vouchers and
free gifts in the outlets for customers who upload
their photos with A&W “The Great Root Bear” on the
spot.
Implement new “A&W Way”, a shuttle program designed for
customers from a Kuala Lumpur area to A&W outlet in Sri
Petaling or Damansara .
This goal is meant to reach potential customers without
means or desire to travel to A&W outlet. If a customer is
made aware of the product line, they may be more willing to
visit A&W outlet and try out the new product, Collagen
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Burger. This is one of the buss marketing strategies for A&W
in the outlet.
Objective 2: To achieve sales target of $2,000,000 for the
first year.
Goal 2: Achieve a ten percent referral-rate with newly
acquired customers.
Tactic: Refresh the A&W website Facebook page to
integrate friendlier and humanistic customer service to
customers who “like” the page and reward those invite
their friends to like the page; The rewards can in the
form of giving free tissue wallet on their next
purchase; increase number of “likes” by 20,000 within
one year.
Goal 2 targets families and individuals by making them feel
special and desired. Gaining trust through the customers
will strengthen the relationships, potentially turning the
referrals into customers and then increase total sales of
the company.
Objective 3: To achieve estimated 20% market share next 12
months.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Goal 3: Increase company reputation by utilizing positive
media mentions nationwide by ten percent with a 12 month
period.
Tactic: Create and disseminate press release on The Sun
newspapers (the highest circulated English newspaper,
with a daily circulation of 305,000 copies), focusing
on positive accomplishments and activities that evoke
good publicity nationwide.
This goal aims to enhance public image of A&W. A press
release can effectively help change and build the public
image of the company. Plus, well-written and distributed
press releases can help to communicate a positive brand
image, improve customer perceptions, enlarge economy of
scale and increase bargaining power of the company
(Westwood, 2011).
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
3.4 Promotional ToolsAdvertising, Internet marketing and public relations are
selected as promotional tools for marketing strategy.
3.4.1 Advertising
A&W Malaysia will use two means of advertising: print
advertising and television commercial advertising.
Advertising has not been utilized aggressively by A&W
whereby the products and services can have their own
advertisement, be it print or electronic media, for example,
A&W has its own print advertisement carrying tagline “More
Than The Usual”. The criteria and reasons of selecting the
print advertising and TV advertising are as follows:
Tools Reasons of
Selection
Criteria of Selection
Advertising
(Newspaper)
(Monday-
Friday
because this
is the
working days
for the
target
audience)
It covers high
degree of market
coverage and
penetration, it is
flexible in terms
of producing and
running the ads
and it is
geographic
selective.
The Sun newspaper is
chosen because it is cheap
and the highest circulated
English newspaper, with a
daily circulation of
305,000 copies. The ads
will be published in first
double page of the
newspaper because those
are the captions that will
attract reader’s attention
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
(SheeHan, 2011). Refer to
appendix for price per
insertion.
TV
Advertising
(Television)
(8pm-10pm
because this
is the time
most of the
family will
watch TV
together)
It has wider
coverage, cost
effective, creates
attention and
creativity to
present
advertising
messages.
TV3 is chosen because it
has the highest number of
19,000,000 page views,
contains 383,000 unique
users and the age group
covers below 18 (11%), 18-
24 (40%), 25-34 (30%) and
above 35 (19%). TV3
trading terms is 30
seconds ads will charge
for RM1000 (SheeHan,
2011).
3.4.2 Internet/ Interactive MarketingInternet Marketing, on the other hand will be focused on
Facebook and Twitter on creating viral marketing by using
rationale and emotional appeal on A&W and at the same time
creates two-way communication between consumers and company.
It is suggested that A&W Malaysia can launch “Pimp My A&W”
contest together with the universities and residents around
Sri Petaling or Damansara. The contest requires the
competing schools and the participants to take photo with
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
the scene in A&W outlet. They can “groupie” their moment
with “The Great Root Bear” and Collagen Burger and the
ambiance in the outlet and then upload the photos into
Facebook and Twitter. The photo with the most “likes” wins.
This will enhance the creativity among university students
and residents and at the same time promotes A&W stores and
Collagen Burger is certainly a great option of healthy meal
for young and discerning teenagers and residents.
3.4.3 Public RelationsThe objective is critical to introduce Collagen Burger to
prospective consumers. The plan for the convention is to
invite people who cannot make it to A&W outlet by fetching
them along the way to the outlet in Sri Petaling or
Damansara. The efforts including sending emails to the
consumers informing them about the conference and media
alerts to local media outlets informing them of the
conference. The conference will feature seminars on:
1. Who A&W is
2. Why A&W outlet exists
3. What is next for A&W Malaysia
4. Green-initiatives for A&W Malaysia
TV3 and The Sun media will be invited to the conference for
A&W Malaysia. The advertising time for TV3 is 8pm to 10pm
because those are the time that most of the families will
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
spend their time watching TV and family activities (SheeHan,
2011). Therefore, A&W can spread the new product launching
news for the targeting family.
It is hope that A&W is able to gain large number of new
customers and generates positive media reports on A&W PJ and
Collagen Burger.
3.5 Pricing StrategyPricing is an important strategic issue because it is
related to product positioning. Further, pricing affects
other marketing mix elements such as product features,
channel decisions and promotion (SheeHan, 2011).
3.5.1 Cost-plus Pricing
The company can set the price at the production cost,
including both cost of goods and fixed costs at the current
volume, plus a certain profit margin (Belch & Belch, 2001).
In A&W, the product and service cost $6.80 in variable costs
(raw materials) and production costs, and at the current
sales volume the fixed costs come to $1.50 per unit. The
total costs are $8.28 per unit. The company decides that
they want to achieve at a 25% profit margin. Therefore, the
targeted price should be ($8.30/1-25%) which is $11.00.
Below shows the calculation of variable and fixed cost per
unit.
Variable cost per unit = $1,412,100/ 212,000 units
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
= $6.80 per unit
*variable cost is derived from utilities, raw material, transportation, salary,
packaging, advertising and promotion and conference
Fixed cost per unit = $312,000/ 212,000 units
= $1.50 per unit
*fixed cost is derived from total cost of equipment and insurance and rental fees
Therefore, Total cost per unit = $6.80+$1.50=$8.30 per unit
3.5.2 Odd Pricing
The company can use the technique known as odd pricing that
prices end in odd number (5,7,9) because the studies shows
that selling for $10.95 appears cheaper than the same item
priced at $11.00. Psychological techniques such as odd
pricing can be used to certain customers’ interests (Belch &
Belch, 2001).
3.6 Contingency PlansWhile carefully planning was involved in setting the
strategic goals for A&W, it may be that these goals are not
met. Therefore, for both sales and financial objectives, a
10% negative deviation from expected sales and projection
returns on assets will be accepted. However, if sales
objectives and return on investment are less than 90% of
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
projections, certain actions will be taken. These actions
include:
No. Problems Solution1 Unacceptable Sales
Levels during the
First Year
A&W will combat this problem by
doubling in-store promotions in the
outlet. A&W will arrange and carry
out these promotions on weekends at
peak hours and distribute vouchers
in the shopping complex at peak
shopping times (Westwood, 2011). If
sales do not increase within one
month of the in-store promotions,
A&W will advertise in the weekly
shopping circulars of the store for
one month.
2 Unacceptable Return
on Equity
In the event that the business lacks
liquidity, A&W will examine the
accounts receivable procedures and
to ensure that cash flow projections
is reviewed to determine if
unforeseen cash expenses are
undermining the financial health of
the company (Westwood, 2011). 3 Unacceptable Return If return on assets and owners’Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
on Equity equity fall below acceptable levels,
A&W will first examine and compare
the cost of production per unit and
marketing with sales prices. If the
margins are too thin, a price
increase for new product will be
considered (Westwood, 2011).
4.0 FINANCIAL PLANThis chapter will outline financial plan as an estimation of
cash needs and decision on how to raise the cash. Sales
forecast, pro forma cash flow, breakeven analysis and return
on investment are presented for A&W.
4.1 Gantt Chart
MonthFeb-15
Mar-15
Apr-15
May-15
Jun-15
Jul-15
Aug-15
Sep-15
Oct-15
Nov-15
Dec-15
Jan-16
The Sun (Mon-Fri) TV3 (8pm-10pm) Facebook, Twitter "Pimp My A&W" Contest Press Conference
Figure 1.0: Gantt Chart of A&W
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.1.1 Justifications
Promotional Tools ReasonsThe Sun and TV3 Base on the chart above, A&W will apply pulsing
method on advertising for both the Sun and TV3. The
reasons are because on February and March, there is
Chinese New Year festival and holidays for the
students; on June and July, there are another
holidays and Hari Raya celebration for the
Malaysians; and on November, December and January,
there are school holidays, Christmas and New Year
festivals for the Malaysians too (SheeHan, 2011).
Therefore, by looking at the opportunities, A&W can
apply heavy advertising during peak selling periods
to stimulate bulk purchase from the consumers. On
top of that, it is analyzed that during the periods
it may bring more profits to the company because of
the demand from consumers.
Facebook, Twitter In addition, A&W will apply continuous scheduling
towards Facebook and Twitter page. This is because
these social media are very cheap, plus it is used
as a “trendy” tool that continuously reinforcement
and penetration into young consumers mind
recollection at point of purchase. By keep updating
and responding to the web user’s comments and
feedbacks, it is believed that A&W can achieve
effective two-way communication between company and
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
consumers (SheeHan, 2011). However, since A&W open
its sources for sharing contents, the company
should prepare to respond for the “bad comments”
that may affect reputation of the company.
"Pimp My A&W"Contest
Furthermore, A&W will organize “Pimp My A&W”
contest in continuous style. It is divided into two
parts, where the first contest will be organized on
half-yearly basis. The purpose of organizing the
event is to follow the trend and encourage young
consumers to take picture about their moments
dining in A&W restaurant in Sri Petaling or
Damansara. Hence, it is predicted that the efforts
may bring extra profits to the company because it
stimulate consumer behavior of trying new products
and stand a chance to win the contest (SheeHan,
2011).
Press Conference Besides that, A&W will be having press conference
in a flighting style during April-May and August-
September. The reason of choosing those four months
is because there are few festivals, activities or
events ongoing for the particular months. Hence,
the press conference will play a role to achieve
economic of scale and set as a reminder and most
importantly, create a viral messages in Malaysia
that A&W is the first company that offers free ride
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
to the customers to the conference (SheeHan, 2011).
Please refer to appendix for table of holidays in
Malaysia.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.2 Sales Forecast
MonthFeb-15
Mar-15
Apr-15
May-15
Jun-15
Jul-15
Aug-15
Sep-15
Oct-15
Nov-15
Dec-15
Jan-16
Sales (cash)109,5
00164,2
50197,1
00197,1
00164,2
50219,0
00164,2
50197,1
00197,1
00219,0
00273,7
50219,0
00Sales (units)@$10.95/unit
10,000
15,000
18,000
18,000
15,000
20,000
15,000
18,000
18,000
20,000
25,000
20,000
Total sales: $2,321,400 Total units: 212,000 units
4.2.1 JustificationsMonths Results ReasonsFebruary
2015
Sales is predicted as 10,000 units of
getting $109,500
A&W Collagen Burger is at the beginning
stage to be introduced to the consumers.
March 2015 Sales unit increased to 15,000 of getting
$164,250
The result is due to the effort of
promoting and advertising through print
advertising, social media and the
contest.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
April-May
2015
Sales are predicted to be increased and
constant at 18,000 units and getting
profit of $197,100
The result is due to the effect of
advertising program that increase
awareness of the new product among the
people.June-July
2015
Sales are predicted to be dropped at
15,000 units for June while the sales
will be doubled on July.
The result is due to June is the fasting
month for the Malays, even though there
are holidays and promotion is done. On
the other hand, sales is predicted to be
doubled on July because Malays will
celebrate Hari Raya and this is the best
time to create awareness to the audience
to maintain their healthy lifestyle that
A&W Collagen Burger is their best choice
during Hari Raya celebration.
August-
October 2015
Sales are predicted to increase for the
next three months and getting average
profit of $190,000
The result is because of the effect of
the advertising and conference setting
by the company.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
November-
December
2015
Sales are predicted to goes up to 20,000
and 25,000 units, breaking records of the
year.
The result is because there are holidays
starting for the month and the children
will accompany their parents to the
fast-food restaurant and Christmas
festival will attract the consumers to
visit the store as result from promotion
efforts.
January 2016 Sales are predicted to drop to 20,000
units
This is because most of the families
will save their money for the purpose of
coming Chinese New Year and planning for
other stuffs like investment, insurance,
properties and so forth.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.3 Pro Forma Cash Flow 2015
MonthFeb-15
Mar-15
Apr-15
May-15
Jun-15
Jul-15
Aug-15
Sep-15
Oct-15
Nov-15
Dec-15
Jan-16
Item Cash Inflow Balance Bring Forward
90,500
106,750
180,450
257,150
273,400
315,400
376,650
453,350
535,050
576,050
644,300
Sales109,5
00164,2
50197,1
00197,1
00164,2
50219,0
00164,2
50197,1
00197,1
00219,0
00273,7
50219,0
00
Shareholder Fund100,0
00
Total Cash209,5
00254,7
50303,8
50377,5
50421,4
00492,4
00479,6
50573,7
50650,4
50754,0
50849,8
00863,3
00 Cash Outflow Fixed Cost Equipment & Insurance
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
20,000
Rental 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 Variable Cost Utilities 1,000 2,000 2,400 2,400 2,000 3,000 2,000 2,400 2,400 3,000 3,500 3,000
Raw Material20,00
040,00
052,00
052,00
040,00
060,00
040,00
052,00
052,00
060,00
080,00
060,00
0
Transportation 5,000 6,000 7,000 7,000 6,000 8,000 6,000 7,000 7,000 8,000 9,00010,00
0
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Salary10,00
012,00
013,00
013,00
012,00
013,00
012,00
013,00
013,00
014,00
015,00
014,00
0
Packaging10,00
015,00
018,00
018,00
015,00
020,00
015,00
018,00
018,00
020,00
025,00
020,00
0Advertising & Promotion
50,000
50,000
50,000
50,000
50,000
50,000
Conference 8,000 5,000 5,000 5,000
Total Cost119,0
00148,0
00123,4
00120,4
00148,0
00177,0
00103,0
00120,4
00115,4
00178,0
00205,5
00130,0
00
Gross Profit90,50
0106,7
50180,4
50257,1
50273,4
00315,4
00376,6
50453,3
50535,0
50576,0
50644,3
00733,3
00
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.3.1 Justifications
A&W will seek funds from shareholders to gain the initial
capital for the first month. As the sales increases
indicates that the cost of production also increases.
Equipment and insurance will be fixed at $20,000 while
rental is $3,000 per month. Utilities and transportation
cost is proportional with the sales of the month. For the
first month, A&W will employ ten (10) full time workers. On
the second month, two workers will be added in. Part time
workers will also be recruited during peak festivals and
seasons. All the funds will be managed efficiently and make
sure all resources are not wasted.
Figure 6.0: Gross Profit of A&W
Source: self-made
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
months
$
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 120
100,000200,000300,000400,000500,000600,000700,000800,000
Gross Profit
Gross Profit
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
As interpreted from the graph, it can be seen that the gross
profit will increase gradually for the next twelve months.
4.4 Break Even AnalysisSales: 212,000 units at $10.95/unit $2,321,400
Shareholder Fund: $100,000
Gross Margin: $2,421,400
Less: Fixed Production Cost $312,000 Variable Production Cost $1,412,100
Net Income Before Taxes: $597,300
The firm’s breakeven output is calculated by using the
formula:
Break even (unit) = Total Fixed Cost / {(Selling Price/unit)-(Variable
Cost/unit)}
= $312,000 / {($10.95)-($6.80)}
= $312,000 / $4.15
= 75,180 units
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Sales in dollar that required to break-even is calculated by
using the formula:
Break even (sales) = Break even (unit) X Selling price (unit)
= 75,180 units X $10.95
= $823,221
If the variable production costs increase by $2 per unit,
the new break even output will be following the formula:
Break even (unit) = Total Fixed Cost / {(Selling Price/unit)-(Variable
Cost/unit)}
= $312,000 / {($10.95)-($6.80)}
= $312,000 / $4.15
= 75,180 units
Assuming demand for the A&W Collagen Burger is 100,000
units, the margin of safety is calculated by following the
formula:
Margin of safety = {Demand-Break even (unit)}/ {Break even (unit)} X 100%
= {100,000-75,180}/ {75,180} X 100%
= 0.33 X 100%
= 33%
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
To earn a profit of $40,000, the break even in terms of target is
calculated by using the formula:
Break even (target) = {Total Fixed Cost+Targeted profit}/{(Selling Price/unit)-
(Variable
Cost/unit)}
= {$312,000+$40,000}/ {($10.95)-($6.80)}
= {$352,000}/ {$4.15}
= 84,819 units
4.5 Return on Investment Return on investment (ROI) for A&W Collagen Burger is
calculated base on the formula:
ROI = {Gain-Cost}/ {Cost}X 100%
= {$2,321,400-$1,688,100}/ {$1,688,100}X 100%
= {$633,300}/ {$1,688,100}X 100%
= 37.5%
Note: all formula adopted from Gulko (2010)
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
A&W
DAM ANSARA
SRI PETALING
$900,000
$800,000
$700,000
Decision Tree
SUCCESS=0.7
FAILURE=0.3
B
A
HIGH=0.2
M EDIUM =0.5
LOW =0.3
C
$0
TOTAL REVENUE
SUCCESS=0.6
NOTHING=0.4
$50,000
SUCCESS=0.6
D
FAILURE=0.4
$1,000,000
$900,000
$800,000E
F
$0
HIGH=0.3
M EDIUM =0.4
LOW =0.3
SUCCESS=0.6
NOTHING=0.4
$50,000
COST=$400,000
COST=$400,000
Created by Trial Version
Created by Trial Version
Created by Trial Version
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.6 Decision Tree
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Software downloaded from: http://www.edrawsoft.com/decisiontrees.php
Asia Pacific University of Technology & InnovationUC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
4.6.1 Calculation of Expected Value for Both Outlets
Expected Value of Sri Petaling and Damansara is calculated by using the formula:
Expected Value= Probability of Success+Probability of Loss- Cost
Expected Value for Sri Petaling
EVB = 0.2($900,000)+0.5($800,000)+0.3($700,000) = $790,000
EVC = 0.6($50,000)+0.4($0) = $30,000
EVA = 0.7($790,000)+0.3($30,000)-$400,000 = $162,000
Expected Value for Damansara
EVE = 0.3($1,000,000)+0.4($900,000)+0.3($800,000) = $900,000
EVF = 0.6($50,000)+0.4($0) = $30,000
EVD = 0.6($900,000)+0.4($30,000)-$400,000 = $152,000
4.6.2 Justifications
A&W should develop and expand its business in the Sri
Petaling outlet in Malaysia. The reasons are because the
expected value for opening an outlet in Sri Petaling is
higher and it is a long-term wise decision for the company
in the future.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
5.0 CONTROL AND EVALUATIONThe evaluation and control activities will include
quantitative methods to measure the effectiveness of the
marketing plan. The purpose of evaluation plan is ensure
each objectives set by the company are accomplished at the
end of the integrated marketing plan.
Objective 1: To create brand awareness of A&W Collagen
Burger to the consumers.
Evaluation Plan 1:
Due to A&W proposed advertisements, it is advised that all
advertisements in the marketing plan under do positioning
advertising copy testing to determine whether they are
relevant for the marketplace. Positioning advertising copy
testing will help A&W evaluate consumer attitude and
purchase intentions, and allow for the consideration
alternative messages that may be more appropriate (Belch &
Belch, 2001).
Objective 2: To achieve sales target of $2,000,000 for the
first year.
Evaluation Plan 2:
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
One of the most economical methods will include intercept
surveys. Intercept surveys are highly effective and will
provide instant feedback (Westwood, 2011). Since A&W is
concerning about getting more referrals, it is important to
understand the reasons behind missed revenue and the loss of
potential customers. Intercept surveys can help A&W to
identify customers who made a purchase and those who did not
and why and their chances to recommend other friends to
purchase.
Objective 3: To achieve estimated 20% market share next 12
months.
Evaluation Plan 3:
Theater testing will be used to identify strengths and
weaknesses of broadcast marketing messages and indicate how
A&W Malaysia’s commercials will compare against its
competitors (SheeHan, 2011). Using theater testing,
individuals will be told to watch and critique television
program, but their reception to A&W brand message will
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
actually be measure which, in turn, helps to determine brand
preference among the target audience.
6.0 CONCLUSIONIt is believed that Sri Petaling outlet will be the best
decision expansion decision to face the stiff competition in
the fast food industry. It is also confident that by
introducing new product, A&W Collagen Burger would be able
to compete with other major fast food players in the near
future. Therefore, each strategic business unit (SBU) like
human resource, information technology, media, finance,
marketing and so forth, plays vital roles in collaborating
to shape a better corporate image. It will simultaneously
create competitive advantage to contribute to the company
sustainability and profitability and finally increase market
share in Malaysia.
It is also believed that with the thorough internal and
external analysis of the group and company, A&W Collagen
Burger will be launched successfully in the introductory
stage of the product life cycle. After all, one can succeed
in the competitive market only after understanding the
complex consumer behavior because this enables the marketers
to undertake marketing decisions which are compatible with
consumers’ needs.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
7.0 REFERENCESA&W, (2014). A&W Malaysia | More Than Usual. [online] Available
at: http://www.rootbeer.com.my/ [Accessed 8 Mar. 2015].
BBC, (2014). BBC NEWS | Health | Purple tomato 'may boost health'.
[online] Available at:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7688310.stm [Accessed
8 Mar. 2015].
Belch, G. and Belch, M. (2001). Advertising and promotion.
Boston, Mass.: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
Carlsjr, (2015). Carl's Jr.. [online] Available at:
http://www.carlsjr.com.my/index.php [Accessed 8 Mar.
2015].
Charlotte, Sandeep, and Jean, (2001). The Food Service
Industry: Trends and Changing Structure in the New
Millennium. The Retail Food Industry Center, 1(2).
Chow, Dickson, Tham, and Wong, (2013). Factors Influencing
Dining Experience on Customer Satisfaction and Revisit
Intention among Undergraduates Towards Fast Food
Restaurants. Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman, 1(1).
Euromotnitor, (2010). Fast Food in Malaysia. [online]
Euromonitor. Available at:
http://www.euromonitor.com/fast-food-in-malaysia/report
[Accessed 6 Mar. 2015].
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Gulko, C. (2010). Accounting, business, and finance. New York, NY:
Ferguson.
Harris, Schwartz, and Brownell, (2010). Fast Food F.A.C.T.S.
Food Advertising to Children and Teens Score: Evaluating
Fast Food Nutrition and Marketing to Youth. Yale Rudd
Center for Food Policy and Obesity. Journal of Marketing
Management, 1(4).
Ibrahim, (2012). Fast Food Industry. Journal of International
Marketing, 1(1).
Indexmundi, (2014). Malaysia Demographics Profile 2014. [online]
Available at:
http://www.indexmundi.com/malaysia/demographics_profile.
html [Accessed 8 Mar. 2015].
Manzouri, M., Nizam Ab Rahman, M., Saibani, N. and Rosmawati
Che Mohd Zain, C. (2013). Lean supply chain practices in
the Halal food. Lean Six Sigma Journal, 4(4), pp.389-408.
Mcdonald, (2015). I'm lovin' it! McDonald's® Malaysia | Home.
[online] Available at: http://www.mcdonalds.com.my/
[Accessed 6 Mar. 2015].
MITI, (2006). Malaysia Third Industrial Master Plan (IMP3)
2006-2020. Pencetakan Nasional Malaysia Berhad.
Mohamed, Z., Kit Teng, P., Rezai, G. and Sharifuddin, J.
(2014). Malaysian Consumers™ Willingness-to-Pay Toward
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
Eco-Labeled Food Products in Klang Valley. Journal of Food
Products Marketing, 20(sup1), pp.63-74.
Mohammad, (2005). Development, Environment and Health
Status. Malaysia Environmental Health Country Profile World Health
Organization, 1(1).
myStarjob, (2013). Managing Baby Boomers, Gen-X and Gen-Y at work.
[online] Available at:
http://mystarjob.com/articles/story.aspx?file=
%2F2014%2F2%2F8%2Fmystarjob_careerguide
%2F14365187&sec=mystarjob_careerguide [Accessed 8 Mar.
2015].
Nik Muhammad, N., Isa, F. and Kifli, B. (2009). Positioning
Malaysia as Halal-Hub: Integration Role of Supply Chain
Strategy and Halal Assurance System. ASS, 5(7).
NPD Report, (2012). U.S. Adults Understand Principles of Healthful Eating
but the Practice of Eating Healthy Varies by Generation, Reports NPD.
[online] Npd. Available at:
https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/news/pressreleases
/pr_101207/!ut/p/c5/04_SB8K8xLLM9MSSzPy
8xBz9CP0os3g3b1NTS98QY0P3QEczA08PSx9jT29HYwMTM_1I_SjjeBc
3Sw8PN28TQ4sgSwsDT1d_QxfPo AAjC0sj_YLsQEUAK0FP4Q!!/
[Accessed 6 Mar. 2015].
Pahim, Jemali, and Mohammad, (2012). An empirical research
on relationship between demand, people and awareness
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
towards training needs: A case study in Malaysia Halal
logistics industry. IEEE Business Engineering and Industrial
Applications Colloquium (BEIAC), 1(1).
Parsa, John, and David, (2005). Why Restaurants Fail. [online]
Cornell University. Available at:
http://pitchforksoptional.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12
/restaurantsfail.pdf [Accessed 8 Mar. 2015].
Poskod Malaysia, (2014). A&W: The Future in Curly Fries - Poskod
Malaysia. [online] Available at:
http://poskod.my/features/future-of-a-and-w/ [Accessed 8
Mar. 2015].
Securities, (2014). EMIS - Kub Malaysia Berhad Company Profile -
Emerging markets. [online] Available at:
http://www.securities.com/php/company-profile/MY/Kub_Mal
aysia_Berhad_en_1661935.html [Accessed 8 Mar. 2015].
Sheehan, B. (2011). Marketing management. Lausanne,
Switzerland: AVA Pub.
Syazwan Ab Talib, M., Bakar Abdul Hamid, A., Hafiz Zulfakar,
M. and S Jeeva, A. (2014). Halal Logistics PEST
Analysis: The Malaysia Perspectives. ASS, 10(14).
Talib, and Johan, (2012). Issues in halal packaging: A
conceptual paper. International Business and Management, 5(2),
pp.94-98.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
The Free Dictionary, (2011). Generation Y. [online]
TheFreeDictionary. Available at:
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/generation+Y [Accessed
6 Mar. 2015].
Tieman, M. (2011). The application of Halal in supply chain
management: inâ€depth interviews. � Journal of Islamic Marketing,
2(2), pp.186-195.
Westwood, J. (2011). How to write a marketing plan. London: Kogan
Page.
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054
BM032-3-3-MKTDM Page of
8.0 APPENDICESDate Holidays Applicable to
3 Feb 2015 Thaipusam
Kuala Lumpur,Putrajaya, Johor,
Kedah, Negeri Sembilan,Perak, Penang &Selangor only
19 Feb 2015 Chinese New Year National
20 Feb 2015 Chinese New Year (2nd
Day) National
14 Mar till 22 Mar 2015 School Holidays National
1 May 2015 Labour Day National3 May 2015 Vesak Day National30 May till 14 June2015 School Holidays National
17 Jul 2015 Hari Raya Puasa National
18 Jul 2015 Hari Raya Puasa (2nd
Day) National
31 Aug 2015 National Day National16 Sep 2015 Malaysia Day National10 Nov 2015 Deepavali National except Sarawak21 Nov till 3 Jan 2015 School Holidays National
25 Dec 2015 Christmas National1 Jan 2015 New Year National
Source:
http://www.onestopmalaysia.com/holidays-
2015c.html
Asia Pacific University of Technology & Innovation UC3F1407KMGT/ TP026054