Appeal - ReliefWeb
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
4 -
download
0
Transcript of Appeal - ReliefWeb
150 route de Ferney, P.O. Box 2100 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland Tel: 41 22 791 6033 Fax: 41 22 791 6506
E-mail: [email protected]
Coordinating Office
Appeal
Pakistan
Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) Appeal Target: US$ 16,964,231 Total cover: US$15,696,095 No further funding requested due to limited implementation period remaining.
Geneva, 17 September 2008
Dear Colleagues, On 8 October 2005, an earthquake registering a magnitude of 7.6 on the Richter scale caused havoc in an area of 30,000 sq/km in the NWFP province of Pakistan and in parts of Pakistan-administered Kashmir. It was the deadliest earthquake in the recent history of the sub-continent resulting in between 73,000 and 86,000 deaths. The earthquake affected the lives and livelihoods of an estimated 3 million people. A first ACT appeal (ASSA51) was launched for both Indian and Pakistani areas of Kashmir, and followed by this rehabilitation phase appeal which was first launched on 10 April 2006, and revised for the first time on 06 October 2006. Please find attached the second and final revision of the ASPK61 appeal for ACT member Church World Service (CWS)- Pakistan/Afghanistan’s rehabilitation programme, with an implementation period of two years and eight months, to close on 31 December 2008. This final revised version of the appeal also includes a Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe (DKH) rehabilitation programme as approved for inclusion and shared earlier with the alliance in September 2007. DKH have been implementing both directly and through an established local partner with an implementation period ending 30 November 2008. Please note no funding has been requested for DKH as their full budget of US$ 1,620,000 is covered by DKH themselves. The most recent revision of CWS’s programme took place in March 2008 in close coordination and communication with the ACT Coordinating Office and the larger funding contributors towards this appeal. At the same time an accompanying extension of their implementation period was approved for an additional 9 months to 30 November 2008. While the changes in CWS’s section of the appeal were agreed in principle with the ACT Coordinating Office and communicated to appeal supporters, this formal approval and issue of the revision as per normal ACT procedures was unusually delayed due to competing emergencies work of the Asia, Pacific and Europe desk of the ACT Coordinating Office. The reasons for revision as explained at that time are as follows:
1. Poor Security Situation: the program is located in region that has a strong following and presence of militant organizations that have harassed and attacked NGOs working in the area and have regularly been calling for strikes and the expulsion of UN and INGOs from the area. This resulted in breakdown of field operations halting progress every now and then. It has also caused psychological stress on the staff.
2. Indecisive ERRA Bureaucracy: The frequent changes in ERRA policy, the lack of coordination between various government line departments, and the delayed issuance of NoC and MoU for our programs has caused and continues to cause delays in implementation.
3. Inclement Weather Conditions: Winter and monsoons (snow and land slides) also caused considerable additional delays in implementation. Some operational areas are inaccessible for at least five months a year; a perennial problem.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 2
Latest update
CWS have reported that the programme targets are on track and they are hoping to complete all planned activities in couple of months, except for the School Safety Programme. In the School Safety Programme, 40 schools were targeted for retrofitting. However, the government (ERRA) did not grant CWS the approval to proceed with the concept of retrofitting due to lack of specific technical expertise. However, approval was given to work on school reconstruction, which then required more funds. Please note that with this change is plans, the budget earmarked for school safety is only sufficient to cover 6 schools and this is where CWS have focused time and efforts. Reconstruction of all six schools is in progress. A further one month extension of the implementation period has been requested and approved for completion of this work by 31 December 2008. A final ACT evaluation of the programmes within this appeal will be conducted. Please see the reporting schedule that follows for deadlines for full ACT reporting on both the CWS and DKH programmes in the appeal.
Project Completion Date:
CWS P/A - 31 December 2008 DKH - 30 November 2008
Reporting schedule:
Reports due ACT CO Interim narrative &
financial reports
Final narrative &
financial reports
Audit
CWS P/A
1st 31 Oct 2006 28 February 2009 31 March 2009
2nd 30 April 2007
3rd 31 Oct 2007
4th 30 April 2008
DKH N/A 31 January 2009 28 February 2009
Summary of Appeal Targets, Pledges/Contributions Received and Balance Requested
CWS / NCA DKH ACT Co-
ordination
Evaluation Total Target
US$
Total Appeal Target/s 15,229,231 1,620,000 35,000 80,000 16,964,231
Less: Pledges/Contr Recd 13,967,316 1,620,000 28,772 80,008 15,696,096
Balance Requested from ACT Alliance 1,261,915 0 6,228 + 8 1,268,135 Note: Appeal ASSA51 has been completed. Reports are awaited and transfer of any balance to ASPK61 will be requested.
For further information please contact:
ACT Director, John Nduna (phone +41 22 791 6033 or mobile phone + 41 79 203 6055) or ACT Program Officer, Michelle Yonetani (phone +41 22 791 6035 or mobile phone +41 79 285 2916)
John Nduna
Director, ACT Co-ordinating Office
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 3
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
ACT Action by Churches Together
ACTCO Action by Churches Together Coordinating Office ACTED Agency for Technical Cooperation and Development AJK Azad Jammu Kashmir BHUs Basic Health Units
CBOs Community Based Organisations
CoS Church of Sweden
CTTCs Construction Trade Training Centres
CWC Community Water Committees
CWS-P/A Church World Service-Pakistan/Afghanistan
DCA Danish Church Aid
DCO District Coordination Office DEWS Disease Early Warning System DHO District Health Officer
DM Disaster Management
DMP Disaster Management Plans
DP Disaster Preparedness
DRU District Recovery Units
EFO Emergency Field Office EPP Environmental Protection Programme ERRA Earthquake Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Authority
FRC Federal Relief Commission
GCM General Coordination Meeting
GoP Government of Pakistan
HAP Humanitarian Accountability Partnership
HHP Health and Hygiene Promotion
HPT Hygiene Promotion Team
HIV/AIDS Human Immunodeficiency Virus / Acquired Immuno Deficiency Syndrome HMIS Health Management Information System HR Human Resource HRC Housing Reconstruction Centres IASC Inter Agency Standing Committee
IDPs Internally Displaced Persons
IEC Information, Education and Communication IMCP Institutional Management and Certification Programme INEE Inter-agency Network for Education in Emergencies INGOs International Non Governmental Organisations
IOM International Organisation for Migration
ISDR International Strategy for Disaster Reduction
LHVs Lady Health Visitors
LWF Lutheran World Federation. M&E Monitoring & Evaluation
MHUs Mobile Health Units MIS Management Information System MoU Memorandum of Understanding
NCA Norwegian Church Aid
NFIs Non Food Items
NGOs Non Governmental Organisations
NOC No Objection Certificate
NWFP North West Frontier Province
ODC Organisation for Development Coordination
PEC Polio Eradication Campaign
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 4
PHC Primary Health Care
PHED Public Health Engineering Department
PHF Pakistan Humanitarian Forum
PM&E Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation
PRA Participatory Rural Appraisal
PSST Psycho Social Support Team
RHCs Rural Health Centres SDC Swiss Agency for Development Cooperation SDF Sahara Development Foundation SGBV Sex, Gender Based Violence SHC Secondary Health Care
SPSS Statistical Package for Social Sciences TB-DOTS Tuberculosis - Directly Observed Treatment, Short-course TMA Tehsil Municipal Authority
TNAs Training Need Assessments
UCH United Christian Hospital
UCs Union Councils
UMM United Methodist Mission
UN United Nations UNDP United Nations Development Programme UNHIC United Nations Humanitarian Information Centre
UNHCR United Nation High Commission for Refugees
UNOCHA United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
VHCs Village Health Committees
WatSan Water and Sanitation WCC World Council of Churches WHO World Health Organisation
WSS Water Supply Scheme
Table of Contents
I. REQUESTING ACT MEMBER – CHURCH WORLD SERVICE (CWS)- PAKISTAN/AFGHANISTAN 5
X. CWS P/A BUDGET 39
I. REQUESTING ACT MEMBER – DIAKONISCHES WERK/ DIAKONIE KATASTROPHENHILFE (DKH) 56
X. DKH BUDGET 67
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 5
I. REQUESTING ACT MEMBER INFORMATION
Church World Service-Pakistan/Afghanistan (CWS-P/A)
II. IMPLEMENTING ACT MEMBER and PARTNER INFORMATION
a) Church World Service–Pakistan/Afghanistan (CWS-P/A) CWS-P/A is registered as an International Non-Governmental Organisation (INGO) with the Federal Government of Pakistan. The organisation has been operational with its relief and development initiatives in Pakistan and Afghanistan since 1954. CWS-P/A, a regional office of Church World Service-Inc, has its central office in Karachi and sub-offices in Lahore, Mansehra, Islamabad, Murree, Quetta, Kabul and Jalalabad. CWS-P/A works through and with both faith-based and secular organisations on pre and post-disaster management and development aspects, to improve the quality of life of underprivileged communities.
CWS-P/A is one of the leading organisations that responded immediately to the earthquake on 8 October 2005. A relief programme was implemented subsequently in the worst affected and remote areas of North West Frontier Province (NWFP) and Azad Jammu Kashmir (AJK). CWS-P/A started implementation of the relief programme in NWFP, where, it has a base of operation for the last 27 years and at present employs over 170 staff in the earthquake recovery and rehabilitation. Specific districts where relief assistance was provided include Mansehra, Battagram, Shangla and Kohistan in NWFP and Rawalakot in AJK. The relief response comprised the provision of shelter, food and non-food items, psychosocial support to families and individuals, emergency water and sanitation facilities, health facilities through Basic Health Units (BHUs) and Mobile Health Units (MHUs) and hygiene promotion. In addition, CWS-P/A runs a comprehensive winterisation programme which provides winterised items like plastic sheets, blankets, shoes, shawls, quilts, and sweaters. This programme was launched to cater for the immense needs of the affected population. A total of 18,000 sq/km area was covered by CWS/NCA in the relief phase. CWS/NCA/CoS have launched an integrated earthquake recovery and rehabilitation programme in the worst affected areas of NWFP and AJK. Under this programme, the support is being provided in seven sectors, including Psychosocial Care and Protection, Capacity Building of CWS/NCA/CoS Staff/Partners/Local Government Officials and Communities, Sustainable Livelihoods, Water and Sanitation and Hygiene Promotion, Environmental Protection, Primary and Secondary Health Care Services and Winter Emergency Programme (shelter kits and food packages).
b) Norwegian Church Aid (NCA) - Technical lead in Water and Sanitation and Hygiene Promotion
Norwegian Church Aid (NCA) is an INGO, with a long history of providing emergency relief and long-term development support in Afghanistan and Pakistan. NCA works primarily with local partners, both faith based and secular. NCA has special competency in water and sanitation. It has provided technical support to CWS-P/A related to water and sanitation interventions during the relief phase and has continued their support in recovery and rehabilitation phase.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 6
c) Church of Sweden – Technical lead in Psychosocial Care and Protection
Church of Sweden cooperates with a large number of independent partner churches and ecumenical organisations in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. It also works in cooperation with international bodies, such as the World Council of Churches (WCC) and Lutheran World Federation (LWF).
Formerly, mission activity is more diversified, including urban mission, theological training, youth work, and inter-religious dialogue. New and important issues include women's struggle against oppression and struggle for human rights. This may include, for example, assistance with legal aid and support to the families of prisoners. For CWS/NCA/CoS earthquake recovery and rehabilitation programme, the CoS is taking technical lead in psychosocial care and protection.
ACT member’s implementing partners
a) Organisation for Development Coordination
The Organisation for Development Coordination (ODC) is a non-political, non-profit, non-governmental organisation focusing on the development of rural areas of Pakistan. The goal of ODC is to improve the livelihoods of marginalised segments through the provision of basic health, education, sanitation, infrastructure, and income generation opportunities. ODC is committed to involving communities in the decision-making, planning and implementation of programmes. This ensures that projects implemented by ODC are supported and ‘owned’ by the communities, and increases social values within those communities. ODC is also coordinating its activities with other organisations and institutions in order to facilitate the exchange of information and experience within the areas of its activities. After the earthquake of 8 October 2005, ODC provided rescue and emergency aid to victims of the earthquake in AJK and NWFP. For CWS/NCA/CoS earthquake recovery and rehabilitation programme implementation, the ODC will be the implementing partner for sustainable livelihood for women. b) Diocese of Raiwind
The Diocese of Raiwind was established in 1980. The Diocesan Episcopal Jurisdiction comprises of former United Methodist Mission (UMM) areas and is predominantly rural and semi-urban. For the last 20 years, the Diocese has been looking after the educational needs of children, irrespective of what community the child belongs. In addition, work is being undertaken to provide quality health facilities, with the main emphasis on the poor rural areas of Raiwind. There are numerous health related programmes on going, especially on the Community Health Programme (initiated in 1985 by the Women’s Fellowship in Raiwind). Gradually the programme has developed its focus towards health centre based mother and child health in 1989 and a community health programme from 1992 onwards, with a prime emphasis on training of village health workers. An Eye Rehabilitation Programme was started in 2001 in collaboration with the United Christian Hospital (UCH) in Lahore. The SAHARA Rehabilitation Project, started in 1994, includes rehabilitation services for physically handicapped children, and was organised as an outpatient clinic in the health centre in Raiwind. During the relief phase, the Diocese of Raiwind, with CWS/NCA/CoS, operated a BHU and a MHU in Rawalakot that provided basic health facilities to people in the earthquake affected areas. The BHU and MHUs will continue to provide support to the affected community in the recovery and rehabilitation phase.
III. DESCRIPTION of the SITUATION
Background
An earthquake of Magnitude 7.6 on the Richter scale occurred on 8 October 2005 causing damage and casualties over 30,000 sq/km area in the NWFP of Pakistan and in parts of Pakistani-administered Kashmir. The main event was followed by 2,0331 aftershocks of magnitude 6 and above (Richter). The epicentre of the main earthquake was located 100 kilometres northeast of Pakistan’s Capital, Islamabad. The focal depth of the main earthquake
1 www.met.gov.pk
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 7
was determined to be 26 km2. This was the deadliest earthquake in the recent history of the sub-continent, resulting in between 73,0003 to 86,0004 casualties. A further 200,000 were injured and more than 3 million people left homeless. The adverse effects of this earthquake are estimated to be larger than those of the Tsunami of December 20045. In the relief phase CWS/NCA implemented one of the largest relief operations in close coordination with United Nations, Prime Minister Relief Cell and other stake holders. CWS/NCA assisted over 30,000 families in NWFP and Pakistani-administered Kashmir. The relief operations have been evaluated and most of the recommendations have been accepted and are being implemented in the recovery phase.
IV. DESCRIPTION of the SITUATION in the AREA of PROPOSED RESPONSE
Apart from the huge number of deaths recorded, the earthquake had also adversely affected the lives and livelihood of an estimated 3 million people. Amidst gallant efforts to provide emergency relief, Pakistan faced the grim prospect of one million people confronting the winter without adequate shelter.6 The government and international humanitarian organisations undertook a massive effort to provide temporary shelter to earthquake survivors to meet the fast approaching winter months. At lower elevations, the shelter, food, sanitation, and health care requirements of over 300,000 individuals and families were met by establishing hundreds of camps. For the highest and most inaccessible regions, humanitarian agencies developed a programme called “Operation Winter Race,” which involved construction of warm rooms coupled with the delivery of roofing materials, blankets and stoves. Approximately 90 percent of the destroyed or damaged houses were in rural areas. The remaining 10 percent were in urban areas, primarily the towns of Muzaffarabad and Balakot. While the total number of homes destroyed is only 10 percent of the pre-earthquake total, urban dwellers represent 20 percent of all individuals displaced by the earthquake. Long-term displacement from the cities of Muzaffarabad and Balakot alone approached 90,000 people7. Reconstructing the urban areas remains a major challenge to the Government of Pakistan and humanitarian actors, including UN agencies and NGOs and INGOs. Urban recovery efforts will take many years and will result in serious and continued displacement and inequities in the lives of those from urban areas, as indicated by the current slow early recovery process. The Government of Pakistan’s Earthquake Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Authority (ERRA) is recognising this reality and is beginning a comprehensive planning process to address it. A wide array of urban issues remains to be addressed, including the question as to where to relocate the city of Balakot and the 35 percent of the residents of Muzaffarabad that will be displaced either for short or longer term. How to gather appropriately and dispose massive amounts of earthquake rubble in a safe and environmentally sound manner? How to meet the housing, economic, educational, medical, and psycho-social needs of the urban residents displaced over the years8. These are all questions to which the answers are still awaited. To meet these challenges on the request of ERRA, the UN Resident Coordinator’s Office9 has started providing technical support to the government, both at federal and district level, yet still a lot has to be done. To ensure good implementation, many humanitarian organisations suggest that ERRA, through the local government units, should identify specific urban reconstruction projects and establish a clear management structure for each. Decision-making power must be pushed to the lowest level possible and when exercised, must include the views of those individuals and organisations at the local level affected by the earthquake.
2 United State Geological Survey
3 According to Government of Pakistan
4 According to media and UN
5 ibid
6 According to Government of Pakistan
7 From different coordination meetings, CWS/NCA attended
8 Data from File & UN reports
9 With relief scaled down, OCHA Pakistan closed on 30th June 2006 and rolled over an OCHA contingent into the UN Integrated Resident Coordinator’s Office. This move came after most of the coordination mechanisms established during the relief phase have been handed over by OCHA and the UN agencies to the government for use in the recovery phase.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 8
There are also challenges in terms of the ability of the most vulnerable to receive the support they need. Potential obstacles include family and village social structures that work against equal access for the vulnerable as well as the rising costs of building materials, which may make it difficult for the poorest families to start re-building. Cash being provided to survivors for reconstruction may be utilised to survive the winter, leaving them with limited funds to reconstruct their homes and restart their lives. The viability of village life depends on more than shelter. Many villagers are concerned about the security of their land ownership and this will be compounded in the recovery and rebuilding phase. Their livelihoods have been massively disrupted. Programmes to support livestock and agricultural development will be critical to achieving food security in advance of the winter of 2007-2008. Above all, heavy rains, landslides and flash floods, the increasing political tension, campaign and attacks against I/NGOs continue to hamper recovery and rehabilitation efforts in the earthquake-affected areas.
Security Situation
Although the Government has control of the overall security situation in the affected areas, the situation can change quickly due to the strong presence of several Islamic and Jihadi organisations who oppose the involvement of foreign troops and organisations in relief operations in the affected areas. CWS/NCA/CoS carefully and routinely monitors the security situation. Currently, there has been continuous propaganda against NGOs/INGOs in the earthquake-affected areas. In 2007, the security situation worsened when various processions by religious leaders in Mansehra took place against NGOs calling for the sacking of all women employees from their programmes. They stated that NGOs working in these areas do not respect their culture and their activities are in violation of Islamic values. Staff and properties of several INGOs and local organisations have been targeted and looted in the last months. In most of the areas, government requires police escorts for all travel of expatriate staff. In the mid of 2007, the Red Mosque (Lal Masjid) standoff and the resultant clash with security forces have led to an increase of serious security incidents. The number of suicide bombs and armed militant attacks has risen sharply. In the last quarter of 2007, an unspecified number of INGOs have relocated expatriate staff to Islamabad and scaled down activities in NWFP. The assassination of Ms. Benazir Bhutto in late December 2007 led CWS/NCA/CoS and other I/NGOs to apply more stringent security measures as a precaution and upon government advice. CWS/NCA sees this as a fleeting outbreak of violence that will not recede over time. The year 2008 is an election year which traditionally stimulates heightened political activities. It is also known that the militants have targeted uniformed security forces almost exclusively since last year up to present. Recently there had been evidence of deliberate targeting of NGO staff, expatriates or programmes. The bomb blast at the IFRC Warehouse in January 2008 and the direct attack on Plan International has once again heightened security alert and posed serious disruption in the over all programme implementation. With such scenario happening every now and then, it is noted that the constant precautionary work stoppage would lead to delays in the implementation of programmes. It is therefore assumed that should the situation remains the same, some amount of delay is to be reckoned with.
Mission Statement
CWS P/A will work together with the people affected by the earthquake to enhance their coping capacities through an integrated recovery programme.
Map Showing Location of Proposed Tehsils for Recovery Programme in NWFP & AJK
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 9
Location: The entire process of granting No Objection Certificates (NOCs) and Memorandum of Understandings (MoUs) is not just bureaucratic but fraught with delays and confusions. However CWS/NCA was able to receive blanket NOC right in the beginning and did initiate some of the recovery rehabilitation activities in Mansehra and Battagram. Below is the listing of the targeted Union Councils (UCs) including new addition:
CWS/NCA/CoS has already completed the first batch of Water Supply Schemes (WSS) allocated by ERRA for its water, sanitation and health and health and hygiene programme. For the period up to 31 July 2008, an additional 23 schemes have been targeted and surveys have been on-going including the preparation of project designs necessary for the application for additional NOCs. Pending the approval of the NOC Application, a go ahead from ERRA to begin work has been granted and preliminary work in various stages is underway. CWS/NCA/CoS has concentrated activities in Mansehra District. The selection of WSS is an on going process and is done in coordination with ERRA, District Recovery Units (DRUs) and other line departments. Areas in NWFP were selected as per the damage assessment done by the Monitoring & Evaluation Team (M&E Team) of CWS/NCA/CoS, previously called the Recovery, Assessment and Monitoring (RAM) Team. The recovery and rehabilitation programme is compiled according to the needs identified by affected people in these areas. Many consultations have also been undertaken with UN agencies, government and line departments to ensure alignment of the recovery programme with the ERRA-UN Early Recovery Strategy.10 Areas in District Rawalakot are selected as per the initial assessment carried out by the Pakistan Humanitarian Forum (PHF). Later the implementing partner Diocese of Raiwind, during implementation of the health programme there, identified further recovery needs in the health sector. BHUs and MHUs are operative in Rarban, Rawalakot and will continue their services in the recovery phase for two years. In addition, the government is provided with medical staff in Ali Sojal, Hussain Kot and Datoot to augment the need for manpower. Overall, the recovery and rehabilitation programme is developed through a series of workshops on Recovery Management and Planning conducted with the councillors of eight UCs in NWFP. However in the process, CWS/NCA/CoS have used the following criteria for the selection of villages: � Villages that were totally destroyed. � Villages with local cohesion mechanisms, i.e. community based organisations, youth activities, etc. � Villages which are open to the participation of women.
10 www.un.org.pk
District and Tehsil Union Council
NWFP District Mansehra: Tehsil Mansehra and Balakot District Battagram: Tehsil Battagram and Allai AJK District Rawalakot
� Balakot � Battamori � Hangrai � Hillkot � Hussain Kot (AJK) � Jaraid � Kaghan � Kewai � Laassan Takhral � Mohandri � Parahana � Pakkar Nakka (AJK) � Phulra � Pshora � Shamlai � Shinkiari � Tanda
� Ali Sojal (AJK) � Banna � Batella � Battal � Behali � Bhogarmang � Chattar � City 2 � City 3 � City 4 � Datoot (AJK) � Dhodial � Ghari Habibullah � Ichrian � Mansehra � Pashto
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 10
CWS/NCA/CoS received NOC from the ERRA11 for its recovery and rehabilitation programme in NWFP and AJK. DRUs are the prime bodies to coordinate and to resolve the problems of duplication and other implementation problems at the field level. As stated earlier, this may change the villages, which have been allocated to CWS/NCA/CoS by ERRA, however, CWS/NCA/CoS will try not to change the Tehsils and UCs mentioned above for recovery and rehabilitation programmes, but this all is subject to the situation. Implementing partners of earthquake recovery and rehabilitation plan were involved actively in the relief operations and are some of the many NGOs working in the affected areas.
V. TARGETED BENEFICIARIES
Number and type
The number of direct beneficiaries of the recovery programme can be estimated with some degree of accuracy, whilst the number of indirect beneficiaries is more difficult to estimate with precision. Many others will benefit indirectly from the programme. These include extended family members, private sector merchants, and both private and public sector service providers and their families.
Criteria for the selection of beneficiaries
The selection of families in NWFP is a coordinated effort involving the M&E Team and all Programme Teams. In Rawalakot, identification of beneficiaries is primarily done by the implementing partner; Diocese of Raiwind. The M&E Team conducted a detailed assessment of all villages of NWFP, where the recovery programme is being implemented. Coordination with DRUs and line agencies and organisations, is a regular process at field level to solve duplication problems. As stated earlier, villages may change to avoid duplication - this will, in turn, affect the number of beneficiaries.
No Programme Components
Revision 1
Appeal Targets
Revision 2
Appeal Targets
1 Winter Emergency Response, Floods and other
Natural Disasters
Shelter Kits 5,000 families 5,000 families
Food Packages 5,000 families 5,000 families
2 Psychosocial Care and Protection
Individual Counselling 1,000 individuals 1,000 individuals
Community Intervention 16,000 individuals 16,000 individuals Training volunteers in Psychosocial Care 40 individuals 40 individuals Community Support Centres Inhabitants of 6 UCs Inhabitants of 5 UCs
3 Capacity Building
Of EFO Staff and Partner Organisations 720 individuals 250 individuals Of Union Councillors 144 individuals 144 individuals Of affected communities 1,500 individuals 1,500 individuals Distribution of Disaster Response Gears/
Equipments --- 12 UCs
Puppet Shows --- 1,200 children School Safety Programme (retrofitting and training) --- 40 schools Sphere Training --- 80 individuals
4 Sustainable Livelihoods
Livestock Provision Programme 1,000 women 1,600 women and men Goat Bank --- 300 women Trade Training Centres 1,785 men 1,995 men
5 WatSan and Health & Hygiene Promotion
Rehabilitation of Water Scheme 26 WSS 51 WSS Rehabilitation and Construction of Sanitation
Facilities 60,000 individuals ---
Hygiene Promotion Awareness and Training 75,000 individuals 60,000 individuals Sensitisation Session with Students --- 4,200 students
11 www.erra.gov.pk
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 11
Distribution of Hygiene Kits --- 5,000 families No. of Village/Volunteers Organised into Committees --- 31/550 Winterisation and Sanitation --- 365 families
6 Environmental Protection
Environmental Awareness through Different Techniques
Inhabitants of 26 villages
Inhabitants of 32 villages
Waste Management Training --- 1,500 women Puppet Shows --- 1,500 children Plantation of Fruit Trees 4,000 families 5,000 families 7 Primary and Secondary Health Services 150,000 individuals 220,000 individuals Static Health Units 9 BHUs 9 BHUs Mobile Health Units 4 MHUs 4 MHUs Laboratory Units --- 2 units Health Houses --- 50 units
The Union Councils are selected on the basis of the established relationships developed during the relief phase. Villages that were destroyed are also on the CWS/NCA/CoS priority list. Widows and families with disabled bread winners are on the top list of individual households. In addition to considering the priorities set by ERRA and other line authorities, CWS/NCA/CoS takes into consideration gender, vulnerabilities as well as long term sustainability when selecting the areas to intervene. The M&E Team visited each village and data was gathered and compiled with the full participation of the community. The community helped the M&E team in the identification of needs and they suggested the implementation mechanism. Communities will also be involved in recovery programme implementation. Coordination at the field level is an on going process. The M&E Team has been coordinating with government line departments and other local organisations in the selected areas. The recovery plan, indicating the areas of intervention, was submitted to ERRA and disseminated to many agencies and organisations to share information and to avoid/resolve duplication and implementation problems at different levels. Regular updates are also being shared with other stakeholders including government line agencies and humanitarian organisations working there. The Code of Conduct for the Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement and NGOs is also considered in the selection of beneficiaries. The assessment team is well aware that above all, the humanitarian imperative comes first and the selection should be undertaken regardless of race, creed or nationality of the recipients and without adverse distinction of any kind. Aid priorities are calculated based on need alone. CWS/NCA/CoS fully respects local culture and customs. Gender is taken into consideration when selecting beneficiaries. A specific livelihood programme has been designed for 1,000 affected women. Community participation, including that of men and women has been reinforced throughout the process. CWS/NCA/CoS is also planning to use local resources in the implementation of the programme, where possible. A complete analysis of the recovery programme has been undertaken by the management to further reduce vulnerabilities to disasters. The team does not view communities as passive recipients of disaster relief, and recognises that “victims” become the main actors and take part in the decision-making in disaster management.
RATIONALE FOR EXTENSION AND REVISION
In August 2006, ASPK 61 underwent its first major revision which resulted to a significant decrease in the Appeal Budget mainly because the Housing Reconstruction component was excluded and a new component on Winter Emergency Response was included as a new activity. The various challenges and difficulties have one way or the other affected the whole programme, which hampered the implementation and resulted in backlogs. The major attributes to such delays include the very volatile, unstable security in the whole country and in the earthquake areas; the weather that caused landslides and road blockage, the bureaucracy within ERRA and the funding that came slow. Taking into cognisance the reasons cited above, CWS/NCA/CoS have proposed for a further extension and revision up to 31 December 2008 with the following justification and rationale:
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 12
1. Full completion of the original programme activities and new targets with scaling up of activities with no
additional cost. 2. The existing socio-political situation in the whole country has posed major delays in programme
implementation as well as the direct attack and campaign against INGOs hampering field activities. Thus, more time is needed to achieve goals and objectives.
3. Maximise funds and resources to ensure sustainability, quality that would generate a more positive impact among communities and beneficiaries.
4. The request for 9 months extension period will also enable the programme to infuse additional activities to further support communities and enhance their capacity in their future role as steward of the programme and assume responsibility over the management and sustainability of the various activities.
5. More time to capitalise on the gains which will enable communities and beneficiaries to take on and continue to be self reliant and self-sustaining.
6. Specific for the Health Programme, the government is to yet ready to address health requirements and assume responsibility to continue and sustain the BHUs and MHUs that were established (still does not have enough human and material resources to support the delivery of health care services). Health issues still remain to be one of the major concerns that need to be addressed especially in the earthquake affected areas. Therefore, there is a genuine need to continue with the delivery of health care services and bring these services nearer and more accessible to communities.
CWS/NCA/CoS, with the help of implementing partners mentioned above, is implementing the recovery and rehabilitation programme in Districts Mansehra and Battagram in NWFP and in District Rawalakot in AJK. CWS/NCA/CoS in Mansehra has good working relations with the communities affected by the earthquake. The implementing partners also have a strong, established base in NWFP and AJK. To ensure better implementation of the programme, CWS/NCA/CoS has doubled its capacity. Some components of the recovery programme are being directly implemented by CWS/NCA/CoS, because of their extensive experience in these components, i.e. psychosocial, capacity building and health services. NCA is undertaking the water, sanitation and hygiene promotion component in close consultation with CWS-P/A. Some other components including women livelihood and health programme in Rawalakot will be implemented by different implementing partners.
Beneficiaries are involved at all levels, ranging from project planning, implementation to decision making. The recovery team ensures their full participation and wherever possible community labourers and resources will be utilised. Community organisations play a significant role in managing the implementation of the programme. The team shares plans with the relevant community organisations, including elders and others notables from the communities and with their co-operation, the various plans are being executed. Gender and environment are also important components of the recovery programme. As mentioned above, the livelihood programme is specially designed to aim to meet the needs of 1,000 vulnerable women. The team will aim to ensure that all segments of the community, including children, women, men and the elderly benefit from different components of the recovery programme. The evaluation of the earthquake relief phase suggested some recommendations, which have been incorporated in the current revised appeal. Based on the recommendation of the evaluation team, the recovery programme is targeting 29 UCs in Districts Mansehra and Battagram of NWFP and four in District Rawalakot, AJK. Similarly, as per the recommendation of the evaluation team, the comprehensive socio-economic data collected by the Psycho Social Support Team (PSST) are being used in need assessment for different recovery components and also in monitoring of activities. The ACT manual is also being translated from English to Urdu language to be used in the programme. Co-operation between CWS/NCA/CoS is also strengthened by having regular meetings and exchange visits to project locations. Tehsil Municipal Authority (TMA) WatSan coordination meetings are also being attended by the team to ensure close coordination with concerned government authorities at the ground level. As recommended by the evaluation team, to work more effectively, a local hygiene promotion team leader has also been appointed and local deputies for the Field Coordinator and Monitoring Officer who are both expatriates.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 13
Similarly, data is being collected gender-wise and the SPSS application, used by M&E team also allows for data segregation. Gender is the cross cutting theme in the recovery programme, being addressed as follows:
���� Programme beneficiaries are gender-specific in the livelihoods programmes; Construction Trades Training is complemented by the livestock provision and training for widows and female-headed households in the affected area.
���� The health programme provides female doctors and female health visitors for the communities as well as male medical professionals. The establishment of 9 BHUs and subsequently Health Houses will aim to address the need for obstetric/gynaecological care, maternal health, due to the shortage or absence of female health professionals. During the monitoring and assessment field trips to villages, it was found that many women could not avail the health centres’ services because of cultural and religious traditions and practices. The recovery health programme targets this population for intervention.
���� Through the psychosocial programme supportive counselling and community based activities are made available for men and women, boys and girls. Data collection tools also allow for segregating by gender.
The recovery team provides recovery programme presentations to union councillors (special emphasis on inclusion of women councillors), to make them fully understand the programme and to ensure their involvement. The Team also requests the presence of community leaders, DRU, TMA, PHED, community-based organisations, the army, and the clergy. The implementing partners of the recovery programme will be part of capacity building training programme. The recovery programme is also well coordinated and the team participates in different UN and ERRA cluster coordination meetings both at field and federal levels. The Sphere Minimum Standards are being fully applied in all sectors and levels of the programming. The booklet on Sphere Standards has been translated into Urdu and staff has also attended Sphere training. The Sphere focal person, appointed by CWS/NCA/CoS is also conducting Sphere trainings for the government and other humanitarian organisations on a regular basis. The Code of Conduct was also raised in the NGO Security Coordination Meeting following an anti NGO campaign in Mansehra. Recommendation for the UN agency to draft a Code of Conduct for such a situation in NWFP in collaboration with the local clerics, GoP, NGO, has also been taken up by the CWS/NCA/CoS Security Committee. CWS/NCA/CoS have been very active in raising the visibility of ACT and members of the ACT network. The ACT introduction has also been translated into Urdu and mounted on walls in all offices and also circulated to partners. The implementation strategy of each component in the recovery programme is discussed under the respective programme sections in this document.
VI. PROPOSED ASSISTANCE and IMPLEMENTATION
Goal: To restore the lives and livelihoods of people affected by the earthquake in the North West Frontier
Province (NWFP) and in Azad Jammu Kashmir (AJK).
Objectives The recovery programme has seven components ���� Winter Emergency Response, Floods and other Natural Disasters ���� Psychosocial Care and Protection ���� Capacity Building of CWS/NCA/CoS Staff/Partners/Local Staff and Communities ���� Sustainable Livelihood ���� Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Promotion ���� Environmental Protection ���� Primary and Secondary Health Services
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 14
WINTER EMERGENCY RESPONSE, FLOODS AND OTHER NATURAL DISASTER S The area that has been affected by earthquake is not just the poorest and the most remote regions in Pakistan but also a region that can truly be classified as multi-hazard. Any natural disasters during winters can have devastating affects on these marginalised communities. The target of 5,000 families that will benefit from the winter emergency programme will also cover the needs and requirements of families likely to be affected by other natural disasters in the earthquake areas like floods, or landslides. There will be no revision in this component and the activity will be finalised in spring of 2008. Beneficiaries/Targets: 5,000 families will benefit from winter emergency programme including shelter kits and food packages.
Goal : Ensure appropriate and timely relief distribution among families affected in order to minimise any other possible risks or secondary effects of disasters. Objective: Provide emergency assistance to include shelter kits and food packages to 5,000 families affected or displaced due to harsh winters and other natural disasters within the Sphere Standards. Expected Results and Activities: 5,000 families affected by natural disasters and other emergencies are provided with relief assistance comprising shelter kits and food packages according to Sphere Standards. Activities:
���� Survey and ocular inspection of affected areas. ���� Needs’ assessment. ���� Community mobilisation for the planned distribution/activity. ���� Survey, data gathering, listing and validation of families affected. ���� Selection of beneficiaries and setting up distribution sites. ���� Distribution of relief items. ���� Coordination and networking with other stakeholders. ���� Record keeping (i.e. tokens, receiving list, request letters, dispatch orders, assessment reports). ���� Coordinate with administration and warehouse staff on the procurement, inventory and quality of goods. ���� Monitoring, impact assessment and evaluation. Implementation Strategy
According to ERRA, an estimated 20,000 families in urban areas of AJK and NWFP will not have permanent houses constructed in 2006, and their tents are unlikely to be adequate to live in for another year. Makeshift temporary shelters may not be available to some families. There is a growing recognition that another relief phase will be started with coming winters and shelter and food would be the major requirements. Apart from possible effects of harsh winter, the early onset and continuing monsoon and torrential rains have resulted to major floods and landslides in earthquake affected areas, in which the likelihood of launching disaster relief operations would be a paramount requirement to help families cope up with the ill effects of these disasters. The selection criteria for relief distribution are as follows: ���� Families whose houses are either partially or totally destroyed. ���� Internally displaced families. ���� Families residing in communities covered by the Recovery Programme and whose source of income is
directly affected by the disaster. ���� Families with high level of vulnerability (e.g. women headed household, with very young children and
disabled member of the family).
Composition of Relief Items:
A) SHELTER KITS 5,000 shelter kits will be provided to most needy. Each shelter kit will include the following items:
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 15
� Family-size Tent 1 � Ground Sheet 1 � Plastic Sheet 1 � Iron Poles 2 (with hammer) � Blankets 4
B) FOOD PACKAGES 5,000 food packages will be given to the neediest. Each food package will comprise of: � Wheat flour 80 kg � Rice 40 kg � Pulses 7 kg � Cooking oil 10 litres � Sugar 7 kg � Tea leaves 2 kg � Milk 2 kg � Salt (Iodised) 1 packet � Match Box 1 packet � Soap 4
The emergency package is according to Sphere Standards. The shelter kit meets the criteria of Sphere Standards and can resist cold and provide safe and secure environment to families against extreme cold. These tents are designed according to their cultural sensitivities and customs. Similarly, the food package has been prepared keeping in mind the Sphere Standards to meet the minimum nutritional need (which is 2,100 Kcals per person per day) for a period of one month for an average of 7 members per family.
PSYCHOSOCIAL CARE & PROTECTION
Rationale for Revision and Extension: The active involvement of the community in the programme as well as the continuous assessment and increased understanding of the team resulted in the identification of new issues and needs, such as women’s empowerment, education, and child protection. As the programme is community based, these needs can be addressed within the current approach, methodology and budget – but the implementation requires an extended period of time. For example, the establishment of the Community Centres is ongoing and an extension would be beneficial to make full use of these Centres. The same targets in the original Appeal will be reached within the extended programme period, with additional strengthening of the programme as described above. The extended time will be utilised to further strengthen the community efforts for recovery and resilience. PSST will continue working with the community members to regain their functioning by building on their strengths while using a right-based perspective sensitive to children and gender.
Beneficiaries/Targets
The following will directly benefit from the programme: ���� 1,000 individuals and their families from 26 villages will be involved in supportive talks. ���� 16,000 individuals from 26 villages will benefit from a mix of recreational activities and workshops including,
but not limited to, life skills, vocational skills, gender empowerment, and child protection. ���� Knowledge and skills in psychosocial care will be provided to 40 selected volunteers. ���� Approximately 30,00012 individuals will benefit from the 6 community support centres. Goal: To enhance and strengthen families’ coping mechanism and resilience in post disaster situation.
Objectives:
���� Enhance people’s understanding of various behavioural responses and identification of the effects of disaster and coping mechanisms.
���� Provide access to community based psychosocial activities and services to women, men and children.
12 The population of the adjourning villages, who will benefit from the centres is also taken into account.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 16
���� Facilitate coordination within the community and with other stakeholders and develop linkages through trainings and formation of village committees.
���� Strengthen interaction amongst families and individuals through Community Support Centres established in five UCs.
Expected Results and Activities:
a) 17,040 individuals provided with psychosocial support services: ���� Organisation of women’s and men’s group meeting on grief, loss, and coping skills and building relationships
within each. ���� Debriefing/counselling with individuals affected by the earthquake in 26 villages. ���� Organisation of recreational activities for affected children/young people/men and women. ���� Dissemination of materials on basic coping skills. ���� Use Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) techniques and tools to facilitate communities to identify problems
and find possible solution. ���� Individuals and families from 26 villages participate in psychosocial activities. ���� Initiation and facilitation of different recreational activities (e.g. drawing and story writing) with children in
the selected communities. ���� Initiation of community collective prayers to bring together the women and men at one platform to rebuild/re
strengthen social networks. ���� Recreational activities for female members (e.g. Henna competition, cooking competition and folk song
competitions, etc). ���� Training of women in handicrafts and other income generating vocational activities. ���� Educational and recreational trips for school and out of school children. ���� Facilitation of sports competitions for adolescent boys and girls. ���� Awareness raising related to different issues affecting communities. ���� Training of community members, specially females members, in various psychosocial issues. b) Social network and linkages established and provided between and among beneficiaries and service
providers.
���� Formation of community support groups composed of men, women and children. ���� Advocacy with other stakeholders involved in psychosocial support programme (NGOs and government
departments) to raise issues affecting the communities and to find solutions together with the people. ���� Facilitate meetings among all stakeholders working in the village for better coordination. ���� Coordinate PSP work with the public sector, the academe and other institution faculty for capacity building
for psychosocial issues.
c) Six Community Support Centres established in 5 UCs :
���� Liaision with Union Councillors, religious clergy and other political leaders, notables in identifying suitable location for the centre.
���� Forging agreements with landlords for the lease or donation of land/structure for the Community Support Centre.
���� Mobilisation of community members/families in construction and setting up. ���� Procuring necessary facilities and equipments needed. ���� Organising committees for Centre Management. ���� Ensureingwomen and children participation/involvement in various Centre activities relevant to their needs. ���� Forging MoU/Agreements with the communities/leaders/landlord for turn-over at the end of the project
period. ���� Monitoring and Evaluation. Implementation Strategy: Under the recovery programme, the support is being provided by the PSST in targeted UCs. Multiple activities are being organised, such as community monitoring and visits to affected households, volunteer programmes that provide much needed psychosocial support (e.g. community youth clubs) and recreation programmes. Through these activities, communities are being mobilised to think about and address their own concerns and issues that affect them.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 17
The Team first carries out the situational analysis including the knowledge about community culture and norms and their current needs related to psychosocial support. It is important to note that people who know the most about the needs of the community are the community members themselves. Consequently, the situational analysis is done with the help of community members, with special care to ensure representation by all of the community subgroups (elders, women, youths, children, tribes, caste, etc.). Communities are given chance to prioritise their needs. Teams first find out how people cope with the current situation and than prioritise their needs accordingly. The emphasis of this programme is on how members can support each other. Team uses different techniques such as community mapping and describe situation and networks. “Community Based Psychosocial Services in Humanitarian Assistance” – a Facilitators Guide by ACT International is also being used as a key material to provide psychosocial care and protection to affected communities.
A range of psychosocial support activities are being held to strengthen coping capacities of individuals and families as well. Part of the psychosocial support programme is to conduct supportive talks, trainings and recreational activities for children. To address the need of a feasible venue for these activities, the Community Support Centre is envisioned being the focal point for community members to interact and provide continuing support to every member. Apart from this, the six Centres also serve as a venue for other community activities included in the Recovery Programme which include the conduct of different training programmes for women, UC leaders, Community-Based Organisations (CBOs) and other community members. To maximise the availability of these Community Support Centres and ensure ownership amongst communities, UC leaders, CBOs and religious clergy are also permitted to utilise the centres for their meetings and other social activities. A Memorandum of Understanding is forged between CWS/NCA/CoS and communities to ensure proper management of the Centre and its sustainability in the future. Transition or Exit Strategy
It is hoped that families supported by the PSST will continue to adjust to the circumstances of their post-disaster lives. The enhancement of the social network will re-strengthen their relations with each other and afterwards they will continue sharing their experiences with each other. PSST will organise community volunteers and train them as support groups who will work with the team and will eventually be organised to assume responsibility over the management of Community Support Centres. This will ensure ownership and future sustainability of the activities and the centres as well.
CAPACITY BUILDING OF CWS/NCA/COS STAFF/PARTNERS/LOCAL GOVERNMENT &
COMMUNITIES
Rationale for Revision and Extension : Like other components, the Capacity Building Programme (CBP) also suffered from similar reasons that caused delays in the over all implementation. To begin with, there was an extensive delay in issuance of NOCs from ERRA. The other causes were security, weather conditions and limited access to target areas due to frequent landslides. In the recent period, it has been noted that there has been significant development taking place at the government level following the creation of the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA). The need to proactively build capacities of local government representatives has been recognised and addressed and would require stakeholders to harness the capacities of community leaders enabling them to embrace and acknowledge these structural changes. The strengthening of the Disaster Response Committees is envisioned to ensure continuity and sustainability of the Programme. In the forthcoming months, the Committees will be encouraged to take the lead and spearhead the various DRR activities in their respective UCs in coordination with the District Disaster Management Authority. The extended time line will be also utilised to develop Disaster Management Plans for the targeted UCs which will be shared to the district government. The DM Plans will guide the communities with the appropriate response mechanism required in disasters and emergency situations.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 18
As an added initiative, CBP aims to expand its target clientele by conducting Puppet Shows in all the targeted UCs that will generate the interest of children as well as developing Colouring Books, with messages in the form of rhymes that will communicate disaster preparedness messages in a more child- friendly manner, and a School Safety Programme. Training on Sphere Standards among staff and partners and even communities will be held as well to enhance commitment towards quality and accountability in disaster response. Beneficiaries/Targets
CBP will now have more than 3,174 people directly benefiting from the training. � 1,500 community people will be trained in disaster management and risk reduction. � 144 union councillors from the 12 UCs covered by ASPK 61 will be trained in disaster management, risk
reduction, good governance and recovery planning. � 250 people from CWS/NCA/CoS Mansehra staff and partner organisations will be trained in 26 training
sessions in various areas from organisational skills to disaster management. � Puppet shows on disaster preparedness will be conducted targeting 1,200 children from 12 UCs. � Retrofitting and School Safety Programmes for 40 selected schools in Mansehra. � 20 individuals will be trained in Sphere and 60 more to benefit from Sphere Orientation Sessions. There are 300,00013 indirect beneficiaries in the 12 UCs where CWS P/A will provide disaster response/preparedness equipment.
Goal : To strengthen and enhance the coping capacities of earthquake affected communities, UC representatives, CWS/NCA/CoS staff and implementing partners.
Objectives:
- Enhance and develop skills, knowledge and experience of CWS/NCA/CoS programme staff and partners. - Build the capacities of UC representatives to play an effective role in the rehabilitation of disaster affected
communities. - Enhance ability of the communities to prepare for and mitigate disasters through different training events
and other capacity building activities. - Form and equip disaster response committees at each of the 12 UCs covered under ASPK 61. - Enhance the children’s understanding on risks and disasters by using interactive activities like puppet
shows that could stimulate better understanding and positive change in behaviour. - Create school environment resilient to multiple hazards through both structural and non-structural
mitigation as well as awareness raising for both students and teachers. - Improve the quality and accountability of the response mechanisms by ensuring that all relevant
agencies/partners are provided the opportunity to develop their awareness and practice in relation to Sphere Standards.
Expected Results and Activities
a. 250 CWS/NCA/CoS staff and partners provided with training � Identify training needs, development of training curriculum and materials. � Contact and engage resource persons. � Conduct need based trainings to include, but not limited to, the following subjects: Gender, PRA,
Communication and Presentation skills, Project Management, Time Management, Supplies Management, Sphere Standards, Report Writing, Financial Management, Community Mobilisation, Leadership, Stress Management, PM&E, Disaster Risk Management, etc.
b. 144 Councillors from 12 UCs are able to take part on the rehabilitation of disaster affected communities: � Identify and mobilise Union Councillors for training. � Develop training materials and identify resource persons. � Train participants in Disaster Management and Recovery/Contingency planning. � Monitoring and Evaluation.
13 The average population of each UC is 25,000
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 19
c. Communities from 12 UCs are able to actively participate in disaster planning and mitigation as well as in other disaster related activities
� Select villages for interventions. � Mobilise communities for training. � Develop training materials and identify resource persons. � Identify venue for training. � Train selected community groups in the field of disaster response/disaster planning. � Monitoring and Evaluation.
d. Puppet shows conducted for 1,200 children � Identify target schools and beneficiaries. � Conduct orientation sessions with teachers and school children on puppet shows. � Prepare and identify venues for the shows. � Finalise ToR and Agreement with puppet groups. � Monitoring and Evaluation.
e. School Safety: Retrofitting and Training for Students and Teachers with school equipment and information materials
� Collation and verification of data. � Assessment and selection of target areas. � Conduct meetings and consultation. � Designing, planning and implementation. � Develop students and teachers training module. � Printing and distribution of information materials. � Conduct training. � Distribution of school equipments, furniture and fixtures. � Monitoring and Evaluation. f. Sphere Training and Orientation Courses conducted for 80 individuals
� Designing of tools. � Identification of participants. � Preparation and finalisation of training/workshop arrangements. � Monitoring and Evaluation.
Implementation Strategy
Training for Staff and Partners: A range of capacity building interventions are planned. Capacity building sessions are being conducted on interviewing skills, procurement, logistics, feedback giving and receiving, facilitation skills and more. Additional capacity building activities will be conducted; new information, knowledge and skill needs and resources are identified. A range of cross cutting themes, and core capability framework and leadership courses will be conducted. The course will also include field trips to disaster affected areas and presentations by professionals from the international and national NGOs and other stakeholders. Training of Union Councillors: The purpose of this activity is to learn practical skills related to the development of Disaster Management Plans (DMPs), giving emphasis on risk reduction and preparedness. It includes some of the latest risk reduction initiatives highlighted within the International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (ISDR), together with other programmes adopted by INGOs and other agencies in Pakistan. After an initial introduction to Disaster Management (DM) work, the range of practical skills required to prepare DMPs are introduced. The workshops do not only build people’s understanding bout disasters but also enable them to develop contingency plans for their respective communities.
a. Disaster Management Plans: A participatory approach will be used in developing the Plan involving the elected officials who have participated in the workshop. The DM Plan will outline all hazards and threats faced by the communities and enlist the various levels of risks and vulnerabilities. The communities and
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 20
their officials will develop appropriate response mechanism or action plan to address the threat and reduce the risks.
b. Training for communities: While UCs are the first to participate in these Disaster Management workshops, similar sessions are conducted at the village level. The basic content of the session remains the same, but instead of three-day long sessions, the interventions are conducted two days. Community members of 12 UCs are participating in these sessions and some of them have produced DM Plans to guide the rebuilding of their communities.
c. Puppet Shows and Colouring Books for Children: The Puppet Shows will be an add-on activity for children. Each show will run for approximately 45 minutes with themes evolving around the concept of disaster preparedness. To ensure full participation and interaction between the puppeteers and the children, there will be series of ‘question and answer’ portion. The show will be tailored in such a way that is culturally acceptable. The participating children will receive colouring books after each puppet show.
d. School Safety Programme: The School Safety Programme will include aspects of retrofitting and school safety training involving both the students and the teachers within the context of risks, hazards, vulnerability and raise awareness on the need for disaster preparedness. School facilities like chairs, tables, safety kits and other learning equipments and materials will be provided to strengthen and support the educational system.
A specialised group from the Disaster Response Team of CWS/NCA/CoS will spearhead the implementation and management of this activity. An expert will be involved in the whole planning process and will conduct regular monitoring to ensure that the principles of safety and engineering are properly adhered to. CWS-P/A will liaise and coordinate with the Donor Sponsorship Cell of ERRA and with the Education Sector at the District level as well as with the DRU. School officials will be involved in the whole process and graduates of the Artisans Training, especially the masons and carpenters will be mobilised for the retrofitting of the targeted schools.
Sphere Training: CWS-P/A has been designated as the Sphere Focal Point for Pakistan and had been collaborating with HAP International and INEE on raising awareness on ‘quality and accountability’ with regards to the delivery of humanitarian assistance. In the recent past, CWS-P/A also served as Sphere Focal Point for Afghanistan as well. Humanitarian aid workers and partners with commitment and capacity to share and disseminate the value and importance of understanding the Sphere Standards will be invited for the Training of Trainers’ Course and will be expected to replicate by conducting Sphere Orientation Sessions within their respective areas of operation, with CWS/NCA/CoS providing technical support and fund allocation. The Training of Trainers’ Course will be conducted at international level maintaining close coordination with the Sphere Office while the Orientation Sessions will be more localised using the local language. The Sphere Focal Person will conduct monitoring visits to all partners to evaluate the progress of work specific to the dissemination of Sphere Standards in disaster response planning. Transition or Exit Strategy: The emphasis on capacity building of staff and partners will enable them to work more effectively with the local communities, who, in time will be able to take on more responsibilities for programme implementation and maintenance. The DM Plans along with disaster response kits will be handed over to Disaster Response Committees, which comprises UC leaders in the presence of the District Disaster Management Authority, representatives from the ERRA and District Coordination Officer. CWS/NCA/CoS will work closely with COMSATS Abbottabad Educational Institution, which has the disaster management expertise along with department of Development Studies. CWS/NCA/CoS and COMSATS will facilitate the development of DM Plans with UC leaders and community members. CWS P/A will involve COMSATS Community Development Unit in ensuring continuity of the work initiated with communities especially in the area of research and DM.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 21
Proper turn over will be conducted by CWS/NCA/CoS where the Disaster Response Committees and community members will continue to work more proactively on disaster preparedness and disaster risk reduction through follow up plans and linking them with the appropriate government bodies at the District and UC level. Booklets, hardware materials and equipment will be kept by the community and the children and will also serve as a long term visual aid even after CWS/NCA/CoS team exits. The school administration will be involved and empowered right from the beginning, so that they will be able to assume responsibility in sustaining the various activities that were developed and implemented.
SUSTAINABLE LIVELIHOODS
Rationale for Revision and Extension
Construction Trade Training Centres (CTTCs): The training for artisans is one of the most successful components of the programme. The CTTCs have been an over subscribed programme, where there is an increasing demand and a long term need for more technically trained artisans. Most of the time, the applicants have always outnumbered the places available in each training course. The CTTCs provide excellent training and the certification is endorsed by the Technical Trade Testing Board. Almost 100 percent of the CTTC graduates are employed and their success stories have been covered by leading newspapers. Further extension in CTTCs will enable us to train additional 210 individuals. ERRA is going to build the new Balakot City and the time for the completion of this project is estimated to take five years. Therefore, there will be huge demand of skilled labour and CWS P/A trainees will be able to utilise their skills as means of livelihood near their respective homes. The extension period will help find organisations and agencies who will be willing to take over and continue with the training of the artisans. Sustainable Livelihood Programme for Widows: Implementation of this component has been carried out together with partner ODC. During implementation, the teams found that veterinarian services in target areas are almost non-existence due to isolation and remote locations. The animal raising practice has not been altered for centuries. It is important that both these issues are addressed for a successful implementation of the project, and for increased impact on beneficiaries. Further, as mentioned in the previously, the release of the NOC from ERRA was also delayed. In the proposed revision, 600 new beneficiaries will be identified and the criteria for selection will now include male headed households who are equally vulnerable. With the livestock programme extended until November 2008, the beneficiaries and their community members will: � Have extended access to improved veterinarian services. 4 mobile veterinarian teams will operate from
veterinarian centres (to be established). The centres will also be a starting point for other programmes within ASPK 61, e.g. hygiene promotion, capacity building, etc.
� Benefit from continuous training on hygiene promotion, raising techniques, livestock management and income generation, as well as the surrounding communities.
� Learn to develop linkages with the outer markets to sell their products. � Manage and own animal resource bank and get benefit for them.
Beneficiaries/Targets:
a) Construction Trade Training Centres: 1,995 men will benefit from the Artisans Training Course.
b) Sustainable Livelihood Programme for Widows:
� 1,600 vulnerable female and male headed households provided with livestock as means for income generation and additional.
� 300 widows and women headed household will benefit from the animal resource pool. There will be a total of 3,895 direct beneficiaries from average households of average seven people and approximately some 27,265 individuals as secondary beneficiaries.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 22
Construction of Trade Training Centres: Goal: To enhance skills and knowledge among the male population and help them to seek out employment opportunities as skilled labourers.
Objectives:
� Conduct trades training for 1,995 men in two districts. � Enhance competitiveness of trained men in the job market.
Livestock Provision Programme:
Goal: To increase livelihoods for vulnerable men and women headed families and to decrease level of dependency on immediate aid and on their extended families.
Objectives:
� Provide income generation opportunities to widows and women headed families. � Facilitate the recovery of local livestock based livelihoods. � Encourage local livestock markets and labour markets by increasing the demand. � Provide skills training to 1,000 widows and women headed families in two districts in livestock care and
management. � Develop an animal resource pool to cater for 300 additional widows/women headed families.
Expected Results and Activities:
a. Construction Trades Training Centres: 1,995 skilled men able to have advantage and access to job opportunities.
���� Identify and utilise existing CTTCs. ���� Develop and review construction trades syllabus. ���� Recruit and hire field officers and instructors. ���� Conduct testing and accreditation of CTTCs instructors. ���� Arrange examination for trainees. ���� Registration and certification of graduates with the NWFP trade testing board. ���� Procurement of CTTCs materials and kits. ���� Recruitment and screening of CTTCs participants. ���� Conduct construction trade training courses. ���� Distribution of tool kits to participants. ���� Arrange graduation ceremonies. ���� Prepare press releases/ads. ���� Conduct monitoring/field visits. ���� Monitoring, evaluation and reporting.
b. Enhancement courses organised and implemented among trainees and instructors through linkages
with HRC/SDC
���� Liaise and coordinate with HRC/SDC. ���� Ground preparation for conducting Enhancement Courses for trainees and instructors. ���� Monitoring and Evaluation.
c. Livestock Provision Programme : 1,600 men and women are able to generate additional income/savings of at least Rs. 1,000/month.
���� Selection of 1,600 vulnerable families. ���� Briefing/orientation to beneficiaries about the project. ���� Identify specific breed of livestock to be distributed. ���� Purchase and distribute livestock to women/families. ���� Vaccination and de-worming of livestock. ���� Provide fodder to beneficiaries. ���� Provide follow-up vaccination and veterinary services for the livestock.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 23
d. Number of livestock increased within the selected areas as compared to baseline information (June 2006) ���� Conduct livestock survey. ���� Compile and utilise survey results.
e. 1,000 women and their households are engaged with the outside market. ���� Conduct assessment and project monitoring. ���� Assist women/families to identify target market for the livestock. ���� Monitor and document progress of the project.
f. 1,000 households have an increased knowledge on technical skills and environmental awareness. ���� Conduct TNAs. ���� Conduct workshop among women on environmental management. ���� Continuing assessment and monitoring of the project. ���� Prepare update and progress reports on project implementation. ���� Conduct skills training for the beneficiaries on livestock management including handling and disposal of
waste.
g. Increased level of self esteem and confidence among women in community affairs as measured by interviews and surveys.
���� Conduct skills enhancement workshop for the widows/women headed families. ���� Conduct information/experience sharing among beneficiaries.
Implementation Strategy
Construction Trade Training Centres: The data collected by the M&E Team is indicative of the fact that people not only lost their lives but their livelihoods had also been destroyed by 8 October 2005 earthquake. To address this problem, CWS/NCA/CoS established CTTCs to provide people, means for sustainable livelihoods. The training on different trades and tool kits provide them skills and means, so they can better find jobs and/or work independently. CWS/NCA/CoS realised that in the current situation, when reconstruction of houses by the humanitarian community has been banned by the government, it is important to train tradesmen as they are required in the reconstruction process. The livelihoods development programme provides basic construction trades training for men in five trades including masonry, carpentry, electricity, welding and plumbing. Specific tools for each trade have also been procured and are being used. It is anticipated that all of the graduates will easily find employment in other construction activities in the province. The trainees are being given government approved certificates and will keep the sets of tools they are using during the training course. The training curriculum is according to the ERRA livelihood recovery plan. CWS/NCA/CoS also arranges knowledge enhancement trainings from Housing Reconstruction Centres (HRC) of the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC). The graduates are also being recommended to government and other line departments and organisations/institutions for employment. The project review indicates that some of the people trained in the centres have been recruited by ERRA and many agencies like ACTED, UNDP and International Medical Corps. Some of them have started their own work and are using their acquired skills. Livestock Provision Programme: As part of its assessment work, the ODC together with ASPK 61 M&E Team has identified vulnerable groups, i.e. female headed households who will be served with livestock till the end of September 2008. The livelihoods programme is also supporting animal rearing considering the loss of livestock in the Mansehra and Battagram districts and establishment of veterinary mobile centres and animal resource bank. In brief, the implementation strategy will ensure that: ���� all beneficiaries participate in all stages of the project cycle. ���� Beneficiaries’ contributions will always be welcome and a sense of ownership will be created in the
community through participation and dialogue.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 24
���� The community will be empowered to make decisions for themselves through the organisation of communities and through focal persons.
���� Awareness will be raised about health and hygiene as well as environmental issues through training and community meetings.
���� Local resources (like club houses) will be utilised whenever possible.
Animal Resource Pool/Goat bank: Apart from the distribution of the goats, a billy-goat was also rotated among the beneficiaries. It was agreed that every beneficiary will turn over the first 2 offspring to the animal resource pool, the Goat Bank. It is expected that by the end of the first 12 months since the livestock distribution took place, approximately 600 offspring will have been born and will be distributed to new sets of beneficiaries - not necessarily widows of female headed households but also men who have become paralyzed due to the earthquake and are currently with no source of livelihood. Basic animal health services will be provided to ensure animals are healthy. Families will receive basic training in animal husbandry practices. Each family is expected to turn over two young animals to the animal bank for the whole duration of the project. These will be distributed to an additional 300 target families. The milk products – milk, cheese and yogurt – can be sold/utilised in the immediate vicinity of the family’s home and will provide a small but reliable source of income. Monitoring efforts of the M&E Team will help determine if the programme should be extended into other areas and for a longer time. Efforts will be done to link beneficiaries to market so they can sell the by products from livestock. Under the environmental protection component, beneficiaries will also be given awareness on different environmental prevention and protection component including waste management, using sanitation facilities etc.
Veterinary Services by Trained Staff: Trained veterinary staff has been hired to deliver health care services for the livestock. Medicines and vaccination are being provided to cure or prevent diseases among animals. Disease outbreaks are investigated to provide diagnosis and treatment services. Veterinary doctors also entertain emergency calls from the beneficiaries.
Transition or Exit Strategy
a) Construction Trades Training Centres: The Trade Training Centres that CWS/NCA/CoS established aim to provide people with the means to develop sustainable livelihoods. The training courses provide skills and training kits to provide the basic means to utilise the skills learnt in the market place and better enable people to find jobs and/or work independently. The courses will provide life skills for 1,995 men. The application of skills beyond the period of the programme is a matter of individual effort and initiative. If the need for trained tradesmen has been met, the Mansehra centre will revert to its owner. The other two centres will most likely be turned over to local communities if possible. For example City Nazim Battagram expressed that it will run CTTC Battagram after CWS/NCA/CoS leaves. CWS P/A local partner, the Hashoo Foundation, is interested in continuing CTTC Bissian. CWS/NCA/CoS also coordinates with graduates of CTTCs in referring them to the government, line departments and organisations/institutions for employment. The project review indicates that ERRA and many agencies like ACTED and International Medical Corps recruited people trained in the Centres. Some of them have started their own businesses using the skills learned. Many in the earthquake-affected areas started constructing their own houses. The trained men from the CTTCs are not only able to use their relevant skills in constructing their own houses, but also informally transfer knowledge to other community members. b) Livestock Provision Programme: Other aspects of livelihoods support may continue under local management, assuming the “goat bank” concept is well established. The intention is to prepare local expertise to continue to support the distribution of new animals. When CWS/NCA/CoS will exit from the current work, the organisation will hand over the facilities and the programme to the Government Livestock Department with medicines and the mobile centres in place.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 25
WATER, SANITATION & HYGIENE PROMOTION
The full implementation and management of the water, sanitation and hygiene promotion component of the Appeal will be taken over by NCA, this being NCA’s line of competency. CWS-P/A will provide the co-partner with the required administration support to ensure efficient and successful implementation of the programme. CWS/NCA/CoS will likewise ensure that this specific component of the Appeal is interlinked and will compliment the rest of the programme activities to ensure a holistic approach in the overall programming.
Rationale for Revision and Extension
Due to ERRA Policies the extension of the programme will only be until the end of July 2008. The targets will be augmented 51 WSS benefiting from 25 additional WSS (on top of the original target of 26 schemes now completed). Target numbers of beneficiaries will depend on the size of the schemes allocated by ERRA. The Hygiene Promotion follows the WatSanN component: the HP team moves in wherever WatSan has rehabilitated or is in process of rehabilitating the WSS. The HP team will however not be able to cover all the WatSan schemes within the extension and aims at reaching a target of 60,000 beneficiaries14 covered by 31 schemes. This adds another 5 schemes to the original target of 26 schemes. The target related to the construction of latrines is largely left because of programmatic reasons – the main reasons being that the rehabilitation/reconstruction of WSS has been given priority within a team with limited capacity. With the extension of the appeal, the remaining period will be used to fulfil commitments made on completing ongoing and promised WSS.
Beneficiaries
a) Water and Sanitation
� Rehabilitation / construction of 51 WSS. � Construction of 10 pours flush toilets/washrooms for Widows Colony, Kashtara Camp.
b) Hygiene Promotion � Hygiene promotion activities will cover a total of 31 schemes, covering a targeted population of 60,000
beneficiaries. � 4,200 students within the target areas will be sensitised on modern hygiene practices approximately. � 5,000 families will benefit from hygiene kits. � 31 Villages/550 volunteers will be organised into Village Hygiene Committees.
Project area for the remaining period
Water and Sanitation
District Union Council Schemes
Mohandri Baila Jared, Bhalla to Kuhar Bazar Baila, Buttan Upper, Lower, Ganja Baila, Ochri Nalla to Dehri Ochri, Shaik to Buttan, Dhanoo
Mansehra
Kaghan Kannari to Lohar Banda, Chitta Pani to Naran, Rawalakot, Jabeian, Baila, Bari Phagal, Hujra Ratta Parr Phagal, Jabbi to Phagal Bazar, Seri to Lower Phagal
Hygiene Promotion
District Union Council Villages
Mohandri Yet to be selected Mansehra
Kaghan Yet to be selected
a) Water and Sanitation
Goal: To provide safe, quality water in the earthquake affected areas.
14 The target is reduced from the original target of 75,000 beneficiaries. The reported number of beneficiaries up until 31
st Jan 2008 was based
on ERRA estimations which tend to be over-estimated. The estimated number of beneficiaries for the remaining villages will therefore be reduced to give a final target of 60,000 beneficiaries. The villages in the planned area of UC Mohandri and Kaghan are also expected to be smaller than the villages already covered.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 26
Objectives:
- Provide clean and safe water to families and communities in the earthquake affected areas of Mansehra and Battagram districts.
- Lower the number of cases of water-borne diseases in the target areas.
b) Hygiene Promotion Goal: To improve environmental and personal hygiene practices of families in the earthquake affected areas of districts Battagram and Mansehra.
Objectives:
���� Reduce the number of persons infected by diseases due to poor hygiene practices. ���� Assist families and communities in ensuring a clean and safe environment through the following: ���� Increasing the number of people with the ability to store clean and safe water as long as possible. ���� Increasing the number of persons with the awareness of the dangers of a dirty environment. ���� Increase the number of people washing hands after toilet use, before eating and after eating. ���� Assist people to become aware of desirable health and hygiene practices. ���� Distribute household and hygiene materials to 5,000 families in the target areas. ���� Decrease and prevent outbreak of diseases related to unhygienic practices. ���� Strengthen communication lines between families/communities and the hygiene promotion team members.
Expected Results and Activities
Water and Sanitation:
a. Clean and safe water is made available as per the Sphere Standards to WSS for villages in Mansehra
and Battagram districts.
���� Obtain clearances and permits required from landlords and government. ���� Coordinate with government line agencies and NGOs/INGOs to avoid overlapping and duplication. ���� Conduct timely damage and needs assessments in the target area(s). ���� Select and hire contractors according to need to undertake the physical works. ���� Repair/rehabilitate damaged water schemes. ���� Establish or/ and strengthen Community Water Committees (CWCs). ���� Setting up of water treatment arrangements in concert with CWCs. ���� Undertake water quality testing for WSS. ���� Conduct regular monitoring and re-assessment of repair/rehabilitation work. ���� Handover completed projects to the beneficiary communities. ���� Develop an exit strategy to enhance sustainability.
b. Long term (sustainable) community access to clean and safe water in villages is achieved. ���� Setting up CWCs. ���� Train CWCs in water management and maintenance techniques.
Hygiene Promotion
c. Clean and hygienic environment is made available to all families and communities in earthquake affected areas.
���� Obtain clearance, permits required from landlords and government. ���� Coordinate with government line agencies and NGOs/INGOs to avoid duplication and overlapping. ���� Conduct damage and needs assessments in the targeted areas. ���� Establish criteria for selection of beneficiaries. ���� Conduct sessions on the promotion of health and hygiene practices.
d. The understanding of school children, teachers and other family members on the importance of hygiene practices is improved and strengthened.
���� Develop hygiene training curriculum. ���� Liaise with school heads and teachers on hygiene training for teachers and students. ���� Train core group/HP volunteers to conduct training sessions.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 27
���� Establish training schedule. ���� Conduct hygiene awareness sessions. ���� Conduct workshops, clean day, and dramatisation sessions for school children. ���� Monitor post training activities. ���� Evaluate training impact.
e. Hygiene practices of families from the villages are improved. ���� Undertake a hygiene needs’ assessment. ���� Select and identify the beneficiaries to receive hygiene kits. ���� Provide information and educate the beneficiaries on hygiene. ���� Distribute household hygiene kits. ���� Monitor and report.
f. Reduced incidence/cases of hygiene related diseases in villages. ���� Undertake health assessment. ���� Gather and verify data. ���� Conduct awareness building on proper sanitation and good hygiene practices. ���� Develop information materials on sanitation and hygiene practices. ���� Monitor behavioural changes. ���� Facilitate meetings with community leaders, women and selected members . g. Strong collaboration and partnership between CWS/NCA/CoS and families/communities is developed. ���� Conduct meetings with communities. ���� Sign MOUs with beneficiaries/ communities. ���� Liaise with local officials, community leaders, women and others. ���� Conduct monitoring and evaluation. ���� Prepare progress and interim reports. ���� Encourage women to participate in programme implementation.
h. 31 villages or 550 volunteers organised at Village Hygiene Committees. ���� Selection of villages from the areas covered by the WatSan Programme. ���� Liaise and coordinate with community elders and water committees. ���� Conduct community mobilisation. ���� Conduct trainings. ���� Reporting, monitoring and evaluation
i. Decreased incidence of water-borne diseases in the target areas. ���� WatSan team conveys water scheme plan and timetable to Hygiene Promotion Team (HPT). ���� HPT conducts baseline survey/data gathering on water-borne diseases in the targeted communities. ���� HPT establishes Village Hygiene Committees (VHCs) made up of village volunteers. ���� HPT trains VHC on basic hygiene practices. ���� HPT and VHC conduct hygiene awareness sessions. ���� Monitor and evaluate hygiene practices.
Implementation strategy
Repairing Water Supply Networks: While initial focus was on villages determined to have borne the brunt of destruction, subsequent assessments and reviews have led to the focus being placed on communities as the unit of operation rather than villages. One water scheme can serve multiple villages. The extension of the programme’s lifespan to the 31 July 2008 has in turn allowed the increase of activities to cover 51 WSS communities. Repair work will continue to include the replacement of damaged water tanks, cleaning of reservoirs, replacement of broken pipes, construction of ponds and water supply stations. Springs in the village vicinity will be located and tapped. Storage tanks will be set up and distribution pipes laid to the beneficiaries. Unlike in the past when the ERRA policy allowed rehabilitation and construction from the source up to a central location, the current requirement provides for the terminal distribution to the individual beneficiaries. This practice naturally entails increased expenditure and more time per water scheme.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 28
Following recommendations by an external consultant, a greater use of building contractors in the rehabilitation/reconstruction of WSS has been encouraged. Owing to the value capacity building contributes to the partner communities, the current method calls for greater community involvement not be set aside. A hybrid approach combining the use of contractors and another making use of local skilled labour will be pursued. The selection of specific designs for use in the area, location of local masons to assist in water scheme reconstruction and equipping local people with tools and technical guidelines to maintain and repair WSS will also be part of the approach. Hygiene Promotion: The Hygiene Promotion activities are initiated in the areas selected for WSS. Activities begin with project staff carrying out research to identify the base knowledge and resources within the community. The research findings provide the basis for the development of a customised hygiene promotion programme. Hygiene promoters/facilitators are recruited and trained from within the community. Basic messages for the correct use of latrines, water sources, kitchen utensils and health and hygiene kits are then designed and delivered. These are promptly disseminated through community meetings, school lessons, posters and models posted at common points, as well as through word of mouth. Child-to-child activities in the schools are being used to raise awareness.
Delivery of Hygiene Kits: The HPT links with the PSST which has been interacting with women groups affected by the earthquake. This team has discovered a link between stresses associated with the non-availability of services catering to their biological needs. In collaboration with the HPT, hygiene kits are delivered to distressed women to provide them with means to meet their hygiene needs. The hygiene kit is assembled based on the Sphere Minimum Standards and local conditions.
Winterisation (Kashtara Camp): It is assumed that at the outset of winter, the living condition amongst families affected by the earthquake will further deteriorate and will add a lot to the miseries already being felt especially among residents of high altitude areas. The tattered tents which have been used since the beginning of the emergency period may not resist the winter’s snow. The situation is expected to be further aggravated by road blockage due to snow and landslides. Predictions that the population will start downward migration to escape the harsh winter climate while not having habitable homes would result into more IDPs. The Winterisation Programme aims to cover the WatSan needs of IDPs who will be relocated to a camp which will be assigned to CWS/NCA/CoS by the district government. The focus areas of the winter response will be on the following: � Provision of safe drinking water. � Construct adequate sanitation facility. � Conduct hygiene promotion activities and cleanliness campaign.
Transition or Exit Strategy
It has been assessed that major water schemes have been badly damaged by the earthquake and to repair them is a huge challenge for government and humanitarian actors. The restoration of water to affected communities in a manner that is sustainable is the key and guarantee for long term health benefits. Through the CWCs, for which also training will be conducted, it is hoped the WSS rehabilitated/reconstructed will continue to operate at the same high level of performance long after CWS/NCA/CoS has pulled out. The hygiene education being undertaken will hopefully become part of the community body of knowledge to be passed on to offspring and others. CWS/NCA/CoS, after repairing water schemes in selected communities will handover the responsibility of repairing and maintenance to the TMA or any other relevant authority or entity. The outcome of this handover shall remain a fully functioning Water Management Committee.
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Rationale for Revision and Extension: Because of slow and low receipts in the first six months, it was decided and communicated to ACT CO that the Environmental Protection Programme will be initiated when adequate funding will be made available.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 29
With the extension of the programme until December 2008, all targets in the original Appeal can be met with slight changes to the approach which excludes the construction of latrines as well as increasing the number of field staff to make up for the lost time. Likewise, with the extended period, additional 6 more villages will be added to the original targets coming up to a total of 32 villages.
Goal: To enhance the knowledge and skills of families and communities in earthquake affected areas on environmental conservation and protection.
Objectives:
���� Enhance the knowledge and raise awareness of communities on environmental protection. ���� Develop information materials on environment conservation and protection. ���� Conduct plantation activities among families and communities to protect the environment.
Beneficiaries/Targets
� Inhabitants of 32 selected villages will enhance their knowledge on environmental awareness by different methods including workshops/trainings, development and dissemination of informative material on environmental awareness.
� 5,000 families will directly benefit from the plantation of fruit trees. � 1,500 women will be trained on waste management. � 1,500 children will be invited to watch/participate in puppet/theatre shows.
Expected Results and Activities
a. 164 workshops in 32 villages (2 workshops/village) on waste management, plantation and environment protection conducted; 1,500 women provided training on waste management and other environmental
issues; and 1,500 children exposed to environmental protection messages through puppet and theatre
shows and provision of tool kits.
���� Conduct social/ground preparation among target villages. ���� Identify target households/families/children. ���� Develop course/training module on environmental conservation and protection. ���� Develop training schedule. ���� Identify training/workshop venues. ���� Document training/workshop proceedings. ���� Identify schools for puppet shows. ���� Engage the services of artists for puppet shows. ���� Finalise ToR and agreement with theatre and puppet groups. ���� Distribution of 1,500 children tool kits among school children. ���� Monitoring and Evaluation. b. Two sets of posters, three brochures for communities and a manual on waste management for programme stage are developed, printed and distributed.
���� Conceptualise and finalise manual, posters and brochures. ���� Compose , design and lay-out the relevant publications. ���� Identification of printers. ���� Print and distribute them to relevant beneficiaries. ���� Documentation, monitoring and evaluation.
c. 25,000 fruit trees are provided and planted by 5,000 households in 32 villages of District Mansehra. ���� Conduct assessment. ���� Identify families and plantation sites. ���� Select and distribute appropriate fruit trees to families. ���� Training of staff on fruit plantation/orchard management. ���� Training of staff on kitchen gardening. ���� Training of staff on nursery raising.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 30
���� Conduct awareness sessions on new techniques of plantation for families. ���� Establish 16 demonstration plots in 8 UCs (2 per UC) with the support of communities. ���� Monitor households/widows on waste management and tree planting activities. ���� Distribute fertilisers and tools for plantation of trees. ���� Monitoring and Evaluation.
Implementation Strategy: The NWFP environment is very diverse in nature and of significant importance for the country’s economy and livelihoods of the local people. People rely on the forest for fodder for their livestock, timber for houses, and above all wood for fuel. In addition, people collect non timber forests products for use at the household level and for cash income. Nowadays, forest depletion is one of the most serious environmental issues in NWFP. The cutting of trees for fuel and lumber has been identified by several professional damage assessment personnel as one of the reasons for some of the landslides caused by the earthquake. It has been identified that the environment of NWFP and AJK is badly affected by the 8th October 2005 earthquake and later due to current monsoon, landslides and flash floods have again affected these communities. In an effort to raise awareness on environmental protection, to enhance the local environment and to protect and hold the soil in place, CWS/NCA/CoS will provide five trees of successful indigenous fruit to each family. Initial assistance will be provided to assure proper planting and tree care guidance will be offered to selected households. In addition to this, 64 workshops in 32 villages (2 per village) on environmental protection and prevention will also be conducted with community members. 1,500 widows or married women will be trained on animal manure/waste management and environmental protection as a part of women livelihoods programme. Information, Education and Communication (IEC) materials on environment conservation and protection will be developed and disseminated among communities. Pesticides/fertilisers and plantation tools will also be given to communities according to need. Children exposed to puppet and theatre shows will be provided with awareness raising kits which include colour box, colouring books, waste bin, umbrella, school bags and chocolate packets.
Transition or Exit Strategy
CWS/NCA/CoS will provide knowledge on environmental protection and prevention to communities affected by earthquake. Sessions with teachers will have a cascading effect and help in dissemination of knowledge to children and communities. Development and dissemination of materials in the local language will also help them refresh their knowledge. Teachers will be motivated to include these in their daily lectures. Plantations will help in restoring the environment. CWS/NCA/CoS will negotiate with village committees to take responsibility for the provided trees. Forestry departments will also be involved and motivated to provide environmental protection to these communities. In order to ensure the sustainability of the programme/activities, continuous monitoring and technical support will be provided to communities by Environmental Protection Programme (EPP) staff and active/trained volunteers. The staff will make regular field/monitoring visits especially after the plantation in order to provide technical support to the communities as baby plants need a lot of care for the first 90 days after plantation. Formats will be developed as monitoring tools to collect data of successful plantation. The same strategy will be followed for the components of waste-management. During the training on waste-management, the staff will also give training to communities on composting which will also require 90 days for technical support, through follow-up visits and monitoring. The continuous capacity building of active volunteers will also help in making the programme sustainable. After getting various trainings (including on-the-job trainings), the volunteers will be able to continue with the various activities, even after programme closure.
PRIMARY & SECONDARY HEALTH SERVICES
Rationale for Revision and Extension
The extension of the health programme is needed because the governmental health system is not (yet) in position to take over due to the following reasons:
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 31
���� The health sector suffered extensive damage as a result of the earthquake. ���� The Health Ministry capacity to supply services and to respond to health needs of its population has
diminished significantly, particularly in the earthquake-affected central and northern region of NWFP and AJK/Rawalakot, where many health units and ambulatory units have been abandoned or have significantly reduced operations.
���� This situation is compounded by the population’s reduced access to functioning facilities due to the damaged road network, land slides and land erosions.
���� The performance of the district health system is at risk of losing ground, threatening recent gains in health status.
The government has planned, in collaboration with donor agencies, a recovery programme in which health structures and services will be restored gradually in the next few years. The requested extension will enable CWS/NCA/CoS to keep the health facilities open for an extended period of time, in places where it is expected that the government is not in a position at the moment to take over, ensuring access to basic health facilities for inhabitants of the remote and earthquake struck areas of NWFP and AJK.
Beneficiaries/Targets
���� Community (primary and secondary health) services will be provided to approximately 170,000 individuals in NWFP and 50,000 in AJK through the BHUs, MHUs and laboratory services.
���� 50 Health Houses will be constructed in Mansehra to be identified by the Health Department with approximately 50,000 beneficiaries.
Goal: To revitalise health service for the affected communities through primary and secondary health care approach.
Objectives:
a) NWFP Health Programme
���� Provide preventive and essential curative health care services to earthquake victims in NWFP. ���� Provide preventive Maternal and Child Health care to women and children in earthquake affected areas
covered by CWS/NCA/CoS in NWFP. ���� Provide mobile health services to beneficiaries residing in far flung areas of NWFP. ���� Conduct staff training sessions in areas like TB-DOTS, SGBV, DEWS, and HMIS System. ���� Provide advance training to female and male community health workers in NWFP. ���� Provide laboratory services and ultrasound scanning for diagnostic support in earthquake affected areas of
NWFP. ���� Reduce maternal and infant mortality through easy access to Safe Delivery Homes.
b) AJK/Rawalakot Health Programme
���� Establish a BHU and 2 MHUs in the target areas. ���� Execute and deliver care and treatment of families and individuals in the earthquake affected areas. ���� Provide maternal and child care to women and children. ���� Provide support to government health services in Rawalakot.
Expected Results and Activities
NWFP Health Programme
a. Preventive and essential curative health care services provided to 170,000 beneficiaries through static and MHUs in NWFP.
���� Establish 8 health units in Mansehra District.. ���� Operationalise services of MHUs and laboratories. ���� Obtain necessary clearance/permits for project implementation. ���� Coordinate with government line agencies and NGOs/INGOs to solve overlap and duplication problems. ���� Conduct needs’ assessments. ���� Treat and manage patients with provision of required drugs free of charge. ���� Timely referral to hospitals via free ambulance services. ���� Conduct health awareness sessions. ���� Distribute IEC materials.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 32
b. Preventive maternal and child health care including immunisation, antenatal, natal and postnatal care and reproductive health services are provided to mothers and children.
���� Offer antenatal services to 100 percent registered pregnant women in antenatal programme at static health units.
���� Achieve immunisation coverage between 85 to 95% for both women and children. ���� Conduct 65% of home deliveries via trained health workers.
c. There is increased access of earthquake beneficiaries residing in hard to reach areas to essential curative health services via MHUs.
���� Provide 2 fully equipped MHUs. ���� Conduct needs assessment. ���� Identify suitable venue for the mobile camps. ���� Provide services to victims.
d. 100 male and female volunteer community health workers are provided with training to strengthen the PHC structure.
���� Identify training needs and resource materials. ���� Selection of volunteers. ���� Identify venue, finalise arrangements and conduct training course. ���� Reporting, monitoring and evaluation. e. Diagnostic support including ultrasound facility and laboratory services are provided to patients. ���� Establish two laboratory units. ���� Establish x-ray unit. ���� Procure laboratory equipments. ���� Training of staff, especially LHVs. ���� Blood screening. ���� Urine analysis. ���� Establish ultrasound clinic. ���� Ultrasound training for medical officers.
f. 50 Health Houses are constructed in District Mansehra. ���� Identify and finalise ToR and Agreement with outsourcing partner. ���� Get NOCs from line departments. ���� Survey and selection of target areas and beneficiaries. ���� Construction and installation of health facilities. ���� Training and orientation of health workers. ���� Community mobilisation. ���� Turnover. ���� Monitoring and Evaluation.
AJK/Rawalakot Health Programme
g. 50,000 individuals are provided access to health care services. ���� Liaise with appropriate government line department for certification and licensing. ���� Establish 1 BHU and 2 MHUs. ���� Procurement of required health facilities and supplies. ���� Conduct community mobilisation activities. ���� Deliver health services with provision of appropriate drugs free of charge. ���� Provide referrals and ambulance services. ���� Recording, reporting, monitoring and evaluation.
h. Maternal and child care services provided to women and children. ���� Conduct antenatal and postnatal care. ���� Immunisation of children. ���� Reporting, monitoring and evaluation.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 33
i. Salaries are provided to 3 doctors and 3 nurses working in 3 BHUs and RHU in UCs of Ali Sojal, Hussain Kot and Datoot.
���� Liaison with government health services. ���� Pay salary of 3 doctors and 3 nurses in the identified government health centres. ���� Monitor the effectiveness and efficiency of the health staff being paid under the project Implementation Strategy
Health Programme in NWFP: The priority of health recovery programme is to provide basic health services to earthquake survivors returning to their areas, where health facilities are completely destroyed by the earthquake. The M&E Team reported a high incidence of diseases such as scabies, diarrhoea, kidney problems, respiratory infections, etc. in selected villages. There was little or no attention to woman and child health. To cater for these problems CWS/NCA/CoS decided to provide primary and secondary health services to disaster affected communities in NWFP. CWS/NCA/CoS health recovery programme includes both preventive and curative health care to earthquake affected population through eight BHUs in different places. These services are being provided through these health centres in NWFP. Two MHUs also provide support to affected population in hard to reach areas in NWFP. Extended Programmes for Immunisation and Reproductive Health are also important parts of health activities in NWFP. Two laboratory units will also be established to provide services with ultrasound facilities. A referral system will also be envisaged for better coverage of the affected population. Malaria, Laishmania and TB control programmes will also be launched. In addition to these basic health units, community volunteers, both male and female will be engaged as community health workers to ensure better involvement of communities in the health programme; to give better health services to people at their places and to refer cases to health centres. Reproductive health services will be offered to all women of child bearing age. Women will also be provided with antenatal, natal and postnatal care. Timely referral to hospital via free ambulance services will also be envisaged. Health Houses: In addition to the BHUs, Health Houses will be constructed in partnership with the District Health Office to promote maternal and child health in the target areas in Mansehra. There will be a cross referral system from and to these Health Houses with the health facility in the catchment areas. Safe deliveries eventually will be conducted in these Health Houses once the Ministry of Health allows Lady Health Workers to conduct deliveries at their level along with proper antenatal and post natal care for the beneficiaries, if, not the Traditional Birth Attendants will be mobilised and trained further to carry out the tasks. Reproductive health services will be offered to all woman of child bearing age through these Health Houses. Vaccination for women and EPI will also be strengthened for children under five in the target area through these facilities. Timely referral to hospitals via free ambulance services will also be envisaged. Health Programme in Rawalakot, AJK: During the relief phase, the Diocese of Raiwind implemented the health programme in Rawalakot District. The Diocese will continue the delivery of health services in Rawalakot through the existing BHU and two MHUs in UCs Pakkar Nakka and Ali Sojal respectively. The services include: ���� Routine medical check-ups and immediate treatment for both in and out patients. ���� Referral services for patients requiring special care or surgical intervention. ���� Rehabilitation services and facilities for those who have damaged or lost limbs. ���� Two mobile clinics to cater to immediate health care requirements in the area. ���� Provision of laboratory services. ���� Public health education programme. ���� Immunisation programme. ���� Provision of doctors and nurses to augment requirement for health staff in Rawalakot, AJK.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 34
According to various health assessments conducted, the common diseases prevalent in these areas are diarrhoea, cough, flu, fever, goitre, respiratory track infection and scabies. The team does not only provide medicines but also extend awareness raising on prevention of these diseases. The medical team, in cooperation with the office of the Rawalakot District Health Officer (DHO), also carries out Polio Eradication Campaign (PEC) and provides polio drops to children through the BHU and the MHUs. Support to Health Services in Rawalakot: Presently, the biggest challenge for the GoP, NGOs/INGOs working in the health sector in the earthquake affected areas is the non-availability of medical staff, especially female doctors and nurses. Most of the health facilities in AJK are without medical doctors. The World Health Organisation took the initiative of rebuilding the health facilities but are still struggling to have full time medical staff. The non-functionality of these medical facilities is attributed to the fact that the government is not able to offer higher compensation packages compared to the offers being made by international organisations. Doctors and nurses prefer to find better opportunities applying for highly paid jobs offered by INGOs. To bridge the gap, the government has sorted out a short term solution by way of asking INGOs to provide support by way of sponsoring the salaries for these medical staff. As per request made by the health authorities of AJK, CWS/NCA/CoS taking full cognisance of the need to support the government initiative by sponsoring the salaries for 3 doctors and 3 nurses in 3 different locations of Rawalakot such as Ali Sojal RHC, Datoot BHU and Hussain Kot BHUs. CWS/NCA/CoS will also be involved in monitoring the services that the doctors and nurses will provide. All other facilities for these BHUs and RHCs will be provided by the government.
Transition or Exit Strategy: CWS/NCA/CoS will work together and explore the possibility of providing health services for a longer period of time with additional facilities to beneficiaries. The team will also strengthen the relations with the government health departments to extend the health services through these health centres where needed and the centres and mobile services will be handed over to them. Priority Setting in case of insufficient or slow funding: In 2006 up to the end of the first quarter of 2007 when there was less money coming in, CWS/NCA/CoS chose some components to support with the resources received; priority was given to WatSan, Health and the Livelihood Programmes. The reason being that these programme activities were linked to basic human needs like water, shelter, security, mental and physical health. People cannot live long without water and will not return and live for long in a village without a water system; consequently, WatSan and health is high on the list. Livelihoods support was high on the list, because the CTTCs and the animals provision as livelihood support for women offer a means to survive whether they receive other assistance or not. Livelihood in this programme is linked to shelter. CWS/NCA/CoS is training construction teams who will build shelters for vulnerable people who would have difficulty providing their own housing. The benefits of this training will go far beyond just providing shelter; it also provides income generating skills for the future. It was for this reason that the Environment Programme was shelf for over a year and not until May 2007 that this implementation took off. CWS/NCA/CoS will continue to work in the area beyond the period of recovery and rehabilitation programme; the emphasis will be on a smooth transition to a longer-term developmental approach from the recovery phase over the next one to two years. CWS/NCA/CoS are committed to linking relief to recovery and sustainable development. To achieve this effectively and to ‘build back better’, an integrated earthquake recovery and rehabilitation programme in the worst affected areas of NWFP is outlined in this Appeal. All of the elements of the CWS/NCA/CoS recovery programme are focused on returning disaster affected families and communities to circumstances that are the same as or better than they had before the earthquake.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 35
VII. ADMINISTRATION and FINANCE
Administration: The administration of these projects is being undertaken by two CWS-P/A offices in Islamabad and Mansehra in close collaboration with the Karachi office. Progress and final reports are being submitted as per schedule using the prescribed formats. The Administration Officers will handle the day-to-day administrative matters in the Islamabad, Mansehra and Karachi offices. CWS/NCA/CoS are the main implementing agencies with several local partners for the recovery and rehabilitation programme. CWS-P/A has selected and hired technical and support staff, i.e. technicians, drivers, field coordinators, and health and hygiene promoters.
Finance: The Finance Division of CWS-P/A ensures financial management aspects are managed with efficiency, transparency and accountability. Regular financial updates are provided to donors as required. Finance Officers, based in Karachi and Islamabad, liaising with counterparts in local implementing partners, are responsible for maintaining financial records of income (from donor) and expenditure, maintaining and cross checking financial records and working with the Programme Coordinator to ensure proper use of funds. Financial Monitoring System: CWS-P/A uses a fund accounting method for incorporating the donations received, whereby each project is recorded separately and all sources of income and utilisation of funds for a particular project can be identified. Financial Statements are prepared in accordance with the requirements of International Accounting Standards as applicable in Pakistan. Also, audits (June and December) of CWS-P/A overall financial statements are conducted by an independent firm of auditors – Ernst & Young International. In addition to this, separate project audits are also conducted by the same firm as per the requirements of donors. CWS-P/A has been awarded the USAID Management Standards in capacity building process under Institutional Management and Certification Programme (IMCP) implemented by the NGO Resource Centre, a project of Aga Khan Foundation (Pakistan). General ledger and project accounting software are also being used, which has been developed by the financial consultants. This software covers the requirements of both general and project accounting.
In respect of ASSA 51 relief programme and EQ Recovery and Rehabilitation: ASPK 61 programme, a special assignment has been given to an Auditing Consultant to conduct monthly regular reviews of the systems and relevant records and submit a report on a monthly basis. The main features of the scope of this audit include:
(a) Review of accounting functions on a monthly basis to ensure that correct accounting is done and the
documentation to support the accounting transaction is adequate and meets the requirements of an audit by donor agencies.
(b) Review of project document and contracts signed between CWS-P/A and donor agencies and to ensure that the clauses in these documents are fully implemented.
(c) Review of the processes used for acquisition of goods for relief and development work, their receipt and delivery to the site and their distribution/utilisation.
(d) Fixed assets are capitalised. (e) Pre-numbered vouchers are used. (f) Monthly bank reconciliation statements are prepared. (g) Monthly closing of accounts is done. (h) Monthly MIS reports are generated. Mechanisms for Internal Control: A full pledge Administration and Operations Team has been set up in Mansehra headed by the Assistant Operations Manager who directly reports to the Recovery Coordinator and liaise with his counterparts from Islamabad and Karachi to coordinate the various activities at Mansehra. New positions were opened for Transport, Logistics, Procurement Officers and a newly hired Office An Administrator who ensures the proper management of the fleet, warehousing as well as accuracy and transparency of all purchases and procurement. The Team ensures and monitors full compliance to the CWS Operations Guidelines and Policies. Likewise, a full time Finance Manager from Islamabad has been deputised and based at Mansehra who provides support to the Mansehra Finance team. The hiring of (3) full time internal auditors is ongoing. CWS has created a
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 36
new department which is the Auditing Department which will be a separate entity outside the Finance department and will directly report to the Deputy Director.
Oversight of procurement and warehousing was handed over to a consulting company and they do not simply provide oversight but build capacities of staff and systems. A Manual on Procurement and Warehousing has been developed and finalised. New warehousing and procurement forms were developed and are now being used. A scheduled training among finance and operation staff in Fraud Detection and Prevention with one of the leading audit companies in the world has been arranged and scheduled to be held by mid 2008. On the programmatic aspect, a new Programme Coordinator has also been hired to keep close monitoring and provide guidance among Team Leaders on the various programmatic and financial issues that affect programme implementation. VIII. MONITORING, REPORTING and EVALUATION
Monitoring Procedures: During project implementation, monitoring is undertaken by CWS-P/A. To ensure that the programme is run with efficiency, transparency, and accountability the M&E Team has been organised and trained. This team has the responsibility to carry out monitoring visits, develop and verify the reports prepared at the field level. Monitoring involves reviewing and planning work on a regular basis, assessing whether activities are carried out as planned, identifying and dealing with problems during implementation. SPSS software (quantitative data entry software) is also being used to sort data and to make reports. Reports are compiled at Mansehra and Islamabad levels.
Reporting Schedule: Reports are made for each six-month period to be received by the ACT CO within one month of the end of each period.
Evaluation: In line with ACT Evaluation guidelines for appeals of over $5 million, an external evaluation of the programme will again be initiated for this appeal. This will be done through the ACT Evaluation mechanism. The aim of the evaluation mechanism is to “enhance transparency and accountability, and allow for lessons to be learnt”. The evaluation process will help determine the relevance and fulfilment of the objectives of the project or programme in question, to measure impact and effectiveness, as well as how well resources were used and to serve as an aid to future decision making. This evaluation will continue the process started under ASSA51 and will be closely linked to the internal ACT-CWS/NCA/CoS monitoring and evaluation mechanisms. In May 2007, an Interim Evaluation was scheduled to take place but did not take place because of visa problems and the volatile security situation at that time. With the revision and extension, a new schedule has been proposed which will be the Final Impact Evaluation to be held in the autumn of 2008. In the interim, a Reflection Workshop among partners, CWS/NCA/CoS and ACT is suggested and will be held in May/June 2008. The Impact Evaluation will be coordinated by an External Team Leader who has the capacity to represent ACT and its alliance members. The programme(s) included in this Appeal will be evaluated by a team consisting of the team leader and two other members: one local and one expatriate who have comprehensive experience of humanitarian work and of the situation and the region. The Terms of Reference and the Mission Plan will be developed and agreed upon with the members well in advance. Provisions have been made for preparation with and reporting back to the implementing members on lessons learned from the different phases of the evaluation.
Exit Strategy:
CWS/NCA/CoS has taken the initiative to start framing up the process of the Exit Strategy for ASPK 61. The Workshop is initiated beginning of March 2008 by an external consultant who was previously working with ACT CO and has an extensive knowledge and understanding of the whole programme as well as the socio-political, cultural context of Pakistan.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 37
The Exit Strategy aims to outline the processes, requirements for turn-over and phasing out as well as enlightens future directions of CWS/NCA/CoS with regards to the management and continuity of the gains and strengths of the programme.
IX. COORDINATION
The programme will continue to be implemented in coordination with the relevant Government authorities in the areas concerned. Coordination with other national and international NGOs and CBOs at the field level is well established and will be continued and strengthened to avoid duplication. CWS/NCA/CoS has participated in ERRA cluster meetings in Islamabad and in Mansehra since they were first organised and continues to play an active role in different coordination meetings including the GCM, PHF and Protection clusters meetings. CWS/NCA/CoS also represents the Pakistan Humanitarian Forum15 in the IASC meetings. Until April 2006, CWS/NCA/CoS chaired the Pakistan Humanitarian Forum (PHF); coordination meetings were held frequently to discuss the crisis situation and possible responses as well as carry out needs assessments. From the platform of Emergency Resource Centre, CWS/NCA/CoS are directly linked with the Federal Relief Commission (FRC), ERRA, and the Emergency Relief Cell (ERC). CWS/NCA/CoS remain in touch with PHF and attends all meetings. In August 2006 CWS/NCA/CoS received a NOC from ERRA for its earthquake recovery and rehabilitation programme in earthquake affected areas. CWS/NCA/CoS will continue to liaise with media both print and electronic media.
Field Level Coordination: CWS/NCA/CoS coordinates with Government-line departments, District Reconstruction Units, UCs and with the District Coordinator’s Office. Linkages with union councillors are well established. Several recovery-planning workshops have been conducted with these stakeholders. These have opened the door to local level coordination with communities and villages. Furthermore, effective coordination has been established among partners at the field level. Monthly recovery update and planning workshops, which focus on sharing achievements, identifying and addressing constraints, documenting lessons learned and joint activity planning that were initiated during the relief phase will continue throughout the recovery programme. Coordination with other ACT members: The scale and the size of the recovery and rehabilitation programme and the appeal has an immediate and an ongoing impact on the workload and costs of the ACT CO. The workload of the programme, finance, communication and administrative staff has been increased. The budget allows for additional support at the ACT CO when required. It also allows for staff visits to the region over the life of the appeal and a contribution towards additional office costs. Furthermore at least one additional Alliance Meeting is envisaged as well as a Regional Workshop which allows for lessons learned during the implementation of ASSA 51 and ASPK 61 to be shared with other ACT members in the region. Communications-related inputs and work over the next two years will include the ACT communications officer working with communications staff of CWS/NCA/CoS in formulating a model of communication response for use by the alliance as recommended by the ACT Communicators Reference Group in November 2005. The budget will also extend to a visit by a communicator/photographer who will document the ongoing response of the member for dissemination to the alliance for use in the fund-raising and communications campaigns. Furthermore, the budget will cover a communication workshop conducted by the member's communications staff, with specific reference to communicating in emergencies, with invitations extended to the communicators from within the ACT alliance to be part of the learning process. Although the members' communication staff will take the lead on this workshop, they will be supported by the ACT CO communication staff.
15 Comprises of some 40 national and international NGOs and donor agencies.
X. CWS P/A BUDGET
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget
PKR
Revision 2
Budget PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision
1 Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Direct Assistance
Recovery Capacity Building Program (RCBP)
Start-up Costs
8 w
eeks;
incl
udes
wag
es, re
nts
, uti
lities
, sa
lari
es
Wee
ks
As
per
incu
rred
expen
se
519,9
70
600,0
00
130,4
51
8,7
39
10,0
84
2,1
39
Inst
ruct
ors
wag
es 1
3x8 w
eeks,
wag
es c
onst
r. s
uper
vis
or
768,0
26
12,9
08
Per
Die
m f
or
trai
nee
s
Wee
ks
As
per
incu
rred
expen
se
1,0
79,9
84
1,0
68,0
00
0
18,1
51
17,9
50
0
Tra
inin
g M
ater
ial (w
ood, el
ectr
ical
wir
e, p
ipes
, ce
men
t, e
tc.)
C
ours
e A
s per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
1,3
68,0
24
150,0
00
317,1
13
22,9
92
2,5
21
5,1
99
Tools
(se
t per
stu
den
t)
par
tici
pan
ts
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
504,0
24
178,0
00
57,2
11
8,4
71
2,9
92
938
Soci
al M
obiliz
ers
W
eeks
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
192,0
06
192,0
00
9,3
37
3,2
27
3,2
27
153
Ass
essm
ent an
d M
onit
ori
ng T
eam
W
eeks
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
479,9
86
90,0
00
113,3
25
8,0
67
1,5
13
1,8
58
Guar
ds
W
eeks
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
143,9
90
54,0
00
13,0
00
2,4
20
908
213
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
W
eeks
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
0
120,0
00
0
2,0
17
0
Const
ruct
ion/r
enovat
ion o
f C
TT
C
Cen
ter
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
179,9
87
600,0
00
69,2
20
3,0
25
10,0
84
1,1
35
Ren
t an
d u
tiliti
es f
or
the
CT
TC
m
onth
s A
s per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
449,9
98
135,0
00
128,0
20
7,5
63
2,2
69
2,0
99
Adver
tise
men
t in
the
new
spap
er in E
nglish
and
Urd
u f
or
the
inst
ruct
ors
and s
oci
al m
obiliz
ers
for
Mah
sehra
, B
alak
ot an
d M
aira
Cam
p
Adver
tise
men
t A
s per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
59,9
76
45,0
00
0
1,0
08
756
0
Tra
vel
and T
ransp
ort
Cost
W
eeks
As
per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
1,3
49,9
95
60,0
00
45,6
64
22,6
89
1,0
08
749
Pet
rol an
d M
ainte
nan
ce a
nd insu
rance
for
4
veh
icle
s
Veh
icle
s A
s per
incu
rred
ex
pen
se
319,9
91
480,0
00
4,0
00
5,3
78
8,0
67
66
Tra
inin
g M
ater
ial
116,9
77
1,9
66
D
river
s 4 f
or
8 w
eeks
64,0
22
1,0
76
3 loca
l w
om
en/c
onst
r si
te to p
urc
has
e &
cook f
ood f
or
const
r te
ams
x2 w
eeks
x 8
sit
es.
432,0
29
7,2
61
M
edic
al f
acilit
y
23,1
45
389
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
40
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget
PKR
Revision 2
Budget PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision
1 Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
M
ater
ials
for
8 h
om
es f
or
wid
ow
s
880,0
05
14,7
90
Sub-Total Start-up Cost
8,932,140
3,772,000
887,341
150,120
63,395
14,547
Housing Costs
Raw
Mat
eria
l fo
r 4085 h
ouse
s
449,3
50,0
05
7,5
52,1
01
Raw
Mat
eria
l fo
r 4085 toilet
and s
eptic
tank
61,2
75,0
03
1,0
29,8
32
Co-o
rdin
ator
Housi
ng p
roje
ct
1,1
99,9
96
20,1
68
Lab
our
Char
ges
1000 lab
ors
120,0
00,0
15
2,0
16,8
07
Const
ruct
ion T
eam
wag
es; 576 m
ember
s
138,2
39,9
78
2,3
23,3
61
Arc
hit
ect a
nd C
ivil E
ngin
eers
; 2
1,9
20,0
05
32,2
69
Fore
stry
Off
icer
599,9
98
10,0
84
Cost
of
5 P
lants
/ H
ouse
2,0
42,5
16
34,3
28
Pro
ject
Man
ger
1,0
79,9
84
18,1
51
Bas
ic tools
16,3
40,0
09
274,6
22
Publica
tions
2,8
59,5
10
48,0
59
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
22,4
99,9
84
378,1
51
War
ehouse
/ S
tora
ge
2,1
60,0
28
36,3
03
Com
munic
atio
n
1,1
99,9
96
20,1
68
Uti
lities
& O
ffic
e Supplies
599,9
98
10,0
84
Sta
tioner
y
359,9
75
6,0
50
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
1,6
79,9
82
28,2
35
D
river
s 4
863,9
99
14,5
21
Cook; 32
9,2
16,0
14
154,8
91
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
1,4
40,0
19
24,2
02
Sub-Total Housing
834,927,019
14,032,387
Transitory Shelters
Raw
Mat
eria
l fo
r T
ransi
tory
Shel
ters
85,9
99,9
90
1,4
45,3
78
Pro
ject
Man
ger
1,0
79,9
84
18,1
51
Bas
ic tools
8,0
00,0
13
134,4
54
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
41
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Publica
tions
1,3
99,9
75
23,5
29
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
5,0
00,0
23
84,0
34
War
ehouse
/ S
tora
ge
2,1
60,0
28
36,3
03
Com
munic
atio
n
720,0
09
12,1
01
Uti
lities
& O
ffic
e Supplies
599,9
98
10,0
84
Sta
tioner
y
359,9
75
6,0
50
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
840,0
21
14,1
18
D
river
s 4
863,9
99
14,5
21
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
5,7
60,0
16
96,8
07
Sub-Total Transitory Shelter
112,784,034
1,895,530
UC Recovery Management Centers
Rec
over
y M
gm
t C
entr
e M
anag
ers
4
5,7
60,0
16
96,8
07
Com
munit
y R
esourc
e C
ente
r
238,0
00
4,0
00
Acc
om
modat
ion f
or
Sta
ff
959,9
73
16,1
34
Buildin
g m
ater
ials
war
ehouse
1,1
99,9
96
20,1
68
Gen
erat
ors
(4)
599,9
98
10,0
84
Kit
chen
(C
ookin
g u
tensi
ls, st
ove,
gas
)
260,0
15
4,3
70
Com
pute
rs
179,9
87
3,0
25
Pri
nte
r
21,0
03
353
Gey
sers
23,9
78
403
Wat
er s
upply
to the
centr
e
120,0
11
2,0
17
Kit
chen
str
uct
ure
138,5
16
2,3
28
Cooks
(4)
576,0
19
9,6
81
Guar
ds
(8)
1,1
51,9
79
19,3
61
Inci
den
tals
219,9
71
3,6
97
Tra
nsp
ort
and s
et u
p (
incl
udin
g lat
rines
)
511,9
97
8,6
05
D
river
s 4
863,9
99
14,5
21
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
1,4
40,0
19
24,2
02
Sub-Total UC Recovery Management Centres
14,265,482
239,756
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
42
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Winter Emergency Response
Win
teri
zed S
hel
ter
Kit
s Shel
ters
5,0
00
18,9
79
0
90,0
00,0
00
94,8
94,6
00
0
1,5
12,6
05
1,5
55,6
49
Food P
ackag
es f
or
fam
ilie
s fa
milie
s 5,0
00
6,4
26
0
35,0
00,0
00
32,1
31,5
00
0
588,2
35
526,7
46
War
ehouse
/ S
tora
ge
m
onth
s 32
54,5
53
0
1,2
60,0
00
1,7
45,6
93
0
21,1
76
28,6
18
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
17,0
66
0
504,0
00
546,0
97
0
8,4
71
8,9
52
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
20,9
57
0
630,0
00
670,6
30
0
10,5
88
10,9
94
Tra
vel
and T
ransp
ort
Cost
lu
mp s
um
0
2,1
00,0
00
3,8
26,3
26
0
35,2
94
62,7
27
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
53,6
09
0
1,2
60,0
00
1,7
15,5
00
0
21,1
76
28,1
23
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
4,6
88
0
0
150,0
00
0
0
2,4
59
Sub-total Transitory Shelters
0
130,754,000
135,680,346
0
2,197,546
2,224,268
TOTAL RECOVERY CAPACITY BUILDING & WINTERIZED
EMERGENCY (A+B)
970,908,675
134,526,000
136,567,687
16,317,793
2,260,941
2,238,815
Protection and Psycho-social Program
Tea
m L
eader
m
onth
s 32
39,3
92
0
882,0
00
1,2
60,5
41
14,8
24
20,6
65
Fie
ld W
ork
ers;
12
month
s 32
121,7
83
9,6
00,0
27
6,0
48,0
00
3,8
97,0
60
161,3
45
101,6
47
63,8
86
Man
ual
s an
d P
ublica
tions
lum
p s
um
2,4
50,9
83
1,0
50,0
00
250,5
00
41,1
93
17,6
47
4,1
07
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
m
onth
s 32
23,3
83
1,4
40,0
19
1,5
12,0
00
748,2
63
24,2
02
25,4
12
12,2
67
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
7,9
93
720,0
09
504,0
00
255,7
79
12,1
01
8,4
71
4,1
93
Acc
om
modat
ion
month
s 32
26,2
84
0
756,0
00
841,0
90
0
12,7
06
13,7
88
Ren
t an
d U
tiliti
es
month
s 32
4,2
85
959,9
73
630,0
00
137,1
31
16,1
34
10,5
88
2,2
48
Sta
tioner
y a
nd O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
s 32
20,6
38
0
252,0
00
660,4
11
4,2
35
10,8
26
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
23,4
69
840,0
21
630,0
00
751,0
16
14,1
18
10,5
88
12,3
12
Dri
ver
s; 4
m
onth
s 32
31,8
88
863,9
99
907,2
00
1,0
20,4
00
14,5
21
15,2
47
16,7
28
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
20,8
73
1,4
40,0
19
630,0
00
667,9
52
24,2
02
10,5
88
10,9
50
Com
munit
y a
ssem
bly
/tra
inin
g/m
eeti
ngs
lum
p s
um
0
210,0
00
2,0
00,0
00
0
3,5
29
32,7
87
Com
munit
y S
upport
Cen
ters
C
ente
rs
6
700,0
00
0
3,6
00,0
00
4,2
00,0
00
0
60,5
04
68,8
52
Com
munit
y/s
chool ex
posu
re tri
ps
lum
p s
um
0
945,0
00
154,6
41
0
15,8
82
2,5
35
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce; 2
month
s 32
18,7
11
0
1,2
60,0
00
598,7
59
0
21,1
76
9,8
16
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
; 2
month
s 32
32,6
93
0
2,5
20,0
00
1,0
46,1
73
42,3
53
17,1
50
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
43
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Pro
tect
ion
2,1
60,0
28
36,3
03
Psy
cho-s
oci
al P
rogra
m
2,1
60,0
28
36,3
03
Men
tal H
ealth W
ork
er
2,8
79,9
78
48,4
03
Psy
cholo
gis
ts 2
3,3
60,0
24
56,4
71
Ass
ista
nt M
enta
l H
ealth W
ork
er
720,0
09
12,1
01
Insu
rance
Ben
efit
s an
d A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
0
690,0
00
0
11,3
11
Sub total Protection & Psycho-social
29,595,121
22,336,200
19,179,715
497,397
375,398
314,422
Capacity Building CWS Staff / Partners / Local officials /communities
Tea
m L
eader
m
onth
s 32
33,3
43
0
882,0
00
1,0
66,9
63
0
14,8
24
17,4
91
Ass
ista
nt T
eam
Lea
der
; 2
month
s 32
20,3
22
0
1,5
12,0
00
650,3
01
0
25,4
12
10,6
61
Fie
ld O
ffic
ers;
6
month
s 32
89,4
13
0
3,0
24,0
00
2,8
61,2
00
0
50,8
24
46,9
05
Tra
iner
s; 2
m
onth
s 32
17,9
38
0
1,2
60,0
00
574,0
00
0
21,1
76
9,4
10
Tra
inin
g f
or
Sta
ff a
nd P
artn
ers
lum
p s
um
0
1,2
60,0
00
733,6
44
0
21,1
76
12,0
27
Tra
inin
gs
for
UC
Lea
der
s lu
mp s
um
0
315,0
00
638,6
71
0
5,2
94
10,4
70
Tra
inin
g f
or
Com
munit
ies
lum
p s
um
0
3,1
50,0
00
1,3
65,0
33
0
52,9
41
22,3
78
Sta
tioner
y a
nd O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
32
20,6
12
2,9
87,9
71
252,0
00
659,5
93
50,2
18
4,2
35
10,8
13
Tra
inin
g m
ater
ial an
d k
its
lum
p s
um
359,9
75
315,0
00
612,6
37
6,0
50
5,2
94
10,0
43
Acc
om
modat
ion
month
s 32
12,3
40
0
756,0
00
394,8
66
0
12,7
06
6,4
73
Mea
ls a
nd inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
11,2
26
3,6
85,1
92
630,0
00
359,2
21
61,9
36
10,5
88
5,8
89
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
m
onth
s 32
11,0
24
381,0
97
1,5
12,0
00
352,7
65
6,4
05
25,4
12
5,7
83
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
3,9
32
0
504,0
00
125,8
35
0
8,4
71
2,0
63
Man
ual
s an
d P
ublica
tions
lum
p s
um
0
1,0
50,0
00
1,2
63,6
55
0
17,6
47
20,7
16
Ren
t an
d U
tiliti
es
month
s 32
2,4
14
0
630,0
00
77,2
59
0
10,5
88
1,2
67
Dis
aste
r re
sponse
/pre
par
ednes
s eq
uip
men
ts
lum
p s
um
0
756,0
00
756,0
00
0
12,7
06
12,3
93
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
8,5
19
0
630,0
00
272,6
15
0
10,5
88
4,4
69
Honora
rium
/Stipen
d
lum
p s
um
0
262,5
00
830,8
50
0
4,4
12
13,6
20
Dri
ver
s; 2
m
onth
s 32
22,1
59
0
453,6
00
709,1
00
0
7,6
24
11,6
25
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
8,0
52
0
1,2
60,0
00
257,6
60
0
21,1
76
4,2
24
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
21,4
56
0
2,5
20,0
00
686,5
78
0
42,3
53
11,2
55
Tra
inin
g R
AM
Tea
m, Psy
cho-s
oci
al, H
ealth &
Hygie
ne
Tea
ms
675,0
27
11,3
45
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
44
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Rec
over
y M
gm
t T
rain
ing U
nio
n C
ounci
l
684,0
12
11,4
96
Rec
over
y P
lannin
g W
ork
shops
for
Com
munitie
s
1,2
35,9
93
20,7
73
Tra
inin
g f
or
Rec
over
y C
entr
e T
eam
s
170,8
24
2,8
71
Dis
aste
r R
ecover
y S
upport
Skills
Tra
inin
g
449,9
98
7,5
63
Spher
e w
ork
shop
lum
p s
um
0
0
2,0
00,0
00
0
32,7
87
Sch
ool Saf
ty P
rogra
m
lum
p s
um
0
0
82,3
80,6
80
0
1,3
50,5
03
Insu
rance
Ben
efit
s an
d A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
0
0
807,3
00
0
13,2
34
Sub-total Capacity Building Program
10,630,091
22,934,100
100,436,426
178,657
385,446
1,646,499
Livelihood Program
Capacity Building for Artisans
Tea
m L
eader
m
onth
s 32
26,2
61
0
882,0
00
840,3
43
0
14,8
24
13,7
76
Fie
ld O
ffic
ers;
3
month
s 32
32,9
06
0
1,5
12,0
00
1,0
53,0
00
0
25,4
12
17,2
62
Wag
es o
f In
stru
ctors
lu
mp s
um
8,1
60,0
08
5,5
80,0
00
5,5
18,1
00
137,1
43
93,7
82
90,4
61
Soci
al M
obiliz
ers;
6
month
s 32
3,5
09
4,7
99,9
84
432,0
00
112,2
97
80,6
72
7,2
61
1,8
41
Ren
t an
d M
ainte
nan
ce o
f T
rain
ing C
ente
rs
month
s 32
9,0
12
2,8
79,9
78
222,0
00
288,3
71
48,4
03
3,7
31
4,7
27
Sti
pen
d f
or
par
tici
pan
ts: 2510
lum
p s
um
43,5
35,9
71
8,4
39,4
80
9,4
65,9
83
731,6
97
141,8
40
155,1
80
Tra
inin
g M
ater
ial
lum
p s
um
1,3
28,5
75
0
0
22,3
29
0
0
Tra
inin
g M
ater
ial (w
ood, el
ectr
ical
wir
e, p
ipes
&
cem
ent)
lum
p s
um
13,7
71,2
15
2,6
36,4
45
2,3
51,4
36
231,4
49
44,3
10
38,5
48
Tools
(se
t per
stu
den
t)
lum
p s
um
5,0
73,6
24
1,8
75,3
00
3,6
05,1
48
85,2
71
31,5
18
59,1
01
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
m
onth
s 32
23,8
87
7,4
99,9
75
330,7
50
764,3
81
126,0
50
5,5
59
12,5
31
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
2,7
71
720,0
09
110,2
50
88,6
78
12,1
01
1,8
53
1,4
54
Sta
tioner
y a
nd O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
s 32
7,0
24
1,8
12,0
13
110,2
50
224,7
75
30,4
54
1,8
53
3,6
85
Ren
t, m
ainte
nan
ce a
nd u
tilities
m
onth
s 32
20,8
21
0
661,5
00
666,2
77
11,1
18
10,9
23
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
6,8
58
1,8
12,0
13
220,5
00
219,4
68
30,4
54
3,7
06
3,5
98
Guar
d: 6
month
s 32
15,1
81
12,8
64,0
19
1,0
58,4
00
485,8
00
216,2
02
17,7
88
7,9
64
Dri
ver
s: 3
m
onth
s 32
688
863,9
99
680,4
00
22,0
00
14,5
21
11,4
35
361
Com
munit
y a
ssem
blies
/tra
inin
g/m
eetings
lum
p s
um
0
105,0
00
259,5
75
0
1,7
65
4,2
55
Const
ruct
ion T
rades
Cen
ter
Cen
ter
0
0
0
400,0
00
0
0
6,7
23
0
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
19,7
11
1,4
40,0
19
252,0
00
630,7
52
24,2
02
4,2
35
10,3
40
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
7,1
74
0
630,0
00
229,5
65
0
10,5
88
3,7
63
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
45
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
12,4
26
0
1,2
60,0
00
397,6
36
0
21,1
76
6,5
19
Tra
inin
g f
or
work
ers/
artisa
ns
3,5
99,9
88
60,5
04
Const
ruct
ion T
rade
Man
ager
599,9
98
10,0
84
Wag
es o
f C
onst
ruct
ion T
eam
Super
vis
ors
; 240
46,0
80,0
13
774,4
54
Pro
ject
Man
ger
840,0
21
14,1
18
Curr
iculu
m D
evel
opm
ent an
d C
ertifi
cation
even
ts
lum
p
sum
0
275,0
00
0
4,5
08
Insu
rance
Ben
efit
s an
d A
llow
ance
s m
onth
s 32
29,6
13
0
947,6
00
0
15,5
34
Sub total Capacity Building for Artisans
157,681,425
27,398,275
28,446,184
2,650,108
460,476
466,331
Animal Loan-Provision Program
Pro
vis
ion of
goat
s/sh
eep to c
om
munit
y
anim
al
5455
6,0
57
9,9
00,0
26
20,5
06,5
00
33,0
43,0
60
166,3
87
344,6
47
541,6
90
Vet
nar
y s
taff
; 6
month
s 32
116,4
99
1,4
40,0
19
1,5
12,0
00
3,7
27,9
75
24,2
02
25,4
12
61,1
14
Med
icin
es
lum
p s
um
8,2
49,9
72
17,0
88,7
50
21,4
65,2
71
138,6
55
287,2
06
351,8
90
Fodder
for
shee
p/g
oat
s lu
mp s
um
3,2
99,9
89
3,4
17,7
50
2,3
76,6
00
55,4
62
57,4
41
38,9
61
Tag
s fo
r sh
eep
lum
p s
um
0
170,8
88
0
0
2,8
72
0
Tea
m L
eader
m
onth
s 32
35,8
09
0
882,0
00
1,1
45,8
93
0
14,8
24
18,7
85
Ass
ista
nt T
eam
Lea
der
m
onth
s 32
18,4
69
0
756,0
00
590,9
95
0
12,7
06
9,6
88
Fie
ld O
ffic
ers;
4
month
s 32
39,9
94
0
2,0
16,0
00
1,2
79,8
00
0
33,8
82
20,9
80
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
54,1
93
0
630,0
00
1,7
34,1
85
0
10,5
88
28,4
29
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
43,6
72
0
1,2
60,0
00
1,3
97,4
90
0
21,1
76
22,9
10
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
7,7
08
720,0
09
378,0
00
246,6
46
12,1
01
6,3
53
4,0
43
Sta
tioner
y &
Off
ice
Supplies
m
onth
s 32
19,7
76
719,9
50
378,0
00
632,8
20
12,1
00
6,3
53
10,3
74
Ren
t an
d U
tiliti
es
month
s 32
22,3
31
0
378,0
00
714,5
82
6,3
53
11,7
14
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
26,4
03
599,9
98
630,0
00
844,8
95
10,0
84
10,5
88
13,8
51
Dri
ver
s 4
month
s 32
32,7
99
863,9
99
907,2
00
1,0
49,5
60
14,5
21
15,2
47
17,2
06
Guar
ds;
4
month
s 32
5,6
98
1,0
07,9
89
705,6
00
182,3
28
16,9
41
11,8
59
2,9
89
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
11,3
44
1,4
40,0
19
252,0
00
363,0
00
24,2
02
4,2
35
5,9
51
Enhan
cing v
et s
kill (w
idow
s) (
Ear
lier
stipen
d f
or
wid
ow
s)
month
s 32
375,0
00
0
12,0
00,0
00
12,0
00,0
00
0
201,6
81
196,7
21
Com
munit
y a
ssem
blies
/tra
inin
g a
nd m
eeti
ngs
lum
p s
um
0
210,0
00
234,7
90
0
3,5
29
3,8
49
Acc
om
modat
ion
lum
p s
um
0
105,0
00
118,3
24
0
1,7
65
1,9
40
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
46
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Vet
inar
y c
ente
rs; 3 b
uildin
gs
month
s 32
4,4
79
1,7
99,9
94
1,8
00,0
00
143,3
31
30,2
52
30,2
52
2,3
50
Tra
vel
& T
ransp
ort
atio
n
0
2,5
00,0
11
0
300,0
00
42,0
17
0
4,9
18
Sal
ary o
f T
rain
ers
for
Hygie
ne
pro
moti
on; 3
1,4
40,0
19
24,2
02
Mat
eria
l f
or
trai
nin
g
125,0
09
2,1
01
Pro
ject
Man
ger
840,0
21
14,1
18
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n C
ost
7,4
99,9
75
126,0
50
Insu
rance
Ben
efit
s an
d A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
0
713,0
00
0
11,6
89
Sub total Animal Loan Provision Program
42,447,002
65,983,688
84,304,545
713,395
1,108,969
1,382,042
TOTAL LIVELIHOOD PROGRAM (IVA+IVB)
200,128,427
93,381,963
112,750,729
3,363,503
1,569,445
1,848,373
Water, Sanitation and Health Education
Fie
ld C
oord
inat
or
month
s 32
591,4
45
12,9
59,9
92
13,6
08,0
00
18,9
26,2
54
217,8
15
228,7
06
310,2
66
Engin
eer
Wat
San
m
onth
s 32
211,9
36
12,9
59,9
92
13,6
08,0
00
6,7
81,9
46
217,8
15
228,7
06
111,1
79
Fie
ld S
uper
vis
or
(Nat
ional
sta
ff )
; 4
month
s 32
99,7
24
2,3
99,9
92
1,6
12,8
00
3,1
91,1
64
40,3
36
27,1
06
52,3
14
Hea
lth E
duca
tion C
oord
inat
or
month
s 32
85,9
80
12,9
59,9
92
882,0
00
2,7
51,3
50
217,8
15
14,8
24
45,1
04
Hae
lth E
duca
rtio
n N
atio
nal
Sta
ff
month
s 32
151,4
77
2,3
99,9
92
4,2
33,6
00
4,8
47,2
63
40,3
36
71,1
53
79,4
63
Tea
m L
eader
Wat
er a
nd S
anitat
ion (N
atio
nal
) m
onth
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Hygie
ne
Kit
s fa
milie
s 13,8
60
333
28,5
94,9
86
21,0
00,0
00
4,6
10,4
98
480,5
88
352,9
41
75,5
82
Const
ruct
ion a
nd m
ater
ials
for
wat
er s
chem
es
schem
es
46
613,6
55
0
52,9
20,0
00
28,2
28,1
25
889,4
12
462,7
56
San
itat
ion M
ater
ials
co
mm
unit
ies
578
10,1
67
11,7
00,0
20
88,2
00,0
00
5,8
76,3
17
196,6
39
1,4
82,3
53
96,3
33
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n a
nd T
ravel
Cost
- I
n C
ountr
y
month
s 32
71,6
81
1,4
40,0
19
3,1
50,0
00
2,2
93,8
06
24,2
02
52,9
41
37,6
03
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
33,1
56
720,0
09
1,0
33,2
00
1,0
60,9
90
12,1
01
17,3
65
17,3
93
Ren
ts a
nd U
tilities
month
s 32
57,5
76
719,9
50
4,4
10,0
00
1,8
42,4
23
12,1
00
74,1
18
30,2
04
Sta
tioner
y a
nd O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
s 32
22,0
20
0
252,0
00
704,6
37
0
4,2
35
11,5
51
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
42,8
69
599,9
98
1,3
35,6
00
1,3
71,7
94
10,0
84
22,4
47
22,4
88
Dri
ver
s: 1
2
month
s 32
62,2
04
863,9
99
1,8
14,4
00
1,9
90,5
29
14,5
21
30,4
94
32,6
32
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
33,7
42
1,4
40,0
19
504,0
00
1,0
79,7
43
24,2
02
8,4
71
17,7
01
Lab
or
Char
ges
sc
hem
es
46
119,5
64
0
33,6
00,0
00
5,4
99,9
21
0
564,7
06
90,1
63
Acc
om
modat
ion
month
s 32
41,5
23
0
756,0
00
1,3
28,7
30
0
12,7
06
21,7
82
Man
ual
s an
d P
ublica
tion
item
s 2,2
30
218
0
525,0
00
486,4
15
0
8,8
24
7,9
74
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
47
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Fuel
for
veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
48,7
77
0
3,7
80,0
00
1,5
60,8
69
0
63,5
29
25,5
88
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
57,6
27
0
5,0
40,0
00
1,8
44,0
76
0
84,7
06
30,2
31
Com
munit
y a
ssem
blies
/tra
inin
g/m
eetings
lum
p s
um
0
315,0
00
452,3
33
5,2
94
7,4
15
Ass
essm
ent
lum
p s
um
540,0
22
567,0
00
1,5
64,5
68
9,0
76
9,5
29
25,6
49
Wat
er M
ater
ials
14,4
00,0
11
242,0
17
Tra
nsl
ators
4
2,3
99,9
92
40,3
36
Hea
lth a
nd H
ygie
ne
Pro
gra
m
3,5
99,9
88
60,5
04
Win
teri
zati
on (
Khas
tara
Cam
p)
lum
p s
um
0
2,2
71,8
44
2,1
05,3
16
38,1
82
34,5
13
Sta
ff B
enef
its
and A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
0
0
1,1
73,0
00
0
19,2
30
Sub total Water, Sanitation & Hygiene Promotion
110,698,975
255,418,444
101,572,067
1,860,487
4,292,748
1,665,116
Environmental Protection Program
Tea
m L
eader
s; 2
m
onth
s 32
0
0
0
0
0
0
Ass
ista
nt T
eam
Lea
der
m
onth
s 32
30,2
50
756,0
00
967,9
92
0
12,7
06
15,8
69
Fie
ld O
ffic
ers;
3
month
s 32
89,9
16
1,5
12,0
00
2,8
77,3
03
0
25,4
12
47,1
69
Pla
nts
/see
dlings;
5 p
er f
amily (
wit
h 1
0 p
erce
nt lo
ss
pro
vis
ion)
month
s 32
27,6
85
2,3
10,0
00
885,9
20
0
38,8
24
14,5
23
Gar
den
tools
and s
upplies
lu
mp s
um
21,0
00,0
00
18,3
20,4
85
0
352,9
41
300,3
36
Fer
tilize
rs
lum
p s
um
21,0
00,0
00
8,1
60,2
32
0
352,9
41
133,7
74
Com
munit
y A
ssem
blies
tra
inin
gs
and m
eetings
lum
p s
um
315,0
00
1,5
74,7
22
0
5,2
94
25,8
15
Honora
rium
/Stipen
d
lum
p s
um
262,5
00
360,0
00
0
4,4
12
5,9
02
Acc
om
modat
ion
month
s 32
3,8
75
504,0
00
124,0
00
0
8,4
71
2,0
33
Man
ual
s an
d P
ublica
tion
lum
p s
um
630,0
00
307,7
80
0
10,5
88
5,0
46
Sta
tioner
y
month
s 32
7,5
68
252,0
00
242,1
85
0
4,2
35
3,9
70
Com
munic
atio
n C
ost
(post
age,
inte
rnet
, te
lephone)
m
onth
s 32
3,6
26
302,4
00
116,0
30
0
5,0
82
1,9
02
Tra
vel
and T
ransp
ort
m
onth
s 32
3,1
13
882,0
00
99,6
05
0
14,8
24
1,6
33
Ren
t an
d U
tiliti
es
month
s 32
4,1
66
378,0
00
133,3
17
0
6,3
53
2,1
86
Fuel
for
veh
icle
m
onth
s 32
11,2
37
1,2
60,0
00
359,5
73
0
21,1
76
5,8
95
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce
month
s 32
5,5
09
630,0
00
176,2
95
0
10,5
88
2,8
90
Dri
ver
m
onth
s 32
11,9
03
226,8
00
380,9
05
0
3,8
12
6,2
44
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
7,4
96
252,0
00
239,8
56
0
4,2
35
3,9
32
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
48
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
7,7
44
252,0
00
247,8
00
0
4,2
35
4,0
62
Insu
rance
Ben
efit
s an
d A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
621,0
00
0
0
10,1
80
Sub-total Environment Protection Program
52,724,700
36,195,000
0
886,129
593,361
Health Program
Mansehra
Med
ical
Off
icer
: 7
month
s 32
184,0
03
12,0
96,0
00
5,8
88,0
94
0
203,2
94
96,5
26
Lad
y H
ealth V
isit
ors
/Nurs
es; 5
month
s 32
56,7
10
4,0
32,0
00
1,8
14,7
21
0
67,7
65
29,7
50
Dis
pen
ser/
BH
U C
lerk
; 6
month
s 32
68,4
52
3,6
28,8
00
2,1
90,4
67
0
60,9
88
35,9
09
Vac
cinat
or/
Mal
aria
Super
vis
ors
(C
HS);
4
month
s 32
19,0
68
3,2
25,6
00
610,1
61
0
54,2
12
10,0
03
Fem
ale
Hea
th V
olu
nte
ers
Tra
iner
/Super
vis
ors
; 4
month
s 32
23,0
49
2,0
16,0
00
737,5
73
0
33,8
82
12,0
91
Mid
-Wiv
es;
month
s 32
1,9
15
6,4
51,2
00
61,2
89
0
108,4
24
1,0
05
Lab
ora
tory
Tec
hnic
ian; 2
month
s 32
18,0
59
1,0
08,0
00
577,9
00
0
16,9
41
9,4
74
Pro
ject
Man
ager
; 1
month
s 32
25,6
67
3,2
76,0
00
821,3
38
0
55,0
59
13,4
65
Pro
ject
Off
icer
; 2
month
s 32
19,2
19
2,0
16,0
00
615,0
00
0
33,8
82
10,0
82
Sto
re K
eeper
m
onth
s 32
10,6
47
378,0
00
340,7
00
0
6,3
53
5,5
85
Dri
ver
s; 6
m
onth
s 32
49,3
35
1,8
14,4
00
1,5
78,7
30
0
30,4
94
25,8
81
Guar
ds;
5
month
s 32
25,8
70
1,4
11,2
00
827,8
42
0
23,7
18
13,5
71
Cle
aner
s/H
elper
s; 8
m
onth
s 32
30,9
55
2,1
16,8
00
990,5
49
0
35,5
76
16,2
39
HM
IS O
ffic
er
month
s 32
9,8
97
504,0
00
316,7
00
0
8,4
71
5,1
92
Ben
efits
and A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
8,6
94,0
00
2,2
28,9
92
0
146,1
18
36,5
41
Furn
iture
's a
nd F
ixtu
res
lum
p s
um
840,0
00
582,9
10
0
14,1
18
9,5
56
Supplies
and e
quip
men
ts
lum
p s
um
1,6
80,0
00
1,1
52,6
43
0
28,2
35
18,8
96
Sta
tioner
y a
nd O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
s 32
12,0
01
252,0
00
384,0
35
0
4,2
35
6,2
96
Ren
t an
d U
tiliti
es
month
s 32
33,7
55
882,0
00
1,0
80,1
69
0
14,8
24
17,7
08
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
34,3
53
630,0
00
1,0
99,3
06
0
10,5
88
18,0
21
Pri
nting a
nd P
ublica
tions
month
s 32
13,1
80
252,0
00
421,7
70
0
4,2
35
6,9
14
Com
munic
atio
n a
nd E
quip
men
t m
onth
s 32
10,2
44
630,0
00
327,8
02
0
10,5
88
5,3
74
Acc
om
modat
ion (
incl
udin
g 8
hea
lth tea
ms)
m
onth
s 32
70,3
08
8,8
70,4
00
2,2
49,8
63
0
149,0
82
36,8
83
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
(i
ncl
udin
g 8
hea
lth tea
ms)
m
onth
s 32
43,5
90
8,0
64,0
00
1,3
94,8
64
0
135,5
29
22,8
67
Med
icin
es a
nd m
edic
al s
upplies
; 8
month
s 32
1,1
08,0
2 5
33,6
67,2
00
35,4
56,7
85
0
565,8
35
581,2
59
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
49
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Med
ical
Equip
men
ts
lum
p s
um
3,4
65,0
00
3,6
50,4
10
0
58,2
35
59,8
43
Fuel
For
veh
icle
;
month
s 32
49,4
24
5,0
40,0
00
1,5
81,5
61
0
84,7
06
25,9
27
Gen
erat
or/
Hea
ting f
uel
lu
mp s
um
604,8
00
253,3
02
0
10,1
65
4,1
52
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce;
month
s 32
26,8
18
2,5
20,0
00
858,1
76
0
42,3
53
14,0
68
Mai
nte
nan
ce a
nd r
epai
rs
lum
p s
um
525,0
00
406,7
43
0
8,8
24
6,6
68
Hea
lth S
taff
Tra
inin
gs
month
s 32
8,6
02
378,0
00
275,2
54
0
6,3
53
4,5
12
Ref
resh
er a
nd B
asic
Tra
inin
g f
or
FH
Vs
lum
p s
um
1,6
80,0
00
390,1
89
0
28,2
35
6,3
97
Bas
ic F
irst
Aid
and D
eliv
ery k
its;
supplies
and
stre
tcher
s lu
mp s
um
1,5
75,0
00
507,8
59
0
26,4
71
8,3
26
Ref
erra
ls to H
osp
ital
s lu
mp s
um
945,0
00
54,3
00
0
15,8
82
890
Hea
lth C
ontingen
cy
lum
p s
um
945,0
00
106,7
72
0
15,8
82
1,7
50
Sti
pen
d f
or
com
munit
y v
olu
nte
ers;
100
lum
p s
um
13,2
30,0
00
66,0
00
0
222,3
53
1,0
82
Hea
lth H
ouse
s lu
mp s
um
0
23,5
00,0
00
0
0
385,2
46
Sub- Total Health Program (Mansehra)
139,343,400
95,400,769
0
2,341,906
1,563,947
Rawalakot
Pro
ject
In c
har
ge
; 1
month
s 16
28,7
50
1,6
38,0
00
460,0
00
0
27,5
29
7,5
41
Ass
ista
nt Pro
ject
In c
har
ge;
1
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Doct
ors
; 3
month
s 16
129,3
75
3,0
24,0
00
2,0
70,0
00
0
50,8
24
33,9
34
Par
t tim
e L
ady V
isit
ing D
oct
or;
1
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Monitori
ng/P
roje
ct O
ffic
er; 1
month
s 16
3,5
16
453,6
00
56,2
50
0
7,6
24
922
Fin
ance
Off
icer
; 1
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Hea
lth E
duca
tor
Consu
ltan
t; 1
m
onth
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Hea
lth E
duca
tor;
2
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Mal
e N
urs
es; 2
month
s 16
19,3
75
504,0
00
310,0
00
0
8,4
71
5,0
82
Sta
ff N
urs
es; 4
month
s 16
60,0
00
1,5
12,0
00
960,0
00
0
25,4
12
15,7
38
Mid
-Wiv
es; 5
month
s 16
46,0
00
1,2
09,6
00
736,0
00
0
20,3
29
12,0
66
Physi
o-T
her
apis
t m
onth
s 16
9,3
75
252,0
00
150,0
00
0
4,2
35
2,4
59
Lab
ora
tory
Tec
hnic
ian
month
s 16
9,3
75
252,0
00
150,0
00
0
4,2
35
2,4
59
Cook
month
s 16
7,0
00
176,4
00
112,0
00
0
2,9
65
1,8
36
Hel
per
m
onth
s 16
5,0
00
126,0
00
80,0
00
0
2,1
18
1,3
11
Dri
ver
; 2
month
s 16
16,0
00
453,6
00
256,0
00
0
7,6
24
4,1
97
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
50
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Cle
aner
m
onth
s 16
7,0
00
176,4
00
112,0
00
0
2,9
65
1,8
36
Guar
d; 2
month
s 16
13,1
25
352,8
00
210,0
00
0
5,9
29
3,4
43
Ben
efits
and A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
2,0
26,0
80
508,4
00
0
34,0
52
8,3
34
Purc
has
e of
med
icin
e @
Rs.
100-e
ach p
atie
nt per
day
, fo
r 100 p
atie
nts
lu
mp s
um
3,2
76,0
00
2,3
73,2
11
0
55,0
59
38,9
05
Med
icin
es f
or
2 M
obile
Clinic
s@R
s.100-e
ach
pat
ient per
day
for
200 p
atie
nts
for
26 d
ays
lum
p s
um
13,1
04,0
00
9,2
93,6
58
0
220,2
35
152,3
55
Monitori
ng V
isits
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Sta
ff E
xposu
re V
isits
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Hea
lth a
nd E
duca
tional
Mat
eria
l lu
mp s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Tra
inin
g f
or
Pro
ject
Sta
ff
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Tra
nsp
ort
and T
ravel
Cost
/ P
urc
has
e of
Veh
icle
for
Imple
men
ting P
artn
er/r
ent
month
s 16
44,6
88
756,0
00
715,0
00
0
12,7
06
11,7
21
Sta
ff A
ccom
modat
ion
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Uti
lities
m
onth
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce;
month
s 16
60,7
12
1,2
60,0
00
971,3
94
0
21,1
76
15,9
24
Fuel
for
Veh
icle
;
month
s 16
87,1
14
2,5
20,0
00
1,3
93,8
16
0
42,3
53
22,8
49
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 16
7,0
42
252,0
00
112,6
77
0
4,2
35
1,8
47
Sta
tioner
y &
Off
ice
Supplies
m
onth
s 16
27,4
29
504,0
00
438,8
57
0
8,4
71
7,1
94
Hea
ting C
ost
lu
mp s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Fuel
for
Gen
erat
or
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 16
49,4
82
252,0
00
791,7
13
0
4,2
35
12,9
79
Boar
din
g a
nd lodgin
g
month
s 16
0
0
0
0
0
0
Equip
men
t an
d R
epai
rs
lum
p s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Audit
and F
inan
cial
Monitori
ng
lum
p s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 16
0
252,0
00
0
0
4,2
35
0
Doct
ors
: 3 (
Support
for
Hea
lth F
acilit
ies
in
Raw
alak
ot)
lu
mp s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Nurs
es: 3 (
Support
for
Hea
lth F
acilit
ies
in
Raw
alak
ot)
lum
p s
um
0
0
0
0
0
Sub- Total Health Program (Rawalakot)
34,332,480
22,260,976
0
577,016
364,934
Sub - Total Health Program (A+B)
173,675,880
117,661,745
0
2,918,922
1,928,881
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
51
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Project Staff - CWS-P/A
Pro
gra
m C
oord
inat
or
2
month
s 32
109,2
16
1,4
40,0
19
1,5
12,0
00
3,4
94,9
26
24,2
02
25,4
12
57,2
94
Ass
ista
nt Pro
gra
m C
oord
inat
or
; 1
month
32
57,1
73
2,1
60,0
28
2,2
68,0
00
1,8
29,5
29
36,3
03
38,1
18
29,9
92
Logis
tics
/ pro
cure
men
t off
icer
; 2
m
onth
s 32
36,1
30
2,3
99,9
92
2,5
20,0
00
1,1
56,1
63
40,3
36
42,3
53
18,9
53
Gra
nt O
ffic
er; 4
.5
month
s 32
169,0
48
8,6
39,9
95
10,5
84,0
00
5,4
09,5
34
145,2
10
177,8
82
88,6
81
Qual
ity C
ontr
ol O
ffic
ers;
2
month
s 32
151,0
61
2,8
79,9
78
3,0
24,0
00
4,8
33,9
63
48,4
03
50,8
24
79,2
45
Vid
eo G
rapher
; 2
month
s 32
2,6
56
720,0
09
2,0
16,0
00
85,0
00
12,1
01
33,8
82
1,3
93
Rec
over
y C
oord
inat
or
month
s 32
321,0
85
8,6
39,9
95
9,0
72,0
00
10,2
74,7
22
145,2
10
152,4
71
168,4
38
Ass
ista
nt R
ecover
y C
oord
inat
or
month
s 32
89,0
40
5,7
60,0
16
6,0
48,0
00
2,8
49,2
82
96,8
07
101,6
47
46,7
10
Web
Man
ager
m
onth
s 32
24,2
94
840,0
21
882,0
00
777,4
01
14,1
18
14,8
24
12,7
44
Hea
d o
f M
onit
ori
ng T
eam
m
onth
s 32
35,4
06
5,7
60,0
16
6,0
48,0
00
1,1
32,9
81
96,8
07
101,6
47
18,5
73
Monitori
ng T
eam
Mem
ber
s; 9
m
onth
s 32
167,2
18
0
12,0
96,0
00
5,3
50,9
77
203,2
94
87,7
21
Oper
atio
ns
Man
ager
2
month
s 32
89,4
43
11,5
19,9
73
756,0
00
2,8
62,1
66
193,6
13
12,7
06
46,9
21
War
ehouse
Off
icer
; 4
month
s 32
18,5
69
720,0
09
1,2
60,0
00
594,2
00
12,1
01
21,1
76
9,7
41
Ben
efits
and A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
0
11,6
17,2
00
8,3
65,8
90
0
195,2
47
137,1
46
Res
t an
d R
ecre
atio
n
lum
p s
um
10,2
95,9
99
1,0
50,0
00
1,1
11,4
85
173,0
42
17,6
47
18,2
21
Fuel
for
veh
icle
; 5
month
s 32
5,0
39
499,9
78
6,3
00,0
00
161,2
50
8,4
03
105,8
82
2,6
43
Veh
icle
Mai
nte
nan
ce; 5
month
s 32
4,9
04
0
3,1
50,0
00
156,9
12
0
52,9
41
2,5
72
Sub total Project Staff -CWS-P/A
62,276,031
80,203,200
50,446,381
1,046,656
1,347,953
826,990
Total Direct Assistance
(I+II+III+IV+V+VI+VII+VIII)
1,384,237,321
835,200,487
674,809,750
23,264,493
14,036,983
11,062,45 5
Capital Items
Veh
icle
purc
has
e &
Insu
rance
; 14 &
Reg
istr
atio
n
No.
14
2,8
55,2
2 0
17,9
99,9
99
36,0
00,0
00
39,9
73,0
74
302,5
21
605,0
42
655,2
96
Mobile
Phones
; 10
No.
10
20,0
90
59,9
76
100,0
00
200,9
02
1,0
08
1,6
81
3,2
93
Sat
ellite
Phone
with a
cces
sori
es
No.
3
106,1
33
299,9
99
300,0
00
318,4
00
5,0
42
5,0
42
5,2
20
Dig
ital
Cam
era
(3)
and v
ideo
cam
N
o.
3
123,8
27
149,9
99
150,0
00
371,4
80
2,5
21
2,5
21
6,0
90
Lap
top; 15
No.
15
91,7
25
400,0
18
1,5
00,0
00
1,3
75,8
80
6,7
23
25,2
10
22,5
55
Pri
nte
rs a
nd f
ax m
achin
es 6
N
o.
6
77,1
17
179,9
87
225,0
00
462,7
00
3,0
25
3,7
82
7,5
85
Furn
iture
& F
ixtu
res
lu
mp s
um
1,9
99,9
73
2,6
44,4
00
2,9
54,1
84
33,6
13
44,4
44
48,4
29
Des
kto
p; 30
No.
30
68,1
68
479,9
86
1,3
50,0
00
2,0
45,0
50
8,0
67
22,6
89
33,5
25
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
52
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Gen
erat
ors
; 11
No.
11
100,1
97
2,9
99,9
90
1,1
00,0
00
1,1
02,1
70
50,4
20
18,4
87
18,0
68
Photo
copie
r; 2
N
o.
2
207,4
00
400,0
18
400,0
00
414,8
00
6,7
23
6,7
23
6,8
00
Sca
nner
; 2
No.
2
43,6
00
225,0
29
150,0
00
87,2
00
3,7
82
2,5
21
1,4
30
Dig
ital
PA
BX
; 2
No.
2
124,7
50
0
500,0
00
249,5
00
0
8,4
03
4,0
90
UPS S
yst
ems;
3
No.
3
148,6
20
0
270,0
00
445,8
60
0
4,5
38
7,3
09
Multim
edia
N
o.
2
100,0
00
0
400,0
00
200,0
00
0
6,7
23
3,2
79
Shre
ddin
g M
achin
es 3
N
o.
3
60,0
00
0
180,0
00
2,9
51
TOTAL CAPITAL ITEMS
25,194,977
45,089,400
50,381,200
423,445
757,805
825,921
Personnel, Admin Operations & Support
CWS-P/A
Gover
nm
ent L
iais
on O
ffic
er; 2
month
s 32
188,2
86
4,7
99,9
84
10,0
80,0
00
6,0
25,1
58
80,6
72
169,4
12
98,7
73
Exte
rnal
Aff
iars
Man
ager
2,3
99,9
92
400,0
00
40,3
36
0
6,5
57
Ass
oci
ate
Dir
ecto
r m
onth
s 32
225,5
78
720,0
09
5,0
40,0
00
7,2
18,4
83
12,1
01
84,7
06
118,3
36
Coord
inat
ion O
ffic
er
month
s 32
16,1
25
4,7
99,9
84
756,0
00
516,0
00
80,6
72
12,7
06
8,4
59
Pro
gra
m R
evie
w a
nd Q
ual
ity O
ffic
er
month
s 32
44,6
83
0
5,0
40,0
00
1,4
29,8
62
84,7
06
23,4
40
Com
munic
atio
n O
ffic
ers;
5
month
s 32
67,3
34
0
3,7
80,0
00
2,1
54,6
80
63,5
29
35,3
23
Info
rmat
ion O
ffic
er
month
s 32
29,0
86
4,3
19,9
97
2,2
68,0
00
930,7
50
72,6
05
38,1
18
15,2
58
Fin
ance
Off
icer
; 12
month
s 32
350,3
69
23,9
99,9
79
27,7
20,0
00
11,2
11,8
13
403,3
61
465,8
82
183,8
00
Adm
in. O
ffic
er; 11
month
s 32
186,1
43
9,6
00,0
27
12,6
00,0
00
5,9
56,5
60
161,3
45
211,7
65
97,6
49
Leg
al A
dvis
or
month
s 32
77,5
55
1,1
99,9
96
1,2
60,0
00
2,4
81,7
51
20,1
68
21,1
76
40,6
84
I.T
. O
ffic
er; 3
month
s 32
69,3
59
3,5
99,9
88
3,7
80,0
00
2,2
19,4
85
60,5
04
63,5
29
36,3
85
HR
Off
icer
; 4
month
s 32
501,9
16
0
2,5
20,0
00
16,0
61,3
16
0
42,3
53
263,3
00
Sec
uri
ty O
ffic
er; 3
month
32
77,7
75
0
756,0
00
2,4
88,7
91
0
12,7
06
40,8
00
Exec
utive
Ass
ista
nt/C
lerk
; 2
month
s 32
22,5
63
0
630,0
00
722,0
00
0
10,5
88
11,8
36
Dri
ver
; 6
month
s 32
55,1
69
2,1
60,0
28
2,7
21,6
00
1,7
65,4
00
36,3
03
45,7
41
28,9
41
Cook; 13
month
s 32
93,0
27
2,1
60,0
28
2,5
20,0
00
2,9
76,8
58
36,3
03
42,3
53
48,8
01
Sta
ff T
rain
ing a
nd D
evel
opm
ent
lum
p s
um
8,3
99,9
72
8,8
20,0
00
12,6
36,7
78
141,1
76
148,2
35
207,1
60
Cle
aner
s; 1
0
month
s 32
42,1
17
1,6
79,9
82
1,7
64,0
00
1,3
47,7
53
28,2
35
29,6
47
22,0
94
Ben
efits
& A
llow
ance
s lu
mp s
um
13,9
67,9
82
18,4
11,1
20
9,0
65,6
46
234,7
56
309,4
31
148,6
17
Res
t an
d R
ecre
atio
n
lum
p s
um
499,9
78
1,0
50,0
00
1,4
69,2
18
8,4
03
17,6
47
24,0
86
Sub total Personnel Cost
84,307,929
111,516,720
89,078,300
1,416,940
1,874,230
1,460,300
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
53
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Staff travel
CWS-P/A
Loca
l T
ravel
lu
mp s
um
14,4
00,0
11
15,1
20,0
00
10,8
46,6
34
242,0
17
254,1
18
177,8
14
Inte
rnat
ional
tra
vel
lu
mp s
um
1,0
00,0
16
1,5
75,0
00
4,0
44,7
23
16,8
07
26,4
71
66,3
07
Boar
din
g a
nd lodgin
g
month
s 32
327,2
94
1,9
20,0
05
7,5
60,0
00
10,4
73,3
95
32,2
69
127,0
59
171,6
95
Mea
ls &
inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
129,0
74
2,3
99,9
92
5,0
40,0
00
4,1
30,3
73
40,3
36
84,7
06
67,7
11
Fuel
for
veh
icle
s; 1
2
month
s 32
128,9
21
2,3
99,9
92
15,1
20,0
00
4,1
25,4
83
40,3
36
254,1
18
67,6
31
Mai
nte
nan
ce o
f V
ehic
les;
12
month
s 32
120,3
96
8,3
99,9
72
7,5
60,0
00
3,8
52,6
78
141,1
76
127,0
59
63,1
59
Sub total Staff Travel
30,519,989
51,975,000
37,473,287
512,941
873,530
614,316
Administration & Support
Com
munic
atio
n
month
s 32
255,6
95
5,9
99,9
80
6,3
00,0
00
8,1
82,2
55
100,8
40
105,8
82
134,1
35
Off
ice
Ren
t &
Rep
airs
m
onth
s 32
343,3
81
2,3
99,9
92
6,0
48,0
00
10,9
88,2
03
40,3
36
101,6
47
180,1
34
Uti
lities
& O
ffic
e Supplies
m
onth
s 32
226,1
96
7,1
99,9
76
7,5
60,0
00
7,2
38,2
59
121,0
08
127,0
59
118,6
60
Rep
air
& M
aint. (
Equip
men
ts)
month
s 32
54,5
68
1,7
99,9
94
1,8
90,0
00
1,7
46,1
89
30,2
52
31,7
65
28,6
26
Sta
tioner
y
month
s 32
111,2
11
1,7
99,9
94
1,8
90,0
00
3,5
58,7
56
30,2
52
31,7
65
58,3
40
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
m
onth
s 32
95,3
32
1,7
99,9
94
1,8
90,0
00
3,0
50,6
24
30,2
52
31,7
65
50,0
10
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
month
s 32
306,1
50
14,4
00,0
11
15,1
20,0
00
9,7
96,8
14
242,0
17
254,1
18
160,6
04
Insu
rance
lu
mp s
um
550,0
18
1,0
50,0
00
2,5
60,5
24
9,2
44
17,6
47
41,9
76
Ren
tal fo
r G
ues
t H
ouse
s; 6
lu
mp s
um
5,7
60,0
16
9,0
72,0
00
7,5
80,8
06
96,8
07
152,4
71
124,2
76
Sub total Administration and Support
41,709,976
50,820,000
54,702,430
701,008
854,118
896,761
Partners' (2) Cost for Reconstruction Project
Pro
ject
Man
ager
; 2
2,8
79,9
78
48,4
03
Pro
ject
Off
icer
; 4
5,7
60,0
16
96,8
07
Consu
ltan
cy
3,8
88,0
27
65,3
45
Fie
ld W
ork
ers;
4
1,9
20,0
05
32,2
69
Tra
vel
1,6
79,9
82
28,2
35
Com
munic
atio
n
1,4
40,0
19
24,2
02
Uti
lities
& O
ffic
e Supplies
959,9
73
16,1
34
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
54
Description
Type of
Unit
No of
Units
Unit
Cost
Original
Budget PKR
Revision 1
Budget PKR
Revision 2
Budget
PKR
Original
Budget USD
Revision 1
Budget
US$
Revision
2 Budget
USD
Sta
tioner
y
959,9
73
16,1
34
Mea
ls a
nd Inci
den
tals
1,1
99,9
96
20,1
68
Dri
ver
s 4
863,9
99
14,5
21
Sec
uri
ty E
xpen
ses
2,8
79,9
78
48,4
03
Sub-total Partners' Cost
24,431,949
410,621
Documentation, Coordination &Visibility
Docu
men
tati
on / Info
rmat
ion D
isse
min
atio
n
lum
p s
um
899,9
97
1,2
60,0
00
2,8
90,5
28
15,1
26
21,1
76
47,3
86
Coord
inat
ion w
ith o
ther
sta
keh
old
ers
month
s 32
224,9
26
4,7
99,9
84
6,3
00,0
00
7,1
97,6
45
80,6
72
105,8
82
117,9
94
Vis
ibilit
y
lum
p s
um
899,9
97
1,1
00,0
00
2,2
11,6
62
15,1
26
18,4
87
36,2
57
Sub total Document, Coordination & Visibility
6,599,978
8,660,000
12,299,835
110,924
145,546
201,637
Monitoring, Reporting and Evaluation
Monitori
ng, R
eport
ing a
nd E
val
uat
ion
month
s 32
80,0
48
0
1,2
60,0
00
2,5
61,5
33
21,1
76
41,9
92
Res
ourc
e M
obiliz
atio
n
lum
o s
um
3,5
00,0
00
0
57,3
77
Sub total Assessment and Monitoring
1,260,000
6,061,533
21,176
99,369
Audit and Evaluation
Audit
& F
inan
cial
Rep
ort
ing
lum
p s
um
1,0
00,0
16
1,0
50,0
00
4,1
76,7
70
16,8
07
17,6
47
68,4
72
Sub total Audit and Evaluation
1,000,016
1,050,000
4,176,770
16,807
17,647
68,472
TOTAL OPERATIONAL COSTS
(I+II+III+IV+V+VII)
188,569,838
225,281,720
203,792,154
3,169,241
3,786,248
3,340,855
TOTAL ESTIM
ATED EXPENDITURE (A+B+C)
1,598,002,136
1,105,571,607
928,983,104
26,857,179
18,581,036
15,229,231
Exchange Rate - Budget 1 USD =
59.50
Actual I USD =
61
Exch
anged
Rat
e ta
ken
on the
bas
is o
f th
e A
ver
age
of
(
Aver
age
rate
of
donat
ion r
ecei
ved
+ C
urr
ent R
ate)
/2 num
eric
ally
(6
0.4
45 +
62.0
0)/
2
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation
ASPK61 (Revision 2)
55
BUDGET NOTES:
1. Deleted Budget Lines
Livelihood/Training for Artisans:
Budget
on T
rain
ing M
ater
ial
Ther
e w
ere
two e
xis
ting b
udget
lin
es o
f th
e sa
me
hea
d.
The
expen
ses
of
both
budget
lin
es w
ere
mer
ged
toget
her
and t
he
tota
l budget
req
uir
ed w
as a
dju
sted
as
per
the
requir
emen
t fo
r th
e ex
tensi
on p
erio
d.
2. New Budget Lines
Capacity Building for Staff/Partners and Communities:
Sch
ool
Saf
ety P
rogra
mm
e: T
his
is
a new
init
iati
ve
that
wil
l fo
rm p
art
of
the
CB
P f
or
com
munit
ies.
It
wil
l in
clude
in i
ts’
com
ponen
t sc
hool
retr
ofi
ttin
g a
nd s
chool
safe
ty t
rain
ing
wit
h t
he
pro
vis
ion o
f eq
uip
men
ts,
gea
rs a
nd i
nfo
rmat
ion m
ater
ials
. A
s m
enti
oned
in t
he
tele
confe
rence
wit
h p
artn
ers
and d
onors
hel
d o
n F
ebru
ary
2008 i
n G
enev
a, i
t w
as i
nitia
lly
pro
ject
ed t
hat
40 s
chools
will
be
targ
eted
for
retr
ofi
ttin
g. H
ow
ever
, E
RR
A d
id n
ot re
com
men
d r
etro
fittin
g a
s an
opti
on b
ut ra
ther
to g
o w
ith n
ew c
onst
ruct
ion w
hic
h m
ay n
ow
aff
ect
the
des
ired
tar
get
and r
educe
40 into
6 s
chools
ben
efitin
g.
Spher
e T
rain
ing: A
n inte
rnat
ional
/nat
ional
tra
inin
g o
n S
pher
e w
ill be
conduct
ed a
mong s
taff
and p
artn
ers
as w
ell as
rel
evan
t gover
nm
ent off
icia
ls. T
he
budget
als
o c
over
s th
e co
st o
f O
rien
tati
on S
essi
ons
among d
iffe
rent lo
cal par
tner
s of
CW
S/N
CA
/CoS.
Water and Sanitation:
Win
teri
sati
on/K
ashta
ra C
amp:
This
is
a new
budget
lin
e under
Wat
San
for
the
wat
er a
nd s
anit
atio
n f
acilitie
s th
at w
ere
set
up i
n K
ashta
ra C
amp d
uri
ng t
he
win
ter
seas
on o
f 2006-
2007. T
he
gover
nm
ent
has
ass
igned
the
tota
l m
anag
emen
t an
d p
rovis
o o
f th
is c
amp w
hic
h w
as m
ade
oper
atio
nal
for
the
win
ter
emer
gen
cy r
esponse
cat
erin
g t
o i
nte
rnal
ly d
ispla
ced
fam
ilie
s to
CW
S/N
CA
.
As
to t
he
tota
l num
ber
of
wat
er s
upply
sch
emes
, 5 w
ater
supply
sch
emes
wil
l be
taken
out fr
om
the
list
of
the
targ
et d
ue
to d
uplica
tion o
f w
ork
wit
h o
ther
I/N
GO
s al
so w
ork
ing o
n
the
sam
e sc
hem
es.
The
over
-all t
arget
wil
l be
reduce
d t
o 4
6 i
nst
ead o
f 51 b
ut
the
cost
for
wat
er m
ater
ials
and l
abour
will
rem
ain t
he
sam
e in
antici
pat
ion t
o t
he
incr
ease
d c
ost
of
serv
ices
and m
ater
ials
. Health Budget on Mansehra:
Hea
lth H
ouse
s: T
her
e is
an i
ncr
easi
ng n
eed t
o b
ring h
ealt
h s
ervic
es c
lose
r to
the
peo
ple
. T
he
pre
sence
and a
vai
labilit
y o
f T
raditio
nal
Bir
th A
tten
dan
ts a
nd L
ady
Hea
lth W
ork
ers
are
not
full
y m
axim
ised
due
to t
he
non-a
vai
labil
ity o
f H
ealt
h H
ouse
s. T
he
incl
usi
on o
f th
is n
ew b
udget
lin
e w
ill
cover
the
const
ruct
ion o
f H
ealt
h H
ouse
s w
ith t
he
pro
vis
ion o
f bas
ic
equip
men
ts a
nd f
acilit
ies.
I. REQUESTING ACT MEMBER INFORMATION
Diakonisches Werk der Evangelisches Kirche in Deutschland e.V. on behalf of Diakonie
Katastrophenhilfe (DKH)
II. IMPLEMENTING ACT MEMBER & PARTNER INFORMATION
Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe (DKH) is part of the Diakonisches Werk of the EKD, the Social Service Agency of the German Protestant Church (one of the biggest welfare institutions in Germany), with its headquarters in Stuttgart. Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe provides humanitarian aid worldwide. It supports people who have fallen victim to natural disasters, war and displacement. It is an effort to help people worldwide who are not able to cope on their own in the emergency situation they find themselves in, regardless of their colour, religion, political affiliation and nationality. One of the most important principles of its work is impartiality and independence. Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe painstakingly observes its aim not to become an instrument for political, economic or military interests. The nature and scope of the assistance are adjusted to the situation in the disaster area within the framework of available possibilities. Aid measures are designed to suit the local conditions and are integrated in the economic, social and political context of a specific country region or region. They are adjusted to respond to the needs and the situation of the victims, respect the dignity of the people, and protect valid laws and traditions. Aid commodities are deployed according to need and correspond to local standards. They are purchased locally so far as it is possible and useful. DKH has been a major financial contributor to various ACT appeals. It has also managed emergency response programmes implementing both directly and through local partner implementing organizations, mostly outside the ACT appeal mechanism. In Asia, this has included responses to the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, and to the earthquake in the Kashmir region of Pakistan since October 2005.
Implementing Partner Information
NRSP (National Rural Support Programme) is the local partner of DKH in Pakistan for the proposed intervention. The overall mission of NRSP is to facilitate the establishment and improvement of sustainable livelihoods of the rural poor in Pakistan. This is accomplished through the mobilization of poor communities to help them plan and implement their own development agenda. The rural development programs of NRSP have helped community groups (called Community Organizations) throughout Pakistan in social organization, women’s empowerment, natural resource management, physical infrastructure development, human resource development, enterprise promotion, and credit and savings projects. The core assumption of the philosophy and approach is that people have tremendous potential and willingness to improve the quality of their lives. In order to harness this potential, NRSP programs organize communities into multi-sector Community Organizations (COs), which are then used as a platform for planning and implementing various developmental activities by the community members themselves. NRSP has been facilitating the relief, rehabilitation and reconstruction operation of DKH in Kashmir/Pakistan since October 2005. NRSP has assisted during the set-up and operation of the two base camps in Hattian Bala and Chikar and has provided its community organisation platform for the distribution of relief items. Having trained Diakonie field staff, NRSP has enabled a participatory approach to the relief operation of Diakonie during the emergency phase, while acting as local partner for the successful completion of the community based hygiene promotion component of an ECHO co-funded project in Kashmir. Similarly, NRSP has provided its field team and expertise for the undertaking of the assessments for the preparation of the proposed intervention. Given good working relations, DKH intends to continue cooperation with NRSP for the proposed intervention. A Memorandum of Understand will be signed between DKH and NRSP.
NRSP is well aware of and committed to the Humanitarian Code of Conduct and has experienced working according to the Sphere standards in projects implemented so far. Similarly, NRSP will have no objection to adhering to ACT principles and guidelines.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 57
III. DESCRIPTION OF THE EMERGENCY SITUATION
The South Asia earthquake hit Pakistan on 8 October 2005, with communities in India and Afghanistan also being adversely affected. The epicenter of the earthquake, the strength of which was 7.6 on the Richter scale, was in Pakistan administered Kashmir (Azad Jammu and Kashmir, AJK). The earthquake disaster caused great loss, in which the official death toll was announced as 73,276 by the Pakistan government, while thousands also died in India and Afghanistan. The material loss was similar, some entire villages being wiped out with no survivors reported. By 31 March 2006, less than 6 months after the earthquake disaster, the Pakistani authorities announced the official closing of the ‘emergency phase’ for assistance. Since then, relief assistance has been taken over by rehabilitation and reconstruction activities in the affected areas of AJK and NWFP (North Western Frontier Province). A large number of international aid agencies together with the Pakistan government have joined efforts in the recovery of the earthquake-hit communities in Pakistan. The reconstruction of permanent houses and public buildings is taking place, along with the improvement of economic infrastructure as a result of which livelihoods are being restored. Aid agencies as well as the Pakistan government carries out medium and long-term projects aiming at the rehabilitation of earthquake-affected communities and the reconstruction and recovery of infrastructure, public services, and livelihoods. With the finalization of technical codes and policies for earthquake-resistant constructions, households are constructing their own homes with compensation payments from the government, while a large number of aid agencies are involved in the provision of permanent facilities for education, health, transportation, and other public services. Nearly two years into the earthquake disaster, reconstruction and recovery activities are well under way.
IV. DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA OF PROPOSED RESPONSE
Location of Proposed Response
The target area of the proposed project is the Southern Jhelum Valley of Muzaffarabad district, Pakistan administered Kashmir (Azad Jammu and Kashmir, AJK). Diakonie on-going and planned projects are in the periphery of Muzaffarabad district and near the Line of Control (LoC - border with India), intervening in villages that are exactly on or very near the fault line, with destruction levels reaching 98%. AJK is one of the most isolated and remote regions of Pakistan and is particularly disadvantaged and has received a very small share of the country's wealth, as well as government and donor resources. The massive destruction from the earthquake has been a result of the vulnerability of the target communities, while such large scale damage has further sharpened the vulnerabilities and reduced the response and coping capacities of the target communities. For the school construction, the specific location is as follows: Village: Nowshera Union Council: Hattian Dupata Tehsil: Hattian District: Muzaffarabad For the community based disaster risk management (CBDRM) project, the details of the villages and towns are as follows: Chikar Union Council in Hattian tehsil: 12 revenue village communities and 5 wards in the town center, with 3,002 households and an overall population of 15,858. Salmiah Union Council in Hattian tehsil: 16 revenue village communities with 3,193 households with an overall population of 16,655. Hattian Union Council in Hattian tehsil: 12 revenue village communities and 5 wards in the town center, with 2,852 households and an overall population of 17,112. Chinari Union Council in Hattian tehsil: 11 revenue village communities with 1,887 households and an overall population of 11,322.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 58
Situation in the Area of Proposed Response
The targeted area for DKH’s intervention is in the Hattian landslide zone. This landslide, triggered by the earthquake, is 2.5 km. long and 1 km. wide. It has formed two lakes, of which one is 70 m. wide and 15 m. deep, and the other one is 103 m. wide and 24 m. deep. Based on a study completed by the Earthquake Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Authority (ERRA) in cooperation with NESPAK (National Engineering Services Pakistan) and the Geological Survey of Pakistan, the dam formed as a result of the massive Hattian landslide is a major threat to those thousands living in the area. The consequences of a failure of these artificial dams could be a second potential large-scale disaster in AJK (see International Landslide Center/Landslide Observatory Open File Report 06-01, Brief Report, Feb. 2006). A number of agencies have undertaken technical studies to identify and understand the underlying causes of the hazards in the area. These studies have concluded that for AJK, landslides are a first-priority hazard, frequently occurring and intensified by the effects of the recent earthquake. Theoretical considerations also suggest that only one tenth of the cumulative elastic energy that has developed over the last several hundred years was released by the earthquake. AJK trails behind the rest of Pakistan in terms of educational indicators. The 8 October 2005 earthquake caused extensive damage to the education system in the affected areas, killing over 18,000 children and 900 teachers. The most recent statistics indicate a literacy rate of around 15%, and a mere 3% for females. The percentage of school-aged children in school (participation rate) at the primary level is estimated to be 74% for boys and 35% for girls. Despite differences in access, the quality of elementary education is poor in AJK as compared to the rest of the country. Students in AJK score lowest on national exams. Moreover, underinvestment has led to impoverished and often structurally unsound classrooms containing little to no furniture or learning materials. Prior to the earthquake, more than 30% of schools in AJK were classified as "shelterless" or "dangerous", highlighting the importance of the recovery of educational facilities in AJK. In the 8 most affected districts of NWFP and AJK, respectively, 46% and 96% of the school buildings were damaged or destroyed. Given the scale of the damage, the Pakistan government and ERRA have encouraged aid agencies to assist in the reconstruction of school buildings. Given the remoteness of the zone of intervention of Diakonie, not much assistance has been brought to the area by other aid agencies.
Security situation
Pakistan has been scene to long-standing violence arising from sectarian, tribal, and ethnic conflicts. Political events of the last one year, starting with the killing of tribal leader Nawab Akbar Bugti in Balochistan, the decision of President Pervez Musharraf to remove the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry, and the riots at Lal Masjid have all instigated further violence and hostilities in the country. A growing and increasingly assertive opposition to the President and the military government has further destabilized Pakistan, particularly in the last several months. The upcoming elections continue to stir the country. UNDSS is monitoring the security situation closely in all areas for spill-over effects. Unlike the riots common in the northwestern region of Pakistan between tribal leaders, Taliban militants and the Pakistan army, the situation in AJK is relatively calmer. Despite the fact that it is considered disputed territory, AJK has nominal autonomy with its own constitution. As AJK has an overwhelming Sunni majority, sectarian conflict is not a foreseen security risk. Therefore, the overall security situation in AJK currently remains calm, after the incident in Bagh where the religious leaders raised alarm for the UN and NGOs demanding the dismissal of all female staff from organizations. This incident was followed by several relief workers being kidnapped for ransom. At the moment, small-scale security problems in the project implementation area of Diakonie are largely related to tribal, family, and caste tensions in the region.
DKH response to the earthquake to date (outside the ACT appeal programme)
DKH has been operating in AJK since the second day after the earthquake, implementing a multi-sectoral programme outside the ACT Appeal mechanism. A well-established relief, rehabilitation and reconstruction operation in the high altitude and remote villages of Salmiah, Chikar, Mera Kalan, and Hattian union councils, with a large number of surrounding settlements having also benefited from the assistance provided by DKH. DKH has provided relief aid, transitional infrastructure, emergency education and vocational training facilities, rehabilitation of water supply and sanitation facilities, psycho-social programs, and support to livelihoods in the target communities. Diakonie is currently undertaking projects which contribute to the recovery of education and economic activities through the rehabilitation of roads, bridges, and school infrastructure.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 59
Within the proposed response now being included within the on-going ASPK61 appeal alongside the CWS P/A programme, DKH intends to continue this support to the recovery of permanent education facilities and the improvement of roads. In addition to its ongoing projects, DKH will now place importance on disaster preparedness at the community level, particularly due to the massive landslide at Hattian mentioned above.
V. TARGETED BENEFICIARIES
On principle, Diakonie has prioritized the needs of the most vulnerable groups, including female headed households (FHH), child headed households (CHH), households with disabled, orphans and the elderly as well as the poorest and most destitute households within the target communities.
School Construction
The school reconstruction within this appeal is of the Government Boys High School (GBHS) Nowshera. The building was totally collapsed during the earthquake. At that time, the school had an enrollment of 205 boys, serving a population of approx. 15,000 from 8 surrounding villages. The currently enrolled 187 boys are undertaking education with 20 teachers in tents near the school building.
Community-based Disaster Risk Management (CBDRM)
In relation to the total population of 106,338 households in the whole of Muzaffarabad district of AJK, the area to be targeted with the proposed project constitutes over 10% of Muzaffarabad district, which is also the most disaster-prone and potentially at-risk area and population of the entire district. The selected target area includes 51 villages and 10 wards in 4 union councils, covering a total population of 57,394 in 10,859 households:
S # UC Name Village Name No. of households Total Pop.
1 Chikar Kotli 232
2 Chikar Bat Cheer 23
3 Chikar Nagni Kaiser Kot 202
4 Chikar Bail 192
5 Chikar Nagni Dharian 192
6 Chikar Bandi Baqalan 347
7 Chikar Jabar Batang 320
8 Chikar Naina 55
9 Chikar Islamabad 143
10 Chikar Lodia Abad 36
11 Chikar Dakhan Padar 123
12 Chikar Kundian Shakrian 238
13 Chikar Ward No. 1 Ramsar Seri 130
14 Chikar Ward No. 2 Batangi 71
15 Chikar Ward No. 3 Harian Chorian 88
16 Chikar Ward No. 4 Chikar Town 55
17 Chikar Ward No. 5 Chikar 150
Sub-total 2,597 14,219
18 Chinari Jaskool 281
19 Chinari Darung 110
20 Chinari Serkh Chanari 120
21 Chinari Serban 266
22 Chinari Khai Garan 135
23 Chinari Andraseri 85
24 Chinari Chakoti 195
25 Chinari Banian 65
26 Chinari Bandi Syedan 160
27 Chinari Mohra Sadaq 266
28 Chinari Chonian 204
Sub-total 1,887 13,116
29 Hattian Kuchadulari 304
30 Hattian Nallah Chakle 130
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 60
31 Hattian Saran 138
32 Hattian Nain Sukh 133
33 Hattian Lasdar 67
34 Hattian Dhulchattian 360
35 Hattian Dhani Bukalan 160
36 Hattian Deharian 114
37 Hattian Bagh Sir 117
38 Hattian Amra Sawan 254
39 Hattian Kaninan 80
40 Hattian Seri Chalan 181
41 Hattian Ward No. 1 Hail Malik Pura 136
42 Hattian Ward No. 2 Hattian 236
43 Hattian Ward No. 3 Dhani Shahrada 253
44 Hattian Ward No. 4 Charoi 92
45 Hattian Ward No. 5 Khanda Bela 97
Sub-total 2,852 13,404
46 Salmiah Noon bangla 123
47 Salmiah Badeyala 187
48 Salmiah Kiati 71
49 Salmiah Maother 257
50 Salmiah Muradabad 88
51 Salmiah Mondan 147
52 Salmiah Kopra 166
53 Salmiah Anderaseri 353
54 Salmiah Nargoli 177
55 Salmiah Panopindi 165
56 Salmiah Kadri Hariala 446
57 Salmiah Lumbio Bari 330
58 Salmiah Salmia 285
59 Salmiah Sarbala 261
60 Salmiah Timber kot 92
61 Salmiah Jaber jandali 375
Sub-total 3,523 16,655
Grand Total 10,859 57,394
The total numbers of direct beneficiaries are as follows: � 5,000 male and female community members from 10,859 households awareness raising including outreach
to a minimum of 60 disabled people;
� 1,600 students from 40 schools for awareness raising activities including outreach to a minimum of 40 teachers;
� 320 members of Community Organizations (COs) for training in community management skills (CMST);
� 10 NRSP staff (8 Master Trainers, 1 Training Coordinator, 1 Project Assistant) for training as trainers in disaster preparedness;
� 488 Disaster Management Committee (DMC) members for training as trainers in disaster preparedness;
� 61 DMCs benefiting from the distribution of Emergency Response Tool Kits;
� 1,525 community volunteers for training in disaster preparedness;
� 200 individuals (such as government employees) from various public authorities and stakeholders at the tehsil and district levels in orientation and coordination workshops on disaster risk management;
� 6 Community Organizations (COs) to receive funds for small scale mitigation measures;
� 57,394 people in 51 villages and 10 town wards benefiting from raised awareness, disaster preparedness, and risk mitigation;
� 25 journalists for the press conference.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 61
The status of beneficiaries is as follows: � 5,000 community members with a low level of awareness of hazards and their negative impacts;
� 1,600 students with a low level of awareness of hazards and their negative impacts;
� 320 Community Organization (CO) members with high motivation, capability of social mobilization, and eagerness to participate in community efforts;
� 10 NRSP staff with the capacity and qualification to train trainers in disaster preparedness;
� 488 Disaster Management Committee (DMC) members, some of them CO members, with the motivation to train volunteers in their respective communities in disaster preparedness;
� 1,525 community volunteers with the enthusiasm and motivation to protect their communities at the time of a disaster;
� 200 key persons from various public institutions, media channels, line departments, and other stakeholders who are critical actors in tehsil and district level disaster management;
� 6 Community Organizations (COs) with the best action and implementation plan for the completion of small scale mitigation projects in major disaster-prone areas;
� 57,394 people with a low level of disaster awareness and preparedness;
� 25 journalists who are key persons in conveying the message of the importance of disaster preparedness and risk reduction to a larger public.
The total number of indirect beneficiaries is estimated to be almost 66,000 as a result of media coverage and public awareness trainings on disaster risk management, as follows:
� 8,000 locals through TV and radio programs and the press conference;
� 250 people per year as a result of the educational film to be produced;
� 200 individuals per year as a result of the case study publication;
� 57,394 locals as a result of the public awareness.
VI. PROPOSED ASSISTANCE & IMPLEMENTATION
Goal: To reconstruct permanent educational facilities, while increasing the awareness and the response capacities of local communities to potential and frequent natural disasters.
Objectives
• To help recover permanent facilities of secondary education through the reconstruction of a government boys high school;
• To build capacities in disaster preparedness and disaster risk reduction of target communities in the highest at-risk area, and to establish their linkages with relevant stakeholders at the tehsil and district levels by raising awareness, reinforcing response mechanisms, facilitating coordination, and strengthening institutional knowledge.
Activities and Implementation Timetable
Project activities are detailed in the following work plans and timetables:
School Reconstruction: 01 September 2007 – 30 November 2008
To contribute to the restoration of school buildings, in addition to 3 ongoing projects outside this ACT Appeal programme, Diakonie will reconstruct a fourth school building, namely the Government Boys High School (GBHS) Nowshera. The building was totally destroyed during the earthquake. At that time, the school had an enrollment of 205 boys, serving a population of approx. 15,000 from 8 surrounding villages. The currently enrolled 187 boys are undertaking education with 20 teachers in tents near the school building. The school will stand on 17,500 sq.ft, with 10 classrooms, 1 teachers room, 1 staff room, 1 admin office, 1 storage room, 3 laboratories, 1 library and 1 hall. Sanitary facilities including 12 latrines will complete the Building.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 62
The completion of this building will take 14 months, with one month to be used for the furnishing of the building. For this, an extended planned project duration the forthcoming winter has been taken into consideration.
Activities
1.
Mo
.
2.
Mo
.
3.
Mo
.
4.
Mo
.
5.
Mo
6.
Mo
7.
Mo
.
8.
Mo
.
9.
Mo
.
10.
Mo
.
11.
Mo
.
12.
Mo
.
13.
Mo
.
14.
Mo
.
15.
Mo
.
Completion of site surveys
and soil investigations x
Completion of school
designs and plans x
Submission of applications
to DRU (District
Reconstruction Unit) and
ERRA
x
Off hauling of rubble
materials from project site x x
Tendering process x x
Award of contract & start
of construction works x
On-going construction x x x x x x x x x x
Monitoring of construction
works by DKH x x x x x x x x x x x x
Completion of construction
work x x
Furnishing of school
building x x
Acceptance of works and
hand-over of building x
Community based Disaster Risk Management: 15 Sept. 2007 – 15 Sept. 2008
Activities 1.
Mo
2.
Mo
3.
Mo
4.
Mo
5.
Mo
6.
Mo
7.
Mo
8.
Mo
9.
Mo
10.
Mo
11.
Mo
12.
Mo
Result 1: Disaster Management Committees (DMCs) through Community Organization (CO) platforms are formed and their capacities for DP/DRR (Disaster Preparedness / Disaster Risk Reduction) are built at village and town level.
A0. Community meetings on hazards and
DP/DRR by SMTs at rural and town level x x x x
A1. Building managerial capacity of COs
through CMST trainings to CO members x x x x
A2. Nomination and selection of DMC
members x x x x
A3. Establishment of DMCs x x x x x
A4.Basic First Aid training to master trainers x
A5. ToT on First Aid from Pakistan Red
Crescent Society x
A6.ToT from FOCUS to NRSP project staff on
CBDRM x x
A7. ToT from NRSP master trainers to DMC
members x x x x x
A8. Distribution of emergency response kits to
DMCs x x x x x
A9. Training of community volunteers by DMC
trainers x x x x x x
A10. Conducting of simulation exercises in
villages and towns x x x x x x
A11. Preparation of disaster management
database in the target area (to be handed over
to tehsil and district level authorities at project
completion, see Result 4)
x x x x x x x
Result 2: Awareness raising sessions in target communities and public institutions are conducted.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 63
A0. Conducting of baseline survey on
community awareness and attitude on DP/DRR x x
A1. Development of training module for
community needs and schools x
A2. Development of training schedule for
school sessions x
A3. Conducting of sessions in community x x x x x x x x x
A4. Conducting of sessions in schools x x x x x x x
A5. Collection of post-training data x x
Result 3: Implementation of small-scale mitigation projects through COs for demonstration and dissemination purposes are realized.
A0. Identification of major hazard-prone spots
in the target area (database to be handed over
to tehsil and district level authorities at project
completion, see Result 4)
x x x
A1. Selection of the most vulnerable hazard
areas with support of technical advisors x x
A2. Preparation of joint action plans by
respective COs in the guidance of technical
advisors
x
A3. Implementation of small-scale mitigation
projects of selected COs x x x x x x
A4. Organization of 6 inauguration ceremonies
linked to exposure visits and institutional
capacity of related public authorities
x
Result 4: DMC linkages with local public institutions are facilitated, while advocating DP/DRR to relevant stakeholders, NGOs, and media personnel at tehsil and district level and institutional knowledge of relevant public institutions is strengthened.
A0. Organization of project inception
workshop at the district (Muzafarrabad) level x
A1. Identification of relevant authorities and
focal persons at the tehsil (Hattian) level x
A2. Preparation of materials for workshops at
the tehsil level x
A3. Conducting of orientation workshops at the
tehsil level x x x x
A4. Exposure visits for demonstration of small-
scale mitigation project in target villages x x x x x x
A5. Invitation of local media personnel to
project site to produce local news x x x x
A6. Handover of disaster management
database and map of hazard-prone spots in the
target area to related stakeholders at tehsil and
district level
x
Result 5: Dissemination of educational, training and information materials on DP/DRR is ensured.
A0. Organizing of press conference at project
opening on International Disaster Day x
A1. Production of educational film as training
material x x x x x x x x x x
A2. Production of project publication as case
study x x x x x x x x x x
Project Implementation Methodology
Since the first day of its relief operation in AJK, DKH has adopted participatory assessment and planning approaches as the best way of identifying those in need, their existential needs and adjust logistics of the relief and recovery operation according to local conditions. As affected people are the best judges of their conditions and needs, the entire operation of DKH is based on input from the men, women and children for whom the assistance is planned. Community representatives have assisted in the selection of distribution spots and have developed a system of beneficiary identification. Participatory approaches have been used in household-based assessments for immediate household needs, as well as in village-based assessments, namely community meetings for the
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 64
identification of community needs such as infrastructural needs. In the community meetings, DKH field staff members have made use of PLA (participatory learning and action) tools, namely focus group meetings, seasonal calendars and daily activities. Special emphasis has also been place by DKH on organizing and training qualified field workers for in-depth assessments and distribution, mobilizing communities in selecting their own relief items, selecting their own distribution points, and making their own action plans for emergency relief aid, as well as participating in the selection and implementation of rehabilitation and reconstruction activities. Abiding by the Code of Conduct for the Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement and NGOs in Disaster Relief, the delivery of relief, rehabilitation and reconstruction activities has respected neutrality and independence, provided regardless of race, religion, nationality, political conviction or other distinguishing features.
This approach will also be applied to the projects included in this ACT Appeal. An effective assessment has already been done and used as a basis for the design of the proposed project. While the school reconstruction project will be directly implemented with DKH project and operational capacity for the school reconstruction project, the targeted community members have pledged to contribute to a maximum level in all upcoming project activities. For the CBDRM project, DKH will implement with and through its local partner NRSP, in addition to its own project staff. The current operational resources of DKH will be shared with NRSP for the purposes of project implementation, while NRSP will provide expertise in the capacity building of Community Organizations (COs) at the village level. The project will establish Disaster Management Committees (DMCs) through the CO platform, form DMCs at the town level, and vertically link these community-based organizations to relevant public authorities. Being actively involved in the raising of community awareness on DP/DRR (disaster preparedness and disaster risk reduction), the main role of DMCs will constitute the human resources readily available for community level response in the event of a disaster in the targeted areas. DMC membership from within the permanent CO members will guarantee the sustainability of the established committees. The active involvement of the existing COs in the action planning and implementation of small-scale pilot mitigation projects is an added value of the proposed project. Both DKH and NRSP are committed to mainstreaming gender in project work. During the relief phase, Diakonie has ensured the participation of women in the planning and implementation of project activities, while designing projects to meet the immediate and strategic needs of women and young girls. A gender balance is also sought in project teams. For the proposed project, NRSP has committed to employing both male and female social organizers and other project staff in order to fully integrate the participation of women, hence contributing to a gender balanced outcome of project activities.
Inputs for Project Implementation
All investment goods purchased to date will be used for the proposed project activities, except for a small number of items to be purchased for the CBDRM project. Three full-time expatriate staff will oversee the management and finances of the proposed project, while NRSP staff assigned to the CBDRM project will be supervised and monitored by the expatriate project coordinator.
Assumptions, Constraints and Prioritisation
The province of Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) with its separate administration, is an area that was heavily militarized and difficult to access prior to the earthquake. Separatist activities inside Pakistani-held Kashmir as well as the tensions between Pakistan and India over India-held Kashmir resulted in violence and bloodshed over many decades in the region. The violence has subsided since the earthquake disaster, as both military and local agencies as well as individual families are in the process of trying to recover from the disastrous event. As a result of heavy damage and destruction to military facilities and infrastructure, the armed forces had to open the area up to the international community. Since the day of the earthquake, expatriates and Pakistanis alike are able to enter and exit the province as they like. Despite the current freedom of movement in the area, there is always the risk that Pakistani authorities declare the province inaccessible to aid workers. Similarly, the latest
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 65
tensions and riots in Pakistan can lead to further restrictions to the movement of expatriate staff, as well as possible outbreaks of violence due to the highly politicized nature of the region. Another possible risk is the highly active landslides in the proposed intervention zone. Despite the fact that all occurring landslides in the implementation area have been treated and cleared up to now with DKH’s heavy machinery, there is still the risk that a major landslide could take place on a scale that seriously impacts the ability of DKH to operate. This project is also planned on the assumption that community members will continue to actively contribute to the organization and implementation of the activities proposed in this project, as they have been doing so far. At community meetings during the assessments for the current project, community members have reassured DKH staff over and over again of their dedication and commitment to the undertaking of the proposed activities. The assumption is that the dynamic, talented and promising individuals from within the local population will be motivated to organize community members, establish community organizations and work for the recovery and increased capacity of their communities.
Transition or Exit strategy
DKH’s overall and long-term exit strategy in the region is to leave behind the foundation and dynamics for a community-based rehabilitation and normalization of life. Upon exit of DKH from the zone of intervention, local partner NRSP will continue working within its original mandate, the development of rural communities, once the population in Southern Jhelum Valley has secured its basic needs, in order to support the local communities’ self-reliance. The approach of social mobilization used by NRSP within its core program encourages community men and women to form groups, typically consisting of 20-25 members, known as a Community Organization (CO), which is an important forum for empowering people to take an active role in the management of local development initiatives. A mobilized community is one that is able to identify its needs and find the resources necessary to meet those needs. Those resources may be their own savings or labour, or funds from the government. TA CO is more than a collection of individuals; it is an entity comprising of members who work for the collective good of the community. A properly functioning CO has both social and economic value, thus in a position to contribute to the improvement of livelihoods. On the social side, it brings community members together to work for a common good. On the economic side, the CO functions as a conduit for the micro-credit that households use to generate income, and as a base for accumulating savings and putting those savings to work for community development. The CO also attracts funds for new activities, both through NRSP and through the links it establishes with government departments and with the private sector. Having adopted the approach of social mobilization and the process of forming and strengthening Community Organizations (COs) in all target villages, DKH has established Water Management Committees within its ECHO-funded project in AJK (see section 3.4), thus securing a strong sense of community solidarity and mobilization in 16 of the target villages. The proposed project is a spontaneous extension of this project, as all communities targeted within the proposed project already have experience in the formation of Community Organizations, Village Reconstruction Committees, and a variety of Management Committees. Planned along the same lines and principles as those used for the establishment of Water Management Committees, the current project proposes to establish Disaster Management Committees (DMCs) in building the capacity and skills of communities in taking precautionary measures as well as dealing with the after-effects of possible disasters in their locality. While falling within the overall and long-term strategy of linking relief and recovery with grassroots activity, such strengthening of community bonds and joint action is also a proof of the sustainability of the current project. DKH’s internal policy to bridge the gap between emergency relief and rehabilitation is operationalized by the promotion of disaster preparedness and risk reduction through a community-based disaster risk management project. As such, the proposed project constitutes the perfect basis for handing over of DKH presence to a sustainable structure, which is the livelihoods program of NRSP in AJK. Once the target communities are equipped with the skills for disaster risk management, DKH’s local partner will continue working in these villages on community development.
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 66
VII. ADMINISTRATION & FINANCE
Donations are the most important source of financing for DKH. Even the smallest donations play their part in effectively helping people suffering in war and crisis zones. DKH undertakes to present its transactions in accordance with the principle of transparent accounting and has all financial transactions checked regularly by independent auditors. All transactions are subject to a legally secured procedure that is fully documented and is verifiable and comprehensible at all times. Formal procedures are in place for the transferring of funds, purchasing equipment and supplies, and use of resources. Since 1993, DKH has voluntarily submitted to annual review by the German Central Institute for Social Issues (DZI). With its Seal-of-Approval, DZI confirms the economical and statutory use of donations. In addition, independent auditors review the field offices, local partner organizations, and their financial accounting.
VIII. MONITORING, REPORTING & FINANCE
In addition to daily and weekly monitoring and follow-up of activities in the field by the Program Manager, Project Coordinator, and Project Officer, the local staff including Engineers, Project Manager, Program Assistant, Training Coordinator, Community Trainers and Social Organizers will plan their activities on a weekly basis and submit their weekly progress reports to senior management staff at DKH field office and also at the main office in Islamabad. Periodic progress will be reported to DKH headquarters. A senior level Administration and Finance Officer will handle overall administration and finance-related tasks of the proposed operation.
Through the senior management staff of DKH in the country of operation, DKH headquarters will maintain continuous dialogue with the field operation, making recommendations, adjustments, and modifications in project development, as the need arises. The expatriate project staff and consultants to the project, who have experience with project cycle management, finances, and project documentation, will take care that DKH Standard Procedures, as well as ACT requirements are strictly followed during project implementation.
Given the importance placed on local capacity building, participatory monitoring is an extension of the participatory approach adopted in the proposed project. Participatory monitoring tools will be developed to ensure that community organizations, disaster management committees, and community volunteers are integrated into the monitoring system. Constant contact with representatives of relevant stakeholders and community organizations will strengthen collaboration and allow for a transparent and fair review of activities.
As funding of this appeal is fully financed by DKH itself, no coordination support in terms of managing funding transfers will be required of the ACT Coordinating Office in Geneva.
IX. CO-ORDINATION
Since October 2005, during DKH’s project implementation in the field, civilian and military authorities, village committees, national and international NGOs, and UN agencies have provided regular support. Excellent rapport with local authorities has resulted in full trust in DKH on the part of public servants, military personnel, and village committees, which creates a base for full information sharing and news updating. DKH regularly attends coordination cluster meetings of the UN agencies and NGOs, both in Islamabad and Muzaffarabad. While informing other aid agencies about own planned and implemented activities in the field, DKH also makes contacts with other agencies that are working in the same sectors and in the Southern Jhelum valley in order to ensure that activities are not duplicated or people in need neglected. The main contact at the national level is the Earthquake Reconstruction and Rehabilitation Authority (ERRA) in Islamabad, whose mission is to plan, coordinate, monitor and regulate reconstruction and recovery activities in the earthquake affected region. District Reconstruction Units (DRU) at the District level are in charge of the coordination and facilitation of the planning of the technical aspect of all reconstruction and rehabilitation projects at the district level, as well as the monitoring of the execution of all projects in the district. Once an NGO submits an application for a particular reconstruction project, DRU makes an investigation and upon approval, sends a
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 67
recommendation letter to ERRA in Islamabad, requesting ERRA to issue an NoC (No-objection Certificate) to the applicant NGO. For the reconstruction of the school, the AJK government contact is the Education Department at the Tehsil (Hattian) and District (Muzaffarabad) level. DRU has already sent a letter to ERRA on 26 July 2007 recommending that the Government Boys High School Nowshera be reconstructed by DKH. The school plans will be provided by DRU, as drawn by NESPAK, National Engineering Services Pakistan. NRSP, as the local partner, has assisted during the set-up and operation of the two base camps in Hattian Bala and Chikar. Similarly, NRSP has provided social organizers for the undertaking of the field assessments for the preparation of the CBDRM project of the proposed intervention. By maintaining close coordination with all related stakeholders, DKH is well connected with all possible actors in the reconstruction and recovery operation in the region. DKH staff will actively participate as a member of an ACT Forum in Pakistan and coordinate and share information with CWS P/A and NCA as well as other ACT-members in the region.
X. BUDGET
Description Type No. Unit Cost Budget
Unit Units USD USD
INCOME PLEDGED (both through ACT Geneva and directly)
Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe 1,620,000
TOTAL INCOME 1,620,000
EXPENDITURE
DIRECT ASSISTANCE
1 COMMUNITY BASED DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT (CBDRM)
Advocacy and public awareness raising
Posters, leaflets 1 12,150.00 12,150
TV program-preparation of program 1 11,390.63 11,391
TV program-on air 1 13,289.06 13,289
Radio Program-Radio Station Fee 3 53.58 161
Radio Program-Announcer’s Fee 3 53.58 161
Cassettes for Recording 1 0.84 1
Other goods and services 1 1,350.00 1,350
Mitigation works
CIF Funds 4 10,125.00 40,500
Other goods and services 1 8,437.50 8,438
Education
Goods and Services 1 18,900.00 18,900
Facilitation of co-ordination
Joint advocacy 1 6,750.00 6,750
Regional workshop 1 6,750.00 6,750
Institutional strengthening
Goods and Services 1 5,435.00 5,435
Local capacity building/training
Goods and Services 1 75,303.00 75,303
Emergency Response Tool Kits (61 Kits)
1. Personal Safety Equipment
Helmet 1,525 6.75 10,294
Gloves 1,525 1.27 1,937
Community First Aid Kit 61 33.75 2,059
Pen and Writing Pad 61 0.86 52
2. Rescue Tools
Ladder community
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 68
Shovels 1,525 16.03 24,446
Axes 1,525 5.06 7,717
Wooden Planks 305 25.31 7,720
Buckets 1,525 3.37 5,139
Flash/Search Light 305 27.00 8,235
Utility shutoff tools 61 25.31 1,544
Crowbars 61 9.28 566
Picks 1,525 6.75 10,294
Megaphone 61 50.63 3,088
Direct Programme Related Costs
Salary of Project Coordinator for CBDRM month 12 5,175.00 62,100
Salary of 1 Program Manager (Consultant) month 12 3,372.75 40,473
Salary of 1 Project Manager month 12 860.63 10,328
Salary of 1 Training Coordinator month 12 641.25 7,695
Salary of 1Project Assistant month 12 464.40 5,573
Salary of 8 Master Trainers month 12 4,050.00 48,600
Salary of 1 Monitoring and Documentation Officer month 12 548.44 6,581
Salary of 6 Social Organizers month 12 2,278.13 27,338
Sub-Total COMMUNITY BASED DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT (CBDRM) 492,354
2 RECONSTRUCTION OF SCHOOL BUILDING
Reconstruction of Government Boys High School (GBHS) Nowshera
Preparatory works (soil investigation/layout/site plan) 4,455
Reconstruction works 643,780
Environmental works 19,450
Furnishing of school 8,500
Direct Programme Related Costs
2007 (1 September - 31 December 2007)
Salary of 1 Civil Works Consultant (50%) month 4 1,147.50 4,590
Salary of 1 Senior Engineer (50%) month 4 540.00 2,160
Salary of 2 Sub-engineers (50%) month 3 641.25 1,924
Salary of 1 Sub-engineers (50%) month 4 320.63 1,283
Rent & Fuel of 3 Vehicles (50%) month 4 607.50 7,290
2008 (1 January - 30 November 2008)
Salary of 1 Civil Works Consultant (80%) month 11 1,836.00 20,196
Salary of 1 Senior Engineer (80%) month 11 1,080.00 11,880
Salary of 1 Sub-engineers (80%) month 10 540.00 5,400
Rent & Fuel of 3 Vehicles (80%) month 10 2,592.00 25,920
Sub-Total RECONSTRUCTION OF SCHOOL BUILDING 756,828
TOTAL DIRECT ASSISTANCE 1,249,182
TRANSPORT, WAREHOUSING & HANDLING
Warehousing
Rental of warehouse lumpsum 135
Wages for Security/ Guards (2) month 12 118.13 2,835
TOTAL TRANSPORT, WAREHOUSING & HANDLING 2,970
CAPITAL ASSETS (over US$500)
Photocopier 35 CPM & Multimedia lumpsum 1 6,075.00 6,075
Office Furniture lumpsum 1 7,425.00 7,425
2 Motorcyles/ Field pieces 2 1,485.00 2,970
TOTAL CAPITAL ASSETS 16,470
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 69
INDIRECT COSTS: PERSONNEL, ADMIN, OPERATIONS & SUPPORT
CBDRM (12 months) (100%)*
Staff salaries (Local)
1 Finance and Accountants month 12 464.40 5,573
1 Office Assistant month 12 126.56 1,519
5 Drivers month 12 126.56 7,594
Office Operations (Islamabad Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 12 1,093.50 13,122
Office Consumables & Supplies month 12 50.62 607
Vehicle Rent & Fuel month 12 759.38 9,113
Office Operations (Field Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 12 1,100.25 13,203
Office Consumables & Supplies month 12 168.75 2,025
Vehicle Rent & Fuel (4) month 12 759.38 36,450
Sustenance month 12 1,994.85 23,938
Communications (Islamabad Office)
Communication & Internet month 12 135.00 1,620
Communications (Field Office)
Communication & Internet month 12 675.00 8,100
Other
External Evaluation lumpsum 16,200
Visibility & Communication lumpsum 16,538
RECONSTRUCTION (1 Sept. - 31 Dec. 2007) (50%)*
Staff salaries (Expat)
1 Administration and Finance Officer month 4 2,369.25 9,477
1 Project Officer month 4 1,579.50 6,318
Staff Travel (Expat)
Int. flights, private health ins, visas, etc. lumpsum 9,315
Staff salaries (Local)
1 Accountant/Admin Assistant month 4 337.50 1,350
1 Project Assistant month 4 337.50 1,350
2 Office Assistants month 4 101.25 810
1 Office boy month 4 67.50 270
Office Operations (Islamabad Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 4 303.75 1,215
Vehicle Rent & Fuel month 4 607.50 2,430
Office Consumables & Supplies month 4 33.75 135
Representation month 4 67.50 270
Communications (Islamabad Office)
Communication & Internet month 4 67.50 270
Office Operations (Field Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 4 573.75 2,295
Sustenance month 4 202.50 810
Office Consumables & Supplies month 4 67.50 270
Communications (Field Office)
Communication & Internet month 4 337.50 1,350
Other
Bank charges, taxes, duties month 4 67.50 270
RECONSTRUCTION (1 Jan. - 30 Nov. 2008) (80%)*
Staff salaries (Expat)
1 Administration and Finance Officer month 11 3,790.80 41,699
1 Project Officer month 11 2,527.20 27,799
Staff Travel Expat)
Int. flights, private health ins, visas, etc. lumpsum 14,904
Staff salaries (Local)
Pakistan – Earthquake Recovery & Rehabilitation ASPK61 (Revision 2) 70
1 Accountant/Admin Assistant month 11 648.00 7,128
1 Project Assistant month 11 432.00 4,752
3 Office Assistants month 11 172.80 5,702
1 Office boy month 11 129.60 1,426
Tax Consultancy month 11 1,188
Office Operations (Islamabad Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 11 864.00 9,504
Vehicle Rent & Fuel month 11 864.00 9,504
Office Consumables & Supplies month 11 54.00 594
Representation month 11 108.00 1,188
Communications (Islamabad Office)
Communication & Internet month 11 108.00 1,188
Office Operations (Field Office)
House Rent and Utilities month 11 1,296.00 14,256
Sustenance month 11 324.00 3,564
Office Consumables & Supplies month 10 108.00 1,080
Communications (Field Office)
Communication & Internet month 11 432.00 4,752
Others
Bank charges, taxes, duties month 11 54.00 594
Repair & Maintenance month 10 270.00 2,700
TOTAL PERSONNEL, ADMIN & SUPPORT 347,328
AUDIT & MONITORING
Audit Estimate 4,050
Monitoring & Evaluation Estimate 0
TOTAL AUDIT & MONITORING 4,050
TOTAL ESTIMATED EXPENDITURE 1,620,000
BALANCE REQUESTED 0