ANGUS LICENSING BOARD

1

ANGUS LICENSING BOARD

Minute of the quarterly meeting of the ANGUS LICENSING BOARD held in the Reid Hall, Castle Street, Forfar on Wednesday 16 January 2008 at 10.00 am. Present: Councillors THE HON RUTH LESLIE MELVILLE, JOHN WHYTE, PETER MURPHY, ALEX

KING, JIM MILLAR, MARK SALMOND and ROBERT SPINK.

QUARTERLY MEETING 1. APOLOGIES

Apologies were tendered on behalf of Councillors Iain Gaul, Helen Oswald and Glennis Middleton.

2. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

The Board noted there were no declarations of interest. 3. STATEMENT OF LICENSING POLICY MEETING

The Board agreed to hold a Statement of Licencing Policy Meeting on Thursday 31 January 2008 in the Town and County Hall, The Cross, Forfar at 5pm or at the conclusion of Corporate Services Meeting, whichever is the later.

4. MINUTES

The minutes of the quarterly meeting on 17 October 2007, adjourned meeting on 14 November 2007 and suspension hearings on 16, 21 and 23 November 2007.

5. ADJOURNED BOARD MEETING

The Board agreed that an adjourned board, if required would be held on Wednesday 13 February 2008 in The Town and County Hall, The Cross, Forfar at 5pm.

6. DETERMINATION OF APPLICATIONS LODGED UNDER THE LICENSING (SCOTLAND)

ACT 1976 AS AMENDED

6(1) DECLARATION OF FINALITY

The Board noted the declaration of finality granted under delegated authority to Lidl, Southesk Street, Brechin on 12 December 2007.

6 (2) RENEWAL OF MAIN LICENCES

The Board noted that no timeous renewal applications had been received in respect of :-

(a) Bridge Street Newsagents, 15 Bridge Street, Montrose – Off Sales (b) Thai Palace, 118-122 High Street, Arbroath - Restaurant

2 The Board noted the following renewal applications (1) to (19) which had been dealt with by the Clerk on behalf of the Board under delegated powers (unless otherwise minuted).

RENEWAL OF LICENCE AUTOMATIC SUNDAY PERMITTED HOURS HOTEL Applicant Premises Agent 1. David Alexander Blacklaws

6 Panmure Place Edzell DD9 7SB

Panmure Arms Hotel 52 High Street Edzell DD9 7TA

James & George Collie LP 33 Aberdeen 1

2. Whitbread Restaurants Limited Whitbread Court Houghton Hall Office Park Porz Avenue Dunstable and Grant Bruce c/o Monifieth Farm Brewers Fayre Arbroath Road Monifieth

The Monifieth Farm Arbroath Road Monifieth DD5 4HB

Brunton Miller LP 20 Glasgow 7

3. Merpro Leisure Limited Brent Avenue Forties Road Industrial Estate Montrose DD10 9JA and Casper Ninteman 1 Panmure Terrace Montrose DD10 8HD

The Links Hotel Mid Links Montrose DD10 8RL

Watts - Montrose LP 2 Montrose

4. Metropolitan Property and Finance Ltd 1 Peterborough Road Harrow HA1 2AX and Nick Chiverton c/o Panmure Hotel Tay Street/Princes Street Monifieth DD5 4AY

The Panmure Hotel Tay Street/Princes Street Monifieth DD5 4AY

Kerr Stirling LP 8 Stirling

OFF SALES Applicant Premises Agent 5. John Cairns

29 Borrowfield Crescent Montrose

Keystore 39 Queen Street Montrose DD10 8NH

Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

6. Tesco Stores Limited Cirrus Building C Shire Park Welwyn Garden City Hertfordshire AL7 1ZR and Colin Robert Mitchell 22A Market Street Montrose DD10 8NB

Tesco Brechin Express Brechin Service Station 49-53 Clerk Street Brechin DD9 6AZ

Hill Brown Licensing LP 6 Glasgow 3

37. Tesco Stores Limited

P O Box 400 Cirrus Building C Shire Park Welwyn Garden City Hertfordshire AL7 1ZR and Graeme Tough 4 Herald Avenue Arbroath DD11 4JJ

Tesco Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HX

Hill Brown Licensing LP 6 Glasgow 3

8. Nusrat Begum Ashraf c/o 18 Tommy Armour Place Carnoustie DD7 7QT

Off Sales 75 Ravensby Park Gardens Carnoustie DD7 7NY

RSB Macdonald LP 20 Dundee

9. Scottish Midland Co-operative Society Limited Hillwood House 2 Harvest Drive Newbridge Edinburgh EH28 8QJ and Jennifer Croall 17 Whitson Way Montrose DD10 9DX

Scotmid 62 Newmanswalls Ave Montrose DD10 9DD

Anderson Strathern DX ED3 Edinburgh 1

RESTAURANT Applicant Premises Agent 10. Ashvale Fish Restaurant Ltd

42-48 Great Western Road Aberdeen and Stuart Devine 80 Dawson Drive Westhill Aberdeen

The Ashvale 14 Trinity Road Brechin DD9 6BE

No agent

11. Montrose Football Club Ltd Wellington Street Montrose and John D Crawford 16 Whinfield Road Montrose

Links Park Stadium Montrose Football Club Wellington Street Montrose DD10 8QD

Shiells LP 2 Brechin

RENEWAL OF LICENCE INCLUDING SUNDAY PERMITTED HOURS

PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises Agent 12. Gail Frances Mullen

6 Provost Square Brechin DD9 6DB

Dalhousie Bar 1 Market Street Brechin DD9 6BA


4 13. William Lindsay and Mrs Joyce

Lindsay Partners and Trustees of Firm of William Lindsay & Son Esklyn Park Forrestmuir Forfar and Rhona Rae Whitton 12 William Street Forfar

TC's Bar & Lounge 116 Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HS


14. Marcus Findlay Waterson Tait Lineside Cottage St Cyrus Montrose DD10 OAG

Northern Vaults 9 Northesk Road Montrose DD10 8TJ


15. Scott Robert McNeil 145 River Street Brechin DD9 7ES

Bridgend Bar 145 River Street Brechin DD9 7ES

No agent

16. Denise Walker 2 Morley Place Arbroath DD11 2AJ

Station Bar 38 Keptie Street Arbroath DD11 3AF

Gillespie Macandrew WS LP 40 Edinburgh 2

17. Sheena Jane Ferguson Cochrane 1 Ashludie Terrace Monifieth

The Vault Bar High Street/Reform Street Monifieth DD5 4BA

Miller Hendry LP 40 Dundee

18. CMC Management Limited 95 Newlands Road Grangemouth FK3 8NT and Nicola Dunsire c/o All Stars International 198 East High Street Forfar DD8 2HG

All Stars International 198 East High Street Forfar DD8 2HG

Harper Macleod DX GW86 Glasgow

19. Mrs Elaine Ann Auld 64 Grangehill Drive Monifieth DD5 4RS

The Crown Inn 49 High Street Monifieth DD5 4AA

Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

6 (3) REGULAR EXTENSION OF PERMITTED HOURS

The Board noted that no applications for Regular Extension of Permitted Hours had been received in

respect of: -

1. Inverpark Hotel, 31 Bank Street, Arbroath 2. Bowlers Lounge, 1-3 Ernest Street, Arbroath – occasional extensions received to

cover the period 16 January 2008 to 31 January 2008. 3. Lochlands Bar, 14 & 16 Lochlands Street, Arbroath – occasional extensions received

to cover the period 16 January 2008 to 25 March 2008.

56 (3) (a) CATEGORY A – WITHIN GUIDELINES

The Board noted the Pro Forma information completed in respect of the undernoted applications (1) to (44) which had been circulated in members’ sets and which detailed the stated need in the locality and how the Regular Extension would benefit the community and outweigh any detriment to the locality.

The Board agreed to grant applications (1) to (55) for the hours specified subject to the entertainment

detailed being provided during the extended hours and on the Board’s standard conditions (unless otherwise minuted).

ENTERTAINMENT

Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 1. Gala Leisure (1991)

Limited New Castle House Castle Boulevard Nottingham and Marie Watkins 6A Commerce Street Arbroath

Gala Club 131 High Street Arbroath DD11 1DP McGrigors DX GW135 Glasgow

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm

The Board agreed to renew the licence subject to the additional conditions that the hours of opening shall not be earlier than 12 noon and shall end at 11.00pm and be available to patrons of bingo facilities only. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 500. 2. Mrs Moira Buchanan

5 Lindsay Street Kirriemuir DD8 5DN

Forfar Indoor Sports Bar Suttieside Road Forfar DD8 3EL No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm

The Board noted the entertainment provided in respect of the premises comprises of indoor bowling and curling. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 460 (77 curling rink, 133 bowling area and 250 in the upper and lower lounges). HOTEL Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 3. David Howatson

Finavon Hotel Finavon Forfar DD8 3QE

Stag Hotel 142-144 Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HX Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am Saturday and Sunday 11.00pm to 12 midnight (c) Satellite TV, live music, live entertainment and bar games Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

6 4. Lamb Leisure (Scotland)

Limited 55 High Street Montrose DD10 8LR and Mrs Natalie C Lamb The Carlton Hotel 139 High Street Montrose

Carlton Hotel & Restaurant 139 High Street Montrose DD10 8QN Watts - Montrose LP 2 Montrose

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 12 midnight (c) Ceilidhs and live music catering for local clientele and tourists. Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 12 midnight

5. John Thompson Esk Hotel 24 Brownlow Place Ferryden Montrose DD10 9RN

Esk Hotel 24 Brownlow Place Ferryden Montrose DD10 9RN No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Darts, dominoes, quizzes, etc Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

6. Ivor Ronald Farmer 116 Linefield Road Carnoustie

Station Hotel 23 Station Road Carnoustie DD7 6AR Scott Alexander LP 4 Montrose

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Disco dances, dances, ceilidhs, games, competitions and functions with entertainment, television and satellite television for patrons Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

7. Antony James Short Cliffburn Hotel Cliffburn Road Arbroath DD11 5BT

The Cliffburn Hotel Cliffburn Road Arbroath DD11 5BT No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live music, karaoke, quiz, sports competitions Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

8. Wendy Piggot Liscannor Easthaven Carnoustie DD7 6LQ

Dalhousie Hotel 47 High Street Carnoustie DD7 6AG No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live music, discos, weddings, dinner dances and games evenings. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

7 9. David Alexander

Blacklaws 6 Panmure Place Edzell DD9 7SB

Panmure Arms Hotel 52 High Street Edzell DD9 7TA James & George Collie LP 33 Aberdeen 1

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) The provision of meals and light background music. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am


The Panmure Hotel Tay Street/Princes Street Monifieth DD5 4AY Kerr Stirling LP 8 Stirling

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Karaoke, televised sport, pool competitions, darts, live DJ, quiz nights, live bands, DJ with entertainment Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 12 midnight

PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 11. The Firm of The Craws

Nest 71 Ravensby Park Gardens Carnoustie DD7 7NY and George Christie Irvine 6 Garten Street Broughty Ferry Dundee DD5 3HH

The Craw's Nest 71 Ravensby Park Gardens Carnoustie DD7 7NY Thorntons - Dundee LP 29 Dundee

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Charity fundraising nights, karaoke, live music, quiz night, pool, darts, dominoes, live televised sporting events (community fund raising events i.e. PTA) Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

12. Forthflats Limited and William Mutch 18 Benholm Gardens Forfar DD8 1XY

Royal Arch Bar 32/34 High Street Montrose DD10 8JL No agent

(a) Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Darts, dominoes, cribbage, pool, satellite tv, karaoke Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 12 midnight

13. Mrs Margaret May Reid 19 Grampian Gardens Arbroath DD11 4AE

The Ram's Heid East Muirlands Road Arbroath DD11 3ES Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Pool, darts, dominoes and occasional live music. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

8 14. Betsy Cook

1 Gardyne Street Friockheim DD11 4SN

Railway Inn 1 Gardyne Street Friockheim DD11 4SN No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Live music, karaoke nights, pool, darts, bridge and Sunday quiz Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

15. Robert Hendry Stack 44 St David Street Brechin DD9 6EQ

Brechin Arms 44 St. David Street Brechin DD9 6EQ No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Darts, quiz, dominoes, bar games, socialising debates. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

16. Meadowbank Inn (2000) Ltd Montrose Road Arbroath and Niall Milne 15½ Victoria Street Arbroath DD11 2BP

Meadowbank Inn Montrose Road Arbroath DD11 5RA Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Dances, dinner parties, functions and weddings. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

17. Graeme William Strachan 137 High Street Montrose DD10 8QN

Occasions Suite 50 Bridge Street Montrose DD10 8AF No agent

(b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

18. Scott Robert McNeil 145 River Street Brechin

Park Bar 21 Park Road Brechin DD9 7AE No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Pool, darts, dominoes, quiz nights, karaoke Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

19. James Andrew Walker 1a Church Street Brechin DD9 6HB

The Bolag Shipping & Trading Co. 1 Church Street Brechin DD9 6HB Kippen Campbell WS LP 10 Perth

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Darts, pool, football, disco, karaoke, quiz, bands Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

9 20. Gail Frances Mullen

6 Provost Square Brechin DD9 6DB

Dalhousie Bar 1 Market Street Brechin DD9 6BA Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Music Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

21. Lucille Margaret Conway 12 Primrose Street Carnoustie DD7 7QB

The Golf Inn 5 Park Avenue Carnoustie DD7 7JA Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Music Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

22. Aberbrothock Bar Co. Ltd. 82 Marketgate Arbroath DD11 1AT and Jim Dear 82 Marketgate Arbroath DD11 1AT

Central Bar 1/3 Brothockbridge Arbroath DD11 1AT Whelan & Co. LP 12 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live music, discos, karaoke, darts, quizzes and dominoes Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

23. Aberbrothock Bar Co. Ltd. 82 Marketgate Arbroath DD11 1AT and Jim Dear 82 Marketgate Arbroath DD11 1AT

Newgate Bar 31 West Newgate Arbroath DD11 5BZ Whelan & Co. LP 12 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live entertainment, pool, darts, quizzes, and dominoes Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

24. Rosetta McDonald 10 Nethercaldhame Brechin DD9 7HN

Red Lion Bar 55/57 Montrose Street Brechin DD9 7BZ No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Pool and darts competitions, quizzes, karaoke, disco, social events and dominoes. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

10 25. Next Generation Clubs

Ltd Mosquito Way Hatfield Business Park Hatfield AL10 9AX and Keith Battle 27 Kyle Crescent Dunfermline KY11 8GU

Next Generation Clubs Ethiebeaton Park Monifieth DD5 4HB Morton Fraser LP 47 Edinburgh 2

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Sports centre activities for members and guests and for visiting sports teams Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

26. West Bay Fisheries (Gourdon) Limited 31 William Street Gourdon DD10 0LW and William Dorward 35 West Bay Gourdon

Market Arms 95/97 High Street Montrose DD10 8QY Raeburn Christie Clark & Wallace LP 4 Stonehaven

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Darts, cribbage, pool and dominoes Monday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

27. Michael Keith Urquhart Elworth 1 Prior Road Forfar DD8 3DP

West End Bar 121 West High Street Forfar DD8 1BL Miller Consultancy LP 6 Forfar

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Darts, dominoes, pool competitions, satellite TV, pre-recorded music, bar games, quizzes Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

28. Fiona Mary Forbes 61 Dundee Loan Forfar DD8 1EA

Victoria Bar 55/57 Dundee Loan Forfar DD8 1EA No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Occasional weekend entertainment i.e. karaoke, live music, quiz nights Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

29. Dragon City Restaurants (Montrose) Limited 24 Rose Street Aberdeen AB10 1UA and Peizhu Yu 79G Huntly Street Aberdeen AB10 1TE

Peking Palace Restaurant Charleton Road Montrose DD10 9EB Plenderleath Runcie LP 54 Aberdeen 1

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Background music and restaurant meals for late diners extension to allow bar service on weekend evenings Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

11 30. Colin MacFarlane

28 South Street Newtyle PH12 8UQ

Commercial Hotel 28/30 South Street Newtyle PH12 8UQ No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Pool, darts, sky sports, live entertainment, quizzes. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

31. Norman Braes 22 High Street Montrose

The Black Abbot Coronation Way Montrose DD10 9DW Harper Macleod DX GW86 Glasgow

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live music, private functions, darts, pool, cribbage leagues. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

32. Alan Blair Wilson 3 Craig Mill Cottages Craig Mill Road Bridgefoot Dundee DD3 0PH

All Stars International 88 Dundee Street Carnoustie DD7 7PH Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Discos, live music, darts, pool, quizzes, karaoke and promotional nights. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

33. Ms Audrey R Smart 137 Dundee Road Forfar DD8 1JD

Chapter & Verse 110/114 Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HR No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live music or disco/karaoke every weekend for our patrons, occasional events eg quiz nights on weekday evenings Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

12 REFRESHMENT Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 34. David Gardner Butter

Woodrae Farm Aberlemno Forfar DD8 3PF

Golf Range and Farm Coffee Shop North Mains Farm Forfar DD8 3RN No agent


The Board agreed to defer consideration of this item until after consideration of the new licence application. Having agreed to grant the refreshment licence the Board agreed to grant the regular extension of permitted hours. REGISTERED CLUB Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 35. Graham Whyte

24 Finella Gardens Dundee DD4 9PL

Strathmartine Bowling Club Rosemill Strathmartine DD3 0PR No agent

For competitions, matches, touring clubs and social evenings. Sunday 11.00am to 12.30pm and 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

36. Charles J T Philip 5 Gables 60 Albany Road Broughty Ferry Dundee

Panmure Golf Club Burnside Road Barry Carnoustie Thorntons - Dundee LP 29 Dundee

Sunday mornings/afternoon to provide facilities for members and visitor golfers. Sunday 11.00am to 12.30pm and 2.30pm to 6.30pm

37. Charles Brown Secretary 16 Taranty Road Forfar DD8 1JY

Royal British Legion (Scotland) Forfar Branch Academy Street Forfar DD8 2HA No agent

Members parties, dances, discos, dinners, Burns suppers, interclub darts, domino and pool contests, ex service associations functions, pool and domino leagues. Sunday 2.30pm to 6.00pm Wednesday and Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

38. Mrs Doreen Wighton 19 Westfield Kirriemuir DD8 5AZ

Kirriemuir Thistle Social Club Westview Park Blairgowrie Road Kirriemuir DD8 5LG No agent

Live entertaiment, cabaret, members birthday and anniversary parties and other private functions, big screen events, bingo, darts, pool and domino competitions. Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Saturday 11.00pm to 12 midnight

39. Andrew I. B. Campbell Secretary 52 Bents Road Montrose DD10 8QA

Enoch Masonic Club 3 Upper Hall Street Montrose DD10 8JX No agent

Masonic meetings, social events such as charity fundraising, social evenings, darts and cribbage leagues, awards of trophies. Sunday 2.30pm to 6.00pm Monday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am Saturday 11.00pm to 11.45pm

13 40. Dallas Roy

29 Beechwood Road Arbroath

Royal British Legion (Scotland) Arbroath & District Branch Helen Street Arbroath Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

Social evenings including dances, Burns suppers, presentation dinners, ceilidhs and other private functions; all for the benefit of the members and those associated with the Royal British Legion within the Arbroath Community Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Saturday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am

41. Ann Rennie 53 Princes Street Monifieth

Monifieth Golf Club 8 Princes Street Monifieth DD5 4AW Thorntons - Dundee LP 29 Dundee

Sunday 11.30am to 12.30pm and 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

42. Brian Buik Low 21 Tayside Street Carnoustie

Royal British Legion (Scotland) Carnoustie Branch 88 Dundee Street Carnoustie No agent

Sports and Social Activities Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday, Tuesday and Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am Saturday 11.00pm to 12.45am

RESTAURANT Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 43. Nael Hanna

Fairneyfaulds Monikie

Café Byzantium Monikie Country Park Monikie DD5 3QN Blackadders LP 6 Dundee


44. Ashvale Fish Restaurant Ltd 42-48 Great Western Road Aberdeen and Stuart Devine 80 Dawson Drive Westhill Aberdeen

The Ashvale 14 Trinity Road Brechin DD9 6BE No agent


14 6 (3) (b) CATEGORY B – OUTWITH GUIDELINES Applicants or their agents were heard in addition to consideration of the Pro Forma information submitted with the relevant applications in respect of the following application numbers (45 to (55) The Board agreed to grant the applications Outwith Guidelines except as undernoted and subject to entertainment detailed below being provided during the extended hours and on the standard conditions (unless otherwise minuted). ENTERTAINMENT Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 45. Wellbank and District

Amenities Association Wellbank Village Hall Kellas Road Wellbank and Robert Croall Glengair Wellbank Mains Wellbank

Wellbank Village Hall Kellas Road Wellbank DD5 3PE Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 2.00am (c) Dancing, discotheques, cabaret, dinners, shows, sporting tournaments and general entertainment events Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 2.00am

The Board noted the entertainment provided in respect of the premises comprises dancing, discotheques, cabaret, dinners, shows and sporting tournaments. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 290. 46. Bellrock Inns Limited

164 South Street St Andrews KY16 9EG and Mark Sievwright 34 Park Road Brechin

Devito's 11 Millgate Arbroath DD11 1NN Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Disco music/live bands Wednesday to Sunday 11.00pm to 2.00am

The Board noted the entertainment provided in respect of the premises comprises disco music/live music. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 220 on first floor. 114 on second floor and 210 on ground floor. 47. Graham Douglas

39 Woodend Drive Kirriemuir DD8 4TF

Buddies 2A St Malcolm's Wynd Kirriemuir DD8 4HB No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 1.00am Thursday 11.00pm to 1.00am Friday to Sunday 11.00pm to 2.00am (c) Discotheque / ceilidh / live music Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 1.00am Thursday 11.00pm to 1.00am Friday to Sunday 11.00pm to 2.00am

The Board noted the entertainment provided in respect of the premises comprises disco ceilidh. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 257.

15 48. Deborah Whyte

46 Maryfield Edinburgh EH7 5AS

Club One 89-91 North Street Forfar DD8 3BL No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Discos - regularly on Fridays and Saturdays and occasionally on Thursdays and Sundays Thursday to Sunday 11.00pm to 2.00am

The Board noted that a letter of objection had been received. Deborah Whyte confirmed that she had not received a copy of the letter of objection. The Board also noted that Ms Norrie, Chairman of Market Mews Residents Association, was not present. The Board therefore agreed that the letter of objection was not competent, as this had not been competently served. The Board noted the entertainment provided in respect of the premises comprises discos, live bands and personal appearances. The Board also agreed to renew the licence subject to an additional condition that the maximum number of persons (patrons and staff) permitted within the premises at any one time be restricted to 280 on ground floor and 60 on first floor. HOTEL Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 49. Tayfield Investments Ltd

and Steven Cumming Holly Hill 69 Dundee Road Broughty Ferry Dundee

Queens Hotel 12/14 The Cross Forfar DD8 1BX No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 12 noon to 12.30pm and 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 12 noon to 12.30pm and 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Thursday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Karaoke, live music, DJs Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Thursday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am

50. Isobel Gracie 3 Bank Street Kirriemuir DD8 4BE

Hook's Hotel 3 Bank Street Kirriemuir DD8 4BE Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Thursday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Karaoke/discos, pool matches and league, dominoes and big screen TV, football. Monday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Thursday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am

51. Oxford Hotels & Inns Management Limited 61 Chandos Place London WC2N 4HG and James Watts Rockridge Low Causeway Culross Fife KY12 8HL

Carnoustie Golf Course Hotel The Links Carnoustie DD7 7JF Kerr Stirling LP 8 Stirling

(a) Afternoon Opening for the benefit of golfing patrons. Monday to Sunday 10.00am to 12.30pm Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live and recorded music. Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

16 PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Hours Requested 52. K & N Leisure Ltd

177 Buchanan Street Glasgow and Karen Mitchell 16 Applegate Arbroath

Burns Bar 35 Lordburn Arbroath DD11 1JD Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am Saturday 11.00pm to 12 midnight (c) Darts, pool, live entertainment Monday to Friday 11.00pm to 1.00am Saturday 11.00pm to 12 midnight

53. Keith Swankie 4 Gardyne Street Letham DD8 2PR

Commercial Inn 2 The Square Letham DD8 2PR No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) Mens darts, ladies darts, pool, dominoes, Scottish music, live music, recorded music, quizzes, competitions and games nights. Sunday to Wednesday 11.00pm to 12.00 midnight Thursday to Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

54. Belhaven Brewery Co Ltd Atrium House 6 Back Walk Stirling FK8 2QE and Donald McLeod c/o Lindsays Solicitors Caledonian Exchange 19A Canning Street Edinburgh EH3 8HE

Sharky’s 21 George Street Montrose DD10 8EW Lindsays LP 102 Edinburgh 2

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (c) DJ, live music, plasma TV (showing terrestrial TV, satellite TV, football, music videos, special events and concerts, sport – live and pre-recorded), karaoke, functions (both third party and organised by the premises), quiz nights and similar. Monday and Tuesday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Wednesday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am

55. Plough Inn (Forfar) Limited and Ian Whyte 48 Market Street Forfar DD8 3EW

The Plough Inn 48 Market Street Forfar DD8 3EW No agent

(a) Afternoon Opening Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm (b) Private Functions for Self Contained Function Suite Sunday 2.30pm to 6.30pm Monday to Sunday 11.00pm to 1.00am (c) Live entertainment, karaoke, provision of darts, pool, dominoes and other games for league teams and individuals Sunday to Thursday 11.00pm to 12 midnight Friday and Saturday 11.00pm to 1.00am

The Board deferred consideration of this application to the adjourned board.

176 (4) CHILDREN’S CERTIFICATES The Board considered the undernoted renewal applications (1) to (8) and agreed to grant the Children’s Certificates for the designated area (unless otherwise minuted). Renewal Applications HOTEL Applicant Premises and Agent Details 1. Merpro Leisure Limited

Brent Avenue Forties Road Industrial Estate Montrose DD10 9JA and Casper Ninteman 1 Panmure Terrace Montrose DD10 8HD

The Links Hotel Mid Links Montrose DD10 8RL Watts - Montrose LP 2 Montrose

Hotel restaurant function area, lounge bar/foyer.


The Panmure Hotel Tay Street/Princes Street Monifieth DD5 4AY Kerr Stirling LP 8 Stirling

Main lounge bar excluding conservatory.

PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Details 3. William Lindsay and Mrs

Joyce Lindsay Partners and Trustees of Firm of William Lindsay & Son Esklyn Park Forrestmuir Forfar and Rhona Rae Whitton 12 William Street Forfar

TC's Bar & Lounge 116 Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HS Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

Lounge Bar only.

4. Marcus Findlay Waterson Tait Lineside Cottage St Cyrus Montrose DD10 OAG

Northern Vaults 9 Northesk Road Montrose DD10 8TJ Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

Downstairs area between kitchen and bar. Toilets upstairs and to the right. Non smoking area as existing certificate.

5. Scott Robert McNeil 145 River Street Brechin DD9 7ES

Bridgend Bar 145 River Street Brechin DD9 7ES No agent

Lounge/function suite with ladies, gents toilets and disabled toilets with nappy changing facilities.

18 6. Sheena Jane Ferguson

Cochrane 1 Ashludie Terrace Monifieth

The Vault Bar High Street/Reform Street Monifieth DD5 4BA Miller Hendry LP 40 Dundee

Lounge Bar.

7. CMC Management Limited 95 Newlands Road Grangemouth FK3 8NT and Nicola Dunsire 47 West High Street Forfar DD8 1BG

All Stars International 198 East High Street Forfar DD8 2HG Harper Macleod DX GW86 Glasgow

Area coloured red on plan – lounge bar to which children have access. Area coloured blue – toilet areas to which children have access.

8. Mrs Elaine Ann Auld 64 Grangehill Drive Monifieth DD5 4RS

The Crown Inn 49 High Street Monifieth DD5 4AA Thorntons - Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

Function Suite and Lounge.

6 (5) CONFIRMATION OF SUBSTITUTION EMPLOYEE/DAY TO DAY MANAGER The Board considered the undernoted applications (1) to (9). After hearing the applicants submissions the Board agreed to grant the confirmations of substitutions of employee/day to day manager (unless otherwise minuted). OFF SALES Applicant Premises and Agent Details of Experience 1. Lothian Borders & Angus

Co-operative Society Ltd 46 Channel Street Galashiels and Lorraine Doig 45 Tarry Road Arbroath DD11 4BA

Abbeygate Supermarket Academy Street Forfar DD8 2HA Gourley McBain LP 2 Carnoustie

The Board noted that Ms Doig had already attended a course.

2. Lothian Borders & Angus Co-operative Society Limited 46 Channel Street Galashiels and Sandra Gall 43 Arbirlot Road Arbroath DD11 2ES

Off Sales 10-12 Cairnie Street Arbroath DD11 3BJ Gourley McBain LP 2 Carnoustie

Required to attend training.

3. Lothian Borders & Angus Co-op Society Ltd 46 Channel Street Galashiels and Carol Cargill 14 East Kirkton Road Arbroath

Timmergreens Disco 7 Arbirlot Road Arbroath DD11 2EW Gourley McBain LP 2 Arbroath


19 4. Scottish Midland Co-

operative Society Limited Hillwood House 2 Harvest Drive Newbridge Edinburgh EH28 8QJ and Neil Robert McHardy 274 Ravensby Road Carnoustie DD7 7NW

Scotmid 49 Barry Road Carnoustie DD7 7QQ Anderson Strathern DX ED3 Edinburgh 1

The Board noted that Mr McHardy had already attended a course.

5. Tesco Stores Limited P O Box 400 Cirrus Building C Shire Park Welwyn Garden City Hertfordshire AL7 1ZR and Graeme Tough 4 Herald Avenue Arbroath DD11 4JJ

Tesco Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HX Hill Brown Licensing LP 6 Glasgow 3

The Board noted that Mr Tough had already attended a course.

6. Lothian Borders & Angus Co-op Society Ltd 46 Channel Street Galashiels and Jackie Millar 61C Millgate Friockheim DD11 4TW

Off Sales Gardyne Street Friockheim Arbroath DD11 4SN Gourley McBain LP 2 Carnoustie


PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Details of Experience 7. Belhaven Brewery Co.

Limited Belhaven Brewery Dunbar and Jacqueline McHaffie c/o Tolbooth 37-43 West High Street Forfar DD8 1BE

Tolbooth 37-43 West High Street Forfar DD8 1BE Harper Macleod DX GW86 Glasgow

Ms McHaffie has 2 years licensing experience. Employed at Victoria Inn, Haddington for 2 years assisting her sister who was the licensee in the operation and management of the premises. ***

The Board agreed to defer consideration of this application, at the request of the legal agent, to the adjourned board. 8. Forthflats Limited

18 Benholm Gardens Forfar DD8 1XY and William David Wallace 26 Colliston Drive Broughty Ferry Dundee DD5 3TL

The Plough (formerly The Arbroath Arms) 3 Fisheracre Arbroath DD11 1LE No agent

The Board noted that Mr Wallace had already attended a course.

20 9. Michael Bartow Forbes

and Gail Forbes t/a Kingennie Fishings Omachie Kingennie Newbigging and Brian Park 3 The Holding Inglismaldie Laurencekirk AB30 1QT

Forbes of Kingennie Kingennie Fishings Wellbank DD5 3RD Thorntons - Dundee LP 29 Dundee

The Board noted that Mr Park had already attended a course.

6 (6) TRANSFERS PERMANENT TRANSFER (FOLLOWING TEMPORARY TRANSFERS) The Board noted that no applications for Permanent Transfer (following Temporary Transfer) had been received in respect of the undernoted premises. The Board also noted that these licences now revert back to the previous licenceholders.

1. The Liquor Store, 35 High Street, Monifieth – Off Sales Licence reverted back to Mohammed Ashraf.

2. West Port Bar, 21-23 Keptie Street, Arbroath – Public House Licence reverted back to Andrew

Cornwall.

The Board considered the undernoted applications (1) to (13). After hearing the applicants submissions the Board agreed to grant the permanent transfers. ENTERTAINMENT Applicant Premises and Agent Details of Experience 1. Deborah Whyte

46 Maryfield Edinburgh EH7 5AS

Club One 89-91 North Street Forfar DD8 3BL No agent

The Board noted that Ms Whyte had already attended a course.

2. Seaton Catering Limited 10 Albert Place Stirling FK8 2QL and Jacqueline Whittingham c/o Seaton Estate Caravan Park Seaton Estate Arbroath DD11 5SE

Seaton Estate Caravan Park Seaton Estate Arbroath DD11 5SE Kerr Stirling LP 8 Stirling


HOTEL Applicant Premises and Agent Details of Experience 3. Kerry Hunter

80 Milton Street Dundee DD5 4QG

The Old Royal Inn 67/73 High Street Monifieth DD5 4AA No agent

The Board noted that Ms Hunter had already attended a course.

21 4. Whitbread Restaurants

Limited Whitbread Court Houghton Hall Office Park Porz Avenue Dunstable and Grant Bruce c/o Monifieth Farm Brewers Fayre Arbroath Road Monifieth

The Monifieth Farm Arbroath Road Monifieth DD5 4HB Brunton Miller LP 20 Glasgow 7

The Board noted that Mr Bruce had already attended a course.

5. Lamb Leisure (Scotland) Limited 55 High Street Montrose DD10 8LR and Mrs Natalie C Lamb The Carlton Hotel 139 High Street Montrose

Carlton Hotel & Restaurant 139 High Street Montrose DD10 8QN Watts - Montrose LP 2 Montrose

The Board noted that Mrs Lamb had already attended a course.

6. Antony James Short Cliffburn Hotel Cliffburn Road Arbroath DD11 5BT

The Cliffburn Hotel Cliffburn Road Arbroath DD11 5BT No agent

The Board noted that Mr Short had already attended a course.

OFF SALES Applicant Premises and Agent Details of Experience 7. Partnership of Eileen

Weighton and Charles J McKenzie 37 Brechin Road Kirriemuir DD8 4DA and Eileen K Weighton Partner/Owner 37 Brechin Road Kirriemuir DD8 4DA

C & E Westmuir Shop & Post Office Main Road Westmuir Kirriemuir DD8 5AP Miller Hendry LP 40 Dundee

Ms Weighton has 3 months licensing experience. Barmaid at Airlie Arms Hotel, Kirriemuir. Booked on course at Angus College on 31 October 2007. ***

As Ms Weighton was not present, the Board deferred consideration of the above item to the adjourned board. PUBLIC HOUSE 8. Lucille Margaret Conway

12 Primrose Street Carnoustie DD7 7QB

The Golf Inn 5 Park Avenue Carnoustie DD7 7JA Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

The Board noted this was a technical application, which had been superceded by a further transfer.

9. James Conway 17 Primrose Street Carnoustie DD7 7QB

Links Bar 96/98 Dundee Street Carnoustie DD7 7PH Blackadders LP 1 Forfar

The Board noted that the application had been withdrawn by the applicant’s agent.

22 10. Brian Burgess

73 Wasdale Park Seascale Cumbria CA20 1PD

Lorne Bar 17 Commerce Street Arbroath DD11 1NA Gourley McBain LP 2 Arbroath

Mr Burgess has over 6 years licensing experience. Manager at Lion and Lamb Hotel, Gosforth. Holds a personal licence issued by Copeland Borough Council. ***

As Mr Burgess was not present, the Board deferred consideration of the above item to the adjourned board. 11. Seaton Catering Limited

10 Albert Place Stirling FK8 2QL and Jacqueline Whittingham c/o Seaton Estate Caravan Park Seaton Estate Arbroath DD11 5SE



12. Caledonia Taverns (Osprey) Limited 150 Aldersgate Street London EC1A 4EJ and Alistair Hammond-Chambers Robinhill Blythbridge West Linton EH46 7DG

The Zoar Inn 20 Muir Street Forfar DD8 3JY Harper Macleod DX GW86 Glasgow

The Board noted this was a technical application, which had been superceded by a further transfer.

13. Sylvia Glendinning c/o Roods Bar 10 Roods Kirriemuir DD8 4EZ

Roods Bar 10 Roods Kirriemuir DD8 4EZ No agent

The Board noted that Mrs Glendinning had already attended a course.

6 (7) CONSENT TO ALTER 6 (7)(a) Delegated Application The Board noted the undernoted delegated application had been dealt with by the Clerk under delegated authority and the Board accordingly noted that this application had been approved. PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Details 1. Angus Council

Cultural Services County Buildings Forfar and Norman Atkinson 5 Tolmount Crescent Montrose DD10 9DQ

Webster Theatre 64 High Street Arbroath

Relocation of Assembly Hall bar from east corner of hall to west corner; and the creation of a small bar in the east section of the ground floor entrance foyer.

236 (7)(b) Board Application

The Board considered the undernoted application (unless otherwise minuted). PUBLIC HOUSE Applicant Premises and Agent Details 1. Seaton Catering Limited

10 Albert Place Stirling FK8 2QL and Jacqueline Whittingham c/o Seaton Estate Caravan Park Seaton Estate Arbroath DD11 5SE


General refurbishment incorporating restaurant and toilet facilities on ground floor and a strip out and refurbishment of the first floor.

The Board noted the memorandum from Environmental and Consumer Protection division dated 31 December 2007. The Board also noted an undertaking had been lodged by Kerr Stirling advising that they would comply with the works required prior to the commencement of trading. The Board agreed to grant the application. 6 (8) FOR THE GRANT OF A NEW LICENCE The Board agreed to approve the undernoted applications (1) to (5) (unless otherwise minuted). Applicant Premises and Agent Type of Licence 1. Mrs Saleha Sherin

Bhuiyan 17 Gotterstone Drive West Ferry Dundee DD5 1QX

Opurbo 31-33 West Port Arbroath DD11 1RF No agent

Full Grant of Restaurant Licence The Board noted that Mrs Bhuiyan had already attended a course.

2. David Gardner Butter Woodrae Farm Aberlemno Forfar DD8 3PF

Golf Range and Farm Coffee Shop North Mains Farm Forfar DD8 3RN No agent

Full Grant of Refreshment Licence (including Sunday permitted hours) Required to attend training.

3. John Reid & Sons Newbigging Farm, Tealing and Elizabeth Hazel Cramond West Winds Shielhill Road Tealing

Farmers Market Newbigging Farm Tealing RSB Macdonald LP 19 Dundee

Full Grant of Off Sales Licence Ms Cramond has 13 years licensing experience. Employed by various alcohol retailers from 1991 to 2004 - marketing and sales. She is to attend BIIAB personal licence holder's course on 11/2/08.

The Board agreed to defer consideration of this application, at the request of the legal agent, to the adjourned board.

24 4. Benjamin Luke Dunn

13 MacLagan Road Carnoustie DD7 7LQ

OC's Café Deli 1B High Street Carnoustie DD7 6AN No agent

Full Grant of Off Sales Licence The Board noted that Mr Dunn had already attended a course.

5. David Howatson Finavon Hotel Finavon Forfar DD8 3QE

Stag Hotel 142-144 Castle Street Forfar DD8 3HX Thorntons – Arbroath LP 1 Arbroath

Provisional Grant of Public House Licence under Section 26 (1) Required to attend training.

25

ANGUS LICENSING BOARD Minute of the special meeting of the ANGUS LICENSING BOARD held in the Reid Hall, Castle Street, Forfar on Wednesday 16 January 2008 immediately following the quarterly meeting.

AGENDA

1. CONFIRMATION OF LICENCEHOLDER’S ATTENDANCE AT TRAINING COURSE

The Board were advised that Marie Faherty of B-lo, 41 Market Street, Montrose had completed a relevant training course in January 2007.

2. UPDATED REPORT ON ALTERATIONS TO LICENSED PREMISES The Board were advised that the alterations to premises at All Stars International, 19 Swan Street, Brechin were now complete.

3. TEMPORARY TRANSFER OF ENTERTAINMENT AND PUBLIC HOUSE LICENCES – SEATON CARAVAN PARK, SEATON ESTATE, ARBROATH The Board noted that an application had been lodged by Seaton Catering Limited and Niki Kingston. Mr and Mrs Whittingham and Niki Kingston were in attendance together with legal agent, Jacqueline Ireland of Kerr Stirling. The letter from Tayside Police dated 20 December 2007 was circulated to the Board. The Board were advised a contract of employment had been received and this was subsequently circulated. Chief Inspector Clark confirmed he was now satisfied that Ms Kingston will be employed with Seaton Catering Limited with effect from February 2008. The Board were also advised that the premises were closed but were due to re-open in March 2008. The Board agreed to grant the temporary transfer of the public house and entertainment licences. The Board also requested that the licenceholder undertakes the appropriate training course.

4. SOMERFIELD, TRINITY ROAD, BRECHIN – RELOCATION OF ALCOHOL The Board agreed to note the proposed refurbishment.

5. LIST OF ACCREDITED COURSE PROVIDERS FOR PERSONAL LICENCEHOLDERS The Board noted the contents of the list.

MATTERS TO BE HELD IN PRIVATE

6. LICENSED PREMISES IN MONTROSE

The Board noted the letter from Tayside Police dated 9 January 2008 and agreed to hold a suspension hearing after the adjourned meeting on 13 February 2008 at 5pm in the Town and County Hall, Forfar.

7. LICENSED PREMISES IN FORFAR The Board noted the letter from Eileen Wallace dated 3 January 2008 and agreed to hold an investigation of complaint hearing after the adjourned meeting on 13 February 2008 at 5pm in the Town and County Hall, Forfar.

ANGUS LICENSING BOARD

Documents

Transcript of ANGUS LICENSING BOARD