345 Via Del Norte, La Jolla, CA 92037

HISTORIC RESOURCE RESEARCH REPORT FOR

VILLA FRANCESCA THE RUTH AND THOMAS L. SHEPHERD HOUSE

345 VIA DEL NORTE, LA JOLLA, CA 92037

Submitted to City of San Diego

Development Services Department 1222 First Ave, MS 501 San Diego, CA 92101

Prepared for: Susan and Karsten Joehnk

345 Via del Norte La Jolla, CA 92037

Prepared by: Seonaid McArthur and Susan Ketring

La Jolla Landmark Group La Jolla Historical Society

PO Box 2085 La Jolla 92038-2085

I" At-a-Glance" Report Summary Property Information & Applicable Criteria

Resource Address: -~3=4""'5--"V"'ia...,d""'e...._l ~N,.,.act.....,e_,_,_L..._a..,,J'""al""la.._,,,C,_,A"""'9""2,,.,.0'""3'-'-7 ____ _ APN: _3_5_7-_o_30_-_02 ____ _

Resou rce Name (per HRB naming policy): Villa Francesca - The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House

· Resource Type: __ S_i_ng_l_e_F_a_m_ily_Pr_o_pe_rty ____ _ Will you be Submitting a Mills Act Application Following Designation? Y ~ N 0

Date of Construction: __ 1_9_4_0______ Architect/Builder: Thomas Shepherd/ Frank L. Stimson, Builder

Prior Resource Address (if relocated):---------------------------

Date of Relocation: N/A ----------

App Ii canf s Name: _ _ S_e_o_na_i_d _M_c_A_rt_hu_r_/ S_u_s_a_n _K_et_ri_n~g __

Address: 5666 La Jolla Blvd #151, La Jolla Ca 92037

Pbone #: 858-922-5162

Ema i I: [email protected]

Owner's Name: Susan and Karsten Joehnk

Address: 345 Via del Norte, La Jolla, CA, 92037

Phone#: 1 (858) 774-9345

Email : [email protected]

The resource is being nominated for designation as a historical resource under:

D HRB Criterion A as a special element of the City's. a community's or a neighborhood·s D historical development D archaeological development D cultural development D social development D economic development D political development D aesthetic development D engineering development D landscaping development D architectural development

ire-fo-Hcrwirrg-reasorr(: . -------------------------------

11], 8 c . . B c . . . . 1

Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd 1 1 1 . 1 . . .ti . - '- ntenon 1or its association wit 1 v-no w 11c 1 1s sigm 1cant m

local. state or national history for the followi ng reason(s): Master Architect Thomas L. Shepherd was the longsst p+acticing architsct in La Jolla's history @AQ-1/'Jith Ruth an impo1iant philanthopi-st-. --

HRB Criterion C as a good/excellent example of _ _ l_ta_l_ia_n_R_e_n_a_is_s_an_c_e_R_e_v_iv_a_l _________ _

HRB Criterion Das a notable work of Thomas Shepherd . a Master _A_r_ch_it_e_ct ___ _ Previously established as a Master D Proposed as a Master

D HRB Criterion E as a property which has been determined eligible by the National Park Service for listing 011

the National Register of Historic Places or is listed or has been determined eligible by the State Historical Preservation Office for listing on the State Register of Historical Resources.

D l-JRB Criterion Fas a contributing resource to the ______ _ ___ Historical District.

Are interior elements/features included in the nomination and proposed for designation? 0 Yes ii No If Yes, list elements a11d location:------------ ----------------

Ii-:. •

-

";At-a-Glance" Report Summary Required Forms and Documentation

Circle Yes or No, indicating whether or not the fo ll owing required documentation has been provided:

Report Copies

Y N Provide one copy of the Historical Resomce Research Rep011, double sided and stapled

Depai1ment of Parks and Recreation Forms Y N Primary Record (523a)

Y N BSO Record (523b)

Y N Archaeological Record (523c) (if applicable)

N District Record (523d) (if applicable)

N Locational Map (523j) (if applicable)

N Sketch Map (523k) (if applicable) N Continuation Sheet (5231)

Attachment A N Assessor's Record

N Notice of Completion

N Water Sewer Records

N Building Permits

N Site Plan with Footprint y N County Lot & Block Book y N Previous Survey Forms

Attachment C y N City SD 800 Scale Eng Maps

Y. N USGS Maps V N Original Subdivision Map ' y N 1886/1887 Sanborn y N 1906 Sanborn y N 1921 Sanborn y N 1 940 Sanborn y N 1950 Sanborn y N 1956 Sanborn

Attachment B y N

N

N

Chain of Title

Directory Search

Deed from the Date of Construction

Attachment D y N Historical and Transitional Photos y N Cunent Photos ofN01th Elevation y; N Current Photos of East Elevation y N Current Photos of South Elevation y N Ctment Photos of West Elevation y N Photos with a key floor plan

(for interiors under consideration)

Attachment E y N Criterion A Documentation

N Criterion B Documentation

N Criterion C Documentation

N Criterion D Documentation

N Criterion E Documentation

N Criterion F Documentation

State of California 11 The Resources Agency

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION

PRIMARY RECORD

Other Review Code

Primary# _ _ _

HRI #

Trinomial NRHP Status Code

Listings Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 17 *Resource Name or#: Villa Francesca - The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House

P1. Other Identifier:

* P2. Location: D Not for Publication • Unrestricted *a. County San Diego and (P2c, P2e, and P2b or P2d. Attach a Location Map as

necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad La Jolla, Ca_Date 194 0 T 16S; R 2 W Pro jec t ed;; Sec unsectioned portion Pueblo Lands San Bernadina B.M. c. Address 345 Vi a del Norte City La Jolla Zip 92037 d. UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources) Zone mE/ mN e. Other Locational Data: (e.g., parcel #, directions to resource, elevation, decimal degrees, etc., as appropriate) APN 357-030-02: Lot two in Block Seven of La Joll a Hermosa, according to Map #1810, f il ed in the Office of the County Recorder of sa id San Diego County, November 21 ", 1924; in La Jolla, a community in the City of San Diego, California.

*P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition, alterations , size, setting, and boundaries)

Villa Francesca-The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House - was designed by Master Architect Thomas Shepherd and served as his family home from 1943 until 1986. Located one and a half blocks west of the intersection of La Jolla Boulevard and Via del Norte, the one-story, 2937 sq. ft., 4 bedroom and 4.5 bathroom home was designed in 1939, just months after the architects first tr·ip to Europe. Shepherd described the home's style as following 181

h century Italian prototypes, today c lassified as Italian Renaissance Revival (McAlester, 2013). Shepherd emphasizes a measured sense of proportion and symmetry through co lor and form: centered at the end of a circu lar drive, the entry fac;ade projects forward from two side aisles and is accented w ith class ical p il asters, a w ide corni ce and molding and low-profile hipped roof covered in green

terracotta tiles . A central axis ~---------------------------------. connects the entry with the

landscaped back garden, that includes vine covered pergolas, decorative tiles and p lanters. The house is iTiex-cellent cond"irion with only minor alterations. *P3b. Resource Attributes: (Single Family Property

*P4. Resources Present: ~uilding P5b. Description of Photo: (view, date,

accession #) Front Fac;:ade -Villa Francesca: Ruth and Thomas L Shepherd House *PG. Date Constructed/Age 1940 and Source:Water hook-up/drawings/ W,istoric iJ Prehistoric :J Both *P7. Owner and Address: Susan and Karsten Joehnk 345 Via del Norte, La Jolla Ca 92037 *PS. Recorded by: Seonaid McArthur and Susan Ketring, La Jol la Landmark Group, La Jolla Historical Society, PO Box 2085 La Jolla C 92038-2085

*P9. Date Recorded: 02-13-2018 *P10.SurveyType: Historical Resource Research Report *P11. Report Citation: (Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none.")

Historica l Resource Research Report for Vi ll a Francesca:the Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd house. *Attachments: =NONE • Location Mapa:ontinuation Sheet aBuilding, Structure, and Object Record · Archaeological Record - .oistrict Record ::Jlinear Feature Record 2Milling Station Record ~Rock Art Record ·:Art ifact Record •Photograph Record =i Other (List):

DPR 523A (9/201 3) *Required information

State of California 11 The Resources Agency Primary #

DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#

BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD *Resource Name or# (Assigned by recorder) Villa Francesca- Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House*NRHP Status Code _lB__ Page 2 of _1 7 __

B1. Historic Name: Villa Francesca - The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House B2. Common Name: Villa Francesca B3. Original Use: single-family home 84. Present Use: single- family home *B5. Architectural Style: Italian Renaissance Revival *B6. Construction History: (Construction date, alterations, and date of alterations) Built in -1940; Back Garden Logia

1949; Addition and Enclosing of Loggia 1961; Pool 1969. Erley Family: Loggia/kitchen addition and new Loggia doors 1994-95

*B7. Moved? 9'0 DYes OUnknown Date: N/A Original Location: Same --------*B8. Related Features: None B9a. Architect: Thomas L. Shepherd b. Builder: 1940 unknown; 1993 Don Dewhurst *B10. Significance: Theme Italian Renaissance - Eclectic Area La Jolla

Period of Significance 19 4 0 Property Type single-family residence Applicable Criteria B, C, and D (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity.)

Villa Francesca-The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd house was designed in 1939 by Master Architect Thomas Shepherd as his family home. Shepherd would become the longest practicing architect in La Jolla's history, spanning the subdivision "boom years" of the late 1920s through the 1970s. Influenced by two months spent in Italy at the close of the Depression, the architect applied elements of classical Italian architecture to his personal suburban home. Classified today as Italian Renaissance -Eclectic (McAlester, 2013) the residence is symmetrically placed along an axis from the front door to the back-patio wall. The fac;ade is set back off the street, aligned at the top of a curved drive, and framed by two olive trees planted by the architect in the 1940s. Classical elements are painted off-white in contrast to building's coral stucco exterior: pilasters, molded surrounds, a wide entablature/cornice that runs the width of the building. The house embraces the Southern California indoor/outdoor lifestyle: doors from living room and loggia open seamlessly onto a verdant patio where original trees and plantings are tucked between enclosed patio areas and walkways decorated with antique tiles collected by the architects during his many travels around the world. Two owners, have made minor changes including replacement of patio doors and a new kitchen, resulting in only minor changes to the building's exterior. The residence has excellent historical and architectural integrity.

B11. Additional Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes) _N_o_ne _________________ _ *B12. References: See Continuation Sheet

B13. Remarks: None

*B14. Evaluator: Seonaid McArthur & Susan Ketring *Date of Evaluation: 12-01-2017

(This space reserved for official comments.)

DPR 5238 (9/2013) *Required information

State of California II Natural Resources Agency


CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial

Property Name: Villa Francesca-The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House Page 3 of 17

I) City of San Diego HRB Criterion A: The key distinction provided by the City in HRS Criterion A is that in order for structures or built

candidates to be considered as historically significant they must be characterized as exemplify ing

or reflecting "special elements" of development. The Guidelines for the Application

of Historic Resources Board Designation Criteria state that:

-Special elements of development refer to a resource that is distinct among others of its

kind or that surpass the usual in significance. It is not enough for a resource to simply

reflect an aspect of development, as all buildings, structures, and objects do. (Italics

added).

Consideration for designation is, therefore, established based upon whether or not the structure

exemp lifies or reflects special elements of development listed under Criterion A.

Discussion: The 345 Via del Norte house, named Villa Francesca by Ruth and Thomas Shepherd

was completed in 1940 in Italian Renaissance - Revival style. For the evaluation under HRS A, the

following aspects of development were considered:

• Historical Development: Historical development shall exemplify or reflect a special or unique

aspect of the city's general historical development; or shall exemplify or reflect a unique aspect

of the city's history (City of San D iego H RB 2009a). There are two ways Villa Francesca -

• The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd house, completed in 1940, exemplifies special aspects of La

J..9 lla's history: (1 it was the home of La o ll a's longest practicing and most prolific architect,

and (2) the design marks a turning point in scale and aesthetic direction taken by the architect.

Shepherd's career spanned the years 192 7 to 1979, or fifty-two years, making him the longest

practicing architect in La Jolla's history. Thirty-six of those professional years were spent while

living in Villa Francesca. It was here that the architect would die at age 82, surrounded by his

characteristic light-filled rooms and the couple's antiques and art. Of the other eleven

architects working in La Jolla in the 1920s, only three continued to work after the Depression,

Richard Requa, Cliff May, and Thomas Shepherd. (McArthur et al. 2017) Shepherd's own

designs, and those built with his partner Herbert Mann, between 1927 and 1937, are typically

multistory Spanish Eclectic designs, with an occasional Monterey two-story residence.

The modest scale of Villa Francesca, and its classical Italian design mark a turning point in the

architect's work. If the CHRID record of Shepherd buildings is sorted chronologically one can

view the shift that occurs in his style after 1940. (See Appendix E, page 61-62) The scale and

simplification seen in Shepherd's Depression-era properties such as - HRS # 1000 (1933),

#898 (1934), #710 (193 7) - show the architect's quest for economies of scale, materials, and

design. Several other Shepherd (non-designated) homes in La Jolla built during the 1930s are

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013}



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


multi-story Spanish Revival designs. 1 (San Diego Union, 1930) However, following what was

likely his first trip to Italy, at the close of the Depression, he created a model Mediterranean

des ign for the suburban home. The architect returned to this model for subsequent

commissions, such as 7741 Lookout Drive, La Jolla, where Shepherd dupli cates the front entry

fac;ade used in Villa Francesca (Appendix E. pg. 63) . While Villa Francesca clearly served as a

conceptual model for the arch itect, and he has played a signif icant ro le in the town's

arch itectural history, the home does not meet Criterion A, as this one design does not appear

to have had an impact to the town 's overall historical development.

• Archaeological Development: Archaeological Development may be prehistoric or historic in

nature but must exemplify archaeological development through subsurface deposits and may

include associated surface features (City of San D iego HRB 2009a). No archaeological sites

are associated with the Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House. The property is therefore, not

significant with respect to any form of archaeological development.

• Cultural/Social Development: Cultural development shall exemplify or reflect development that is associated with a group of people linked together by shared values, beliefs, and historical associations, or are properties associated with significant achievement in the visual and fine arts (painting, sculpture, architecture, theater, dance, music), literature, philosophy, religion, science, mathematics, the social studies, or any of the disciplines that are commonly associated with public and private institutions of higher learning and/or academic inquiry. Social development shall exemplify or reflect development that is associated with relations and interactions with others (City of San Diego HRB 2009a) . Historic research into the Ruth and Thomas L Shepherd did not reveal an association with events or associations. The property is, therefore, not significant with respect to any form of cultu ral or social development.

• Economic Development: Economic development shall exemplify or reflect development associated w ith the local, regional, state or national economy or economics, including manufacturing, labor and agriculture, maritime and transportation industries (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House is not associated with any patterns of economic development reflecting local or reg ional economic patterns or industries. The property is, therefore, not significant w ith respect to any form of economic development.

• Political Development: Political development sha ll exemplify or reflect development associated with politics or the political atmosphere, including women's suffrage, neighborhood activism, labor organizations and the Civil Rights Movement associated with ethnic and gay/lesbian issues (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House is not associated with any pol itical movements or individuals associated w ith politics. The property is, therefore, not significant with respect to any form of political development.

• Aesthetic Development: Aesthetic development shall exemplify or reflect development

associated w ith an artistic arrangement in theory or practice (City of San Diego HRB 2009a) .

1 See "New Architectural Gem for La Jolla", San Diego Union March 9, 1930, and the Roger and Jennie Jewell Pelton house,

1802 Amalfi Street, La Jolla, buil t in 1932.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House is not assoc iated with any specific aesthetic patterns

of archi tectura l developments or arrangements that reflect any noteworthy design elements.

The property is, therefore, not significant with respect to any form of aesthetic development.

• Engineering Development: Engineering development shall exemplify or reflect development

associated with engineering (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). The engineering design of the

Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House is not associated with any unusual or unique aspects of

eng ineering design or development. The property is, therefore, not significant with respect to

any form of engineering development.

• Landscape Development: Landscape development shall exernplify or reflect development

associated with garden and park design, subdivision design, or ecosystem/habitat restoration

and may include professionally applied standards or design ingenuity within landscape disciplines (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). While Thomas Shepherd did plant the o live trees

in front of his property, and landscaped the back garden, it is not of significance to garden and

park design in the region.

• Architectural Development: Architectural development shall exemplify or reflect development

associated with the city's-built environment, especially that designed and constructed by nonarchitects, including real estate developers, contractors, speculators, homeowners and others associated with the building industry (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). As the Ruth and Thomas

L. Shepherd House was designed by the architect it is not representative of a particular form of

residential development in the bui lding industry.

When evaluating a historic resource, integrity is the authenticity of the resource's physical identity clearly indicated by the retention of characteristics that existed during its period of sign ificance. It is important to note that integrity is not the same as condition. Integrity directly relates to the presence or absence of historic materials and character-defining features, while condition relates to the relative state of physical deterioration of the resource. In most instances, integrity is more relevant to the significance of a resource than condition; however, if a resource is in such poor condition that original materials and features may no longer be salvageable, then the resource's integri ty may be adversely impacted. The seven aspects of integrity used in evaluating a historic resource are:

1. Location is the place where a resource was constructed or where an event occurred. 2. Design results from intentional decisions made during the conception and planning of a

resource. Design includes form, plan, space, structure, and style of a property. 3. Setting applies to a physical environment, the character of a resource's location, and a

resource's relationship to the surrounding area. 4. Materials comprise the physical elements combined or deposited in a particular pattern or

configuration to form a property.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

·~

State of California 11 Natural Resources Agency


CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


5. Workmanship consists of the physical ev idence of crafts emp loyed by a particular culture, people, or artisan, which includes traditional, vernacular, and high styles.

6. Feeling re lies upon present physical features of a property to convey and evoke an aesthetic or historic sense of past t ime and place.

7. Association direct ly links a property with a historic event, activity, or person of past t ime and place, and requires the presence of phys ica l features to convey the property's character.

In order to assess each aspect of integrity when evaluating the Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd

House, the fo llowing steps were taken, as required in the City of San Diego Guidelines for the

Application of Historical Resources Board Designation Criteria, Land Development Manual,

Historical Resources Gu idelines, Appendix E, Part 2, Adopted August 27, 2009a:

1. Integrity of location is the place where a resource was constructed or where an event occurred

(City of San Diego HRB 2009a). Integrity of location was assessed by reviewing historic records

and aerial photographs in order to determine if the structure had always existed at its present

location or if it had been moved, rebuilt, or its footprint significantly altered. According to the

water hook up records, and the di rectories, The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House was

completed in 1940 at its current location. The building has not been moved or its location

otherwise impacted in any way, and therefore, retains integrity of location.

2. Integrity of design results from intentional decisions made during the conception and p lanning

of a resource. Design includes form, plan, space, structure, and style of a property (City of San

Diego HRB 2009a) .

Integrity of des ign was assessed by evaluating the spatial arrangement of the house on its lot

and its architectural features. Shepherd knew Lower Hermosa well . After joining the Mann

Building Company in 1926, he designed numerous homes in the subdivis ion, both w ith and

without his Associate. Examples are the historically designated homes: HRB#560, HRB #833,

HRB #630, HRB # 1144, HRB #993 . He often bought the lots, designed the homes, then so ld

them (i.e. 391 Via del Norte HRB #993, and the house next door at 6130 La Jolla Boulevard

where he would live for two years (See Photos Appendix E. p 68). The scale of these projects

reflects the architect's skill and the standards set by the subd ivision's developers, La Joll a

Properties. The subdivision implemented covenants and restrictions to assure exclusivity by

requ iring approval of all architectural designs; minimum lot frontage (70'-80'); lot depth (150');

and a minimum construction costs.)2

Shepherd stated to the current owners of Villa Francesca that "he had the pick of the lots" in

Lower Hermosa for the house. (Joehnk, 2016) He initially purchased Lot Two (2) Block Seven

2 Great detail on this subject is covered in Jamison, La Jolla Hermosa, 1985.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


(7) in Lower Hermosa, in November 1938, only three months after return ing from what was

most likely his first trip to Europe. (San D iego Un ion, Apri l 17, 1938 and August 14, 1938,

Appendix E. p. 64) The trip was an inspiration, for five months later Shepherd completed seven

pages of drawings for the home for "Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Shepherd," dated January 1939.

While the house was under construction in 1940, the architect was interviewed by the La Jolla

journal. He described the design as not following any particular style but "181h century Italian

precedent" ... "with a large plot of land which will adapt itself to a curving driveway" . .. with

"use [of] two-toned coloring and the blue-green roof ti les. (La Jolla Journal, May 16, 1940,

Appendix E. p 65) The original Plot Plan shows that the house and garden are centered

squarely on the central north-south axis, with an 86' wide frontage. The lot depth is a 148.84'.

Villa Francesca preserves the entire front fac;ade of the original: west side, back garden, the

curved drive, coloration, and the original footprint with a minor addition to the East facing

facade. The design falls under the eclectic directions taken by early Twentieth century

arch itects today classified as "Italian Renaissance" (McAlester 2013). Characteristics of the

style seen in Villa Francesca are: the low-pitched simple hipped roof covered by ceramic tile;

an entrance accented by classical pi I asters; and the symmetrical fac;:ade. Also characteristic is

the central entry which projects forward from the front fac;ade, with two side wings set back on

either side. Four pilasters support a wide molded cornice that runs the length of the low

profile green glazed terracotta roof.

Fmm tl9-is point, th-e classical fa~ade t-akes--on-a Mediterran-ean feel typica~ of-the-many-Spanish

revival homes designed by the architect. Paired ten-lite casement windows are centered

between the pilasters, framed with molded surrounds. Heavy wood shutters are used on the

front windows, their green color echoing the color of the tile roof and unifying the entire

fac;ade. As mentioned in the 1940 interview with the architect, the stucco's two-tone "coral"

coloration sets off the classical details and is complemented by the green ti le roof. The front

door has a raised plaster door surround with plinth, lintel extensions (ears) and recessed

paneling and two leaded lights. Additional original details on the fac;:ade include the metal

light fixture above the front door, the origina l wall mounted mai l box, and cast hardware. The

form of the circular drive is preserved as drawn on the original plan.

Most of landscape plan is as originally conceived: two olive trees are situated at the top of the

circular drive; hedge rows along the front side walk, and trees in the back garden are

preserved. Original wood pergolas, attached to the west and east sides of the house, vary and

extend the horizontal roof line, adding to the sense of scale. Fenestration on the sides and

back include multi-paned wood windows, diamond paned leaded windows and French doors.

In 1961 -62, the Ruth and Thomas Shepherd enclosed the west wall of the sun porch with large

aluminum sliding doors, and in 1969 installed a pool and pool equipment shed. The newly

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995){Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI# Trinomial


enclosed space provided seating for large dinner parties. In 1994, the Erley1s rep laced the

former sun porch with a new kitchen, enlarging the space on the east side with an additiona l

250 sq. feet. The Shepherd's former (very small kitchen) became a butler's pantry. The Erleys

replaced the aluminum sliding doors installed by Shepherd in 1961, with five pairs of single

lite French doors with segmented arch and recessed bottom panels. These are distinct from the

French doors used by Shepherd which are diamond paned leaded windows. The Erleys also

filled in the Shepherd' swimming pool. In 1997, the remodeling project was featured in San

Diego Home and Garden. (Appendix E. p 74) The swimming pool was not part of the

architect's original plan for the house. As such, the changes made after the 1939 original

design, and 1961 additions made by Shepherd adhere to the Secretary of the Interior's

Guidelines for Rehabilitation, specifically Standards 9 and 10 which state:

(9) New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction, shall not destroy

historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from

the old and shall be compatible with the massing, sizing, scale, and architectural features

to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment.

(10) New additions and adjacent or related new construction shall be undertaken in such

a manner that if removed in the future the essential form and integrity of the historic

property and its environment would be unimpaired.

A vine covered original pergola is located on the left side of the front fac;ade inhibiting a view

of the minor addition made to the East facing side of the house. The Shepherd's use of the

aluminum material for the door enclosing the original sun porch, per the architect's comments

to the current owners, was for economic reasons. Shepherd previously enclosed a sunporch

during remodels of the Herbert and Alexa Childs house at 210 Westbourne-HRB #1265. In the

Erleys' remodel, wood French doors are more compatible with the high level of materials used

in the rest of the house. Therefore, because the additions did not destroy original materials, or

affect the massing, sizing and scale of the house, it has retained its key architectural elements

and integrity of design.

3. Integrity of setting applies to a physical environment, the character of a resource's location,

and a resource's relationship to the su1-roL111ding area (City of San Diego HRS 2009a). Integrity

of setting was assessed by inspecting the elements of the property, which include topographic

features, open space, views, landscapes, vegetation, man-made features, and relationships

between buildings and other features. The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House is located at

the northern border for the Lower Hermosa development. The nearby residences are a mix of

historic homes, dating from the 1920s, to those from the 1970s. The homes are all situated on

large lots with formal landscaping, similar to the Shepherd house. Therefore, the building

retains integrity of its setting.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


5. Integrity of workmanship consists of the physical evidence of crafts employed by a particular

culture, people or artisan, which includes traditional, vernacular, and high styles (City of San

Diego HRB 2009a). Integrity of workmanship was assessed by eva luating the quality of the

architectural features present in the structure. The workmanship displayed in the execution of

the residence is good and alterations portray the same level of workmanship; therefore, the

Ruth and/fhomas L. Shepherd House retains integrity of workmanship.

6. Integrity of feeling relies on present physical features of a property to convey and evoke an

aesthetic or historic sense of past time and place (City of San Diego HRB 2009a). This was

assessed by evaluating whether or not the resource's features, in combination with its setting,

conveyed an aesthetic sense of the property in the 1940s when the Ruth and Thomas L.

Shepherd House was built. The building has been well maintained and its outward appearance

has generally remained the same since its period of construction; therefore, the residence

retains integrity of feeling.

7. Integrity of association directly links a historic property with a historic event, activity, or person

of past time and place; and requires the presence of physica l features to convey the property's

historic character (City of San D iego HRB 2009a). Because the Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd

house was designed as the family home by the architect, it is associated with his legacy in La

Jolla. The Shepherds were very social and the house served as a meeting place for friends and

associates for over thirty-six years. Hence, Villa Francesca possesses integrity of association.

II) City of San Diego H RB Criterion B: Is identified with persons or events sign ificant in local, state or national history.

Villa Francesca, The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd house is identified with Master Architect

Thomas Shepherd. Appendix A, p. 3 provides a copy of his p lans for the residence. Shepherd's

main house plans are dated January 14, 1939; plans for the back patios March 3, 1949, and

the sun porch enclosure October 17, 1961. An interv iew with Shepherd when the house was

under construction appeared in the 1940 La Jolla journal (Appendix E. p 65). The blueprints are

titled "Residence for Mr. and Mrs. Thomas L. Shepherd." It is unknown why the Shepherds

rented the house from 1941 and 1942, to George and Adelaide Harrison. The City Directory

does record that Shepherd lived in the house from 1943 until his death in 1979, at the age of

82 . Ruth Shepherd lived in the home until her death in 1986. (Appendix E. p 81)

Shepherd received recognition and numerous awards for his work, notice of which appeared

in the La Jolla and San Diego press throughout his career. This recognition is local as well as

national: the Gordon Grey/Shepherd residence on Spindrift drive, was used as the cover of

April Country Life of America (Doubleday in 1929), and Ada Black's home, was pictured in the

September 1929 issue of House Beautiful as a building to be featured in the "Traveling House

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI #

Trinomial


Beautiful exhibit". (San Diego Union, 1929) In 1930 House Beautiful again se lected one of

Shepherd's designs - the Walter P. Trible home (6028 Folsom Dr. HRB #1144) - as an

example of a "model home" to be exhibited in the publ ication's traveling exhibit. (Appendi x E,

p. 66) Shepherd's legacy in La Jolla is considerab le. He remodeled w ith Herbert Mann the La

Valencia Hotel, designed the Marine Room, La Jolla Beach and Tennis Club. The arch itect's

"Shepherd Build ing" at 1117 Wall Street, La Jolla, his "call ing card," remains an important commercial structure in the Village. (Anderson 1980)

Throughout their married lives the Shepher·ds played an active ro le in the social register of La

Jolla. In 1940, Shepherd is noted as serving as President of the La Jolla Conservation Society,

an early group concerned with growth, development and city planning, of La Jolla. (San Diego

Union, 1940)

In 1947 Ruth Shepherd began photograph ing the Shepherd homes and at that time she stated

the count was 103. She estimated the number of projects doubled by the time of architect's

death in 1979. (Anderson, San Diego Union 1980.) His role as an architect of note is seen in

the nineteen properties which have been historically designated by the City of San Diego

Historic Resource Board. (Appendix E. CHRID report p 61)

Upon Thomas Shepherd's death, per his request, there was no service or memorial, only a

black ribbon tied on the front door of Villa Francesca. Having no heirs, upon Ruth Shepherd's

death over two million dollars was left to the Scripps Memorial Foundation, including the

couple's home and its contents.3 This donation funded and endowed the 400-seat Shepherd

auditorium. The Shepherds also left a gift of over f ive million dollars to the YMCA of San Diego

County. This donation made a tremendous impact in the community by allowing the YMCA to

completely renovate its historic firehouse location on Hershel Avenue in downtown La Jolla.

This satellite YMCA branch was renamed the "Shepherd YMCA Firehouse" in honor of their

gift. In add ition, the Shepherds' philanthropy was a significant part of the major renovation and

grand re-opening of the main La Jolla YMCA branch location, now ca ll ed the Dan McKinney

Family YMCA. (Teplin 2018) As one of the reg ion 's lead ing master architects whose work had

a considerable impact on San Diego, and for Ruth and Thomas Shepherd's ro le as

philanthropists and civic leaders, Villa Francesca - The Ruth and Thomas Shepherd house is

significant to local history fulfilling the requirements of Cr iterion B.

3 Gordon Marston, Ruth Shepherd's son by previous marriage, would predecease the couple.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


Ill) City of San Diego HRB Criterion C: Embodies distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of construct ion or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship.

By the end of the Depression, Shepherd was the on ly consistently practicing residential

architect in La Jolla. Several of his La Jolla homes had won awards and were published in

national magazines giving him notoriety in the commun ity. 4 (San Diego Union 9-8-1929 and

1-7-1930) He was astute enough to realize that the Depression marked a sea change in

residential design. The 1935-36 California Pac ific International Exposition, Balboa Park had

perpetuated the pastiche of Spanish Colonial, Renaissance and Baroque elements. However,

the Shepherd's four-month trip to Europe in 1938, principally Italy, refocused the architect's

vision. His own residence, to be built in exclusive Lower Hermosa, would draw upon classical

prototypes, keeping in mind the post-Depression mindset of economy of scale and materials .

Shepherd would have been aware of the Cl iff May "modern Hacienda" homes under

construction, nearby, on Avenida Cresta. Like May, Shepherd was seeking a new residential

form, one more suited to the practical needs of his clients. However, Shepherd's taste turned

toward the more formal, classical prototypes he had just seen and studied in Italy, along with

the romance of the Mediterranean garden. In 1940, this was the direction he felt relevant to

himself and his sophisticated clientele.

The final plans for Villa Francesca are dated January 14, 1939, only five months after the

.. .

-Shepherds~ r:€turn from-a f.our=mor:itb trip t.o-E.u.r:Gp.€. ~Apper::idi-x E. p 6-4) The a.r-Gh-it-€-G-t~s-st1.Jd..y-0t--~

Palladian and villa architecture is clearly seen in his design. Set back and centered on a semi-

circular drive, the north facing front entry is based on a rectangular plan. The original Plot Plan

(Appendix E. p 11) shows house and garden centered squarely on the central north-south axis

of the 86' wide frontage.

The eclectic style of the Shepherd house is classified as "Italian Renaissance" (McAlester,

2013), but which Shepherd would call "Southern California." The defining features include:

the low-pitched hipped roof, covered with ceramic t i les; an entrance area accented by

classical pilasters; and the emphasis on symmetry. In Villa Francesca, a centra l-wing projects

forward from the front fac;:ade, differentiated by color and detail. The stucco for the central

entry is painted in coral, setting it apart from the molded details and the side aisles which are

painted in an off white. Classical details on the central wing include: four flat pilasters with

simple Tuscan order capitals supporting a wide horizontal cornice. Centered between each of

the pilasters, on either side of the front door, are paired 10-lite casement windows, with

molded surrounds. Thick wood shutters hang on either side of the front windows, their green

4 La Jolla Homes Given Publicity by Magazines, San Diego Union. September 8, 1929; Two San Diegans Awarded Prizes in Home Contest, San Diego Union. December 7. 1930.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HR!# Trinomial


co lor echoing the co lor of the roof tile and unifying the ent ire fa~ade . The heavy front door,

also framed with sculpted stucco, is made of paneled aged wood, w ith two leaded windows

set in a diamond pattern. The decorative bronze cast door handle, lock, and light fixture as

we ll as the inset mail slot are original. The chi mney is also covered by ceramic tile. Other

fenestration includes paired multi-lite fixed windows, multi-light French doors, extensive us of

leaded glass set in diamond patterns. In the opin ion of Tony Crisafi, AIA, Island Architects, La

Jo ll a, Villa Francesca is a very carefu ll y planned and conce ived design: "Shepherd has adapted

the formal aesthetic of the "sty lar" present in the Ita l ian vi ll a, to the Southern California

suburban home." (Crisafi 2018)

Front and back garden details are based on Italian/Mediterranean prototypes and decorated

w ith multiple t il es brought from the Mediterranean. The layout for the pergolas and garden

"rooms" are visible in the 1949 drawings and the layout and decor are preserved today.

(Appendix A. p 10) There is a conscious use of symmetry and perspective to give a heightened

sense of depth and scale: in front, the circular drive is framed by two olive trees, hedge rows

border the front walk, and line the entry "plaza" perimeter. A central axis enfilade draws you

through the front door and living room to a pair of French doors that open onto the back

garden and beyond. The perspectival path passes a 19thcentury Italian terra-cotta wellhead

surrounded by four putti hold ing flower gardens; opening to a wrought iron gate and tall a/lee

of ficus trees; past hand pa inted ceramic tiles, to a shaded wall where a sculpture of a putti,

cast in bronze, beckons you near. The garden space is divided into three separate "rooms"

surrounded by low walls and loggia. Original glazed Middle Eastern ti les decorate all of the

garden walls. Several of the original trees and plantings survive. (Appendix D. Photos 51 -58)

Although the residence has undergone minor changes it has retained its original footprint,

massing, and shape, as well as all of the main characteristics of the Italian Renaissance -

Revival style, original to its time of completion in 1940. The garden, designed, decorated, and

planted by Shepherd also retains its original integrity. Therefore, the res idence and garden are

eligib le for designation under H RB Criterion C.

IV) City of San Diego HRB Criterion D:

Is representative of the notable work of a master builder, designer, architect, engineer,

landscape architect, interior designer, artist, or craftsman.

Thomas Leroy Shepherd was born on January 1, 1897, in Platteville, Wiscons in. After

graduating from the University of Wisconsin, he attended the Graduate School of Architecture

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

State of California Il Natural Resources Agency


CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


(Avery Hall), Columb ia University, New York, from 1920-1921 .5 Prior to arriving in La Jo ll a, he

worked as manager of the construction department for McCrory Stores Corporation; the offices

of architect Grosvenor Atterbury, New York and in 1923, for Roy Seldon Price (Beverly Hills)

and Wallace Neff (Pasadena). In correspondence requesting a position with Santa Barbara

architect George Washington Smith, Shepherd stated he was "not only capable of carrying

drawings from sketches to completion but [could) also be depended upon for outside

supervision." (Appendix D, p 67) Shepherd and Smith met on September 3, 1924.6 When

Shepherd joined the Mann Building Company in 1926, it was reported that he had been

"connected with the offices of George Washington Smith." (La Jolla Journal 1926) It is likely

that Shepherd was introduced to La Jolla through Smith's large project at 7040 Neptune Place

for Franklin P. Sherwood (1926 - 1929).

Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, Shepherd's work followed the trending eclectic mix of

Spanish-Mediterranean design. The Mann Building Company was awarded such important

commissions as construction of the La Jolla Country Club, the renovation and tower addition to

the La Valencia Hotel (1928) and the design for the First National Trust and Savings Bank of

San Diego (1928). Between 1928 and 1930, the team designed multiple homes in Lower

Hermosa. Shepherd also designed projects independently of Mann, such as the Shepherd

Building on Wall St (1928-29). Despite the Depression, Shepherd's work continued into the

1930s. Examples are the large Spanish style residences of Lida V. Bevis on Newport Terrace,

featured on the cover of the National publication of "Country Life in America," (San Diego

Union 1 931) and the home for Roger and Jennie Jewell Pelton at 1802 Amalfi drive (1935 -

San Diego Union 19777).

From 1935 into the 1940s, Shepherd played an active role as one of the leaders of the "La Jolla

Conservation society." In coordination with the National Housing Administration's La Jolla

office, he drew plans to transform and enhance the west side of Girard Avenue (between

Prospect and Silverado street, from what he called "pill-boxes" to Southern California

architecturally, and relieve the former unsightliness." (San Diego Union, 1935, Appendix 69).

With Mann's departure for Pasadena in 1932, Shepherd operated from 1118 Wall Street and

after 1945, he relocated his offices to 7856 Ivanhoe, La Jolla.

While working with Herbert Mann, Shepherd met Ruth Marston, the office draftsman, who he

would marry in May 1931 . (La Jolla Journal 1931 ). In December 2, 1938, four months after the

s Email March 1, 2018, Office of the Registrar, Columbia University, verified Shepherd attended the School of Architecture, 1920-1921, but did not graduate. 6 George Washington Smith Papers, Architecture and Design Collection, University of California, Santa Barbara. Letter from Smith to Shepherd setting up appointment to meet. 7 Shepherd's plans, dated 1935, are in the collection of current owner Ann Craig.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

. '



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HR!# Trinomial

Property Name: Villa Francesca-The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd House Page14of17

couples' return from Europe, Shepherd acquired the lot at what was then 311 Via del Norte

(later became 345) and by, by January 14, 1939, he completed the drawings for Villa

Francesca. Shepherd continued to perfect the home throughout his life (see drawing for the

house and garden (1949), and enclosure of the such porch (1961 ). (Appendix A p. 3-11)

Villa Francesca skillfully adapts classical concepts of design, balance and proportion to the

suburban Southern Ca lifornia home. The classical front fac;ade centered at the top of the

curved drive is unique in the architect's work. Shepherd exemp lifies how color can be used to

unify and harmon ize a front fac;ade: the molded details, pilasters, w indow and front door

surrounds, enliven the fac;ade through form and color, contrasting w ith the green shutters and

roof ti !es. In 1 940, there were sti II the craftsmen and sources for the hand-hewn shutters, front

door, leaded windows and hand wrought fixtures. By placing the house along a central ax is,

Shepherd demonstrates his mastery of proportion, and his use of perspective and vanishing

points expertly directs vis itors through the rooms and to the back garden.

The home exemplifies des ign principles that would become fundamental to the architect's

work: the garage is placed to the back of the house, to not dominate the front elevation; the

landscaping in front is simplified to enable viewers to see the full design of the house; the set

back is extended to give the 'Impression that the house is located farther back on the lot and

creates the feeling of spaciousness even for a standard size lots" (interview with Shepherd, San

Diego Union 1975). Shepherd's use of scale, and perspective, and placement of rooms takes

advantage of California light and sun, a feature apprec iated today by homeowners who life in

his homes. By situating the "L" shaped p lan along a north/south exposure, the entire south

side of the house opens into the garden benefiting from morning light. Villa Francesca models

a layout, situation and design which maximizes the indoor/outdoor lifestyle. Villa Francesca

enabled Shepherd to implement features he appreciated and could share with his discern ing

clients.

In 1940, when Villa Francesca was completed, Shepherd rented the home to friends. We know

the architect was in La Jolla as he remained active as President of the La Jolla Conservation

Society (San D iego Union, 1940). While Shepherd was likely active in some aspect of the local

w ar effort, it is not clear if he served in the Navy during World War 11.8

The Post War economy with its demand for housing along w ith modernist trends impacted the

architect's later work. By the end of the 1940s he evolved his particular vers ion of the wood

sh ingled "Ranch." From the 1950s on, the Shepherd's undertook trave ls throughout the world,

and in one of the rare interviews w ith the architect, it was clear that this experience affected

a Military records were searched through ancestry.com.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI # Trinomial


his designs.9 Affable and practica l, he chose to adapt des igns to his client's interests and needs.

(Julia Fleet, 1967 Appendix p 70) This flexibi lity and Shepherd's charm helped hi m to bu ild a

following which continued throughout his fifty-year career. Shepherd was the architect of

choice for the design of large scale La Jolla homes and the remodeling of many of the homes

he had worked on since 1927. He was also an avid investor/speculator. He purchased

multiple lots, designed, and built commercial and "spec" homes, and sold them. Several

projects were in Lower Hermosa and in the Vi llage.

Villa Francesca-The Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd house is considered a notab le examp le of

twentieth century Italian Renaissance - Southern California style -- by Master Architect Thomas

Shepherd. Therefore, the house is eligible for designation under HRB Criterion D.

V) City of San Diego H RB Criterion E:

Is listed or has been determined to be eligible by the State Historical Preservation Office for

listing on the California Register of Historical Resources. Villa Francesca-The home of Ruth

and Thomas L. Shepherd has not been determined eligible by the State Historical Preservation

Office for listing on the register, and hence does not qualify under HRB Criterion E.

VI) City of San Diego H RB Criterion F:

Is a finite group of resources related to one another in a clearly distinguishable way or is a

geographically definable area or neighborhood containing improvements which have a special

character, historical interest or aesthetic value or which represent one or more architectural

periods or styles in the history and development of the city.

No historic district presently exists for the La Jolla, or for La Jolla Hermosa. Villa Francesca-The

home of Ruth and Thomas L. Shepherd is not part of a finite group of resources related to one

another in a clearly distinguishable way or within a geographically definable area or

neighborhood containing improvements wh ich have a special character, historical interest, or

aesthetic value, or which represent one or more architectural periods or styles in the history

and development of the city. Therefore, the residence does not qualify under HRB Criterion F.

9 La Jolla Historical Society, Shepherd Archives include a series of postcards sent by Ruth Shepherd to her son, from South America/Ecuador (1958), Japan (l 956), France (l 956) , Italy (1968).

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

. .

State of California 11 Natural Resources Agency


CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HRI# Trinomial


References

Ancestry.com

Tony Cristafi, Interview, December 21, 2017

Co lumbia Univers ity A lumn i Reg ister, 1754-1931, New York, Columbia Un iversity Press, 1932 (On-Line Database)

Columbia University, Office of the Registrar, Emai l, March 1, 2018

Wilford Wayne Donaldson FAIA, La Jolla Historical Survey - Prepared for City of San Diego Planning Department, La Jolla Historical Society, 2004

Julia Fleet, The world at home: the Thomas Shepherds' exceptional existence abroad and in La Jolla, San Diego Magazine, July 1967, p. 98-101; photos by John Waggaman

Susan Holt, Searcher/Examiner, Lawyer' Title, Email dates Dec 7, 2017, Dec 17, 2017

Thomas Shepherd Archives, La Jolla Historical Society

Fry & Sm ith Directory, City of San Diego, 1938, 1940, 1941, 1942, 1943, 1944-45

Susan and Karsten Joehnk Interview, January 29, 2016, correspondence Oct. 2017

Thomas A. Jamison, LA JOLLA HERMOSA-A Subdivision Triumph. The Journal of San Diego History, Summer 1985, Vol 31, No. 3, 1985

La Jolla Journal

Bridal Couple Presides over Charming at Home, June 4, 1931

7 8th Century Idea for New Residence, May 1 6, 1940

La Joi la Light

New Man Joins Staff at Building Company -October 26, 1926, p. 6

Cynthia Queen, Ruth Shepherd donates home, contents to charity. Sept 2, 1993

Virginia Savage McAlester, A Field Guide to American Houses (Revised): The Definitive Guide to Identifying and Understanding America's Domestic Architecture, New York A lfred A. Knopf, 2013

San Diego Union

La Jolla Homes Given Publicity by Magazines, San Diego Un ion, Sept 8, 1929

New Architectural Gem for La Jolla, San Diego Union March 9, 1930

Two San Diegans Awarded Prizes in Home Contest, December 7, 1930.

La Jolla Plans to 'Life' Face of Business Street, April 28, 1935

Shepherds Sail for Vacation in Europe, April 17, 1938

Shepherds Return from Europe, San Diego Union August 14, 1938

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)



CONTINUATION SHEET

Primary#

HR!# Trinomial


La Jolla Annual Exhibit Schedu led, April 1, 1940

Red Cross and Brit ish Relief Work No Hindrance to Courtesy Parties, December 1, 1940

Richard M. Daniels. His Style Creates Tradition, March 2, 1975

3 La Jolla Homes by Shepherd to be Visited, Apr il 11, 1979

T.L. Shepherd Architect, Dies at 82, December 12, 1979

Nancy Scott Anderson, Thomas Shepherd, August 28, 1980.

Seonaid McArthur, Molly McCain and Diane Kane, Jazz Age to Our Age: Arch itects and Developers of 7 920s La Jolla: La Jolla Historical Society, 201 7

George Washington Smith Papers, Architecture and Design Collection, University of California, Santa Barbara

Bruce Snider, Judicious Restraint, Remodeling Magazine, December 1997

Frank Teplin, Director of Major Gifts, YMCA of San Diego County, Email to Seonaid McArthur, February 2018

Phyllis Van Doren, C uardians of the Past, San Diego Home & Garden, August 1997, pp . 56-83

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

.. .

Appendix Table of Contents

APPENDIX A BUILDING DEVELOPMENT INFORMATION ....................................................................................................... 1

BUILDING DEVELOPMENT LIST ............................................................................................................................................. 2

ELEVATIONS AND PLANS- A RESIDENCE FOR MR. & MRS. THOMAS L. SHEPHERD .... ... .. . ..... ........ ................................... .. ..................... 3

COUNTY ASSESSOR'S BUILDING RECORD ...........................•............•...................•...............................•..............................•...... 12

NOTICE OF COMPLETION ..•.... . .... .. . .. .•........... .... ......... ........ ......•... .. .. ......... .. ..... . . ......... ...... .. .. ......... . .. .. ............ •. ... ........ ......... 15

WATER/SEWER HOOK UP ..................................... . ................ ........... .. . ...... ... .......... .... ... ...... ......................... ............. ..•....... 17

CONSTRUCTION PERMITS ..................................................................................................................................................... 18

SITE PLAN WITH FOOTPRINT . ......................•..........................•.... . .................. . ................................... ......... ................. ....... ... 36

PREVIOUS HISTORICAL RESOURCE SURVEY . .. •. ........ .....• ...... ...... . ............... . .... .... .. .... ........ .... ... ... ... ... .. ...............•........................ 37

APPENDIX B. OWNERSHIP AND OCCUPANT INFORMATION .............................................................................................. 39

CHAIN OF TITLE •... .... .. .........• ••.. ..•.••.•... ........ ........ . . .. ....•......................• . .. ·······•······· ..................... ·•··········· .....•.. ·••· ··· .....•...... 39

LISTING OF OCCUPANTS .................................................•.......•......... ........ ... ................. • ...... . ..•................. •... •. .. .......... ...... .. .. 40

DEEDS FROM DATE OF PURCHASE OF LOT ............................. . . .... ..... . ... . .................. .. ........................ ... .. . . . ................................ 41

APPENDIX C. MAPS ............................................. ............................................................................................................... 44

CITY OF SAN DIEGO 800 SCALE FOR LA JOLLA ······· ................ ... .................. . .... ........................... .. ... ................... ........ ... ............ 45

USGS MAP 2015 .............................•........ .... ........ ...... ....... . ......•........•.......... ... .........•.................................... . .................. 46

USGS HISTORICAL (1953) ........•........................... ... ........................ .. .... . ....... ... ...................... . ..... .. ... ....... •........... ............... 47

ORIGINAL SUBDIVISION MAP, 1923 ...•.....•........•.•.................... •.. .•............. ..... .... ...... ...............•........ .. ...... ...... .......... .. ......•.... 48

SANBORN MAP 1926-1949 ........... .. ............................................................ ........... ... ................................................... .... .. 49

SANBORN MAP 1952 . . ... .... ............................... .. ............ . .............................................. . ................. ... ........... ... . .. .. .. . .. ....... 50

APPENDIX D. PHOTOGRAPHS ............................................................................................................................................ 51

FRONT FA<;:ADE AND DETAILS ........... . ............................ .. .... ........ .. ... .. ........................ ... ................................ ......... ..... . ....... .. 52

WEST AND EAST FACING ELEVATIONS . ....................... ........... . . .................................... . ............................................................ 53

WEST ELEVATION FROM GARDEN AND DETAILS . .... .. ... ....... ...... ..... .. ............ . ....... .... ..... .. ............................. ............................... 54

WEST GARDEN ELEVATION WITH PERGOLA AND ART MOUNTED BY SHEPHERD ...•..•........................................•.......•.. •. .......•.........•.... 55

PERSPECTIVAL V1Ews: NoRTH/SouTH Axis .........•......•.•......• •. ..........•..•• .. ................. . ...•......... •.. .•....... •..... .. •....•........•. .... ..•....... 56

SOUTH ELEVATION FROM GARDEN AND DETAILS ...•........... ...................................... . .................................................................. 57

SOUTHWEST GARDEN PERGOLA AND HISTORIC TILES ......................................................................................................•............ 58

RUTH AND THOMAS SHEPHERD IN BACK GARDEN (1967) IN EUROPE (1938) (TOP), CURRENT OWNES SUSAN AND KARSTEN JOEHNI< IN

GARDEN, 2017 .........•.....•................................•......•........................................................•...... ...................................... . . .. 59

APPENDIX E - HRB CRITERIA- SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION ......................................................................................... 60

CHRID - HISTORICALLY DESIGNATED BUILDINGS BY SHEPHERD ...... ... ..... ......... ..... ..... .... .. .. ......................... ......... .. .. ........ . 61

REUSE OF FRONT FA<;:ADE ELEMENTS BY SHEPHERD •.•••....•.............•........•........................................•.......................................... 63

SHEPHERD'S SAIL FOR VACATION IN EUROPE/SHEPHERD'S RETURN FROM EUROPE -SAN DIEGO UNION ................................................. 64

NEW MAN JOINS STAFF OF BUILDING COMPANY (LA JOLLA LIGHT 10-26-1926} .............................................................................. 65

18TH CENTURY IDEA FOR NEW RESIDENCE (LA JOLLA JOURNAL 5-16-1940) ..................................................................................... 65

RECOGNITION AND AWARDS FOR SHEPHERD 1929, 1930 ....•............................ . .....•........................................... .. ..............•....... 66

THOMAS SHEPHERD LITTER TO GEORGE WASHINGTON SMITH (8-28-1924) .. ....... . ................... .. .... ......... ................. ... ................... 67

FIRST HOME OF THOMAS SHEPHERD-6130 LA JOLLA BLVD .......................... . ............................................................................. 68

SHEPHERD'S PLAN FOR V ILLAGE BEAUTIFICATION, WPA ERA, 1935 ...... . ............................................................ .... ... ... .................. 69

THE WORLD AT HOME, JULIA FLEET, SAN DIEGO MAGAZINE 1967 ....... .. ........ ... ...... .............................. ........•.......•....................... 70

GUARDIANS OF THE PAST, PHYLLIS VAN DOREN, SAN DIEGO HOME AND GARDEN, 1997 ........... . ...... . .............. . .....•. •.... ...................... 74

TABLE OF RESIDENCES FOR THOMAS SHEPHERD 1927-1986 ....... .. ................................................... ........ .. .. ... ................ . ... ...... .. . 81

APPENDIX A

BUILDING DEVELOPMENT

INFORMATION

1

2

-Building Plans -County Assessor's Building Record

-Notice of Completion -Water/Sewer Connection Record

-Construction Permits -Site Plan with Footprint

-Lot and Block Book Page (None) -Previous Historical Resource Survey Forms

-,-

I

'" "" .

\ r (

t i

(J

\

(

~ ~,;

·'.·,·· 1·1

•/ ,- I, ·N ~

>

t. ·;•·

··~

.. , ,..._-:•., .;·

l \• I '·

'I .. ]

. ,~ J

0

• ·"'·;J"•

•l

'· / .\'\

' • ' ' ,. "

~

"

~ .. ~ ! " 't .

I /J t·~ 1~~?

t : _ . r .

• I q , - Ji ' ( •' . . \! t [-----·] i . ~ ( J

,\ I I ·" ~ \ -· . ~ :

~ .J :

,J

[[=3' . . ' '.

, ,.;,,,:1

.. ,:

\.::._ __ _ ',;.-_

'4

.,

\ Ji ·,: , 1"j •

•• 1! !~ p--·L.:. · ' . ·- --- 1 i~' i; ··- ~i! .o,,, T

:'I. I

1j - , .... ;1, !·_· '""·~..,· j ~ j' 1 ·:

l i, .,_ - -- • ! ! j C •-•••Ji ~ ! . , .,.:. - .. ""'''a. • ~ ;.-l.

() . ' . (I . • , . ..

,11 ,. -r., t ~i f:c-··- ·--·-~- ;~ Ji 1:r: ' :: ij:

l .,:,

' . -l~,~---.

L----~.~

11 -,, l : I I

,_ _ _ _ ,. . .

~· ··~· .

. l· I . . - ..

.l:. _ 1 ___ i - .i

If . . ~

I •.

L ... ........ - - c__.

.. 0-:;,6

- ~,

~

' ,,_ ___ _

,; '-, ", \ , ,· ~ " I/}

. ~-~--...,. -

.. 1- .... r~,r/

~)

'>:)

:.,,.

~

~ ,,,

-t, I t· I i I . t I

I I ! i

I !

i I . I ~----

/! / !

., I ·, ,, •. IT I ·' .

~·, : ·~

.,I

..

""'.' ..

..··;1:, 1 ..... !. ~ ~--•· ~ .,. l ~'

.,

•

; 7 7 I' ,"_:,'!! _ .... - -

' i

\

\ I i \

, I

~ .L. .. __ ::__ ;-.,7u· -- _ ., ______ ...

!i ..

·7 .L "'0 /f/

---,-J

,,,. , ., ,.,.,,,,,,. - --·- -· ----

7 ;- (7 ... r .t / ,

,I

t-··

- ;

,..

1 l

. '.'

"

·I I.I ~ "),

I

I

-\ \, .:, l l ' "' ~

~ t -ill,

\)

I" ,_

..J...

- - --;. ~-.9

1, !{

\ -r •.)-

.. S·.~•

---.. 'I

I :-·

'Q:t==I ·Ii'

I +-i ~-- - ·--

,,'1,L . ~ - ·;,,£.:.;·5r - · - ---;~/-,S . --:s~t-·- ;7 ,; ·· -..,o .. ~ 7 · .. ?,I --

.. L-.S-/ ,,fi~B - .,?;? -,- ... 9~L --- - -· --- .. cv -.,;~

•·.1

' ,.

i. ., ·• ~ !; ..

I

-1-1 ' +-

..

" ·- uL-,/,.C -,.

j --• I '° ------·--- ---- -----

! I ' I '.

i I

1 - _:L I

,.,...$;// :..s I ti ~ I ' ;( . 1, i..i

~l r--"1

'

I-

- - I +-- 1'i, ... 'A, •• • .,.J_ ~ . •• r---.-.. ___ ..,,.. __ ;;;Jt.-t;_-.,A-.:~.--,-v .~-~n_ r - -1

.: ----,- ~' '--4 ·- ---- - - - ' . ==~==~ ~ ,, ,, ~ ., ., - i,, -= · ---- -=';t· ~-i=fr~------------·~-.::.::..-=l==..,

.,_t"::;.,· j ' , ,,, j : ' - ... , I , , , .) ~ : a ! '\ ,l'

I!! .j.'r.

~ ; 1 -r~j . ~ I l ; ,_,, " " ' I

,-u ~; ·-: i'. R ·~ -~-_,.,, ~ -; ! ~ I

'I 11

- I-

;.

,,..! ·,E/

., : · ~ I

.. p-,(?/ . -- -r-

---------- -~----

/._

,?·,?

I .,

,,0-,0?

L

- · · . I s· ~ 1 . ~

~ ~

i ::1' ,' I j t-.

.; ,, I ,; I :....i

l· 5>

J ~t-

' · !: :

-,... ,,./-,//

:~ - ..

L.::_; I.

,,9-,/Y;"

I ·

J

ct ··· \ d I

\

' 'o ,, \I' "l

---1.

: I I I

I I

I I

I

T I I

r, •

.. ~·

;_, -: ;1';_·.-~

o ·

; .:>--,, ... . ~ft:} 0

' ,-._r , ,. , •L

\ .;' ·-·1

C '· ~ •• L .

~; ., . . . . <:;) ,.~;/ ., .. ' : ~' ~ l_

' ,,

~,

1

i "' ~

k I l . •~-

i I, .. ' '

' ' I

~

,,9-, /

.. ~ ~Jr;

v1~~ .. __ ·,'.~J

.- ; ,,.,.,/i : t, • ... ~. ' ..

"' "'1 'f" ..... "'

I. , I! ,•

: ! .; 1'- .....J

i. , t..:

-- ~-

.;, . .,.

11· ·J 4 .,)....,.,:

. ,'

·-r ··-·- ··· 1 '

L.

I

'< • j ~ '.L.. ·--~'\)- ··- 11 ~ 11 '.

~ Jl_ ____ . -···-~·-.J --~·-· · ___ --·- -1

\ \

i

i - ·--· - -~--

11

·: I I I I I I 1

i I · l ·~ ;. ~ ' .. ,J} I , . :~ j r I

IL . j_ ----· _J I 'ii . i ·· :-·-·, I

;:I ; J-l~ .j 'B . !1 .:.:...:.L_··. · -- - 1'-:-_4 _;_:J_ .. ~ ~ ______ lJ

I I- ;:,,0-;t:-

I : .i ....... ·-:: ____ :, ____ ·: ._j ,,,.. t-··· ·-

'--

.,.

<.)'!>

' L . • . . I I

!

· 1 !

· I !

:.1

., t-·· ~o,i;

I·. ·--·~ - ~ . .. --~ I

I , . I

l .. u ... : ~ I'

. .., .. . . ' ··~ . ~ ~ :,. •; .. . ~ ~ . ,v. I ~ •t ' ' ' :: .. t . ; I ·'··-~-~ ... JJ ,;.,1

'

I ' -~.-d-

j

. 'q

! ~i . I Jl I. - · J_ ___ -~-- _J

------1 ,<?,¥

.- .. ·

•

.J .,

"' r: 1- )

a t;,, f;~-\, , . <..t L•'"' --

:-"- - - -··=--::., .. · __ 1 r-~- ,, ___ _

. _, _

' I

1 • ----=---~ l L~ ll...

----.~

~ .,.,,., I

~ -- ·'--'ll)> ~-

; ~ - GJ)'? ~ I

1 ' ~-c· ,C, ~~ I -~ ' ' -~ •,

~ ,, f ', .;

-, ~ ';,.___I'-··- ,

• --i,( ~~

(,\(),........-) .-Y -· . ,-{'-A.,)")' ,, ' ~ ~\

G :J y~ i I ,, ''°'>-. :I , Pk ,., , r {6,-.~ -' ')r-, ·; ,~ - ,I I ,1 '" " _;< I J.

'"l(Jj .. )j ,) V v- :\ .. _ \ '\i:_ ~;J?/:E./'l-~t Ii _j. "'-. .. --.) :5

·.11 ·- -

l---i - -------------------'-

1 I. -~· j I

·----~ i

I . - : ____ ___ _J

. . - I

:i~ I i 11,

c l I I i: ': I

• _J l ~ l ' : .. :='-1 c:...: - · ~'l ,------ r. 1~ '.,,- . Jt· I . 'jj· ~'- . :~--::'.' l---__J i j

i/.~ ~ '--'-=-.J - =:..J - -.e

•I :

'·t <;\

·-',.

.:;ir---- ••

' I ~ rL \, I l

' .. f~ - I. ' ) ___ __ _J _ ~

- .. , i • ~' ~Ir---------<

I

\,

'

-1 -

- ------- f : I . ~--·----- . "j I ~

--1: { ~ j •

JJ! I -, !1

'. '1 I• • • I'

! t ~ .· .. --~-~~~ i ~· Li __ ----·------~- _j[

11

"- . ;--- -----. 1-· 1

I 1

j i

1,

i' I' I! " ' ' L._,,_

I ·------- - - ---- ~ ... . , - --~r I'

__ J t: J: . -, -;:

I L- ·.::-:-=--~-~~--=~1 I -- ·-- ---- ---it

;..

.,

. " I

1'.;J .\ I .. !·J ":'-

. ;

r~ ,.. :':·~ f· ,~ ;( ··, it ij: ...

I i Ji t ~., ~ , ( f'

~ 11;· {.•',

ij .. l'J'

;.1

., •:

il ... •• •,' ... ;: )',

,·

/I

\

~ ,I

\ '.

\ I

\

-=.::- ::.:-=--=-------·

' ·

I

\

>.

~ ~

~)-,.

. "'-~ ~ _',~.-~ \ --~ ~

hlLJ

'·-·-.... -. ....

___, f '·

'( .... i • ' }- · '

\~~8--. ·_: '/' ./ ' l ~--- '<.;"\..,

(> r, A ; \

\,\• I ,.,~ ,,, ! 'l~ :

"~ "'. ' i

·/

i. ' ~ -.•

/

- - [ ___ -

I \ \

' \ '

I

\

', I ~ '

i ~ ,' / ( )

i > ) ~ ' _) )

'' "" .f ) .., ,. .... ..,..... _,-) .

_ _:_• · -- ~::. =_:::..::.-::.=. ___ =-. _ _____ ____ . ~ - - . -:-· -=. : : -: :- :: : -.: - ----------·-··----- ----

· --...__,___,_____ I ~----~-~-s----.. --1 --- ---------~~ ~..::,( .. -::,~. ... ..... , -. .,. .... "" -·--- ·7i- - - --:-..,.;""\' ,-~-.....--

r- 1 I I ·l f'I ·:C.. I t = - --~

' ' ' I I I 1 !," ,. " ' I "'" • "'· 1•! "· - ~· •. "· .

,o~.=. 1 L1D •NC:, :;;c~ ~i&,,1c.

-~~

W E:_S T E:.LE:.V . S( A L P- y4 • ... r-o"

'!,:!. I( t:..=. ,.1.ac "'~"""e

··-·, .. .. "L.

F'-'-'F~

- < ·~t~ -~ "'F"IM. t= L .~(s,Ci-:.r.}

_ ""'·T =" ---- I 1 ----" --·---p~---E...A S T

1~~~...:.::~~ I ~Pfi~~s r!i., ~ V ·

~~, 2. I< 4 ~""TUD!i 4i) 1(,: ,,.,.--

-' I ~I

I ~--=-':.=·.:2,_.

(i'

-~ -------i

.... \. t!x1",na1.'i. !-1-:-1::.

I I t

-~

' =-----11;; •1'",T , Dl'tlVC.

r;.7.1,-TIMQ. j MAIC·~ 1 """''S"T•N:;.. P.::.'IOM I Q.A~-AlbC.

I

,:~-1-~

"'"''"1' .p ~

~:-::~· ~.:iDUC>

l !" . .,.. L----'

i I

<:

-=,t)

.. 0 , ... - I D- -· \ ~ -,

i ---

1 ol ·· i

~- :.:.j "1'-1..ei'

@

~ \ i E.>c.1•;.TIN (:, l';(l."':.!C'l:!NCU

41,, °?, p. ~INCL~ :'.4-'1 ~>,JG. ,,.

H"a.<. _ _ SE.CJ:.lqN <SCA!-S ~ " ::f· O"

~~-)

\~f=~\ ( ( \ 8:n.o'

I"!,'.: IC":.

;

~;:;~;,.:::;~ .:~Li-!~, -icd c~L. -~·~:.$:.~! ... ce L . 0'1C::.IA

1 ,. eoL" 'S1 - 'i '" ,.. I0 1 - 1" - · - . J. • -· I t - . J .1 -

. l'" !,.,":'1.?1' , C"UTLET ....... ~ 1 J j l J ~t,-:J L~ ?,EA 1H.::,. N•ULLldl,;)$ < ~~( ~ -_:_c_.:~:;;~-- __:;:

I I M<W

0

<c•T• :;TOPS ·- 'I

~~J ~~~~ ~(~ ~OR I y~.~~-~

~(: _,~·: __ Aoc:>,-:. OUT L..E"T

·'

I

l, J - __ 8'· 11 ~~ _ __

1 ___ -· _ 1?,,'.,o" _ _ __ __ ., . s'-4!,q,."_

,,·[ r·- --- -··-·--·-f ·,- - -------- --q fj ~''~"'~~'c;·)· N1 I :,b ___ :::z __ I '

2 ' 0

~ " ~1

I ~I! L- 2 r--. 1 -- f · -I ~-

- I . ·J - - - - . _ I • I . ~-;;~j;-_;;; ·~J~-- ··- -·· I ____ J 1r--L 11...:r:~-tj- _'Ji -

~'c-' i't !-~t·1 lj ,1 JJ,

\

L - - g° ·"'"

- ~~~:~; " -~ --\" .

F O U N D A T I O N 'SCA L e.:

PLo-r I II _ ....

I 'PLAIN

,,_~- i--

l.CIT 2., E. LOC::..K. 7 L A JOL L. A. ~eF-.,M0"'5 A

PLAN !...."= 1

1• 0 11

. PLANS!. ELEVATIOl,:!lS ----------- ---f-',--ALTEJZ.AT IONS .f. ADD1TI01'JS

1 0 THe. i=:.esto e ,-,i c e O F ... ·

Nlf2. . ~ MJ';S. T140MAS L . SHEPHEf2,D ~ 4 S V IA DEL h!OIZ.TE.

LA .JOLL A, CALl!':0~ / A

.. -t:· -- - - -- ·- --- - ·- ···-- · ,~!i\1:'z.1 iTH~~~: }~c·~1~~f,_HE.K

. LA ..J0!...1.. A , C. A LJs;'Oin.JrA V I A ~N_:='~I E.. -- --- --,

l..e - 17-(, I

~9UhlTV ·ASSESSOR

.NIA RESIDENTIAL 'BUILDING RECORD 'SHEET _/_ OF ~L SHEETS PARCEL .JS 7,- 0.3 c· •· 2 . .-, • . -

~- • - ' 1., ,o • • • II . to~---~ -··· -.::r.;=--r---. ...--

.• ~- '-- ' '- ADDRESS ...3-9-5"" 1//c! v'Jf.• .,-,/,,,.,, £ •

<

~R.OC D~SCRIPTION OF BUILDING ~

CLASS 8 SHAPE CONSTRUCTION STRUCTURAL EKTERIOR ROOF LIGHTING AIR CONDITION ROOM ANO FINISH DE1 #L C, Lioht )( Framt! I, Stucco on Flot A Pitch ,t w,rina y Ht!afin~ Coolin9 FLOORS FLOOR FINISH ~TER/OR FINISH

~Ao~ Sub-Standard "x . • 'I. G.V'-~< - J.cuA1 'X Goble -i..4 J<:T. Cond11i1 '-) Forud Clean'g ROOMS

B I 2 TRIM I 'ilalls - Moferlol Grade Ceilinqs

ARCHITECTURE x Standard Sheathing Siding " X u Hip 4 8.X. Cable Gravit) Humid. All X i:"1'NilOM fFG-

4wl\ 6- '5 .PL -A hove ·Standard Concrele Block Shed 4 Fixtures Woll Unit

I Stories Special B.&B. I IT.~ 6. C~f Up Few Cheap Ent.Hall I C .4RP, TYPE Brick St,in9/e Dormers X Avg. ';( Mt!d. I Floor Unit l.ivinq ~ I

use oesim FOUNDATION Adabe Shake y Rolt. .. ~ ':. ' Mony Specia1 Zone Unit Dining) I

)< Sinqle >< )( CMct"I" )< Floor Joisf, 88B.I T.&6. X Gvtters '.X Cenlra{N I ,tt;J./, I J;(A"TC - I. "-

Ooublt! R2infarced 'X 1sr, " " " "I, Jsx ( .~J.11 P PLUMBING 8ed • ::i CIIP.JYp,_..., ,_ '<."/ ...... ;; '< -Duplex Brick 2""!

n .. _ Bric/,. Shingle IPoo,j #d. ~,- Bed~ ¥ ~-~=· .I(

Al)arfmenf Wood Suh·rloar Stone Shake Oil Burner \\_ !1'i ,~ N . (lQ

F/of-Courf Piers .)( Concrete Floor WINDOWS · X Tile I X Sink o~/ = Moft1! D. H. I X1Caseml!!'nl Tile Trim, x Laundry 12..oM·B.TU. ur1,:...1r, / ,; ;Nn 7/ ~

.. !ns11lofed Ceilinq:: Metal Sosh Compo.; X' Water Htr. ·Auto. X Fireplace 3.,, Kitchen I .i.//(0 ,

Si: I Unifs Lighl I IHeavv Insulated Walls Screens Compo. S~inqfe Water- Sonner L>rain Bd. Maferial: .s. S'TL. / Lqfh: Ft. Spr,;,,,h,

. CONSTRUCTION RECORD · EFF£C. APPR. NORMAL % Goqo RATING (£,G,A,F,P) BATH DETAIL Permit "'7-/, ,?-fo.~,..

AmotJnf Dole YEAR YEAR Aq• Remain'g

Tobie 0/o Cond. Arch. rvnc. Con~ S/oroQe SDOce Worl<- Fl. No. FINISH FIXTURES SHOWER

No. For life Attr. Pion form rupb'd Closet m'nsh;. Floors Walls We lo. Tub TvDe Grade Sf. n G.D. Finish

/.~?7!' ?.V.. (j- . Roon S-.7..:!-'/0 /P"rS- /~¥ /r, ¥..:z A1 f.,.,, 7~ G- r: e-- E .+ ..4 ,<_. I I ,L //1/0 />/. . I I I OLD &.- I T (.

7.,961 Fr./lf'..C v,S" ,--s'· 7'2. I 9 r, 'i ,'; /i(oo tJ~ tJ- F-' - A- ..,. - A I I ,<//,/(}- f)/, I I I 0/..IJ A I Tl. ,K,,'-//7,f &vi'. MA\<, 7o0 l !J •.; '1-l~I /ti 12. J7 {C, 'n/. 70 f ,:. p A I l/.,2 /_,,A/b If . I I -,,l,:! G-

/"·.5<.;"Jflf -p,..A l /<./10 11.1.z::,-<;<; . go OIi

1 C?..mJt-,10 ,~,).,}-~ ,. ![~£; .. i · Oi· ).o'i"l SPECIAL FEATURES

1 Czo'-"'!> h,(( l:,,-A {j~ l'7 ,,,-a-'l: . Boo!< Cases /Jv1/f m Rerr19. X Venetian Blinds

' (i,os'>..li ~...w- ;oo:> //·'>-~ 'I .... ShuHers 11 11 Ov~n f /J/df<! X G- . ..J .

/ I ./ Venf .Ccfn X ,. " 015/1(,uash~r . -

fl / u A c:;~(r-,COMPUTA TION 1-').1·"-li

Appraiser 8 Dote A-:d:.r-./ f.-Ae:{3 ff/(, 1 iq7;;i... rt£,, ... r ",ol'if A f,1µ.,;,, /D-tO-'i {

Unit Areo V Untr i, Cost un,t Cost l}n1t ~t. I/Unit Cost ~nit I Cost g~;~ Cost Unit Cost Unit Cosf Coat Cost Cost Cost Cost co,t co,t

0 ) 3 3,- /,7 ~() ,J t"r, 17 /3.o~ ..fO~Tlt. l.:5oo ]'(1 f&

-4.f, 7:() 7Co fJo ~p ~oo. SoD J'fo

. (I 'u. .P. <:?.. ) • /2/,, /. (JO / ,{ C (~, I ;JC,

G:.4.~ -¥orJ .2-70 //,{fo J-./.9 t /9~o (,,.,,n 1.1.t/oo 'X6 .:Z:N?PS. /.-';"()() /S-oo Sa::, qr0,,;':\' 1

'tj AOO ~97 \ 7/poe> n.ss:> )~2'#8

~~ l57C '1 \ .;>l)OD0 .,1,1. "" ~ /?m,Jvt fool~~ ~l Qi«. "" I~".,.,·> (~Do=>)

Cf•~ '><It r,& - /"Jf> 1.<,;;11.,,..-<Q /t,H', <5•;~->>

+¥,t ~ IA '_,,, "' (l ·--~ :

-I

~

~- - t:l -TOTAL 3~17.:> " -3~-~ 'l b?ul~ v >< ~OOOJ i-l.

-i; ·ia 7 , ... .... uV! LIi J.J,.,- I-'

NORMAL % GOOD / 'JS" l,o - I p..J-, 1a· .t

I!' .t!l..£1"'7 ;..,,,.__ J.L...'{.f/7 ~1.f. ( rqtJ d);.,> ·-

R.C.L.N.D "" /) ./

0A 3-54 / - I JI Q \;f--- - - - ~-

A-II 8-56 •

COV.NTY- ASSES~OR ' · - - - ----··S'A~Jt!OO GO-c,_...J1Fq,'*N1A f,f/SCEL~ANEOUS BUILDING · ~RD

· · • · ADDREss 3c./S" v'-t-~ D'e I Nc:r:r~ lsHEET § oF 3 - SHEET ==========-============================~-===~~====;;;L)_=====

DESCRIPTION OF BUILDINGS ~ -

. ~ - ~

PARCELfS]..L OJ:()'~~ . - . .

Bldg. Wall 8 £xtuior Roof 21" Sfor-J ~e«r £ff;,

Tdl• Structur, Slzi Found. Floor 8 Inferior Detail No. I "'•

Typi covu or LoO -But/I y.41, - r:

' l \,,l,-- ~(f,) JJ ~ ~ 2 '-.l~ i..f,1 ~ C l'l nr- Q Ll {"'\ 1+<- l~tX< ~l 91o I 97r Y<-3\) ?. r,~Qt~' ()p,.IJI

I ~ 97u '((.7\) / 9?o

t -, ·-' OJ

r, -· :J

.... :::0 CD n ~

- I ~

<!....-- COMPUI/ffJ,'9N Appraiser- Date Lu J Pil.t - 1.../-. 21 ~ Jo 1 '?firn-Bldg. Area gn,f Cost % R. ~ /I}, gnit Cost Gbod ~:~: gnlf Cost I r.!'';..-1 ~-£·~· Unit Cost Gr~d R.c.;.~: No. osf Good L. .D. ost ost r.ru:;t l N .

L -Z... Io o 2..1 Cl() _j I Ob 93 1153 al.I ~l,

'7 ' ('2.u (-z..l, /,,:) (' 91 :577 ~ 1 (. v~

-Total --z_ 1 i. \l ~ .2'11~ J. 7 :).,,, ~t;''W Appraiser- Dote d BIO(J. Area Unit cost % R. C.N. Unit Cost % R.C. N. gnlt Cost % fl-£:~: Unit Cost Ir.~" ~-~ i. No. Cost Good L ND. Cost Good L.N. D. ost r.ood CD,.t

- ---

I-" -w --

Total A- IS e-!>e

... . . .........,.

-~ . ~, : .. t: :·:~l· ·t·· • ' I

• +- • • t • .. . .. .. ., .. : ;. . .. . ..

; fl. ·JJ ~l

t -·· ·-~~ ..

:,...

a

~ C) -.... ~ ::, CL :a C) (,)

' .. " ~

"' "'I '3

"(

... I\ 'l

<"\ )(

:..-... C'&

J

.,

(I

~

" ff" r,,. I'( II' ~

.. ,,.. '\ -....

(:\ 0

< ;/.

.._. ~ " ~ ' t'\ ). "v ")

")

'

.... ""' " ~ 'l ' ~ ~

~ "" '

1 . -')I- ~

L .. y

~

.. " ,IC ... 11::1 I;

l

;..._ - - .. ··-- -

'

I j ..,1 .. -~ I '<> .._ ....--------'

I ...

. . ~

', I

- - .J

. r

q. < I

·l

' ·1

I •' I , ,. 14

'

~ -.

rt • .. .;. f r ..

• i

... it

~ f

t

' . ... .

.. I t

..... , . . .. ..

-+--1-t--+ • --· ' • i + •

• +- .... ..f )

....... : f

, • I r .... ,, ,. I ., __ , . ·±; t-. "t +--

' r._ -----.. -+-4~ -~· -~~ r,

t '-• ->-t -..... ""t -............ ....

...... _ ,._5,.-,_

.... -~ . t .... .

.. t ·U fl l.: ~-..-!..:_:_L· H1ll < I I :

• It f. I. .. I • ,,_, l .. ! ~ i.. ,

t~f~ r

' + .. • .. • J

412

OFFICIAL RECORDS IOOK i

ST.A ff OJ' CALll'OllNU ! II COONTY OF SAN DIEGO BS

I e.Q111Jlbi11. ~1"11Aay or October lll40, . betore 1118, 1"RJ.NX 1, 1".AUST a Notary Public in and ror I ~aiill ~ty) jmd state, residing, .therein, dul7 oommiadoned and l!Vlorn, peuonall.y ap-peared Bl!RBJR'I' C, !IELLY, known to me to be th9 V1oe President and fl!'Lll'N o. BZLSHJr J known to me to be the _ Secretary or ths oorporati.;u iib.at executed -the within 1natzwnent and known to me to be t he persona who e:z:souted the within inatrument on behalf or the I 001'1>oratic:n therein named, and acknowledged to m.e that euoh corporation axeouttd the I IJ4llle •

IN WIT!BBS WH!RBOP', I hne orrioe, in said County and writtan,

hereunto set m:; band and artixed my orrioial seal, at ~ State, the day and year. in this oert1:!io5 te rir et )!J!&'",--_

lo't,;-,~"-· !'RANK 1, FAUST '( l.ltW!K ~

Notary Public 1n and r or said Co11nty and State,'-~ l!'AUBT i RECORDl!:D AT

-, A ·~'.Y· Rl!'~ST 07 SOU'I'HER!t TITLB & TRUST CO OCT 8 1940 at 9 A, !.!, - --

COMl"Al'UCO

$1,00 - 52150 - 4 ~t ...... "'r,'~

'°"1n Oflm'Tl' ~

ROG?:!! N, BOWl':, COUNTY !lECORDl!:R BY DEPUTY D, COLlr

---000---

GRANT DDD

L, O, HAMPTON AND OP.ALM, H.U!PTON, husband and wire, as joint tenants, For and 1n i

oone1deration or (ilO,OOi DOLLARS, DO REREBY GRANT to FORTUNE DOGNE.AUX AND EDITH MAEIE J

DOGNEAUX, hueband· alid wire, ea Joint tenants, .ALL THAT REAL PROPERTY situated 1n the

City or Ban Diego, County or San Diego, State or Ca11rornia, bounded and described as

fu~~I I Lota l to 12 inolQeive and Lota 1~ to 17 inclusive in Block 367 or E, O, Rogers• Bubd1vis1on of Bloak 367 or Old ~ 6an Diego, according to the Map thereof No, 4.29, tiled in the o1'1'1ca of the Recorder or aaid San. Die@-~, Ootooor 11

1 1887. 1u11:fifl,J.k.'\'TA-R\ . +--- .. . ~

~""""~O-~ti.T~1~·~--""'<M,K\

WI'mESS our bands this 3rd day or October 19 A n1-· ' j a i.--..1" . -]

2...~an ---- 50 u&Ms- T nts--------'- . -··- . . . . -·-- .. ,- I Signed and execution 1n presence or --

STA'm O! CJ.LIFORNlll COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO SS

L, 0, HAMPTON

OPAL M, HA1!PTON

On this 3rd day or October l.940, berore .me, EARL !UGLUND a Nobr:r Public in and ror said County end State, residing therein, duly colllllliaaioned and sworn, personally appeared L, 0, HJMP'l'ON AND OP.At M, HAMPTON, known to .me to be the persona described in and whose na.mee are subscribed to the within 1netrwnent and acknowledged to .me that tbay executed the same,

IN WimBSS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my ofrioj_al seal, at my ortice, in said County or San Diego, State of Celi!ornia, the day and year in this oer-tificete riret above written. ~-• __ _

URL HAGL1JND ,.~ i,_ Notary Public in and tor the County or Ban .,0 EARL '\• . Diego, state of California, ili~ HJ.GLUNp Uy oo.amiesion expire• Nov, 6, 1941, ~~-

R!OORDED AT UQ.UIST Ol" SOUTmraN TITLE & TRUST CO, OCT 8 19~ at ll .A, L!,

tl,00 - 52151 - 4

COM-P...,..6:0 -- _ "1B..,- ROGEB N, HOIIE1 COUNTY RECORDER --. ,.. 'tv • BY DEPUTY D, OOLB

---000---

( NOTICE OF COMPLll'l'ION 1 NOTICE IS llERl!'BY GIVEN that THOMAS L, BBXPmm!) wboee address is 7650 Ivanhoe Avenue

Le Jolla Clllirornia, is now and was on the !irteenth day or l.!ay 1940, the owner in tee o

that certain real property situated in La aolla 1 County or San Diego, ea1trornia, des

cribed as tollows, to witt

Lot 2 Blook 7 La loll a Her1110sa, City o:f B1111 Diego, C-.litornia

'l'HJ.T ae aaoh owner or said. land 11aid TbOJllle t. Shepherd, aboQt the 15th day ot 11a1

lll40, entered into a oontraot with 1BANX L, B'l'Il!SON ea oontreotor, ror ths ereotion and

aonstruot1on on said land or a certain building, to wits

• 7%111111 and Btuooo Residence and Garage,

. !JUT •id bu1ld1.ug hall been duly construottd, end th'e same wae actually completed

. 106 15

I

11m: I . £i. :·:.

I ~:JI'. I( ',

:!·'. r . ~. ,-

. ,

I

.1

I

I

I

OFFICIAL IECOIDS BOOK

I ~n P~R1t'1'lt.ft1oe 11 ghen p11r1uant to the p.roviaiau ot Section U87 ot the Code ot

1 ~~~&,-:~t~Wir9g ~ ~ ~i9rt~ or Cal1torn1a.

j Dllted this 19th day or September 1940.

I'· STATE OJ! CALIJ!ORNU) COUNT?' OF BAN Dill'GO)SB

i THOMAS L, 8HEPlllraD ba1D8 t1rst d11ly llworn depose and ean thet he is the OWller ot the ! property described 1n the toregoing not1oe 1 thsl'iie hes read the aame, and knows the i contents thereot, and that the taots therelll stated are true,

!I Subeor ibed and sworn to be tore me this

19th day ot September 1940,

I . UI'l'H ·~ :ml00BON ·

Notary l'ublio ili and tor the County ot San Diego, State ot Calitornie.

RECORDED AT RE~BT 0'1 THOW.S L, Sl!EPlDraD OCT 8 1940 30 min psst ll J., M, COMP",..m.:o

ROGER N, HOWE, COUNTY R!CORDER ~-"'i"'~,n-$1. 00 - l52154 - 4 BY DEI'U'l'Y R, ZBRVAS -.....,,,..,.,._,

---000---

NOTICE OF Dln!'AULT

I MAUD J, XEMPJm es trustee unde.r that oe.rtain deed ot trust, exeouted by mmMAN 11,

I JJ.COB .um EDNA M. JACOB, husband and wire, as trust ors, to IUUD E, KEMPER sa trustee, I •

j and TRI :!SOONDIDO W'lUAL BUILDING AND LOAN ASSOctATION, a corporation, now llllown as

.TJm' :ESCONDIDO lBDln!AL SAVINGS .AND Lo.AN ASSOCIATION, as beoerioiary, dated l!'ebruery 16, . .

11135 and recorded J>.aroh 12, l'i3l5 in book 3811 page 77 ot Ottioi.el Records, in the

ot:r'ice or the County Recorder or Ban Diego County, Calirornia, hereby gives notice that

I a breach or the obligation tor which such transter 1n trust is secured has occurred, I

! the nature of such breach being the tailure to 1

i l, Pay the installments or $15,60 on the tiret day or each month aa provided 1n eaid

ldoed ot trust, tor a period ot more then three months,

/2, To pay the interest on euoh installments oil the t1rst dl!Y or eech month ea provided

I tor in said deed t trust '- t01:_ aJJ_§llod or mor~ t.han_thr_ee mon.t.ha. i 13, To pay the taxes upon the property described in said daed or trust;

i and that the trustee elects to sell or cauee to be sold the trust property to satiety

!said obligation.

Dateds October 7th 1940, MAUD R, xm&PBR Trustee

Claude L. Chambers Attorney tor Trustee

RBOORDED AT R:EQtllrBT 011' C. L, CRil!BERS OCT 8 l'i40 30 min past 9 A, J4.

t1.oo - 52157 - 4

COMl'"Aftll:CI ROOBR N. HOWE, COUNTY Rl!CORDIR et-......._

•·~w• BY DEFUTY' B, ZERVAS

---000-

ABS!tam!l!NT OF DUD OP' TRCBT

l!'OR V.Atmr RECJIVM>, the undersigned here by grant e , 11esigns and transters

Natio11,el Trust & BaTi.Dgs Bank ot Los An8elea, all benet1oial interest under that cer

tain :Oeed ot Trust dated August 26, l'-40 , executed by lLORENC:E ALVERSON, s widow,

Tr11etor to OSION TITLl!' ·DfBURAJIO! AND TRUST COMPANY, a aon,oration, ot Sen Diego, cal,

Trustee and recorded Sept, 11, l'i40, 1n Book 1062 page. 471 ot Ottiaial Beoorde in the

ott'ice ot the County Beoorder ot San :01ego Oo1111ty, Calitornia;

'?OGll'l'BrB wm the note or notes therein deso.ribed or .raterred to, the money due and

to beoome due thereon with interest, end all ·rightll aoaru.ed or to aoorue under sa1d

Deed ot '1'.ru.st,

DATKD thi1 l•t day ot Ootobu l'-40• .

•. 106 413

' . 17

(_

' I ... , . . •,

INSPEC.TION APPROVALS /,

/:, '/~,; ·· -· -'-----ii··---- - ---

) tt.Tf-: j Jf\if:~~>t~:c·; \:,t·t

/ --- t,:.--·----• r i i

_ __,_ ____ -IN,cii'LCT!UN

; I ·--- -···---·--·- --·-·------ -·- ------ _____ .. ·--·-1· .. __ - --- -----· ·1 ·--··- ·-·- --·--··-·- --·-

n:msr~:IA.N PROTtcncN i [ 1 2 ·-·· -·--··-·--··-- ---- ------- .... -- ·-- - -!----------· t··:;. ·-----·--····-·······-- -;

"' 1~/ "\(t r--r~';n<.iJ-•,\1-,,,-.. r, •••Y}!':]",i('l..!t"(V -~ •:•i.°j /\,,~,• r, f·~r>( • l •' ~ L,!~· .-· l ; ...... .,. - t l ,_..Ji .. , ..... ~ -·~- l • l t\l.,).., .. tr ,l~.t.-1' ~.K. ~ •. ,._ ,!. ~._1 ,, _,,"'I \ I .... ' f',1 .

I·--··-···,., ... - -.. ,. - .. - --------··----·----.. ·- --····----···-·,· 1/, /·f,·-·- -·( ·"·_()···-·-······ ·-·····!

\ 4 !T./\tv,L' , I'!/. ... ·./.r,· 1 I ( .•· 1 t __ ..... ..... ··-----· ·---·--· - ·· -· -- ·--··- - __ , ...... ... - -- ·------· ·--·------- ·l- / .. ... ~)'::: .. ...:.... J_ ~J---,- ---·--- - ·--.- ··· -- __ .! ; :S Rfn,1FC.~-~~C"Ji".J(; ST tEi l i • "f (---·--··-. ·-·. ·--· ---·- ------ ---··--·- _ .. _____ -· ---• ! l. •. •

) . ~ (,

j .......... .

' ! __ ,

I -" -{ I - "i~ -· ·t --- -~~r--

.: , / /. '1 /,· .. ,,,..,:_ i . ~ I ,., ,; Jc...._ -~'1···//., - ---. ......... ____ ! - t···-·"7~· .

(Jc:c.tn~J.\J-.~C.:\' set/\ r;! ,ttT?(:.+-J l 1? ' i ·--- ...... - ..... ··-··-"···-··· ·.····-----"'"" ·---··1:. _.. - ------ "'-="

l:l{.·:~~)i·i:S {;: ' :~tl·)t}()\1VS I""·-··-·· ' T:J ?:;r:E

I I

',I

''

........... _____ -- . i - I

I

..i

ti)<.(r:} j-(!\R[n /1:1 A. i'{t gr SJt:~r;.JS I

""'" "W••••--•·-·•-••••-•- ••----••·•-"••-·--•••·---·-•--•H"•-••••-!, ______ ., ____ •_•·-••••-~-•••-•-·•-"· "- "•"••••---""'"") I . .

· ·1 ~ sr·f{J/\L n~-Jsp,;:;t~r(">\::·s 1~t:P\.)f-rr J \ t !,---- ______ .... __ _ ._ ... , .. -~- --~-.. -- .. ---.. --·--··--w.2,_, ______ . ____ ,. ___ , _____ ,n•>·-· . - - - ··-·· - --. .. -~.,.. J r ___ ............ _ t 7 . . . . •, f

le.:· ·i. ,S .;;:::::Fi [',l,i\L .:.c:c," . . :: I - .-.-.- ·,:,: ..... ,c::·.·:.: ,:::·:,:=. ~";!.:c·'-·:·.:c::a ::;-:::.. ... -:.: . .:;::-c .:: .... :~=. =.:::~ ··-. · 1 .. . ";r /., .. ;::>,:/ ~ ~ .. -:;::- J.~f """,::;.~..----··: ···- .. ,. ............... 1

!-·-·"···-· D.t,.T E ·-----t---.... -.... ----.-------··-··-··--···--·-·---..... _. CO R i:.ZCC T!ONS -· ....... .. ___ ,,. -· ......... ,·-···-·-.. ·-·· .. -·--·---! I i \ !--·-··-··"·"·"·--····-.. ·-·--; --.................... ,.--·-·-··-·· .. ······-····--·------.. ,·-···--·--·--·-.. ·-- ·---•"""" ___ ,,.,_, ____ ....... ,_. ________ .. _____ ................ -1 i ~ ~ I I i

!~~~~-~~~-~~-----·-·"" i --··-·-··-····-·· --____ ,, __ -----·-·----·· ---· .. ·····--·-·--·-·--·-.. -·-·-···•" . .... ..: ..... ---·- ~·:·~·:_----~---: , I 1

I I I r····---.. -.. -·---------· .. ···--; ..... ----------· ·-............ _. __ .............. ·---.. ·-·-···-·-- .... _____ .. __ __ ··---- .... ---·--··------·--·-·····- -----·-·-··---.. -·1

! j I '---·---·-·-·-··- ·-·-.. i--·- "·- --·--·-·-·-···-"·-··-·-···--·-·-·-·-·--.. , .... __ ...... _ .. ........................ ·- .. -- . ____ ........ -··----··-.. ·-·····--··""""-· -f ! ' i ! i I !-·--···-·----.. --.. ........ --l.,,.,·····-·-··-·"·-· .. ·----. ......... .. -·-···------·-,., .. , .. - .. ·---·--.. -- .... -·-·--·------······-·-·--·--·· ............ _ ----------·····-·"···"··--"-!

l=~=--~--:1====~=~-==-=--=-=-~---·-·-~---------_J ' • ::.t • • ... -~

~ ,1

I

~.,

tatiitlt Pluablng and 611 APPuc,tnon APPLICANT ALL

: msmE HEAVY I.INES

us" o,· fl\'.~. n 1,a). OF .su:§: _;:::S)r':2!:NL __ iJ _.J.::::,.'1A!~~-L-

P 1&: R M r ·; F E i.;: S

{ h<:reby ack.n();,\dedgi:.; th~t i h~"'~ i'f:.\~:d ihi~ e.p·pllcation ; thi:t 1he

jnfcrrnation :s corl\~c:t-.: ;arid th~H ( cirn ·rh~ owt,tH\ or ·:he duly .31,ttht1 ri 1:<.d

a~:,erti' o·f the Cf(1n,:H". i ag~·<-,e. \"t, con1plv with t.::i~~., ~1:rH.l statH t.;j~.v.; iT?QtA·

latlng conrtrnctlon; and in doin~1 the '-'/Ork w.itrori:,;ed (·hereby, no ~,er-

son wm br:i ~ip!ay,,d Jn viofaition ot th;; L;,bor Code •}f \-h-· Sti:;te c,f CerHfolirda reifr.,th'\g ttt w,._1rkn1r,r\"'~ Crtf\')fXH1Snltf(H'\ h1SUi"i'l YV.;.e,

I..-.

,. ' ~ .. , l .,:.~'} .,/' ./ .• J /f :.IGN!-.., rlH:;~ or fi'/ '/...,,;' .,e.,g kt!. ,.. . ,r /" .,, { ~" . 1, /~.I, -' fJERl,M TTE!:. __ / .1 ••• Jl.-»(L/,,,-,!._''f.,l.,1"£~:-:.1. ~U:11.i.'l.f:'.df... _________ _

~- HC)I r;E :)~'-~/!:F

.. \..

i I i· i

t ; ___ -' I

·-·! ·+

·I --!- -

I

I. ' -!--. ' .j.

o. ~··J,,C·f E.ftTY L., '·~~ ,:,i.~fAf·,.1

!. ROUGt I C':Y·.-\h.1: IE

~.:~? fT i .j . !

·1 t:. F'!!-IAL l ..

Pi!'l-:~:n 11.t" i-01, ,:::,v:. 2.. .A~f I~- 1 EST

' .. 1

I _;

:!. \iF.l'·,!1S .~ 1 ... ,'°'1·:-.

4. UiJ1 r·. " VAL\f·,

I 1-;

' .I-

·""" ........ __ .......... _........ _, ________ ..,. ..... ,,_ ........ _,_ .. __ ~ ......... ..... , ...... ________ ~,, ......................... ~

U~E .'i:OP~t

APPUCATl10N APPROVAL

THIS fEltl-./t!T r.;m:~, r,!L•'t !HCOr,4~ Y'AUO

wrnt srt,Nrn ¥ff m~.i.:croa 1;:ii: !NSFF.C

-r,0.-1 ll~l'ART!v\!;i-l"i (;[;_ , 115- DEHrrv, AN O

H:FS Ar1F :'Ail;' M-.1!) i,ff£11'T !!; ,~c-

INSPECTOR

...

8vildi11g

<1V,1!~cR·s f··JA.IM:

1,.1.t, :, AOl)~'l :~:-:~~.

cir,

/\{?C: ·! i l"i:f-·r '-" ;:t-~C\; ·JD:\'

s·i i~i.:t ,· /,\ODl~E:5-S

Li ,:-·;::;, .. ;~;F NO. -··-- ··-··:--- ··-·-· ~c1 :t t·~i!'.JC rt:r-tr;~Ac;·r ', i:

!~rp:-;I.: ,\i)r;.,.

A!'Pll(A,.JT Fill ' INSIDf !-1£.h.\. 1 I.INeS u.,....., _______ _

I \ ITL H~:·. 1 Gl.~~t.?.:·~·~2 ·- _,_ .. ____ ..... .,._,.. ....... ~~ '"'--·-------·-

·t t:;. t -K)

-~ _ .i!~,-~~b_~~~~~L---------·

•1 ri'-··

JOB :,)ESCIUP!fON .. -- ··--·- ···- -··· ··--·---~- ·--····--~ ··- - . --~.'fi~l. i~ Ct~..:~~~·~~.':}!: ·;Attrn:., ~~·ai~:-;-; t.fr. !kJt.;;;:t;. If t,.:-.1 t ~-;;: .:.:o·:"1\

',.(;1,· ..... ·.'')· •. -.. - --~' ... _El ~ •. iJ' ', •. ,,,_.·.·. • .. -~.'~ t, . u , \ ,..~ ... - - - t f !-:~_::: __ ;_ - r;,t,e.·"'.-f-s.= a~ ~ .sa i)f!,9.iNJ,:;

...'.~)cH.· ::s.\, -c3..45__1J .. 1:,\ .d-&.1 Ne:::::t.a ... - . --.. ·-----· NE:Vif iJ i /\tlER CJ r.:if:f..fiCt.k)~- , []

. ADD _,_._m-._ ~- ·--··--·-·· _ , __ i,~:: P Ai R ·--·--· [] ·-··-. ·-· !\'~·ti!.~ __ _ [] ·-·--Rf:'SH."iF.::i~TiJ:.,L t::Jl /-.;Ufv1B~:;1 O·f.- :J: NU?v\Bl:t:~ •.'.:.if:

~~ON ~.!~EStDE~rrv:·.+ _I.] _! :::·t?rnf:~~ -, _ ____ r>~y~~-~i!~~5-~· .YJ"in~~ -~ r.ouN·rl 5.r\NITP .. Tt~::....,N D!STf::;1.:T I PRiVJ\TE o~SP(lS,o:\L . .:\r--¥!~:c,v.i;L

Rl:CEH'T NO. ____ ........ ------ --·-·- --------.. L ___ ...... _. ___ .. __ _ ____ ____ ......... STATEMEN1l' rM' PROP\()!iifS!,1; 1'J$r.;

-l'OAi,t NO, 1·1-UII t 7<t0)

~.l.~'il/J{li.ilw:•t,..:,.i . .\:il. ,t,,;./l'Ll'"' ;l '7'~~t. ·.~ o ~·~~jt .. ,1"A!,·~

\1~ ct •. ·.~ f .. 't( .f f,i:: • f~?~t ~it:A~..i:~ HU,

- o1•.•~u'J;.~ t11 • .1·,, l~Nli

'·1."'1ii Nl1 1Jl

Jd.,'~h f.•J;t.; : ... ~ ... :)

~!( ..

':_ ,, . . I

.•IJ

! ,;.I

I I ,~-. \ I :, "'

i"'' ,...,-, ,· ,!. .~

INSPECTION RtQUf:'!.iT (CHECI< T'N.O SQUARES) ROU(;',H 0--··"'~~··· .,.. READY

__ FINAL ____ [1 _______ _ ___ N01 I~.'

. "/

,· .[ ,,··,,

I'.\'.'

''

D µ-~-- .... __ _____ ,, __ _ I hrm,by oc~n,,wledgo that I have reod this oppllcotivn: J·ha t tho

ATTENTION

THIS PERMIT

AUTHO.IZES

ONLY THE

WORK LISTED

ABOVI!

!NSPS:C",'JON OEPA.Rl'M l!N1"

<:,,

'.~

APPL.CATION APPROVAi. THIS /'ER.MIT 001:S NOT BECOME' V,b,LID UNTl,L ~ SIGNED SY DIRECTOR ;:- F INSPECTION DE-'. :! · PARTMENT OR HIS DE, JTY I ANP FEES ARe

PAIO AND RECEIPT IS ACKNOWLEOGJ:O IN

SPACE P~

~·c~-1- ·- ·----:--::1

Doffl, _/~(__

INSPECTOR/

$ , OU ILO ING

:r___ . --- . - - .. --.-------- ---,-- -----~-~~~-~ ~~"''"''-~'.,'.:!:::.~~::~~=::::~:~~: ~~:"',,==1--,.~:.::_~ NSPE<:r~.:.=~-~J S PEC1' t O~=-="=P=P=f=~O=V=A=:l.::S====t:=====,j::,=:=:="""'""':=••t"'!CI

l l. Sl'RVICL lQUll>Ml' 1·H I ! l? UN,lERGROUNO CONDUIT

f. • ...... .. . ... ·-- ·-" -- :;.·~·: • , ---- ·--t-••• ---·--·!----···--·-·--·t •< C /. 0 --- _J~.:_.:..._1-,!::.,Z:...!!::Jlll~,4-i,ot,,iC!i,l..l!/..:l!lt.:l::.i!.:=.;+...ir. I A. Ut·-J;',EIHWGl l)JfJ ,,:I<\,•. l i I I ,,, .,L,,, }- •- •-•o, ,,o,, ··-·o --~.- -·-••••-t••- --'••••-·-- "i-·-· ••-·• ·W•••----~ • ---,--·---- -----·-·--·----+-----,1----... --,-....,.,;u.~!,,'I) ! (~. \NFA1'Hf.R 1-1~:..l'.\1) l ! I .l, ROUGH \!V(l!ING l . I

i.... '.:_ ~'.~~·~ICE ,:~r-i~~:_r_::~': '· \f\U. --!----- -------- -f------------··-·-------~s-· ·R,Ar:1---... ,rr TY Dt _! IU,; CMl: I: ----~

! D. \f,Jf./\'fH!?.W-'RO(;ri" l i i b hX,tJi<f:~ r----··· ·------ -- --· --- - - .. . ; ....... -------·r--·----·-- - ·----- _t ________________ _ ----t--:-- ----i f:. flONO iN(; ! 1 , 7. :':!'-lilt. L _____ _________ ·- • · .... ---------· ·- ------- ··------- f------------·-· r·-···------------· ------------! -----·- ·-----------------1 f··, .• :.f~OU! .. ~C , \ I I , I !

r. ~:,;,~-~:~- -- .) ____ J _____ -)----- ______ ----__ --....J-, ....... ____ ...... ____ .... _e-'",r<!li'\="!'l.l

i kf(.f. .. ,,JCI .. , ,,., cl-, , I ,·o;,10.r•"(''' j •:l·· !>()if D , I 1··"'~/ ... I ~,:)'~- u.~.-lET" 1;1.1 ,_ ':\ l~col,:J...""'"'" ii '"'"i, .. ,,~:.·i:-rl: .. ~~"~:;.;,:"'."() -.~;~·:::-..::::;.~~:. --·,""t~~~~"..:~p ;...::l=.1=·. =p======RA=N=G=E=O====,=-~""">:i!ll'l"'~, r ,-• , lh! c, 1'--C:CH)i"/ ' "i"e:1,1 A,;rn·q;:,;•1,\1 .. !NSPECTIONS, IU, MARK5 . ETC

' - -. ... I ----,-- -- --- ·' -------- - --- -- ------------ -----------·----·-·--

'r·------ _____ ! _________ --- -- ------1-----------t--- ---------------- -----·----------- ---------- --------

~:~~ 1. - ... +--- -----:- ----·---:_~-=~~~~-~-:~=-=~ :~~~~~==~=~~==~--------------,,;?,'.~=--:-~..ii !--------·---- . -l ... ". --- .. ----- --!-- ---- . --t .. ·------ -·-· ---· ·-·--- ---------------· ~ l I I

'_ ~--1_ ~~---__ J_ __ -l_ ______ ______ -_______________ --~--~--...;;-·-l.--..,..,....,...~~~

, I

I 1 ~-- ··--···- -- -- " -·1- ------, ------------------------------·

--- . ----------·-···-· ----1----------1--- --------- --------·----. -- ' .. ----------·-·1-·--'-- 1--------· 1, ~ ' • .

. I -----+-:-·--·----------- ... - ---,- " . ---------,- - ---· ------ ------------------------

El _, __ .]_ _______ ______ ____ ·--f ____ ____ JI-----------·--·--·-··-----······-- __ . _

---- --· - -- ·----- .. -- -· --- --- .. - --- ---- ----------- .. ------------ -- · _______________ ___..,._,,_...-,.,.._,_.,,;;::;;::.;...:,,...,.....,.;.1:,1t,. I •

(___ . ------ -- i-=-t ·------ -·-----------,...,· i .

1--..... --·+------ -., ,., -----+·---------.....+------- ----4---(f--""""'!,.......~-----"""--:-I..~-+--- ~~~~;;-:-;~r.f,r,!tlirtf

7 ""'·'--'-"-.._. __ _.__..---1------1----.. ---~

"' ~-

I I \

\

I

Cl C 1::11:::, ? Ci 1J ::::: 24\!

:NSPECTION RECORD 2

::

,

1

~ , ~- ·~·J!._ . .: ~. _:_~~'. -~~~~ - ~,·.: -1~1f, rl~·IJ :'I~•~•~ Al " I.'• n .. _

11

·- ~-'-- ~ ~~ -~ ~~~; - -- -.j . J~ ~· " ,j,f • ' , , ./ ~: ; ~·!~ Ir ~f.~1QUhJ1'i ··r:1-~r:·: i j ~

I \; t\• 'lw"I .! l\ri I

I

I , l . - l I '.'d '. 'i !f'i I' 1,( ,: .1' H 'Nl ~iH. "tJ/' r i;_j 'I •1 f d 'A t' i ~ -~--L~! - l.:,j . l . .:1.t..f? - . - , ~- \,,:,,:., : ,,11; 1(!,f .,.; I !, ,,,;:,, :• YI '! ,., ., ,,:,,,,: j .. .. 1--- .. ---·- -----··! I IJ \!vi" f'. I I H:i~';','.! _ _.;( j I Id \ If.'( ·., I I

I L I i - f .. . i- - - . ·--·-·-i i f10N::.liN(~

1

1i i ? !-\f-.;.\L J ~""/"/i-y /./ ,,.. .. - ·, ,., / ., A=" ...,.7 .,! I Y//• ,'i.;C-, !1'( ( . / ~ /i'' ·' 1:,j,

; .. . .. - - ·1 r·---- · t·- . -. ·-·------- --- . -··· ·-:Y,7"7"c,/-," ~, ,4 .. ,- . ..,. --+---- ·~----

1 ,~;:~~·~-)~·:·~~ -------·--- L _ ----- --1----- i .. ----- _ ----- ---- .. 1L .......... _____ t _________ ,, __ ._ ·, '" S/lii(HtS I __ .. ________ ) ------------·-·-- ... J- --·- l -·-··---·-·--L .... .. -.. --- .. ·-·-------1·-R-l:~~f:;;~;~.;~~:;--·---------- ! !n::1J~; iHW:J;c,l'4 ~Oil: LJ Tf.M!'O~.;RY 1\/\tm 0

! :)U )LF.'/ i] Tl, ;!.. f_l . L~i~ .'.' ·:: .. ~'.:~~ '_ l·JS ....... (~]-----.Ji:'·,! :'. .,~:., ...... ~'. .. _g ___ . ·-:.· .. ... -'~-:\:·:~-~f:...!~-- _ ........ ':~v1::~r: ____ r2.,=b. i==· ":,~:~~=~-:-"(''·"~l:~~-f~~t ~~::.. "'(-: .~·:, ! - -t..... . .. . ..: .. I , 1-- - -· -- -~ ~ . .. -i +-- --.... ---- ----- ---L _____ ·---- -~--- ------·--+- ----·-+·---·------··--·---------- ------- - ... -----·- ·--·-- -I . I ' L..... . .. !.... ..., ... --· -----/.-··--·. -·-- ---- ........ ... ---l l \ ! ,---- +-----. ...... 1-- --····1 ·- ·--- -·-·. -····-- -·- .. -- - ---·--·-. ... - .. r-·------ -- -,----- -· ----- - i·-- ·- .. t----------·--------------- -- ------------------------------------

~. -1- - -- --- --1---t- --"-·-·-----------...... ... ·--··-·-·-·- .... -------~~-- . · ~

1

I --- - ---- -- 1- --+-- ______________ .. ____________________ ___________ --__ . ____ ....J

I I ·- . ---- -- ---------1---------·r----........ ---------------·----··------.. ------------------ -------.. --- ---· - -I l • ··---------1--· ........ ...... ,.-~ ....... ·---·----·· . ··- - -' I

~~-t -=-~ ~~~=---f === ~=-~- =-·· .. -~_- ----· - .. ------~---~- . --------~----

~.I.It ,!: l()i.JJ\•; ! j •.; ~ ~ ' ·.

---·--------'-- - - - -1------- - --- - ------ .. --- - --- --.. - ·

--····---.- ...... -·r--··---- ·r I. .. i --- ··- t~- ___ I.

--;-···--·--, I I

.-4. - ----- --- -"

,t'l!M'rf i<SVM&H

'25 .. &20ti-l J

r F F S

e

e

-·-----·- ... ..-:c--·

·· ··- ,..6 - ...,

--- ----·-·-··L lNSPECTi0:-1 OF_ EQUii"MENl .-, ---··----+----::air.---,,---~ .... --•;r '--------------··--··--·-·---·--------~ --__:_ ____ _

····-·---···--- ~

UCHJSf: BOARD AS

CAl..1.. 236-6256 FOR INSPEG:TI.ON

. ATTENilON I 1' THI$ JllltMi'I' l

I Al!'/1101tl:i'.il:S ON!.V YIU

W~";lf,it( NO'c!'i1)< · 1

l'-WPo.C"l'l(.)N 11_ l'l)l!'.f'AR1'MENT

f ;,RT' iiL-

Plumbing and Gas 1f i.J 1,/;t3f; ~

, ... ' I·, ,~~

•• ,. ·1,,1. 1 !·.'1 1 ' 1

• \ .... •,, ·.:· ; ;! ; ;•,.:... ;_1!

f- !- ' ' / )·~ . '. j /• t '.:f, I 'I!: ~·i·

.... ,:.·_ ,.

___ ./.::t~}id· _t) ~~ -·-···- __ .)::·t.Jc:J ·( ..... ,.. AODAES~i:

CJsi.LL 236-6256 fOR. !NSPECTWN

FO R_!N5PECT ION _DE_PT ._usE ONt. V

;--· , ____ AP?ROVED -·- ___ l,.,,..,.)

!_~~ L /l :.~ t:"M E l·l 1

.. ~LL~~.-~ ----- .. ----~-:i ___ E ~ .. ~~-~-C-'.~~~-':. '~~

P.C . SEWEH CGM·! .

BUl!...L>/;..;G ~'ERMiT [:'J H,~S- ~---j

f- \ ~ !'i!<~·- -~ '. ~-~ . H ~ r'J

L ~~ i'lt-", ~:.: --..:) !' H CF

r· J. .. ! (I IN 1\L. 1:,

\ t:VJ.:.c,1-1 H/!,.~)lf'-1.5

A TT ENT I \) I\!. I THIS P EP.MtT i

---··-.. 1 _,.'t trr~10 R 17- E '; I

r--· I ONI. Y 'HH: i i_ ___ .i ,,1 rilcET WOR\{ NOT'.:L'. I

if,;.-::PCCT l0r,J ! ;•EF AR'fMENT

8EF..M 1.ssuED AU'fKOf"12.1r-:b !:111:ucTu.'\t WOPt< lN CONNr::c1·1eN w1·1H THi.s I !CE! .

-Ji, ~ .a 'i'- r--- .. ___ ·---- -- ·---------- ·-lil.iSPli::,-0- ... .. sfJll1i:o

T 6RM I ( 'I< . 2/ ij l n "" I\ , , , ,~ ';

·-·-... '"'\ ....... - .. - -~------··---.....-' PfiRMIT ::::1 \iwMEJE" E_509~

! + I

.../. ! i r-·

Afll0UN1

~ 1 • 111 l I •'., I ,. , I• • ' I

I·; II

'I I I J•

11·,I ) ),' ' !1 • ,

1 ·1. l't:nnit fyµo ., , .. r• .,

, . U (, !J :::, 2 1:::i U ;:=:

.28 •

Perr Applicati,

t ·2. -i\;)1~;:\ i~d(jt m, '- I;•, i 't. ,,,,, T···,.·--·--·------ ---1 f' !an Flh: No. Fc, r City us ,, On!y

rj .UI "f.J~)

• -1-~ l I

' l . ,··, ·.,

1J11il "f.)o J /\ { (! __ 4 [) 1.±~ Ci~

M;,q,-1'k,. I Ii .'I' I

' J• I ·- ...... ' 1-'a rce l No. P:ir• Pl f:,1a1.• f'.J(J. ·fa._t.~O~fi<.H's "Fiar..::r..h. No-.

·::~,r> · , . ,·. "~ .• ·' · C•'L c,c.> CowJ1 l1011 uf ',oil ,,t Sit12: ' 1 Undisturbed ' 1 Compact Fill U Loc,s< Existing Us0 ·

Sff<

Oosc1ipt10 11 of Work t:r,.I (_ l.. t, ·~ . .• . ..' ·,. ·--·- \;r I";_ . \ -~ ··---···---·-···----·---- - \Total Floo r Are;;~ q\ 3. Deslgnoi' name · /\ddr,Jss

Of:.v-l\-\u k" • . ;1. 1 \t ,!, -· .. /t. ;_ j i;,. / A.J,,f!. l> ,. I>.. '>I IS City -·-------------·-·-·- .i t,,• ,., ·- ·zip 6icfo . Telephone l.icense Nu_m_b:-c-r __ _

'-A- -\ ou .":>..- · 1· -~ c: '. ! A'..:-4 ·n'1fo·J.~ 4. Applicant Name Please check one: i.;onl1ac:to1 /1\~t" '' for Contractor Owner .X.:. Ag011t for Owner

----~xA>~L 1-\-..."J x . > F---Address ' /,;::; + l City I ,_ I . . • Stale- . Zip.fade - Telephone

,, Ca1/<r-,_/LV A\.J 1::. 1 .. n- ~··JU./,,, ··- ':/>, 1-1.0'!;J . 1~s4: . o-/(o::, 5. Properly o""w_n_e_r/"'L_e_s_s_e_e""''renanl Name P/e;-;;;c,7eci< one 'fu: ow,wr I 1 Lessee or Tenanl _____ ...... ..;.._,_ ___ ..;... _

______ _ 121 ,-- t':c:... .ANP. --\€-1>::r:::~E. . s-.1:;;;d::·c{ ' • . _ .. --·· .... Add1 oss-;; 1 . ; .• ,... . <:!i ty I Sla te Zip Code

.,,'\-'? \J(A, \ )\=L. r--.101k\ \-·. 1. h ,\c,u./i.,- '- A- '':·iJ, •, ·i 6. C-;,ntrac:tor Name -·------ -- ---- - - - - - -

Telephone 'J'?0 - c;,.-,z.,+'.==,

---- f?E:.l~URS\"' A,--ii.., f>, ';'_;,';f. / (. , --------·-·----------- -------------- --· ·--

Adcire1:s, ) 5 _1J (4P-,A/4:> f\\J f:: ---- -- ____ ct~ ~iu,\_ - ----- ~~~ ------~I1(~~\~b ____ ~ftec:nk:1'::> Stale License No. . ;,E?, \ "17_ 1 ___ ·-·. _ License.Class .J~,! - ---·-- Ci ty Business_Tax No. ")4 r'.Jo'}.'lzz_ ______ _ Licensed Contractor's Declaration: I hereby c1 tfinn that I am licensed under p1ovisions of Chapt0.r 9 (commencing wi th Secti on 7000) ol Divisio of the Business and ro lession Go9e, ald my licem,e i;i in fwll force and effect. Signllfure • / /,I ·' r> ! Title <Aoc _ ,.-- Dale •. c <;:t,.-:-., /'-- _ _,.,. , __ ..- Y._ "'r-C':>)f)(,-~1 to ... ·\. ··::p 7. Workers' Compensation Declaration: I hereby altlrrn under penally of perlury 0 110 of tho following declarations:

r'.l a. I have and will maintain a certilicato of consenl lo sell-insure lor wor~ers' compensation HS provided by Scclion 3.,00 ol the Labor Code, for lhe erlormanc=-o ___ _ ol thawork for-Which-this p<-,mil 1s--issued.

;;@_ b. I have and will maintain workers' compensation, as 1equ ired by Seclion 3700 of 1hr. Labor Code, for lhe p~rlotmH ')Ce ol lhe work /or which this permit 1s is· sued. My workers' compensation insurance carrier and policy number are: Insurance Cc:::,~~y "\'~2-E',r~ \'fr\ ------- Policy No. ~\ ~j>~·-/oCZ 4:?__ _ ______ Exp1ralion Date I - \ -4'<e

(This sectlOh need not be complm,d If U10 porrnlt is lor one hundred du/lais ($100) 01 less). t>fZr 0, I ce1til1 ::·lft: !:' the porform,;.nco of lhe wol1<~or ,lch U,ls 1ietJri l ls lssuod, I shall nCll u,nploy any porson 111 a,y mannor so a, lo bocome suljoc/ lo the Wol1<e,s' Componsalion Lows of Calitor-

11~, ord agree that 111 .~'"'.!d b?Coft>~~ct to )IY~>s' ~;,yhsatioi,~o,\iisim~'of ::rn 3700 of /ho Labor Code, I shall !01thwith com~y wl~, /hose prnvsl011s

Signature / LY-- "" L1 ·· ./ ~ l . ----+ Date Co -"! - .]5 ___ _ Warning: Fellu1a to socu10 wrnkars' componsallOll covorago Is unlawful, ;w,d shall subjecl an employei to criminal penalties and civil fines llP toono hundied thousand dollars ($ 100,000), In addlbon to

lho 1:osl ol crn".;,unsaUon, damagos as provided fo, in Soction 3706 of tho Labor Cede, interest, and attomoy's fees.

r-..,_O .. W-f1;i-.!:J ullaer Declaration: I ha1aby affirm that I am e•c·mpl lrorn the Conlractor·s License Lew for the following 1ea~on ISa,o. 703 1.5, Business and Professions Code: oft~ o; co~nty which requires a permit to construe!. alt01, improve, demollsl1, or repair any shuctwo, prior to its iss\j8,l,eo, 11lso ,oqulres Iha applicant fo, such permit to lila a slg stalemen: that ho Is licensed pursuer, / lo the p,ovlslons ot the Conllaclor·s License Law (Chapter 9, com!)UIAcil,g with Soc\1011 7000, of Division 3 ol the Business and Protess

. Codl!),or Iha.I he is exempt therefrom, and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation o1 Sodtorr1031.5 by any opplico11t Im a perm,, subjecls the applicant to a civil per ol not 1ho18 than five hundl8d dollars ($500)1 : _ __........

0 I, es owner of tho proµo rty, or my employo~s v..u, wages as their sole compensati011, wl)j;lo-1~~11< and lhe st,ucluie is nol inlended DI olfe1M for solo (Sec. 7044, Business and P1ofesslons Code: Contractors License Law does not apply to en owner of pr"IJ011y who builds or il)Jll!ff'/os thc1&01>, md vmo does such wo1k hlmsell 01 lh1ough his own omployees, pro~ded that such lmprOYemenls ari Intended or.off01ed for sale. II, however, tho building or hnp1w,mcn1 In sd~o year of complabon, tt,e 0"'11er·b111ld•1 will have rho lluufen ol proving Il ia! he did not build DI lmpmva loi lho putpose of~

0 t, ~s·owne1 of the prt1>arty, am exdUslvely :011!1Acting v.,th llc~acto,s lo construct the prOject (Sec. 70H, [lusrnoss and P1otoss1ms Cooo: l ho Con1mclors Lir.enso Law does not apply to an ow,, · •propirty v.llo bulds 01 lmprwes thereon, Md cont1acJµerCuch projects wlih conlrncto,(s) licenser. pursuanl lo U,e Cmtrncto1'5. Llc1Ntse t.0•·1) .

0 l•am,exempt under SecllOll _ ~or this roasm: Sigp·ature ::;?"""".- . . . Date

~, .. • , t11ott~h Lending Agency: I hOl ei>y nl!rm Hint lho101,. con,tructio11 ,~,ding ogoncy ror H,o pe1 /ormonoe o/ H,e WOik for which 1111, 11•11n ll /s lssu•d ($• .1097, Glv. C).

l!.~~~4~~ Na.)rle Lender's Address

. ht -slg1\'1ture: l'csrtlfy that I hBVH road this appllcallon end stale that the abovo ln lormat,on ,s correct. end /hat I am /he owner 0 1 lhe duly authorized agent ot illt{f)lg(e" 10 comply wllh all city and slate laws relallng to building construcllon. I heieby nuthonza representatives ot tho r;11y of Son rnego to enter upon the abov • li~,iiilb.~erty tot lhspeotlon pur.posos. It, alt o, mflklnu the Carl llkate of Exompllon from the Workors' Compensation provis ions ol the Labor Coda I &h<iuld b11Come st ,uo~/rovlslons, I wll_l tort11wlth oo ply. In the even' I <Jo nol oomply with the Workerc' Compensation Law, this permit shall be deemed rovoked .

Legacy BPIS Permits

Y41-920-01 Project Information

Legacy PMT ID: 1645718

THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO Development Services Department

1222 First Avenue, San Diego, CA 92101-4154

Plan File: A-103703-94 Status: A OTC: D Contractor Info: DEWHURST & ASSOCIATES Worker's Comp. Ins: FREMONT COMPENSATION

Submitted: 06/09/1994 Owner Builder: D

License: 381927 Phone: (619)454-0763

Expires: 09/30/2003

Purpose of Permit Address: 000345 VIA DEL NORTE

Permit Num: C-304670-94

Comments: X01=GARAGE CONVERSION TO BEDROOM EXTENSION;X02=REM0DEL PORTION

Policy: WP 93578116-01

Expires: 01/01/1995

Address ID: 112549

Status: F Issued: 09/20/1994

Expires: 12/06/1995

Finaled: 06/09/1995

Desc. of Work: KITCHEN ,BATH ,EXT BDRM,DET. GARAGE/WORKSHOP, EXT TRELLIS , INT'R RMDL*B/23/94 CH SCOPE OF WORK-ADON ONL Y*P/C-FOUNDATION REPAIR 11 /03/94**

Code Quantity Use/Type of Construction Rate Unit

D40 256 DWELLING ADDITIONS WOOD FRAME $74.00 SF

MOB 35 INTERIOR PARTITIONS $36.75 LF M31 72 OPEN PATIO COVER/ WOOD $6.50 SF M58 761 ROOF STRUCTURE REPLACEMENT $10. 75 SF X01 24 OTHER -RATE DETERMINED BY TECH $55.00 EA X02 715 OTHER - CONTRACTORS VALUATION $22.00 EA

Structure Information

Lot: Model/Desc: REMODEL AND ADD Type of Constr: VN lnsp Cat:

Bedrooms: Stories: OCC Group:

Studio: 0 Permitted: Units: 0 OCC Load:

1: 0 Fir Area:

2: 0

3: 1 Total: Units: 1 Plan Chech Fee:

4: 0 Fir Area: 256 Valuation: lnit: 5: 0 Bldg Area: $2748.00 Final:

p2k V 02.03.38

CLS: B-1

BTC: 74002955

APN: 357-030-0200 Structure: 001

BC Code: 4341

BC Desc: ADD/ALT 1 OR 2 FAM, NO CHG DU

Value

$18,944.00 $1,286.25

$468.00 $8,180.75 $1,320.00

$15,730.00

C Soil:

R3/M1

$337.35

$34,217.00 $45,928.00

Arlette Moulton 446-5438

L~gacy BPIS Permits THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

Development Services Department

Y41-920-01 1222 First Avenue, San Diego, CA 92101-4154

Additional Info for Plan File: A-103703-94 Permit: C-304670-94

Inspection Status

Inspection Type Scheduled By Complete I nit Status

11 SANITARY PLUMBING

11 SANITARY PLUMBING

13 MECHANICAL

14 ELECTRICAL

29 ALL FOUNDATION

54 FLOOR SYSTEM(S)

55 ROOF SYSTEM

58 GAS PIPING PRESSURE

58 GAS PIPING PRESSURE

61 TUB AND SHOWER

65 ALL FRAMING

65 ALL FRAMING

66 ALL ROUGH ELECTRIC

66 ALL ROUGH ELECTRIC

67 ALL ROUGH PLUMBING

68 ALL ROUGH MECH

69 ALL FRAMING & ROUGH



70 INSULATION 73 THERMAL - FLOOR

79 ALL INSULATION 81 EXTERIOR LATH

82 INTERIOR LATH

83 DRYWALL 83 DRYWALL

83 DRYWALL

99 FINAL

Project Fee Calculation

__ Q_t-'-v Description < APPLICATION FEE > < ENERGY CONSV PC FEE>

PLAN CHECK FEES PLAN CHECK ADJUSTMENT SUPPLEMENTAL PLAN CHK PLAN DEPT SM RES/CML

Permit Fee Calculation Qtv Description ---

< APPLICATION FEE > BUILDING PERMIT FEE COMB INATION PERMIT FEE

ENERGY CONSERVATION < ENERGY CONSV PC FEE> STATE FEE (RESID.)

SEISMIC FEE (RESID.)

Project Fee Summary

Invoice No Amount

0032424 94 $224.05 0027293 94 $863.20 0024483 94 $52.00 0024482 94 $52.00 0019283 94 $200.00 0017127 94 $68.64 0016597 94 $388.17

• p2k V 02.03.38

Printed

11/03/1994

09/20/1994

08/23/1994

08/23/1994

07/06/1994

06/15/1994

06/09/1994

11/10/1994 11/10/1994 WEB p

11/18/1994 11 /18/1994 WEB F 11/18/1994 11/18/1994 WEB p

11/10/1994 11/10/1994 WEB p

11/14/1994 11/14/1994 LMT p

11/18/1994 11/18/1994 WEB p

12/13/1994 12/13/1994 WEB p

01/06/1995 01/06/1995 WEB p

05/24/1995 05/24/1995 LMT p

01/31/1995 01/31/1995 WEB p

09/28/1994 09/28/1994 WEB F 12/09/1994 12/09/1994 WEB F 01/31/1995 01/31/1995 WEB p

05/19/1995 05/19/1995 JAF p

01/06/1995 01/06/1995 WEB p

01/31/1995 01/31/1995 WEB p

12/22/1994 12/22/1994 WEB F 01/09/1995 01/09/1995 WEB F 01/31/1995 01/31/1995 WEB F 02/02/1995 02/02/1995 WEB F 01/10/1995 01/10/1995 WEB p

02/10/1995 02/10/1995 JAF p

02/22/1995 02/22/1995 WEB p

04/11/1995 04/11/1995 WEB p

01/10/1995 01/10/1995 WEB F 02/22/1995 02/22/1995 WEB F 02/24/1995 02/24/1995 WEB p

06/09/1995 06/09/1995 JAF p

Fee Fund Account $160.00 41300 73528

$33.74 41300 73418 $280.15 41300 73411 $113.75 41300 73411 $52.00 41300 73411

$200.00 100 77137

Fee Fund Account $80.00 41300 73528

$519.00 41300 73412 $241 .43 41300 73411

$51 .90 41300 73426 $33.74 41300 73418

$3.21 63010 77940

$138 63085 77940

lnit Payment Time Cashier

RJH 11/03/1994 13:46 SEV

PGB 09/20/1994 10:56 MER

SXD

SXD

TFR 07/06/1994 14:39 SEV

TFR 06/15/1994 12:28 LLS

PGB 06/09/1994 12:59 MER

Other Remarks

UNDERFLOOR MAX 135 DEG U/FLR DUCT@ MSTR BDRMI MAIN TO HOUSE

NEW & EXIST;OK TO SHEET NAILING

RG MOVE1

INFO, MAIONTAIN 17"@ W/L pp ANOP, MST, HST & AB'S

RE NEW

INFO ONLY

INFO,C LIST ANOIC

pp ANOP ALL

PP OW @ LIVNGROOM WALL PP EXCEPT@ 1 HR GARAGE WJ

GARAGE-OK

Paid Kev $160.00 AP01

$33.74 EC02 $280.15 PC01 $113.75 PC02 $52.00 PC03

$200.00 PL02

Paid Kev $80.00 AP01

$519.00 8001 $241.43 C001

$51 .90 EC01 $33.74 EC02

$3.21 ST01 $138 ST03

ST Revenue Date

p 11/04/1994

p 09/21/1994

V

V p 07/07/1994

p 06/16/1994

p 06/10/1994


Legacy BPIS Permits THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

Development Services Department r «98 3 of 3

Y41-920-01 1222 First Avenue, San Diego, CA 92101-4154

Additional Info for Plan File: A-103703-94 Permit: C-304670-94

Total Fees Incurred: $1 ,744.06 Amount Paid To Date: $1 ,744.06

Clearance Checklist

Clearance Required Approved Appr. Date lnit Comments

STRUCTURAL CALC !El !El 09/20/1994 PGB

ENG PERMITS !El !El 09/07/1994 DFM EXEMPT PER JJI

MICROFILM PLANS !El !El 05/15/1996 SYS ROLL: A2815 FRAME: 0165

OTC PLN CHK STR !El !El 11/03/1994 LGR FOR STRUC 002

SUPPL PC FEE !El !El 08/23/1994 SXD $52 CHARGED FOR MECH RECHECK

PLANNING !El !El 09/19/1994 GJP EXEMPTCDP PER HOOPER #1170

RESIDENTIAL MEC !El !El 09/19/1994 GLB

SAN DIEGO UNIF !El !El 09/20/1994 PGB EXEMPT

SPEC INSP AGRMT !El !El 11/03/1994 RJH STRUC 002

STRUCTURAL !El !El 09/19/1994 LGR

WTR&SWR PERMITS !El !El 06/10/1994 AQD USE EXTG MTR SZ 03

BID ZONING !El !El 09/20/1994 PGB

• p2k V 02.03.38 Arlette Moulton 446-5438

Legacy BPIS Permits THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO

Development Services Department

Y41-920-01 1222 First Avenue , San Diego, CA 92101-4154

Project Information Legacy PMT ID: 1873505

Plan File: A-104014-95 Status: A OTC: D Contractor Info: DEWHURST & ASSOCIATES

License: 381927 Phone: (619)454-0763

Expires: 09/30/2003

Purpose of Permit Address: 000345 VIA DEL NORTE

Permit Num: C-302643-95

Comments: X01 = 74- 10.75 = 63.25

Worker's Comp. Ins: HOMESTEAD INS CO

Policy: N370942

Expires: 01/01/1996

Status: F Address ID: 112549

Issued: 06/13/1995

Expires: 01/17/1996

Finaled: 07/21/1995

Desc. of Work: EXISTING PORCH TO BE CONVERTED INTO HABITABLE AREA

Code X01

Quantity Use/Type of Construction 73 OTHER -RATE DETERMINED BY TECH


Rate Unit $63.25 EA

Lot: Model/Desc: ENCLSE PORCH Type of Constr: vr-J lnsp Cat:

Bedrooms: Studio: 0

1: 0

2: 0

3: 1

4 : 0

5: 0

Inspection Status

Inspection Type


79 ALL INSULATION

89 ALL LATH & DRYWALL

90 FINAL

Project Fee Calculation

Qtv Description ---< APPLICATION FEE >

< ENERGY CONSV PC FEE>

PLAN CHECK FEES

Permit Fee Calculation Qty Description ---

< APPLICATION FEE >

BUILDING PERMIT FEE

COMBINATION PERMIT FEE

ENERGY CONSERVATION

< ENERGY CONSV PC FEE>

STATE FEE (RESID.)

SEISMIC FEE (RESID)

Project Fee Summary

Invoice No

0016820 95

0016759 95

Amount

$410.61

$167.95

Total Fees Incurred:

• p2k V 02.03.38

Stories: 1 OCC Group:

Permitted: Units: 0 OCC Load:

Fir Area:

Total: Units: Plan Chech Fee:

Fir Area: Valuation: lnit: Bldg Area: Final:

Scheduled By Complete I nit Status

06/27/1995 06/27/1995 JAF p

06/27/1995 06/27/1995 JAF p

06/28/1995 06/28/1995 JAF p

07/21/1995 07/21/1995 JAF p


$7.22 41300 73418

$72.15 41300 73411


$111.00 41300 73412

$128.64 41300 73411

Printed lnit

06/13/1995 AQD

06/12/1995 PRL

$410.61

$11.10 41300 73426 $7.22 41300 73418

$0.35 63010 77940

$0.1 5 63085 77940

Payment _T_im_e __

06/13/1995 09:09

Amount Paid To Date:

Cashier

MER

$410.61

C

Submitted: 06/12/1995 Owner Builder: O

CLS: B-1

BTC: 74002955

APN: 357-030-0200 Structure: 001

BC Code: 4341

BC Desc: ADD/ALT 1 OR 2 FAM, NO CHG DU

Value $4,617.25

Soil:

R3

$72.15

$4,617.00 $4,617.00

Other Remarks

FTGS& ROOF EXISTING

89

Paid $80.00

$7.22

$72.15

Paid $80.00

$111.00

$128.64

$11 .10

$7.22

$0.35

$0.15

ST

p

V

Kev AP01

EC02

PC01

Kev AP01

B001

C001

EC01

EC02

ST01

ST03

Revenue Date

06/14/1995


Legacy BPIS Permits

Y41-920-01 Additional Info for Plan File: A-104014-95

Clearan~IJ:l?J<i'jS,,vith Fnntpri nt Clearance ReQuired Approved

MICROFILM PLANS ~ ~

OTC STRUCTURAL ~ ~

PLANNING D D RESIDENTIAL MEG ~ ~

SAN DIEGO UNIF ~ ~

WORKERS' COMP ~ ~

WTR&SWR PERMITS ~ ~

BID ZONING ~ ~

p2k V 02.03.38


1222 FirstAvenue, San Diego, CA92101-4154

Permit: C-302643-95

Appr. Date lnit Comments

10/29/1998 SYS ROLL: A2908 FRAME: 0135

06/13/1995 AQD

06/12/1995 PRL

06/13/1995 AQD

06/13/1995 AQD <500'

06/13/1995 AQD

06/13/1995 AQD USE EXTG MTR SZ 03

06/13/1995 AQD


L~gacy BPIS Permits

Y41-920-01 Project Information

Legacy PMT ID: 1582529

Plan File: E-504728-94


1222 First Avenue, San Diego, CA 92101-4154

Status: A OTC:~ Contractor Info: BFI PORTABLE SERVICE Worker's Comp. Ins: CALIFORNIA INDEMNITY INS

Submitted: 10/11/1994 Owner Builder: D

License: 285247

Expires: 07/31/2096

Purpose of Permit

Phone: (619)726-5830

Address: 000345 VIA DEL NORTE

Permit Num: E-504728-94

Comments:

Desc. of Work: TEMP POLE SFR 345 1 /2


Policy: N-3028518F

Expires: 10/01/1995

Address ID: 112549

Status: F Issued: 10/13/1994

Expires: 05/11/1995

Finaled: 11/12/1994

Lot: Model/Desc: Type of Constr: lnsp Cat:

Bedrooms: Studio: 0

1: 0

2: 0

3: 0

4: 0

5: 0

Inspection Status

Inspection Type

15 METER RELEASE

90 FINAL

Permit Fee Calculation

__ Q_t-'-v Description ELEC ISSUANCE FEE

TEMP POLE

Project Fee Summary

Invoice No

0030040 94

Amount

$65.00

Total Fees Incurred:

• p2k V 02 .03.38

Permitted:

Total:

Scheduled

10/12/1994

11/12/1994

Printed lnit

10/13/1994 CJC

$65.00

Stories: OCC Group: Units: 0 OCC Load:

Fir Area:

Units: 0 Plan Chech Fee:

Fir Area: Valuation: !nit: Bldg Area: Final:

By Complete lnit Status

10/13/1994 WEB p

11/12/1994 WJB p


$35.00 41300 73440

Payment Time Cashier

10/13/1994 11 :01 MER

Amount Paid To Date: $65.00

CLS: C-61

BTC: 84009025

APN: 357-030-0200

Structure: 001

BC Code: 8001

BC Desc: ELECTRICAL 1 OR 2 FAMILY

C Soil:

Other Remarks

RE TEMP POLE

NR TEMP POLE

Paid Kev $30.00 E002

$35.00 E034

ST Revenue Date

p 10/14/1994


•,r1-i-T, 0"-1ve.

aY1~1'l~C,. ,

1 M,I\IC~ •x1$T1"':;, l"-OOM I Q>Al7,A61ii'

I

r. ........ ~"".' r-------+-,n--1

l \ L ~ .,_ ....,_ J ----:1-._ _________ ___,

Beo.o'

SITE PLAN WITH FOOTPRINT

THOMAS SHEPHERD DRAWING FROM

OCTOBER 17, 1961-SUNROOM CHANGES

' . 36

\ I

LaJolla Historical Survey

La .Jolla Hermosa Historic District

l• Jolla Herrnosa l-'1stor1c 01$1nct

prope rty

@- Map 7

Map and Page from

La Jolla Survey for City of San Diego Planning

Department,2004

By Wilford Wayne Donaldson FAIA

37

Address 6037 6106 6114 6118 6121 6122 6126 6130

0 311 322 203 225 226 300 300 321 328 335 338 345 350 355 364 375 380 391

6000-6100 6003 6fJ04 6007 6011 6012 6014 6015 6017 6020 6021 6023 6026 6030 6100 6105 6106 6110 6111 6118 6119

City of San Diego Planning Department

POTENTIAL HISTORIC DISTRICTS

Street Name NRHP Status Code La Jolla Blvd 7R La Jolla Blvd 503 La Jolla Blvd 7R La Jolla Blvd 503 La Jolla Blvd 503 La Jolla Blvd 7R La Jolla Blvd 503 La Jolla Blvd 5B Mira Monte 5B , Walkway Mira Monte 5B Mira Monte 503

Via Del Norte 3S Via Del Norte 503 Via Del Norte 5B Via Del Norte 7R Via Del Norte 503, Street Trees Via Del Norte 5B Via Del Norte 5B Via Del Norte 6Z Via Del Norte 503 Via Del Norte 7R Via Del Norte 5B Via Del Norte 5B Via Del Norte 503 Via Del Norte 503 Via Del Norte 503 Via Del Norte 3S

Vista De La Mesa 503, Street Trees Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista D-e La Mesa 51:3 Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 7R Vista De La Mesa 7R Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 5B Vista De La Mesa 503 Vista De La Mesa 503

Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA La Jolla Historical Survey

38

38

APPENDIX B

OWNERSHIP AND OCCUPANT

INFORMATION

-Chain of Title -Listing of Occupants from City Directory

and La Jolla Bluebook -Copy of the Deed from Date of Purchase of

Lot

39

Chain of Title

345 Via del Norte

Title Records for APN 357-030-02

I Grantor II Grantee II Date Recorded II Instrument# I La Jolla Properties, Inc. Frances East Barker 25 November, 1929 29-65619

Frances East Barker Thomas L. Shepherd 2 December, 1938 38-65620

Ruth Shepherd Scripps Memorial 11 September, 1986 86-398832

Hospitals Foundation

Scripps Health Richard Arthur Erley 8 March 1994 1994-0150984

Richard Arthur Erley Karsten Joehnk and 20 July 2001 2001-0503200

Susan Rutan Joehnk

Listing of Occupants City Directory/La Jolla Bluebook

Year Name Occupation 1941-1942 George B. and Adelaide L. Floriest (Adelaides Fine

Harrison Flowers, La Jolla)

1943 - 1986 Thomas L. and Ruth Architect/Interior Decorator

Shepherd 1986-1994 Unknown (owned by Scripps N/A

Memorial Hospital Foundation)

1994-2001 Richard Arthur Erley Retired/Interior Designer 2001 - Present Karsten and Susan Rutan Real Estate / Lawyer

Joehnk

41

Deeds According t o tax assessor number 357-030-02 : in 1938, Thomas Shepherd acquired the Subject Property lot (Lot 2 block 7) and the Adjacent Lot (Lot 1, block 7. The adjacent lot was acquired after the Subject Property house was completed, in 1947. Deeds are included here for Lots 1 and 2 of Block 7, with their notation of sale to Shepherd. The Sanborn maps reflect that the two lots

were one/then split some time in 1950s

I

1-t Jz we, . .

~1::t~:;::=i:.:~~r~: ... _ ... - 1a1 •• ,...m ......

. ;, ' )~s L, SBKPHERD, a married man a$ hi.s -~~~~ ~~d -~~ · ,i . ' ! h1S v;!,!'e DO HE!lEBY GM!lT TO F'LO!IBNCE SCRIP?$ l'i:&LLOGG, a vidow ALL Xl'AT RUL • OPERTY 1

f situat~~ .. ,tha City or San Diego County or San Diego, Stat& of C&litor bo1.111ded am I , d12scribed as ~Uovs:

: ill or'r,Qt Three, B1oclt Tvelve or La Jo11a. HorJ1osa u~. 1, excepting that portion ly.1~ northve•terly of a J.j_ne described.:;,.to11ov•:

Beg1nn.1ng at ·t be most northerly corner or said)=<>: Three thence in a. •tra.1ght line to a ~int on tbe s outhweaterly 11~ r Lot Three said line being a1so th& nortbea:iterly l.ine or Caaino de Costa distant thereon 23.0 !'eet Southeasterlr-,!ro• the J"-Ost westerl corner or Lot Three. According to Map thereor No. 10101 tiled in the o ce or the Recorder ot said San

·, Diego County l!oveaber 21, l.~24-. '- . : WifiESS m: hand_ a.nd seal_ thh 9~il~ay or ,.ful.1, 194?

'".//

,/', .•.

/,/ "'-.,

STAXE Ol' · CALIFORllIA.) ,

THOMAS L. SllBPHEIID RUTH F. SHEPBSRO

(SB&L) (SRlL)

COU?iTY OJ!' SAN DlEGO)SS //' ·,"-.,,_

On the 9th day or July ~bet'ore ae , JI: . 'ii, BI!ic!IAM a Notary Public in and tor sa.id

I Countr and Stat~, perrll:, appeared THOMlS L. S~P~d RQ'?H F ' SBSPHIBD, hu.aband / I

a nd vi!'e known to .,-,,,e to be tba ;,erson.... whose name_ u au ribed to the torego:!.ng in.tru-

ment, and aek~si/~dged to me th.at u executed tll! sue. ~'

.,._, ... _.._,/,..91' hand and ott1c1al Sea.l. ~

11:.W,BI~ ·-!fot&l')' Public in and tor sud Coun ot ,san. ,-Diego State or C&litorllia,

MY collllisa!on expires Sept, 21, 194-7

JUL 21 194-7 9 A. I(. f "ir::::~:~::.. .. - rt;,,;J11/1 13_?/ Cl&'PU'IY CO. UCOfllOO ·: :.,

$2. 75

FLORUCII SCRIP~S IC&LLOGO DO_ llEREBY GRANT TO THOMAS

j_.c; J / so:1:.-and separata,,roperty-!LL-Ti!A!r- REAL PiiOPERff--sitWlted in the City o~ San Diaco

£;l0 d CoWlty or San Diego, State ot calitornia, bounded and ducribed as tollova:

5/:3V{n -7. Lot Ona (1), l31oclt Seven {7), La J'ol1a Hermosa Unit l!o. 1, 1n tile

I Cit;r ot San Diego County ot San Diegot State ot caU.fornia, accordi°' to Map thereat No, 1A10, filed 1n the orr1ce ot tbe County Recorder or said San Diego County lfovqber 21, 1924-,

,····· . 1 t ; w

ilITN&SS ,q band and seal this 18th day or July 194-?

STATE OF CALIFORNIA) COUBTY OF SAli DI&GO)SS

FLOREffl::E SCl!.lPPS K&LLOOG (SEAL)

., On the 18th day ot Jul7 194-7 before u , The Undersigned a Notary PUblic in and tor said

Co..mty and State, ~rsonally appeared Florence Scripps Kellogg known to .. to be the

I person whose llllllle is subscribed to the foregoing instrument, and aclcno-wl.edged to me that

.,b.e !1:Xecuted th!I same.

I WIT!IZSS ~d Ot!icial Seal.

1 6 E. W. BING.HU( Notary Public in and ror said County or Sa.n

D1ego1 State or Cal:!.!orl)j,a, My coaaission oxpires Sept, 21, 19!!-7

; Bi1:CORDBD AT REQUEST Oil' ONIO!f TITLE INS, & TBUST CO. JUL 21 194-7 9 A.. M,

1.00 - 71+1+31 - 3

ROIIB.~ N. BO\o/E COUJITY RECORDER

BY DE?UTY D. COLE

= COMP,o.Rzo

F r r r . .... ~ •· .. ·- ·' ·' ,,

c ij·,ciAL 1eco1oi eooi .. . . ' ·· . .. -· · . , .. . - -. ·~

••

/ • ··1

Onio,i '1'1tle Inaur1111oe Co. Dec 2 19)8 at 9 A.M. '·-.-~.:;\>:·:., · i Roger N, Howe, County Reoor<lor ;;; '•.,,,' ' B7 Deputy D. Cc,le - ,~ --- /~. C; 1 ;,'), ·,: ' :

.Y _:> .:> w ( C/ /J~ ··, - . OOOOOQOOO

' 29JJ8J ' U,T.r.co •. ,,SJl.JI. ~.J.·e~o,

1·Colit'. D~o · i l9)tl '

i .. --~ O<llfar"'"~' ... ··-:::::::·.:. .. · ,.L.....~

and 1n oonaidoration ·or the sum or T.EN I I, FRAliCJilS E:.A3T JJA.Rl:KR, a IDB.rr1eG ~orcan,. For

, , DOLLARS, 00 illiREBY OP.1\NT TO TBOMM5 L. SH1!:PJIBRD, ALi'., 'l'RA'I· Rl>Ai. PROPERTY att.11e.t,id ln the

~·.,,.. :2,.. .!lJ!l County of San Diego, State of CoJ.ifornia, bocmdad and deaot"!bGd aa rollo'1'0:

j : LO~ O tN BLO CK SEVEN OF LA JOLLA l:IZR?.iOSK, AO<.:O!illllW TO ILJl' 'J'BERZOF ,¥181•), t'I1ED 3 f!Od~ 7 Dl THE OFF!C! OF T!l.8 COUNTY RE<;ORD:&R 0.F SIi.ID SAN DIEGO COUNTY, NDVN.lllER 21st, 1924.

; ,wrTNES3 my bond and seal tb1o 26th dat ot ijo76Ulber , 1938 • . ; -- J Frances East Barker (SEAL)

.i j l .,.

.I •

f / .l r '

I •

:STAn OF CA.LIF0RN.i:A, ' coUNTY Oe SAN DIEGO, ) oa. On t~ie 2Htb day of NoV6!llbe1•, 1938, before me, EDITH E. · : :BURNE, a Notary Public 1n e..:,,d ror sold 0ounty ®d State, personally epp~ared FRANC1!S EAS'li ,BA11Klnl l:llown to me to be the person J1hoae name- is subscribed to the roregolilg instrument,! ;and ~oknowled~~d to me tbat she executed the eam•. :

; ~~l~~~s my band and otf;;;;;y:;:~;;:1:a:n:n:0

:e::1:nc:~:YC:::1:::::~ fl~;;~§/!.::::"<..~,:

• llBl .' Reoorded at ~equest of Union Title lnsur1111oe Co. Deo 2 1938 at 9 A.M. {, ' .

... ,:re~ .. i1,oo-J Roger "· Ho.-e, County Reoorder e: ,. · -~'.<_·," _,, .. :65620 By Deputy D. Cole /e,, ;:··

ooaoo.0000000 .,,..,...l..,.,_,..;~:~:·:, ,, .. ,.

!flTJ.J, R:e:CONVllY ANCE .. , .. ,,,....

\ ~o:'i ALL MEN BY THESJ!: Plll':SENTS:

. -..:\'HAT, WHEREAS, UNION TRUST COIIPANY 0.F SAN DIEGO, a corporation bev1ng

;r,J ac~~sinsss &t San Diego, Cal1rorn111, Tx-ustae undor Deecl ot Trust ecu~ed by

AL'lllRT O. SAlJ.Q.!ER. and BEIi.TRICE A. SAUClER, Trustol'S, e!td recorded So •mber 28, l9J8

" in Book 829 Page~O, uf Oific1ai Records, itl the office of th~o1"1lty Reaordar of S"11

;Diago County, ca:ar~-~ has boe~. duly requested to reconvy/tha property trnrainarter

'.roentlonad, by reason or th~ satista~tion of the l.nzP.bto £ess eeour_ ad by ss.ld Deed or

tTrustj ~ ' NOif, Tlil!REFOllE, IN COMPLI.WCE ~h osld roques} and in oonsidoretion or the sWll or

'one Dollar, reo~ipc of whlob is bsr<>~Jcnow1'>cl;ed, and the payrnsnt or said indebtedness),

lseid Trustee DOES HEREBY !IB(JOl:IVJrr '!'O THE ~~n· or Persoos Lege.Uy Ent1tle'1 Thereto, but / c.~ :,r1t)lout warranty, all or the property .,aovered ,y~d Deod or Trust bow held by sold

:Trust,,q under the terms ot sald D_?'1~t' '!'rust, rerer~e to whioh i• bereby mode for r-u11!

-perL1culars. / IN wrr1rnss WHEREOF,. said ~ll'lon Trust Com.£.i&ny ot SBJ:.. D1eg as Tr1.1steE:r, ~n oa,;.~ed its

:corporate ' nam,; '2nd •~"1 t~/bo hereto ern,ed by its Vioe-Preslds t and 11.ssioten~ .• ~-~~- i

!ta .ry, thereunto duly a.l,Ythcrized, this 1st d£y or December, 19)8. ~ °',_, ; / , ,;pprov~d .B. i11H0H fRU'S'i'\ :

_/ tiNION;Ry~~G~O~~r~\i~L: ~;~,bn~rustee, ~w~~l' / By Lloyd Baldridge, Assietant Seoretuy · Il'OalNIA•

. . I/ -.;:'"·~ . , {3TA'fE OF CAL{Jl'ORNlA, ) ~ COUN'i~ 07 .s'AN O.IEGO , I ea, On .this 1st day ot Peoe~ber, 1938, before me, WAR~~ !INDEL, B/Notary .Publio lo _end tor said County , psrsone.llY appeared A. G, RRADKR known-...._ ; ,t c, n,e tO" be the Vioa-Prealdent, en_ d LLOYD BALDRIDGE, kno'<ll to me to be the Assistao.t Seo-,...._

.- .. .... I

l 855'

) ,.· ·eJ )

,., . ..f i . ,!, . •.'.\ f. ·, .,·.,

t .· ··<

.. ~ .. , '1 :J

J rateri/or UNION TRUST COll.PA.?lY Of ~AN· DIEGO, Trustee, the oorppratlon that exeouted tho i -......, ;tol'e,B\)ing in•tl,\llll•Dt, IUld known ti:> me to be t!le peroons wllo e:reouted tba saJ11e on 'oehal:r or "-...... . .tbp-' 001'l)oration tllerein name~, ~d eokno ... ledged. to me that suob Mrporstion exeoutad tb• ! -...._ ~ Jl'Ul)e aa auob 'J'ruatae. ·y-- ··, 1 '~,.:,,.,--

/ . if.ITN!SS my- bl!lnd an.:1 oftlo1al oeal. /~·1""R":{,-r~ ..... · ·· .. '- ·-..... "-· ,.,/ } Mru,ty Et Jind?l · · ary };j~ "'

-~ I )lotary PubUo in and :ror· said County · 1odol ) i· ... C;t Sau . Di.;gc, .a~t-e er' C~li:i'oro.la. \, )84

l:!eoor<ied ct re\ueet or Onion Title In~uro.Loe Co, D&o 2 19;,B at 9 A.Ii.. ·-:•(•.,.-::,··<,,· .. F•e fL00-5 Roger N ... SQn, County R"ool'd&r

·~5612 lly D0,iut7 D. Cole

/ • L 000000000~0000 ''t:-"ll /'),·,, . .. ,.,, .

I • • -

43

Page 1 of 1 Requested By: s.holt, Printed: 10/27/2017 10:04 AM

Doc: CASAND:855-00069~06073

APPENDIX C

MAPS

-CITY OF SAN DIEGO 800 SCALE

-USGS MAP (North/arrow/site)

-USGS- CURRENT & HISTORICAL

-ORIGINAL SUBDIVISION MAP

-SANBORN MAPS

1886/87, 1906 1921 Not

Applicable

1949

1952

44

21

Subject Property

!8 __

~ "$1

.~ "' ,ti'

A. tP

----- - ----- ------0------

6~---- -------

L._ ___ _

&3 3 EGO. CALIFORNIA

CITY OF SAN DIEGO 800 SCALE MAP

FOR LA JOLLA

45

Subject Property

I ~Q

I

~ \ ~

I I

*

L-

Current USGS Map 1 :Z()/ ('

345 Via del Norte

USGS La Jolla OE West Quadrangle (7.5-m inute)

46

Subject Property

Historical USGS Map (1953) With Subject Property Indicated

........ f- ~. t.. IOLL,;

I f .. ' ~t I.JG

- . . :: -~ -.=.-.~·

47

........ -"

::!00!

Subject

Property

~~ = v..J~K. ·-~"' .~ ............... • -

Figure

Original Subdivision Map

La Jolla Hermosa, October 1923

48

La Jolla May 1926-July 1949, Sheet 26

Sanborn Map 1926-1949 Sheet 6

49

50

Sanborn Map 1952

APPENDIX D PHOTOGRAPHS

51

Front Fa~ade -345 Via del Norte, La Jolla, Ca Details

52

West Facing Elevation - Top

East Elevation - Bottom

53

West Elevation From Garden

Detail

54

West Garden Elevation with Pergola Shepherd Garden Art

Stone Griffins from Taromina, Sicily Terracotta Relief depicts St. Martins, patron Saint of

Convivial Gardens ( Julia Fleet 1967)

55

Perspectival Views: North - South Axis Top: View Looking South Through Living Room

Doors toward Bronze Putti Bottom View from Putti Looking North

56

South Elevation From Garden

West Pergola

Islamic Tile from West Garden Room

57

58

South West Garden Room

Tiles from Spain and Iran

' '

Top-left: Ruth and Thomas Shepherd in Back Garden (photo by John Waggaman, published in House and Garden, 1967)

Top-right: Photo in Italy, likely 1938 (La Jolla Historical Society Collection)

Bottom: Susan and Karsten Joehnk in Garden, 2017

59

APPENDIX E

HRB Criteria

Supplemental Documentation

' . 60

HISTORICALLY DESIGNATED BUILDINGS BY SHEPHERD & HERBERT MANN OR SHEPHERD ALONE

CALIFORNIA HISTORICAL RESOURCES INVENTORY DATABASE

Senrch > Results> Property >

Search by Property

OTE: Help Ups are avallabls by clicking a search criteria labe l.

Address:

APN: l,.IQR f\.111mho.r

HRB Name:

Architect: Shepher~

R11ilriar-

[search Results: Displaying 1 to 19 of 19 records

Detail Address

6101 Avenlda Cresta San Diego, CA 92037

-

Yea r Built

1925

1925

1927

1927

1927

1928

1928

11928

1930

1933

1934

Architectural S~ District I Location

Mediterranean Revival Map

Mediterranean Revival Map

-- ~~~ S~nlsh Ectectic Map

I ~ ---

§9-anlsh Eclectic Map

~nlsh Eclectic ~.- Map

I I I

L___ Tudor Map

Spanish Eclectic --! Map

L_ §9-anlsh Eclectic Map

-~-

C Zigzag Modeme Map

Colonial Revival Map

French Eclectic --- ...- Map

NRHP Code

!---

---

---

---

r-I

I ---

---

---

~~

HRB #/Dist. Contrib. #

327

181

689

763

757

829

560

833

230

1000

898

Search Date: 01/05/2018

HRB Name

Dar11ngton House

Proe!!!:1 Status

Designate

The Little Hotel by the Sea I Designate

Lester Palmer /Herbert Mann-Thomas Shepherd I Designate House

Ada Black/Herbert Mann and Thomas Shepherd I Designate House

lou1se and Thomas Rothwell/Thomas Shepherd I Designate House

Philip Barber/Herbert Mann and Thomas Shepherd I Designate Spec House No.1

Henry and May Turner/ Herbert Mann-Thomas I Designate Shepherd House

K arsten and Susan Joehnk/Thomas Shepherd I Designate House

Parker Office BUIiding I Designate

Parker and Dorothy Seitz/ Thomas Shepherd I Designate House

Minnie Gerhard/ Thomas Shepherd House Designate CTI ~

+ 1937 Colonial Revival Map

-- --- _L 1940 I ModemRanch Map

-1947 California Ranch Minimal Map

Traditional I 1948 California Ran~ --- Map --,,,- -

---1948 Modem Ranch Minimal I Map Traditional

-=·-1962 French Eclectic Map

---1971 I French Eclectic I I Map

Map ~

1~ 1 ~Ole®.~7 I "'

11 I 11r--•··,,.l-.1. .1 - mnru 1

710

--- 514

I

--- 993

849

1 024

-- -1265

1144

Lowry McClanahan/Thomas Shepherd Hou e

M@el Scruggs/Thomas L. ShePherdHouse

~

!_Jsbon & MargaretDurham/Thomas Shep House

Cassuis & Kate Peck/Thomas Shepherd Ho~se

, Alfred and Jesslc;a Phinneyffhom~s L. Shelfherd House

Herbert and Alexina Childs/Thomas L. Shep~erd House

w"'"'""' '-""1,e T;l,Wn,omos s-"" I"'

Designated

Designated

Note and File

Designated

I Designated

I Designated

I Designated

Designated

-

en N

Reuse of Front Fa~ade Elements 7741 Lookout Drive, La Jolla, Ca

Constructed 1948

••• ••• ••• ••• •••

63

THE SAN DIEGO UNION: SUNDAY MORNIN~ APRIL 17,, 1938

1 Shepherds Sail For Vacation

'

~1'~-~~~ i I ha_:ve ea:barked on a th.--ee rnocths -: Etl."'Qpea.n trip. . They sailed from ,.. I New .York y~ !or Naples. \: I trom w!lere they will visit Capri , I and Po:c:pcll travel . on to Rome. . I F!orence. ·Vffllce. Milan • . Ge!lOa.

visit Par-.s and London. z::d re-

f! tum home -on a Holland-.Arnttr0111 liner about Aug. 1C * .•• .•

ALL HAIL TO THE EA

l SHEPHERDS RETURN FROM EUROPE;

64

I "'The hom~g thrill is the I nved 'Tu~y !or a visit ~ abou1 I best o~ all no ir.atte- how mar-..,.elous j two weeks.. Mr- and ~ Dammann : the tri _ ~ M..-rs.. Yn.omas nepne: ; r~ moved !mm W.mne.tka...fil,, ____ _ ' of La Jolla, who ·with Mr_ Sh herd I to Nashville. Tenn_ The visitor i= · arrived home Tuesday !ram three ! being welcomed by her many months aboard. apologized for the j friends. Mrs.. Ga..'"lli's brother. F. M.

! triteness o! the expression while! Harle o! Beaumont. Mrs. Harle. Mrs. ; urging its fundamez:tal truth. . : Garth's namesake,. Wtlm.a Harle. and

T'ney were ln Italy two months. i Latham Harle. are also making the : visiting Naples. .Rome, Florence. I Garth's a visit. · Venice.the Riviera and Genoa. and I * * • found all happiness and peace. Mrs.., Mrs.. Craw!ord .Jonson was hostess

· ~ ~ with ·no"..hing t.o sug- 1 at luncheon yesterday at Casa de gest war clouds except drilling sol- ! Manana to_ a ~Olll) a! ;rormger sci

. dier:s, and they.bad more the cheery ! members mcludlng Mn;_ :niomas · aspect a! Boy Scouts. They caught I Dammann, Mrs_ H~ H~ck and a glimpSe .of the king. bttt not af / the ~ Rosalie Maks. Grace Mussolini. who was busy entertain-. Reddingius. J"anet Fueischer. Betty in.g Hitler_ . I Peyton. Betty Donnelly, Beverly

Mr. and Mrs.. e-o spent ! Jonson. Margaret .Jean Hamilton. three weeks in France and O?le in ! Gena Chalmers. Nancy Bradley .m.d E:r!gland. 1 Ma...-jorie Palmer-

* .. .... I * ~ *

San Diego Union

Shepherd's Set Sail for Europe April 17, 1938

Shepherd's Return from Europe August 14, 1938

65

-----0 .. ----- -w Man Joina ta

Of ·Building Compan --------· T. L. Shophnr<l of Lo,q Angeles hna

Joln~d the organlutloh of tho it' nn Dulltllng Company. • tre is a grodunte of Columbia Uni\fen;lty, nncl hn1 en r.onncctcd with the C'f'T\cc of G~or o Wu1thlnrton · · Smith, Snntn n,nb ra ntch ltccf;· and with WR1lcco Neff of

I ~~ . deris Cor stve~ 1 yeftrs. · c• • o-----

J8t&-Centul!y Idea : fer New Re~idence

'1/J:1!. ,n:4 Mrs. Thom,a;a L. $bepberd p buil~hag J\l new resi<ilen~e on Via del Norte, L Jolla D:erines&, on a large plot (!)f laind w-hie wiU adapt itself to a e11rving drivewa . ¥r. Shepn~!Fd ha$ :followed no definite style in ~- , signing the new !:louse, , bu,t 8tl,1', centUll!:£' ~Jia.n precedent ~ · Been ioU@~ed... hn @ff-w}ute ~ terior wili De pointed U]> b'i ~·0:rrQ1

paneiling, a»d the :FoOf wiM add a note of soft blue-gree~ in its heavy 'tilings. It is planned ta plant 0Iive tPe~s at eithe.l end oi the :residence.

TOP: Shepherd joins Herbert Mann Building Company, La Jolla Light, October 26, 1926

BOTIOM: Shepherd is Interviewed when Subject Property, Villa Francesca is being built, La Jolla Journal, May 16, 1940

lA JOLLA HOMES fr GIVEN PUBLICITY

BY MAGAZINES Two DbtiACtn·e ResJdt.nc.s

Win raatuie f'fa.ou in fa.stern Publlcallons, -----.... a .......... .,,. ....... -----·------·i.-la ... -e..,-.-. ........

____ _.., _ ___ .... _ _ .., __ _ IO .. 9;:" .. '7":U:. - -, IO- -------C:'" ,,, _ _,, ... - ,=-~~ =.,-m.-: =~.::~-= __ __,_ .... -----.. -----....... -e-1 .............

::, ta .:::-"L--=-: ::': ...... au.. .............. """ :.. ... ·~~--~= -----·-----=-=-~::~ ..,. .. '", ............ ....., ..... "":.---·- .~~- 0/(.... ~ i..-.. ~"=':,:-:~ ..... = g: =~- ,: :-..:~--.. ~,:-.=.- .......

County ~-' .. . .. ... . ' '

_.._. I I

Recognition and Awards for Shepherd Top: San Diego Union September 8, 1929

Bottom, December 7, 1930

' ( I t ..,. "\ 111 'l'

(&'iii. ... '\. .,.,...·, .. "'~ ••· • .J • ..,,. . , ... • 4. ·,,, 4 ........ .r\. ._ ' • ,A1

... i ;.. • : . . , • .__ .. , ... Nit' . s --: ., f"

•II )II ,s , ,.:-' ' -· ;~ .. ~,,

397 South Fair Oaks , Pa sadena Cal ifornia , August 28, I 924 .

Mr . George Washington Smith, Santa Barbara, California.

Dear Sir:-

Have you an o~ening fo~ an architectural draftsman who is not only capable of cerry.r,ng drawings from sketches to completion but can also be depended uuon for outside supervjsion?

A graduate of the Uni verei ty of '.visconsin, I went to the archHectural school of Columbia University for my architectural work.Leaving there I became assis t ant manager of tbe construction deµartwent of the McCrory Stores Corporation.Then to Grosvenor Atterbury's o~fjce where I worked,both in and out of the office, on a Beven building group for the Hartford Orphan Asylum.

Coming to California last year I entered the office of Roy Seldon Price where the Thomas H.Ince house formed the greater part of the work.Four months ago I came to Pasadena and since that time have been wit~ Wallace Neff.The work of each of the above offices is without doubt familiar to you without explanation,

Should you be interested in talking with me I will gladly drive to Santa Barbara or will meet you at your convenienoe when yon are in Pe.sadena.

Very truly yours,

Thomas Shepherd Letter to George Washington Smith

August 28, 1924 Architecture and Design Col lection. University of California,

Santa Barbara

1 67

6130 La Joll a Blvd -Thomas Shepherd' s Design & Home Shepherd owned the lots for this house and the home at

391 Via del Norte at this time . 1929-1930:

San Diego Union, July 22, 1928 And historic photo (inset)

68

THE SAN Di.EGO UNION: SUNDAY MORNING, APR

~LA JOLLA PLANS 'Before and After' of Beautification

• TO 'LIFT' FACE OF BUSINESS STREET By Wi'.I..LIA!II J.. WRIGHT

La Jolla is p...rcpa:iN;. to have the te.ce o1 it.$ ma!.n. business street li!tcd- liftP.d in:o a ba.$ic unifocm· ity and harmony o! architecture. and out ot !ts µr~t status. wh..ic.b. is tbe c:d..!n.a.?-.r -row ot pill -box :slorcs.... I

Toe proj.:Cl. as plaw!ed, U!-.·olves th~ west side of. Gi..-urd <IX!!. 1.a:t.he two bllx.k:s betwce.o Pro:roect :,;-.C. Silvc....-v.!o sts. Now these two bl~ conta.!n burtdi.ngs ot brick. stucco 3..C.d tramc; colored red..

~~~~: ar:~;~~~O\~d ,-arlOU!S They ~ ;i. ehcck.crbo:u:d of

bllS.Uless t roDt.5"" lha1 is n ot clur.c.terisllc or 1...3. .Jo~ or or south ern Calllol"'r;i.a.. u·s jc:.st an ucdk.try h~~ d.15trici:: Uai ini;:-ht be {ott.!!d anywb ue with no a.ttr...c.Uon or appeal t.o \.be e;ye. Se\·t:ral btt.ild.tng.s of a Cili!·.1rnla

:.t:·k o1 .ucl:iHecture. SClttered among the ""pillwboxes:· showed whaL the sL..-ee>- could be. Some ti.Inc aJ;,O tbe !..a. JollD Co_os_ervalion ~!dy stsi.rted out tp O!"l..CJ; the I £ti"eet U;> to tbe level ot its poss!Qili li~

DrawinJ;S ?repatT.d ·n,omas L.. Sbepbc:rd. La .Jolla

a,n;hi tcct .lb"l"eed to draw up a "suggestive·· p!.ac.. P!lotographs ot the !roct.age we.:-e to.ade and Shepherd

t =:·b~il~~~~ ~0o~~t~ that mn.de tbein :ill. fu:JdB.mCJlhllJY,

.r -·

·;-~-~ ... . .--..... '

. . 'I. . _LL-:

the !!al!!e !>reed ot ca ts :o the eye. -

~~- ., J.1; ...

- ·::-:- II,

a -we did.I!.'t ;varu: to spc.od. ao,y With the e:rpcndfhtto c t only a sm.3.U :unou.nt tor new pcint and minor 1 p money hut v,:e tbougb.l tbcu a uui• alluations. La. J al.Lans hope to =f'.non-1..t!: their main sired into lcu:·· 1/ d • St d t

Proposal - -.... - . . .. :, ~,.~ ... .//. ... ~ ~ ... ~ ,u ,. ,., . .:. .

. ~;. ... "'

·, :.-

.:Qe<j, pr:o~ should b~ Wd out." I m nnious .. civic ~ · beau ty 2nd onifonn.ity. Pl;csc.n1: c:~ colors n lan u en s says Sbcp2:J:erd. ··we fclt t,b.at a ~ oca:doxu.l .. .PllJpbr,ox"'" :u-cl>it.cctnre (below) w owa beco.me. tDlitcr plans! ;residential town ~ik~ r.a J?l~a of the 1..:a. Jol..b. C nns,ervation society. the pleas-In; unlty )ho lXTI :abo'f' t- r I'"\...,... 1 : r T I'\ :Would !;.ave ~ethir:tt lil;c 2. ClVJCI • - - 'I.. • "'Af.a ln OT ~"Vng ci.:-r:~u. W?t ~!rely_ a ~ow o! s_-.o:~·· j Colru::fn.l .awrunr;s FlanIJcll Owners EnthttSi.ast:ic h- _ _ I

Chen.~ and Wongs LE Dings and. Dcr,g;;: l SBANGllAl. -;:;:ii" 'li (AJ

America :.be Sm..i~ and the J

So color.a.11.on \..<; U1c 1.11o,:t fro • D-OT"~t bet.or of the l)lan. 1Jndc.r n ;\ll bt'1ld11>? ,t"oul.d Qc l)D.lntt;d or pLL-i1.cr-.'1"~ed. to tLO

.. ou-,.~lute" c:alo r; "'for ~es.,~ snlllhioc and ccncra.J. J\.tb:.tcU-i;·c,. n=."

Tb.ls Q.Q0-,'1,a.-i.o.g \.VhU,e al:;o. f:; aD !coal bucl,;;rouod. fo,: :dllm lotter,;,;! dl.rectly t.tpQ.n 1he b~~oo: pa1ntad co. ;ippl.lcd ..,.,.,, .),"""'1,. WUh ill 'the ~ -::t:.!tc. mvcb o! tile disharmoo..,.. 'bcr;.,~ cws blllldlllg ""d Uc nc:ct would~ !)Car.

In s,,mc ~ :he p!M tecom•

~ sllh.;:~:~~"~c;~:9 lnp. mosU.,- l>;- <On>lc • lrc->ll=:l'A tiled com.fee ,.m b.-lng alma,.: a.n:r bvildl.og into ;;outilc:::u Calilo,-

E;;'"Cl~~~&""<I role"c Lil)

Ln other ~es tlle elimination of - ewners O: tbe property are ex- s. Qldpfasb.!cned ·';d1Jge1;'brc:;3d" trim i.s prCS:iUlg great e:itbosiasm.." sa:s d suggested. ~ tl:tls all c::tp be cal°.. ?vesmlth. -r feel sure- tha t all o! C r;;,::_ ~ ~e ~tii!t si~hi~ G~! 'ther.rl will CQlll~ i:n." A regional of- p ground with variety :md :;park.le ficial oC tbe hoo:slng 2dm.tnistration e proridecl by awtliJJgs o! rna.QS l'L"CCIJ'".ly d eclzred that La J olla":; S bright colors. pJao 1...c; 1.be on ly comrnan.it!" e!ltcr-

Wlth the J>l:m . .::.oco~eted.. C!.cGit- pri..c.e o! 1-ts Sort in the cormtn-. and -able costs :ire enleri.DJJ !!iio its promised fnU cooperation. ~~ w~~t. .,~- ~te_r~~nsiu c~; He gatberl'd p b ot..ographs and project, cstimatC!S that tbc entire daU. . .st,rtin,g: tbm La Jolla's unique two blocks. a.boat mo feet.. ~ be eoterprise would be gi...-en n.,tionaJ I brought iolo un.iior-=ity UDder the n otice in the May issue of the t>J= ior obottt S\000 lJoasicg a<!Ini.nls!ration·s periodl=L · ~i.L-n.at~ arc be.in~ m.,d.e up tor I .as a.a c:,.-atople 'to other commu.o.ieach ir.djtjdnal bw1dinr. and the I ti~ Coosc.-va1fon ]e;:i.fJUe. with M1s:s & a finishing t pacb (or pe:-b.1.us· .Alice M.. Ke?s cspedall.y aclivc:. is 2.S a s'..a...-ter. d epenci:ing upon 'Ule 'bdcling tbe preblCI.tl 01 fl.oaadng, a\."3.Ilab ility o f SERA labcrr) tl).c, a:!on!{ two b:oats.. I

Erl orts :a.rr: being m:r.de. of street will be p L'Ul'ted with palms course. to lntc.ccst p rnpcrty own- a ;id trp.ica! ~e:e::iery_ The- result. I.a crs in impro~ their own bttild ~ I J":J!J.~ !~L -qu! ~ d.ist blctivc,. .tt!..!;5" and: brln.,.--ine 1.hcru into l i ne i:".an::ionlous and !:iouthen Cali-wit.h th e community. It is h oped. !orn;ao. I

~ ;1 ~!0~ :~ ~ !i;oca~li~e - - --- ---- - -- I Uut th e pla..-. will be.nefit the community :more t.h2D: th e iodi,idc.::.!.. Just across the st"eet. trom the

b•.!l..!din;::.; cove.red by tl:!e pl=i.o is UJ.c lk-ucr- B.ous:.IJ; beadquar-..e.-s. S. D . NC$In!th. La Jofm ogcnt for fr.I'.." Na.:1ona.I B ousi...;; adn'l.L"l.isir.ltfou, is. reaCly to an.toge: !or S~parccnt t!naodn1; of the rc.-pa.1.-s. altcratioosl ;md ir.;:'pro7em~u c.:ille'<i tor under the pfa.n. -- - .... .. .. .

Shepherd 's Village Beautification Proposa l

San Diego Union, April 28, 1935

69

By Julia Fleet

N OT long ago, in olden times, tr.nd itself was o status srmbol, an .,J1,·nture \\'o rl lll' of note. The ace ,)f

,1nl uence has destr~yed this inte rprtt:1tinn Ruth and T nm Shepherd Jong h,11 e been virtuosos in the ir inventive appro"ch to tr;1.vel. and are sti ll resolute against the present swell of tour conformity and guidebook dictation. The key to their furmul.1 lies in the Shepherds themselves. They He· orig inal , buorant, and authentic and are en dowed with an indispensable enthusiJsn, coupled with an equal ly indispens,1ble Jiscrimin,1tion, an alertness to the unusual, .1 u.,te fo r the exotic, and an exception.ti rt spons ireness to sight, sound anJ smc:11. Without a goodly portion of these qualit ies , wntinuous traveling can deteriorate into " rep,·· titious and relentless bore. rn11til/ut·d

The world at home T he Thomas Shepherds' excep tional existence abroad ,t11d in La J olla

Le/I, nb?re: In a relatively limited area, Toni Shepherd h.1s created captivating perspecti1·es by artfullr contriving illusions such as this ,tllet. He is an imaginative architect and the design of thew:!IJ;:- wifh its image of cnateau-d1mens1on dept11 leads to a del ightful deception. All the carefu lly rnncci1·cd garden enclosures h,1ve a specific center of interest , some

Jlowing from the :tl lee. some from the house itse lf.

Left: One uf the garden vistas is composed of sucntlents banked under an assemhlagc of antique tiles discovcreJ in th gypsy quarter of Se,·ille. Thcr depict the ancient ,·ersion nf bullfighting When illuminated M night, the individual g.tr· den fantasies are intensely theatrical.

Right: Ruth and Tom Shepherd are profoundly recepti,·e to the art of living in Japa n and return time after lime. The charm of restr.1int and of beauty, concealed in a war that it may be discol'ered ind il'idu:tlly, has g reat appeal to them. Abroad and at home, they never ti re of exper iencing J,ipan . They man·el at the Japanese ahi lity to take the simplest ob· ject, often by necessity. and turn it into a work of pure .trl. The Shepherds are wearing y11k,,1m, a sumrner cotton ki 1n1,no which is supplied upon arri, al at the country inns of Jap.1n to loosen world!)' bindings and induce repose. In th is, one of sever,1! g,1rde11 enclosures at their La Jolla house. ,tre lw!\ stone gritlins from Taormina and 01·erhearl is an ,111cit11t Shur.1ku lantern from northern J"pan. The med.illi"n h.i; .1 relief r,f St. Martins, the patron saint nf cnn,·ivi.tl g.1thcri11.~.,

•

-.,

•

The world at l101ne f 1111//J/l{t .I

. //1 ,, 1p: Ru1h )htpht·rd " 11eori11g vnc of the hrnd.•omc lfor-

11.m, '·"" th.11 ,lie "·" cullc,1ed. In this ,:iblc arrangc111en1, ,hr u,c, lwr ,wn111111,; hrnnr.c dorc c,1nr!c lobra and epergnc. llth,nd the 1.1!-lc ·~ .1n c·ar ly orchitcc tura l persp<:<1i," r,1in1ing . • 1 ,t·1cn11·c11tlq·c111ur) \\11rk mud, in dem;md for l'ilhs <•f th~( pu .. ,J 11,,. ,,;"lJ hirJ, <•n the sideboord arc 'n1a1 tt·m1,lc <.ir11n.~, '"th •ht· 1r,1d,11011al co lored -gloss inserts .

11, ,,,1. ·1 ht ht.tutdull) .lc1.11kd che,1 is from nurthern J l<•n · ,hu (Ul'l'lr l'•ri .,J 1he 1110,n 1sla11d of J~pan) and char,ic\cri<l,c

"' th.n ·""' The. hrrn,,.,. dog was ori1,i11alli o temple In·

,,.,,.., hw,1t·r .111J 1hc hr1111zc h,1ndwarmN on the chtsl 1s frnn, _1.,1'·'" 111< ,ullli)' whrcd Ji,gurc is wi1hcm1 an 1de111iftable ·'!(" 111 .11111t!U") .11,J ,~ l1al1.,,,.c,m cd polychrome s1011c.

I . 11 /, Jr Tht l111d) sr.dlop<:d, gi ldtd wood he:idbn;,rd 11·.15

found 111 the llrc111.1 1.111:11 .1rea near Venice. lndi.1n pnnts ari,

" ·111crcd 11n the lx-..1 Lr/1: Th<.' g,,,ly colored he:idboard ,son .,~,.irt )' '~" \\l11,h 1ht Shc.-pherds sa\\ 1n Brngn. northc.-n1 Por tu_;: .d .,, thq "Jtd1c,I !ht Ox Prixcssion of Feast o ( rite Cross.

Th" Shepherd, wd !IC\I JidJ, "I "'I'"' cncc with nu h.trdt·ncJ .,11,1u,lc, 11r h11hh11.~ plans ;,nd tht·rcbr rc1.11 11 freedom r11 11n1 1ru"1!-C'. ft is .dw.1p, \f<::-ir,1blc: ln d:,t\'H·r .1

sc~nc prc-cw<:r<:xpmure, hur 111.11 1> "" ,11np1L task now. The 1110~, nh,cur(' \ 1f1.1~c.. tir 1, .

Jnnd nl0f11Cll\3rd)' I Ng<:, ,,n I\S (,.,_ ,,.( 111.1

sign and Hilton e:<1.l\.1 li l111 The Shc1,herd, try to (trCUllll (' Ill this /i.1>.1rd hy tll(t:rrns111,~ searches deep " ·11'1,11 the· 11111r<·s 11( ., 1111111 · try, c,cn if the 11h1rt< prcd1Jd<: the h,.~11<',t ll'1·d in hnt and rnld runn,ni; .1mc11111c·,

Abol'c all , Ruth .111d Tom c,d1t" 1h.11 sad ly prc"nlenl s 1.11c 1>( 111111d 1h.11 1r.11c·I " \ral'el 011d horn<: ,, h11111c·, i111111u1.1bl) ,.,,,If, alc:d with clin11!!<.- u( <:n, ironmt.:nt 11n 1hc· 1111c: hand •nd coJoced ,l11k'l> .mJ tl1111mrni.: mt111

uries on the oth,·r. 011 m,111y lei ci/ .111J 111 monr dimen ,nn~. they 1111crl.tcc 1ht1r iflJ"· 1vhich hn1·c lx"'n rx1e11~11c, \\'Hh 1h,·,r L., Jolla existence It " ., ,,·l('C111..-. h111 .di t11clus11·1: blendin_i; Th('ir h11t1,c rs 11111 "'

pc r.son:\ I trc-.1H1rt.'\ rc.-n11ni't<:nc.c·.,; /.1r~c<.· .md sm•I I The) n,•,er he,,r,,tc II h<·n .111 t1n11ulw compels them ro cxpl11re ., d1.111,c lwJe, 111 the-woll shop t11 .t11 unl,kclr lnr('1~11 .ille1 They create in1rigu111~ ,1 11d unu,u.11 d"hc.,. ll'hich h,"e bec-n ,,11J1<:d 111 thr:ir l..11,ht-n a.{tcr experiment, 111 11,,11\ c ,pot, 11 ho, tht· k-ss odven\ll nit" 1111i;h1 h.11 c hl.>11d,,.I 111

dismar. \'{lith (UlllJ'IC:lt Ullf.i<:lt'cc,11,n11u,1tt"'-\ ,

ther ha\(• SlfltJ .,nJ .,d.,,,1,d llllj'rt·""'"'· tus{oms nnd f~'\."'<.·)'i111n, .1unrd111~ 111 rhcir J1:sircs rnJ n<:cr:smic,

TI1c Shc:phrrJ, tr.t\cl, h.11 , h<·tn \\hnlh unp~des tn.1n . fnr 111 no \Lty .ire the·\ 1•r :hur

h(c pcdc,tri.111 .111,I, h) ·'"""·"'""· th<: re spo11ses o( their (ri<:n.l, h.11<: h,u1 ,·11l11rn,·d

71

.. 73

I Photo by John Waggaman

I

wners of homes designed by the late La Jolla architecr Thomas Shepherd glow with their good fortune. To own two in a lifetime is co be doubly

blessed and to live in the architect's own romantic version of an 18th-century Icalian-style home adds a special touch.

A retired couple, who had owned another Shepherd-designed house in the same neighborhood since 1977, were ready to move to a smaller home when the Shepherd estate became available. They were well-suited ro undertake the rehabilitation and restoration of this 1947 La Jolla landmark, which Shepherd had designed for himself before World War II and built after the war. They are to be commended for their sensi tive approach to remodeling the home with the help of Dewhurst &

Associates, a fourth-generation La Jolla builder, and La Jolla landscape architect Todd Fry, ASLA. Without destroying any of its most important attributes they have enhanced the small treasure in a way Shepherd surely would have approved.

Architect for Dewhurst, F.W. Trip Bennett, III, AIA, says of the 1995

-~ J)/~v/#//1.e,,/&zt,~0 ~ws,7/~77

..

74

By Phyllis Van Doren

Photography by

Roland Bishop

•,

..

renovation, 'Tm uneasy taking credit for any of ic because 1t was a Thomas Shepherd house to begin with and the homeowner, an interior designer, did so much ." Her desire was for a simple, warm, rich look that would suit their lifestyle and collection of English antiques.

The owners found a magnificent paneled wall , just the right size, in Chicago to surround the fireplace in the living room. Plaster was used instead of drywall co maintain the integrity of the home . The exterior paint color was carefully masked and retained as is and the existing roof's green-painted barrel tile was painstakingly marched on the new additions for the galley kitchen and the master suite.

"The designer-owner has such a good sense of color," says Donald Dewhurst, the projecc manager, who praises her choices chroughouc the projecc. Excerior and interior light fixtures , including chandeliers, were refurbished by Jim Gibson and retained . The from driveway, which had

f\.bove: dining room has late- l 8th-centt11y

table and chairs: Brnnsclnuig fabric on the

end chairs; I 8th-century French tctpestl')'

belonged to Thomas Shepherd. Opposite

above: guest bed1·00111 f11rnished with vintage

Baker pieces. Finials on bed are from a

Napoleonic traveling bed; valances are

antiques fo1md in England; bed dmsing

and draperies fabricated from patterned

sheets by Sman Hart Henegai: Opposite

below: kitchen features WmOhs cabinets;

b1·eakfast-corner antiques i11cl11de a French

table, Italian chairs aud painted

Scandinavian clock.

deteriorated, was replaced with exposed aggregate to simulate a gravel drive. The tiny kitchen was turned into a butler's pantry with extra appliances for entertaining, china storage and flower-arranging necess1 nes.

One of the biggest uansformations was the loggia, which had lost its original intent and has now been turned into a beautiful Mediterranean-style galley kitchen with cabinetry from WmOhs of Denver. A 1950s sliding glass door was replaced with a colonnade of arched doors facing the courtyard that emulates the original arched door from the living room. This makes the kitchen, with a breakfast cable at one end and sitting area at the other, a sunny, cheerful place to be and enjoy the garden. A motorized awning controls sun exposure during the hottest months.

A loggia on back of house was remodeled into a galley kitchen with new arched doors.

\f/eflhead, a 19th-centmy Italian terra-cotta piece, is 01·igina! to the garden. Opposite:

a pool wc1.s removed and garden 1·estored with new gravel paths.

76

One of the biggest transformati ons

was the loggia, which had lost its

original intent and has now been

Mediterranean-style galley kitc!1en .

New floors of antique French clay rile, recycled from old chateau barns, have been laid in a diamond pattern with wood pickets in living room, dining room, kitchen and terrace. The owners had used chis floor pattern in their first Shepherd house and found ir attractive and easy to care for. It also echoes the diamond-shaped leaded windows chat Shepherd often used in his houses, including this residence.

"Shepherd was a master of proportion," say che homeowners . "It is a very subtle element but che reason why he was able co create such warm 'people ' houses.

"This is a 2,500-sguare-fooc house but char living coom feels grand because of che proportions," Bennett says.

The small garden's basic design has been retained, as has the forced perspeccive viewed from che living room through an arch. "We built cages co protect the eugenia bushes and basically just trimmed and fed

CONTINUED ON PAGE 82

I

78

A U G U S T I 9 9 - 591

I

I I

I

82 5,.-,, Die e,o H OM E /GARDEN LifurJltt

GUARDIANS CONTIN UED FROM PAGE 63

70 ' .,J

them ," says Todd Fry. There were several beauti ful or ig inal garden ornam ents. "We moved som e of the Spani sh and Portug uese til e inse t s around bm we left the 19th-century Italian terra-cotta wellhead alone."

A pool and an unhealthy olive tree were removed, gravel pathways put in and a solid wall cut out tO reveal more of the garden. "We really just simplified ," say the owners.

Shepherd did not cover up his houses wi th landscap ing , so Fry has kept the landscaping low and to t he perimeter as it was on the street side.

1!homas L. ShepherJ. l ~j]-197'9

Thomas Sbe~herd wa cliie most .t1ioli.iic a11ch~ceet wotki~.g in La Jolla from. his arrri aJ: ilil ll926 im thl,

l1s death OlilJ Dec mbe11 8, ]91 :Hl!is iadie wife R\}th cemem~ coum :in,g '.L 03 houses by 1: 947 a 1!Wice ttka1r rn,any bi)( hJ deatra. 'l appe81h of many of ufue meigab :bioo4Si .l!ike 't!he Ji3arber T!iact, :I!-0 , H erm0sa, l!.a: J oJlla S.aQ:1res and Muit lands has t!@ d'o with t<m.e Jioltla E00k'' uhat hti! cteatem wi blJ!ild · n,gs.

I I I

The addition of an axial path from the street is a nice improvement.

"We are very happy with remodel and working with Dewhurst. The quality of the craftspeople is superb, " the owners say. "Shepherd was very proud of his house and, especially, the garden. He brought us here when we consulted with him about the remodel of our previous house . His house was very special to the neighborhood, coo, and from the street we haven 't changed its look at all . We felt chis was very important."

Known for his warm, iGl'y'Ji1ieai.ld.o/, stful homes, he had g;e~ eme @f oportion and loved C©l!Wty.a,ncls a,m.d

rdens. His style ir elegant aruil das' based on historical o~tion. ffe mbined details from S;pain, lt!a<l'}f. ance and England like the smiallJI amond-shaped leaded windows at graced so many of the designs ~1---..,...:..--......-~ th tiled roofs and interior arches.

native of Wisconsin, he studied hitecture at Columbia University, erned for a short time with orge Washington Smith in Santa rbara, stopped off in Pasadena efly, then moved to La Jolla for

rest of his life. The original ine Room for the La Jolla Beach

fennis Club and rhe 1940 remodf the Darlington House bear his ature. He referred to a Spanish de built at 111 7 Wall Street in olla in 1933 as his "calling

om the tiniest cottage in the er Tract to the mansions on the his homes are still eminently, le and s0 much a part of the

iJ©lll past - and present - of :111:ai .•

80 ,,

81

Thomas L. Shepherd -Table of Residence

Source: City of San Diego Directory

I Date II Residence Address 11

Extant I 1927 Not Listed -

1928 1292 Prospect, La Jolla, CA No

1929-1931 6130 La Jolla Blvd., La Jolla Yes

1931-1942 7847 Exchange Place, La Jolla Yes

1943-1979 (DOD-Thomas 345 Via del Norte Yes

Shepherd) Subject Property

1986 (DOD) Ruth Shepherd

345 Via Del Norte, La Jolla, CA 92037

Documents

Transcript of 345 Via Del Norte, La Jolla, CA 92037