POCcmiCKASI AKA]lEMIDI HAYK

BonpoCLI AUG 311993

<l>HJIOCO<l>HH HAY'lHO.TEOPETH'IECKHH )KYPHAJI 1993

H3METOI C HIOJISl1947 rOJJ:A BLDWJJ:HT EJKEMEOI'IHO

HHCTHTYT~HROCO~HHPAH

t'tKtOOtrAS ROCM IJ7 sutter UbrarY OolumbiB UnNersitY

C 0 .u E P )K A H H'E ~•• Vnrk M 'I 1M!'

fIOCTMOACPHH3M H KyJIhTypa (MaTcpHam,I "KpyrJIOro CTOJIa"). BhICTYIIHJIH:

O.B. BaHHIIITcHH, B.I1. HOBHKoB, B.A. fIoAopora, n.B. KapaccB 3 H.C. ABTouoMoBa ­ B03Bpamallch K a3aM 17 E.r. Tpy6Hua - fIOCITOTaJIHTapHall KyJIhTYpa: "BCC A03BOJICHO" HJIH "HHqCrO HC

rapaHTHpoBaHo"? 23 B. rpOHC - Aa, aIIOKaJIHIICHC, Aa, CCHqaC 28 M.Jf. Cy660THU - TCOPHll H IIpaKTHKa HCJIHHCHHOro IIHChMa 36 3. };aYMau ­ «1lHJIOCO¢Hll H IIOCTMOAcpHHCTcKall COqHOJIOrHll 46

C1'HJIOCOeJlHH, pCJIHrHH, 06m;CCTBO

B.B. Payrncu6ax - nOrHKa TPOHqHOCTH 62 H. Ro6KOBHI( - XpHCTHaHCTBo H KYJIhTYpa 71

~HJlOCOeJlHH HuayKa

M.r. SlpOWCBCKHH - fICpC)I(HBaHHC H ApaMa pa3BHTHll JIH'IHOCTH (IIOCJICAHCC

CJIOBO n.c. BhlroTCKOro) 82

C1'HJIOCoeJlHH 3a py6C:lKOM

IO.H. CTeeJlauoB - "Hc 3a6JIYAHTbCll IIO nyTH B llIaM6aJIy" 92 P. reDOU - IJ;aph MHpa 97 B.R. MaUHU - EaxTHH H 3aIIaA (oKOHqaHHc) 134 H.C. nJlOTUHKOB - HOBoc HCCJICAOBaHHC 0 rCrCJIbllHCTBC 151

MOCKBA • ~YI(,b • 1993

2

KPlffHK8 H6HWtHOrpact»HJI

C.H. IIyIUKHD, JI.E. manOIUDHKOB - A.A. KoponhKoB. npOpO'IeCTBa KOHcraHTHHa JIeoHTheBa; A.<l>. CHBaK. KOHcraHTHH JIeoHTheB

'B.C. mBl.lpCB ­ X. CKonHMORCKH. TaHl\YIOJ..WfH lUHBa B 3KOnOrH'IeCKHH BeK . .

155 157

Harrrn aBTophl . 160

CONTENTS

POSTMODERNISM AND CULTURE (a round-table discussion). N.S. AVTONO­AMOVA. Return to sources. E.G. TRUBINA. Posuotalilarian cullure. B~ GROYS. Yes.

Ap0s:aIypse. eys, now. M.M. SUBBOTIN. Theory and practice of non-linear writing. Z.'BAuMAN. Philosophy and postmodernist sociology. B.V. RAUSCHENBACH.

. Logic of triplicily'. N. LOBKOVITZ. Christianity and cullure. M.G. JAROSCHEVSKY. Experienee and drama of the development of person (the last word of L.S. Vygotsky). R. GUENON. King of the World. V.L. MAHLIN. Bakhtin and the West. BOOK REVIEWS.

PE.uAKI~llOHHMI KOJIJIEfIDI

B.A. JICKTOPCKHK (rJIaDIILIK pCl\aKTop), LC. Apc¢JLcBa, A.ll. BOJIOI\HII, n.n. faKI\CIIKO,

Ii.T. fpHrOpI.HU, B.n. 3HII'ICUKO, A.t!». 301JB, B.K. KauTop, B.)I{. KCJIJIc,

JI.H. MHTPOXHU, H.H. MOHCCCB, H.B. MOTPOIIlHJIOBa, B.ll. MYl\parcii (3aMCCTHTCl1L

rl1an1l0rO pcp;aKTopa), A.n. OrypI,oB, T.ll. OiilcpMau, • -I. npYlKHIIHII (oTncTcTBcIIIILIH

cCKpcTaph). B.A. CMHpIlOB, B.C. CTCIIHU, B.C. WHhlpCB

nOCTM(

MaT

Or pej\llJll(HH. Bonpoe 0 !f>eHoMe MLIX BCOOpeMCIIHOii 3anBl\II0ii IIHTCf Oh!3BBBillHC ern K lKH311H, B 'leM COC1 TeMoii "Kpyrllorn crOlla", npoBoAHBU nOKa3allO BKTyallbllocTh TeMhI, OCol ryBl\HH HIIBcrOllTCllhHYIO IIc(,l6xoAHI

O.E. BAI1HIIITEI1H (Kall(

pamypbl lLW. A.M. TOPbK020 P.

OJOBO "nocTMop;CPIIWIM"

OpHrHUal1LUOcTH B lIamcK KpH

~HK, 1101\ BLIBCCKOK 1I0CTMOP;C

CTHXH. 110 H nC'lL 611HIILI, 1I0C

CCOpHTLClI, a TaKJKC la'lHC11l1Tl

Hl nalITCOlla MHpOBOK KYl1hTYf

AnrycTHII. Ol\lIaKO, IICCMOT:

TCpMHUa. caMO nOllllTHC lIapa

IILIM H IICOIlPCI\Cl1CIIIILIM. B IIHJKOIICKOC, lana)\lrn'lCCKOC, r:

TCXIIH'lCCKHii pCAaKTOp H.B. K a pall 11 a ill 0 0 a

Olano 0 na60p 25.12.92 ITOAIIHcallO KnC'laTH 1.02.93 4>OpMBT 6YMBrH 70xloo 1/16

orpCCTlIali nC'laTb YCJl.nC·I.II. 13,0 YCJI.Kp.-OTT. 29'2,4 Th!C. Y'l_-H31\.1I. 17,3 GYM.II.5,0

THpIDK 22 090 3K3. 3aKa3 4020 l~clla 12 py6.

AAPCC pCAaKl\HH: 121002, MOCKoa, [-2, CMOIICIICKHii 6yllboap, 20. TCIICrpOIl 201-56-86

MOCKODCKajj T11norparpHli N. 2130 "IIaYKa"; 121009, MocKoa, [-99,llIy6HllcKHii ncp., 6

© «Bonpocbl rpHllocorpHH», 1993 r.

1I0llLITKC BLICTPOHTL 110rH'lllbo

IILIC Hl1l1IOCTP~HH BJ\Pyr 061l

IIHlM qmrypHpycT KaK l1CCTllbo

llla'lallWK lIpl1LIK. paCC'lHTa:

BOCllpHliTHC.

AM6HBa11CHTIIOCTb 6yKBa11l

Hl1H "1I0Cl1C MOI\CpIlHlMa" I\or:

IIhl, 11 OCTMOP;CPIIHlM - nOCTC()

1I0CTL lIarncro ncpeJKHBaIIHlI

cc611 KaK concpmcullo oco6yl­

I\YCTpHaJILIIOrO o6u-\ccrua J].. : CTpYKTypal1HlMa B ryMallHTa

nOCTMOJ\CPIIHlMOM 1I0llHMaCT

l1CTHK, BCli cyMMa Kyl1bTyplIL

BPCMCIllIOCru" BCI\CTCII IIpH6_

Typhl H BOlIIHKlIOBCIIHlI IIOCT'

C p;pyroK CTOpOIILI. caM

OllpCI\Cl1ellllOC COOTIIOIIICIIHC:

BallHlI. ECl1H BlllTh, K npHM:

HMCIIIIO YCHl1HlIMH J].. J{JKOKC;

I

r/>HJIOCOr/>HH H HAYKA .

,;

llepe}J{HBaHHe H ApaMa pa3BltTHR

JDI'IHOCTH

(nOCJ1e]J,Hee CJ10BO JI.e. BbiroTcKoro)

M.f. SlPOmEBCKMH

JI.c. BblrOTCKHii 6bIJI Bbl/lalOIl.\Hiicli rCIIcpaTOp np0611CM. HMellllO aTO 06CTOllTellbCTBO

npH/laCT erO'TCKCTaM UC TOllbKO PClIHKTOBblK xapaKTCp.

CHMClleM BbirOTCKoro aCCOI\HHpYIOTCli rllaBllblM 06pa30M TaKHe TCMbl, KaK "pa3BIlTHe

BbiCurnX nCHXH'IeCKHX cj>YHKI\Hii" , "MbIUIlICHHe H PC'Ib". OTCIO/la H npHHlIToe B MHpOBOii

lIHTepaType npCACTaBlIellHe 0 lIeM KaK OTBaJKUOM HCCllC/lOBaTClIC KorHHTHBHblX npOI\Cc­

COB. H3BeCl'IIblii aMCpHKaIICKHii, yqCHblii AJK. Epyucp H 70-x rO/lax CBH/lCTClIbCTBOBall:

"'KaX<JlbIii UCHX01l0r, KOTOpblii 3aIIHM31ICli B MHUyBlllylO '1CTBCPTb BCKa n03HaBaTClIbHhlMH

npOI\CCCaMH H ·HX pa3HHTHCM, /lOllJKCH npH3HaTb TO 601lbUIOC HlIHlIIIHe, KOTOpOC OKa3allH

na Hcro·orpY/lhi JIbBa CCMCIIOBH'Ia BI,lrOTCKoro"l.

MCJKIlY TCM KOHC'IIIOii TO'lKOii ero HCKaUHK clIyJK!-1110 /lPCHIICC, 110 06pCTUICC B ClIOJKllhiX

nOHopOTax aTHX HCKallHii 1I0BblA CMblClI 1I0HlITHC 0 nCpCJKHBaHHH. OHO COnpllra1l0Cb C

KaTcropHeii ·lIH'IUOCTH, KOTopall, COOTBCTC'CBCIIIIO MCTOj(01l0rH'ICCKOii nO/lnO'lBC HCClIC/lO­

BallHH BbJrOTCKorO,MblClIHlIaCb B KOOp/lHUaTaX CHCTCMUOCTH, pa3BHTHlI, /lCTCpMHHH3Ma.

3'rIf.o6'hliCUIlTClIbllbIC npHIII\HUbl, KaK H3BCCTHO, IlMCIOT CJIOJKuylO "6Horpacj>HIO", npe06­

Pa3YllOh B CMcne HCTOpH'ICCKHXanox.,

. TIpeo6pa30BallHlI, COTplicaBUIHC B nepBoii '1CTBCpTH lIaUIcro CTOllCTllli neCb cj>pOHT 2

Hay'IUhlx 311aIIHK 0 '1ClIOBCKC , 06yClIOBHlIH 00311HKIIOOCIIHC Y BblrOTCKoro 3aMblClIa nOCT­

POCIIHlI nCHXOJIOrHH B TCpMHllaX IIpaMbl. 31'01' 3aMblCell ClIOJKHlICli ua o/lHoii H3 pa3BHlIOK

cronYTHi

B rO/lbl CTYACu'IccTBa OIl, 06yq3llCb lIa IOpHIIH'IeCKOM cj>aKyllbTCTC, npocj>eccHOnallbllO

3anHMlUICli lIHTepaTyplloii KpHTHKOH, B Ayxe HMnpeccHoHHcTcKoro HanpaBlIenHlI. Ero

yqHTellcM 6bl1l 1O.A. AiixeuoallbA, BblClIallHblH B 1922 r. no H30eCTnOMY, canKI\HOHH­

pOOaIIHOMy nOllHT6IOpO, cnHCKY. 3aUliTHli KpHTHKOK CO'lCTallHCb C H3yqenHcM cj>HlIOCOcj>HH

1 . ., Ep'yJlep )lx. nCHXOJlOrHlI nOJllallHlI. M., 1977. C. 9.

2 HanoMll1O lIaH60Jlcc BJlHlITCJlblfblC KOMI1JICKCbl HAcll, H3MCIIHBWHX B TOT ncpHoA OOJ1HK nCHXOJlOrHH:

lI>ellOMCIIOJIOrHlI ryCCCpJlll, HIITYHTHOH3M Ecprcolla, nCHXOallaJIH3 ~peHAa-AAJlCpa,rCWTaJIbT-nCHXOJlO­

~, nC~lIaJIH3MlUTcplla, 6HXCOHOpH3M, COIVt0nCHXOJlOrH'lCCKOC lIanpaBJICIIHC 00 ~paIlQHH OKallc HAP.),

KYiIbTyp<>JJohlll ]J.HJlbTClI, pyCCKali pe<PJlCKCOJIOrHlI. Bbll'OTCKHH <PoPMHpoOaJICli 0 nOJlCMHKC co oceMH 3THMH

lIanpaoJicIIHlIMH.6e3 KoropblX IIC BOOIIHKJlH 61.1 cra 1I00aTopcKHe KOIIQcnIVtH. 'lYlKOC CJI080, npeJlOMJllIliCb B

cra TBOP'ICCKOM C0311allKK, n0300JlllJlO OTKPJ,(Tb 1I0BbiC IlpOOJlCMJ,(, lIanpaBJllIli lIa nOKcK cOOCTOCllllblX

peWCIIK'H. BbiroTcKKil 6blJl BblAalOlIlKHClI MacTcp AKaJIOra (110 IIC K3OOJ1K'lCIIKlI 3anaAllblX KOIIQcnQHH KaK

"aIlTHMBpKCKCTCKHX", 'KaK Tora Tpc60BaJIa HACOJIOrH'lCCKali KIIKOK3HQKlI). OnnOIiCIITllblil Kpyr, B KOTOpoM

po~a.iiilcb H npcOOpa300bIBaJIHCb cro HIICH, IIcOObl'lailllO WKpoK. CKOJlbKO-IIH6YAb paolloro IIC 6blJl0 IIH Y

0AlIoro H3 COOCTCKKX nCKXOJloroO. 06 onnOllCIlTIIOM Kpyrc KaK <PaKTOpe TBOp'lCCTBa CM. 101010 CTaTblO

"OnIlOIlCIITIIJ,(H Kpyr K lIay'lIlOC OTKPhITKC" (Bonpochl <PKJI<X:Olf>KK, 1983. N. 10).

~~~~ pyKOnHCCK nepBOK3na'lHTCli "Tparel\Hs

'TaMJICTOM" 011 ywClI B 601lbllJl'{lIblA CaBaTI

B TOT nepHOA OU TpaKTOB31I XYAOJKeC

KaJKAOH OTAellLHOA Aywe "nOTpllCCUHoe OU

CTBOBlIBHll B "3AeumcM MHpe".

lloC1lc peBOlllOI\HH, B HOBOH COIl,HoKym

CKOrO. CTaBWCrO B fOMelle Y'lHTClICM B

CABHr. Ou CTlIBOBHTCli CTOpOHUHKOM eCTCC'

UOH JKH3IIH.

Tenepb cro ¥'IHTellb He AJl:xeuBanbA.

BHHMlIBHe ue TOllbKO cj>H3H01l0rOB, HO H Be(

napTHH - TpOI\KOro. EyxapHua) KUHn

UCPOUOH AeliTenbHOCTH (noBeAeHHlI) JKHBOT

BbirOTCKHii3aAyMbIBaeTCli 1Ia11 npOCKT(

B eAHllYIO 06'beKTHBuylO lIayKy 0 '1e1l0BcKt

ua'lalle 1924 r. B lleTporpaA Ha Bcep

BbIrOTCKOro CBHAeTellbCTuyeT, 'ITO yJKe B

cy6'beKTHBHbIM MeTO/lOM nCHX01l0rHIO "CB

BH/lell Yll30HMblC nYUKTbl pecj>lIeKC01l0rHH.

31'0 H n06YAHlIO ero - 6C30CCTnoro M'

fOMeJIli - 060HIIHTb ua cj>OpyMc, C06paBil

BClIHKOrO CTapI\a H.ll. IIaBJIOBa B AyanH:

npeJKucii lIayKoH 0 BblCUIHX lKH3neUUhlX cj>:

"B CYII\IIQCTH AyanH3M, - yrneplKAan B

3pCUHll llaB1l0Ba H EexTepeoa"4. 3a KOUT 5

CTapHullhlii AyanH3M Ayum H Tella . QT06b1 H36aBHTbcli 01' nero, BblroTCKHI

UeHpO/lHUaMH'IccKYIO CTpyKTypy npH3naK

COI\HOKYRbTypnYlo ccj>epy '1cnOBC'ICCKOii :

MOMCHTa np06yJKAenHlI B HeM n03HaBaTeJl

BBOAHT nOUliTHc 0 pe'lCOOM pecj>neKce. HI

pecj>lIeKca OpraIIH3M, C03UaIIHC, 06I1.\eUH~

31'01' HHTerpan CTan apXeTHnOM BOOX Il

np06ncMIIbix nonliX OHa HH npO/lBHranaCb

'1eCKHJl: KOMnOHeHT. BblrOTcKHH 060311

,"HMeuHO cnOC06I1l.CTb pecj>neKca (nepcJK:

MeTOM nCpCJKHOaIlHlI) - aTOT McxaUH31 "Epecj>nCKCOO H3 oAnoA CHCTeMbl B APyrYlo

KaK peI\CnI\HH CHrnalla (Ce'lCUOB, IIaollo

KapTLI. npHMcurnOali K nOrH'ICCKH rOMore

"npHUIClIbI\CH" H~ COOCpUICUUO Apyroro

06'bllCUHTCnbHblx ua'lan.

TeM uc Mcuce TepMHU "ncpClKHBallHC'

UO-:lK3HcTeUI\HallbUblii cMblcn, npH06pe

3 CoXpallHJlKCh CBCIlCIIHlI, 'ITO B IOIIOCTH 011

IIKX POJlh raJolJlCTa (CBHACTCJlhCTBO C.4>. L{OOKIt

aBTOpy 3THX CTpOK).

4 BblzomcKuu Jl.C. Coop. CO'l. T. I. M., 19E 5 Y'lCHHC naBJlOBa OTKphlTHCM 1I0BbiX ACTCE

MOTHBaQKollllhlH <PaKTOp HAP.) paAKKaJIhllO Me

IIYTblMK TPBJ:\HQHOIIHhIC npCACTaOJlCIIHlI 0 C0311111

KOTOphlA CIlM naBJlOB peWHTCJlbHO OTpHQaJI. B "Korna ABBJ:\QaTKJlCTllilH onhlT CTallCT TpHAQan

UHT. CO'l. C. 56). TaK 0110 H npoH30WJlO. naBJI

ropax 1I00CACIIHlI lIa ypoOIIC 'leJlOBCKa.

6 BblzomcKuu II.C. Co6p. CO'l. T. I. C 50.

TercJlSI H CnHU03bI. CpCAH 06'bCKTOB pa60TbI ero <j>HJlOCO<j>CKo-auan:HTH'ICCJ(C'I"O ;Y'" BbIACJlSlJlCSI TeaTP APaMbI. QCPC3 BCIO lKH3nb OH npOHec WCKcnHpoB "faMJICT"3. Bllepe'lBe

ero PYKOnHceH ncpBOH3Ua'lHTCSI "TparcAHSI 0 faMJlCTe. up~c AaTCKOM" Y. IDOKCDIIp&. C "faMJlCTOM" OH ywCJI B 60JlbHHqublll: CaHaTopHll: B Cepe6pS1HOM 60py, OTKYA&tBe 8epaynC:1I.

B TOT ncpHOA OU TpaKTOBaJI XYAOlltCCTBCHHbIll: TCKCT KaK CHMBOJl, BLl'3b1BIUO~A.8

KaJKAOH OTACJlbHOll: AYWC "noTpSlceHHOC O~ymCUHC" HCB3GbwBoro TParH3Ma CBOerO c:y:tQe­CTBOBaHHSI B "3AClWfCM Mape".

IloCJIc PCBOJlIOl\HH. B HOBOll: C01'HOKyJlbTypUoll: aTMoc<j>cpe. B MHpOB033peBHIl BI.JrOT. cKoro, cTaswcro B fOMeJlC Y'lHTCJlCM B COJlCTCKOll: WKOJlC, npOH30wcn pal'HKaJIlaBLi.

cABHI'. OH CTaHOBHTCSI CTOpOIlHHKOM CCTCCTBeHHollayqlloro aBaJIH3a JlH'lBOCTH H ee JG'Zoa· HOll: lItH31IH. .

Tcncpb cro )"IHTCJlb UC All:xCUBaJIbA, a M.Il. IlasJlOB. Ilo UpHKoBasweA B 1923 r. BIIHMaHHC He TOJlbKO <j>H'JHOJlOrOB, HO H BCCll: MbICJlJlll\Cll: POCCHH (B TOM 'IHCJlC B 'HI'COJIOl'Oll

napTHH - Tpo~Koro, EyxapHHa) KHHrc "nBaAl\aTHJlCTHBll: OULIT B3yqCBBli RLicmel

ncpBUOH ACSlTCJlbHOCTH (nOBCACHHSI) lItHBOTUbIX" OH ycnclWfo npowcJI UaBJIOBCX)'lO mlCony.

BbIrOTCKHH3aAYMbIBaCTCSI UM npoeKTOM 06'bCAHHeHHSI UCHXOJlOrHH Hpe<j>JlekCOJlOnHI

B CAHUyIO 06'bCKTHBHyIO uayKy 0 '1CJlOBCKC. BoopylltCIllIbIll: 3THM upOCKTOM, OB upaex&JI R

Ha'laJlC 1924 r. B IlcTporpaA Ha BccpoccHll:cKHll: C'bC3A UCHXOHCBpOJlOroB• .z:tOJtJl!l~ BbIrOTCKOro CBHACTCJlbCTByCT, 'ITO ylltc B CBOHX UCpBbIX UOULlTKax BJlHTI. B OTp8BJIcSBB)'IO

cy6'bCKTHBnblM MCTOAOM nCHXOJlOrHIO "CBe'lIt)'IO KpOBI." eCTCCTBeHHona)"IHoro 3UllRliK. DB BHACJI YSl3BHMI.IC n)'IIKTbI pe<j>JlCKCOJlOrHH. M3 KaPTHUbI nOBeACIIHSI B3blMaJIOCI. C030aDe. 3TO H n06YAHJIO cro - 6C3BccTuoro MOJloAoro "npOCBC~CHl\a" H3 UPOBHHQtI&JIIoBOrO

fOMCJISI - OGBHUHTb lIa <j>OpyMC, coGpanwcM CO BCCH POCCHH HCCJleAOBaTCJlcA 1l0Rel'enll,

BeJIHKOrO CTapl\a M.Il. IlaBJIoBa B AYaJIH3MC - rpexc, KOTOpblH caM naBJIOR '1HcnRJI :sa beTBO npelltHCH uayKoH 0 BblCWHX lItH3UCHUI.lX <j>YUK~SlX.

"B CYU~U9CTH AYaJIH1M, - yTBeplltAaJI BI.lroTCKHll:, - H CCTI. HacTo~ee BMlI not TO'IXe

DlTHC 3pCHHSI IlaBJIoBa H ECXTcpCBa"4. 3a KOHTypaMH UOBOH KapTHUbI nOBcAcUIDI UpoCOe'lBBlUI

10BOll: CTapHUUblH AYaJIH3M AY1WI H TCJla5. .. . D~CC­ QT06b1 H36aBHTbCSI OT ucro, BbirOTCKHH npe06pa3ycT nOUSITHC 0 pe<j>JICKce, RBac.Bcro DBaJl: ncilpOAHHaMB'IecKylO CTpyKTypy npH3HaKH, UCBCAOMbiC <j>H3HOJlOrHH. OHH UpeACTlJIJIlInB 11.1MB CO~OKYJlI.TypUYIO c<j>cpy '1eJIOBC'ICCKOA lKH3HH, K KOTOpOH BbIrOTCKHA 6L1J1 IlplrltQRlUlC 13aJlH MOMCHTa np06ylltACUHSI B HCM n03HasaTeJlbUbIX HUTepeCOB, a HMCUUO - CJlOBO, pe'lb. OR

BBOAHT nOliliTHU 0 pC'ICBOM pc<j>JlCKCe, HUTerpHpyli B l\CJIOCTHOCTb UOA HMeueM pe'leBOro

KUblX pe<j>JIeKCa Opral1H3M, C03UalIHC. 06~eUHC H KyJIbTypy. ,

:lCb C 3TOT HHTCrpaJl CTaJI apXCTHnOM BceX nOCJICAYIO~X ABHlItCHHll: cro MLlCJIR, R Kanx 681 ~CAO­ np06JICMUblX nOJlllX oua Hfi npOABHraJIacL. B "TCJIC" pC'ICBOrO pe<j>JICKCa 3aJ10llteU IlCHxw"

I3Ma. qeCKHH KOMnOHCHT. BblroTcKHll: 0603Ua'laCT cro ApCBUHM CJlOBOM "nepelitHBaBlie".

>e06- "HMeuuo cnoc06U('CTL pc<j>JICKCa (ncpClKHBaIlHlI npcAMcTa) 6bITI. pa3ApallCHTeJleM (ape/{­MCTOM nCpClItHBaIJHlI) - 3TOT McxaUH3M C03UaTCJII.UOCTH H CCTb MCXaBH3M. ncpeAa'IH

pOHT pe<j>JIeKCOB H3 OAUOH CHCTCMbI B APyrYI0,,6. TpaKToBKa a<j><j>cpeUTllOrO 3BeHa peclmeKca He IIOCT­ KaK pCl\cnl\HH CHrUaJIa (Ce'lCUOB, IlaBJIoB). a KaK "ncpelKHBallHlI npCAMCTa", n)'Tan:a.~

KJlOK KapTbI, npHMCUIHBali K JlOrH'IeCKH rOMorCIIIIOMY cnoc06y KaY3aJII.UOrO aHaJIH3a UOBeXCHBlI

"npHWCJlI.l\CU" H~ COBepwcuuo Apyroro pllAa. JlHWCIiHOro npHBbI'IHbiX AJIli HaTyp~c1'll

JlbHO 06'bllCUHTCJlLUbiX lIa'laJI.

Ero TCM lie Mcuec TepMaIl "ncpelKHBaIlHC", ueCUIHH B rOAbi IOUOCTH BbIrOTCKoro JIH'lH0eT­OHH­ UO-3K3HcTcul\HaJlLUbIH CMblCJI, npH06pCTaJl AJllI ucro OTIlI.IHC "HMHAlIt" HBTerpaJILBol

I<j>HH

3 CoxpallHnHcb CBeAellHJI, 'ITO B IOIIOCTH OH CTaBHn nlO6HTenbCKHe CneKTaKnH, HCDOJlHA.I • OAHQ¥ 113

IIHX ponb faMneTa (CBHAeTenbCTBO c.eI>. ,U06KHHa, Apyra IOIIOCTH BblrOTcKoro, B HIITepBblO, .all_ Jd; ll'HH: aBTOpy 3THX CTpoK). .

0.110­ 4 BblzomcKuu 1I.C. Co6p. co'!. T. 1. M., 1982. C 57. lAp.). 5 Y'IeUMe TIaBnoBa OTKpblTHeM 1I0BbiX AeTepMHHal1T nOBeAellHlI (ycnoBUblA CHnIBJI, nOAKpelUleHIIC DIe rHMH

MOTHBaI<IIOllllblii <t>aKTop H lip.) paAHKBJlbUO MeHlIno KaTeropHlo oprauH3Ma. Ho OHO OCTIlBJIllJlO IRI-rpo:.IJiCb B

UYTblMH TPllJlMI<HOllllble npeACTaBnellMJI 0 C03uaUHH cy6"bCKTa, ero BIIYTpellHeM MICpCl. OTClOlla _ AYBJIII:Dl,IHblX

KOTOpblii caM TIaBnoB pewHTenbHo OTpHI<aJI. B TOM lKe neTporpllJlCKOM AOIOlBl\e BblI'OTCKHI npeApeW:4 KaK

"Koma ABaAI<aTHneTllilii onblT CTaHeT TpHl\I<aTMneTIIHM. nonolKeuHe Aena H3MeIlHTClI" (BwromClCwJJ.C:lpoM

UIIT. CO'l. C 56). TaK OHO II npOH30wno. TIaanoB BblABHHyn rHnOTe3Y 0 "BTOPbIX CHnIBJlaX" KaKperynit. HM Y Topax 1I0BeAeHMJI lIa ypoBHe '1enOBeKa. TblO

6 BbllomcKuu Jl.C. Co6p. CO'l. T. 1. C. 50.

'1aCTH cyry60 TCJICCHOrO aKTa - pCq,JICKCa. B TO )l(C BpeMll 3TOT TCpMHH OKa3L1BaJIClf C nOHllTUCM 0 3HaKC, npOHH3hIHaJI BCIO H:

KpaflHC pa3MLlTLlM, nOCKOJIhKY OXBaTLlBaJI Bee COIICP)l(aHHC C03HalIUll. H3 06JIaCTH TCOpCTH'lCCKHX H3hlcKallHJ;

o HCM MO)l(HO 6hlJI0 tiLl CKaJaTh HC'ITO nOll06HOC CKaJaHHOMy BLlrOTCKHM no nOBollY CMhlCJI nCHXOJIOrH'lCCKOrO KpH3Hca") S­

nonllTUll 0 pCq,JICKCC7 . PC'll, nlJIa (no H. rc6cmo) 06 0IlHOM HCMC~KOM pCMccncHHBKC, . npCIICTaBJIliJIa lIanpaBJICHHC, KOTOpOMY

Y::JIhlUlaBrnCM B rOJIJIallllHH n OTBeT lIa Bee CBOH BonpOCLI: "qcA 3TO 110M? KTO npHCXaJI? H ' , , IICHXOlIorHH". C JICrKOH pyKH cro nOCJIo

T.II." 0IlHH H TOT )l(C OTBCT: "KaHIIBTq,cplIJTau". OH peillBJI, 'ITO nec B crpaHC conepwaCTCll BapliX H T.n.) Ha3WBaJOT KyJIhTypHO-BCTC

0IlIIHM '1CJIODCKOM, Torlla KaK CJIODO npoCTO 0311a'laJIO, 'ITO cro HC nOHHMaIOT. 060 neCM aYTL B npCIIMCTHWA yxaJaTCJIh K cro cc

rOOopHTh "3TO peq,JICI;C" HJIH "3TO ncpe)l(KBalIBC" - 3Ha'lHT 06CCCMLICJIHBaTh TCpMBH. anTop HH p:uy HC npHMCHHJI 3TO 0603H

TIOHIITHC 0 nepC)I(HBallHH MOrJIO npH06pccTH 3BPHCTH'ICCKYIO HarpY3KY TOJIhKO B MHO­ PCaJIB30Banaoro IlIKOJIOK BhlrOTCKoro

rOnJIaHOBOi CHCTCMC IIpyrHx Hay'lnLlx KaTcropuA (B TOM '1HCJIC nOHllTBll 0 "l\paMC KyJIhTyp Ha nCHXOIIOrH'lCCKYIO opraHU~

pa3BHTHll", CM. HH)I(C). B lIallllLlA ncpHolI TBOp'lCCTBa BwoTCKoro 3TO cmc HC npOH30mJIo. aHK). CTaJIUHCl'alI nOJIHTHKa HHBCJIUp·

Ero MLlCJIh npollCJIaJIa orpoMHylO pa60Ty no OCBOCHHIO nCHXH'ICCKOrO MBpa '1CJIOBCKa, MaCKOH He3yHTCKOH q,OpMyJIW 0 elllIao:

npc)I(l\c '1CM TCpMHH "nCpC)l(HBallHC" CTan cc 3aBCpWalO~M aKKoPlloM. l-13l1arllll CBOH uaKJIal\hlBalla BCTO aa 3TY np06JICMY·

npOCKT CJIHllHHll nCHXOlIorHH (npCIICTaBJICHlIoA TCpMHHOM "ncpe)l(HBaHHC") C peq,JICKCOJIO­ H3MCHcaHll B nCHXHKC y:l6CKOB B ycnoBl

rncA, BLlroTcKHA cmc IIH'ICrO IIC CKa3aJI 0 MapKCH3Mc8 . OH BncpBLlc 06paTBJIcli K HCMY B KaK nOIlHTH'lCCKH BpellHalI.

CBJl3H C nonhlTKoH 3aMClIHTh 1I0HlITBC 0 pCq,IICKCC HOBOA CTpyxTypHOA CI\HHH~cA nOBcllc­ Bo Beex OI\CHKax H HHTcpnpeT8I\HlIX

HUll - pe~cA9 • TIPH 3TOM HMCJICII B BHllY oc06L1A TBII pCaKnHH - PCaKnHlI cy6"heKTa

Ha TBOpeHHC HCKyCCTBa.

B pa60Tax r.B. TIJIcxallona BwroTCKuA HamCJI IIPCIICTaBlICnUC, cornacuo KOTOPOMY B

ocnOBC HCKyccTBa JIC)I(HT "lIa'laJIo aIlTuTc3W". 3TO "Ha'laJIO" CTaJIO IlJIll BhlroTcKoro

JIHBO ycMaTpUB;l.CTCll B OTKpWTHH, 6JIBrC

, XHKlI, COI\HOKYJIhTYPHhlX q,aKTopOB paJE

HC3C. MC)I(AY TCM HapliAY C 3TOA JIHHHI

llHoncpcKoe 3Ha'lCIIHC KOTOpoA HC YCTYI

OpUCIITBpOM IIpH pa60Tc H~ IIHccepTa~HcH "nCUXollornll HCKyccrna" (1925), rllc, COOTIICCli

TpH plilla llBJICIIHii: CO~HOKYJIhTYPHhlA (CCMHOTH'ICCKHJl), IIciip06HOJIOrH'ICCKHH H IICHXOJIO­

rn'lCCKHH, 011 1I0Ka3hIBaJI, 'ITO H30MOpq,IIh1C OTlIomCIIHll MC)I(IIY IIHMH 1I0p0)l(,laIOT ~CJIO­

CTllylO 3CTCTH'ICCKylO pCaKI\HIO. CTOIlKIIOBCfiHC IIpOTHBOnOIlO)l(lIhlX 'lyBCTB HIIH, COfllaCHO

HCOJIOrn3MY BhlrOTCKoro, IIpOTHBO'lynCTBHC.

KOllJIH3HH 3CTeTH"CCKOH pCaKI\HH Dhlpa)l(alOT BHyTpellllHH IIpaMaTH3M, TaK KaK PC'll,

HIICT 0 IICPC)I(HBaHHllX JIH'IUOCTH, 0611\alOmCKCli C 1I03TH'ICCKHM TCKCTOM, a HC 0 IIpaMaTH­

'1CCKOM xapaKrepc OTiIOrnCIIHK peaJIhHhlX IIcACTBYIOIUHX JIH~ fia "CI\CHC" peaJIhHOA )l(H3HH.

H TCM HC Mcncc y)l(C :lI\CCh Y BhlrOTCKoro IIp06HBaJIaCh MhlCJIh 0 B03MO)l(HOCTH

IIpHMCHllTh XOpOIliO 311aKOMOC CMy 110 HCKyCCTBOBCII'ICCKHM 3anllTHllM IIPCIICTaBJICHHC 0

npHII~Hnax nOCTpOCIIHlI IIpaMhi K uay'llloMy 06"hllCHCIIHIO IICHXH'leCKH pcryJIHpycMoro

nOBeIlCUHll '1CJIOBCKa, npHTOM, no cro CJIODaM, "n caMhlC KpHTH'ICCKHC H OTBeTCTBellHLlC

MHHy-rL1 )l(H3I1H,,10.

CHlly Toro, 'lTO 6h1l1a HaMC'ICHa B reKCT'

BanHhlMU. Ha IIcA \I 060PBaJlClI efO TBOF

PC'll, IlIJIa 0 BHCIlPCHHH B anllapaT

I\pyra KarerOpHH:, KaK JIH'lHOCTh H Me)l(JI:

C JIH'IHOCThlO H311aBlla KOppe~POBa.r:

MC)I(JIH'IUOCTHhIM OTIIOiliClIHlIM BhlrOTCI

IIpaMC. Hc caMa no cc6c '1JICHOpa311CJII

TOTCJIh BHlleJI pCllIalOmCC OTJIH'lHC '1CJIO

COnpll)l(CHUhlC C HcA lIepe)l(HBallHlI JIH",

CKoro B pOJIH q,aKTopoB, IIpHi;1aIOII\HX, U

B H3BCCTHOH HaM BCClleIlHoH.

]:\HJIhTCH npCIIJIO)l(HJI <liOpMyJIy "llh BCJIHKorO ApaMaTypra 60JILilie IIpaBl\h1

BMCCTC B311TLIX. TICpCJIOMHWM D TBOp'leCTDC BwrOTCKoro CTaJI cro TpaKTaT "HCTOPH'ICCKHA CMhlCJI

TIOJICMH3HPYli OT oAHoro TCKCTa K T: IICHXOIIOrH'ICCKOrO KpH3Hca". 3TOT CMWCJI OH yCMaTpHBaJI B TOM, 'ITO nCUXOIIOfHlI

6CpCMCIIlla OC06WM MCTOIIOJIOrH'lCCKHM HanpaBIICHHCM ~ 06mcA IICHXOJIOrHCA KaK

HayKoH 0 KaTeropHlIX, rll06allhllhix CXCMax H 06"hllCHHTeJIhHhIX IIpHu~Hnax, pcryJIHpylO­

II\HX UCCJICIIOBareJIhCKYIO pa60Ty B JII06hlX OTpaCJIllX, OXBaTWBalOn\HX Bee llBJICHHsr, rOBopsr

CJIOBaMH BwrOTCKoro, "OT naCJI8)I(IICHHll TparCIIHCA 1\0 6pella cYMaCllIeIlIlICro".

CHJIhHhlJl CBOHM nOJICMH'leCKHM COllep)l(anHeM, 3TOT TpaKTaT 6hIJI 060pBall Ha

06emaHHH aBTOpa Ilpell<:TaBHTh CBOH IlJI8I1 1I0CTPOCIIHII 3TOA lIayKH. 06CmaHHC OCTallOCh

HeBhIllOJIlICUHhlM. Pa3pa60TaTh 0611\YIO nCUXOJIOfUlO" KaK MeTOIIOJIOfHIO lIaHHOH KOH­

KPCTlIOA IIHC~HIIJIUHhl, nOll0611YlO 06mcA q,H3HKC HJIH 06mCH 6UOJIOrHH, HO HC MCTO~O­

JIOrHH B ce q,HJIOCOq,CKOM H3MepellHH, OH HC CMOr, OCTaBHB 3TY 3~a'lY nOTOMKaM, 1I0HhmC

ce HC pCillBBillBM.

HOBhlH 3Tall B TBOp'lCCTBC BhIrOTCKOrO OTKphlJIO cro 06pamCHUC K npclICTaBJICHHIO 0

Ha TOM, 'ITO ~CJIh lIayqHoH nCHXOJIOrnH

IICHXOTCXHHKa B 0IlIlOM CJIOBC, T.C. Hay'!:

OBJIaj:\CHHIO nCHXHKOH, K HCKyCCTBCHHO,,"

BhIrOTCKHA OTqCTJIHBO BUIICJI, qTO q HayKH CC rJIaBllblA )l(H3I1CIIHhlH nepB ­

JIHllIaJIaCh ncpcnCKTHB 060CIIOBaHHlI

JIlOlIcl\:. BCllh "HapHcoBaHuyIO Kopony IJ

illTCpHOM. QTo6h1 OTCTOllTh npHII~HII

CKoro. !lBllllCTCli aKCHOMaTH'lCCKHM TaK

THKU), Tpc60BaJIOCh DLIHTH 3a npCAC~

(CBOIIHBIUcro ncuxHKy K TCJIeCHOH Mcxa

HHlI BhlCIlIHX ~CHHOCTllhIX oPHCHT8I\HA pOJIH 0PYIIHK TpYlla B 06pa60TKC BCmCCTBa. BOnpCKH 06W'lHhlM CChlJIKaM Ha 3aHM­

CTBOBallHC BhlrOTCKHM "OPYIIHHHOrO" 1I0llXolla y MapKCa, OTMC'Iy, 'ITO rllaBHali

MCTOIIOIIOrn'lCCKall HIICli 6hlJIa BOCnpHlIlITa BhlfOTCKHM y CnHII03h1, CpaBlUlBIUCrO MCTOIIW

HCCIlCIIOBallHlI HCTHllhi C 0PYIIHllMH TpYlla11. npHII~Hll 0PYJ\HHIIOCTH MhlCJIH, COIlPlI)I(CHHhlA

MIl: BpamaJIaCh q,H.IIOCOq,CKO-IICHXOJIOrn

B cnC~HallbHOM 061llHpHOM TpaKTi

nCp3hl OT COKpaTa H )lcKapTa 110 yqCIIH

OTCTaHBall IIPCHMYII\eCTBa TCJIeOJI

IlJIaTOHOBCKOM "«!>CIIOllC", rllc H311arall

7 TllM lKe. C. 82.

8 MelK):\y TeM oonpoc 0 pe<tx>pMe nCHXOJlOfHH 0 /lyxe MapKcH3MD K TOMy opeMellH yJKe WHpoKO 06cyJK­

/lDJlelI. 'TpaKTDT 06 O'lHlI.\enHH HllTeJlJlCKTa" (0 H3/1a 9H'oooe nOllllTHe JlerJlo 0 OCHooaHHe pcaKTOJlOfHH. 06·t.JIDJlelJlJoA K.H. KOPHHJlOOblM HCTHIDIO "MDpK­ 3nreJlbCD nD nCHXOJlOrH'IeCKHe HCCiJe/lOODIIH

CHCTCKOK nCHXOJlOfHeii". TepMHllY "PCaK~HlI"Dldl'OrCKl!ii cnepoD npH/lDJI CO/leplKlUlHe, OTJlH'IHoe OT KOpIlH­ "MDpKCHCTCKDll nCHXOJIOrHlI". MapKcH3M on 01

JlOOCKOro, a 3aTeM Boo6u.\e OT Hero OTKD3DJ1el1. "opraIlH'IecKoMY poeTy JlofH'IecKoli CTpyKTy

10 BW20mcKuu J1.c. ITcHXOJlOrHlI HCKYCCTBa. M., 1987. C 250. 11 0..: Bbl20mcKUU J1.c. COOp. CO'l. T. 1. C 318-319. BbiroTcKHii CCblJlDeTCli liD paoory CnHH03bJ

CTaTblO "DhlroTCKHii H MapKcH3M 0 cooeTCKoM

12 Bbl20mcKuu J1.c. Co6p. co,!. T. 1. C

84

l3bIBaJICSI

o I10BOl{y

~eHHHKe.

HeXaJI? H

lpwaeTCSI

160 DeeM

wm. :> B MHO­

"l{paMe

IH30UIno.

~nOBeKa.

'aR cBoil

leKcono­

: HeMy B

I10Bel{e­

y6..eKTa

0POMy B

OTCKoro

OOTHecSi

CHxono­

:1' I.\eno­

ornacuo

IK pe'lb

~aMaTH­

KH3HH.

lICHOCTH

[eHHe 0

yeMoro

BeHHbIe

CMbIcn

onorHSI

eil KaK

JIHPYIO­

rOBOpSi

laH Ha

ranOCb

Ii: KOH­

eTO~O­

OHbIHe

HHIO 0

3aHM­

laBHaSi

eTOl{bI

~HHblii

6cYJIC.

Map!(­

mpHH­

IH03bI

C nOHSITHeM 0 3HaKe. I1pOHH3bmaJI BCIO Hccnel{OBaTeJlbCKylO pa60TyBbIroTCKoro. nepe~SI H3 06naCTH TeOpeTH'IeCKHX H3blCKallHA (I1epBOHa'laJIbHO B TpaKTaTe "HCTopH'IeCXHA

CMbIcn nCHXOnOrH'IeCKOrO KpH3Hca") B KOHKpeTHO-HayqHylO 3KcnepHMeHTaTHKy. QHa

npel{CTannSina HanpanneHHe. KOTOpOMy MOllCHO 6blJI0 6bI I{arb HMSI "HHCTpYMeHTaJIbHOil

nCHX ono'rHH " • C nerKOH pyKH ero nOCnel{OBaTeneil ee nOBceMeCTHO (n yqe6HHKax. cno­

BapSiX H T.I1.) Ha3bIBaIOT KynbTypHO-HCTopH'IeCKoil TeopHeil. nOCTaTO'lHO. OI{HaxO. B3rmf­

HyTb B npel{MeTHblil YKaJaTenb x ero C06paHHIO cO'lHlleHHii. '1T06bI y6el{HTbClI. 'ITO CaM

anTOp HH paJy He I1pHMeHHJI 31'0 0603Ha'leHHe. OTKaJaJICSI 01' Hero. QHO Tpe60BaJIO ,He

peaJIH30BaHHOrO illKOJlOH BbIrOTCKoro cpaBHHTenbHoro aHaJIH3a BJlHSlHHSI PaJJlH'IHbIX

KynbTyp Ha I1CHxonorH'IecKylO OpraHH3~HIO '1eJlOBeKa (Kpoec-KynbTypHbIX Hccnel{OBa­

HUH). CTaJIHHClCaR I10JlHTHKa HHBenHpOBaHuSi I1anHTpbI KynbTypHbIX HHBapHaHT (I101{

MacKoil He3yHTCKOH q,OpMyJlbI 0 el{HHOil I10 COl{epllCaHHIO COI.\HaJIUCm'leCKOil XyJlbType)

HaKJlal{blBana BeTO Ha 3TY np06neMY. TIpel{npHHlITaR A.P. JIYPHSI I10IlbITKa H3yqHTh

U3MeHeHHSI B I1CHXHKe y36cKOB B ycnOBHlIX KynbTypHoro cTPOHTenbcma 6blJIa oCyllC/{eHa

KaK I10nHTH'leCKH BpeJlHaR.

Bo BceX oi.\eHKax H HHTepnpeT~uSlx TeopHH BbIrOTCKoro ero rnaBHbIil BKnal{ cIIpaneA­

JlHBO yCMaTpHB$l.eTCli B OTKpbITHH. 6naro/{apSi ceMHOTH'IeCKoMy cnoc06y 06..SlCHeHHSI I1CU­

XHKU. cOl.\HoKynbTypHbIX q,aKTopOB PaJBHTHSI KOrHHTHBHbIX q,YHKl.\HiI '1enOneKa B OHTore­

He3e. MellCl{y TeM Hapll.llY C 3TOil nHHHeH ero Hccnel{OBaHuH I1pOpUCOBbIBaJIaCb I{pyraR.

IIHollepcKoe 3Ha'leHHe KOTOpoil' He YCTYIIaeT nepBoil. QHa HecpanHeHHO MeHee H3Becma B

cuny Toro. 'ITO 6blna HaMe'leHa B TeKCTax, OCTanIllHXCli He3anepWeHHbIMH H HeoIly6nuxo­

BaIlHbiMU. Ha HeA 1I 060pBaJICli ero mOp'leCKHH nyn. CKa3aHO nocne/{Hee cnOBO.

Pe'lb wna 0 BHel{pellHH B aHIIapaT Hay'lHoil IICHxonOTHH TaKHX 1{0nonHlIlOJl\HX I{pyr

I{pyra KaTeropHH. KaK nH'lHOCTb H MellCJIH'IlIOCTHble OTHOlIleHHlI.

C nH'lIlOCTblO U3/{anlla KOppeJIHpOBaJIO nOllllTHe 0 nepellCHBaHHH. TIpHMeHHTenbHO lICe K

MellCnH'IHOCTHbIM OTIIOlIlellHlIM BbIrOTCKHH BBOI{HT B 3Ha'leHHH HX napaq,paJa I10HSlTHe 0

I{paMe. He caMa no ce6e '1neHopa31{enbHaSI pe'lb. B KOTOpoil. KaK H3BeCTHO. ell.\e ApHc­

rOTenb BHI{M pelIlalOlI.\ee OTJIH'IHe '1enOBe'leCKOH l{yllIH 01' JKHBOTIIOH. a "l{paMam3~SI" H

conplillCeHHble C Heil nepellCHBaIlHlI nH'IIIOCTH BbIcTynalOT B ropH30HTe BUl{eHHSI BbIrOT­

CKoro B ponH q,aKTOpOB. npHl;lalOJl\Hx. Haplll{y co cnOBOM. IICHXHKe '1enOBeKa oc060e MecTO

B H3BeCTHoil HaM BceneHHoil.

)J;HnbTeH I1pel{nOllCHn lJiopMyny "llIeKcnHp B nOllllTuSlX". OTMe'laR. 'ITO B Tpare/lHlIX

BeJIHKOrO I{paMaTypra 60nbwe IIpanl{bI 0 '1enOBeKe. '1eM BO Bcex yqe611HKax nCHXOnOrHH. '

BMeCTe B311TbIX.

TIoneMH3HpYli 01' OI{Horo TeKCTa K I{pyrOMy C ::>THM npoeKTOM. BbIrOTCKHH HaCTaHBaJI

Ha TOM. 'ITO I.\enb lIayqlIoil nCHXOnOTHH "He llIeKCIIHp B nOIlSiTHliX. KaK I{nSi )J;HnbTeSI •••• HO

I1CHXOTeXHUKa B OI{UOM enoBe. T.e. Hay'IHaR TCOpIUl. KOTOpaSl npHBena 6bI K nOI{'1HHeHHIO H

OBnal{eHHIO I1CHXHKOH. K uCKycCTBeHHoMy ynpanneHHIO I10Be/{eIlHeM"12.

BbIroTcKHil OT'IeTnHBO BHl{en. 'ITO q,opMyna "llIeKcnHp B nOIlSlTHSlX" oTceKaeT 01' Tena

HayKH ee rnaHlIhlil lICH3IIeUHblH HepB - IIpHlIl.\HII l{eTepMHIIH3Ma. Ho Torl{a ncuxonoruSi

nHwanaCb I1epCIIeKTHB 060CHOBlUIHlI I1pOrpaMM. Clloc0611bIX H3MeHSlTb l{eSiTenbHOCTb

nlOl{eil. Bel{b "HapucoBaHllylO Kopony Henb311 1{0HTb". 1I0BToplin BbIroTCKHH 3a BunbliMoM

IIITepnoM. llT06w 01'CTOSlTb npHlIl.\HII l{eTepMHuH3Ma. KOTOpwil. 110 y6clICI{eHHIO BbIroT­

CKoro. lIBnlleTCSI aKCHOMaTH'IeCKHM TaKlICe H I{nll nCHXOnOTHH KaK HayKH (a He 6enneTpHC­

THKH). Tpe60BanOCb nbIilTH 3a npel{enbl KOIITpaBep3bl l{eTCpMHIIHCTCKoro 06..SlCHeHHSI

(CBOI{HBlIlerO IICHXHKy K TeneCHoil MeXaHHKe) H TeneonOTH'IeCKOrO I10IlHMaIIHSI (KaK oIIBca­

HHlI BbICIIIHX i.\eWIOCTHbIX opHeHT~HH H lIepellCHBallHil nH'IUOCTH). BOKpyr KOTOpOH BeKa­

MH Bpall.\anaCh q,H,TIOCoq,CKo-nCHXOnOrH'IeCKaSI Mblcnb.

B CIIel.\HanLHOM 06llIHpHOM TpaKTaTe BhIrOTCKHii IIpOC,JIeI{Hn cyl{b6bl 3TOH KOHTpa­

Bep3bI 01' COKpaTa H neKapTa I{O yqellHKa )J;HnbTeli 3. llIupaIlrepa H M. llIenepa.

OTcTaHBaSi npeHMYII.\ecTBa TenCOnOrH'IeCKOH UCHxonorHH. llInpaHrep HanOMHHn 0

I1naTOUOBCKOM "«PeI{OHe". rl{e H3naranaCb noneMHKa COKpaTa C AlIaKcaropOM. KOTOpylO

'TpaKTaT 06 O'lHU\eHHH HllTeJlJleKTa" (0 H3AallHH 1914 r.). 3THM lie OTpHltaeTCIi OJlHlIlIHe paooT MapKca H

3Hrenl.ca liB nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHe HCCJleAOOOIIHII BI.JrOTCKoro. OAllaKO AJlII lIero 61.1J1 lIenpHeMJleM TepMHH

"MapKCHCTCKaJI nCHXOJIOrHII". MapKCH3M 011 0ltellHOaJl KaK OlllKlII.Jii, 110 BlleWIIHii q>BKTOp no OTHowellHIO K

"oprallH'IecKoMy pocTy JIOrH'IecKoii crpyKTypI.J 31101lHII" (TaM lKe. c. 422). lloApOOlIee 06 aTOM CM. MOIO

CTSTI.IO "Bl.lroTCKHii H MapKCH3M 0 cooeTCKoii nCHXOJlOrHH" /I llCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHii lKypllaJI. 1992. Nt 5. 12

BblwmCKUU JI.c. COOp. CO'l. T. I. C. 389. ' '

85

:

llinparrrepHa3Ban "COKpaTonCKHM napaAOKCOM". lIpclKAc qCM npHlUlTb 5IA. BcnBKHA:

MYApen;. ccnH BCpHTb lInaTOIlY. oCnapHBan <pHnOCO<pCKylO KOIln;cnn;HIO AllaKcaropa.

JtOTOpblH IIcKorAa. 6YAyqH 06BHHcnB 6C360lKHH, 6clKan H3 A<pHH. COKpaT. BonpCKH

lIaC1'05lUHlIM APY3CH. OTKa3anC5I nocrynHTbTaKHM lKC 06paJOM. HaXOA5ICb B "norpaHHqHoA:

CH'i'YaI~HH" ncpcA nHn;OM CMCpTH. Olf pa3Mblmmm HC 0 nH'lUOH cYAb6c, uo 0 rn06aJIbHoA:

npo6nCMC: 0 npH'IHHaX, KOTOpblC npaB5IT '1CnOBCqCCKHM nOBcAcnBCM. COKpaT

paeCKa3blBan. KaK B MonOAOCTH C BcnHKHM pBCHHCM npHHlWC5I 3a KHHrH AHaKcaropa.

'IT061J "nOCKOpec HX npo'lCCTb H nOCKOpee YJuaTb. 'ITO lKC BCcro nyqmc H 'ITO XYlKc,,13.

, Pa30'laponaHHC nOCTHrno CoKpaTa. KorAa. B'IHTaBmHCb B AHaKcaropa. OH y6cAHnc5I.

'ITO' Y" Hcro ACHCTBH5IMH qCnOBCKa pyKOBOAHT yCTpoA:CTBO Tcna. a HC MlICHHC 0 nyqrncM,

MHlmHc;xoropoc AHKTyCT HC y6clKaTb H3 TlOpbMbl. a nOAqHHHTbC5I TOMy. 'ITO "HaJHa'lHnO

TOCYAapcTBO". "Aa. Kn5lUYCb c06aKoA:. - BocKnHKHyn COKpaT. - JTH lKHnw H JTH KOCTH

YlKC AaBHO. 51 AYMalO, 6bWH 6bl rAC-HH6YAb B Mcrapax HnH B nCOTHH, YBJICqCIIHblC nO:lKHWM

MtJelIHcllit () nyqllJCM". lIo llinpaHrcpy. "COKpaTOBCKHM napaAOKCOM" pa3 H HaBccrAa

onpoBcprHyTa npaBOMcpllOCTb TaKoro 06"b5lCHCIIH5I nOCTynKoB, KOTOpWC aHCnnHpycT K

TCnccnoA'(')praHH3~HH.

"lIoci'aBncHHbIH B nnaTOUOBCKOM "c1lCAOHC" Bonpoc 0 TOM, nOqCMY COKpaT OCTaJIC5I B

a<pHHcKoA: 'rlOpbMC. BwrOTCKHH C'IHTan npOTOTHnOM OCHOWIWX np06nCM COBpCtotCHHOH

nCH~onorHH. Ho 3ACCb. nOA'ICpKHBan 0111 HC MoryT YAonnCTBOpHTb HayqHylO Mwcnb HH

onlfcaTenLHa51 (TcnCOnOrHqCCKa5I) KOIU~cnn;u5l, HH 06"b5lCIIHTCnbna51 (KaYJanbHa5l). Ha nOT

:Bonpoc "TCOpH5I AlKcMca-JIallrc OTBCqaCT CCbJnKOH na paCT5IlKCIIHC H paccna6nCHHC

MycKynon. cliI6aJOJD;Hx qnCllbl. a TCOpH5I IlIcncpa - YKaJallHCM lIa TO. 'ITO IIpc6~BaI1HC B

TCMJlHn;C HMcno n;cnblO YAonnCTnopHTb BblCllJCC qyBCTBO n;CIIHOCTH. If TO, H APyroc

OAHHaKOBO AanCKO 01' ACHCTBHTcnbHO lIayqUoro ornCTa lIa nonpoc"14.

'''HH HaTypanHCTHqCCKa5l, IIH HIITCIln;HOHanbHa51 TCOpH5I IIC 06paJD;aJOT BHHMaHH5I lIa

,,15 K aKOBa lKC JTa "? enHC~I...1111'y'10 npHqHIlY . '"HCTHlllIa51 npHqHlIa. paBHncli nH BbJrOTCKHH C

,"cmcpaToBCKHM napallOKcOM"1 fOToBoro OTBCTa B cro TCKCTax HCT. If BCC lKC.

OpHCHTHpy5lCb IIa JTH TCKCTL.I. nonblTaCMC5I OrnCTHTb, KaKHM lKC OH MOl' 6w 6bJTb: lIpClKAC

Bccro cncAycT HMCTb B BHAY. 'ITO BblrOTCKHM OTBcpranaCb HCXOAHa51 anbTcpHaTHBa,

~aCalOJD;a51C5I npHqHU nOCTynKa: nH60 YCTPOHCTBO OpraIJH3Ma. nH60 HpaBCTBCHHOC non5lrnc

("MllClme 0 nyqrncM"). BCAbcaM, 06paJ OpraIIH3Ma pCllJHTCnbHO H3MCIIHnC5I. nocnc 1'01'0

KaIC cro TCnCCUa51 pa60Ta BhlcTynHna B BHA'O npoAyKTa npCAllJCCTBylOJD;CrO onWTa

lKH311CtIlIbiX BCTpeq CO CpeAOH -ycnonllo-pC<pn'OKToplIbIX (no lIaBJIoBY) H CCMHOTH'lCCKHX

(no BwroTcKoMy). BCAb nc nCHXHq'OCKHC <PYIlKD;HH BblrOTCKHH CqHTan npOH3BOI\HblMH 01'

HcApOAHHaMHKH. HO olla CTaBHnaCb n 3anHCHMOCTb 01' IIHX.

O'lCBBAno, 'ITO M03r (KaK oc06a51 <pYIIKn;HOlIaJIblIa5I CHCTCMa), H3MCU5ICMbIH 6naroAap~ -C:03HaTem,HO YCTauaBnHBacMblM HIIAHBHAOM 3uaKOBO-CMblcnOBbIM Cn5l351M. JTO HHOH

<pH3HO.p.0IilqCCKHH npH60p. '1CM pa60TaJOJD;HH lIa ycnonllo-p'O<pncKTopHbIX CB5I351X.

lIOH5ITH5I lKC, Ha KOTOpbJC OpHCIITHpycTf'lI qCnOB'OK (B TOM qHCnC HpaBCTnCHHbJC). B

CBOIO OHcpeAb 5Inn5l10TC5I pC3ynhTaToM cro <pOPMHPOBaIIH5I B THrnc COn;HaJIbIlOH npaKTHKH.

llOJTOMy PCllJCIIH5I H IICHCTBH5I cncAycT npHUHMaTb 11'0 3a HaqaJIbllblC, IIO 3a KOHCqUble

3BCHb51 ,cnOlKlIoro KaYJanhlIoro p5llla. yxoAlIlI,cro B rny6b HM'OIOJD;'OH TlpaMaTHqeCKYIO

HCTOpHIO CHCTCMbl. lIpHTOM n;cnOCTIIOH CHCTCMbl, rAc nCHXHqCCKOC H COMaTHqeCKO'O B

HHAHBHJlC IIcpaJAcnWlbl. AeHcrnH5I lKC JTOrO HlIlIHBHAa COn;HaJIbHO OpHCIITHpOBalIbl. BCAb

CBOHM Bbl60pOM COKpaT paCCqHTWnan npenOllaTb UPaJJCTBClIllblii ypOK OKPYlKaJJUlHM 'Oro

yq~nH.KaM.,C TCM qT06bJ caMblH BblCOKOH n;CHOH - n;CHOH CBOCH lKH3HH - IIOKa3aTb

HcupaBoTyAlIaKcaropa. 06"b5lCIIHTCnblla51 nCHXOnOrH5I COCPCIIOTOqHnaCb Ha TcnCCIIOM

~'OXaIl~~C; HC 3HalOJD;eM liB CMb~cna. IIH AyxonHOCTH. OnHCaTCnblla51 lKC. HanpOTHB. Ha

:qUCTOR AyX,OBHOCTH. He 3UaIOJD;CH TCn'OCHOCTH H nOToMy lKHBoro qCnOBCKa B nCpHnCTH5IX

c:ro pe,aJIbHOrO 6b1TH5I. )f(H3IIb qCnOBCKa KaK 3CMIIoro cyJD;ccrna OKa3bIBanaCb a6COnIOTIIO

6CCCMblcncnlIoA, IIC HMCJOJD;'OH IIH n;cnH. IIH n;CHIIOCT'OH, a cro BblCllJHC qyBCTBa - a6co­

mOTHO 6C3lKH3IICHHbIMH. " ... l.J:T06bJ coxpalIHTb lKH311b qyBCTBa, Mbl AonlKllhl OTKa3aTLC5I 01'

cro CMbICna.... qT06bl coxpalIHTb nCpClKHBaHHC, 'Oro CMblcn, MI.l AonlKHW OTKaJaTbC5I 01'

lKH3nH.,B 060HX cnyqallX Mbl 0AHllaKOBO AonlKllbl OTKa3aTbCli 01' BCliKOH IIaAClKAbl KorAa­

13nAamoH. ci>~Aoll, 97D. ~~. ',' '

"' J BlK,zpmcKU(l Jl.C. COOp. COq. T. 6. C. ,286. 15 TaM lICe.

JlH60 lIayqJlO UOCTHOIYTb qCnOBCKa H m

BblroTcKHH HaAc5Inc5I nbl6paTbC5I H:

C0<pH10 CUHII03bl; upeoAonCBllJCrO KapT­

KY" BcnHKoro p~HonanHcTa H AeTep

TpaKTaT BbiroTcKoro 06 JMOn;u5lX 6wJI

HaencAHHKOB B XX B., B TOM qHene AHn Ha BCpcHIO 0 TOM. 'ITO ncpcnCKTHBHblM

5I3WK 06paJOB llJeKCIIHpOBCKHX TparcAH:

BblrOTCKoro. BCKTOp lKC JTHX PaJllYMH

ncpelKHBaHHH, KaIC HCCYJD;CH KOHCTpyKl

"<pHnoco<pHH lKH3HH", <pCHOMCHonOIilI

'1T06bl npHAaTb CMy npH3HaKH. OTKI

06"b5lCHCIIH5I.

Ha OAHOM 1f3 BalKHblX nOBopOTOB C

nCHxonorHH". Ec 3aMblCCn 3apOAHnC5I

<pHnOCO<pa-MapKCHCTa lIonHTn;cpa "Kf MOlKHOCTb H3yqCUH5I '1cnOBCKa HC B ~

HanpaBnCHHe) HnH TcnCCUblX pcaKD;HA:

Horo c06blrn51 lKH3HH nHqHOCTH, AHHal

Ma•.. JlHqlIOCTb KaIC yqaCTIIHK ApaMbl. ~ OTlIbJIIC OH nonaraCT, 'ITO IICAOC'I

MClKllY nOBcAcHHCM lKHBOTllbiX H

ncpeMclIHblM. BbJBOA5IU~M AaJICKO 3a

CHCTCM. 31'0 npelK/lC Bccro nHqlIOCTb.

"l.J:TO TaKoe qenOBcK? An51 fcrcm

opraHH3M. An51 IIac COn;Hanblla51 nHq

nonnOJD;ClllIa5I B HII/lHBH/lC" 18. JIH'IIIOC1

BblCllJCH uCHxonQIiIH.

lIpoeKT nCHxonOIilH B TCpMHHax /lP

BbirOTCKoro, He 6bm PCaJIH30BaH. Ho

THlJOBCC, naBnOBCKoMy "ypaBlIoBCUlHBa

TaKHC acnCKTbI. KaK H3IIaqaJIbHYIO lIa

JlHn;. /lHBCprCIITHOCTb HX HHTCpCCOB.

BJlH5IIIHC Ha cro HccnC/lOBalIH5I HCTOpHI

An51 AHnbTC5I - nOHHMaIIHC. rcpl

3peHHC - TaKOBbl nYTH IIOCTHlKCHH5I

cqHTanOCb npO/lYKTHBlIblM. Kor/la H

CMbiCnaMH. BblrOTCKHH lKC Tpe60BaJI I

HCKycCTBa K caMoH JTOH /lpaMc, OTKp:

MCTO/lOB, npoHH3aHIIbiX npHIIn;HnoM

JIH60 /lCTCPMHlIH3M (H Tor/la IICT pa3

OI\HOH CTOpOlIbl. nOBc/lcIIH5I <PH3HqCCK

BacMblH "51" KOHTHHHyM CMblcnOB

BbirOTCKOMY, OCTaCTC5I r1JaBIIWM lKl

O/llIaKO npHMCIIHTC1JbHO K C0311aIIHI<

naTHblH CC npHpollc. 31'0 6bm IICHXH'i

CTCKoro 06"bllCIICHHlI, OT1JHqlIa5I OT M

acCOn;HaTHBlIoH nCHXOJlOIiIH). 01' 6HOJ

1101'0 111J5I <PYIlKD;HOllaJIH'JMa H pe<p1JC1

06pa3 MblllJnCUH5I BhlroTcKoro onpe

16 BblzomcKuu Jl.C. COOp. COq. T. 6. C. 17 Bbl20mcKUU Jl.c. KOIIKpeTlIllJI nCHXO

18 TaM lICe. c. 59. 19 3Aecb Bbll'OTCKHH npeABOCxHTHn KC

KOTOpblX BblpallCeH B "HapaCTalOll\eM HilT

HanpllllCellllOCTH B CaMOOpl'a1lH3aL\HH H H3)

Participatory epislemology and Psychology 01 1989. P. 142).

:JIHKHH JlH60 ua)"luo I10CTHIlIYTb 'leJIODeKa H uaCTOll~ce 3Ua'lellHe ero BHyrpeHHeA lICH38.... 16 ... '. ~aropa, BblroTcKHH HaAeliJICli nbl6paTbclI H3 AyaJIHCTH'lecKoH JIOByUJKH, onHpaacb ua.•,UIO­

[)I1peKH COlpHIO CuHH03bl, I1peOAOJIeBwerO KapTe3HlUICKHH cuoc06 MbIWJIeHHlI. Ho pac'leT ua "3'111­IIH'lHOH KY" BeJIHKOrO pal\HOHaJIHCTa H AeTepMHHHCTa CUHU03bl 6b1JI 06pe'leH ua HeYJ'aqy".

aJIbllOH TpaKTaT BblroTcKoro 06 3MOl\HlIX 6b1JI 060pRlUI Ha H3JIOlKeHHH B3rJIlIIlOB neKapTa • ero ~OKpaT uacneAHHKoB B XX B., B TOM 'lHcne ABJIbTell, OnHpamueroCli Ba nOHllTHe 0 nepellC:llJlQlDl!l

~aropa, ua BepcHIO 0 TOM, 'ITO nepCneK'l'HBHblM AeJIOM nCHXOJIOrHll MOlKeT CTaTb nepeBO~ Ra..~~1 ,,13 1I3b1K 06pll30B weKCUHpoBCKHX TpareAHA. Pa3AYMbll 0 epYR~H nepellCBBlUDIlI Be nO~lIJIJI

~I\HJIClI, BbIrOTCKoro. BeKTOp lKe 3THX PIl3AYMHA onpeAeJIliJIClI CTpCM1IeHHeM OTBoeBaTb noJiJlJ'lIe'o

('lWeM, uepelKHBlUIHH, KaK uecy~eH KOHCTpyKQHH JIH'lHOCTH Y AHJIbTell H /lPyrHX npHBeplK.eaqe»

la'lHJIO "epHJIOCOepHH lKH3HH", epeHOMeHOJIOrHH, uepcOHaJIH3Ma H pOACTaeuUblX Te'leuBA,CT«!M

KOCTH '1T06bl I1pHAaTb eMY I1pH3UaKH, oTKpblBaIO~e I1epcIIeKTHBy ero AeTepMHBIICTCl:oro

llKHblM 061>lICHeHHlI.

,Bcefl~a Ha OAHOM H3 BalKHblX I10BOpOTOB CBocro lIyTH Oil 06paTHJIclI K HAee "/lPaMaTHCfeCKOI

pyeT K I1CHXOJIOrHH". Ee 3aMblCeJI 3apOAHJICli y Hero I10A BIIe'laTJIeHHeM pa60TbI epPaB~}'3ClOl'O

epHJIOcoepa-MapKcHCTa TIOJIHTl\epa "KpHTHKa OCHOB I1CHXOJIOrHH", rAe 06cYXAanachB03­

'aJICII B MOlKHOCTb H3)"leuHlI 'leJIOBeKa He B ,TepMHilax upOI\eCCOB C03HaHHlI (BBTPocneleTR8BOe

leHuoH

eJIb HH

uanpaBJIeHHe) HJIH reJIeCHblX peaKQHH (6HxeBHopH3M), a B repMHuax ApaMhl Kale qeJl(K3'­

Bora C06blTHli lKH3I1H JIH'lHOCTH, AHHaMHKH ee nOCTyuKOB. "ABHaMHKa JIII'IHOCTII - fr­a 31'01' Ma••• nH'lUOCTb Kax )"laCTUHK ApaMbl. ApaMa JIH'lHOCTH. TICHXOJIOrHlI rYMaHH3HpyeTClI~1,. iJICIIHe OTUbIHe OH I10JIaraeT, 'ITO ueAOCTaTO'lHO yTBepAHTb 3HaK B Ka'leCTBe Bo1topCUAena

allHe B MelKAY noueACUHeM lKHnOTUblX H 'leJIOUeKa. Tpe60uaJIOCb o(ipaTHTLClI KROlnal'N

lpyroe I1epeMeIIllblM, UbIBOAlIU.\HM AaJIeKO 3a I1pCAeJIbl C03HAaeMblX B JIOIle KyJIbTypbl i3IlUC)BWX

CHCTeM. 31'0 I1pelKAe accra JIH'lIlOCTb. . "

IHII Ha "\fTO TaKoe 'leJIOUeK? AJIli rcreJIli - JIOrH'leCKHH cy61>eKT, AJIli nasnoua - (:OrA,

CKHH C opraHH3M. AJIli lIac COl\HaJIbUali JIH'lllOCTb, COUOKYUIIOCTb 06~eCTBeHHblx oT-!lOwcmHI,

e lKe, BOIlJIO~eUHaa n HIIAHuHlle,,18. nu'IIIOCTb ­ OC06b1H THII oprlUlH3auHH, I1epUH'lHoe noHlITHe

pelKAC BblcweH I1CHXOJIQrHH. . ,

aTHBa, TIpoeKT I1CHXOJIOrHH U TepMHHax APaMbl, KaK H MIIOrHe ApyrHe I1POAYKTHBIIble·3IDu.IC~~

>lllITHe BblrOTCKoro, He 6bIJI peaJIH30UlUI. Ho I1peACTaBJIeHHe 0' ApaMaTH3al\HH, UUOAlI~ee, B npo­~ Toro THllOneCnaUJIOUCKOMY "ypaulloneIlIHulUlHIO CO cpeAoH" H rOMeOCTaTH'lecJCHM peryJIJI~.,M.

[)I1bITa TaKHe acueKTbI, KaK H3I1a'laJIbHYIO IIauplilKelIllocTb C03HaHHlI H I10DeAeHHlI AeACTBYJOUt1fX

leCKHX JIHl\, AHBepreHTHocTb HX HHTepecoB, KPH3HcIIbie "B3PbIBbI" H T.n., oKa3aJIorJly6ciK~e

MH 01' BJIHlIHHe Ha ero HCCJIeAOnaUHlI HCTOpHH IIepelKHBaHHA JIH'lHOCTH19.

JJ;JIli AHJIbTell - I10HHMaUHe, repMeHeBTH'leCKaa HUTeplIpeTauHlI, HUTy&THBRoe UP9~ 3peHHe - TaKOBbI IIYTH IIOCTHlKeHHlI 3TOH HCTOpHH BO BceA ee IIOJIBore. TIPH3TOM:0~O C'lHTaJIOCb npoAyKTHBllhIM, KorAa HMeeT AeJIO C YlKe 3aue'laTJIeHHblMH XYAO.B.K~

CMblCJIaMH. BhIroTcKHH lKC Tpe60BaJI 06paTHTLCli 01' OTCBeTOB ApaMbl :lKH3HH B tBope~

,Ie), B HCKycCTBa K caMoK 3TOH APaMe, OTKpblTOA, KaK OU (ibIJI yoepeH, AJIJI HayqHLlX ~OBIlTRA :,8 .

~THKH.

~'lUble

MeToAOB, I1pOUH3aHIlblX I1PHUl\HIIOM KaY3aJIbIIOCTH. BblrOTCKHH OTBepr aJILTepJlanlll;:

'JIH60 AeTepMHlIH3M (H Torlla ueT pa3JIH'lHH M:elKAY H3)"leHHeM C03HaHHlI 'leno.eia ;......!c ~CKYIO OAHOH CTOpOHbI, uOBeAeuHlI epHJH'leCKHX H OpraUH'lecKHx TeJI - C APyroA), JIH(iO uepe..­

Koe B BaeMblH "51" KOHTHHHyM CMblCJIOB H l\eHHOCTeK. TIpHRl\HII AeTepMHIIH3Ma. cqtn~eJto BeAb BblrOTCKOMY, OCTaCTCli rJIaBllblM lKH3HeHllblM HepBOM OpraHOHa Ha)"lHoro U03RllJI*1l.

M ero OAuaKO npHMellHTeJIbHO K C03HlUIHIO JIH'lHOCTH 011 06peTaeT OCO(iblH xapaxTep; ~e~·

~a3aTb uaTIIblH ee IIpHpoAe. 31'0 6blJI IICHXH'leCKHH AerepMHHH3M KaK oc06aa epopMa Aerepr.Qulir­

~CIIOM CTCKoro 061>lIClICHHlI, OTJIH'lllaa 01' MeXaIlH'lecKoA KaY3aJILHOCTH (onpeAeJIlIIOIL\eA oGJijlx

IB, Ha accOIlHaTHuuoH I1CHX01l0rHH), 01' 6HOJIOrH'lecKoro AeTepMHIIH3Ma AapBHHa (nap8AIWMa1IL­

eTHliX uoro AJIli epYIIKl\HolIaJIH:JMa H peepJIeKCOJIOrHH) H HCTopH'leCKOrO AeTepMHHH3MaMapKc·••

IOTIIO 06pa3 MblWJIeUHlI BblroTcKoro OilpeAeJIHJI I10HCK I1CHXOJIOrH'leCKOrO HeoAeTepM:JnrlclMa.

a6co­

.ell 01'

Cli 01'

~orAa-

16 BblzomcKuu R.C. Co6p. coO{. T. 6. C. 288.

17 BblZOmcKUU R.C. KOIIKpeTIIllJl nCHXOJIOrHlI. BCCTIIHK Mry. CePHli IlcHXOJlorHlI. 198L .l't I, c,·62.18 ~ .

TIlM lKe, c. 59. .

19 3Aecb BblroTCKHH npeABOCXHTHJI KOH~enTYaJJbHbleCABHrH B cOBpeMeHHoA nCMXOJIOrHII. Ollll" Ib

KOTOPblX BblpalKeH B "HapaCTalOU\eN HIITcpece K POJlH 6ecnopliAKa, HapyweHHlI PUHOlleal•• p0Cft HanplilKellllOCTH B CIlMOOpraIlH3a~HH H H3NeHemiH OTKpblTblX pa3BHBBJOU\HXCli CMcrcN" (M,. MaJuJ",q. Participatory epistemology and Psychology of science. In: Psychology of science. Cambridge Univenil)' ~

1989. P. 142). .;

C7

cnoc06Horo BLlpB8Th MhICnh H3 ':l8KOiI1HlB811110rO Kpyra "l\BYX nCHXOnOrHH"

BeHllouayqlloA H AyXOBHo-KynhTypHOA (rYMaJIHCTHqeCKOH).

TIoIIllTHe 0 nCHXHqeCKOH npHqHlIIlOCTH BBen lIa 3ape HOBOl!: nCHXOnOrHH ee nepBLlif

nHAep B. Byllj\T. B 60ph6e 3a ee Ue3aBHCHMOCTh 0'1' ApyrnxAHc~HnnHH OH H8CTaHnan Ha

"3aMKHYTOM UCHXHqeCKOM pllAe". HMenOCh B nHAY, 'ITO AYllleBIILle npo~cccLI AeTepMHHH­

POBaJlhI AYIlleBULlMH )l(e - qyOCTBO BOCnpHliTHeM, nocneAHee, B CBOIO OlJepeAh, BOneBhl:M

HaqanOM (aDnep~en~HeH) H T.n. OAHaKO nceM CBOHM nocneAYIOIl\HM nporpeccoM nCHXO­

norHlI 06113aJIa HMeHHO TOMy, 'ITO 3'1'0'1' pliA pa3MLlKanCli 6narOAapli OTKpLlTHIO 06y­

cnOBneHHOCTH <paKTOB C03HallHlI nH60 <PYHK~lIMH OpraHH3Ma, nH60 COl\HanhH1>IMH npo­

~eccaMH•. BYUATOBy cxeMy pa3pYlllHno H3}"IeHHe peanhBoA pa60ThI C03HaHHlI. KOTopoe He

lIBnlleTClI, nOA06HO Cy6CTaJl~HH CnHH03hl. causa sui. YTBep)l(Aali B xaqeCTBe npeAMeTa

nCHxononm C03HaJIHe, BLlrOTCKHH H3H8qanhHO 1paKToBan ero Kax "MeXaJIH3M co~anh­

Horo KOHTaKTa". 0'1' 3Toro 06IQero "cLlporo" npeACTlillneHHlI OH wen no nYTH BLllIBneHHlI

Bce HOBhlX H nOBhlX AeTepMHHaHT. Ka)l(AlUI H3 IIHX lIBnllnaCh KorlIHTHBHhlM ru6pHAoM,

nOp0)l(AeHHhiM Me)l(AHcl\HnnmIapnLlM "CKpeIQHBaDHeM". CnepBa 3'1'0 6hIn8 pea~HlI (3CTe­

THqeCKalI), KaK npOH3BOAHoe 0'1' nepeceqenHlI npo~eCCOB, nop03Hh H3}"IaeMLlX TeopHeA

nHTepaTypLl. HeAp0<pH3HonorHeA H nCHxonorHeil:. 3aTeM Ha c~eHY BLlwen 3HaK, KaK

nCHXOnOrnqeCKOe opYAHe, HMelOIQee npo06pa30M CO~HoKynhTypHO~ TBOpeHHe - 0pYAHe

TpYAa. 3a 311aKOM cne1\onano (B KaqeCTBe AeTepMHHaDTLI) 3HaqeHHe cnona, H3AaDHa

H3yqaeMOe nHnrBHCTaMH, 110 CTaBWee y BhlrOTCKoro oc060A nCHXOnOrHqeCKOA eAHHH~eA

nopO)l(AaeMOH "naprnepCTBOM" MLllllJIeUHlI H pe'IH. Jlpyroil: el\HJrn~eH, conpliralolQeA cnOB~ C )l(H311hlO nHqIlOCTH, BhlCTyITHn ero CMLlcn. Ho ero rn6pHAlloCTh, KaK MLI ceHqac ynHAHM,

HMena HHLle OCUOBaJlHlI - ne nHHrBHCTHqeCKHe, a CnO)l(HBumecli B HCKyCCTBe TeaTpa. B

3TOM )l(e HCKyCCTBe 6hl}J0 noqepnllYTo nOUliTHe 0 ApaMe.

B AaHIIOM cnyqae nepcA lIaMH cOBepweuHo 3KcKnlO3HBHhiH <peHoMell Me)l(AHC~HnnHHap-,

1I0ro CHHTe3a. Bo BCliKOM cnyqae. aJIanOrnqHLIH r1pe~eAeHT Mile HeH3BeCTelI. BeAh HOBoe

nOllllTHe pOAHnOCh He lIa CTLlKe lIayqHLlx AHC~HnnHH, a 6naroAapli HHTerp~HH "npo­

cneKTa", 3aAaHIIOrO HCKyCCTBOM, C "ceTKOH" HayqHOrO MhllllneUHlI. CnOBO KaK MaTepHan

XYAO)l(eCTneHuoro MLlIllnCUHlI, 6Yl\yqH BOBneqellO n KonnH3HH ApaMhl, 06peTaeT npH3HaxH,

lIeneAOMhle <pHnonorHH. B cnoIO OqepeAh 3TH npH311aKH B KOHTeKCTe HayqHO-nCHXO­

nOrnqeCKOrO MhllllnellHlI crallOBliTCli y' BLlrOTCKoro cpCACTnOM nepeXOAa 0'1' KaY3anhHoro

npel\CTaBnellHSl 0 BnHSlIIHH nllellllleH CpeAhI Ha C0311aHHe HHAHBH1\a K CHCTeMlIOMY 06'hllClle­

IIHIO CO~HanhlloH cHTyal~HH (noA06uoH c~elIapHIO ApaMhl), C03l\aDHOH B3aHMOl\eHCTBHeM

3Toro HIIAHnHAa C l\pyrHMH nepCOHa)l(aMH. KaK H B ApaMe, 3'1'0 B3aHMOAeHCTBHe AHano­

rnquo.

TIpHII~Hn AHanorn3Ma 6hIn, KaK H3neCT1I0, 060cuonaII M.M. EaXTHHLlM. Ho AJIlI Hero

~eHTpOM aHanH3a KaK HCKyccTBa, Tax H nH'IUOCTH cny)l(Hno C03HaHHe qenOBeKa a He

qenOneK BO nceH nonllOTe ero TenCCUO-AYXOBlIoro 6h1THli. B CBOHX B033pelI~lIX Ha

np06neMY "}I H ApyroH" EaxTHII OTCTaHBan nonllonpaBHe H nonlIo~elIlIoCTh Moero H

qy)l(oro 2~03I1aIlHlI, AalIHhlx TonhKO l\HanOrHqeCKH ("Ha rpanH~e", "Ha nopore", a "He

BHYTPH" ). lIo C0311aI1He, KaKHM 6hl )l(HBLlM H 1\HanOrHqHhiM OlIO HH 1paKTonanoch - 3'1'0

lIe eAHIICTBeHlIoe "H3MepeIlHe" qCnOBeqCCK?H nHqHOCTH. C nepBLlx )l(e cTpaHH~ CBoero

Magnus Opus - KIIHrn "MhllllnellHe H peqh" BLlroTcKHH npeAynpe)l(Aan: "KTO oTopBan

MhllllnellHe C caMoro uaqana 0'1' a<p<peKTa, TOT HancerAa 3aKphl1l ce6e l\opory K

06'hliCHe1lHlo npHqHH caMoro MLllllneUHlI, nOToMy 'ITO l\eTepMHIIHCTCKHA allanH3 caMoro

MLllllneHHlI npel\nOnaraCT BCKphlTHe l\BH)I(YIQHX MOTHBOB MhlcnH, n01pe6IIoCTeil: H HHTe­

peCOB, n06y)l(l\eUHH H TeHJ{ell~HH. KOTopLle HanpannSlIOT l\BH)I(eIIHe MhlcnH B Ty HnH

ApyrylO CTOpOlly"21.

Jlo BLlrOTCKoro nCHXOnOrnqeCKHH aIlanH3 peqH n06YAHn <ppaH~Y3CKoro HCCneA0BaTeJllI

ell. TIonalla pa3nHqaTh B cnone 3miqcIIHe H CMLlCJl22 • CMLICJI - no TIonallY - onpeAe­

JllIeTCli KOHTCKCTOM, B KOTOpOM ynoTpe6nlleTCli cnOBo. BLlrOTCKHH npHHHMaeT 3TY

TpaKTonKy, 110 HapliAY C IICH, 06paIQlUICL K HCKyccTny TeaTpa, OII npHAaeT Tf.pMHHY

20 CM.: EaxmuH M.M. 3CTeTHKa ClIOBeClloro TBOp'leCTBa. M., 1979. BepcHK 0 BlIKJlIIHH EaxTHlla Ha BblroTcKoro, npHHJlTOii PJlI\OM aDTopoD 3a 1\OCTOBepHyKJ, JI nOI\TBeplK)l.ellKii lie Ilarnell. B 6axTHHcKOM KpylKKe B cepel\Hlle 20-:< rol\OD BblroTCKHii Ol\eHKBalICJI KaK 6HxeBHopKCT (CM.: BO/lOWUIIOB B H 4>peii-I\H3M. M-JI., 1927. C. 31.). . •

21 Bbl20mclCuu JI.C. COOp. CO'l. T. 2. C. 24.

22 CM. TaM lKe. C. 347.

~:~ .

. ':"cMLlcn" npHHl\HDH8nhlI0 Honoe H3Mepe­

:'ICOBTeXCT, 8 nOATeKCT. nOHliTHe 0 KOT0p'

OXphlTLIH 3a BhlCKa3h1BaHHeM MOTHB no·

TeKCTa) CMhlCJI HeBhlBOAHM. Ero 06HaJE

AeACTBHSl. "3a Ka)l(A0il: pennHKoA repoll

BaDpaBneHBOe x BbDlonueQ:HIO onpeAene=

• . B noHHTHH 0 CMhlcne CXBalJeHa Taj;

· \ XOTeBBH, MOTHB~OBBOH HaDpll)l(eBBoC"

TIoBliTHe 0 cMLlcne BOlllJIO B pa3nH'

" C0<pHH C ~enhlO npOTHBOnOCTaBHTh BOCl!

· :JaAaHHlIM ee (3TOH nH1JHOCTH) 3eMHh1M,

o cMhlcne, BcneA 3a nOlIliTHeM 0 3Ha'l

paCCMaTpHBaTh 06a nOHliTHli B KaqeCi

OTnll'lHLlX no cBoeMY KaTeropHanhBoMy

HLIMH TepMHHaMH B nOrIfKe. nlfHrBHCTK

BO nCHxonoruqeCKHX AeTepMHHaDT )l(H3I

.'. nan TepMHHhI, AaBHO H npOlJHO yTBep):

)'DOTpe6nllIOTCli B pa3~qHLlX HenCHXOJli

3aAa'leil:. peweHHe KOTapO~, no Moep

xaTeropHanLHoro aJlanH3a. HMeHHo CHe

0'1' "Mop<ponorHH" KOTOpOH 3aBHCHT BR:

BhlH aBanH? reKCTOB BhIrOTCKOrO n03.

HaDThl, CHCTeMa KOTOphlX 06pa3yeT (E

pa30MKHYThlA no 0THollleHHIO K opraE

060pOTOM "3HaK.KaK nCHxonOrHqeCKOo

repMHHOM "3HaqeHHe" KphInaCh KaTera

3bmano lIa KaTcropHIO MOTHBa.

CMbICn cnOBa He CTan AJIlI BhlrOTCKC

KOTOpali Aana 6LI KnlOq KO nceMy nCHX:

nepeXCHBaDHIO. Teneph OH yTBep)l(Aael

C03BaHHlI, T.e. nOJlHOH, H3 KOTOpOH C

CTano 6hlTh, nepe)l(HBaUHe, nO-nepBI>­

BenH'IHHa B CTpyKType C03Halmll, BO-Bl

JIllli)l(yIQalI nOBeAeHHeM. H, HaKOHe~, B-1

BOH CHTY~HH ee pa3BHTHli. TepMHH "nepe)l(HnaHHe" - AaBIIHH

npHopHTeTHhlA xapaKTep JlHnhTeH, •

XCH3HeHHYJO ~enocrnOCTh. BhlrOTCKHH C

nepe)l(HHaHHH, - nHcan 011, - Aalla, C

APyroA - oc06eHIIOCTh MoeH nHqHOCTIt

Aon)I(H? 6hlTh npe06pa30BaHO. BenHq;

Be'lTO ~~lllIlee no OTIIOlllellHIO K pe6c:

06'heKTHHHhIX. 6e30rnOCHTenhHO K peE

<paKToM cYlQeCTBOnaDHlI ycnoBHH"27.

6naroAapli nepe)l(HBaDHIO pe6eHKa. "3 nepe)l(HBaHHH pe6eHKa, T.e. K H3yqeHl

23 Bbl20mclCuU JI.C. COOp. CO'l. T. 1. C. 3~ typ CrallHClIaBcKoro, me PIII\OM CpenJIHKo1i1 paro, KOHe'lHO, B CaNOM TeKCTe HeT.

24 0 CMblClle H 311AB'lax KBTeropHalIbllOrO XX cTOlIeTHH" (2-e H31\.1974). B Heii npe1\npH:

HblX nCHXOllOl'H'lecKHX 1IIK0lI.

25 BblzomClCur'J JI.C. COOp. CO'l. T. 4. C. ~

26 TaM lKe. IIepelKHBaHKe MblClIHlIOCb B

Cpe1\OBOe 06pa3YIOT reWTBlIbT ("eI\KIIHl\Y"). [ HHeM C 1\pyroii l\ellOCTHOCTblO - 3I1B'leHHe: nCHXOlIOrH'leCXHii NHp) H pe'lb (COl\KalIbllbIM IIJ

27 TaM lKe. C. 258.

88

:TCCT­ "CMbICJI" npHH~HnHaJIbHO HOUOC H3MCpeHHC. rCHcpaTopOM CMbICJla CJIOua ubICTynJIaCT HC

KOHTeKCT, a nOATeKCT, nOHliTHC 0 KOTOpOM uuen CTaHHCJIaUCKHH. IIOATCKCT YKa3bIuaCT Ha

~PUbIH CKpbITbIH 3a UbICKa3bIUaHHCM MOTHB nOCTynKa. 113 UCp6aJIbHOrO OKPYlKCHHlI CJIOua (KOH­

,M Ha TCKCTa) CMbICJI HCUbIUOAHM. Ero 06HaJKaCT CTOJIKHOUCHHC yqaCTHHKOU ApaMaTH'ICCKOrO

MHHH­ AcACTBHlI. "3a KalKAoA pCnJIHKOA rcpoll ApaMbI CTOHT XOTCHHC, KaK yqHT CTaHHCJIaBCKHA,

[CUbIN DanpaBJICHHOC K UblIIOJIBCBHJO onpeACJICHHblX BOJICBhIX 3a1{a'l"23.

[CHXO­ , B nOHlITHH 0 CMbICJIC CXBa'lCHa TalOKC H npCACTaBJICHHOCTb lKH3HH JIH'IHOCTH B CC

06y­ XOTCHHH, MOTHBaI\HOHHOA HanplllKcHHoCTH, npHCTpacTHOCTH, a<p<pcKTHBHOCTH.

npo­oc HC

IIOHliTHC 0 CMbICJlC BOIlIJlO B pa3JIH'IHblC HanpaBJICHHlI <pCHOMCHOJIOm'lCCKOH <pHJIO­

CO<pHH C ~enbJO npoTHBOnOCTaBHTb BOCXOlKACHHC JIII'lHOCTH K ~CHHOCTliM KaK HACMbHbIM

~MCTa 311AaHHlIM ee (3TOH JIH'lHOCTH) 3CMIlbIM, TeJICCHbIM n06ylKAcHHlIM. Y BbIroTCKoro nOHliTHC

IIMb­ o CMbICJlC, BCJICA 3a nOHlITHCM 0 3Ha'lCHHH, 06pcJIO OC06bIC npH3HaKH, n03BOJIlIJO~C

IICHHlI paccMaTpHBaTb 06a nOHliTHlI, B Ka'lCCTBC C06CTBCHHO nCHXOJIOmqCCKHX, CTaJIO 6bITb,

IIAOM, OTJIII'lHbIX no CBOCMY KaTcropHMbHoMy CTaTycy 01' cOAcplKaHHlI, COCAHHlICMoro C YKa3aH~

'3CTC­ HbIMH TCpMHHaMH B JIOrHKC, JIHlITBHCTHKC, <pCHOMCHOJICrHH. ,[(JIli 0603Ha'lCHHlI C06CTBCH­

lpHCH DO nCHXOJIOm'lCCKHX ACTCpMHHaHT lKH3HCACliTenbHOCTH qCJIOBCKa BbIrOTCKHH HCUOJIb30­

, KaK BaJI TCpMUHbI, AaBHO H npOqHO YTBCPAHBIillICCli B TC3aypycc pyccKoro 1I3bIKa. Bcc OHH

'YARc ynOTpe6JIliJOTCli B pa31U1.'1HbIX HCnCHXOJIOmqCCKHX KOHTCKCTax. 3TO CTMKHBaCT C OC060H

~aBHa 3a1{a'lCH, pCIIICHHC KOTapO(i, no MOCMy y6ClKACHHJO, HCB03MOlKHO HHaqC KaK nYTeM

II~CH,

:JIOUO

KaTerOpHMbHoro aUaJIH3a. HMCHHO CHCTCMa KaTcropH'A: 06pa3YCT "ccT'IaTyJO 060JIOqKy",

OT "Mop<p0JIOrHH" KOTOpOH 3aBHCHT BHACHHC nCHXHqCCKOH pCaJIbHOCTH24• KaTCrOpHaJIb­

IIARM, DhIH aDMH:? TeKCTOB BbirOTCKoro n03BOJIliCT 06HalKHTb 3a HX TCpMHHaMH TC ACTCpMH­

pa. B BaHThI, CHCTeMa KOTOpblX 06pa3YCT (B npOTHBOBCC aKCHOMaTHKC HHTpOCnCK~B:OBH3Ma)

pa30MKHYTbIH no opIornCHHJO K OpraHH3MY H CO~HMbHOMY MUpy npH'IHHHbIA PliA. 3a

map- , 060pOTOM "3HaK.KaK nCHXOJIOrH'ICCKOC 0PYAHC" pa3JIH'IaCTCli KaTcropHli ACHCTBHlI, 3a

IOUOC TCpMHHOM "3HaQCHHC" KpblJIaCb KaTcropHli nCHXH'ICCKOrO 06pa3a, a CJIOBO "CMbICJI" yKa­

"npo­ 3bIBMO Ha KaTcropHJO MOTHBa.

~pHaJI CMbICJI CJIOBa HC CTM AJili BbIrOTCKoro nOCJICAHCH "CAHH~eH" B nOHCKax "KJICTOQKH",

BaKH, KOTOpali AMa 6bl KJIJO'I KO UCCMy nCHXH'IcCKOMy CTpOJO QCJIOBCKa. 3Ty pOJIb OH ncpeAaJI

:HXO­ nCpClKHBaHHIO. Tcncpb OH yTBcplKAaCT, 'ITO "ACHCTBHTCJIbHOH AHHaMH'ICCKOH CAHHH~CH

,Horo C03BaHHlI, T.C. nOJIHOH, H3 KOTOpOH CKJIaAblBaCTCli C0311allHC, 6YACT ncpelKHBaHHCN25 •

lIcnc­ CTMO 6hITb, ncpClKHBallHC, Bo-ncpBbIX, HaH60JIcc nOJIHali (cpaBHHTCJIbHO C ApyrHMU)

nHCM BeiIH'IHHa B CTpyKType C03Haimll, BO-BTOpbIX, 3TO BCJIH'IHHa AHHaMH'ICCKalI, CTMO 6blTb,

laJIO­ AJDIlK~alI nOBCACHHCM, H, HaKOHC~, B-TpeTbHX, B HCM npeACTaBJICHa JIH'lIIOCTb B CO~Mb­

BOH CHTY~HH CC pa3BHTHli.

Hcro TcpMHH "nCpClKHBaHHC" - AaBIlHH rOCTb B <pHJIOCO<pHH H nCHXOJIOrHH. EMy npHAaJI

a HC DpBOpHTCTHbIA xapaKTCp ,[(HJIbTCH, HCTOJIKOBaB cro KaK HHTyHTHBHO nOCTHracMyJO

x Ha lKB3HCHHyro ~CJIOCTIIOCTb. BblrOTCKHH COCAHIIHJI C 3THM TCpMHIIOM APyroc COACPlKaHHC. "B ,ro H nepClKHBaHHH, - nHCaJI OH, - Aalla, C 0AlloA CTOpOllbl, cpCAa B cc OTHOIIICHHH KO MIlC, C

tine APyrOH - OC06CHHOCTb MOCH JIHQHOCTH"26. CorJIaCHoBblrOTCKOMY, caMO nOHliTHC 0 CpeAC

- 31'0 AOJIlKH? 6hITb npC06pa30BaHo. BCJIH'IaHiliCH nOMcxoH OH C'IHTaJI B3rJIliA Ha cpcAY "KaK

,ocro DCQTO ~~lIIHCC no OTIIOIIICHHJO K pC6cHKy, KaK 06CTaHOBKy pa3BHTHlI, KaK COBOKynHOCTb

puaJI

ry K

06'bCKTHBHbIX, 6C30THOCHTCJIbHO K pe6eHKy CY~CCTBYlOIQHX H BJIHlIJOIQHX Ha Hcro CaMHM

epaKToM C~CCTBOUaHHlI YCJIOBHH"27. CpcAa npH06pcTacT "HanpaBJIlIIO~Ce 3Ha'lCHHC"

doro 6J1arOAapli ncpelKHBallHJO pe6cHKa. "31'0 06113blBaeT K myooKoMY BHYTpCHHCMy aHaJIH3Y

IHTe­ ncpelKHBaHHH pc6cHKa, T.e. K H3YQellHJO cpeAbl, KOTopali ncpcllocHTCli B 3Ha'IHTCJIbHOH

HJIH

rcml

eAc­

, 23 B&/20mcKuiJJI.C. COOp. CO'l. T. 1. C. 357. BblroTCKJlA npHBO/lHT npHMepbl H3 pelKHccepcKHx napTH­

typ CrallHCJJaBcKoro, me pli/lOM C penJlHKoA repoll YKa38110 CTOllLl\ee 38 ileA xOTellHe, 0603118'1eIlHII KOTo­

poro, KOlle'lIlO, B eDMOM TeKCTe lIeT. 3TY 24 0 CMblCJJe H 3B1\8'1DX K8TeropHBJlbllOrO BJIBJlH3a B KOIIKpeTIIOA lIayKe CM. MOJO K1IHry "IlcHxoJlOrHll B

mHy XX CTOJIeTHH" (2-e H3/1. 1974). B ileA npe/lnpHIIlIT8 nonblTK8 K8TerOpHBJlblloro 811BJ1H38 KOlIl\enl\HH 38nBl\­

,HLIX nCHXoJloJ'H'lecKHX WKOJI.

25 B&120mCKuiJ JI.c. COOp. CO'l. T. 4. C. 383. 811a

:KOM 26 TaM lICe. IlepelKHB811He MblCJJHJlOCb BblroTCKHM K8K CHCTeMlloe 06p830BaIlHe. me JlH'IIIOCTlloe H

peA­cpe/loaoe oOP83)'1OT reUIT8J1bT ("e/lHIIHI\Y"), l\eJlOCTIIYIO npHpo/lY KOToporo BblJ'OTCKHK nOIlCIIlIJI cpaBlle­

7­ HHeM C /lpyroA l\eJlOCTIIOCTblO - 3118'1e1lHeM CJJOB8, r/le lIepa3/1eJlbHbi MblWJlellHe (0110 npe/lCT8BJllIeT

,~. IICHxOJIorn'leCKHA MHp) H pe'lb (COI\HaJlbllbiA npol\ecc).

~i 27 TaM lICe. C. 258. ,~

90

cTcnCBB B8Y11'L CaMOrO pC6eHlCa"28. Pa3BHTHC nCHXHKH - 3'1'0 He KOHBCpreH~WI 6HOJIO­

rJI1IeCItRx B BHeUIHC-CO~HaJILHLlX lj>aKTopOB, ·-HO OCTpOClOlIteTllali .llpaMa. H B ".llpaMY­

pa:nUFnlJl BCT}'DaeT HOBOC .lleACTBYIOlltee JIH~0"29 - JIH'lHOCTL pe6eHKa.

ApaMa o:ma'iaeT CTOJIKHOBCHHe. npOTHBO.lleAcTBHe, KOHlj>JIHKT XapaKTepoB. He 6e3~ lIB'IUOCTRLlC. BHCUIHHe 06CTOJlTeJILCTBa. a HMelOlltas: CBOH "c~eHapHH" .llHHaMH'leCKaJI

CllCTeMa B3lU1MOAcACTBWI H nocTynKoB .lleACTBYIOIQHX JIRQ - TaKOBa CO~HaJILHaJI "cpe.lla".

Ii JroTopoA lj>OpMBpYCTClI pe6eHOK KaK 0.llHH H3 Y1IaCTHHKOB 3TOA .l\PaMLI.

Oc:o(ioc 3Ua'leHHe BLlrOTCKHA npHAaJI nepeXO.llaM 0'1' 0.lllloro B03paCTa K .llpyrOMY.

Ito'ic)pww npBC}'lltII KOHlj>JIHKTLI H KPH3HCW30• H.lleJl 0 BHYTJ>eHHHX 3aKOHOMepHOCTlIX

pa3JU1TJ1J1 npBBeJIa cro K BaliCHOMY nOJIOllCCUHIO 06 onTHMaJILHLIX cpoKax 06Y'IeHHJI. B

rplUlKI(ali: 1t0TOPLlX OHO HlUI60JIee 3KOHOMHO H nJIO~OTBOpHO. H3 3Toro CJIe.ll0BaJIO He

TOnLltoDoJIOlltCHHC 0 TOM, 'ITO pe6CHOK .ll0JIliteH C03peTL .llJIJI yCBOeHHJI onpe.lleneHHOro

ypoau:niaBBA B HaBLIKOB, HO TaKlitC npe.llocTepClIteHHe 06 onaCHOCTH, rp03J1llteH

BOpMlllU.BOuy pa3BHTHIO JIH'lHOCTH, ecnH BpeMJI ynYllteHo.

B nepaLix AeTCKHx pe'leBLIX pCa~HJlX - "';;JIOBax" - BLIpaliteHO "alj>lj>eKTHBHO-BOJIIO­

1'IlHBoe~ -col'eplltauHe31. HMeHHo B 3TOM cO.lleplltaHHH KopeUHTCli TO oc060e OTHOUIeHHe

JIK'lHOCTII IC MHPY. KOTopoe BLIpaliteHO TCpMHHOM "nepelitHBaHHC". 3a HHM CKpLITLI

kou"nHKTLI H KpH3HCLI pa3BHTHIi. BUYTpeHHlIJI lItH3HL pe6eHKa "CBJl3ana C 60JIe3HeHHLIMH

• MY1IBTeJILHLIMH nepClItBBaHHJlMH. C BUY11'eHHHMH KOHlj>JIHKTaMH'·32. DnllTL nepe.ll HaMH

"nCllXOJIOI'H1i B TepMHHax .llPaMLI" - .llpaMLI BIIY11'eUllcit, He3pHMOH .llJIli BHCIIllIcro Ha6JIIO­

AaTen.. KOTOPOMY BH.llIlLI JIHWL OT.lleJILHbIe CHMnTOMLI B BH.lle KanpH30B. ynpJlMCTBa,

ueraTIIBH:JMa pe6eHKa H .llpyrHX npOJlDJIellHA "TPY.llIIODOcnHTyeMOCTH". )l(H3HeuIILlH nYTL

'IeJ{OReKa '::- ,3'1'0 HCTOpHJI ero nepelltHBaUHA. MJIa.lleH'leCTDO - 3'1'0 B03paCT rOcn0.llCTBa

"HepaC1JneUCHHhIX nepelitHBaHHA, npe.llC'l'aBilJIlOmHX KaK 6LI CnJIaB BJIe'leUHlI, alj>lj>eKTa H

QJl()oJl(eUBJI,,33. Ho Tor.lla HCTO'lHHK nepelitHBaHHA 3aKJIlO'lell B npOTHBOpe'lHH "Mellt.llY

MaltCHMaJILUoA CO~HaJILHOCTLIO Mna.lleH~a H MHUHMaJIbHLIMH B03MOlitHOCTJlMH

06~elDl."34. Ha paHilHX cTyneUJlX pC6CHOK ellte IIC 3HaeT CBoero "~". KpynHLIM UIarOM, OTKphI­

aaJO~M UOBylO rJIaBY B CTaHOBJICHHH JIH'lHOCTH. lIBJIlICTCJI nepeCTpOHKa, CBJl3aHHalI C

OCM...cnemIOA opHeHTHpOBKOA B c06CTDeHIILIX nepelitHBaHHJlX. B03HHKaeT "0606llteHHC

neP,elltKBaHHA HJIH alj>lj>eKTHBuoe 0606lltCHHe, JIOrHKa 'lynCTD"35. B nepelltHBaIIHH HHTe­

rpapoaauLi nOrHKa 'IYBCTB H JIOrHKa MLICJIH, 3aKOHOMCPlI0 BC.lly~e K CMeHe B03paCTHLIX

"cIJopM/UUlA". 3'1'0 AaJIO BLIroTcKoMY OCHOBaHHC BBCCTH nOHJlTHC 0 JIH'lHOCTIIOM B03paCTe,

ItU OTJUI'IaIOIqeMCJI He TOJILKO 0'1' naCnOpTIIOrO, 110 H TaK Ha3LIBaeMoro YMCTBCHHoro

~pac:Ta. (ieC'lHCJIeHHLIe H3MCpCHHJI KOTl)pOrO nyTeM pa3JIH'lULIX onpe.lleJICHHH "K03lj>­

c1J~eBTa BH'I'eJIJIeKTYaJILHOCTH" (JQ) nOrJI'JTHJIH 3HcprHIO I1CCKOJILKHX nOKOJICHHH nCHXO­

noroa.

I'o~en~ BLII'OTCKOrO ynHKaJILIIa CPC.llH .llPYrHX nanpannclIHA B03paCTHoA nCHXOJIO­

I'B.~ kOTOpali B TY 3noxy C'lHTaJIaCL Pa3.llCJIOM ne.ll0JIOrHH. BpJl.ll JIH CJIe.llyeT C'lHTaTL

CJl)"laAUOCTLIO. 'ITO 3JIOC'lacmoe napTHAHoe nOCTaHOBJIeHHe 0 ne.ll0JIOrHH 6WJIO np0.llHK­

TOBlIHO,CraJIHHhIM B 1936 r. B npeMBCpHH BOJILUIOrO Teppopa. HCTHHULIH nOJIHTH'IecKHA

CWLJeJl KpHTHItB "ne.lloJIOrH'IeCKHX H3Bp8llteHHA". nOBJICKWCA 3a C060H H3rnaHHe H3 WKOJILI

'-cCJleAOaaTeJIeA AeTeA. HX HH.llHBH.llYaJILHLIX pa3JIH'IHA, HX JIH'IIIOCTHLIX CJIOlitHOCTCA,

3~1C1I1O'IanCJI B TOM, 'IT06LI KYJILTHBHpOBaTL B napTHAuo-roCY.llapCTBellIlO ynpanJIlicMoA

Wltone eTaH.llap'l'IIOCTL MLIUIJICHHJI, 06e3JIH'IeIlHOCTL C~3IIaHHlI H .llCHCTDHJI. YHH'lTOllteHHe

!\eJIoA uaY1luoA 06JIacTH HeBepHO 6bIJIO 6LI 06'LJlClIlITL npHXOTblO CTaJIHlIa JIH60 JIH'IIIO

28T... ~e. C. 383. ;!g'TaN lite. C. 238.

~. BLIroreltHA ACTaJlbHO npowlaJlH3HpoRan KpH3HCbI ncpHOAa 1J000POlKACHHOCTH, ncpooro roAa, Tpex

JlCT !I ceNII nCT. IIpo6ncMa KpH3HCOB B pa30HTHH pe6eIlKa 06cYlKAanacb H 0 3anaAIIOii nCMXOnOnlH, HO HX

lIHyrpclDllIA xapaKTep HCH3Memi0 CIIOAHnCll nHOO K 3K30felHlb/1ol, nMOO K 6HOnOrM'fCCKMM npH'fMlIlIM•.

31 Cw. TaM lItc. C. 266.

32 T... lite. C. 250. '33' .

TaN lItc. C. 271. 34 :TaN lItc. c. 282.

, 35 -raNlitc. c. 309.

..-pOUyDIUHMH ero CJIY'laAHbIMH 060c'I

e.llenCHlIaJl CO~HaJILHO-nOJIHTH'lecKa.

,;,; " nceB.llO'l'eopeTH'leCKHMH co06palKcI

~H 6JIara TPY.llllII\HXCli. CO~aJIH3Ma.

.~ C JIHKDH.lla~HCH B 0IlHO'laCLe IIC.ll0Jl

:8AeonOrH'lCCKHX rpexax BCCX, KTO 1i

;"BhIroTcKoro. HHKTO He CMor CKa3aTb •

.:;06pa3 'ICJIOBeKa KaK JIH'lHOCTH, pa3BHB

- nonlipeH no OTHoweHHIO K TOMy, BO

~8BHnynHpoBaHHJI HMH KaK 06'LeKTa~

;,' ua6pOCKax TeopHH B03paCTOB (Kallt.llb

pa3BHTHlI JIH'lHOCTH) BLIrOTCKHA caMbIM

T)'aJILHhIe BhIKJIa.llKH C c06CTBeUHLIM

Ae-rcA. Ero TeOpHli. HMeJl BbICOKYIO lj>HJI­

'K B3Y11eHHe HCTOpHH nOHlITHA D OHTOr/:,

'1epuoBoA pa60Te C pc6eIIKOM, onHpa.

1C0TOPbIX 6bIJIH HM CaMHM "paCKonaUbI".

KOH~en~HJI BbIrOTCKoro Tpe60Bam:

pe(ieHKa". BalitHOCTb oxpallLI 3.ll0POBb:

CKoro• .lleKJIapHpOBaJIaCL nOBceMeCTIIO.

DHaJILIIO IIOBbIH nyIIKT. Pe'lb WJIa 06 ".

6epC'lb nCHXHKy pe6cIIKa C TO'lKH 3pel

KOToporo HMceT cBoA YIIHKaJIbHbIH CT

pOBaIIHe 3Toro - ry6HTCJIbIIO .llJIlI JIH'lI[

D'leBH.lleH He TOJIbKO lj>HJIOCOlj>CKO-1

CMLICJI TeopHH BLlrOTCKoro, npOHH3am:

03apeuo pa3pa60TaHHOe HM nOHJlTHe 0

nOHCKax HIITerpaJIbllOH CXCMbl Hcno_

JIH'IIIOCTH.

36 ITo oocnoMMHallMJlM B.E. rMypMalla, "n.

nony'fHnH Ha OCHooaHMM TCCTOO YMCTOCllllblC •

KOOCKoi!IlIKOnbl" (eM. JIeOHmbeB A,A. n.c. Bbo

37 HYlKlIO nM CUIC pa3 HanOMMllaTb, 'fTC

. _nynbCbl, HC "lKH3UCllllblH nopblo" H T.n., a

HeKnaCCM'fCCKOro HCOACTCpMHHMCTCKOro CTMnli

BOOHHKaeT He MHa'fC KaK 0 AHanOnl'feCKOH no

pa30HTMJI IIC003MOlKlla 6C3 ncpelKMoalOUlHX:

AononIlHTcnbHOCTH". ,UpaMaTH3M M AManorH3I

AooaHHoi! CHCTCMC OhlCIlIMX nCMXOnOrM'fCCKHX

TonbKO 3TO 06U1CnpHUJlTO'COJl3blBaTb C OKna;

6YAYJIlCC rnaoy 0 nCTonHCM nCMxonorMM.

38 "ITcpeCTpoHKa nOTpe6HOCTCii H n06ylK):

ncpexonc OT o03paCTa K o03pacTY" (Bbl20mc paCXOAllUlCMCJI C YOCpeHHOCTblO 0 caMOCTOlITCJ[

(cp. ITMalKc), 3aocplllanHcb, OCpllCC, 06pblBanl'!

OTnH'fIIOi! OT nOnXOAa nMollcpa 3Toro Hanl

Personality. N-Y., 1935). B 1933 r. nCOHH, :

craOIllYIO <fJalllMCTcKoii, OCTallOOHnClI lIa HCCKe

3NHrpMpooaTb, npeAnOlKHnH paOOTY. Ho 011

KOJlJlCAlK" Hop6epTa BMHcpa, KOTOpblH paOOl

HeOAlloKpaTIIO 6CCCAooan C neOHIIOM. ocr.

CBHneTcnbCTOYIOT nCOMIIOOCKMC oocnOMHlla

lIH'fIlOCTM. MOCKOOCKMe AManorM 6YAYUlHX

-, ", eocnpoH30cn nCOHIIOOCKMC 3KcncpMMCIITbl, 0

'. pa3pal5oTKC np06nCMbl nM'fHOCTM M CC MOTMoal :t

3aTPOllYUIlIHMH cro clIY'IaHIIhIMH 060CTORTclIhCTBaMH36• B cro 3110llcRHHRX B~rll,a 6hI-11a

OIlPCIIClICHlIlUI CO~HallhHO-nOllHTH'ICCKlUIJIOrHKa, H CBOH pCIlIeHHII OH "palllH;HaJIJ13Hpp­

Ban" nceBIIOTCOpCTH'IeCKHMH co06palKeHHlIhlH. npH3BaHHhIMIi y6cllliTL, 'ITO OHH npHHRThI

, PallH 6JIara TPYlIlllQHXCR, CO~aJIH3Ma. , " ,Hc 6Cl­

C JIHKnHlla~HCH B 0IlHO'IaChC nCII01l0rHH lIaQa1l0Ch H306JIH'ICHHe B q,HJIOCOq,CKHX Hm'!CCKlUI

BAe01l0rH'ICCKHX rpcxax Bcex, KTO 1allHMaJICR IIcTCKoit UCHXOJIOrHeit. B TOM .'IH,clle"cpclla",

BhIroTCKoro. HHKTO lIe CMor CKa3aTh rJIanlIOC - pa3pa60TaHHhIit HM ryMaHH<ilH'IcCKHA

06pa3 '1ClIOBCKa KaK llH'IlIOCTH, pa3BHBalOII.\p.itcR uo CBOHM BHyTpeHHHM 3aKOHC»437• 6hIlIIIpyrOMy.

DOJIlIpeH no OTlIOIlIeIIHIO K TOMy, BO 'ITO upenpaII.\aJIa JIlOllcJi: CO~HalIhH,~, U'p~J':X:Hlfa:pHOCTJlX MaBHDyJIHpOBaUHR HMH KaK 06"heKTaMH. CJIellyeT oc060 UOIl'ICpKHyTh, 'ITO .BCBOHX

'ICHHR, B Ba6poCKax TCOpHH B03paCTOB (KalKllhIit H3 KOTOphIX IIBJIIICT OIlHH H3 aKl'0B IIpa~hI

>BaJIO Hc pa3BHTHR JIH'IHOCTH) BhIrOTCKHA caMhIM UCUOCpellCTBeIIlILIM 06pa30M CooTHocJ,in KOHI~erl~

~JICHHOrO

TyallhHhIe BhIKJIallKH C C06CTBCHHhIM MlIOrOllcTHHM OUhITOM nOCUHTaH~R(,H.~'.o6y,c~HRp03RII.\cA

AeTeit. Ero TCOpHR, HMCII BhICOKYJO q,HJIOCOq,CKylO HanpanJICHHOCTh, 6hIJIa yKopeJicHa (K£

B H3yqcHHc HCTOpHH UOHIITHit B OHTorcHc3C, HX CBR3eH C PC'IhlO H liP.) B nonccl\lIcBHoi!:IO-BOJIIO­

'ICpHOBOA pa60Te C pe6CIIKOM. OnHpaJIaCh IIa IIJIOTHhIe nJIaCThi 3MUHpHH, (~orHe ,H3HOrncHHC

KOTOphIX 6hIJIH HM CaMHM "paCKOUaIIhI". ' " , , CKphIThI

KOH~cn~HR BhIrOTCKoro Tpc60Balla IIpaKTH'!eCKHX IIcJi:CTBHH "uo OXpaIiC pa3BHTHliICHHhIMH

pe6CBKa". BalKHOCTh oxpaIIhI 3110POBhll IICTCH, KaK q,H3H'ICCKoro. TaK H nCHXOJIOMe­)CII HaMIl

CKoro, IICKJIapHpOBaJIaCh nonCCMccTIIO. BLIrOTCKHH nIlOCHJI B 3TY lIeKlIap'axiH~'IIPHH~­) Ha6JIIO­

IIBa1IhHO 1I0BhIH nyuKT. PC'Ih IlIJIa 06 "oxpalIc Pa3BHTHII", CTaJIO 6hITh, 0 Hc06icoAHMOCTH pRMcTBa,

6ePC'Ih nCHXHKy pe6cIIKa C TO'lKH 3pelIHlI cro JIH'IIIOCTIIOro n03pacTa, KalKnaR H3 3nox hIH nYTh

KOToporo HMCcT CBOH YUHKaJIhIIhIJi: CTpOH ncpclKHBauHA, cnoH IIpaMaTH3M38• HmopH­cnollCTBa

pOBaIIHe 3Toro - ry6HTCJIhHO 111111 JIH'!IIOCTH, cYIILGa KOTOpOK 3aKJIa/lhIBaCTCR B IICTCTBC. lq,cKTa Ii

O'IenHlleU ue TOllhKO q,HJIOCoq,cKo-nCHXOJIOrH'ICCKHK. 110 H CO~HaJIhIIO-HpancTBeUlIhlii: : "MClKIlY

CMhICJI TCOpHH BhIroTcKoro. npoHH3alllloA 'IHCTOH np06hI ryMaIIH3MOM. 3THM 'iKe cUeTOM HOCTRMH

03apello pa3pa60TaHIIOC HM nOllllTHC 0 UCpClKHBaIIHH. CTanweccro nOCJIellHHM CJIOBOM B

DOHCKax HIITCrpaJIhlIoit cxeMhI HCIIOJlIICIUIOK IIpaMaTH3Ma opraIIH3a~HH H HCT()'PHH , OTKphI­ JIH'IIIOCTH. 3aHHlUI C

06II.\CHHC " "c, ',', ,~_r'

DH HHTC­ :t'",

IpaCTHhIx

103paCTc,

rBeHHOrO

{ "K03q,­

H nCHXO- 36 no oocnOMHHaUHlIM B.E. rMypMoua, "norpoM ne/lonoroo ua'lBnCli nocne HHJKOil OI(eHKIf; kOTOpYlo nony'lHnH Ha OCHOOOHHH TeCTOO YMCToellllLle cnOCOOUOCTH BacHnHlI CTBnHHa, TOrna Y'leIlHKa 110-il MOC­

llCHXOJIO­ , KOBCKOil WKonbl" (CM.ReOllmbe8 A.A. JI.c. BblroTCKHit M., 1990. C. 64). :, " !.. "

C'!HTaTh 37 HylKUO nH ell\e paJ HanOMHHaTb, 'ITO "OIlYTPeHuee" /lnll BblroTCKOro - aTO He cnolltllHHLle

npolIHK­ . , HMnynbCl.I, He "lKHJHeIlIlLlil nopblD" H T.n., a cHCTeMHoe oopaJOOaHHe, oo'LlICHeHHe KOTOporo Tpe6yeT

:'H'ICCKHH IreUaCCH'IeCKoro HeO/leTepMHHHCTCKOro CTHnll M,blwnellHlI. nepelKHoaHHe - 6YIIL 0110 ClIMoe HHTHMHoe ­" BOOHHKoeT He MHa'ie UK 0 /lHBnol'H'IecKoll no ollpe/lenellHIO /lpOMe paJBHTHli. Ho H COI(HBnbHaJI cHTyaI(HlI J IlIKOJIhi

paJOHTHli UeBOJMOlKlla 6eJ lIepelKHoalOll\Hx HH/lHOH/lOO. 3/1ecb /leiicToyeT cooe06paJHblii "npHHI(HnKHOCTCH,

l\ononHHTenbnoCTH". ~paMaTHJM H /lHanOrHJM, a He COMO no ce6e npe/lCTaOneHH,e 0 JnaKOBo-onocpe­.BlIRCMOH

l\008llHoil CHCTeMe OblCWHX nCHXOnOrH'IeCKHX q,YIIKI(HlI (MelKq,yuKI(HOIlBnbllbIX cOllJeil H T.n,), - 0 neAb rOlKCHHC TOJIbKO aTO ooll\enpHlIlITo'CBlIJLIOaTb C OKnllAoM BLlroTcKoro - OTKpLIOBnH 1I00ylO, yCTpeMJleHHyKl B ;0 JIH'IIIO (iyl\Yll\ee rnaoy 0 neTonHCH nCHXOnOI'HH. . ,

38 "nepeCTpoilKa nOTpe6HOCTeii H nooYlKllellHil, nepeOI(ellKa lIeuuocTell eCTb OCHOOHOii MOMenT npH

nepeXO/le OT OOJpaCTa K OOJpacTy" (BblwmCKUU R.C. Coop, CO'l. T. 4. C. 385). Ha aTOM nOnOJKeHHH, pacxOl\llllleMClI CyoepeHHOCTbH) 0 CllMOCTOliTenbHoil CTllAH8JlbHOii nOI'HKe paJOHTMlI KOrnHTHOHblX rpYH/,L\HlI (cpo nHalKe). JaOepWBnHCb, oepuee, ooPblDBnHCb lIa6pocKH BblroTCKHM /lHHOMH'IecKoll TeopHH nH'IHOCTH, OTJlH'IUoil OT nO/lXO/l8 nHOllepa aTom HanpaoneHHlI KYPTII JIeoHllo (Levin K.A. Dynamic: lheory of

'O/la, TpeX " Persona1ily. N-Y., 1935). B 1933 r. JIeBHH, Ha nYTH HJ KHTaJI (r/le ou '1HTan neKI(HH) B repMaHHH).

:1IH, HO HX CTlIIIwylO q,awHCTcKoii, OCTaUOOHnCli ua HeCKonbKO lIe/lenb 0 MocKoe. 3/1eCb eMy, npM1llloweMy peweUHe

M., 3MHrpHpoOOTb, npe/lnOlKHnH pa60Ty, Ho Oil npe/lno'len CiliA (ooiil\ll TaM onocne/lCTOHH 0 "HeJp_blll .. ItOnne/llK" Hop6ePTa BHHepa, KOTOpblii pa60TBn IIllA nporpOMMoil KH6eplleTHKH). B MOCKBe BblrOTCICHil (HeOl\II0KpaTHO 6eCe/1008n C JIeoHuoM, ocnapHoali (0 /lenHK8TUOM, /lpYlKeCToeHIIOM TOHe, 0 '1eM "CBH/leTenbCTOYIOT neOHUOOCKHe oocnOMHllaUHlI) ero npe/lCTBonellHlI 0 /leTepMHllaHTax lIooelleHHlI

~"H'IHlX:TH. MocKoocKHe /lHanorH 6Y/lYll\HX KnaCCHKOO MHpoooii nCHxonorHH (npH'IeM BblrOT~'~Hii • pOHJOen neOHIIOOCKHe 3KcnepHMeHTLI, ouecli 0 IIHX HOOLle nepeMellllble) CLlrpBnH OalKftYJO PO~'i. 0

pa60TKe np06neMbl nH'IIIOCTH H ee MOTHOaL\HH. 31'0 oco6aJ1 TeMa. ';'