Kegagalan dalam pengadaan jasa konstruksi

8/18/2019 Kegagalan dalam pengadaan jasa konstruksi

1/5

PENGADAAN JASA KONSTRUKSI

ARTIKEL TENTANGPERSEKONGKOLAN DALAM TENDER STUDI KASUS

DI INDONESIA

NAMA : ADE YUDHA ISWARA

NIM : 125060100111022

DOSEN : Dr. Eng. ACHFAS ACOE!" ST "MT

KEMENTERIAN RISET TEKNO#OGI DAN PENDIDIKAN TINGGI

UNI$ERSITAS !RAWIJAYA

FAKU#TAS TEKNIK

TEKNIK SIPI#


2/5

2016

Beberapa Kasus Persekongkolan Dalam Tender d Indonesa !ang "ela#

Dpu"uskan ole# KPPU$

D%&%' ()'*%+%,%n -n- %%n /-)'%%n /% %,, *)r*)/% %ng )&%+ /-(,3&)+ KPPU /)ng%n )(,%n %ng *)r*)/%" %,, ()r%'% /-)'%%n %r)n%

')nr KPPU -n/%%n )r,)* ')r(%%n ()r,)3ng3&%n /%n )&%+ ')&%ngg%r

P%,%& 22 Un/%ng4n/%ng N3'3r 5 T%+n 1" ,)/%ng%n %,, )/% /-n%%%n

3&)+ KPPU -/% )r*- ,)%r% ,%+ /%n ')%-n%n ')&%ngg%r P%,%& 22 Un/%ng4

n/%ng N3'3r 5 T%+n 1. D)ng%n /-)'%%nn% )/% %,, )r,)*

/-+%r%(%n /%(% ')n7%/- g%'*%r%n n ,/- %,, *)%(% /%&%' ')',%n

,% ()r'%,%&%+%n ()r,)3ng3&%n /%&%' )n/)r ')')r&%n ()'*-%n /%n

(r3,), %ng ,%ng% r'- 83'(&-%)/9 /%n 3'(&),.

%$ Pu"usan KPPU No$ &%'KPPU(L')&&%*

K%,, T)n/)r P-(%n-,%,- /- S'%)r% 3&)+ PT. C%&) P%-; In/3n),-%.K%,, -n-

*)r'&% /%r- ,% &%(3r%n %ng /-)r-'% 3&)+ KPPU (%/% %ngg%& S)()'*)r 2000" KPPU )'*%&- ')n)r-'% &%(3r%n /%&%' *)n

,)*%+ ,r% )r%ngg%& 1< S)()'*)r 2000" %ng *)r-,- ()rn%%%n *%+=% PT.

C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% )&%+ ')n)&)ngg%r%%n )n/)r %ng +%n% /%(% /---

3&)+ *)*)r%(% g)&-n-r r)%n%n ,%7%" /%n r)%n%n %ng &%-n -/% /%(% ')n-'%-.

?1@

P)ng%/%n ) KPPU )n%ng PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% - ,)n/-r- /%%ng /%r-

()ng,%+%4()ng,%+% )&%, )-& /%n ')n)ng%+. M)nr ()ng%/%n ')r)%"

/%&%' ')&%%n )n/)r (-(%n-,%,- /- S'%)r%" PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-%

')&%%nn% /)ng%n ,-,)' (%) %ng ')ng%-*%%n ()r,%+%%n4()r,%+%%n)-& /%n ')n)ng%+ -/% /%(% - /%&%' )n/)r )r,)*.

R)n%n% )n/)r /%r- PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% -n- /-%ngg%( -/% =%7%r *%g-

(),)r% 8*-//)r,9 %ng &%-n /%n -/% ')')n+- r-)r-% /%r- %,%, )%/-&%n /%n

),)%r%%n. R)n%n% )n/)r )r,)* ')'-&-- ))n%n4))n%n /%n

()r,%r%%n4()r,%r%%n %ng -/% &%B-' ,)()r- %ng /-(%%- /%n )n/)rng


3/5

n ')ng%r%+%n )(%/% ()'%,3 )r)n.P),)r% )n/)r +%n% )'(% *-//)r,"

%- PT. Prn% !-n% N,% %ng ')'-&-- %,-&-%, (,)-ng /%n +)% r)%')n"

,)+-ngg% +%n% /%(% ')n%=%r%n &3= gr%/)" PT P%r%-n/3 N,% P)r-=- 7g%

,)%r% /)ng%n PT. Prn% !-n% N,%" PT. C-r% T*-n/3 T*.

Y%ng ')'-&-- %,-&-%, (,)-ng /%n +)% r)%')n" ,)+-ngg% /%(% ')n%=%r%n

&3= gr%/) /%n +-g+ gr%/)" /%n PT. S)%'&),, P-() In/3n),-% J%%" %ng ,)%r%

/)ng%n PT. C-r% *-n/3 T*." /%(% ')n%=%r%n &3= gr%/) /%n +-g+ gr%/).

!)r/%,%r%n &%(3r%n4&%(3r%n )r,)* /- %%," /%&%' (,%nn% %+-rn% (%/%

%ngg%& 20 A(r-& 2001" KPPU ')n%%%n *%+=% PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% /%&%'

)n/)r %ng /-,)&)ngg%r%%nn% )&%+ ')&%%n ()r,)3ng3&%n /)ng%n /)ng%n

,)7'&%+ ()'%,3 %ng ')n7%/- (),)r% /%&%' )n/)r )r,)*. P)r,%+%%n

()'%,3 %ng /-%ngg%( )&%+ ')&%%n ()r,)3ng3&%n /)ng%n PT. C%&) P%,-;

In/3n),-% %/%&%+ PT. C-r% Tr*-n/3 T*." PT. P%r% In/3n,% P)r-=-" /%n PT. Prn%

!-n% N,%. M)nr KPPU -n/%%n (%r% ()'%,3 )r,)* ')r(%%n

()r,)3ng3&%n /%n )&%+ ')&%ngg%r P%,%& 22 UU N3'3r 5 T%+n 1.

Analsa

(,%n KPPU )r+%/%( PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% %/%&%+ -/% )(%" %r)n%

')ng)n%- ()r,%r%%n )n/)r %ng /-*)r-%n 3&)+ PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-%" -/%

')&%ngg%r %,%, /%n 7%n %ng /-%r /%&%' P%,%& 2 /%n < UU N3'3r 5 T%+n

1" %r)n% ()r*%+%n ()r,%r%%n /%&%' ()&%,%n%%n )n/)r %ng /-&%%n

3&)+ )r&%(3r %/%&%+ )*-7%%n ()&% ,%+% %ng -/% /-&%r%ng ')nr UU N3'3r

5 T%+n 1. S)/%ng%n ')ng)n%- (,%n KPPU %ng ')n%%%n *%+=%

)r&%(3r %% PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% )&%+ ')&%%n ()&%ngg%r%n P%,%& 22 UU

N3'3r 5 T%+n 1" %- -n/%%n ()r,)3ng3&%n %/%&%+ -/% )(%" %r)n%

,)&%'% ()n)&-/-%n %ng /-&%%n 3&)+ KPPU -/% ()rn%+ /-)'%n *- *%+=%

PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% )r&-*% /%&%' ,% ()r,)3ng3&%n.

H%& -n- /-,)*%*%n %r)n% PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% ,)*%g%- ()n)&)ngg%r% )n/)r

-/% )r*- /%n -/% )r&-*% /%&%' ,%+% ')n)n%n ()')n%ng )n/)r %ng

/-&%%n 3&)+ PT. C-r% T*-n/3 T*." PT. Prn% !-n% N,%" /%n PT. P%r%-n/3 N,%

P)r-=-. !)r/%,%r%n +%& )r,)*" %ng ,)+%r,n% /-7%/-%n )r&%(3r %/%&%+ )-g%

()r,%+%%n (),)r% )n/)r %ng )r&-*% ()r)'%n /- H3)& Ar%/%" %- PT.

C-r% T*-n/3 T*." PT. Prn% !-n% N,%" /%n PT. P%r%-n/3 N,% P)r-=-. H%& -n-


4/5

/-,)*%*%n %r)n% PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% ,)*%g%- ()n)&)ngg%r% )n/)r -/%

)r*- /%n -/% )r&-*% /%&%' ,%+% ')n)n%n ()')n%ng )n/)r %ng

/-&%%n 3&)+ PT. C-r% T*-n/3 T*." PT. Prn% !-n% N,%" /%n PT. P%r%-n/3 N,%

P)r-=-. O&)+ %r)n% -" %ng )r7%/- /-%n%r% ,),%'% (),%-ng /%r- (),)r% )n/)r

PT. C%&) P%,-; In/3n),-% %/%&%+ *%n -n/%%n ()r,%-ng%n ,%+% -/% ,)+%

%ng *)r*)n ()r,)3ng3&%n" )%(- -n/%%n ()r,%-ng%n ,%+% -/% ,)+% %ng

*)r*)n %r)&" /%n *)r/%,%r%n P%,%& 11 Un/%ng4n/%ng N3'3r 5 T%+n 1"

/-n%%%n *%+=% P)&% ,%+% /-&%r%ng ')'*% ()r7%n7-%n /)ng%n ()&% ,%+%

,%-ng%nn% %ng *)r'%,/ ')'()ng%r+- +%rg% /)ng%n ')ng%r (r3/,- /%n

%% ()'%,%r%n ,% *%r%ng /%n %% 7%,%" %ng ')ng%-*%%n )r7%/-n%

(r%) '3n3(3&- /%n %% ()r,%-ng%n ,%+% -/% ,)+%.

)$ Pu"usan KPPU No$ &+'KPPU(L')&&%*

K%,, T)n/)r P)ng%/%%n !%r-) /%n !)n3n-) !S0226 3&)+ YPF M%, S3+)%,

S'%)r% !.$.P)r%r% *)r'&% /%r- &%(3r%n (-+% ()&%(3r /)ng%n ,r%n%

)r%ngg%& 1> S)()'*)r 2001 %ng ')n%'(%-%n &%(3r%n ')ng)n%- T)n/)r

P)ng%/%%n !%r-) /%n !)n3n-) !S0226" ,)&%n7n% /-,)* /)ng%n T)n/)r N3.

!S0226. (-+% )r&%(3r %ng ,)%&-g, ')r(%%n ()n)&)ngg%r% )n/)r %/%&%+

YPF M%, S3+)%, S'%)r% !.$.. (-+% ()&%(3r ')ng%7%n )*)r%%n )(%/%

)r&%(3r n ')n-n7% &%ng +%,-& )n/)r )r,)*" %r)n% )r/%(%

))n/)rng%n ')ng%r%+ )(%/% ,% )n/3r /)ng%n *)*)r%(% %&%,%n" %n%r% &%-n

-/% )r/%(% )7)&%,%n ')ng)n%- ()ng)r-%n API W3'-ng !)n3n-) %r)n% API

,() 1


5/5

!)r/%,%r%n ))r%ng%n )r,)*" '%% ()&%(3r ')ng%ngg%( *%+=% )n/)r N3'3r

!S0226 %/%&%+ /-,r-'-n%- /%n *)r,-% '3n3(3&-,-. H%& -n- %r)n% ()r,%r%%n

%ng /-)%(%n 3&)+ )r&%(3r" %- !)n3n-) %ng /-(%,3 +%r, ')'-&-- %( API

'3n3gr%' /%n /-%ngg%( ')r(%%n ,% r)%%,% ,)+-ngg% /%(% ')ng%r%+

)(%/% ,% )n/3r" %- PT. MI In/3n),-%.

KPPU /%&%' (,%nn% ')n%%%n *%+=% T)r&%(3r" YPF M%, S3+)%,

S'%r% !.$. %ng ,)%r%ng *)rn%'% CNOOC S3+)%, S'%r% !.$. -/% )r*-

,)%r% ,%+ /%n ')%-n%n ')&%ngg%r P%,%& 22" P%,%& 1 +r % /%n /. Un/%ng4

n/%ng N3'3r 5 T)n%ng #%r%ng%n Pr%) M3n3(3&- /%n P)r,%-ng%n U,%+% T-/%

S)+%.?1

Analsa

K))n%n /%&%' P%,%& 22 Un/%ng4n/%ng N3'3r 5 T%+n 1" )r/%(% n,r4

n,r %ng +%r, /-()n+-" %- %/%n% ()&% ,%+% /%n %/%n% ()r,)3ng3&%n"

n%'n /)'--%n /%&%' ()r%r% -n- -/% /-)'%n n,r ()r,)3ng3&%n %ng

/-&%%n 3&)+ ()r,%+%%n YPF M%, S3+)%, S'%)r% !.$. +%& -n- ')ng-ng%

()r)'%n4()r)'%n %ng /-%/%%n %n%r% (-+% )r&%(3r /)ng%n PT. MI In/3n),-%

%/%&%+ *)r%-%n /)ng%n '%,%&%+4'%,%&%+ %ng 'n& /%&%' )g-%%n

()ng)*3r%n %ng ,)/%ng /-7%&%n%n" )r'%, ()n)/-%%n *%+%n4*%+%n

()ng)*3r%n /%n ()r%&%%n. D%&%' )n/)r -n- 7g% -/% )r/%(% -n/%%n

()n),%-%n %% ')'*%n/-ng%n /3')n ,)*)&' ()n)r%+%n %%

')n-(%%n ()r,%-ng%n ,)' n ')ng%r /%n ')n)%(%n ()')n%ng )n/)r.

!)r/%,%r%n +%&4+%& )r,)*" '%% n,r ()r,)3ng3&%n %ng )r/%(% /%&%'

P%,%& 22 Un/%ng4n/%ng N3'3r 5 T%+n 1 -/% )r()n+-.

Ole# * S!arp ,da!a" [Perancang Peraturan Perundangan Muda LIPI]

S'*)r : +(,:,r-.=3r/(r),,.3'20001()r,)3ng3&%n4/&'4)n/)r4

%ng4')ng%-*%%n4()r,%-ng%n4,%+%4-/%4,)+%4,/-4%,,4/-4-n/3n),-%4

%')r-%4,)r-%4/%n4%n%/%
https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/https://syukriy.wordpress.com/2008/08/18/persekongkolan-dlm-tender-yang-mengakibatkan-persaingan-usaha-tidak-sehat-studi-kasus-di-indonesia-amerika-serikat-dan-kanada/

Kegagalan dalam pengadaan jasa konstruksi

Documents

Transcript of Kegagalan dalam pengadaan jasa konstruksi