Beda Antara Verifikasi & Validasi

8/10/2019 Beda Antara Verifikasi & Validasi

1/18

http://www.faqs.org/qa/qa-18935.html

Question by bhalchanra

!ubmitte on "/#$/#%%"

&elate '(Q: comp.software.testing 'requently (s)e Questions *'(Q+

&ating: &ate this question: ,ote

what is the ierence between erication 0

aliation in software testing

(nswer by 2anish (grawal

!ubmitte on /1$/#%%"

&ating: &ate this answer: ,ote

,erication means to chec) whether things are going on as per the gien input an

specications.

,aliation means to test the prouct whether it wor)s correctly in functional

manner.

Answer by NavSubmitted on 6/22/2004Rating: Rate this answer:

Verification - Are we doing the thing right? (Efficiency)

Validation - Are we doint the right thing? (Effectiveness)
http://www.faqs.org/qa/qa-18935.htmlhttp://www.faqs.org/qa/qa-18935.html


2/18

4 ome 6 '(Q-&elate Q0(s 6 7eneral Q0(s 6 (nswere Questions

Search the Q&A Archives

Search Q&As

...difference between verification &validation in...


3/18

Rating: Rate this answer:

verification and validation

Answer by +anish Agrawa

Submitted on 6/*!/2004


Verification means to check whether things are going on as per the given inpt and

specifications.

Validation means to test the prodct whether it works correctly in fnctional manner.

Verifikasi berarti ntk memeriksa apakah hal-hal yang ter!adi sesai maskanyang diberikan dan spesifikasi.Validasi berarti ntk meng!i prodk apakah semanya ber!alan dengan benardalam cara fngsional.

Answer by Nav

Submitted on 6/22/2004


Verification - Are we doing the thing right?

(Efficiency)

Validation - Are we doing the right thing? (Effectiveness)

"av

Verifikasi - Apakah kita melakkan sesat dengan benar? (Efisiensi)Validasi - Apakah kita melakkan sesat yang benar? (Efektivitas)


4/18

"av

Answer by ,hina'aran

Submitted on 6/2-/2004


verification is process of determining the degree to which the work prodct of given

phase is satisfy the prior phase.

validation is a process to verify that application is working properly according to the

re#irements.

verifikasi adalah proses penentan se!ah mana prodk ker!a dari fase diberikanmemaskan fase sebelmnya.

validasi adalah proses ntk memastikan bahwa aplikasi tersebt beker!a denganbenar sesai dengan persyaratan.

Answer by .hang

Submitted on !/-/2004


$hat comes first and $hy???

Validation or Verification

Apa yang datang pertama dan %engapa???Validation or VerificationValidasi ata Verifikasi

Answer by sangi

Submitted on -/4/200

Rating: Not yet rated Rate this answer:


5/18

verification is condcted early in '.*t involves some reviews and meetings to

evalate the re#+ code+docments and specifications+ (are we bilding the right system).

validation is condcted at the end of development life cycle+ *t involves actal testing.

(did we bild the right system).

verifikasi dilakkan pada awal '.*t melibatkan beberapa review danperteman ntk mengevalasi re#+ kode+ dokmen dan spesifikasi+ (apakah kitamembangn sistem yang tepat).validation is condcted at the end of development life cycle+ *t involves actaltesting.validasi dilakkan pada akhir sikls hidp pembangnan+ sebenarnya inimelibatkan peng!ian.(did we bild the right system).(apakah kita membangnsistem yang tepat).

Answer by uddy

Submitted on /*1/200


Verification is the process of determining whether the system is in compliance with it,s

specifications.

Validation is the process of determining whether the system will work in the eal $orld

Verifikasi adalah proses ntk menentkan apakah sistem sdah sesai denganspesifikasi it.

Validation is the process of determining whether the system will work in the eal$orldValidasi adalah proses penentan apakah sistem akan beker!a di eal$orld

Answer by +ayan' +$

Submitted on /-/200


Verification is to check software workability.

Validity is to get otpt from system for a valid inpt.


6/18

Verifikasi adalah perangkat lnak ntk memeriksa kemngkinan ntkdilaksanakan.Validitas adalah ntk mendapatkan otpt dari sistem ntk inpt yang valid.

Answer by 3en'at

Submitted on /24/200


Verification takes place before validation+ and not vice versa. Verification evalates

docments+ plans+ code+ re#irements and specifications. Validation evalates the

prodct itself. /he inpt of verification is checklists+ isse lists+ walkthroghs and

inspection meetings+ reviews and meetings. /he inpt of validation is the actal testing of

an actal prodct. /he otpt of verification is a nearly perfect set of docments+ plans+

specifications and re#irements

Verifikasi ter!adi sebelm validasi+ dan bkan sebaliknya.Verification evalatesdocments+ plans+ code+ re#irements and specifications.%engevalasi verifikasidokmen+ rencana+ kode+ persyaratan dan spesifikasi.Validation evalates theprodct itself.Validasi mengevalasi prodk it sendiri./he inpt of verificationis checklists+ isse lists+ walkthroghs and inspection meetings+ reviews andmeetings.%askan dari verifikasi adalah daftar periksa+ masalah daftar+ daninspeksi $alkthroghs perteman+ tin!aan dan perteman./he inpt ofvalidation is the actal testing of an actal prodct. %askan dari validasi adalahpeng!ian yang sebenarnya prodk yang sebenarnya. /he otpt of verification isa nearly perfect set of docments+ plans+ specifications and re#irements 0tptdari verifikasi adalah yang hampir semprna kmplan dokmen+ rencana+spesifikasi dan persyaratan

Answer by aay#orwa

Submitted on /-*/200


Validation is done at development site and verification is done at client site

Validasi dilakkan pada pengembangan sits dan verifikasi dilakkan pada sitsklien


7/18

Answer by uday 'umar

Submitted on *0/1/200


verification means whether the system is right or wrong.

validation means whether this system is right system or wrong with respect to cstomer

e1pectations.

verifikasi berarti apakah sistem benar ata salah.

validation means whether this system is right system or wrong with respect to

cstomer e1pectations.validasi berarti apakah sistem ini adalah sistem benarata salah terhadap harapan pelanggan.

Answer by 5reeti

Submitted on *2/*/200


Verification ensres the prodct is designed to deliver all fnctionality to the cstomer.

Validation ensres that fnctionality+ as defined in re#irements+ is the intended behavior

of the prodct2 validation typically involves actal testing and takes place after

verifications are completed.

Verifikasi memastikan prodk ini dirancang ntk memberikan sema fngsikepada pelanggan.

Validation ensres that fnctionality+ as defined in re#irements+ is the intended

behavior of the prodct2 validation typically involves actal testing and takesplace after verifications are completed.Validasi memastikan bahwa fngsi+sebagaimana ditetapkan dalam persyaratan+ adalah perilak dimaksdkanprodk2 validasi aktal biasanya melibatkan peng!ian dan berlangsng setelahverifikasi selesai

Answer by beans


8/18

Submitted on *2/*/200


verification becase it is beans to beans to beans

Answer by ivan

Submitted on *2/2*/200


Verification3- *t is doing 4nit /esting on the prodct dring initial or intermediate or final

stages.

Validation3- *t is doing prodct testing where the entire prodct is ready and rnning and

yo are checking the entire fnctionality of the 5rodct application.

Verifikasi3 - *ni adalah melakkan 4nit /esting pada prodk selama awal atamenengah ata tahap akhir.Validation3- *t is doing prodct testing where the entire prodct is ready and

rnning and yo are checking the entire fnctionality of the 5rodct application. Validasi3 - *ni adalah melakkan peng!ian prodk di mana selrh prodk sdahsiap dan ber!alan dan anda memeriksa selrh fngsionalitas dari aplikasi5rodk.

Answer by RAQ

Submitted on */4/2006


Verification3 checking that the system6component (any work prodct) works in

conformance to the re#irements.

Validation3 checking that the system6component works in conformance to the

re#irements in its intended environment.


9/18

7oth are related to re#irements+ bt validation focses on the environment in which the

system will be working.

Verifikasi3 memeriksa bahwa sistem 6 komponen (sema prodk ker!a) beker!a di

kesesaian dengan persyaratan.

Validation3 checking that the system6component works in conformance to there#irements in its intended environment.Validasi3 memeriksa bahwa sistem 6komponen beker!a di kesesaian dengan persyaratan dalam lingkngandimaksdkan.

7oth are related to re#irements+ bt validation focses on the environment inwhich the system will be working.8edanya terkait dengan persyaratan+ tetapivalidasi berfoks pada lingkngan di mana sistem akan beker!a.

Answer by Aruna

Submitted on */**/2006


first verification comes then validation

we can !stify like this

Verification is one which we test or verify dring the Application is rnning

Application means here %odle

Validation is one which we follows after the prodct is completed

5rodct according to this collection of modles

verifikasi pertama datang kemdian validasi

we can !stify like thiskita dapat membenarkan seperti ini

Verification is one which we test or verify dring the Application is rnning Verifikasi adalah salah sat yang kita meng!i ata memverifikasi selama Aplikasisedang ber!alan

Application means here %odleAplikasi berarti di sini %odl


10/18

Validation is one which we follows after the prodct is completedValidasi adalahsalah sat yang kita mengikti setelah prodk selesai

5rodct according to this collection of modles5rodk sesai dengan modl

koleksi ini

Answer by abd

Submitted on -/*6/2006


Verification is done pon the docments like 9..+ ..+ % 5lan+ ecrity 5lan+ isk 5lan+

etc

Validation is done pon the actal prodct6software so as to check the rnning of itaccording to the re#irements.

"ow yo can tell which one is done first.. rite?

Verifikasi dilakkan atas dokmen-dokmen seperti 9+ + % 5lan+ 8eamanan5lan+ isk 5lan+ dllValidation is done pon the actal prodct6software so as to check the rnning ofit according to the re#irements.Validasi dilakkan atas prodk sebenarnya 6perangkat lnak sehingga dapat memeriksa men!alankan sesai denganpersyaratan."ow yo can tell which one is done first..ekarang Anda dapat mengatakanmana yang dilakkan terlebih dahl ..rite?rital?

Answer by ritu

Submitted on -/21/2006


adfasdf

Answer by +ohanasarat


11/18

Submitted on /**/2006


Validation & Verification

Answer by asd%

Submitted on /-0/2006


the best definition i,ve seen is that verification makes sre prodct works as advertised

to otside pblic2 while validation makes sre prodct meets company,s internal

specifications.

definisi terbaik yang pernah klihat adalah bahwa verifikasi memastikan prodkbeker!a sebagai diiklankan ke pblik di lar+ sedangkan validasi memastikanprodk memenhi spesifikasi internal persahaan.

Answer by e

Submitted on !/1/2006


AAA::::;;;

'oes this mean that+ if * am doing */


12/18

$eb+ saya cek akan verifikasi !ika apa yang saya lakkan set! dengan t!ansebelm melakkan it dan validasi akan memeriksa hal-hal seperti spell 6grammar check?(* need to know "0$;?;)(Ak perl tah E8AA"


13/18


%ost 0f people ay,s+that+validation comes 9irst+7t my thinking is +Verification omes

9irst and /hen Validation+7ecase 4ntil and nless i will "ot %ake ight /hing :ow $e

an 4se+/hat,s$hy Verification omes 9irst..

8ebanyakan 'ari orang 8atakanlah,s+ bahwa+ validasi datang 5ertama+ /apipemikiran saya adalah+ Verifikasi omes 5ertama dan al Validasi+ 8arenaampai dan kecali saya akan /idak %embat ight /hing 7agaimana 8ami'apat %enggnakan+ /hat,s$hy Verifikasi omes 9irst ..

Answer by a%a&



Verification - hecking the redentials we have or not ( heck Employee have *' ard )

Validation - hecking the credentials that we have are right or wrong (Employee can *'

ard and if right door opens )

Verifikasi - %emeriksa 8redensial kita ata tidak (5eriksa 8aryawan memiliki *'ard)

Validation - hecking the credentials that we have are right or wrong (Employeecan *' ard and if right door opens )Validasi - %emeriksa kepercayaan yang kitamiliki adalah benar ata salah (Employee can *' ard dan !ika kanan pintterbka)

Answer by 37R83A9



=3 $hat is the difference between verification and validation?

A3 Verification takes place before validation+ and not vice versa.


14/18

Verification evalates docments+ plans+ code+ re#irements+ and specifications.

Validation+ on the other hand+ evalates the prodct itself.

/he inpts of verification are checklists+ isses lists+ walkthroghs and inspection

meetings+ reviews and meetings. /he inpt of validation+ on the other hand+ is the actal

testing of an actal prodct.

/he otpt of verification is a nearly perfect set of docments+ plans+ specifications+ and

re#irements docment. /he otpt of validation+ on the other hand+ is a nearly perfect+

actal prodct

=3 Apa perbedaan antara verifikasi dan validasi?

A3 Verification takes place before validation+ and not vice versa.>3 Verifikasiter!adi sebelm validasi+ dan bkan sebaliknya.

Verification evalates docments+ plans+ code+ re#irements+ and specifications.%engevalasi verifikasi dokmen+ rencana+ kode+ persyaratan+ dan spesifikasi. Validation+ on the other hand+ evalates the prodct itself.Validasi+ di sisi lain+mengevalasi prodk it sendiri.

/he inpts of verification are checklists+ isses lists+ walkthroghs andinspection meetings+ reviews and meetings.%askan-maskan dari verifikasiadalah daftar periksa+ masalah daftar+ dan inspeksi $alkthroghs perteman+tin!aan dan perteman./he inpt of validation+ on the other hand+ is the actaltesting of an actal prodct.%askan dari validasi+ di sisi lain+ adalah peng!ianyang sebenarnya prodk yang sebenarnya.

/he otpt of verification is a nearly perfect set of docments+ plans+specifications+ and re#irements docment.0tpt dari verifikasi adalah yanghampir semprna kmplan dokmen+ rencana+ spesifikasi+ dan persyaratandokmen./he otpt of validation+ on the other hand+ is a nearly perfect+ actalprodct0tpt validasi+ di sisi lain+ adalah yang hampir semprna+ prodksebenarnya

Answer by a'shatha

Submitted on -/21/200!


Verification means set of activities that ensres the software that correctly implements

the fnction.


15/18

Validation means set of activities that ensres the software has been bilt is tracable to

cstomer re#irement.

Verifikasi berarti serangkaian kegiatan yang memastikan perangkat lnak yang

benar mengimplementasikan fngsi.Validation means set of activities that ensres the software has been bilt istracable to cstomer re#irement.Validasi berarti serangkaian kegiatan yangmemastikan perangkat lnak telah dibangn adalah tracable kebthanpelanggan

Answer by #rasadtavva

Submitted on /1/200!


Verification comes first. /hen the validation.

Verification is done at each level or step of the development process

reviews@

Validation is done to yor end prodct or code. All kinds of testing@

efer

http366www.ble.com6editorials6B-C-DC-FGHHI.asp

orry for keeping nit testing and some other testing nder Verification in my earlier

note@

Verifikasi lebih dl./hen the validation.8emdian validasi.

Verification is done at each level or step of the development process Verifikasidilakkan pada tiap tingkat ata langkah dalam proses pembangnan reviews@lasan@

Validation is done to yor end prodct or code.Validasi dilakkan ntk prodkakhir Anda ata kode.All kinds of testing@ema !enis peng!ian@

eferihathttp366www.ble.com6editorials6B-C-DC-FGHHI.asphttp366www.ble.com6editorials6B-C-DC-FGHHI.asp


16/18

orry for keeping nit testing and some other testing nder Verification in myearlier note@%aaf ntk men!aga peng!ian nit dan peng!ian lainnya di bawahVerifikasi dalam catatan sebelmnya@

Answer by +ittar hardwa

Submitted on /*!/200!


Verification comes before Validation becase Verification evalate 'ocments+ plans+

code+ re#irements and specifications.

Validation evalates the prodct. /he prodct can be evalated as per its specifications

and it is e1pected that the prodct will be validated rightly if re#irements+ specifications

are correct.

Verifikasi datang sebelm Validasi karena mengevalasi Verifikasi 'okmen+rencana+ kode+ persyaratan dan spesifikasi.

Validation evalates the prodct.Validasi mengevalasi prodk./he prodct canbe evalated as per its specifications and it is e1pected that the prodct will bevalidated rightly if re#irements+ specifications are correct. 5rodk dapatdievalasi sesai dengan spesifikasi dan diharapkan bahwa prodk akandivalidasi tepat !ika persyaratan+ spesifikasi sdah benar.

Answer by srini

Submitted on /*/200!


Verification is the process of ensring that the prodct(As a whole) which we are

developing is right.9or E13 eviewing the $ork 5rodcts(9nctional pecs+high leveldoc+'esign 'oc etc)+ reviewing the code(tatic %ethods)etc.....

Validation is the process of ensring that the prodct which we have bilt(ompleted) is

right and is as per the re#irements and matches all the ser re#irements...


17/18

Verifikasi adalah proses ntk memastikan bahwa prodk (ecara keselrhan)yang kami kembangkan adalah right.9or E13 %ereview 5rodk 8er!a (9nctionalpecs+ tingkat tinggi doc+ 'esain 'oc dll)+ memeriksa kode (tatic %ethods)+dll ....

Validation is the process of ensring that the prodct which we havebilt(ompleted) is right and is as per the re#irements and matches all the serre#irements...Validasi adalah proses ntk memastikan bahwa prodk yangkami telah membangn (engkap) yang benar dan sesai dengan persyaratandan sesai dengan sema persyaratan penggna ...

;our answer wi be #ubished %or anyone to see and rate$ ;our answer wi not bedis#ayed immediatey$ 8% you


18/18

other #ro%essiona advice$ "AQS$>R? does not endorse any o#inion or any #roduct or service mentionedmentioned in these #osts$

Beda Antara Verifikasi & Validasi

Documents

Transcript of Beda Antara Verifikasi & Validasi