European Research Studies Journal Volume XXIV, Special Issue 1, 2021 pp. 152-170
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding Submitted 05/01/21, 1st revision 08/02/21, 2nd revision 28/02/21, accepted 20/03/21
Dorota Kurek1
Abstract:
Purpose: The aim of the conducted research was to show what kind of solutions based on
artificial intelligence are used by modern organizations to automate HRM activities and carry
out the so-called digital employer branding.
Approach/Methodology/Design: Scientific literature and other reports connected with
employer branding and AI were analyzed. Choosing from the group of methods, the author of
the article used analysis, synthesis, abstraction, analogy, and comparison.
Findings: The research results show that solutions based on AI have found application in
onboarding, talent management process or improvement of employee competences. Applicant
Tracking Systems, Talent Acquisition Systems and Talent Management Systems as well as
chatbots are changing the process of employer branding into digital employer branding.
Practical Implications: The results are significant to all kinds of organizations among which
there are also public organizations. Implementation of new technologies will not only change
the image of the organizations but also will make the HRM activities more objective and easily
managed especially while remote work.
Originality/Value: The research provides theoretical assumptions and practical answers to
encourage further research globally.
Keywords: Artificial intelligence, processes automation, digital employer branding, HRM
activities.
JEL classification: F16, J5.
Paper Type: Research article.
Conflict of interest: The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
1Ph.D., War Studies University, Warsaw, Poland, Management Institute Management and
Command Department, e-mail: [email protected]
Dorota Kurek
153
1. Introduction
Constantly changing customer requirements in connection with the dynamic
development of modern technologies cause more and more organizations to make
efforts to use in practice IT solutions allowing for the improvement and simultaneous
modernization of processes, including personnel processes. The changes made are
motivated not only by the very desire to improve, but above all to reduce repetitive
work, and thus monotonous and time-consuming one, which also allows for fuller use
of the potential of employees by involving them in other more creative activities. The
digital revolution, including the impression of artificial intelligence solutions, allows
for a change in the image of an organization, which is particularly important for
companies operating in an environment with a high level of competitiveness, and thus
organizations caring for their own image as a desired employer in the market, which
is directly related to the employer branding strategy implemented by many
organizations. Considering the progressive automation of personnel processes, the aim
of this article is to show what solutions based on artificial intelligence (AI) are used
by modern organizations to automate personnel processes and implement the so-called
digital employer branding.
Choosing from the group of methods, the author of the article used analysis, synthesis,
abstraction, analogy, and comparison. Special attention was paid to reports covering
the AI issue and the analysis of websites of selected organizations dealing with
employee recruitment and shaping the organization's image, which allowed for the
identification of IT solutions used in practice and allowing for the automation of
processes and the implementation of digital employer branding. The analysis was also
carried out on the offers of companies creating solutions based on artificial
intelligence for the needs of customers and in accordance with their guidelines, which
made it possible to achieve the research objective.
2. Artificial Intelligence in the Service of Modern Organizations –
advantages and Disadvantages of Business Automation
Artificial intelligence is a term that appears more and more often in scientific and
business discussions as well as in everyday life. According to Mijwel (2015),
“Artificial intelligence is the general name of the technology for the development of
machines, which are created entirely by artificial means and can exhibit behaviors
and behaviors like human beings, without taking advantage of any living organism.
Artificial intelligence products, which, when approached as an idealist, are
completely human like and can perform things such as feeling, foreseeing, and making
decisions, are generally called robot names” (Mijwel, 2015: 3). Whereas in Oxford
Dictionary AI is defined as “the theory and development of computer systems able to
perform tasks normally requiring human intelligence, such as visual perception,
speech recognition, decision-making, and translation between languages” (Oxford
Dictionaries, 2019). However, according to the Encyclopedia Britannica, “Artificial
intelligence (AI), the ability of a digital computer or computer-controlled robot to
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
154
perform tasks commonly associated with intelligent beings. The term is frequently
applied to the project of developing systems endowed with the intellectual processes
characteristic of humans, such as the ability to reason, discover meaning, generalize,
or learn from experience” (Copeland, 2020).
The term artificial intelligence was first used in 1956 at the Dartmouth Conference
(Spector, 2006: 1251), but, referring to the pages of history, mention of this type of
solution, namely humanoid robots, can already be found in ancient Greek mythology
(Mijwel, 2015). Marvin Minsky, who stated in his book “Stormed Search for Artificial
Intelligence” that “the problem of artificial intelligence modeling within a generation
will be solved” (Mijwel, 2015: 2), was therefore not wrong. The next breakthroughs
showing the technological progress and growing interest of AI are the computer
winning a chess match with master Garry Kasparov in 1997, or the sorting out the
Rubik's cube combination by using less than 20 moves (2010).
Artificial intelligence combines three key elements, such as, high-speed computation,
a huge amount of quality data and advanced algorithms differentiate AI from ordinary
software (EY, 2018: 1). The use of special algorithms increases the accuracy of the
performed actions, thus eliminating the so-called human factor error, moreover, “the
technology based on artificial intelligence is able to imitate the cognitive functions
that we attribute to the human mind, including the ability to solve problems and learn”
(Syam and Sharma, 2018).
Artificial intelligence, originally associated with science fiction films, has been
permanently applied in contemporary organizations, becoming an essential element
for modernizing and accelerating particularly repetitive processes. According to Amer
Awad Alzaidi (2018) “artificial intelligence as a field of science has become a
competition for modern computer systems. The application of human-like reasoning,
learning and self-correction capabilities, combined with the development of hardware
and software technologies, has made it possible to offer users technological solutions
based on complex algorithms, communicating at high speed, allowing for efficient
decision-making, by some considered comparable to human decisions, by others – far
beyond the capabilities of experts” (Alzaidi, 2018: 140).
Artificial intelligence has found its greatest application in sales, marketing (Jarek and
Mazurek, 2019: 49-51) and human resources (Ruby Merlin and Jayam 2018). Wayne
F. Cascio and Ramiro Montealegre in their article "How Technology Is Changing
Work and Organizations" (2016) show in detail the issue of technology impacting the
change of work environment and the organizations themselves. The authors stress the
need to conduct in-depth research on the impact of the technology using, among
others, the ethnographic method (Barley, 2015) and experience sampling (Beal, 2015)
to maximize the positive effects on individuals and organizations and minimize the
negative effects. The above-mentioned action will be a stimulating and continuous
challenge for the following years, as AI enters almost every area of human life – both
private and professional (Cascio and Montealegre, 2016).
Dorota Kurek
155
However, not all organizations are in favor of implementing solutions based on AI.
The main reasons for this attitude include:
− the cost of implementing solutions,
− the fear of losing the confidentiality of personal data,
− the need to use more safety protocols to develop a safe automatic
environment,
− the need to update and maintain solutions,
− limited possibility of integrating existing systems with AI-based solutions,
− dehumanization of personnel activities,
− the need to adapt solutions to the legal and ethical requirements of the country
and organization in question (Khanzode and Sarode, 2020).
The staff themselves draw attention to concerns that they are being deprived of a
certain range of activities, which may contribute to job cuts, especially in posts where
staff have been responsible for repetitive and routine tasks and therefore not requiring
a high level of competence. In turn, researchers Peter Cappelli, Prasanna Tambe, and
Valery Yakubovich show four main problem areas directly related to the use of AI-
based solutions in HR, such as:
1. complexity of HR phenomena,
2. constraints imposed by small data sets,
3. ethical questions associated with fairness and legal constraints,
4. employee reaction to management via data-based algorithms (Cappelli,
Tambe, and Yakubovich, 2018).
Huge concerns about the use of artificial intelligence are also linked to the
understanding of the word intelligence, which for many people is intrinsically linked
to human as a key human attribute, not a machine (Mijwel, 2015). Those in favor of
these solutions, in turn, point out:
− reducing the burden of repetitive activities on employees, such as answers to
customer questions,
− reducing subjectivity in processes, which has a positive effect on the
organization's image as an employer,
− shortening the time of the activities,
− facilitating reporting activities and the calculation of return on investment,
− the possibility of relieving the burden on the organization and directing its
main efforts towards activities directly contributing to its success and market
position (Chowdhury and Sadek 2012; Ahmed, 2018; Khanzode and Sarode,
2020).
The implementation of AI solutions requires several components, such as cloud
solutions, digital help e.g., assistants, automated machine learning, APIs allowing to
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
156
connect to multiple messengers (Skype), social networking messengers or non-
standard chatbots. As EY company emphasizes “A key medium of conversational AI
is the chatbot. This product provides intuitive instruction and performs pattern studies
to act as a smart and efficient assistant. The bot uses logic to determine user inquiries
and connect with enterprise systems to get the desired results. Machine learning plays
an important role, working with patterns and using cleaner sets of data” (EY, 2018:
5).
The practical use of modern IT solutions by many organizations is an obligatory
element allowing for the effective use of the resources held. However, many
companies are still afraid of implementing solutions based on AI, which does not mean
that they will not be forced to do so by the economic situation, as many organizations
have found out in connection with the Covid-19 pandemic. Changes in the use of AI
have already been seen to a large extent when comparing the results of the 2018 and
2019 studies conducted by Oracle and Future Workplace. The study of 8,370
employees, managers, and HR leaders across 10 countries, found that AI is becoming
more prominent with 50 percent of workers currently using some form of AI at work
compared to only 32 percent last year. Workers in China (77 percent) and India (78
percent) have adopted AI over 2X more than those in France (32 percent) and Japan
(29 percent). The majority (65 percent) of workers are optimistic, excited, and grateful
about having robot co-workers and nearly a quarter report having a loving and
gratifying relationship with AI at work. Workers in India (60 percent) and China (56
percent) are the most excited about AI, followed by the UAE (44 percent), Singapore
(41 percent), Brazil (32 percent), Australia/New Zealand (26 percent), Japan (25
percent), U.S. (22 percent), UK (20 percent) and France (8 percent) (Oracle, 2019).
Greater interest and confidence in artificial technology is not only due to
organizational needs, but above all to the cultural specificity of generations Y and Z,
which have entered and continue to enter the labor market, mostly recognizing modern
technologies as natural and obvious solutions (scientists point out to avoiding
generalization in relation to representatives of generations – Lyons and Kuron, 2013;
Brant and Castro, 2019). An upward trend in the interest in and use of solutions based
on AI will be visible in the coming years, and the pace of its implementation will
largely depend not only on the financial background of the organization, or on gaining
supporters of such solutions, but above all on the economic situation, social needs,
and the level of competition on the market.
3. Needs vs. Difficulties in Automating Processes in an Organization
According to the 2020 company report Oracle’s Top 10 Cloud Predictions. The impact
automation, AI, machine learning, blockchain, and more will have on IT by 2025, one
of the 10 key changes that organizations will face in the near future will concern the
fact that “Automated business processes will enable more personalized interactions in
HR, sales, and other business domains” (Oracle, 2020: 12). The authors of the report
emphasize that “AI and autonomous technologies are permeating the workplace,
Dorota Kurek
157
streamlining routine business processes and freeing up professionals to focus on
more-meaningful and productive human interactions. For example, automated
workflows can streamline recruiting operations by tracking applicants and fielding
requests from new hires. Some HR teams use AI to identify top candidates by
comparing their stated qualifications against job postings. Chatbots can communicate
with candidates to answer questions and schedule interviews. These automated
functions alleviate routine administrative tasks so HR professionals can focus on
hiring qualified candidates that match the corporate culture. By 2025, 70 percent of
recruiting will be taken over by AI and bots” (Oracle, 2020: 13).
The implementation of modern solutions in the case of many organizations has led to
a situation where the existing systems are not fully interconnected, as evidenced by
data from the “Leading the social enterprise report: Reinvent with a human focus:
2019 Deloitte Global Human Capital Trends”, according to which many
organizations still have a mixed set of HR systems in place. Only 5 percent of this
year’s survey respondents told us they have a fully integrated HR cloud platform. Most
of the others have some combination of cloud and on-premises software, and 29
percent have no systems at all. Since many organizations are still using and
maintaining numerous HR systems, the quality of the user experience and the level of
integration have not reached the levels often promised by HCM cloud vendors.
Many organizations are using employee engagement layers to improve their solutions’
overall usability and to provide a higher level of technical and functional integration
(Deloitte, 2019: 94). The lack of integration of the systems, or the implementation of
only half of the solutions, leads many users of AI-based systems to think that the
solutions offered to them are not able to fully meet their needs. Organizations expect
a great deal from modern solutions, so it can be considered that they see the possibility
of improving these tools, as confirmed (Figure 1).
Meeting the expectations of users is a task faced daily by employees of many
companies offering AI-based systems, so it can be considered that the user experience
itself is a huge source of inspiration for changes in systems, including enriching them
with solutions and links that have not been implemented before. The market of HR
technologies based on AI is constantly developing, thanks to which we can see more
and more solutions offered by companies that already cover almost all areas of
personnel activity, including recruitment and selection, talent mobility management,
employee appraisal, onboarding, training, communication and knowledge exchange,
work organization, benefits, or payroll administration. Other areas that are also slowly
becoming more and more automated include surveys of employee opinion and
engagement, tools to build a good atmosphere and wellbeing of employees linked to
coaching activities, performance management, tools to support self-study of
employees or to allow employees to keep up to date with unethical situations at work,
also to reduce harassment (Deloitte, 2019).
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
158
Figure 1. Organizations generally expected more than they actually got from their
HR cloud system
Source: Based on Deloitte Insights (2019), Leading the social enterprise: Reinvent with a
human focus. 2019 Deloitte Global Human Capital Trends, p. 95.
https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/cz/Documents/human-capital/cz-hc-trends-
reinvent-with-human-focus.pdf.
AI is applied in many areas of functioning of contemporary organizations (Mihalcea,
2017), as it is emphasized in the EY publication: Human resources executives have
faith that merging AI into HR administration functions will benefit and improve the
overall employee experience. This will provide more capacity, more time and budget,
and more accurate information for decisive people management (EY, 2018: 1).
Applications based on artificial intelligence therefore allow not only to increase the
potential of employees, change the image of HR departments to a more professional
one, but above all to improve analysis, prediction, and diagnosis activities. However,
the choice of technology adequate to the needs should be based on the recognition of
the requirements of the organization, the employees themselves, as well as the
knowledge of organizational culture, as these are the key elements in adjusting
solutions to the existing systems and internal organization relations.
The implementation of solutions based on artificial intelligence also requires the
creation of an appropriate climate in the organization which will be conducive to
change, and this is possible through the following actions:
− to thoroughly test the solution before it is implemented in the organization to
ensure that the results are acceptable and that the business model fits into the
existing values, organizational culture, and strategy,
− to precisely define the purpose of the solution and to promote this purpose
among the employees,
− to make employees aware of the disadvantages and advantages of the new
solution by showing them specific situations,
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
other
consolidated view
easier to use, less training needed
increased HT tech innovation
ease of uploads and new releases
lower costs of ownership
better data and workforce insights
real-time data and dashboards
shift toward becoming a strategic HR function
better employee experience
3%
57%
59%
59%
59%
59%
60%
61%
61%
65%
4%
48%
35%
32%
38%
33%
40%
44%
28%
39%
actual expected
Dorota Kurek
159
− to encourage employees to gather their experience, which can provide the
necessary information to better tailor the solution to existing needs,
− to involve the employees from the department to which the solution is
dedicated in the process of its creation, which will allow for closer
cooperation with the IT department,
− to define the expectations of workers reasonably distributed over time,
assuming an adequate amount of time to learn and get used to the solution in
practice,
− to prepare training for employees to enable full testing of the solution,
− to encourage employees to report problems with the way systems work,
including suggestions for improvements,
− to create a transparent procedure for the use of the solution with the
identification of the persons responsible for the technical supervision of the
solution, which is an essential element in crisis situations (Reilly, 2018: 13-
14).
The indicated actions not only increase the probability of success of the organization,
but also allow employees to prepare gradually for using modern solutions. Such an
approach is particularly important in the process of building the image of the
organization as a good employer, which can rationally use both modern technologies
and the potential of its employees.
4. Solutions for the Automation of Personnel Processes Used in Poland and
Worldwide
Solutions based on artificial intelligence are increasingly becoming an integral part of
every process in an organization, especially personnel processes. The pursuit of
efficiency while maintaining high quality has become the basic reason for
implementing modern tools facilitating and accelerating the work of HR departments.
Special attention of HR departments is paid to solutions dedicated to recruitment and
selection, as in many cases these are the most time-consuming and repetitive activities,
hence the possibility of simplifying and accelerating them is important. Solutions
based on AI have also found application in onboarding, talent management process or
improvement of employee competences.
In the online employee recruitment process, many organizations use tools dedicated
to particular processes. Companies use e.g., ATS (Applicant Tracking System), i.e.,
an application facilitating the flow of information, collecting, storing, securing, and
managing the data of candidates applying, as well as full automation of the entire
recruitment process (Salahudeen et al., 2017). The above software greatly facilitates
the acquisition of new employees. An informed employee is a person who should
know in many cases a candidate's CV is not addressed directly to the recruiter, but
checked by the system, therefore preparing a correct CV optimized for ATS
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
160
algorithms is the first step to success. ATS makes it possible to collect candidates'
CVs in one place, to identify people who meet the competence requirements included
in the competence profile of a given position to the greatest extent, thanks to which
time for the analysis of application documents is shortened to a minimum. Not only
organizations use ATS solutions directly, but such a tool is also applied by e.g.,
LinkedIn (Alzhrami, 2020). Examples of ATS applications popular worldwide include
Taleo, Workday, Brassing, SmartRecruiters, iCIMS, JazzHR, SuccessFactor, Jobvite,
Greenhouse, CATS, Lever and BambooHR (Picture 2). In turn, e-Recruiter, HRlink,
Traffit, Element, AppManager, elevato or hrappka.pl are also used in Poland.
Figure 2. Top Applicant Tracking Systems used By Fortune 500 Companies
Source: R. Kelly (2019), Top ATS Systems Used by the Fortune 500 in 2019 (Workday Beats
Taleo).
https://blog.ongig.com/applicant-tracking-system/top-ats-systems-used-by-the-fortune-500-
2019.
The key advantages of ATS systems with extended modules include the ability to
specify:
− average employment time,
− average time for disqualifying a candidate,
− effectiveness of recruitment sources (where the candidates learned about the
recruitment, applications from which sources end up with employment, etc.),
− conversion of candidates (what percentage of candidates are employed),
− scale of resignation of candidates (how many chose another offer or resigned
from recruitment),
− average assessment results for each candidate,
− reasons for rejecting candidates,
− workload of recruiters,
− effectiveness of recruiters.
Thanks to the ATS system, it is also possible to monitor on an ongoing basis which of
the candidates has agreed to participate in future recruitments, which allows for
22,60%
22,40%14,40%
9,40%
7,40%
4,80%
2,60% 2,60%
1,40% 1,20%1,20% 1,20%
Workday
Taleo
SuccessFactors
Kenexa BrassRing (IBM)
iCIMS
Dorota Kurek
161
automatic anonymization of data at the right time or asking candidates by e-mail for
updated approvals. It is worth noting that the anonymized candidate remains in the
system as a statistical entry, which allows for the preparation of aggregate data and
reports, while ensuring their full reliability. The extensive reporting functions also
make it much easier to carry out reporting and integration with the “Career” tab on the
website.
Full online employee recruitment also includes a job interview. Software dedicated to
video recruiting can be used to conduct a virtual meeting. However, not every
organization could use this solution, which is why in many cases public solutions are
still popular, including free applications such as Facebook Messenger, Google
Hangouts, WhatsApp, or Skype. The process of conducting a recruitment interview
can also be supported using tools for analyzing the voice of candidates, which allows
to determine their degree of involvement or authenticity. An exemplary tool is the
solution offered by PRECIRE – combining psychology and artificial intelligence for
language analysis. The method was first patented in the USA in 2017, while it was
first introduced to Europe and Switzerland in 2019 (PRECIRE, access 26.08.2020).
The recruiter's work may also be supported by, among others, a tool called RefLynk
allowing for automatic verification of the skills that the candidate has included in his
application documents. This solution is based on a series of tests and tasks, so not only
recruiters but also the candidates themselves receive feedback. It significantly speeds
up traditional reference checking, making the whole process shorter, less labor and
cost intensive. The indicated solution may also be used during an exit interview, and
the questionnaire sent to departing employees may contain both open and closed
questions based on the Likert scale (Reflynk, access 26.08.2020). Similar
opportunities are also offered by Vitay, a Canadian-based organization established in
2017 that offers a piece of software called Vitay, which can also be used for live
training by the Internet. Recruiters can also use solutions such as Jointl, Good Egg,
SwiftCheck, Checkstar and many others (SOURCEFORGE, access 26.08.2020).
Chatbots are also used in personnel activities. “An HR Chatbot is one major category
within AI recruiting software that allows job seekers and employees to communicate
via a conversational UI via SMS, website, and other messaging applications like
What’s App. The platform allows for meaningful exchanges without the need for HR
leaders to take time out of their Day” (Select Software Reviews, 26.08.2020). The
word is a combination of "chat" and "robot". These are made up of a complex technical
and text-based dialog system. Communication with a chatbot is done via text input or
speech recognition and serves to receive, answer, and process user requests without
the need for human intervention. Chat bots are being used more and more frequently
to assist communication processes and digitalize procedures. This is because the latest
generation of chatbots not only carry out a conversation with the user, but also trigger
specific processes in other systems and applications by controlling technical
interfaces. The chatbot thereby becomes an "Actbot" (Bönke, 2020).
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
162
Chatbots are unusual solutions that are used in the following activities:
− initial verification of competences, candidates' qualifications, availability, and
expectations,
− planning of recruitment interviews, including careful analysis of recruiters'
schedules, and matching the timing of the interview with other duties,
− conducting a conversation in the Career tab with potential employees,
suggesting job offers adequate to their competences,
− engaging employees in referral programs by sending employees information
about the existing program and the possible benefits of referral of a valuable
employee,
− conducting preliminary "interviews" consisting of providing the potential
candidate with information about employee benefits or development
opportunities in the organization,
− supporting employees in the process of onboarding by answering standard and
routine questions, which allows to reduce the burden of HR staff (Nawaz and
Gomes, 2019).
An important aspect in the process of using chatbots is the possibility of measuring
the activity of these solutions by analyzing e.g., the percentage of people interacting
with the chatbot, the detachment of people passing from the career tab to the ATS, or
the percentage of people registered via the career tab on the organization's website.
This type of data allows you to show the rate of return on investment, which was the
purchase of a given solution. Chatbots such as XOR, Ideal, Mya, Wade and Wendy
have found a permanent application on the market. In Poland, chatbots were
implemented by Budimex, one of the largest organizations in the construction
industry. Emplocity, as a solution provider, helped to implement the chatbot, which is
responsible for the verification of candidates' experience, language skills and financial
expectations. It also analyses the acquired information and recommends the best
applications (Budimex, access 28.08.2020).
Chatbots as solutions dedicated also to personnel activities are primarily devices that
are constantly learning to better identify the needs of users. Each subsequent query
therefore becomes a treasury of knowledge. As fast and uncomplicated systems,
chatbots also have another key advantage, namely full 24-hour availability (Nawaz
and Gomes, 2019; Wisskirchen et al., 2017). However, chatbots are not always able
to meet all challenges, so it is worthwhile for them to be equipped with the possibility
of direct connection between the user and the employee, which is particularly
important in resolving conflict situations, including those related to ethical issues. The
key advantages of chatbots include:
− timely implementation of processes without the mistakes typical of humans,
such as fatigue or irritation,
− low operating costs, reduction of costs related to infrastructure and
employment of additional staff,
Dorota Kurek
163
− the speed of response, regardless of the number of inquiries,
− standardization of responses to allow control over the image that an
organization wants to achieve,
− shortening the time spent by employees on searching for answers to standard
questions related to the functioning of the HR department (e.g., how to apply
for a leave, what form to fill in, how to take advantage of benefits, how to
settle a business trip),
− improving internal and external communication,
− reducing the process of duplication of documents and facilitating the process
of collecting and standardizing documents.
Accepting a candidate for a job does not fully complete the process of obtaining
employees. It is crucial that the employee is properly implemented, adapted to the
work environment and organizational culture, as well as supported in the performance
of new duties at the workplace. Artificial intelligence has also found application in
onboarding, which allows for the reduction of rotation among newly hired employees.
Onboarding for many organizations is usually associated with a series of questions
that appear among newcomers, which should be answered. The repetitiveness of these
questions allows artificial intelligence to be used to improve the whole process not
only from the point of view of the organization, but above all the new employee. A
well-constructed onboarding chatbot should make it possible:
− to introduce an employee to the company,
− the training necessary for an employee, inter alia, to be authorized to use the
systems in question, or to equip an employee with the knowledge and skills
related to the job and resulting from the organizational culture and therefore
specific to a given organization,
− social integration of an employee with other employees.
General, professional, and social needs should therefore be met by using chatbots.
This solution has been described by some as a virtual mentor, because in many cases,
such a person can effectively replace chatbots. Reducing the stress associated with the
first days at work using modern solutions is the key to reducing employee turnover
and increasing retention, which at the same time translates into the image aspect not
only of the HR department itself, but of the entire organization.
Chatbots are also used in other areas of the organization's operations (dialogs of sales
departments with external customers, support of purchasing functions, product
management, marketing support, internal communication, customer service
department), where, considering the most popular systematics of chatbots division,
the following ones are most often applied:
− notifying chatbots, which are responsible for providing one-way information,
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
164
− process chatbots, which help clients go through a standard process that
requires several decisions to be made, and therefore to select actions from the
pool,
− conversation chatbots responsible for conducting a conversation with a client,
which is possible thanks to the use of NLP (Natural Language Processing),
which enables the client to answer several standard questions while
identifying the client's needs (Machowczyk, 2018).
Artificial intelligence has also found application in the process of talent acquisition,
which has significantly changed the previous approach to employer branding activities
(Rajesh, Kandaswamy, and Rakesh, 2018). The process of talent acquisition begins
already at the stage of recruitment and selection and is then carried out through the
appropriate organization of onboarding activities, improvement of competences,
organization of remuneration policy, fair system of assessment, planning of career
paths and efficient flow of information in the organization (Harsch and Festing, 2020).
The talent management process is carried out with the support of TAS - Talent
Acquisition Systems and TRM - Talent Management Systems. These systems allow
not only for integration with ATS and HRIS (Human Resource Information Systems),
but also other systems in an organization, which allows for a more professional
approach to human resources management.
Some employers opt for talent management suites, such as Oracle Taleo Cloud
Service. These systems are typically delivered from software as a service (SaaS)
platform and offer talent acquisition, performance management, compensation
management and learning management modules. Other big talent management
vendors include SAP, with its Success Factors software; IBM Kenexa; Cornerstone
OnDemand; SilkRoad; and Halogen. (…) Another route employers take is to use
dedicated talent acquisition software from vendors such as Recruitee, JazzHR,
MightyRecruiter and COMPAS (SeachHR Software, 2019). Several solutions are also
offered on the domestic markets as part of startups.
The well-known TAS include, among others, RecruiterFlow, Yello, iCIMS, Ideal,
Recruiter – Talent Acquisition Software, SumTotal Solution, Ascendify, Employee
Experts and Talentrackr (Software Suggest, 2019). Some of the solutions indicated
allow for full integration with social media, career portals and CRM (Customer
Relationship Management), additionally offering the possibility of video calls, tests
and assessments, knowledge management, payroll, working time and attendance
while being a cloud-based talent acquisition software. The very interest in the process
of talent management is of great importance in the process of building the image of
the organization because it shows the willingness of the organization to undertake
longer cooperation with employees who have the appropriate potential and
willingness to develop. Increased interest in the talent management process results in
increased popularity of job offers for Talent Acquisition Specialist positions and the
creation of Talent Acquisition Teams.
Dorota Kurek
165
Artificial intelligence is also used in HR departments in the process of improving
employee competences. LMS – Learning Management Systems are solutions used by
many organizations (Mohammed et al., 2017). These solutions based on AI allow
better integration of the user with the platform, which results in a more personalized
training process. By identifying both cognitive, behavioral, social, and emotional
characteristics of the user, it is easier to motivate the user to learn. The more user data
is entered into the system, the faster the system learns by identifying the needs and
educational opportunities of employees. The result of such actions is better selected
and profiled educational material.
On the other hand, the organization has an opportunity to see the process of acquiring
new competences by the employee, which facilitates the process of competence
management, and enables a more precise determination of the career path and its
location in time. The best-known LMS include, among others, the following:
TalentLMS, LearnDash, SkyPrep, Academy of Mine, Docebo, Blackboard, Moodle,
JoamlaLMS, Adobe Captivate Prime, SAP Litmos LMS and many others (Enfroy,
2020). In Poland, organizations also use such solutions as tomHRM – a platform that
offers both ATS, time registration, training management, employee assessment and
onboarding (tomHRM, access 30.08.2020).
5. Digital Employer Branding – Towards the Image of a Modern Employer
The implementation of solutions based on AI in the organization allows not only to
streamline operations, reducing the time of certain tasks, but above all to better
manage human resources. Professional career tab on the organization's website or
profiles on social networking sites such as Facebook or LinkedIn are popular activities
in the process of managing the organization's image. However, given the level of
advancement of technology available on the market, they are completely insufficient
to build a strong employer brand. Currently, the recommended activities include
preparing professional recruitment videos, running company blogs, interactive games,
publishing newsletters, managing chats, and participating in online (virtual) job fairs.
Attracting talent and building employee engagement only becomes effective when
brands are strategic, consistent, transparent and authentic in their messaging (Chan
and Hyun, 2014), so it is very important to build and manage EVP (Employer value
proposition) (Biswas, 2013), which should be agile and responsive – thus following
both market trends, while at the same time being embedded in the organizational
culture and offering key values relevant to the organization and the talent it wants to
attract. All the above-mentioned activities can be supported by implementing
solutions based on AI in the organization, enabling more professional management of
the organization and its image. The literature has thus referred to the term Digital
Employer Branding, which includes a set of activities undertaken by the organization
to build the employer's image and implemented using digital solutions, including AI.
Examples of actions are presented in Table 1.
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
166
Table 1. Activities implemented within digital employer branding Title of the action Description
Creating and sharing
EVP
The information about EVP should be reflected in the overall image building
activities, and not only in the job advertisements and career tab on the
website. The appropriate presentation and communication of the package of
benefits offered to potential job applicants is possible through the creation
of a recruitment video, placement in published newsletters, special exposure
on social networks and during virtual job fairs.
Digital storytelling (…) could be used as a means of increasing the employer brand by bringing
more authenticity and legitimation into the commercial communication of
companies (Crisan Bortun, 2017: 280).
Social media activity Active profile management on websites such as Facebook, Instagram,
LinkedIn, etc.
On-line job interview Conducting job interviews via e.g., Facebook Messenger, Google Hangouts,
WhatsApp, Skypeect.
Automation of
recruitment and
selection processes
Implementation in the ATS organization. Linking ATS with other systems
used in the organization in the HR department, including the career tab on
the website.
Automation of talent
acquisition process
Implementation in the TAS organization. Linking ATS to LMS and TAS.
Automating the
competence
management process
Implementation of LMS solutions allowing not only for implementation of
standard competence development activities, but also for improvement of
onboarding activities.
Use of chatbots The use of chatbots in the process of recruitment and selection, onboarding,
improvement of internal communication and standardization of internal
documentation.
Analysis and
forecasting
Through the use of solutions in personnel processes based on AI,
organizations gain the possibility of collecting a huge amount of
information, which facilitates reporting and carrying out the necessary
analyses to determine e.g. the scale of retention, rotation, or efficiency of
recruits, the quality of candidates' applications, average recruitment time,
etc., which leads to determining the expected time in which the investment
in modern systems will pay off.
Especially during the Covid-19 pandemic, organizations recognized the advantages of
Digital EB, although the term itself is not popular both in typically scientific and
organizational considerations. For it is becoming increasingly natural to use modern
technologies, which in the times of the pandemic made it possible to carry out remote
work, including increasing the confidence of potential users with solutions which,
until now, were considered too modern or unnecessary. The implementation of the
solutions described in the article in many cases makes candidates aware of how
modern an organization is, on what values it places particular emphasis and how it
treats employees.
The introduction of remote working has in many cases become possible because
organizations have used systems which can be operated on generally available mobile
devices without great difficulty. In addition, the employer has the possibility of
viewing the activities carried out by the employee in the system without any major
difficulties, which makes it easier to control the work of subordinate employees.
Dorota Kurek
167
It is worth emphasizing, however, that digital EB alone does not allow for building
the desired image of the employer, because in many cases it is treated as a tool for
building the first, but important, good impression. Positive experiences should
continue to be created through appropriate behaviour of the organization's employees,
equal treatment, smooth internal communication and effectively implemented
socialization processes (Tumasjan et al., 2020). The indicated activities supported by
solutions based on AI allow, in combination with a well-developed EB strategy, to
build the desired image of the organization as an employer.
6. Conclusion
The future of personnel activity, including actions aimed at shaping a positive image
of the organization as a desired employer in the labor market, both in Poland and
abroad, will be based, according to the predictions of both theoreticians and
practitioners, on hybrid solutions, seamlessly combining modern technological
solutions based on AI with standard activities, albeit undertaken with greater
awareness of the relationship between the image of an organization and the
effectiveness and quality of activity in each area. The multiplicity of factors
determining the current situation on the labor market shows the complexity of the
needs of the organization as well as those of employees, job candidates and clients.
Satisfying the existing needs is not always possible through standard activities, hence
the demand for non-standard activities – although in many cases more effective – is
growing.
However, not all organizations recognize the need to implement modern solutions,
which is related to the specificity of the organizational culture, including the fear of
employees themselves losing their jobs. It is clear from several studies which have
been carried out, implementing solutions based on artificial intelligence is not always
tantamount to making employees redundant. In many cases, the effect of the
undertaken modernizations becomes the possibility of better use of the intellectual
capital of employees, smoother management of the knowledge and experience of
employees, which in the end translates into their better adaptation to the labor market
and greater value as an employee.
The activities of HR departments and actions undertaken to shape the image of an
organization as a desired employer in the labor market are increasingly based on
solutions using AI. Automation of processes such as recruitment and selection,
onboarding, improvement, and talent management significantly facilitates work,
including increasing objectivity in action, introducing important standards. Such
solutions as ATS, TAS, LMS and chatbots revolutionize the business while allowing
to shape the image of an organization as a modern employer. Digital employer
branding is based, among other things, on these tools, and combined with activities on
social networking sites and creative management of the career tab on the website, it
significantly increases the organization's chances of image success, which is
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
168
particularly important in the case of companies operating on a highly competitive
market.
References:
Ahmed, H.E. 2018. AI Advantages & disadvantages. International Journal of Scientific
Engineering and Applied Science (IJSEAS), 4(4), 22-25. Alzaidi, A.A. 2018. Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Performance of Banking Industry in
Middle East. International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security,
18(10), 140-148. http://paper.ijcsns.org/07_book/201810/20181021.pdf.
Alzhrami, A.M. 2020. The Effectiveness of E-Recruitment Software Over Other Online-
Based Recruitment Methods. Global Journal of Economics and Business, 8(2), 330-
336. https://doi.org/10.31559/GJEB2020.8.2.12.
Barley, S.R. 2015. Why the Internet Makes Buying a Car Less Loathsome: How
Technologies Change Role Relations. Academy of Management Discoveries, 1(1),
31-60. https://doi.org/10.5465/amd.2013.0016.
Beal, D.J. 2015. ESM 2.0: State of the art and future potential of experience sampling
methods in organizational research. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and
Organizational Behavior, 2, 383-407. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-
032414-111335.
Biswas, M. 2013. Employer Branding: A Human Resource Strategy. Human Resources
Management in India: Emerging Issues and Challenges Edition, First Publisher: New
Century Publications, ed. R.K. Pradhan and C.K. Poddar, 160-180.
Bönke, K. 2020. How chatbots help with onboarding new employees.
https://www.coyoapp.com/en/blog/how-chatbots-help-with-onboarding-new-
employees.
Brant, K.K., Castro, S.L. 2019. You cannot ignore millennials: Needed changes and a new
way forward in entitlement research. Human Resource Management Journal, 29(4),
527-538. https://doi.org/10.1111/1748-8583.12262.
Cappelli, P., Tambe, P., Yakubovich, V. 2018. Artificial intelligence in human resources
management: Challenges and a path forward. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3263878.
Cascio, W.F., Montealegre, R. 2016. How Technology Is Changing Work and Organizations.
The Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 3,
349-375. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-041015-062352.
Chan, Y.Y., Hyun, J.J. 2014. Brand Transparency in Social Media: Effects of Message
Sidedness and Persuasion Knowledge. The Korean Journal of Advertising, 3(2), 5-44.
doi: 10.14377/JAPR.2014.9.30.5.
Chowdhury, M., Sadek, A.W. 2012. Advantages and limitations of artificial intelligence.
Artificial Intelligence Applications to Critical Transportation Issues, 6, Transportation
Research Circular E-C168, 6-8.
Crisan, C., Bortun, D. 2017. Digital Storytelling and Employer Branding. An Exploratory
Connection. Management Dynamics in the Knowledge Economy, 5(2), 273-287.
doi.org/10.25019/MDKE/5.2.06.
Deloitte Insights. 2019. Leading the social enterprise: Reinvent with a human focus. 2019
Deloitte Global Human Capital Trends.
https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/cz/Documents/human-capital/cz-hc-
trends-reinvent-with-human-focus.pdf.
Encyclopedia Britannica, Artificial Intelligence, Copeland B.J.
https://www.britannica.com/technology/artificial-intelligence.
Dorota Kurek
169
Enfroy, A. 2020. 17 Best Learning Management Systems (LMS) of 2020 Ranked.
https://www.adamenfroy.com/learning-management-system.
EY. 2018. The new age: artificial intelligence for human resource opportunities and
functions, 1-9. https://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/EY-the-new-age-
artificial-intelligence-for-human-resource-opportunities-and-functions/$FILE/EY-the-
new-age-artificial-intelligence-for-human-resource-opportunities-and-functions.pdf.
Harsch, K., Festing, M. 2020. Dynamic talent management capabilities and organizational
agility - A qualitative exploration. Human Resource Management, 59(1), 43-61.
https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21972.
https://budimex-innowacje.pl/tag/chatbox/.
https://precire.com/technologie/?lang=en.
https://sourceforge.net/software/product/Veremark/alternatives.
https://www.reflynk.com/exit-interviews.
Jarek, K., Mazurek, G. 2019. Marketing and Artificial Intelligence. Central European
Business Review, 8(2), 46-55. doi: 10.18267/j.cebr.213.
Kelly, R. 2019. Top ATS Systems Used by the Fortune 500 in 2019 (Workday Beats Taleo).
https://blog.ongig.com/applicant-tracking-system/top-ats-systems-used-by-the-
fortune-500-2019/.
Khanzode, Ch.A., Sarode, R.D. 2020. Advantages and Disadvantages of Artificial
Intelligence and Machine Learning: A Literature Review. International Journal of
Library & Information Science, 9(1), 30-36. http://www.iaeme.com/Master
Admin/Journal_uploads/IJLIS/VOLUME_9_ISSUE_1/IJLIS_09_01_004.pdf.
Lyons, S., Kuron, L. 2013. Generational differences in the workplace: A review of the
evidence and directions for future research. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 35,
139-157. https://doi.org/10.1002/job.1913.
Machowczyk, M. 2018. Raport. Polskie Chatboty 2018. https://www.k2.pl/blog/raport-
polskie-chatboty-2018.
Mihalcea, A.D. 2017. Employer Branding and Talent Management in the Digital Age.
Management Dynamics in the Knowledge Economy, 5(2), 289-306. DOI
10.25019/MDKE/5.2.07.
Mijwel, M.M. 2015. History of Artificial Intelligence. Computer Science, College of
Science. 1-6.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322234922_History_of_Artificial_Intelligen
ce.
Mohammed, I., Kadir, K.A., Adnan, Z. 2017. Demystifying the Learning Management
System (LMS): Journey from e-Learning to the Strategic Role. European Journal of
Business and Management, 9(9), 12-18.
Nawaz, N., Gomes, A.M. 2019. Artificial Intelligence Chatbots are New Recruiters.
International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and Applications, 10(9). DOI:
10.14569/IJACSA.2019.0100901.
Oracle. 2019. New Study: 64% of People Trust a Robot More Than Their Manager. Global
research highlights how AI is changing the relationship between people and
technology at work, Redwood Shores, California. https://www.oracle.com/corporate/
pressrelease/robots-at-work-101519.html.
ORACLE. 2020. 2020: Oracle’s Top 10 Cloud Predictions. The impact automation, AI,
machine learning, blockchain, and more will have on IT by 2025.
https://www.oracle.com/a/ocom/docs/cloud/oracle-cloud-predictions-2020.pdf.
Oxford Dictionaries. 2019. Artificial intelligence. https://en.oxforddictionaries.
com/definition/artificial_intelligence.
Use of Modern IT Solutions in the HRM Activities:
Process Automation and Digital Employer Branding
170
Rajesh, S., Kandaswamy, U., Rakesh, A. 2018. The impact of Artificial Intelligence in Talent
Acquisition Lifecycle of organizations: A global perspective. International Journal of
Engineering Development and Research, 6(2), 709-717.
http://www.ijedr.org/papers/IJEDR1802131.pdf.
Reilly, P. 2018. The impact of artificial intelligence on the HR function. IES Perspectives on
HR 2018. Institute for employment studies, 142, 1-18. https://www.employment-
studies.co.uk/system/files/resources/files/mp142_The_impact_of_Artificial_Intelligen
ce_on_the_HR_function-Peter_Reilly.pdf.
Ruby Merlin, P., Jayam, R. 2018. Artificial Intelligence in Human Resource Management.
International Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics, 119(17), 1891-1895.
https://acadpubl.eu/hub/2018-119-17/2/153.pdf.
Salahudeen, V.A., Palanisingh, V., Gurumoorty, T.R. 2017. Emerging Trends in Recruitment
and Selection. International Journal of Organizational Behavior and Management
Perspectives, 6(2), 3168-3171.
SeachHR Software. 2019. Talent acquisition. https://searchhrsoftware.techtarget.
com/definition/talent-acquisition.
Select Software Reviews. 2020. The Top 12 Best Recruiting and HR Chatbots.
https://www.selectsoftwarereviews.com/buyer-guide/hr-chat-bots.
Short history of artificial intelligence. https://blog.edrone.me/pl/sztuczna-inteligencja-ecrm-
machine-learning-big-data-ai/.
Software Suggest. 2019. 9 Best Talent Acquisition Software for Recruitment.
https://www.softwaresuggest.com/blog/best-talent-acquisition-software/.
Spector, L. 2006. Evolution of artificial intelligence. Artificial Intelligence, 170(18), 1251-
1253. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.artint.2006.10.009.
Syam, N., Sharma, A. 2018. Waiting or a sales renaissance in the fourth industrial
revolution: Machine learning and artificial intelligence in sales research and practice.
Industrial Marketing Management, 69, 135-146.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2017.12.019.
tomHRM. Onboarding pracowników. https://tomhrm.com/onboarding-pracownikow/.
Tumasjan, A., Kunze, F., Bruch, H., Welpe, I.M. 2020. Linking employer branding
orientation and firm performance: Testing a dual mediation route of recruitment
efficiency and positive affective climate. Human Resource Management, 59(1), 83-
99. DOI: doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21980.
Wisskirchen, G., Biacabe, B.T., Bormann, U., Muntz, A., Niehaus, G., Soler, G.J.,
Brauchitsch, B. 2017. Artificial Intelligence and Robotics and Their Impact on the
Workplace. IBA Global Employment Institute. https://www.ibanet.org/Document
/Default.aspx?DocumentUid=c06aa1a3-d355-4866-beda-9a3a8779ba6e.