Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 68
RESEARCH ARTICLE E-ISSN: 2394-837X Vol.2.Issue.1.2015
Journal for Advanced Research in
Commerce and management studies
A Peer Reviewed International Research Journal A Journal of
S S Publications, Repalle-522265, Guntur (Dt), Andhra Pradesh, India
ANALYSIS OF FACTORS AFFECTING MOBILE COMPUTING ADOPTION
IN THE NIGERIAN ECONOMY
Oluigbo Ikenna Victor1, Ajere Ikenna
2, Okpara Chinyere
3, Ujunwa Anuli
4
1-3Department of Information Management Technology, Federal University of Technology Owerri, Imo State, Nigeria.
4Department of Computer Science, Federal Polytechnic Nekede, Imo State, Nigeria.
ABSTRACT
Mobile computing is term used to describe technologies that enable people to access network
services anyplace, anytime and anywhere. This study analyses the factors affecting Mobile
Computing Adoption in the Nigeria Economy; and to determine if these factors will contribute to
or mitigate adoption of mobile computing in Nigeria. The data used for the study were mainly
primary data, sourced through structured questionnaire to rate the opinion of the selected
population. These data were subjected to multiple regression analysis and the Analysis of
Variance (ANOVA). In the analysis, Mobile computing was regressed against the components
that affect its adoption - High cost of data, Poor network coverage and Irregular power supply.
The result discloses that these factors have a significant effect on mobile computing adoption;
with 97% of respondents agreeing to high mobile computing adoption if these factors are
mitigated. The researchers recommend that to ensure high level mobile computing adoption and
acceptance, government and relevant agencies should work towards providing an enabling
environment devoid of these components that affects mobile computing adoption; as mobile
computing can be a major factor for economic development.
Keywords: Mobile Computing, Nigerian Economy, Economic development, Mobile computing
adoption, Network Providers
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 69
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
INTRODUCTION:
The emergence of mobile computing is an innovative revolution the world has seen,
expanding the reaches of computing and telecommunication around the world. Its simplicity
and apparent ease of use, has facilitated its use and adoption by people from all walks of life.
Mobile Computing generally involves taking a computer and all necessary files and software
out, onto relatively smaller more portable devices. It is primarily classified into portable
computers, mobile phones and wearable computers.
The study of [1] reveals that there is considerable growth in the use of mobile phones in
recent years, leading to increasing demands for land, energy and labour, for setting up and
maintaining efficient state of the art telecommunication base stations, and their associated
infrastructures. Currently, there are about 100 million telephone subscribers in Nigeria. This
exponential growth in mobile phone usage, has not only brought about rapid and sustained
economic growth to Nigeria, but has also made available cheaper and economically
affordable telecommunication services to Nigerians. [2] Highlighted that the forage of the
Nigerian nation into the world of telephony at large, began in 1985, when the telecom
market reform of the administration, evolved from the several administrative structure and
operational changes, through three successive natural developments. Various studies
indicates that in the space of 20 years, the mobile computing discipline has witnessed rapid
evolving innovations, and has moved from being technology for the privileged few, to a
main stream technology. [3] In his work describes perceived usefulness of mobile
computing as the degree to which a person believes that adopting the technology would
enhance his or her job performance. According to [4], five factors influence the growth and
impartation of Mobile computing in any economy;
1. Economic Factor: Available data as well as extensive research, shows that initially,
a county’s GDP affects its ability to develop or adopt wireless technology. This must
be considered in relative terms however, as poorer countries may in fact be more
enthusiastic adopters of mobile technology to replace the inadequate and unreliable
mobile and wireless infrastructures already in place. Developing economy will
always seek to consolidate its fragile mobile technology facilities, trying to improve
the speed, efficiency and communality of the services it provides its citizens.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 70
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
2. Geographic Factor: Countries with small land mass are able to speed up the
adoption of wireless infrastructure, the greater the geographical landscape, the
greater the capital and components required to set it up. For example the amount of
requirements needed to set up a mobile service in Nigeria (937,000 sq. km) would be
greater than that required for a smaller country like Ghana (92,099 sq. km) [9].
3. Industry Factor: A variety of industry related factors contribute to the increase of
mobile adoption levels in various countries, usually stemming from the level of
expertise the industry players have achieved.
4. Government Policy: In Nigeria, the government have particularly been participating
actively in favourable promotion and encouragement of wireless technology, thus
leading to their high adoption rates. For example, Nigeria’s mandatory registration
and regulation on the mobile operators via the NCC has ensured that everyone no
matter their income level would be comfortable with owning a mobile phone [10].
5. Socio-Cultural Factor: In a country like Nigeria with numerous popular media
personnel, advertisers believe that whatever products these famous people endorse
would be attractive to the masses. Mobile phone production companies and mobile
operators alike, flood the media outlets with such adverts, aimed at making their
products and services more attractive to the masses, and hoping they would acquire
and adopt these products and services, thus increasing the adoption of mobile devices.
2. Objectives of the Study
The broad objective of this study is to analysis the factors affecting mobile computing
adoption in the Nigerian economy. The specific objectives are:
1. To identify the factors affecting mobile computing adoption.
2. To evaluate the effect of factors as a whole that affect mobile computing adoption.
3. To evaluate the effect of each individual factor that affects mobile computing
adoption.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 71
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
3. Research Questions
In order to carry out this investigation, the following questions formed the basis for data
collection:
1. What are the possible factors that affect mobile computing adoption?
2. To what extent do all the factors affecting mobile computing have on mobile computing
adoption?
3. To what extent does each of the individual factors affecting mobile computing have on
mobile computing adoption?
4. Research Hypotheses
HO1: There is no significant effect of the factors affecting mobile computing as a whole on
mobile computing adoption.
HA1: There is significant effect of the factors affecting mobile computing as a whole on
mobile computing adoption.
HO2: There is no significant effect of the individual factors affecting mobile computing on
mobile computing adoption.
HA2: There is significant effect of the individual factors affecting mobile computing on
mobile computing adoption.
5. Research Methodology and Design
This research took the form of a survey research of explanatory type. The requirement of
explanatory survey was fulfilled through a questionnaire and secondary sources of data.
Primary and secondary data were used in this work. The primary data was generated from
administered questionnaires to the population under study, while secondary data was
collected from the relevant literatures, journals, texts, and the electronic sites. The population
of a study is a census of all items or subjects that possess the characteristics or that has
knowledge of the phenomenon being studied [6].
Of the One Hundred and Twenty (120) questionnaires fully administered, 104 samples
responded; giving a response rate of 86 percent, while four (4) were discarded because they
contained errors such as incomplete answers and inconsistency. 100 questionnaires,
amounting to eighty four percent (84%), were found suitable for the analysis.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 72
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
6. Method of Data Analysis
Simple percentage and regression analysis are used in analysing the data collected from the
survey. Regression analysis is a statistical tool, which helps to predict one variable from the
other variable on the basis of assumed nature of the relationship between variable [6].
In the analysis, Mobile Computing was regressed against factors that affect its adoption
which are: High Cost of Data, Poor Network Coverage and Irregular Power Supply.
Multiple regression analysis and Analysis of variance (ANOVA) were the tools used in this
study to evaluate the factors affecting adoption of Mobile computing, with F-test utilized in
determining level of significance. The student t-test was used to test for level of significance
of each individual factor.
In multiple regressions, the model describing the relationship between the dependent variable
and a set of independent variables X1, X2 . . . Xn can be expressed as:
Y = a +b1X1 + b2X2 + . . . + bkXk
Where: a, b1 and b2 are the unknown parameters to be estimated
Y = Mobile Computing = Dependent Variable
X1 = High Cost of Data = Independent Variable
X2 = Poor Network Coverage = Independent Variable
X3 = Irregular Power Supply = Independent Variable
The decision rule is to accept the null hypothesis if the critical tabulated value is greater than
the calculated value, otherwise reject. H0 is accepted at the 5% significance level, if F * < F1
– α (n-k-1). Otherwise, H0 is rejected in favour of HA. H0 is accepted at 5% significant level if
/t/< t0.05. Otherwise, H0 is rejected in favour of HA. Alternatively, at 5% significant level, we
reject the null hypothesis H0 if (P > 0.05), or to accept the alternative hypothesis HA if (P <
0.05).
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 73
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Results and Discussions
7.1 Respondents Characteristics and Classification
Table 1: Sex of Respondents.
SEX PERCENTAGE
MALE 61%
FEMALE 39%
TOTAL 100%
Table 2: Age Group of Respondents.
AGE GROUP PERCENTAGE
18 – 27 64%
28 – 37 30%
38 and above 6%
Total 100%
Table 3: Preferred Network Provider.
Network Provider PERCENTAGE
MTN 40%
GLO 34%
AIRTEL 18%
ETISALAT 8%
Total 100%
Table 4: Time Spent daily on mobile device.
Occupation PERCENTAGE
Below 1 hour 5%
2 – 4 hours 17%
5 – 8 hours 68%
Above 8 hours 10%
Total 100%
Table 5: Years of using mobile computing
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 74
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Years of usage PERCENTAGE
Less than one year 5%
1 – 4 years 70%
5 – 9 years 22%
Greater than 10 years 3%
Total 100%
Table 6: Factors that affect mobile computing adoption
Factors PERCENTAGE
High Cost of Data 41%
Poor network coverage 38%
Irregular power supply 21%
Total 100%
Table 7: Adoption of mobile computing, if constraining factors were minimized.
Response PERCENTAGE
Yes 97%
No 3%
Total 100%
8. Model Estimation and Hypothesis Testing
The result obtained from the multiple regression analysis is shown in Tables 8, 9, 10
Table 8: Model Summary
Model R R Square
Adjusted R
Square
Std. Error
of the
Estimate
Change Statistics
R Square
Change
F
Change df1 df2
Sig. F
Change
1 .966a .932 .930 .660 .932 440.850 3 96 .000
a. Predictors: (Constant), Irregular power, High cost of data, Poor network coverage
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 75
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
8.1 Estimation of relationship model and Interpretation
With reference to Table 8, the meaning of the various statistical tool used in analysing the
model of this research work were given as follows:
1. The co-efficient of correlation (R) shows the degree or extent of relationship
between the dependent and the independent variables. The value 0.966 shows the
existence of a positive relationship between these variables.
2. The co-efficient of determination (R2) explains the proportion of the total variations
in the dependent variable that is attributable to the variations in the independent
variable. From Table 8, it was observed that about 93.2% (0.932) of the variation is
the dependent variables are attributable to variations in the independent variables.
3. The adjusted co-efficient of Determination (R2 Adjusted) is 0.930 which implies that
the actual variation is 93.0% as against 93.2% suggested by normal R2.
Table 9: ANOVA
Model
Sum of
Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regression 575.245 3 191.748 440.850 .000a
Residual 41.755 96 .435
Total 617.000 99
a. Predictors: (Constant), Irregular power, High cost of data, Poor network coverage
b. Dependent Variable: Mobile computing
From Table 9 above, the model reaches statistical significance at (sig = 0.000), therefore we
reject the null hypothesis H0 and accept the alternative hypothesis HA.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 76
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Table 10: T-test for the constructs
Model
Unstandardized
Coefficients
Standardiz
ed
Coefficient
s
T Sig.
95.0% Confidence
Interval for B
B Std. Error Beta
Lower
Bound
Upper
Bound
1 (Constant) .279 .228
1.223 .224 -.174 .733
High cost .354 .025 .454 14.222 .000 .304 .403
Poor network .241 .033 .274 7.290 .000 .176 .307
Irregular
Power
.364 .029 .435 12.390 .000 .305 .422
a. Dependent Variable: mobile computing
Table 10 shows that the unstandardized Beta Coefficients that present the contributions of
each variable to the model. The t and p-values shows the impact of the independent variables
on the dependent variable.
Using the regression output on Table 4.10 we estimated the following equation.
Y = 0.279 + 0.354X1 + 0.241X2 + 0.364X3
Where Y = Mobile Computing = Dependent Variable
X1 = High Cost of Data = Independent Variable
X2 = Poor Network Coverage = Independent Variable
X3 = Irregular Power Supply = Independent Variable
9. Hypothesis Testing
The formulated hypotheses are tested as follows:
HO1: There is no significant effect of the factors affecting mobile computing as a whole on
mobile computing adoption.
HA1: There is significant effect of the factors affecting mobile computing as a whole on
mobile computing adoption.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 77
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Using the decision rule, we found that the calculated F-ratio is 440.850 and the tabulated
value of F-ratio is 2.53. Since Fcal > Ftab, we reject the null hypothesis (H0) and accept
alternative hypothesis (HA) and conclude that there is significant effect of the factors
affecting mobile computing as a whole on mobile computing adoption.
HO2: There is no significant effect of the individual factors affecting mobile computing on
mobile computing adoption.
HA2: There is significant effect of the individual factors affecting mobile computing on
mobile computing adoption.
In order to properly determine the effect of the individual factors affecting mobile computing
on the adoption of mobile computing, we breakdown the hypothesis (HO2) and (HA2) into the
following sub-sections:
HO2 (a): High cost of data has no significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
HA2 (b): High cost of data has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
Using the decision rule, we found that the tabulated value of t-statistics is 1.665 and the
calculated t-value of High cost of data is 14.222. Since t cal > t tab, we reject the null
hypothesis (HO2 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis (HA2 (b)) and conclude that High
cost of data has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
Alternatively, at significant level of 0.000 for High cost of data, this variable is also
significant because this probability value 0.000 is less than 0.05 significant level (P < 0.05).
We therefore reject the null hypothesis (HO2 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis (HA2
(b)) and conclude that High cost of data has significant effect in adoption of mobile
computing.
HO3 (a): Poor network coverage has no significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
HA3 (b): Poor network coverage has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
Using the decision rule, we found that the tabulated value of t-statistics is 1.665 and the
calculated t-value of Poor network coverage is 7.290. Since t cal > t tab, we reject the null
hypothesis (HO3 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis (HA3 (b)) and conclude that Poor
network coverage has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 78
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Alternatively, at significant level of 0.000 for Poor network coverage, this variable is also
significant because this probability value 0.000 is less than 0.05 significant level (i.e P <
0.05). We therefore reject null hypothesis (HO3 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis
(HA3 (b)) and conclude that Poor network coverage has significant effect in adoption of
mobile computing.
HO4 (a): Irregular power supply has no significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
HA4 (b): Irregular power supply has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
Using the decision rule, we found that the tabulated value t-statistics is 1.665 and the
calculated t-value of Irregular power supply is 12.390. Since t cal > t tab, we reject the null
hypothesis (HO4 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis (HA4 (b)) and conclude that
Irregular power supply has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing. Alternatively,
at significant level of 0.000 for irregular power supply, this variable is also significant
because this probability value 0.000 is less than 0.05 significant level (i.e P < 0.05). We
therefore reject null hypothesis (HO4 (a)) and accept the alternative hypothesis (HA4 (b)) and
conclude that Irregular power supply has significant effect in adoption of mobile computing.
9.1 Result Discussion
Results are being discussed here in context of research questions.
Question One: To what extent do all the factors affecting mobile computing have on mobile
computing adoption?
The test of hypothesis on this research question shows that the collective factors affecting
mobile computing have a significant effect on mobile computing adoption. The conclusion
was drawn from the result of the F-test in which F-calculated value of 440.850 is greater than
the F-tabulated value of 2.53 at 5% significance level which according to decision rule
implies that the collective factors affecting mobile computing have a significant effect on
mobile computing adoption.
The positive relationship of the factors affecting mobile computing usage on its adoption
shows that these factors can greatly hinder students, IT workers and various individuals at
large from adopting its solutions in their daily endeavours. This is in accordance with [11]
that posits although mobile computing has greatly improve the level of uptime a user can
use in accessing relevant information through the internet, its constraining factors still stands
as a limiting factor towards its adoption.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 79
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
Question Two: To what extent does each of the individual factors affecting mobile
computing have on mobile computing adoption?
In order to examine the significance of each individual factor, this research question is broken
down into sub question:
2a) How significant is High cost of data as a factor affecting mobile computing adoption?
The test of hypothesis on this research question shows that high cost of data has a significant
effect on, since the probability value of 0.000 is less than 0.05 significance level. This result
is in tandem with respondent’s perception that High cost of data has a significant effect on
mobile computing adoption. Students, Experts and Individuals at large adopt technology
based on a number of reasons, one of which is the extent to which an individual feels it helps
reduce their workload. Perceived benefits refer to the extent which an individual feel that
adopting technology would actually reduce the effort in his daily activities. Mobile
computing helps individuals to be in constant contact and communication even when on the
go, people can have access to quality information with just a limited time. However the
problem of high cost of access is a limiting factor towards adoption of mobile computing.
2b) How significant is Poor network coverage as a factor affecting mobile computing
adoption?
The test of hypothesis on this research question shows that Poor network coverage has a
significant effect on mobile computing adoption, since the probability value of 0.000 is less
than 0.05 significance level. This result is in tandem with respondent’s perception that Poor
network coverage has a significant effect on mobile computing adoption access
Poor network coverage is an evident problem in mobile computing, some areas in Nigeria
suffer low network footprint coverage, and as a result individuals cannot make a phone call
or access the internet. This is in accordance with [7] who posits that a major benefit of
mobile computing is to be able to access information on the go, however some areas in
Nigeria that suffer poor network coverage makes this unattainable.
2c) How significant is Irregular power supply as a factor affecting mobile computing
adoption?
The test of hypothesis on this research question shows that irregular power supply has a
significant effect on infusion and diffusion of IT platforms, since the probability value of
0.000 is less than 0.05 significance level. This result is in tandem with respondent’s
perception that complexity and maintainability of devices has a significant effect on mobile
computing adoption.
Journal for Advanced Research in Commerce and Management Studies 80
http://www. jarcms.sspublications.co.in
This problem of irregular power supply is also a trivial issue in the use of mobile computing,
because the devices through which the individuals access the internet work on batteries. And
due to dilapidated power supply these devices are usually very low leading to low usage of
mobile computing. This is in accordance with [7] which posit that shortage power supply
usually constraints people for having maximum utility with mobile computing.
10. Summary and Conclusion
Mobile computers, have greatly enhanced the chances and opportunities of interpersonal
sociability and shared practices. Mobile computers have created employment opportunities
and provided people various means of gaining knowledge and enhancing themselves, as well
as created means for people to conduct activities which would have not been previously
possible, over the internet, all from the comfort of the palms of your hands.Even with the
rapid advancements that the mobile computing industry has provided, the findings in this
research have proven that certain factors affecting mobile computing has greatly reduced its
adoption. Mobile Computing is the basis of the infrastructure of emerging global economies;
there is therefore the need to find ways to promote this ever growing industry, and
emancipate people economically and intellectually.
References
[1]Ireti A. (2006) “Spatial analysis of GSM subscriber Call Data Records”
http://www.directionsmag.com/entry/spatial-analysis-of-gsm-subscriber-call-data-
records/123196
[2] Akande T.M and Ajao M.S. (2006) “Awareness of Hazards and Use of GSM Mobile Phone
among Non-Commercial Drivers in Ilorin, Nigeria” Annals of African Medicine Vol. 5, No. 4;
2006: 166 – 169
[3] Davis, F. D. (1989) “Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of
Information Technology” MIS Quarterly, 13(3): 319–340, doi: 10.2307/249008
[4] Adekomi, A. (2007) “The challenges of an ICT driven instructional system in an era of dependent
economy” A manuscript submitted for publication to Obafemi Awolowo University Ile-Ife
[5] Nworuh G. (2004). Data Presentation and Analysis: Research methodology and capstone,
Owerri, Avan Global Publications.
[6] Salako, O.A., & Tiamiju, M.A. (2007). Use of search engines for research by postgraduate
students of the University of Ibadan, Nigeria. African Journal of Library, Achieves and
Information Science 7(2):103-115.
[7] www.wikipedia.com
[8] www.ncc.gov.ng
[9] www.reuters.com/article/idUskBNH600320140911?Irpc=932
Top Related