The House of Mengüjek in Divriği: Constructions of Dynastic Identity in the Twelfth Century
Late Dynastic Pottery from Theban Tomb no. -61-
Transcript of Late Dynastic Pottery from Theban Tomb no. -61-
Avis aux futurs auteurs
Bulletin de liaison de la céramique égyptienneBCE 25, Ifao, Le Caire
Il serait souhaitable que les textes parviennent à l’Ifao fin septembre 2014 au plus tard. Les normes pour la publication seront données aux futurs auteurs sur simple demande, nous sollicitons l’application stricte de ces normes dès la remise des manuscrits.Chaque article sera soumis à l’approbation du comité de lecture.
Contact : [email protected]
I n st I t u t f r a n ç a I s d ’a r c h é o lo g I e o r I e n ta l e
b c e 24 – 2 01 4
24éramique �gyptienne�B uLLetin
de Liaison de
© INSTITUT FRANÇAIS D’ARCHÉOLOGIE ORIENTALE, LE CAIRE, 2014 ISBN 978-2-7247-0650-5 ISSN 0255-0903
Comité de Lecture
BCESusan Allen, David A. Aston, Bettina Bader, Pascale Ballet, Janine Bourriau, Catherine Defernez, Jean-Yves Empereur, Peter French, Stan Hendrickx, Colin A. Hope, Pamela Rose, Dietrich Raue, Teodozja Rzeuska.
V
W. Raymond JohnsonIn Memoriam Helen Jacquet-Gordon (1918-2013) .....................................................ix
Alain ArnaudièsBibliographie de Helen Jacquet-Gordon (1951-2012) ........................................... xiii
Sylvie MarchandAvant-propos ........................................................................................................................ xxiii
Carte..................................................................................................................................................xxiv
Repères chronologiques ............................................................................................................xxv
i. Parcours régional ............................................................................................... 1
Littoral méditerranéen ................................................................................................... 3
Julie Monchamp Céramiques romaines de Smouha (Alexandrie), iie siècle apr. J.-C. .......... 5
Delta ........................................................................................................................................... 13
Nicholas Hudson Preliminary Report on the Pottery at Tell Timai (Thmuis) ......................... 15
Sommaire
VI
b u l l e t i n d e l i a i s o n d e l a c é r a m i q u e é g y p t i e n n e
Sylvain Dhennin, Sylvie Marchand, Julie Marchand, Aude Simony Prospection archéologique
de Kôm Abou Billou/Térénouthis (Delta) - 2013............................................. 51
Région memphite .............................................................................................................. 69
Katarína Arias Kytnarová Ritual Ceramic Deposit from the Tomb of Prince Werkaure?
A Tentative Interpretation ........................................................................................... 71
Susan J. Allen Pottery from the Pyramid Complex of Senwosret III
and Middle Kingdom Mastabas at Dahshur 2003-2010 (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York) ............................................... 85
Région thébaine et Haute-Égypte ....................................................................... 93
Gábor Schreiber Late Dynastic Pottery from Theban Tomb No. -61- ....................................... 95
Guy Lecuyot La céramique du Ramesseum et de ses abords,
état des recherches ........................................................................................................ 101
Julia Budka Zîr Vessels from the Tomb of Osiris at Umm el-Qaab ............................... 121
Valérie Le Provost Fouilles récentes d’un habitat à Tell Edfou,
la céramique de la fin de la Première Période Intermédiaire au début de la XIIe dynastie : une séquence de transition ......................... 131
Oasis de el-Hayz ........................................................................................................... 151
Stanislava Kučová, Květa Smoláriková Roman Transport Amphorae from Bir Showish,
el-Hayz, Bahariya Oasis ............................................................................................ 153
VII
s omma i r e
Oasis de Dakhla ............................................................................................................ 161
Clementina Caputo Amheida/Trimithis (Dakhla Oasis):
Results from a Pottery Survey in Area 11 ........................................................... 163
Nord-Sinaï .......................................................................................................................... 179
Silvia Lupo, Claudia Kohen 2010 Season at Tell el-Ghaba, North Sinai. Preliminary Report ........... 181
2. Inventaire des sites de production céramique en Égypte et en Basse-Nubie ........................................................ 199
Sylvie Marchand Inventaire archéologique des sites de production céramique
du Prédynastique à l’époque moderne. Égypte et Basse-Nubie ............. 201
Valérie Pichot, Kaan Şenol The Site of Akademia: The Amphora Workshop of Apol(l)ônios.
First Excavation Campaign (July-August 2012) ............................................. 225
Nicholas Hudson Late 4th Century BC Pottery from Tell Timai (Thmuis) .......................... 241
Zulema Barahona Mendieta La producción cerámica en Medamud.
Estudio de la cerámica procedente de los hornos del Reino Nuevo, Baja Época y Época Ptolemaica ............................................................................. 267
Bibliographie ................................................................................................................................. 281
Index chronologique .................................................................................................................. 313
Adresses des auteurs ................................................................................................................... 315
Excavations��carried�out�between�1999�and�2008�by�the�Hungarian�Archaeological�Mission�in�the�Ramesside�tomb�of�Amenhotep,�chief�physician�in�the�domain�of�Amun�(no.�-61-)�on�el-Khokha�yielded�a�significant�collection�of�pottery�vessels�roughly�dating�to�the�period�
between�550�and�350�BC.�As�observed�by�D.�Aston,1�numerous�New�Kingdom�tombs�in�the�same�area,�including�those�of�Nefersekheru,2�Amenhotep,3�Amenemope,4�and�Amenmose5�must�have�been�re-used�for�new�interments�this�time,�based�on�the�pottery�discovered�in�these�tombs.�Late�Dynastic�pottery�has�also�been�excavated�in�TT�32,6�-59-7�and�-400-,8�and�the�author�has�seen�ceramic�vessels,�comparable�to�those�found�in�TT�-61-,�in�the�storeroom�of�the�nearby�tomb�of�Kenamun�(TT�412),�which�come�from�Mohamed�Saleh’s�excavations�in�this�area�in�the�1960’s.9�Taken�together,�the�above�facts�tend�to�indicate�that�the�southern�slope�of�el-Khokha�was�one�of�the�nuclei�of�the�Theban�necropolis�between�the�Saite�and�Ptolemaic�Periods.
The�number�and�distribution�of�the�vessels�excavated�in�TT�-61-�demonstrate�that�the�tomb�was�re-used�for�multiple�burials,�seemingly�by�more�than�one�family.�Somewhere�about�the�middle�of�the�6th�century�BC�a�shaft�tomb�was�cut�to�the�statue-room�of�TT�-61-,�which�housed�at�least�four�burials�interred�there�during�the�second�half�of�the�century,�the�date�being�established�on�the�basis�of�pottery,�including�a�Type�D�
1.� Aston�2003b,�p.�162-163;�Aston,�Aston�2010,�p.�114,�p.�186.2.� Feucht�1985,�pl.�LII-LXII,�LXVII-LXXIII.3.� Strudwick�1996,�p.�176-177,�pl.�68-69.4.� Assmann�1991,�p.�222-235.5.� Seyfried�1990,�p.�201�(nos.�617,�634,�640),�p.�206�(nos.�669,�674,�675,�680),�p.�221�(no.�375),�p.�228�(nos.�1387,�1412,�1419,�1430),�p.�230�(no.�2069),�p.�243�(no.�1823),�p.�256�(no.�1842),�p.�279�(nos.�2161,�2163,�2235,�2242).6.� Schreiber�2008,�p.�82-83,�pl.�LXXX-LXXXI.7.� Personal�observation.8.� Personal�observation.9.� On�the�excavation�of�TT�412,�see�Saleh�1983.
Gábor Schreiber Late Dynastic Pottery from Theban Tomb no. -61-
95
96
g á b o r s c h r e i b e r
96
amphora�from�Clazomenae.10�Another�shaft�tomb,�with�a�rectangular�aperture�and�a�chamber�opening,�quite�atypically,�along�one�of�the�long�sides�of�the�shaft�at�the�bottom,�was�constructed�towards�the�turn�of�the�6th�and�5th�centuries�BC,�where�a�small�collection�of�local�pottery�and�a�Lesbian�amphora�were�uncovered.�Besides�these�spots,�Persian�to�Nectanebide�burials�seem�to�have�been�deposited�also�in�the�New�Kingdom�burial�chambers�opening�at�the�terminus�of�the�sloping�passage.�The�vessels�associated�with�these�interments�have�been�excavated�mostly�in�the�debris�of�the�sloping�passage,�where�they�had�been�scattered�by�looters.�Less�surprisingly,�the�overwhelming�portion�of�the�material�is�composed�of�locally�made�vessels�manufac-tured�out�of�Nile�B2�and�C�fabrics,�and�Marl�A4�fabric�(variant�2).�Among�the�Nile�wares�beakers/bowls�with�direct�rim�and�raised�base�proved�to�be�overwhelmingly�characteristic�(fig.�1a).�The�typo-chronology�of�this�shape�still�needs�to�be�worked�out�fully.11�What�seems�certain�is�that�it�is�already�present�in�the�Saito-Persian�strata�of�Elephantine12�and�that�it�develops,�probably�sometime�around�the�Thirtieth�Dynasty�and�seemingly�gradually,�into�what�is�frequently�termed�a�footed�cup�in�Ptolemaic�contexts.13�Of�beakers�furnished�with�one�or�two�spouts�near�the�base,�three�examples�have�been�uncovered�(fig.�1b).�The�shape,�used�quite�evidently�for�pouring�funerary�libations,�finds�ready�analogues�in�the�material�excavated�by�Petrie�in�his�Cemetery�N,14�and�as�such�it�is�to�be�ascribed�to�the�later�5th�and�4th�centuries�BC.�Finally,�ano-ther�indicator�of�a�Persian�Period�date�within�open�shapes�was�hemispherical�bowls�(“goldfish�bowls”)�made�of�Nile�B2�fabric�(fig.�1c),�which�are�exceedingly�typical�of�the�period�between�550�and�400�BC�throughout�the�country.15
Among�closed�shapes�two�classes,�viz.�neckless�jars�and�bag-shaped�jars�have�been�identified.�While�the�former�group�invariably�exhibits�jars�of�Nile�B2�with�a�simple�rim�form�and�a�height�between�45�and�50�cm�(fig.�1d),�the�latter�is�an�umbrella�category�which�comprises�technically�and�morphologically�different�vessels,�including�a�red-burnished�neckless�variant,�and�bag-shaped�jars�with�neck�and�two�handles�attached�to�the�upper�part�of�the�body.�One�example�of�the�latter�with�linear�decoration�on�the�rim�and�neck�(fig.�1e)is�particularly�interesting,�for�it�seems�to�represent�a�direct�
10.� See�Cook,�Dupont�1998,�p.�155,�fig.�23.3g.11.� Masson�2011a,�p.�272.12.� Aston�1999,�p.�217-218�(nos.�1935-1945).13.� Budka�2008,�p.�78-79;�Budka�2010c,�p.�384-385.14.� Petrie�1909,�pl.�XLII.15.� Defernez�2001,�p.�64;�Masson�2011a,�p.�277.
97
l at e d y n a s t i c p o t t e ry f r o m t h e b a n t o m b n o . - 6 1 -
forerunner,�datable�to�the�later�5th�or�early�4th�century�BC,16�of�Ptolemaic�balalis,�frequently�painted�not�only�with�linear�but�elaborate�floral�decoration�as�well.17
The�collection�of�Marl�vessels�consists�almost�exclusively�of�carinated�jars�of�the�local�Marl�A4�fabric�group�(fig.�2a-b).�The�jars,�with�a�modelled�rim�form�and�some-times�with�a�ring�base,�are�derivatives�and�results�of�an�organic�development�from�late�Third�Intermediate�Period�carinated�jars.�Besides�these�local�containers,�a�few�small-�to�medium-sized�closed�shapes,�such�as�a�bottle�(fig.�2c)and�squat�jars,�made�out�of�K5�fabric�have�also�been�found�in�association�with�this�pottery�assemblage.18�These�vessels�are�best�understood�as�imports�from�the�Memphite�region.19
Finally,�the�collection�of�Late�Dynastic�pottery�from�TT�-61-�is�completed�by�a�few�painted�vessels�datable�to�the�4th�century�BC.�Carinated�bowls�ornamented�with�a�painted�(red�or�black)�rim�band�have�two�examples�made�of�Nile�B2�(fig.�2d),�and�one�example�made�of�the�local�LDP�(Late�Dynastic/Ptolemaic)�Marl�1�fabric�(fig.�2e).20�Of�the�Nile-based�vessels�another,�flat-based�carinated�bowl�(fig.�2f ),�a�bottle,�and�a�bag-shaped�jar�(fig.�2g)�are�to�be�noted,�whilst�the�corpus�of�locally�made�Marl�ves-sels�consists�of�a�carinated�bowl�with�handles,�a�bottle,�three�fragmentary�small�jars,�probably�squat�jars,�and�a�medium-sized�bag-shaped�jar�with�ring�base�(fig.�2h).�It�is�noteworthy�that�with�the�exception�of�a�single�sherd�of�a�large�container�which�comes�from�the�surface�debris,�no�pottery�from�these�contexts�bears�floral�decoration.�As�has�been�shown�elsewhere,21�the�linear�style�generally�predates�the�elaborately�decorated�floral�vessels�at�Thebes,�but�it�continued,�with�minor�changes,�down�at�least�to�the�end�of�the�Ptolemaic�Period.�Given�that�TT�-61-�did�not�yield�any�burial�equipment�which�may�be�unequivocally�termed�Ptolemaic�in�date�and�that�with�the�exception�of�the�single�aforementioned�sherd�no�floral�vessels�were�found,�it�seems�quite�feasible�to�associate�these�pottery�finds�with�4th�century�BC�burials.
16.� For�contemporary�analogues�from�Saqqara,�see�Aston,�Aston�2010,�nos.�95,�299,�333-334.�For�a�Late�Dynastic�local�example�from�the�Kharga�Oasis,�see�Marchand�2007,�p.�492,�fig.�21.17.� Schreiber�2003,�p.�30-31,�pl.�10-14.18.� For�K5�fabric,�see�Aston,�Aston�2010,�p.�5-6.19.� The�possible�northern�origin�of�vessels�made�of�K5�fabric�found�in�Upper�Egyptian�contexts�has�been�indicated�by�Aston�1999,�p.�5.20.� Schreiber�2003,�p.�26.�For�the�local�LDP�Marl�fabrics,�which�can�be�compared�with�Aston’s�K100�and�K200�fabrics,�see�ibid.,�p.�17-18.21.� Schreiber�2003,�p.�43-45.
98
g á b o r s c h r e i b e r
Fig. 1. Bowl with direct rim (a); spouted beaker with flat base (b); hemispherical bowl (c); neckless jar (d); and bag-shaped jar (e); from TT -61-.
c.
d.e.
a.
b.
Fig. 1-5 Bowl with direct rim (Fig. 1), spouted beaker with flat base (Fig. 2), hemispherical bowl (Fig. 3), neckless jar (Fig. 4), and bag-shaped jar (Fig. 5) from TT -61-
1/4
0 1 5 cm
a
b
c
de
99
l at e d y n a s t i c p o t t e ry f r o m t h e b a n t o m b n o . - 6 1 -
h.
g.
c.
a.
b.
d.
Fig. 6-13 Bag-shaped jars (Fig. 6-7), bottle (Fig. 8), carinated bowls (Fig. 9-11), and linear bag-shaped jars (Fig. 12-13) from TT -61-
1/4
0 1 5 cm
f.
e.
Fig. 2. Carinated bag-shaped jars (a-b); bottle (c); carinated bowls (d-f); and linear bag-shaped jars (g-h); from TT -61-.