Happiness as Resistance: Moral Obligations of the Oppressed

7
- \- -r -l -l - !v -l - *? -r - -t - U?; - - - -l - r-rl - - > l-l - t- -l - - LJ st- - m gg orF s. H- o-(D o o o a 3 o

Transcript of Happiness as Resistance: Moral Obligations of the Oppressed

-\- -r -l -l -!v -l -*? -r - -t -U?;

- - - -l-

r-rl

- -

> l-l -t- -l - -LJ st-

-m

gg orF s. H-

o-(D

o o o a 3 o

P =9=

.am 30 !.t o5

. :^

,x

rc

N6

f=F

F w

u

h-J

iik

r ^

iiry

?;n

r

& B

=':

a:e

E 5,

:

s9

=sF

E E;

, g

g

i E^

'u 6

o

1=

E o

J q

- 5=

r s

=J

H

S ;

IA

=di

.e"

aA

E ri

6 P

F di

=. ;

E-P'

, 2 e

3 -

,ri

90-

< ^A

I

o ;:

aa

!F-i

a- a

E 2

+ ;

tt,

=.itr

Ed

Ei

Z 9o

= I

i@

6-

a g

X't=

'o

=t':

g or

u :

t_

d K

s lE

: I

+*

I -+

)i':

F sJ

ii =

93

: =

= P

i. ;

o !+

^

=:

- ='

L .Y

Dtr

X @

, Z

g ;s

[ 1

+v E

E

]. ==

" 2

=' al

p

qg

?As

a =

,( g

\ e€

tr *

c P

.' i.

J ^i

/\

*o ni9 I

ai'

J1 EE oa<

EO-

-l Ed t- tn Frl o o z -l rn z -l a

F ps

:1

<:;i

EN.

V -S

5 w

o!?

Es

7 iT

iSr-.

D'.

EPU

^;

$ r.

dq

6a(D

a'

=.B

6'S

L^ i>, ds 3.x

.< :- O

a G .o

a < o h 4 .{ b

,Jr { o- z p - o n a q o 1+) = o n

N k .o (\ a (\ h h

(, 11 o o o + q q ? o 13 f a

N (\ ! G ft o (\ F: 4 s "-i (\ q ? o g q

o B Ed p- a nl ts o o o a (D o E

ln o 4 l..r o 4 trl v v o p s q N 6 s\ (\. G O

q

? a F o o ,f o (D ts L +r d o p- U)

F) (D o ,1 a q

6 (\ h 4 (\ (\ v (\ s o

? o 4 oq TD (D Fd o o + q o t a o - s (D E a a @ io rd

a^ \- G (\ h Fr uo \i q (\ a N o \ 2 d

FE

T'B

'UEf

!\:-Y

.+

5 X-

, i,l

H *

s o

a=.'\

<PY

Y tE

Q

o'F

<E

--

e =

oP!

J$!1

re

l'\r

3.I

6:'

.?a

b $

Oqr

k!

-

5osr

D-

p Fr

s d;

q C

N

Po

Fl*

u.)

ta>

E' -

S'<

N\ * N ct b q .a

z> 5E'

-o E.G X::

rS os SS 9eG

s: +-:

od =oa z'x g.S. qq

N v\ o i. Oa

N (\ d G o B l\ ci G o' q \ o (t 4

\J a: o 4 o

o n ? ::- 0) ID o o o ts1 q

U\)m

N) o\

5s

UJ

(, \oo'

\\o -I

o

^P? /^

l*=

\JP

!: Ed

FU

A TE

x 5f

r29

i3

=F^{

.JH

Y Ei

;zj

,f w)

Fq,

-,Hf,-

tt^'P o

c7F

FU (,

)

nd Lrr A v) rn \-/

:1 3

$

50

0 0€€

o o

o tD

T'1

0t

= 3

!rr

anA)

or

C

,t =

=E

iF[g

;g;B

lfE €

EiEg

f =Fr

sr +F

=Er

gIEi

EiEE

EIgi

Err[E

EiEE

EEEB

E

Iggl

EiIg

[lIEg

Eila

tEg*

HEE

I

IBEI

EgiE

ESE[

1$EE

lgEl

EE

EE=E

[EEi

BEE1

11*E

Es?

lEE

o\

EEEE

gEiiig

EEiE

$EiE

irig[

EgIIg

[gEi

E[El

i

Eiga

EliiE

EE1E

iEgI

Eg[$

3 iE

E E

EBgE

Ei[E

rEEE

EI['E

EHB:

gE$

{E$'

JEig

iEEE

iEiiE

E Ei

i * EESg

EEEg

E[EE

FO t o a o o

Bt[;*

f1Ia

;r *[a

+ ffi

fi;a:

gF1E

Eg IB

Bfig

[+8

-

+AI?

gE3g

E[[ 3

EEE

*EIII

$EEI

FEE[

g $E

+I$g

E;i E

ti$:E

;iiis

E +

3rI.i

g$I$

iEiE

E[[rE

'EEg

EIEi

l E

$lEl

EEgf

iffi ;

IaE*

E+f{

luEg

iIi[E

EH

sEi*r

sar

=aEl

ETiri

= u

uil}[

iEfE

E[Ef

llE3

r=+E

B:;4

,ix

gt;fi

tEir

P ;g

i1+i

BE33

ii3rrE

H IE

fi;Ei

ig g

rgH

EFES

ssif

$cgE

lri3E

$fii;

tFi$

*Ess

$;iE

te}

EEE$

i$E;

i 'i+?

iti[8

3+s;

ii[E

H3t

E s,

EE*

aH s

'aa

n -ia

utas

cI:t+

ir +t

iIfE

g[g[

[EIiE

g[i}

[gE

il i I

EEgE

I;Eg

*Egg

lEga

l3*

aagE

l;g;g

ilEig

Eiae

gEgE

EgEI

iEiE

iEE*

FsF.

3€"a

'*?

Ea lg

Eg'*a

[IEEE

ElEl

gE[[E

E:u

iais

iiiEEE

EEE?

aiEE

ffia[

Ei[e

lgiiE

EE gg

g;lI-

r ;}i

aE a'

Eu=

1

'*aai

r,Hig

E e

aaiIE

iEEE

=*iE

EE?

*EiE

ffiE*

EeE

6E

E.E

F f.*

qT

IiiEE

EEE3

iEgi

iEiE

EB-i[

EEEB

igEI

EEEI

gEEi

igi+

[E;it

gi E

Hi*t

=EiiI

r?i:g

;ss

*E tT

E $1

X

EEiE

BEIIE

EIIil

q*lllE

EgEE

[EiE

llEE;

1tE

*iei;E

iigng

H +

rgfE

iIlB*

'i+E*

i'se-

-= 5

u

ri+Eq

6=,q

;-E c

+esr

ie u

iIiilI

iEE

iEiA

a E

s$ig

i[gBi

:E E

*-E;

+a=a

qg11

+E?H

flEi:

is*

*$ge

"iIg*

i1ilF

r*; 3

+f;a

EE+s

s bn

'= a

g;E;

UEt

IlFEE

qeg.

agiE

i;.gE

gEI*E

iEiE

=U;E

E gI

E

*Elg

BIEE

IEEi

EBEA

IEEg

lgiB

ilEEi

iaEl

EEii

gE

E E:

:sil

H!

E 6

- e;

E.i +

*E?l

3;;['

3es;

A+ss

[[[ ff

ia?*

iEE$

sHE;

ra

d E.

o

1[ BE

I11E

liE EE

I lEa

EiEE

E E[

BlE1

?EgE

EeE

E =

= ?c

iee

; ia a1

e3 +

cE +

i *E

iEE9

EE a

E iiE

eeE-

I r:g

;EnF

1a i=

1*:+

as33

i ?Er

IqoE

_+-=

EBe

E B'

:+

i* ;

=*EE

era?

H g

g1ie

iEr;;

g 6*

EEg Ii[

$Ei+

i 6$ i

Es;:i

ElFL

Sa iE

;eqg

E iE

fi i

Fs*

r+E;

is EEE

E i:

* l; * 5

B r;

;L!

o9r-<

O3r

lg!g

gEgI

ii:;a

;* iili

eE Eg

EEgE

$gI li

ilg E

'IEEg

geg3

Egis

ggEi

EEEi

Eiia

Elgg

gra

E Zf

; *E

i

B1E?

EIe]

1lt

a F

I 3c

r i7,

'z'3g

s3.E€i

e = *:

a ==

='i g

gi $E

E Ei

Ellg

' EH 1

r1f E

F* s

i*i i

"sfe

traT:

sreE

t{iH

EEFi

Ise?

c;**

iiggI

if; ia

gi;l

-i*r+

Ei;a

=:'i s

FIg*

g=[e

'rjrE

a=si

Eila

r FAi

ss[c

I B$g

I*6

'-{..x

3-?g

Frqg

E;F€

ii +;

E-Ta

i: Ia

E3a

.po

_.o

p-6'

H q

E E

. &E:

3 B

EErE

;*-tE

Er*

arq

;5EA

aE i

iial€

;ar

qq =

[gflf

iEI}f

iaita

atr;E

at af

fia E

igl g

3qll?

r1*a

1

E*gl

ll ffi

aEqH

EEiE

IiEiE

i iEE

E lg

gl[[t

[Egg

g

si€E

Iis3i

?B?E

3Ee?

+E}fE

i ?iE

r '?e

i]r€E

i E B

E11E

iEEi

EIEE

EEEE

EEEi

1E Ei

Eg EI

i[i IE

i E:H

Ir ia

:la

: e1[

igEB

E.iH

.EEE

iilEffi

A '-i

F*E*

g*E3

[ =

{ N)

ID Fd o o P o I 7 A) 0e E) o o o B o o o.

alsr

:rEqg

1lgg

iggg

}SIS

g,$[

gI[$

[1[g

{,Ig

gggs

ggig

I,$ gg

tgtg

;g E

F gE

[liiig

gg a

g.$E

r$+s

+g; $

*sEE

$E IE

EEllE

E iE

Bi =

iaE,

;i;ix

;**gs

gE1i

'3*ii

g.l**

'rF

**'E

sBg*

$1*s

e=$a

uii[3

EE

Jll

n-: E

' >, I

PE.}E

6"

r -i,

LIIN

-

= F!

!.'

(D .

.a, !

Y

>>eJ

o

\^H B.B

8

=s*

d'N

qJ:

tt\h,

^PN

5,tu

9t

5B5

g g

ts."

iz

tsts

[ e

r=-t

F 3r

; s

o-.= A>

a|/-

-a-

E{E

.oo+

o#t

s+ i;

o.

a (! o FO @ n oq 0c o o (D (D o ii' o E os. 4= H

\uq

{i-

, u)