Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto ...

52
5/5/22, 8:34 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-05-04/family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 1/12 Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit Nearly three months after a 16-year-old girl was thrown to the ground in a violent arrest by Rialto police, her family has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit seeking $10 million in damages. The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court on Wednesday, alleges the officers used excessive force and battered the girl during the arrest, among other claims. Court documents name as defendants two Rialto police officers, Police Chief Mark Kling, the city of Rialto, San Bernardino County and 10 people whose identities are not yet known to the plaintiff.

Transcript of Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto ...

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 112

CALIFORNIA

Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto policefiles federal lawsuitBY GREGORY YEE | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 842 PM PT

Nearly three months after a 16-year-old girl was thrown to the ground in a violent arrest

by Rialto police her family has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit seeking $10 million in

damages

The lawsuit filed in US District Court on Wednesday alleges the officers used

excessive force and battered the girl during the arrest among other claims

Court documents name as defendants two Rialto police officers Police Chief Mark

Kling the city of Rialto San Bernardino County and 10 people whose identities are not

yet known to the plaintiff

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 212

The teen was arrested Feb 11 after police stopped her for riding an illegal motorized

bike in a residential neighborhood at high speeds Kling said days after her arrest Police

launched an investigation into the officersrsquo actions and apologized to the girlrsquos family

A portion of her arrest was captured on bystander video which shows the officers grab

her arms and then fling her to the ground One officer appears to grab her neck

ADVERTISEMENT

The officers were not named in the days after the arrest but court documents claim that

an officer named Ivan Delgadillo Arce choked and struck the teen while another officer

identified only as Zamora failed to intervene

Zamora is also accused of conspiracy ldquofor attempting to cover up the brutal battery on

the minor and for furtherance of conspiracy by arresting the minor and lying to her

father and grandfatherrdquo according to court documents

CALIFORNIA

LAPD protesters clash downtown after rally against overturning of Roe vs WadeMay 3 2022

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 312

The girl identified in court documents only as ldquoSAJrdquo was riding a homemade ldquomini-

bikerdquo with her twin brother near their home documents stated

ldquoKids riding homemade mini-bikes are commonplace in Rialto and as long as the

youths wear helmets local law enforcement usually turns a blind eye but this day

marked a change to this unwritten policyrdquo the lawsuit states

The girl was stopped around 4 pm Feb 11 at the intersection of South Linden and

Pinedale avenues by the officers who accused her of speeding

Delgadillo cursed at the girl repeatedly and questioned her sexuality ldquocreating a

negative tone for what could have been a negative encounterrdquo the lawsuit alleges

According to a transcript included in the lawsuit Delgadillo accused the girl of lying

after she told him she was 17 She was later determined to be 16

The exchange became more heated as the officer asked her whether she wanted to keep

the bike and had someone to pick her up

ldquoStop being a smart assrdquo Delgadillo said according to the transcript ldquoYoursquore not talking

to your DaDa or your Mama [in a mocking tone] Yoursquore talking to police officers Ok

Stop being a smart ass and we can treat you like a young lady Okrdquo

The officer accused her of going 40 mph on the bike

ldquoIrsquom not asking you Irsquom telling you because we were following yourdquo Delgadillo said

ldquoWe had to get up to like 80 to catch up to you hellip Wersquore trying to tell you that yoursquore

detained right now for a crime The crime is you canrsquot be riding these things like thatrdquo

Delgadillo told Zamora to make sure the teen got her helmet off according to the

transcript

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 412

ldquoPut it to the side hellip before she grabs you and hits you with it as a weaponrdquo Delgadillo

said

The girl called out to another minor across the street telling the minor to get her

brother The officers meanwhile moved to arrest her

ldquoIrsquom communicatingrdquo the girl said ldquoNo come on Irsquom communicating with yourdquo

CALIFORNIA

Cedars-Sinai faces civil rights lawsuit over Black motherrsquos 2016 deathMay 4 2022

Delgadillo told her to stop several times according to the lawsuit

ldquoDo I have to tase yourdquo he said ldquoI donrsquot wanna tase you Stop resisting Stop

resisting I donrsquot wanna hurt yourdquo

As he spoke Delgadillo threw the girl to the ground according to the suit She landed

on a shoulder she had recently had surgery on the lawsuit says

Delgadillo put his knee on her chest and said ldquoDid you just try to bite me Handcuff

her Handcuff her nowrdquo

Delgadillo said the girl tried to bite him a second time and the officers put the girl in

their patrol vehicle as her grandfather walked up according to the suit

At the same time Delgadillo ldquoforcefully intentionally and without regard for the

minorrsquos life struck her directly in the throat sucker punch style while she was

handcuffed and in the patrol unitrdquo the lawsuit alleges

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 512

The strike is visible on Delgadillorsquos body-camera video but not on a bystanderrsquos

cellphone video according to the suit

Zamora told the girlrsquos grandfather that they tried to detain her and that he and

Delgadillo ldquotalked to her very nicerdquo

The grandfather asked whether she was going to jail for resisting

ldquoNo shersquos going to jail for assaulting an officerrdquo Delgadillo said ldquoAre you kidding merdquo

ldquoShersquos under arrest for disrespecting usrdquo Zamora said to the girlrsquos father who had also

walked up according to the transcript

ldquoHe hurt my neckrdquo the girl said ldquoHe hurt my neck He hurt my neck He put his hand

around my neckrdquo

ldquoWe were as polite as we could possibly be to herrdquo Delgadillo said

CALIFORNIA

Two LAPD officers under investigation for firing bullets into neighborsrsquoapartmentsMay 3 2022

The lawsuit acknowledges that Kling apologized shortly after the girlrsquos arrest but says

ldquowords without actions are hollow and are received as suchrdquo

The police chief failed in his handling of the incident the suit alleges because the

assault occurred while the girl was handcuffed and seated in the back of a patrol vehicle

ldquoWhile this explains why [he] refuses to release the damning body worn camera footage

it does not explain why [he] has not fired defendant Delgadillo for the brutal battery on

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 212

The teen was arrested Feb 11 after police stopped her for riding an illegal motorized

bike in a residential neighborhood at high speeds Kling said days after her arrest Police

launched an investigation into the officersrsquo actions and apologized to the girlrsquos family

A portion of her arrest was captured on bystander video which shows the officers grab

her arms and then fling her to the ground One officer appears to grab her neck

ADVERTISEMENT

The officers were not named in the days after the arrest but court documents claim that

an officer named Ivan Delgadillo Arce choked and struck the teen while another officer

identified only as Zamora failed to intervene

Zamora is also accused of conspiracy ldquofor attempting to cover up the brutal battery on

the minor and for furtherance of conspiracy by arresting the minor and lying to her

father and grandfatherrdquo according to court documents

CALIFORNIA

LAPD protesters clash downtown after rally against overturning of Roe vs WadeMay 3 2022

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 312

The girl identified in court documents only as ldquoSAJrdquo was riding a homemade ldquomini-

bikerdquo with her twin brother near their home documents stated

ldquoKids riding homemade mini-bikes are commonplace in Rialto and as long as the

youths wear helmets local law enforcement usually turns a blind eye but this day

marked a change to this unwritten policyrdquo the lawsuit states

The girl was stopped around 4 pm Feb 11 at the intersection of South Linden and

Pinedale avenues by the officers who accused her of speeding

Delgadillo cursed at the girl repeatedly and questioned her sexuality ldquocreating a

negative tone for what could have been a negative encounterrdquo the lawsuit alleges

According to a transcript included in the lawsuit Delgadillo accused the girl of lying

after she told him she was 17 She was later determined to be 16

The exchange became more heated as the officer asked her whether she wanted to keep

the bike and had someone to pick her up

ldquoStop being a smart assrdquo Delgadillo said according to the transcript ldquoYoursquore not talking

to your DaDa or your Mama [in a mocking tone] Yoursquore talking to police officers Ok

Stop being a smart ass and we can treat you like a young lady Okrdquo

The officer accused her of going 40 mph on the bike

ldquoIrsquom not asking you Irsquom telling you because we were following yourdquo Delgadillo said

ldquoWe had to get up to like 80 to catch up to you hellip Wersquore trying to tell you that yoursquore

detained right now for a crime The crime is you canrsquot be riding these things like thatrdquo

Delgadillo told Zamora to make sure the teen got her helmet off according to the

transcript

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 412

ldquoPut it to the side hellip before she grabs you and hits you with it as a weaponrdquo Delgadillo

said

The girl called out to another minor across the street telling the minor to get her

brother The officers meanwhile moved to arrest her

ldquoIrsquom communicatingrdquo the girl said ldquoNo come on Irsquom communicating with yourdquo

CALIFORNIA

Cedars-Sinai faces civil rights lawsuit over Black motherrsquos 2016 deathMay 4 2022

Delgadillo told her to stop several times according to the lawsuit

ldquoDo I have to tase yourdquo he said ldquoI donrsquot wanna tase you Stop resisting Stop

resisting I donrsquot wanna hurt yourdquo

As he spoke Delgadillo threw the girl to the ground according to the suit She landed

on a shoulder she had recently had surgery on the lawsuit says

Delgadillo put his knee on her chest and said ldquoDid you just try to bite me Handcuff

her Handcuff her nowrdquo

Delgadillo said the girl tried to bite him a second time and the officers put the girl in

their patrol vehicle as her grandfather walked up according to the suit

At the same time Delgadillo ldquoforcefully intentionally and without regard for the

minorrsquos life struck her directly in the throat sucker punch style while she was

handcuffed and in the patrol unitrdquo the lawsuit alleges

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 512

The strike is visible on Delgadillorsquos body-camera video but not on a bystanderrsquos

cellphone video according to the suit

Zamora told the girlrsquos grandfather that they tried to detain her and that he and

Delgadillo ldquotalked to her very nicerdquo

The grandfather asked whether she was going to jail for resisting

ldquoNo shersquos going to jail for assaulting an officerrdquo Delgadillo said ldquoAre you kidding merdquo

ldquoShersquos under arrest for disrespecting usrdquo Zamora said to the girlrsquos father who had also

walked up according to the transcript

ldquoHe hurt my neckrdquo the girl said ldquoHe hurt my neck He hurt my neck He put his hand

around my neckrdquo

ldquoWe were as polite as we could possibly be to herrdquo Delgadillo said

CALIFORNIA

Two LAPD officers under investigation for firing bullets into neighborsrsquoapartmentsMay 3 2022

The lawsuit acknowledges that Kling apologized shortly after the girlrsquos arrest but says

ldquowords without actions are hollow and are received as suchrdquo

The police chief failed in his handling of the incident the suit alleges because the

assault occurred while the girl was handcuffed and seated in the back of a patrol vehicle

ldquoWhile this explains why [he] refuses to release the damning body worn camera footage

it does not explain why [he] has not fired defendant Delgadillo for the brutal battery on

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 312

The girl identified in court documents only as ldquoSAJrdquo was riding a homemade ldquomini-

bikerdquo with her twin brother near their home documents stated

ldquoKids riding homemade mini-bikes are commonplace in Rialto and as long as the

youths wear helmets local law enforcement usually turns a blind eye but this day

marked a change to this unwritten policyrdquo the lawsuit states

The girl was stopped around 4 pm Feb 11 at the intersection of South Linden and

Pinedale avenues by the officers who accused her of speeding

Delgadillo cursed at the girl repeatedly and questioned her sexuality ldquocreating a

negative tone for what could have been a negative encounterrdquo the lawsuit alleges

According to a transcript included in the lawsuit Delgadillo accused the girl of lying

after she told him she was 17 She was later determined to be 16

The exchange became more heated as the officer asked her whether she wanted to keep

the bike and had someone to pick her up

ldquoStop being a smart assrdquo Delgadillo said according to the transcript ldquoYoursquore not talking

to your DaDa or your Mama [in a mocking tone] Yoursquore talking to police officers Ok

Stop being a smart ass and we can treat you like a young lady Okrdquo

The officer accused her of going 40 mph on the bike

ldquoIrsquom not asking you Irsquom telling you because we were following yourdquo Delgadillo said

ldquoWe had to get up to like 80 to catch up to you hellip Wersquore trying to tell you that yoursquore

detained right now for a crime The crime is you canrsquot be riding these things like thatrdquo

Delgadillo told Zamora to make sure the teen got her helmet off according to the

transcript

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 412

ldquoPut it to the side hellip before she grabs you and hits you with it as a weaponrdquo Delgadillo

said

The girl called out to another minor across the street telling the minor to get her

brother The officers meanwhile moved to arrest her

ldquoIrsquom communicatingrdquo the girl said ldquoNo come on Irsquom communicating with yourdquo

CALIFORNIA

Cedars-Sinai faces civil rights lawsuit over Black motherrsquos 2016 deathMay 4 2022

Delgadillo told her to stop several times according to the lawsuit

ldquoDo I have to tase yourdquo he said ldquoI donrsquot wanna tase you Stop resisting Stop

resisting I donrsquot wanna hurt yourdquo

As he spoke Delgadillo threw the girl to the ground according to the suit She landed

on a shoulder she had recently had surgery on the lawsuit says

Delgadillo put his knee on her chest and said ldquoDid you just try to bite me Handcuff

her Handcuff her nowrdquo

Delgadillo said the girl tried to bite him a second time and the officers put the girl in

their patrol vehicle as her grandfather walked up according to the suit

At the same time Delgadillo ldquoforcefully intentionally and without regard for the

minorrsquos life struck her directly in the throat sucker punch style while she was

handcuffed and in the patrol unitrdquo the lawsuit alleges

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 512

The strike is visible on Delgadillorsquos body-camera video but not on a bystanderrsquos

cellphone video according to the suit

Zamora told the girlrsquos grandfather that they tried to detain her and that he and

Delgadillo ldquotalked to her very nicerdquo

The grandfather asked whether she was going to jail for resisting

ldquoNo shersquos going to jail for assaulting an officerrdquo Delgadillo said ldquoAre you kidding merdquo

ldquoShersquos under arrest for disrespecting usrdquo Zamora said to the girlrsquos father who had also

walked up according to the transcript

ldquoHe hurt my neckrdquo the girl said ldquoHe hurt my neck He hurt my neck He put his hand

around my neckrdquo

ldquoWe were as polite as we could possibly be to herrdquo Delgadillo said

CALIFORNIA

Two LAPD officers under investigation for firing bullets into neighborsrsquoapartmentsMay 3 2022

The lawsuit acknowledges that Kling apologized shortly after the girlrsquos arrest but says

ldquowords without actions are hollow and are received as suchrdquo

The police chief failed in his handling of the incident the suit alleges because the

assault occurred while the girl was handcuffed and seated in the back of a patrol vehicle

ldquoWhile this explains why [he] refuses to release the damning body worn camera footage

it does not explain why [he] has not fired defendant Delgadillo for the brutal battery on

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 412

ldquoPut it to the side hellip before she grabs you and hits you with it as a weaponrdquo Delgadillo

said

The girl called out to another minor across the street telling the minor to get her

brother The officers meanwhile moved to arrest her

ldquoIrsquom communicatingrdquo the girl said ldquoNo come on Irsquom communicating with yourdquo

CALIFORNIA

Cedars-Sinai faces civil rights lawsuit over Black motherrsquos 2016 deathMay 4 2022

Delgadillo told her to stop several times according to the lawsuit

ldquoDo I have to tase yourdquo he said ldquoI donrsquot wanna tase you Stop resisting Stop

resisting I donrsquot wanna hurt yourdquo

As he spoke Delgadillo threw the girl to the ground according to the suit She landed

on a shoulder she had recently had surgery on the lawsuit says

Delgadillo put his knee on her chest and said ldquoDid you just try to bite me Handcuff

her Handcuff her nowrdquo

Delgadillo said the girl tried to bite him a second time and the officers put the girl in

their patrol vehicle as her grandfather walked up according to the suit

At the same time Delgadillo ldquoforcefully intentionally and without regard for the

minorrsquos life struck her directly in the throat sucker punch style while she was

handcuffed and in the patrol unitrdquo the lawsuit alleges

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 512

The strike is visible on Delgadillorsquos body-camera video but not on a bystanderrsquos

cellphone video according to the suit

Zamora told the girlrsquos grandfather that they tried to detain her and that he and

Delgadillo ldquotalked to her very nicerdquo

The grandfather asked whether she was going to jail for resisting

ldquoNo shersquos going to jail for assaulting an officerrdquo Delgadillo said ldquoAre you kidding merdquo

ldquoShersquos under arrest for disrespecting usrdquo Zamora said to the girlrsquos father who had also

walked up according to the transcript

ldquoHe hurt my neckrdquo the girl said ldquoHe hurt my neck He hurt my neck He put his hand

around my neckrdquo

ldquoWe were as polite as we could possibly be to herrdquo Delgadillo said

CALIFORNIA

Two LAPD officers under investigation for firing bullets into neighborsrsquoapartmentsMay 3 2022

The lawsuit acknowledges that Kling apologized shortly after the girlrsquos arrest but says

ldquowords without actions are hollow and are received as suchrdquo

The police chief failed in his handling of the incident the suit alleges because the

assault occurred while the girl was handcuffed and seated in the back of a patrol vehicle

ldquoWhile this explains why [he] refuses to release the damning body worn camera footage

it does not explain why [he] has not fired defendant Delgadillo for the brutal battery on

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 512

The strike is visible on Delgadillorsquos body-camera video but not on a bystanderrsquos

cellphone video according to the suit

Zamora told the girlrsquos grandfather that they tried to detain her and that he and

Delgadillo ldquotalked to her very nicerdquo

The grandfather asked whether she was going to jail for resisting

ldquoNo shersquos going to jail for assaulting an officerrdquo Delgadillo said ldquoAre you kidding merdquo

ldquoShersquos under arrest for disrespecting usrdquo Zamora said to the girlrsquos father who had also

walked up according to the transcript

ldquoHe hurt my neckrdquo the girl said ldquoHe hurt my neck He hurt my neck He put his hand

around my neckrdquo

ldquoWe were as polite as we could possibly be to herrdquo Delgadillo said

CALIFORNIA

Two LAPD officers under investigation for firing bullets into neighborsrsquoapartmentsMay 3 2022

The lawsuit acknowledges that Kling apologized shortly after the girlrsquos arrest but says

ldquowords without actions are hollow and are received as suchrdquo

The police chief failed in his handling of the incident the suit alleges because the

assault occurred while the girl was handcuffed and seated in the back of a patrol vehicle

ldquoWhile this explains why [he] refuses to release the damning body worn camera footage

it does not explain why [he] has not fired defendant Delgadillo for the brutal battery on

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 834 AM Family of teen thrown to ground in violent arrest by Rialto police files federal lawsuit - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04family-of-teen-thrown-to-ground-in-violent-arrest-by-rialto-police-files-federal-lawsuit 612

the minorrdquo the suit says

The lawsuit also states that the girl was booked into juvenile hall on suspicion of assault

and battery on the officer and imprisoned for four days without cause

The familyrsquos attorney Caree Harper is asking the court to award $10 million in

damages plus attorneysrsquo fees and any other relief the court deems appropriate

Adaacuten Ortega a Rialto spokesperson said the city and Police Department do not

comment on pending litigation

In a February statement Kling said he viewed officer body-camera footage ldquoand

although the video depicts the juvenile resisting officers we are investigating the

officerrsquos decision to trip the juvenile to the ground and later placing his hand on the

juvenilersquos throat during the arrestrdquo

A San Bernardino County spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment

Wednesday

CALIFORNIA

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

G Y

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 16

COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly

May 04 2022 1132 AM

JOSHUA TREE mdash The COVID-19 vaccine and testing site at the Joshua Tree Community Center will reduce services after today The site which was

previously open every Monday and Wednesday will be transitioning to a special-event-only location

ldquoDue to lack of demand starting next week it is switching to special events onlyrdquo said county spokesperson David Wert ldquoIf demand increases then

we will increase services and dates as well as neededrdquo

Wert said an average of eight people were vaccinated per day at the community center from March through Monday May 2 By contrast an

average of 23 people were vaccinated per day at the community center from June 6 to Dec 29 2021

Special vaccination events are scheduled for the Joshua Tree Community Center from 10 am to 2 pm May 11 and June 8 Appointments will be

Coming soon high $400s and upCentury Communities

SUBSCRIBE

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182671covid-clinic-in-joshua-tree-no-longer-open-weekly 26

available on myturncagov starting on the Thursday prior to the week of event Walk-ins are always welcome

Organizations or entities interested in hosting a vaccine clinic in the Morongo Basin can submit their request at sbcovid19comvaccine-or-testing-

event-program

Morongo Basin residents can still receive vaccines at the Walgreens in Yucca Valley Walmart in Yucca Valley Morongo Basin Community Health

Center in Yucca Valley Vons in Yucca Valley Rite Aid in Twentynine Palms and Desert Oasis Healthcare Additional locations may be listed on

myturncagov or vaccinesgov

Referrals for additional locations to receive a COVID-19 vaccine may also be available through medical groups or primary care physicians

COMMENTS (0)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 17

Your ballot is in the mailBy Jeneacute Estrada Hi-Desert Star

May 04 2022 1204 PM

MORONGO BASIN mdash County residents can expect to get voter information on the June 7 primary election this month County voter information

guides were delivered to the US postal service this week and mail ballots will be delivered to the postal service on May 9

Locally seats for the Hi-Desert Water District Joshua Basin Water District Morongo Unied School District Yucca Valley Town Council Twentynine

Palms City Council and other local ofces will all be up for election

The candidates for specic districts in a residentrsquos area will be included in their voter information guides

A list of candidates can be found at httpstinyurlcom3e59mx9a

SUBSCRIBE

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Your ballot is in the mail | Hi-Desert Star

httpshidesertstarcomnews182677your-ballot-is-in-the-mail 27

Up for election are the seats for the state governor lieutenant governor secretary of state and other state ofces

For most state and federal contests the two candidates with the most votes no matter what their party will appear on the election ballot for the Nov

8 election

For county contests if a candidate receives more than 50 of the vote in the primary they are considered elected If no candidate receives more

than 50 the two candidates with the most votes will appear on the general election ballot

For most city ofces the candidate with the most votes in the primary election wins the seat

There are two contests on the ballot to ll the same US Senate seat Registered voters may vote on both The rst contest is the regular election for the

full six-year term of ofce beginning on Jan 3 2023

The second contest is a special vacancy election since the current senator Alex Padilla is temporarily lling the vacancy created when former

Senator Kamala Harris was elected vice president

ldquoThe primary election will be the rst opportunity for you to vote for candidates in the newly drawn congressional state Assembly state Senate

board of equalization county supervisorial and City Council districtsrdquo said Secretary of State Shirley Weber in a press release

County residents can vote by mail at ballot drop-off locations at early voter sites or at polling places Every voter registered before May 23 will

receive a vote-by-mail ballot Voted ballots must be postmarked on or before June 7

ldquoIn the last two major elections six to seven times more voters cast a mail ballot than voted at a polling place on Election Dayrdquo said county Registrar

of Voters Michael Jimenez ldquoMail ballots denitely widen the breadth of ballots we receive backrdquo

There will be 300 polling places in the county that will be open from 7 am to 8 pm on June 7 Your polling place is printed on the back cover of

your county voter information guide

A complete list of polling places is available at wwwsbcountyelectionscom

COMMENTS (1)

You must Sign Up or Sign In to post comments on articles amp stories

542022 517 PM

The list of candidates for San Bernardino County can be found herehttpswwwsbcountygovuploadsROVElections20220607Report_CandidateListpdf Our local town council school board andwater board seats are not on the June ballot they will appear on the ballot for the General Election in November

You have to be logged in to commentUser information from the previous website did not carry over so all users must re-register

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 112

CALIFORNIA

LA County Board of Supervisors votes to create super agency onhomelessness

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 212

County supervisors voted 3-2 to revamp eorts on homelessness Above an encampment in downtown Los Angeles inNovember (Luis Sinco Los Angeles Times)

BY RUBEN VIVES | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to create a new office or

department that would coordinate the countyrsquos response to the homelessness crisis in

the region

The new entity would have authority over various agencies mdash including the countyrsquos

departments of health services social services and mental health mdash and would report

directly to the Board of Supervisors

In a divided vote the supervisors called for the county chief executive to return with

recommendations on the specific powers and structure of the new office Among the

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 312

options to be considered were modeling it after the county Office of Emergency

Management which coordinates county agencies during emergencies or elevating the

Homeless Initiative which currently manages homeless funds from the Measure H sales

tax

The new entity was one of seven recommendations presented to the board Tuesday by a

special committee set up to examine ways to improve the countyrsquos response to

homelessness Among them were several proposals to improve the efficiency of the Los

Angeles Homeless Services Authority and clarify its role That joint powers agency

could implement some of the recommendations independently but others might

require negotiation between the city and county

All the recommendations were approved on a single 3-2 vote

Supervisor Kathryn Barger who co-authored and introduced the motion said the

recommendations would improve coordination of services for unhoused people and

increase accountability of the countyrsquos agencies

ldquoThe end goal is to reform the systematic dysfunction that has resulted in the dismal

outcomes wersquore seeing play out on our streets in our storefronts and in our

neighborhoodsrdquo she said ldquoWe now have a path forwardrdquo

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 412

The changes would give county agencies and cities access to the Homeless Management

Information System a database that tracks services provided to people experiencing

homelessness Additionally the board approved a recommendation that a yet-to-be-

determined share of revenue from Measure H the 2017 sales tax increase to help

homeless people be directed to a ldquolocal solutions fundrdquo to help support citiesrsquo efforts to

implement their own homeless housing and service plans

Supervisor Hilda Solis who co-authored the motion said the recommendations provide

a ldquo framework for building a transparent inclusive and accountable homeless

governance systemrdquo

ldquoBut what I am most grateful for is the voice our city partners had at the table to

enhance collaboration to support unhoused individuals living in their jurisdictionsrdquo she

said

Given its name many perceive LAHSA as a one-stop shop for solving the countyrsquos

homeless crisis

But the agency doesnrsquot control many of the tools that help people get off the streets and

into housing Its powers overlap with that of city and county departments complicating

the larger effort to get people into housing

Created in 1993 LAHSA was given limited powers and an even more limited mission of

stopping the city and county from bickering over federal dollars for homeless housing

and services Its inability to live up to the publicrsquos expectations mdash coupled with the

countyrsquos skyrocketing homeless population mdash has led to a growing consensus that the

agency needed to be restructured

Those efforts started last July when the Board of Supervisors established the Blue

Ribbon Commission on Homelessness an eight-member committee tasked with

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 512

conducting a comprehensive study and analysis of LAHSArsquos governance and operations

and providing recommendations to change and improve the agencyrsquos effectiveness

Six months of meetings resulted in the recommendations in which the commission and

its staff sought feedback from the county supervisorsrsquo staff Los Angeles City Council

members business associations coalitions of faith leaders officials from cities across

the county and civic groups like the Committee for Greater LA

The supervisors say they want LAHSA to refocus its efforts on ensuring that federal

funding opportunities are in line with state and local priorities

Despite its approval at least two members of the board remain skeptical about whether

enacting the recommendations would fix any of the ongoing problems They also worry

about the disruption of services during the transitional phase

Voting against the motion was Supervisor Sheila Kuehl who said the recommendations

would ldquocause a thickening of the county bureaucracy and a process of administrative

seat-swapping that will divert time resources and attentionrdquo

ldquoItrsquos like moving the deck chairs on the Titanic and thinking it will keep it afloatrdquo

Supervisor Holly J Mitchell said she still couldnrsquot see how the new entity could

coordinate so many different departments on a complex issue She also worried about

the costs in implementing the recommendations She said the county had already spent

$1 million just to conduct the study

ldquoThis motion is creating another system without us knowing how much money we are

using where itrsquos going and the impact it will haverdquo she said

Ahmad Chapman spokesman for LAHSA said the split of votes among supervisors

demonstrates the difficulty in addressing the crisis

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04la-county-board-of-supervisors-to-overhaul-top-homeless-agency 612

ldquoLAHSA remains committed to leading our rehousing system with commitment

innovation and heartrdquo Chapman said ldquoHomelessness is an all-hands-on-deck

emergency that requires all of us working together to bring our unhoused neighbors

homerdquo

Times staff writer Doug Smith contributed to this report

CALIFORNIA HOUSING amp HOMELESSNESS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Ruben Vives

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Ruben Vives is a general assignment reporter for the Los Angeles Times A native of

Guatemala he got his start in journalism by writing for The Timesrsquo Homicide Report

in 2007 He helped uncover the financial corruption in the city of Bell that led to

criminal charges against eight city officials The 2010 investigative series won the

Pulitzer Prize for public service and other prestigious awards

SIGN ME UP

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 17

By By ELIZABETH CHOUELIZABETH CHOU | | hchouscngcomhchouscngcom | Daily News | Daily NewsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1201 pmMay 4 2022 at 1201 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 556 pmMay 4 2022 at 556 pm

Homeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessHomeless residents of Echo Park confront Los Angeles police officers moving in to remove people living at the Echo Park Lake homelessencampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)encampment in Los Angeles late Wednesday March 24 2021 (AP PhotoDamian Dovarganes)

People living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo inPeople living on streets in three Los Angeles neighborhoods and one Westside encampment expressed a ldquonear-universal interestrdquo in

getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4getting housed but 43 were never contacted to move into housing according to RAND Corporation research released Wednesday May 4

The fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help localThe fact that 43 said they were never contacted about housing may be the ldquomost importantrdquo finding of their research so far to help local

leaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their reportleaders address LAs homelessness crisis researchers wrote in their report

About 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offeredAbout 90 of unsheltered people who participated in the survey expressed interest in getting housing researchers said Half were offered

housing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they saidhousing or shelter and one-third are on housing waitlists they said

ldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remainldquoWe found a near-universal interest in obtaining housing among our survey respondents but about half of those we spoke to remain

unhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND reportunhoused despite reporting being offered housing in the pastrdquo said Jason M Ward an economist and lead author of the RAND report

RAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack ofRAND researchers also found that other top deterrents to housing cited by people living on the streets were safety concerns and lack of

privacy in offered housingprivacy in offered housing

NEWSNEWS

RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butRAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters butwant to get off the streetswant to get off the streetsA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inA survey of unhoused people in four locations in LA finds near-universal interest inbeing housedbeing housed

bull bull NewsNews

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504ldn-l-homeless-survey-0504 27

Researchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomightResearchers said this means that the congregate shelters that city and county leaders have put more funding into in recent months ldquomight

have a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquohave a limited ability to effectively address homelessnessrdquo

Of those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel orOf those surveyed 80 said they would accept a private room in any form of housing or a permanent stay at a hotel or motel or

permanent supportive housingpermanent supportive housing

Respondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term orRespondents were less interested in group shelters or sober living homes About half said they would accept safe camping short-term or

transitional shelters or shared housingtransitional shelters or shared housing

ldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelterldquoThe type of housing offered to unsheltered people matters a lotrdquo Ward said ldquoOur findings suggest that large expansions in shelter

capacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquocapacity in the city may do little to move unhoused people off the streetsrdquo

Other factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours atOther factors the unhoused respondents cited as preventing them from getting housed were challenges with filing paperwork the hours at

shelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstaclesshelters or the curfews at shelters Location and lack of cleanliness followed by various house rules were also considered obstacles

The findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans RowrdquoThe findings are among early results from systematic random surveys of 216 people in Skid Row Venice Hollywood and ldquoVeterans Rowrdquo

near the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The resultsnear the Veterans Affairs building on the Westside The surveys were conducted from September 2021 through January 2022 The results

were offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisiswere offered up amid an often contentious conversation in Los Angeles on the homelessness crisis

Angelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked inAngelenos cite ending homelessness as their top priority and it is a key issue in this year s municipal elections The issue is locked in

debates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streetsdebates over the reasons people are homeless and what should be done to most effectively help people get off the streets

In an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 andIn an effort to quickly remove encampments the city of Los Angeles recently adopted an anti-camping ordinance LAMC 4118 and

continues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areascontinues to enforce other laws restricting people from living on sidewalks in parks and in other areas

The anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people areThe anti-camping law was adopted after a court ruling in the Martin v Boise case said that such laws can be enforced as long as people are

offered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housingoffered shelter The court ruling did not specify the type of shelter or whether it needs to be permanent housing

Meanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas thenMeanwhile the city has begun carrying out operations to force people out of encampments in public spaces such as parks and plazas then

fencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tentsfencing off those areas to prevent people from returning to rebuild makeshift shelters and set up tents

An operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people wereAn operation at Echo Park Lake a year ago led to 200 unhoused people being forced out Although city leaders claimed those people were

offered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the cityoffered housing many ended up on the streets in other areas of the city

Heightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outsideHeightened attention was focused on encampments in Venice last winter when Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva stepped outside

of his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfrontsof his usual jurisdiction to intervene there and to criticize city leadersʼ handling of growing encampments on local beachfronts

Villanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said theVillanuevas Homeless Outreach Services Team transported a few people to shelters although some critical of Villanuevas efforts said the

Sheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless servicesSheriff s Department was not really equipped to provide homeless services

An operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo accordingAn operation led by Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin to house about 200 people in Venice was ldquolargely successfulrdquo according

to media reports cited in the RAND report to media reports cited in the RAND report which is availablewhich is available at the RAND website at the RAND website

RANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their countRANDs research is ongoing Researchers plan to release a final report after conducting more surveys They will also continue their count

of people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhousedof people living on the streets using teams that include people with experience working with and providing services to the unhoused

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Elizabeth ChouElizabeth Chou | Reporter| ReporterElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosElizabeth Chou has reported on Los Angeles City Hall government and politics since 2013 rst with City News Service and now the LosAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowAngeles Daily News since the end of 2016 She grew up in the Los Angeles area and is formerly a San Gabriel Valley girl She nowresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern Groupresides in the other Valley and is enjoying exploring her new San Fernando environs She previously worked at Eastern GroupPublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturePublications covering the cities of Montebello Monterey Park City of Commerce and Vernon She earned a BA degree in literaturefrom the University of California Santa Cruzfrom the University of California Santa Cruz

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing homelesshomeless Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADNTop Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PE Top Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDFTop Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 17

By By CITY NEWS SERVICECITY NEWS SERVICE | | newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom | |PUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 443 pmMay 4 2022 at 443 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 531 pmMay 4 2022 at 531 pm

Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution against Los Angeles County Public Health Director Barbara Ferrer said she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing and caution againstCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoCOVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to drop all precautions PhotoScreenshot of livecastScreenshot of livecast

Los Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearingLos Angeles County s public health director said on Wednesday May 4 that she sympathizes with people weary of calls for mask-wearing

and caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo toand caution against COVID-19 spread but with case numbers still rising and new variants emerging she said it would be a ldquomistakerdquo to

drop all precautionsdrop all precautions

ldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and theldquoI do know that most everyone is tired of the pandemic tired of wearing masks and exhausted trying to deal with the uncertainty and the

ever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize theever-changing guidancerdquo Barbara Ferrer told reporters during an online briefing Wednesday ldquoAnd it s very tempting to minimize the

impact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic livesimpact of the virus to support our desire to return to our pre-pandemic lives

ldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections whileldquoUnfortunately I think that would be a mistake that would make it harder for us to embrace strategies that extend protections while

minimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostminimizing disruptions There continue to be sensible steps we can take to reduce risk and prevent serious illness and death for those mostvulnerablerdquovulnerablerdquo

She again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to getShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arenʼt mandated She also again pushed for people to get

vaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sickvaccinated and receive booster shots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

Ferrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county hasFerrer reported another 2484 COVID cases on Wednesday reiterating that the average daily number of new infections in the county has

increased by 200 over the past monthincreased by 200 over the past month

NEWSNEWS

Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersFerrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbersshould inspire continued cautionshould inspire continued cautionShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentShe again urged residents to wear masks when in crowded settings even if they arentmandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostermandated She also again pushed for people to get vaccinated and receive boostershots and to stay home if they are feeling sickshots and to stay home if they are feeling sick

bull bull NewsNews

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 818 AM Ferrer reminds LA County Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News

httpswwwdailynewscom20220504ferrer-reminds-la-county-uptick-in-covid-numbers-should-inspire-continued-caution 27

The increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positiveThe increase has not yet translated into increases in hospitalizations and deaths According to state figures there were 248 COVID-positive

patients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care uppatients in county hospitals as of Wednesday up slightly from 236 on Tuesday Of those patients 27 were being treated in intensive care up

from 22 a day earlierfrom 22 a day earlier

Ferrer reported five more COVID deaths on WednesdayFerrer reported five more COVID deaths on Wednesday

As of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overallAs of Wednesday the average daily rate of people testing positive for the virus was 22 up slightly from previous days but still low overall

The seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week agoThe seven-day average daily rate of new cases in the county was 21 per 100000 residents up from 17 per 100000 a week ago

She noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent specialShe noted that the BA2 variant of COVID-19 and its offshoots now represent 96 of all local COVID infections that underwent special

testing to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the wintertesting to identify variants BA2 is a subvariant of the Omicron strain of the virus that caused a sharp surge in cases during the winter

months The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshootmonths The county however is already seeing rising numbers of cases identified as BA2121 which is an offshoot of BA2 That offshoot

now represents 8 of cases tested in the county she saidnow represents 8 of cases tested in the county she said

The county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 FerrerThe county is also monitoring the progress of two more variants blamed for spiking case numbers in South Africa mdash BA4 and BA5 Ferrer

said only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identifiedsaid only one case of BA4 has been detected in the county and no BA5 strains have been identified

Ferrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in healthFerrer offered a reminder that while indoor mask mandates have been lifted in most settings face coverings are still required in health

care facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airportscare facilities homeless shelters skilled nursing facilities aboard transit vehicles and in transportation hubs like airports

She conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited LosShe conceded that enforcement of the masking rule at airports is a challenge although she noted that inspectors who recently visited Los

Angeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the ruleAngeles International Airport found that most employees were adhering to the rule

ldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as theldquoI think it s harder for the disembarking passengers to understand the rules in LA Countyrdquo she said ldquoI have a lot of confidence that as themessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminalmessaging continues people will get more comfortable with the fact that they need to put their masks on once they get into the terminal

areasrdquoareasrdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews TipsContact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Coronavirus UpdateCoronavirus Update Stay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inboxStay up to date on the latest coronavirus coverage in your area right in your inbox

Enter your email to sign up

SIGN UP

City News ServiceCity News ServiceCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties ItsCity News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles Orange Riverside and San Diego counties Itsreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the Cityreporting and editing sta cover public safety courts local government and general assignment stories Contact the CityNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscomNews Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or newssocalnewscom

newssocalnewscomnewssocalnewscom

SPONSORED CONTENTSPONSORED CONTENT

San BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForSan BernardinoCalifornia Launches New Policy ForCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDayCars Used Less Than 49 MilesDay

By By ComparisonsorgComparisonsorg

Tags Tags CommunityCommunity CoronavirusCoronavirus Coronavirus vaccineCoronavirus vaccine EducationEducation governmentgovernment HealthHealthPublic healthPublic health Top Stories BreezeTop Stories Breeze Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPTTop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 110

OPINION

Op-Ed COVID vaccines need to be evolving much faster

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 210

(Nardus Engelbrecht Associated Press)

BY ERIC J TOPOL

MAY 4 2022 3 AM PT

The virus that brought us COVID-19 is now going through accelerated evolution Our

vaccines must do the same

The Omicron wave was by far the worst yet for the United States with at its peak well

over 1 million new cases a day nearly 160000 COVID-19 hospitalizations and almost

4000 deaths per day That was attributed to the BA1 variant the most densely mutated

version of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus since the pandemicrsquos origin About 40 to 50

of Americans were likely infected with this virus in the brief span of 10 weeks

Now wersquore facing even worse Omicron family variants BA2 and BA2121

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 310

For perspective Omicronrsquos BA1 was about 50 more infectious than Delta the variant

it replaced At the time it was hard to conceive of a version of the virus that could be

more contagious But BA2 which out-competed it here in the US is 30 more

transmissible than BA1 And BA2121 now overtaking BA2 is another 25 more

infectious than BA2 Accordingly in recent months since Omicron was first recognized

in the United States in late November wersquove gone from a hyper-transmissible virus

strain to two more that take that problem to another level

To make matters worse the Omicron-specific vaccines that are in clinical testing by

multiple vaccine manufacturers such as Moderna and Pfizer use the BA1 spike and

will most likely not be adequately protective against BA2121 infections or other new

Omicron family variants

ADVERTISEMENT

The latest variants have appeared in rapid succession a worrying sign that the virus will

prove adaptable over time Already the new Omicron variants are thriving in part

because they have become more difficult for our immune system to ldquoseerdquo They donrsquot

look like a prior version of the virus to which we have been exposed or against which we

have been vaccinated

That means even the millions of people who had Omicron BA1 infections earlier this

year are still vulnerable to infection with BA2121 especially if theyrsquore unvaccinated

That will promote spread and prolong the pandemic Moreover people who get

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 410

BA2121 infections may be susceptible to ldquolong COVIDrdquo the chronic condition that can

lead to significant functional impairment

Although existing vaccines are not particularly helpful at preventing infections with or

transmission of the new BA2 variants they do still work especially with boosters to

protect against hospitalizations and deaths We also have the Paxlovid pill pack for

treatment of any of these variants which has been shown to reduce hospitalizations and

deaths by 89 in people deemed at high risk While Paxlovid is variant-proof at this

time resistance can emerge and there have been reports of early relapse a problem

that has not yet been adequately explained

Where does this leave us The new BA2 variant is clearly going to add to the increasing

cases of COVID-19 in the United States now averaging about 60000 per day up 50

in the last two weeks but grossly underreported because of at-home testing and

individuals who arenrsquot tested at all There will be an increase in hospitalizations and

deaths especially among Americans age 50 and older who account for 92 of the

deaths in the pandemic

It is unlikely these major outcomes of the BA2121 variant will reach the profound

levels of the original Omicron wave here because there is certainly some cross-

immunity from prior exposure to BA1 So we need to be gearing up for whatrsquos likely to

come next further Omicron evolution and a new variant that has little to do with

Omicron

In South Africa a new fourth wave has begun with BA4 and BA5 which share some

properties with the BA2121 that we are dealing with There are many other Omicron

subvariants that are cropping up throughout the world that are not yet well

characterized but could potentially take the place of the ones dominating now

There is also an overwhelmingly high risk of a completely new variant for multiple

reasons The millions of immunocompromised people any one of whom could have

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Op-Ed Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomopinionstory2022-05-04covid-variants-vaccines-ineffective-omicron-ba-2-12-1-ba-4-ba-5 510

accelerated evolution of the virus within them and subsequently transmitted the virus

The huge populations around the world where vaccines have made negligible inroads

Abundant animal reservoirs with spillover to humans already documented The higher

incidence of coinfections in people such as Omicron and Delta forming ldquoDeltacronrdquo mdash

lineages that fortunately to date have not taken root

While we would all like the pandemic to be over we do not appear to be witnessing the

end The likelihood of more noxious variants ahead is high and our preparedness is

poor

Governments around the world need to make it a priority to support development of

variant-proof vaccines such as against the entire sarbecovirus family and all anticipated

variants The US pushed for the first wave of vaccines with an initiative called

Operation Warp Speed and that push should continue In the months ahead our

current vaccines may offer diminished protection against hospitalization and death

Likewise more oral drugs beyond Paxlovid need accelerated development and there are

many very good candidates in the pipeline

Ignoring the warnings will not make the virus go away It keeps getting fitter and more

transmissible while our human qualities of fatigue and complacency feed right into the

virusrsquos remarkable opportunism

Eric J Topol is a professor of molecular medicine at Scripps Research and author of

the newsletter Ground Truths

OPINION OP-ED COVID-19 PANDEMIC

A f h i i

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 116

CALIFORNIA

A top California official pushed hard for a $600-million maskdeal Fraud claims followed

ADVERTISEMENT

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 216

California Controller Betty Yee seen during a 2016 hearing sent a series of text messages in 2020 to promote a $600-million deal for the state to purchase protective masks from a startup healthcare supplies company The agreement waslater canceled (Rich Pedroncelli Associated Press)

BY MELODY GUTIERREZ | STAFF WRITER

MAY 4 2022 5 AM PT

FOR SUBSCRIBERS

SACRAMENTO mdash In the frantic first weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic three companies

promised California officials that they could secure millions of protective masks in

exchange for $16 billion in no-bid government contracts Each effort ended badly for

the state

Two years later lawsuits stemming from the failed contracts provide a glimpse into the

dealmaking mdash including how California Controller Betty Yee a two-term Democrat with

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 316

no formal role in the contracting process worked behind the scenes to help a pair of

political operatives land a deal that turned out to be one of the statersquos most flawed

The $600-million contract with Blue Flame Medical LLC a healthcare supplies startup

was later flagged as a case of possible fraud and the state was forced to claw back its

massive upfront payment But Yeersquos involvement with the effort never became public

even after the deal collapsed and state lawmakers demanded a full accounting of what

had happened

Over the course of a pivotal week in March 2020 Yee provided Blue Flamersquos co-founder

with private advice on how to negotiate an advance payment and discouraged him from

disclosing how much the company would pocket from the deal according to text

messages documented in a lawsuit involving the contract

ldquoI will see to it that the wire happens first thing this morningrdquo Yee wrote to John

Thomas a longtime Republican strategist who founded Blue Flame with GOP

fundraiser Mike Gula in a text message on March 26 2020

Hours later the state wired Blue Flame a down payment of $457 million The

companyrsquos internal records disclosed as part of a lawsuit show that it stood to turn a

profit of $134 million by charging the state 20 to 30 markups

ldquoSweet mother of Godrdquo Gula wrote in an email to Blue Flamersquos lawyer after calculating

the companyrsquos potential windfall one of hundreds of documents included in a lawsuit

the company filed against its bank Chain Bridge for triggering the fraud concerns

Chain Bridge then sued JPMorgan Chase the statersquos bank In February JPMorgan one

of the worldrsquos largest banks sued the state to recover its costs in untangling the deal

CALIFORNIA

California lawmakers question statersquos vetting of failed coronavirus contractsMay 11 2020

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 416

ADVERTISEMENT

Two other massive COVID-19 mask deals also remain mired in lawsuits

Court documents reveal that a settlement was reached between the state and Advoque

Safeguard a Santa Clara company that failed to deliver most of the N95 masks it was

contracted to make while 10 million masks that did arrive were later recalled for failing

to meet federal filtration standards State officials said the company which faces three

lawsuits stemming from its other mask deals has yet to make any of the agreed-upon

payments

In a third case Alabama company Bear Mountain alleges that California officials

improperly canceled an $800-million mask contract that was promoted by an

influential Sacramento lobbyist

The agreements were among many no-bid contracts intended to help California officials

quickly buy lifesaving supplies a process allowed under Gov Gavin Newsomrsquos

proclamation of a state of emergency due to COVID-19

ldquoNo-bid contracts are subject to all kinds of problemsrdquo said Larry Gerston a political

commentator and professor emeritus at San Jose State ldquoThey are subject to foolish

things You have to wonder how many things we donrsquot know aboutrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 516

Like many vendors that ended up securing a California government contract Blue

Flame looked for inroads with political insiders The company offered cash commissions

and retainers to lobbyists strategists and medical sales representatives according to

records contained in the lawsuit

Yeersquos political fundraiser initially made the introduction to Thomas according to a

deposition of Rick Chivaro chief counsel to the state controllerrsquos office Court

documents identify the fundraiser as Stephanie Daily Smith a Democratic political

consultant based in San Diego County Yee through her office and Daily Smith declined

to comment

As the statersquos paymaster Yee is tasked with carrying out the final details of spending

taxpayer dollars Her office issues checks for the state of California and can raise

concerns about whether funds are being spent wisely The job of vetting and selecting

who receives state contracts largely falls to a different California government office the

Department of General Services

Subscribers get early access to this story

Wersquore offering LA Times subscribers firstaccess to our best journalism Thank you for

your support

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 616

Explore more Subscriber Exclusivecontent

But in a series of text messages written between March 20 and March 27 2020 and

made public in the Blue Flame lawsuit Yee went out of her way to advocate for the

company mdash after Thomas began by telling her he had 100 million N95 masks at the Port

of Long Beach that his company could ldquomove to you guys todayrdquo

Hours later Thomas said ldquoWersquove almost sold all of this first shipmentrdquo but he

promised that 100 million masks would arrive each week Yee then said she had made

the governorrsquos office aware of his offer The next day Thomas thanked Yee for her ldquohelp

birddogging thisrdquo to which she responded by saying ldquoGot it Will press governorrsquos

folksrdquo

The text messages show that the state controller promised to step up her efforts to

convince Newsomrsquos office to make the deal after Thomas warned that California was

losing even more supplies to quicker buyers

In his deposition last year Thomas said Blue Flame did not sell any of the 100 million

masks he claimed to have at the port despite what he had told Yee

In one text message Thomas wondered whether he should disclose Blue Flamersquos profits

to state officials as a way ldquoto ease everyonersquos concernsrdquo about price gouging Yee the

gatekeeper to the state treasury warned against doing so

ldquoIf you share info with State it may become a matter of public record and make

headlinesrdquo Yee texted Thomas ldquoIf this is proprietary info keep it that wayrdquo

As concerns rose over the pace of negotiations Yee suggested how Thomas should word

his request to Newsom administration officials for Blue Flame to be paid in advance mdash

telling him to do so ldquowithout invoking my namerdquo Thomas took Yeersquos suggestion

sending a near-verbatim request text messages show

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 716

ldquoPrepayment is not a problem for my office under the emergency declarationrdquo Yee

assured Thomas in one text referring to Newsomrsquos COVID-19 order

Four days after Yee suggested a cash advance the state wired $457 million to Blue

Flamersquos bank amounting to an upfront payment of 75 ldquoWe got it Thank yourdquo

Thomas texted Yee afterward

But the large payment triggered a warning by Chain Bridge Bank officials of a potential

scam given that Blue Flame had opened its account with the bank the day before Amid

the bankrsquos concerns state officials asked for the wire to be reversed a few hours later

CALIFORNIA

Suppliers cash in as California taxpayers hit with wildly inflated prices for masksApril 23 2020

With the deal in jeopardy Thomas again turned to Yee

ldquoHi Betty sorry to bug you but I have an issue that I need your help withrdquo he wrote

ldquoCan you call me when you have a momentrdquo

This time the state controller mdash elected in 2014 and reelected in 2018 mdash didnrsquot

immediately respond The next day she told Thomas to instead communicate with state

procurement officials and ldquoplease cease to keep me in the loop it is not helpful You

have a credibility issue now that you need to solve Good luckrdquo

In seeking to explain Yeersquos role Chief Counsel Chivaro said in a lawsuit deposition that

ldquothe controller was merely trying to ensure that we had the face masks that we needed

and other PPE to protect the nurses and the doctors that were handling these COVID

cases

ldquoHer job was not to vet Mr Thomas in any way shape or formrdquo Chivaro said of Yee

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 816

In a statement to The Times Blue Flame officials placed the blame on the fraud warning

issued by Chain Bridge Bank

ldquoThere is no doubt in our mind that Blue Flame Medical would have fully delivered all

100 million masks to California had it not been for the reckless and negligent actions of

Chainbridge Bankrdquo the company said in its statement

Other deals made in the early spring of 2020 to secure protective masks were also

problematic

One day after the Blue Flame deal fell apart California signed an $800-million contract

with Bear Mountain a company led by former Alabama Atty Gen Troy King That

contract was canceled less than six weeks later after state officials said the company

failed to deliver most of the masks

The deal was aided by Paul Bauer a Sacramento lobbyist who at the time worked for

the prominent government relations firm Mercury Public Affairs mdash before departing

soon after questions were raised about the contract

Bear Mountain executives alleged in their December 2020 lawsuit that the state

abruptly canceled its contract without warning and refused to accept millions of masks

they had secured The state has insisted that Bear Mountain missed its first deadline

then initially delivered just 2 of what was required

ldquoWhile COVID-19 ravaged the state for weeks Bear Mountain continued to miss

deadlines and the few deliveries it made fell far short of its contractual obligationsrdquo

attorneys for the state wrote in the lawsuit

ldquoThese were massive contracts for tons of moneyrdquo said Jon Coupal president of the

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn ldquoItrsquos hard to Monday morning quarterback this but itrsquos

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 916

entirely appropriate to go back and look at how much was spent and the decision-

making processrdquo

The Bear Mountain deal collapsed as Newsom was facing criticism over an even larger

deal to purchase masks a $1-billion contract with China-based auto manufacturer BYD

The companyrsquos efforts were beset with delays in April and May 2020 resulting in BYD

having to reimburse the state $2475 million after initially failing to obtain federal

certification of its N95 masks

CALIFORNIA

Newsomrsquos secretive $1-billion mask deal with Chinese automaker sparks bipartisanconcernsApril 20 2020

Ultimately BYD delivered state officials said the company accounts for 85 of the 300

million N95 respirators California has purchased to date

ldquoWe were having to sift through a lot of sketchy people but there were good actors too

and the state came out of it for the most part in a good placerdquo said Brian Ferguson a

spokesman for Newsomrsquos Office of Emergency Services

In the case of Advoque the company touted its California roots and its price point

offering to manufacture nearly 100 million N95 masks at $225 each mdash far below the $5

to $12 state officials were paying others as suppliers and middlemen cashed in on the

global shortage

But the deal quickly faltered

Advoque was supposed to deliver 40 million masks by July 31 2020 but only 6 million

arrived On Sept 10 company officials alerted the state that there were issues with its

masks They had failed federal filtration tests and the companyrsquos certification was

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1016

revoked meaning the masks could ldquono longer be manufactured assembled labeled

sold or distributed as a NIOSH approved productrdquo according to a press release from

Advoque at the time referring to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and

Health

California officials issued a recall for all of the companyrsquos masks sent to healthcare

workers and essential employees who rely on the high filtration standards for

protection

Advoque agreed in 2021 to repay $187 million to taxpayers By last month when the

final installment was due the state had not received any money from the company

Due to Advoquersquos ldquofailure to make timely payments the state served a notice of defaultrdquo

Monica Hassan deputy director of the Office of Public Affairs at the Department of

General Services told The Times

In a statement the company said ldquoAdvoque Safeguard is continuing to work with the

State of California to reach a solution that is in the best interests of the State and its

citizensrdquo

Three companies are suing Advoque alleging that they too were sold faulty N95 masks

Two of the lawsuits allege that Advoque paid millions to its executives instead of

reimbursing customers Some companies cited Californiarsquos massive contract with

Advoque as an impetus for their own contracts

ldquoCaliforniarsquos deal to buy $90 million worth of Advoquersquos N95 masks was a stamp of

approvalrdquo said Joel Reese a Dallas lawyer representing Titus Group Inc in a case

against Advoque ldquoNow we are wondering how Advoque obtained that stamp of

approvalrdquo

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomcaliforniastory2022-05-04california-official-betty-yee-covid-mask-deal-fraud-claims 1116

Four months before the Advoque deal fell apart the same question asked by Reese was

raised by California legislators during a lengthy public hearing that examined the

collapse of the Blue Flame contract Top state officials did their best to explain what

happened and why

Yeersquos role however was never mentioned

Times staff writer Hannah Wiley and librarian Jen Arcand contributed to this story

CALIFORNIA POLITICS CALIFORNIA POLITICS

The stories shaping CaliforniaGet up to speed with our Essential California newsletter sent six days a week

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Melody Gutierrez

Twitter Instagram Email Facebook

Melody Gutierrez covers state government and politics in Sacramento for the Los

Angeles Times

Show Comments

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 111

WORLD amp NATION

Nearly 15 million deaths in the last two years were associated withCOVID-19 WHO says

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest COVID-19 Virus tracker Hospitalizations Vaccines Newsletter

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 211

A man is swabbed for a coronavirus test at a site in Beijing (Mark Schiefelbein Associated Press)

BY MARIA CHENG | ASSOCIATED PRESS

MAY 5 2022 706 AM PT

LONDON mdash Nearly 15 million people were killed either by COVID-19 or by the

coronavirusrsquo impact on overwhelmed health systems in the past two years mdash more than

double the official death toll of 6 million the World Health Organization said Thursday

Most of the fatalities were in Southeast Asia Europe and the Americas

In a new report the United Nations agencyrsquos chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

described the figure as ldquosoberingrdquo saying it should prompt countries to invest more in

their capacities to quell future health emergencies

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 311

Scientists tasked by the WHO with calculating the actual number of COVID-19 deaths

between January 2020 and the end of 2021 estimated between 133 million and 166

million deaths that were either caused directly by the coronavirus or were somehow

attributed to the pandemicrsquos impact on health systems such as people with cancer

unable to seek treatment when hospitals were full of COVID patients

The figures are based on country-reported data and statistical modeling but only about

half of countries provided information The WHO said it wasnrsquot yet able to break down

the figures to distinguish between direct deaths from COVID-19 and others caused by

the pandemic but said a future project examining death certificates would probe this

ldquoThis may seem like just a bean-counting exercise but having these WHO numbers is so

critical to understanding how we should combat future pandemics and continue to

respond to this onerdquo said Albert Ko an infectious-disease specialist at the Yale School

of Public Health who was not linked to the WHO research

ADVERTISEMENT

For example Ko said South Korearsquos decision to invest heavily in public health after it

suffered a severe outbreak of the virus MERS allowed it to escape COVID-19 with a per-

capita death rate around 5 of that of the US

CALIFORNIA

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 411

lsquoWersquore now into our sixth waversquo Coronavirus gains in California spark newconcernsMay 4 2022

Accurate numbers on COVID-19 deaths have been problematic throughout the

pandemic as the figures represent only a fraction of the devastation wrought by the

coronavirus largely because of limited testing and differences in how countries count

COVID-19 deaths According to government figures reported to WHO and to a separate

count kept by Johns Hopkins University there have been more than 6 million reported

COVID-19 deaths to date

Scientists at the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of

Washington guessed that there were more than 18 million COVID-related deaths from

January 2020 to December 2021 in a recent study published in the journal Lancet and

a team led by Canadian researchers estimated there were more than 3 million

uncounted coronavirus deaths in India alone The WHOrsquos new analysis estimated there

were more than 4 million missed deaths in India

Some countries including India have disputed the WHOrsquos methodology for calculating

COVID deaths resisting the idea that there were many more deaths than officially

counted

Earlier this week the Indian government released new figures showing there were

474806 more deaths in 2020 compared to the previous year but did not say how many

were tied to the pandemic India did not release any death estimates for 2021 when the

highly infectious Delta variant swept through the country killing many thousands

WORLD amp NATION

Funeral pyres burn Gravediggers know no rest Indiarsquos COVID-19 crisis is alsquonightmarersquoApril 28 2021

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 511

Ko said better figures from the WHO might also explain some lingering mysteries about

the pandemic such as why Africa appears to have been one of the regions least affected

by the virus despite its low vaccination rates

ldquoWere the mortality rates so low because we couldnrsquot count the deaths or was there

some other factor to explain thatrdquo he said adding that the crush of deaths in rich

countries like Britain and the US proved that resources alone were insufficient to

contain a global outbreak

Dr Bharat Pankhania a public health specialist at Exeter University in southwest

England said the world may never get close to the true toll of COVID-19 particularly in

poor countries

ldquoWhen you have a massive outbreak where people are dying in the streets because of a

lack of oxygen bodies were abandoned or people had to be cremated quickly because of

cultural beliefs we end up never knowing just how many people diedrdquo he explained

Breaking NewsGet breaking news investigations analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in

your inbox

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times

Although Pankhania said the estimated COVID-19 death toll still pales in comparison to

the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic mdash when experts estimate up to 100 million people died

mdash he said the fact that so many people died despite the advances of modern medicine

including vaccines is shameful

SIGN ME UP

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 817 AM Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times

httpswwwlatimescomworld-nationstory2022-05-05nearly-15-million-deaths-associated-covid-19 611

He also warned the cost of COVID-19 could be far more damaging in the long term

given the increasing burden of caring for people with long COVID

ldquoWith the Spanish flu there was the flu and then there were some [lung] illnesses

people suffered but that was itrdquo he said ldquoThere was not an enduring immunological

condition that wersquore seeing right now with COVID

ldquoWe do not know the extent to which people with long COVID will have their lives cut

short and if they will have repeated infections that will cause them even more

problemsrdquo Pankhania said

WORLD amp NATION COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Show Comments

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 19

By By STEVE SCAUZILLOSTEVE SCAUZILLO | | sscauzilloscngcomsscauzilloscngcom | San Gabriel Valley | San Gabriel Valley

TribuneTribunePUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 617 pmMay 4 2022 at 617 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 818 pmMay 4 2022 at 818 pm

Rancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 HeRancho Cucamonga City Council Member Sam Spagnolo died Monday May 2 2022 Hewas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofwas 80 Spagnolo had served on the City Council for 18 years (Photo courtesy city ofRancho Cucamonga)Rancho Cucamonga)

Sam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga CitySam Spagnolo one of the longest-serving members of the Rancho Cucamonga City

Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80Council and a retired fire captain has died He was 80

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Rancho Cucamonga CouncilRancho Cucamonga CouncilMember Sam Spagnolo dies at 80Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80He spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inHe spent 18 years on the City Council and 35 years inthe fire districtthe fire district

bullbull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 29

ldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by theldquoMyself and my fellow City CouncilFire Board members are deeply saddened by the

loss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a preparedloss of our colleague and friendrdquo Mayor L Dennis Michael said in a prepared

statement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Communitystatement ldquoCouncil Member Spagnolos service to our Rancho Cucamonga Community

will have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquowill have a lasting impact for generations to comerdquo

Spagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquoSpagnolo who died Monday May 2 was described as a ldquopillar of the Ranchopillar of the Rancho

Cucamonga CommunityCucamonga Communityrdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-rdquo by the city He was elected to the City Council in 2004 and re-elected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in Novemberelected in 2008 2012 2016 and 2020 His four-year term in District 1 ends in November

20242024

The council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancyThe council will decide in the next two to three weeks how it plans to fill the vacancy

City leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold aCity leaders could appoint someone for the remainder of Spagnolos term or hold a

special election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Firespecial election said Michael who also worked in the Rancho Cucamonga Fire

Protection District with SpagnoloProtection District with Spagnolo

ldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fireldquoI was very blessed to have worked with Sam for my entire career in the fire

department and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWedepartment and my entire career as an elected officialrdquo Michael said Wednesday ldquoWe

had our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquohad our differences but we always had the greatest respect for one anotherrdquo

Spagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captainSpagnolo spent 35 years as a firefighter with the fire district He retired as a fire captain

on Dec 31 2003on Dec 31 2003

James Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 yearsJames Curatalo a retired battalion chief who worked alongside Spagnolo for 20 years

said his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crashsaid his fellow firefighter and friend was always looking out for victims of a car crash

fire or other emergencyfire or other emergency

ldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo CurataloldquoWed be on calls and someone had lost their vehicle or was in a hard wayrdquo Curatalo

recalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember herecalled Wednesday ldquoHe thought ahead about what they might need I remember he

would make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquowould make arrangements to find people a hotelrdquo

Later Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind ofLater Spagnolo and others in the fire department incorporated a new kind of

firefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victimsfirefighting ethic into a mission statement that included caring for the victims

ldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And thatldquoSam was an initiator of those types of things that went above and beyond And that

became part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on thebecame part of the culture of Rancho Cucamonga firerdquo said Curatalo who sits on theboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water Districtboard of directors of the Cucamonga Valley Water District

It was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl whoIt was Spagnolo who helped start the Ashley Smith Fund named after a girl who

sustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael saidsustained severe burns that raises money for children with burn injuries Michael said

Spagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training programSpagnolo also helped found the city s CPR and first-aid training program

As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo As a retired firefighter and council member Spagnolo tried for more than 20 yearstried for more than 20 years to to

honor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished tryinghonor the men and women of the New York City Fire Department who perished trying

to save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terroristto save the lives of people trapped in the World Trade Center as a result of the terrorist

attack of Sept 11 2001attack of Sept 11 2001

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504rancho-cucamonga-council-member-sam-spagnolo-dies-at-80utm_medium=socialamputm_campaign=sohellip 39

Spagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants fromSpagnolo helped the nonprofit organization Freedoms Flame retrieve remnants from

the World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksvillethe World Trade Center Pentagon and Flight 93 that crashed in Shanksville

Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The Pennsylvania and brought them back to Rancho Cucamonga The development of adevelopment of a

911 Memorial Park911 Memorial Park that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in that will display those remnants began gaining momentum in

April in the last few months of Spagnolos lifeApril in the last few months of Spagnolos life

In one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingIn one of his last public appearances Spagnolo attended the April 4 ground breakingfor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for thefor Fire Station 178 On that property about 144 acres has been set aside for the

memorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be madememorial park The city is raising money by asking for donations which can be made

by visiting by visiting cityofrcusnews911memorial-projectcityofrcusnews911memorial-project

ldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears asldquoI was hoping he couldhellip see that park completedrdquo said Michael choking back tears as

he spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquohe spoke Wednesday ldquoBut he will see it from heavenrdquo

The Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday nightThe Ontario City Council adjourned its meeting in Spagnolos honor Tuesday night

Mayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy whoMayor Paul Leon called Spagnolo ldquoa spectacular individual and a humble nice guy who

cared about his communityrdquocared about his communityrdquo

Spagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire DivisionSpagnolo served as president of the League of California Cities Inland Empire Division

and as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directorsand as chair of the Omnitrans Board of Directors

Spagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren NoSpagnolo is survived by his wife Viola three children and seven grandchildren Nofuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations infuneral or memorial services have been released The family is requesting donations in

his honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Associationhis honor be sent to the Rancho Cucamonga Professional Firefighters Association

(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To(RCPFA) where the funds will be distributed to the 911 Memorial Park and St Jude To

donate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor ofdonate send a check made out to RC Firefighters Benevolent Fund with ldquoIn honor of

Sam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave RanchoSam Spagnolordquo noted on the memo line to RCFA 9259 Archibald Ave Rancho

Cucamonga CA 91730Cucamonga CA 91730

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

Steve ScauzilloSteve Scauzillo | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags city councilcity council Foothill CitiesFoothill Cities Inland EmpireInland Empirelocal politicslocal politics ObituariesObituaries obituaryobituary Top Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 18

By By BRIAN WHITEHEADBRIAN WHITEHEAD | | bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom | The Sun | The SunPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 1043 amMay 4 2022 at 1043 am | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 119 pmMay 4 2022 at 119 pm

The San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to beThe San Bernardino City Unified School District tapped Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin to besuperintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)superintendent in March 2021 (Courtesy of the San Bernardino City Unified School District)

San Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willSan Bernardino City Unified School District Superintendent Harry ldquoDocrdquo Ervin willretire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3retire at the end of the school year he announced Tuesday May 3

Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired Ervin the district s first Black superintendent was hired a year agoa year ago to replace longtime to replace longtime

Superintendent Dale MarsdenSuperintendent Dale Marsden

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

San Bernardino schoolsSan Bernardino schoolsSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toSuperintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin toretireretireErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredErvin the districts first Black superintendent was hiredlast year following a national searchlast year following a national search

bullbull NewsNews

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 28

In a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made theIn a news release Wednesday May 4 district officials wrote that Ervin said he made the

decision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health anddecision to retire ldquoearlier than expected after carefully considering family health and

progress toward his professional goals hererdquoprogress toward his professional goals hererdquo

Across three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendentAcross three decades Ervin has served as a teacher principal assistant superintendent

and superintendentand superintendent

ldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toldquoWhen I joined the SBCUSD teamrdquo he said in the release ldquomy goal was twofold First toreopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for areopen schools to in-person learning after the pandemic pushed classes online for a

year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-year and second to set us on a transformational path toward becoming a high-

performing public school districtperforming public school district

ldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricularldquoI am proud to say we accomplished the firstrdquo he added ldquoand have good curricular

instructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquoinstructional and assessment systems and structures in place to support the secondrdquo

Early in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp LearningEarly in his tenure Ervin gathered community input through his Listening amp Learning

Tour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful ofTour and with the help of the district s leadership team helped develop a handful of

overarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news releaseoverarching goals to strengthen student outcomes according to the news release

He then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goalsHe then encouraged district stakeholders to join a task force to build on those goals

creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025creating the Framework for Excellence Vision 2025

The plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future successThe plan is expected to provide the district a roadmap to future success

In the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeksIn the news release Ervin said the San Bernardino school district community seeks

transformational changetransformational change

ldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in theldquoSuccess is possiblerdquo he added ldquoif everyone stays focused on making decisions in the

best interests of kidsrdquobest interests of kidsrdquo

Ervin Ervin faced backlashfaced backlash in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community in the fall for his alleged attitude toward teachers and community

membersmembers

At board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized theAt board meetings in September and October public speakers criticized the

superintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitariessuperintendent for as much and called for his removal Dozens of local dignitaries

spoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behindspoke up in Ervins defense before district leaders discussed the allegations behind

closed doors Oct 5closed doors Oct 5

ldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk aboutldquoI can say the board did as we always do when people bring concerns we talk about

those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6those concernsrdquo board member Gwen Dowdy-Rodgers said in a phone interview Oct 6

ldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquoldquobut ultimately the most important thing is that we found no need to take any actionrdquo

In addition to overseeing In addition to overseeing the district s return to in-person learningthe district s return to in-person learning this school year this school year

Ervin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic includingErvin spearheaded myriad other programs amid the coronavirus pandemic including

efforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wideefforts to focus on equity educational access and innovation as well as a system-wide

digitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improvedigitized four-year plan to guide high school students toward graduation and improve

their college readinesstheir college readiness

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 816 AM San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220504san-bernardino-schools-superintendent-harry-doc-ervin-to-retire 38

Join the ConversationJoin the Conversation

We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulWe invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightfulconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at allconversations about issues in our community We reserve the right at alltimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningtimes to remove any information or materials that are unlawful threateningabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneabusive libelous defamatory obscene vulgar pornographic profaneindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationindecent or otherwise objectionable to us and to disclose any informationnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightnecessary to satisfy the law regulation or government request We mightpermanently block any user who abuses these conditionspermanently block any user who abuses these conditions

District leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meetingDistrict leaders will discuss the process of replacing Ervin at a future board meeting

Editor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofEditor s note This story has been updated to reflect the specific criticisms some had ofthe superintendentthe superintendent

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Brian WhiteheadBrian Whitehead | Reporter| ReporterBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaBrian Whitehead is a reporter for The San Bernardino Sun covering Colton FontanaGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and theGrand Terrace Rialto and San Bernardino He previously covered prep sports and thecities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register Acities of Buena Park Fullerton and La Palma for The Orange County Register AGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismGrand Terrace native and Riverside Notre Dame alumnus he earned his journalismdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasdegree from Cal State Fullerton in 2010 Since joining The Sun in late 2017 he hasreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andreported on development education homelessness marijuana political strife andthe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcythe myriad issues facing San Bernardino post-bankruptcy

bwhiteheadscngcombwhiteheadscngcom

Follow Brian Whitehead Follow Brian Whitehead bwhitehead3bwhitehead3

Tags Tags educationeducation Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun

httpswwwsbsuncom20220503should-redlands-increase-tax-on-warehouses-voters-may-get-to-decideutm_medium=socialamputm_sourhellip 16

By By JENNIFER IYERJENNIFER IYER | | jiyerscngcomjiyerscngcom | Redlands Daily Facts | Redlands Daily FactsPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 3 2022 at 325 pmMay 3 2022 at 325 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 708 pmMay 4 2022 at 708 pm

A tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands votersA tax hike on distribution centers could join a crowded November ballot for Redlands voters

Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an Among the regional state and Congressional races there is also an ordinance restricting development in the cityordinance restricting development in the city and and voters in threevoters in three

districts will choose new City Council membersdistricts will choose new City Council members

The council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilitiesThe council on Tuesday May 3 unanimously asked staff to prepare documents to put a business license tax increase on logistics facilities

before voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballotbefore voters The documents would come back to the council for approval before going on the ballot

The move follows the Planning Commissions The move follows the Planning Commissions February recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehousesFebruary recommendation that the council enact a moratorium on new warehouses to give to give

staff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal hasstaff time to prepare a report on the effects of current and already approved warehouses on traffic air quality and more That proposal has

not yet been brought before the councilnot yet been brought before the council

An April 2021 study found the city at that time was An April 2021 study found the city at that time was home to 56 warehouseshome to 56 warehouses over 100000 square feet over 100000 square feet

According to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowestAccording to a written report by city staff relative to other local cities that tax warehouses by square foot Redlands is the second lowest

based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2based on research from 2019 Redlands charges 47 cents per square foot Rialto and Fontana both charge 75 cents and Ontario charges 2

cents per square footcents per square foot

The current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in theThe current rate will bring in about $440000 this fiscal year Finance Director Danielle Garcia said and an increase of 1 or 2 cents in the

tax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquotax ldquowould potentially yield $91600 and $183200 respectively per yearrdquo

The San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballotThe San Bernardino County Registrar of Voters estimated it would cost the city $81500 to put the measure on the ballot

Councilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the councilCouncilman Eddie Tejeda said he asked for the item to come before the council

ldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have onldquoAlthough it is going to cost us some money it will bring funding that the city can use to mitigate the affects that the warehouses have on

our communityrdquo he saidour communityrdquo he said

Originally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts ofOriginally he said he thought the money could be used for road repairs but now he thinks it could be used to reduce the impacts of

climate change on the community such as for planting treesclimate change on the community such as for planting trees

City Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial TaxrdquoCity Attorney Dan McHugh told the council if the tax revenues were earmarked for particular purposes it would become a ldquoSpecial Taxrdquo

and the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only aand the measure would need to be approved by two-thirds of the voters If the money went into the general fund it would need only a

majority of voters to approve itmajority of voters to approve it

Staff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotStaff will come back to the council likely in July with a recommendation on the amount of the increase The registrar s deadline for ballotmeasures is in Augustmeasures is in August

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom Guidelines

News TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact UsReport an ErrorReport an Error

LOCAL NEWSLOCAL NEWS

Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses VotersShould Redlands increase tax on warehouses Votersmay get to decidemay get to decide

bull bull NewsNews

Tags Tags 2022 Elections2022 Elections developmentdevelopment ElectionsElections governmentgovernment logisticslogistics Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 18

By By JEFF COLLINSJEFF COLLINS | | JeffCollinsscngcomJeffCollinsscngcom | Orange County Register | Orange County RegisterPUBLISHED PUBLISHED May 4 2022 at 709 pmMay 4 2022 at 709 pm | UPDATED | UPDATED May 4 2022 at 1148 pmMay 4 2022 at 1148 pm

A state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans onA state lawmaker is working on a Southern California exception to his 2021 bill giving local jurisdictions that failed to update their housing plans ontime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials saytime just one year to complete state-mandated rezoning instead of three The penalty applies to 97 of the regionrsquos local jurisdictions officials say(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)(Photo by Mindy Schauer Orange County RegisterSCNG)

Local and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing toLocal and state officials are working on a deal to soften penalties affecting almost every Southern California city and county for failing to

adopt adopt state-approved housing plansstate-approved housing plans by a February deadline by a February deadline

Under a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 insteadUnder a new law adopted just last fall those cities now are required to rezone land needed to meet state housing goals by Oct 15 instead

of the usual three-year timelineof the usual three-year timeline

If they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuitsIf they fail to meet the rezoning deadline the state can find them out of compliance with state housing laws exposing them to lawsuits

stiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisionsstiff fines a cutoff of housing grants and a loss of local control over planning decisions

ldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre outldquoEveryone was late and so it s been very hard because at the same time hellip (state housing officials) were sending letters saying ʻYouʼre out

of compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief ofof compliance you could like lose your funding And that is sending all the cities into you know crazy moderdquo said Guy Strahl chief of

staff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquostaff for bill author Richard Bloom D-Santa Monica ldquoIt s driving all the cities crazyrdquo

Just five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel VictorvilleJust five cities and one county in the six-county Southern California Association of Governments region mdash Duarte San Gabriel Victorville

Westlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquoWestlake Village Wildomar and the county of Ventura mdash met the Feb 11 deadline to adopt a state-certified plan or ldquohousing elementrdquo

NEWSNEWSHOUSINGHOUSING

Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineCities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadlineseek rezoning extensionseek rezoning extensionAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptAlmost every city and county in Southern California faces penalties for failing to adoptnew housing plans on timenew housing plans on time

bull bull NewsNews

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 28

lsquoDifficult taskrsquolsquoDifficult taskrsquo

Stiff sanctionsStiff sanctions

Read more Read more Yorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing planYorba Linda is Orange County s first city to adopt state-mandated housing plan

The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate The remaining 191 jurisdictions in the SCAG region now have only until Oct 15 to rezone land needed to accommodate huge increases inhuge increases in

state-mandated homebuilding goalsstate-mandated homebuilding goals mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall mdash a time-consuming task many cities said is impossible to accomplish by the fall

Kome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measureKome Ajise SCAGs executive director said his agency had been seeking more time for rezoning since last year because the new measure

Assembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plansAssembly Bill 1398 ldquochanged the rules of the gamerdquo just as the regions localities were in the process of revising their housing plans

ldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningldquoWe knew immediately when 1398 passed it was going to be a problemrdquo Ajise said ldquoGiven the number of cities that we had just beginningto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquoto get their housing elements done it was going to be impossible to meet the deadlinerdquo

A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398A proposed compromise seeks to create a Southern California exception to AB 1398

Strahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have beenStrahl said housing advocates representatives of the state Housing and Community Development Department and Bloom have been

working on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning processworking on an amendment giving Southern California cities ldquoa little more timerdquo for the rezoning process

The compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can beThe compromise bill s provisions are still being worked out Strahl said Bloom is hoping to finalize its language soon so it can be

introduced as an introduced as an ldquourgencyrdquo ldquourgencyrdquo measure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passagemeasure allowing it to take effect immediately upon passage

ldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure thatldquoThere s multiple issues going on hellip Weʼre still trying to make sure (state housing officials are) comfortable Weʼre trying to make sure that

the Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl saidthe Senate is comfortable So there s a lot of people weʼre still checking in withrdquo Strahl said

AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up AB 1398 is one of the latest in a series of new laws drafted over the past five years to beef up the state s Regional Housing Needsthe state s Regional Housing Needs

AssessmentAssessment or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at or RHNA process The half-century-old statute requires California cities and counties to plan for their fair share of housing at

all income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least onceall income levels As part of that process local governments are required to update the housing element of their general plans at least once

every eight yearsevery eight years

In response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAGIn response to the housing crisis the state created new methods for assessing housing needs that resulted in the tripling of the SCAG

regions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housingregions homebuilding goal to 134 million homes by the end of the decade For some cities the increased goals would boost their housing

stock by 40 or more by October 2029stock by 40 or more by October 2029

Numerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since theNumerous cities said it would be impossible for them to complete the time-consuming rezoning process on such a massive scale since the

process includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQAprocess includes public hearings and environmental reviews under the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA

Meeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn MirzakhanianMeeting an Oct 15 rezoning deadline ldquois going to be very difficultrdquo said Manhattan Beach Planning Manager Tylyn Mirzakhanian

ldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip WeldquoIt is a very difficult task to demonstrate capacity for 774 new units in a small city that is completely built outrdquo Mirzakhanian said rdquo hellip Wedonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquodonʼt have a single vacant site to rely on And so we were hit with very stringent requirements because of thatrdquo

Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city Long Beach Planning Manager Alison Spindler-Ruiz said her city canʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcelscanʼt complete the rezoning of about 800 parcels until sometime next until sometime next

year even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use planyear even though the city got a head start after recently updating its land-use plan

ldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of publicldquoThe rezoning process takes a whole host of extensive community engagementsrdquo Spindler-Ruiz said ldquo(They include the) noticing of public

hearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquohearings mailings and (the holding of) public hearings by both the planning commission and the city councilrdquo

The city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statementThe city of Los Angeles needs to rezone enough land to accommodate about 255000 additional housing units the city said in a statement

Officials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time toOfficials identified about 243000 ldquocandidate sitesrdquo on the list for possible rezoning Even three years may not be enough time to

accomplish that task accomplish that task the statement indicatedthe statement indicated

ldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appearsldquoRezoning efforts typically take several years from community engagement and initiation to adoptionrdquo it said ldquoA one-year timeline appears

to be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquoto be infeasible hellip and even a three-year timeline is significantly expeditedrdquo

In Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the cityIn Redondo Beach rezoning will require voter approval said Community Development Director Brandy Forbes The soonest the citywould be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023would be able to get such a measure on the ballot would be March 2023

ldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquoldquoWe can do it within a three-year timeframerdquo Forbes said ldquoWe just canʼt do it in one yearrdquo

Under AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing elementUnder AB 1398 cities that fail to meet the October rezoning deadline would be ruled out of compliance with the state s housing element

law setting in motion a wide array of potential consequenceslaw setting in motion a wide array of potential consequences

Non-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bikeNon-compliant jurisdictions face the loss of numerous state and federal grants including competitive grants for fixing roads adding bike

lanes improving transit or building affordable housinglanes improving transit or building affordable housing

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

5522 808 AM Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise

httpswwwpecom20220504cities-that-failed-to-meet-californias-housing-deadline-seek-extension-of-rezoning-ruleutm_medium=socialhellip 38

They also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits withThey also cannot deny affordable housing projects for being inconsistent with zoning or the general plan and face possible lawsuits with

fines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliancefines ranging from $10000 to $100000 a month Fines can be multiplied by six for jurisdictions that continue to be out of compliance

Bloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updatedBloom said in a press release when AB 1398 was signed into law that the measure was designed to incentivize cities to adopt their updated

housing elements on timehousing elements on time

ldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share ofldquoUnfortunately there have been instances where cities deliberately adopt faulty housing elements to avoid building their fair share of

housingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets thehousingrdquo Bloom said ldquoAs the housing crisis grows in California it is critical that every local government adopt a plan that meets therequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquorequirements of state law (and) that they do it on timerdquo

State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11State officials say 185 Southern California cities and five of the regionrsquos six counties failed to update their housing plans by a Feb 11deadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in thedeadline exposing them to a host of sanctions if they donrsquot complete needed rezoning by next Oct 15 A proposed deal now in theworks would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)works would give those cities more time to rezone (Photo by Mark Rightmire Orange County RegisterSCNG)

SCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining localSCAG chief Ajise said tougher planning and fair housing requirements coupled with COVID-19 lockdowns and delays in determining local

housing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elementshousing allocations put the regions cities and counties about six months behind in adopting their new housing elements

Most cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews andMost cities had a draft housing element done by last October but the back-and-forth process of getting housing department reviews and

making revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approvalmaking revisions pushed most jurisdictions past the Feb 11 deadline to get state approval

ldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process SoldquoThe process is not that easyrdquo Ajise said rdquo hellip We didnʼt expect that law would change the rules of the game while we were in process So

(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo(AB 1398) didnʼt come as a surprise to us but we were also not expecting that it would apply to usrdquo

Housing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losingHousing advocates expressed conditional support for a rezoning extension saying they want to spare cities the consequence of losing

affordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on timeaffordable housing grants but donʼt want to let them off the hook for not getting their housing plans done on time

ldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo saidldquoWhile we want there to be consequences we donʼt want to make the situation worse by (cities) losing affordable housing moneyrdquo said

Leonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LALeonora Camner executive director of Abundant Housing LA

ldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housingldquoSCAG got caught in kind of the middle of thisrdquo added Kennedy Commission Executive Director Cesar Covarrubias an affordable housing

advocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to holdadvocate ldquoWe understand there are cities like LA that have thousands of sites It s a bigger challenge for them hellip But we need to hold

cities accountablerdquocities accountablerdquo

Newsroom GuidelinesNewsroom GuidelinesNews TipsNews Tips

Contact UsContact Us

Report an ErrorReport an Error

AuthorAuthor Jeff CollinsJeff Collins | Reporter| Reporter

Tags Tags Affordable HousingAffordable Housing california-legislaturecalifornia-legislature Local BusinessLocal Business Top Stories BreezeTop Stories BreezeTop Stories IVDBTop Stories IVDB Top Stories LADNTop Stories LADN Top Stories LBPTTop Stories LBPT Top Stories OCRTop Stories OCR Top Stories PETop Stories PETop Stories PSNTop Stories PSN Top Stories RDFTop Stories RDF Top Stories SGVTTop Stories SGVT Top Stories SunTop Stories Sun Top Stories WDNTop Stories WDN

  • COVID clinic in Joshua Tree no longer open weekly _ Hi-Desert Star
  • Your ballot is in the mail _ Hi-Desert Star
  • LA supervisors vote to create super agency on homelessness - Los Angeles Times
  • RAND research finds the homeless avoid big shelters but want to get off the streets ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Ferrer reminds LA County_ Uptick in COVID numbers should inspire continued caution ndash Daily News
  • Op-Ed_ Omicron wont be the last coronavirus variant to haunt us - Los Angeles Times
  • California Controller Betty Yee pushed for a COVID mask deal - Los Angeles Times
  • Nearly 15 million deaths associated with COVID-19 WHO says - Los Angeles Times
  • Rancho Cucamonga Council Member Sam Spagnolo dies at 80 ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • San Bernardino schools Superintendent Harry lsquoDocrsquo Ervin to retire ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Should Redlands increase tax on warehouses_ Voters may get to decide ndash San Bernardino Sun
  • Cities that failed to meet Californiarsquos housing deadline seek rezoning extension ndash Press Enterprise