Deconstructing "Chappelle's Show": Race, Masculinity,and ...
BA Dissertation on Children's Cultures: Deconstructing Little Red Riding Hood
Transcript of BA Dissertation on Children's Cultures: Deconstructing Little Red Riding Hood
Children’s Cultures
MD3408
Special Studies
Student’s Name: Alexia Kasparian
Student’s ID Number: K07237189
Tutor’s Name: Ewan Kirkland
1
Deadline For Submission: 16/01/09
Contents Page
1. Introduction…………………………….Page:.4-5
2. How Fairy Tales Have Been Used to Shape Society and What the Authors of Little Red Riding Hood Have To Say………………………………………….Page:6-7
3. The Film’s Continuous Motifs,
Metaphors & Symbols…………………………………….Page:8-14
2
4.The Dominance Of Story-Telling in the
Company of Wolves………………………………………Page:15-
20
5. Conclusion………………………….Page: 21
6. Bibliography…………………………Page: 22-23
List of Figures
1. ‘‘Rosaleen’’. From The Company of
Wolves, by Angela Carter (1984)………………………………
Page: 11
3
2. ‘‘Baby Figurines’’. From The Company
of Wolves, by Angela Carter (1984)
……………………………Page: 12
3. ‘Courtesy of the Canon Group’. From
The Company of Wolves, by Angela Carter
(1984) ………………………………………Page: 17
4
Critical Analysis of the use of the
Dream Framework of the film a Company of
Wolves , and How This Structure Explores
Dominant Ideologies of, Sexuality,
Femininity, and the Loss of Childhood
Innocence
To the literary critics who study the fairytale from
a diverse range of theoretical approaches, they have
found that Little Red Riding Hood was the first love of Charles
Dickens, who confessed, ‘‘I felt if I could have married
Little Red Riding Hood, I should have known perfect
bliss’’.(Beckett,2002) As Sandra Beckett (2002) has
claimed in her book Recycling Red Riding Hood, no folk or fairy
tale has been so persistently reinterpreted,
recontextualized, and retold over the centuries as the
story of Little Red Riding Hood. Some critics feel that, the
story of Little Red Riding Hood belongs to the ‘‘literature of
exhausted possibility’’ (Beckett, 2002). In addition to
the fairy tale being retold, it is undoubtfully the most
commented and criticised of all time.
In my research paper, I would like to focus on the
movie A Company of Wolves (1984), this media text is
illustrating and presenting puberty and adolescence,
through a twisted modernization of the classic story Little
Red Riding Hood. This movie explores the loss of childhood
5
innocence, purity and the corruption of the world of
adolescence, with the ingenious use of the dream
framework; and displays once a child ‘creeps out of the
children’s world into the world of adolescence’, there is
‘no way back` to the innocent children’s world. Thus this
is a depiction of the reflection of ideas of childhood in
the film, and not an artistic depiction of the actual
life. The film follows the dream framework from the very
beginning, portraying a young girl’s ‘fantasy world’
where ‘wolves run wild’. The rationale for choosing this
particular media text is because it mimics the
universally loved fairy tale of Little Red Riding Hood, but it
explores the fairy tale in an intense symbolic and
metaphorical fashion. It is essential to state that the
fairy tale itself has been adapted in so many different
versions, this depicts how universally loved it is.
However, for these different adaptations to be;
‘‘Truly accepted as a classical fairy tale and
presumed ‘‘good’’ for the well being of children, a
narrative must be eminently rational..notions of the
acceptable treatment of children’’ (Zipes, 1993: 60).
In order to correctly ‘decode’ this movie, it is
essential not to see it in a ‘superficial flick’, but to
decode it as one would decode a literary piece, which
contains a lot of symbolic language. As Perrault
illustrates that all good fairy tales have ‘‘meaning on
many layers’’ (Cited in The Uses of Enchantment, 1991:169),
and that only the child can know which meanings are of
6
significance to him/her at the moment. As the child
matures, the child discovers, ‘‘new aspects of these
well-known fairy-tales, and this gives him the conviction
that he has indeed matured in understanding since the
same story now reveals, so much more to
him’’(Bettelheim,1991:169). This can only happen, when
the child is not told the real story behind the fairy
tale. Only the detection of the formerly hidden meanings
of a fairy tale, is the child’s spontaneous and imitative
achievement does it attain significance for him/her.
It is imperative to state that in the aforementioned
media text, exists four very essential ‘narrative
stories’ that occur; two of these stories are narrated by
the Grandmother, who has the role of Rosaleen’s (the
female protagonist) protector. As children were
traditionally presented as being in need of protection,
the other two of the stories that are narrated, are
narrated by Rosaleen herself. In these stories that are
being narrated, the viewers are being illustrated how an
innocent child loses her childhood innocence, and how she
becomes ‘corrupted’ as she enters the world of
adolescence. The ‘corruption’ of adolescence is further
demonstrated by the sexual, aggressive, bestiality in
men, and how this ‘evil’ in men also exist in women, thus
this demonstrates a construction of female and male
sexuality. These ideas in the film reflect on dominant
ideas of childhood, femininity and sexuality.
7
I would like to divide my research paper into three
different sub-sections to highlight three very essential
topics that contribute into my in depth- analysis. The
first sub-section is how fairy tales, have been used to
shape society and what the authors of Little Red Riding
Hood have to say. In addition the second sub-section is
about the film’s continuous motifs, metaphors & symbols.
While the third sub-section, is about the dominance of
story-telling in the Company of Wolves.
Sub-Section OneHow Fairy Tales Have Been Used to Shape Society, and
What The Authors Of Little Red Riding Hood Have To Say
In the first sub-section, I will illustrate and
depict how fairy tales have been used to shape society,
and what the authors of Little Red Riding Hood portray in their
different adaptations. Fairy tales have always played an
important role in shaping society, and their ‘deeper
messages’, have been used to teach ‘moral lessons’ to
children. It is essential to depict that fairy tales for
young people, predominantly children, cannot be detached
from the fairy tales for adults.
As Zipes states in his book Fairy Tales and the art of
subversion (2006), an individual can speak about the single
literacy fairy tale, or ‘wonder-tale’ for children as a
symbolic representation, permeated by the ideological
perspective of the individual author. Therefore it is
8
essential to incorporate the story of Little Red Riding Hood as
children’s cultures. It is also crucial to illustrate
that fairy tales for young people, predominantly
children, cannot be detached from the fairy tales for
adults as previously mentioned. Nearly all critics and
reviewers, who have mastered the emergence of the
literary tale in Europe agree, that; educated writers
deliberately appropriated the oral folktale and
transformed it into a type of literary discourse about
morals and values. So that children and adults would
become cultured according to the social order at that
time. Zipes states, ‘‘...Fairy tales operate
ideologically, to indoctrinate children so that they will
conform to dominant social standards, which are not
necessarily established on their behalf’’. (Zipes,
2006:34)
The fairy tales may be one of the most vital
artistic and social authorities in children’s lives,
especially the moral lesson that exists in the story of
Little Red Riding Hood. But it has been evident, until the
publication of the Art of Subversion; little attention had been
given to the traditions in which the authors and
collectors of tales used established forms and genres, in
order to form children’s actions, values and relationship
to society. As Zipes (2006) persuasively portrays,
‘wonder tales’ have always been a powerful discourse,
capable of being used to shape or subvert attitudes and
9
behaviours within culture. Zipes ask questions that link
the fairy tale to society and to our ‘‘political
unconscious’’.
I would also like to add that in Perrault’s stories,
especially his adaptation of Little Red Riding Hood; he didn’t
just want to entertain his audience, but to also teach a
specific moral lesson. His adaptation of Little Red Riding Hood
loses much of its appeal, because it is obvious that his
wolf is not a rapacious beast, but an actual metaphor,
which leaves little to the imagination of the hearer.
However there are elements presumably which evade the
intentions of the author. The same metaphor of the
‘wolves’ are used in the Company of Wolves, to mirror the
bestiality, the aggressive sexuality in men. Perrault
further illustrates as previously mentioned, that all
good fairy tales have ‘‘meaning on many layers’’, and
that only the child can know which meanings are of
significance to him/her at the moment. As Bettelheim
(1991:172) illustrates, The Brothers Grimm adaptation of
Little Red Cap also depicts the crucial problems the school-
age girl has to solve, if oedipal attachments linger on
in the unconscious, which may drive her to expose herself
to the prospect of seduction. This mirrors Rosaleen’s
character in the Company of Wolves, and how she is not just
‘seduced’, but she is also presented as a seductress. The
film is in parallel with the Little Red Cap, as the wolf does
10
not do anything ‘unnatural’ to the girl, and ‘‘nothing
that she did not want’’(The Company of Wolves,1984).
Thus this depicts Rosaleen’s seductive nature, and
corruptive nature, because of her loss of childhood
innocence. Rosaleen’s character subverts the traditional
image of the innocent, naïve child, she is provocative
and she is seen as a ‘seductress’. She portrays what
happens when a child loses his/her innocence and ‘creeps
into the adult world’. Thus this is a depiction of the
reflection of ideas of childhood in the film, and not an
artistic depiction of the actual life as previously
mentioned.
Sub-Section TwoThe Film’s Continuous Motifs, Metaphors & Symbols
In the second sub-section, I will illustrate and
emphasise the film’s continuous motifs, metaphors and
symbols which surround this media text. It is not
‘feasible’ not to ‘notice’ these continuous symbols; due
11
to the fact that they aid us to ‘decode’ this film
correctly, in addition, they help us to comprehend how
the ideas of childhood, femininity and sexuality are
‘represented’ and ‘constructed’ in the film.
The prevalence of essential moral struggle is very
much in existence in the fairy tale Little Red Riding Hood. As
Patricia Cooper (2000:187) states, hyperdrama is served
in The Company of Wolves, for a dual purpose; firstly to mimic
the actual fairy tale of Little Red Riding Hood, and secondly to
translate a fairy tale into a horror story. The above
film focuses on the female protagonist, Rosaleen, and the
stages she goes through to enter the adolescent world,
and how this reflects to the corruption of her childhood
innocence. As Bruno Bettelheim (1991:172) demonstrates,
the film’s underlying goal is to educate moral
instructions to the leading heroine about the
relationship of the world’s they find themselves in. Little
Red Riding Hood is universally loved because, although she
is moral, she is tempted; and because her fate tells us
that trusting everybody’s good intentions, which seems so
nice, is really leaving oneself to fall in the ‘trap’.
Thus reminding the audience that the ‘‘Sweetest tongue
has the sharpest tooth’’ (The Company of Wolves, 1984).Thus
reflecting on the traditional ideas of femininity,
sexuality and childhood innocence.
According to an online analysis (2007), the film
necessitates its viewers to enthusiastically engage the
key themes from each scene, and is not appropriate for
12
those only prepared to observe a ‘superficial horror
flick’. This film can be seen to be in parallel with
horror films, with werewolf narratives, however the
werewolf narrative is used to depict female sexuality and
the sexual aggressive nature which exists in men. This
media text draws the viewers into a mental landscape; it
captures them and draws them into the distressing world
of a little girl’s wild fantasy world, situated in a
fairy tale-like setting. The movie is produced and
directed in such a way, to capture the audience, making
them feel as if they are ‘trapped in a fairy tale`
themselves. The ghostly and unearthly scenery builds up
into a Freudian nightmare, illustrating puberty through a
twisted modernization of the classic story “Little Red Riding
Hood’’ as aforementioned. For Freud there is no tabula rasa,
therefore, there is no innocent child, this is developed
in the film’s ‘dream framework’, where we are depicted
dominant ideas of sexuality which exist within children,
and how this sexuality causes the loss of childhood
innocence.
One of Angela Carter's themes and concepts that are
essential in this movie, is that the corruption of
adulthood is unconditional, thus reflecting on the ideas
of sexuality. When one enters the world of adulthood,
there is no preservation of innocence and purity of
youth; this is when there is no way back. Thus this is a
depiction of the reflection of ideas of childhood in the
13
film, and not an artistic depiction of the actual life,
as previously mentioned. In addition the ideas of
childhood in the film are presented as a temporary
identity. The viewers are presented and illustrated a
juxtaposition of the protagonist’s innocence, displayed
by her childhood toys and dolls in her room at the very
start of the film. Juxtaposed with the toys, the sleeping
Rosaleen is seen to be wearing smudged red lipstick, with
a magazine lying next to her that has a symbolic title,
‘‘The Shattered Dream". The title is not only hidden with
symbolic meanings but it is also ominous, as Rosaleen’s
‘dream of her childhood innocence is soon to be taken
away’. This is a Freudian outlook of children’s dreams
about sexuality.
On her door hangs a white chiffon dress, symbolizing the
path of her entering into womanhood and adolescence. This is
illustrated at the finale of the movie, where the viewers try to
‘catch their breath’, as they view ‘the wolf’ invading her room,
symbolising the destruction of Rosaleen’s innocence. The viewers
are presented with strong visual imagery, as they see Rosaleen’s
childhood toys being ‘destroyed’ by the wild wolves invading her
room, the same way she is being destroyed and corrupted
metaphysically. The vividness of this scene is out of the world,
the aim for the destruction of her childhood is indisputable.
Her cry can be interpreted to symbolise her comprehension and
acknowledgment of what she must lose to enter into the adult
world. This scene differs from the literary text, where the loss
14
of childhood innocence is seen as a more positive act. However in
contrast with the film, which follows the Freudian dream
framework, they have represented this scene, in an intense
‘horror narrative’. Thus this is portraying sexuality in a
‘horrific fashion’.
Thus illustrating, what happens when people grow up,
they put their toys away in the attic as if they were ‘gone
forever’, symbolising the ‘death of innocence’. Thus this
reproduces dominant ideas of childhood, and how a child’s
innocence becomes corrupted as they enter adulthood, because of
a child experiencing sexuality. The background music in the
beginning of the film is ominous, it adds up the tension
throughout the film, until it reaches its final climax.
As soon as the first scene is about to enter the dream framework,
poignant music is played, reflecting on the atmosphere, the mood of
the scene. Alice, Rosaleen’s sister is presented in the
protagonist’s dream, and how she is being attacked by a sailor toy
and a human sized teddy bear. This act is symbolic. The childhood
toys that are attacking the protagonist’s sister, Alice, are being
rebellious. Due to the fact that Alice, has entered the adult world
and she is now too old to be playing with her toys. In addition the
large ticking clock also stands as a symbol and a metaphor in this
scene, as it is reinforcing that time passes too quickly, and Alice
does not belong in the children’s world anymore. Thus this scene
illustrates ideas of childhood and sexuality.
Alice’s final ‘death’ to her childhood innocence is when she
is attacked by a pack of wild wolves in this scene, where they
15
‘kill’ her savagely. This scene can be interpreted in so many
different ways. My belief is that her ‘death’ was metaphysical as
she was possibly ‘raped’ by men or sexually abused. These sexually
aggressive men in this scene are presented as wild beasts, - in the
form of ‘wolves’ to emphasise the aggressive sexual nature of men.
This scene can be interpreted as the arrival of sexuality, which is
represented in a conservative construction of childhood. In
addition this scene refers to Freud, and how he claimed that all
children were sexual. The two worlds of the dream and the reality
world of the girl exist in this film, to portray that a young girl
is free to dream about sexuality and the passage of womanhood.
However in reality sexuality sometimes has to be repressed, whereas
young girls are liberated to dream sexually. Alice’s cry depicts
her helpless nature, and how women were traditionally represented
as the ‘weaker sex’. At Alice’s funeral her mother tells Rosaleen,
‘‘Kiss your sister goodbye for the last time’’. This quote should
not be taken literary; she is actually depicting ideas of loss of
childhood innocence, representing the ‘death of childhood’. Thus
the funeral stands as a symbol to the ‘burial of childhood purity’.
As Diane Herman(1998) has pointed out in her important essay, ‘The
Rape Culture’, ‘‘the imagery of sexual implications between males and
females in books, songs, advertising and films is frequently that of
sadomasochist relationship thinly veiled by a romantic façade. Thus
it is extremely difficult in our society to differentiate rape, from
‘normal’ heterosexual intercourse; relations undeniably our culture
conduct, as a result that she faces the possibility of rape’’.
16
Figure 1
According to an online analysis (2007) of the film,
Rosaleen’s red cape is symbolic to her childhood
innocence, the cape was originally made to keep her safe
as well as hide her feminine body from the male world.
While Rosaleen states that the cape is comforting,
"...soft as a kitten," it becomes apparent, that the cape
must be ‘destroyed’ symbolically losing her innocence, in
order for her to enter into the adult world. The Hunter
later on in the movie tells her "...into the fire with
it, you won't need it again," this portrays the hunter’s
lust and his strong passion to burn the child’s innocence
to try to wake up the dormant woman in her. A further
interpretation I would like to demonstrate is, the colour
of the red shall, can also stand as a symbol of the
provocative nature of Rosaleen, and how she will follow
the path towards adulthood, this portrays the loss of
childhood innocence and purity, the colour red reinforces
female sexuality, and femininity.
This media text has a problematic status, because of
the fact that the viewers are presented with a young girl
17
that subverts the traditional image of the sweet innocent
little girl. This is ironic, as her grandmother’s
function in the story is to guide her precious
granddaughter to ‘‘not stray from the path’’, but the
colour of the shawl reinforces sexuality, feminine desire
and womanhood. Thus this depicts the adult-child power
relations in this media text.
The symbolic death of her grandmother’s head being
shattered like glass, and the red shawl liberates
Rosaleen free to mature, to enter the world of the
‘wolves’, as it is illustrated in the film to portray the
corrupted state of adolescence. As in Freud's analysis of
dreams, Rosaleen's dream deals with her ‘inner demons’-
her repressed sexuality, thus portraying elements of her
psyche as characters in her dream. In Rosaleen's dream,
her Grandmother ‘‘symbolizes the path of rules, care, and
fright’’. In her dream Rosaleen is warned by her
Grandmother to never "stray from the path… Once you stray
from the path you're lost entirely! The wild beasts know
no mercy’’. What the Grandmother is really saying is ‘‘to
stay on the path of celibate adolescence leading to
marriage and to beware of the bestial, aggressive
sexuality of men’’ (Hyldreth, 2008).
"Oh, they're nice as pie until they've had their way with
you. But once the bloom is gone, oh, the beast comes
out." What her grandmother is actually trying to warn her
is, how men ‘transform’ when they have their ‘evil way’
18
with a woman, displaying their true colours, this scene
depicts dominant ideologies of male sexuality.
A further interpretation of her Grandmother’s
constant warning of ‘‘don’t stray from the path’’, can be
interpreted in a radical feminist way- in their view of
the aggressive sexuality of men and their dominance over
women. A child has been traditionally portrayed in the
need of protection, thus this highlights the function of
the grandmother in the film. This can be associated with
the Brothers Grimm adaptation of Little Red Cap, ‘‘as her
mother is aware of Little Red Cap’s proclivity for straying
off the beaten path, and for spying into corners to
discover the secrets of adults’’. (Cited In The Uses Of
Enchatment, 1991). Thus this reinforces the dominant ideas
of childhood and sexuality.
Figure 2
The film deal with the theme, of the protagonist’s
developing sexuality in a magical series, as if it is
mimicking a fairy tale setting. In which she suddenly
breaks out of the scenery of the dream world and climbs a
19
tree. At the top of a tree she finds an abandoned bird’s
nest containing eggs and a hand mirror. As Damon Hyldreth
(2008) illustrates, she magically finds a red lipstick
and wears it and admires herself in the mirror, at the
same time the audience is taken back to Rosaleen’s room
where she is sleeping restlessly- there are a lot of
references to the sleeping Rosaleen in the movie. The
mirror in her bedroom and the lips smudged with lipstick
is being displayed. The eggs, the visual demonstration of
the ‘unbroken egg’, (Cartmell, et al 1998:52) of the
short story, crack open to reveal figurines of babies,
representing Rosaleen’s passage into adulthood, her
sexual latent The protagonist’s personal traits
challenges prevailing attitudes, towards the institution
of childhood, due to the fact that this particular scene
reflects on the ideas, of female sexuality, and the loss
of childhood innocence.
As the authors of Sisterhoods (1998:52) state that,
the juxtaposition of the hand mirror, red lipstick and
eggs, symbolise the socially and biologically determined
aspects of femaleness. This particular scene serves as a
form of ambiguity, not only depicting the protagonist’s
adolescent state, through an economic use of symbolic
taken directly from the literary book, but also
reinforcing female subjectivity via visual references to
the dream structure. (Cartmell, et al 1998:52)
20
As Damon Hyldreth (2008) portrays, the viewers are
presented with our protagonist moving her young delicate
figure forward as she takes one of the gleaming tiny
figures, placing it in her pocket. As Rosaleen returns
home through the woods to her horror, she comes across to
a large ‘wolf’ sitting above her on hill. As she walks
approving the tiny little statuette in her hand she seems
impervious to the wolf. When she returns home, she shows
the figurine to her mother and we see a close up of the
figurine. Rosaleen's seeing herself in the mirror as a
woman and retrieving the tiny figurine of a man
symbolizes, that she has the awareness of herself as a
woman with power to give birth, birth not only to a baby,
but to her own adult self; this symbolises the corruption
of adolescence, and the loss of her childhood innocence.
This scene also makes references to the beginning of the
movie. When it is stated in the movie that she has a
‘‘tummy ache’’.-reflecting on her menstrual cycle, also
the red lipstick is ominous to her destiny, this reflects
in her development as a woman. Thus this reflects the
traditional ideas of female sexuality, and the loss of
childhood innocence.
In the aforementioned story the grandmother which
symbolises wisdom and knowledge is also an adult wolf. It
is essential to critically analyse the term ‘wolf’ in
this text, the motif, the ‘icon’ of the ‘wolf’, should
not be taken literally but metaphorically. The ‘wolf’
represents, experience and acknowledgment of the real
21
world. It is essential to display that the grandmother
narrates two very significant stories to Rosaleen,
because according to her a ‘‘child is never young enough
to know’’. (The Company of Wolves, 1984) Thus this is once
again reinforcing and highlighting dominant ideas of
childhood and sexuality, represented in this film.
22
Sub-Section ThreeThe Dominance Of Story-Telling in the Company of Wolves
In the third sub-section, I will illustrate and
present the dominance of ‘story-telling’ that exists in
this film. ‘Story-telling’ reflects upon issues of
childhood and socialisation. Traditionally children were
told stories by their parents, as a way of indoctrinating
them into dominant values including their own situation
as children. Two of the ‘narrative stories’ are told by
the Grandmother and the other two ‘narrative stories’,
are narrated by the Protagonist herself.
In one of her narratives, the Grandmother tells a
story to our protagonist about a newly wed in the
village, and how her husband disappeared on their wedding
night because of ‘‘call of nature’’. I would like to
critically analyse and examine this quote, the groom’s
disappearance contains ambiguity, and his actions can be
interpreted as the ‘unfaithful’ husband, who abandoned
his wife on their wedding night. This possible analysis
can be coo-related with the reappearance of the husband
after a long period of time to find his wife in her
23
second marriage making supper for her children. His
aggressive gesture towards his wife is highlighted when
he violently slaps her on the face calling her a
‘‘whore’’ and ‘‘if I was a wolf once, I’ll be a wolf
again’’. All this, add up to his aggressive, uncouth
nature, his bestiality, and his unfaithful nature. He
violently removes his skin and metamorphosis’s into a
wolf to attack his wife, but when the wife’s second
husband marches in the room, he chops his head off and he
immediately transforms back into a man. Carter could
possibly have created this, in order to mirror the fact
that even if there is ‘bestiality’ and ‘abusive nature’
in men, this does not change the fact that he is still
human. The scene portrays the grandmother’s collusion in
patriarchal accounts of gender relationships.
For Anwell (1988), these violent transformation
scenes are inherently connected, to aggressive, masculine
sexuality. Anwell also argues that the film, ‘‘surrenders
to the commercial pressures of mainstream cinema in the
use of expensive, state-of-the-art animatronics to effect
the werewolf metamorphoses’’. Avis Leewallen (1988)
quotes at length from this passage in Duncker’s essay,
but departs from Duncker’s analysis in the recognition of
the use of ‘‘an inner confessional narrative’’, which
both acknowledges patriarchal structure, and provides a
form of critique against it.
Her grandmother’s second narrative story is about a
boy who meets the ‘Devil’ in the woods. It is essential
24
to decode and interpret this scene in a symbolic fashion.
A car appears out of nowhere in the forest, a car driven
by Rosaleen who is presented in an altered way, wearing a
blonde wig. The viewers are presented with Rosaleen’s
provocative greeting smile, when she opens the door to
introduce the boy to the ‘Devil’; this scene reminds the
viewers when Rosaleen’s mother states, ‘‘if there is evil
in men. There is evil in women too’’. The ‘Devil’ hands
the boy a potion while he is holding a skull in his hand,
when the car vanishes from the woods, the boy opens the
magical potion and puts some drops on his body. We are
then illustrated with a magical transformation of the boy
into a ‘wolf’, where the body hair grows on the boy,
making him scream in pain, as he ‘transforms’.
Thus the scene portrays how a boy violently
transforms into an adolescent and how this ‘wolf
transformation’ is a natural act this is further evident,
when the viewers are presented with the tree’s roots
aggressively capturing the boy. This symbolises that the
‘werewolf transformation’ is a natural act as
aforementioned. In Jordan's film the ‘werewolf’
transformation is linked directly to male sexuality; here
we see the devil encourage a young man into the sexual
sphere. The scene endorses parts of an old legend. One
of the ways to turn into a werewolf is to drink such a
potion, this scene can also be interpreted in another
way; the car itself represents the ‘wolf’-adolescence.
The idea relates to the male lust, and this lust is
25
produced and created by women, and the source of this
lust is the ’Devil’-the evil in men. This is symbolically
a rich moment indoctrinating and constructing gender and
sexuality in the film. ‘‘That’s a horrid story’’, is the
response of the heroine, thus reflecting Rosaleen’s
denial of male sexual aggression, and a woman’s power to
provoke and to seduce men. This scene depicts gender
representation, the construction of male and female
sexuality as previously mentioned, and the loss of
childhood innocence, because of the existence of
‘sexuality’ in this film.
This scene, can contradict Maggie Anwell’s (1988)
reading of powers relations in the movie, because this
scene mirrors the subversion of gender power-relations
which are represented throughout the movie.
As Henry Jenkins (1998:261) would suggest, the
film’s theme of these ‘‘children’s cultures contains
these adult fantasies. It contains the transformation of
this into a projection on to children of the adult
language of lust and craving. In this view the little
seductress is a multifaceted phenomenon, which contains
adult sexual lust, but which captures into the equally
complex fantasies carried by the little girl herself’’.
The child is theologically constructed as, ‘‘One view
stressed the angelic natural goodness of children the
other stressed their devilish, potentially evil, self-
willed nature’’.(1972:8) As a sample of the first view,
Shipman quotes from the essayist, John Earle,
26
subsequently Bishop of Salisbury, who in 1628, at the age
of eighteen wrote in Microcosmographic.‘’The child is the
best copy of Adam before he tasted of Eve, or the apple,
and he is happy whose small practice in the world can
only write his character..’’(Shipman, 1972:9). Thus this
latter quote displays the corruption of childhood
innocence, due to the existence of ‘sexuality’.
Figure 3
The third story that is being narrated in the film
is narrated by the female heroine of the media text
Rosaleen, and the story is being addressed towards her
own mother. Thus this scene demonstrates a dramatic
reverse between adult-child power relations. The viewers
are portrayed with a subversion of power relations, where
the adult- the mother is presented to be the listener,
and the child is depicted as the story teller. Story-
telling reflects upon issues of childhood and
socialisation, as aforementioned. Traditionally children
were told stories by their parents, as a way of
27
indoctrinating them into dominant values including their
own situation as children. Carter’s story is being
critical of this, as we are presented subversion between
the adult/child power relations.
In Rosaleen’s story the viewers are taken to a
wedding scene, where the aristocratic bride and groom
have just exchanged their vows, and they are seated at a
dinner party along with their guests. Out of nowhere a
pregnant Irish woman enters the dinner party, disturbing
the guests with her presence. With her presence, she
makes it quite obvious that the groom had committed
something so terrible, leaving the girl pregnant. Her
statement that the ‘‘wolves in the forest are more
decent’’, can be interpreted how the wealthy and the
aristocratic families can be described as everything,
besides ‘decent’. She compares the wealthy with the
actual ‘wolves’ in the forest, to depict that they are
worst then the actual wild creatures living in the
forest. Thus this quote reinforces the aggressive nature
of men’s sexuality.
As soon as she turns around to look at the mirror,
the mirror cracks, transforming all the guests into
‘wolves’, this symbolic and metaphysical transformation
has a very essential meaning in this scene. The ‘witch’
portrays the ‘power’ to unmask the Aristocratic guests
and to reveal their ‘true colours’. The story narrated by
Rosaleen, is not about ‘werewolf transformations’, but
the ‘wolf’ image has been used to present the
28
animalistic, deceitful behaviour of the aristocracy. This
scene depicts gender representation and the construction
of male and female sexuality. ‘‘The use of circus music
and extensive camera movement produce a carnivalesque
atmosphere, reinforcing the facade of kitsch
intertextuality’’. (Cartmell, et al 1998:52) Catherine
Neale (1996) suggests that ‘‘this is an intentional
alienation technique which ultimately fails’’, arguing
that ‘‘in the decision to sacrifice the illusion of
transformation at this point in the film, presumably in
order to force the viewer to appraise what they are
seeing, elements of bathos and banality cannot be
controlled’’.
It is hard not to notice the parallel between the
texts of A Company of Wolves, and Disney’s Beauty & The Beast, when
one analyses the ‘aggressive, sexuality in men’, which is
represented by the Beast, in the Beauty & The Beast. An
essential paradigm can be illustrated when the Beast
screams at Belle, when she refuses to dine with him he
screams, ‘‘Then you can starve!’’. The Beast represents
and stands as a symbol of the uncouth Aristocrat, who is
aggressive and brutal, similarly the ‘Aristocrats’ in
Company of Wolves are portrayed as ‘less decent then the
wolves living in the forest’. Henry Giroux (2001) states
that, ‘‘enchantment comes at a high price, however if the
audience is meant to suspend judgment of the film’s
ideological messages’’ (2001:96). This statement
highlights in order to comprehend the representation of
29
aggressive, heterosexual nature of men, it is essential
to decode the ‘ideological messages’, as previously
stated.
A very significant point to illustrate is that the
story is narrated by the female protagonist of this media
text, thus subverting the traditional image of children
being naïve and innocent. Firstly, for Rosaleen to
narrate such a story to her mother does not only reverse
power relations between adults and children as
aforementioned; but it also demonstrates Rosaleen’s
acknowledgment and comprehension of the path towards
adolescence and the corruption of her own childhood. The
fact that Rosaleen is narrating the story, illustrates
she has the power to be in control and through her story,
it is evident that she is aware that ‘‘wolves may lurk in
every guise’’. (A Company of Wolves, 1984)
As Damon Hyldreth (2008) depicts, as Rosaleen
narrates her second story, which is addressed to the
wolf, we see a white rose in full bloom opening in slow
motion. As it opens it begins to turn deep blood-red
turning completely red when fully open. The rose
symbolises Rosaleen, depicting that her development as an
‘adult wolf’ is complete; she has found her male partner
and domesticated the ‘beast ’within him. The
‘transformation’ of the white rose turning into a red
rose, portrays Rosaleen’s innocence being destroyed, the
colour of the rose reinforces her menstrual cycle-her
30
metamorphosis into an adult wolf has been completed. It
is vital to display that, the ‘wolf’ is not just the male
seducer, but he also represents all the asocial,
animalistic tendencies within us. Traditionally roses
were symbolically used to depict sexuality, femininity
and passion.
Anwell (1988) offers a sensitive reading of Carter’s
sexual politics in the story; by declining to abandon the
logic of the gaze, Anwell misguidedly interprets the film
as reinforcing the patriarchal victim/aggressor approach
of the original fairy tale. By emphasizing ‘the struggle
to speak female desire’, she disregards the essential
role of the female voice and story-telling in her
enthusiasm to censure the film for a voyeuristic
portrayal of the female protagonist.
There are a number of significant and vital themes
that surround this film. An imperative paradigm is, at the
very end of the movie, the viewers see the protagonist’s
dream world collide with ‘the real world’. The last
series of events build up with tension as the viewers are
close to the final climax, keeping the audience in
constant suspense. We the viewers see Rosaleen reaching
her destiny- losing her childhood innocence and her final
‘metamorphosis’ and final ‘transformation’ from an
innocent child into an ‘adult wolf’. Thus this media
text, constructs not only children’s audience but also
adult’s audiences. This scene is vital as the audience
31
‘sees’ the Freudian dream framework being collided with
the world of reality. Rosaleen’s sexuality and her
passage into womanhood from her dreams have now been
collided with her world of ‘reality’.
32
Conclusion
To conclude this research paper, I have focused
on the movie A Company of Wolves and have depicted how this
media text, represents puberty and adolescence through a
twisted modernization of the classic story Little Red Riding
Hood, as aforementioned. This media text as previously
mentioned, explores the loss of childhood innocence,
purity and the corruption of the world of the
adolescence, with the ingenious use of the dream
framework. This film portrays once a child ‘creeps out of
the children’s world into the adult world’, there is no
‘way back’. However this is a depiction of the reflection
of ideas of childhood in the film, and not an artistic
depiction of the actual life. It has been evident that in
order to correctly ‘decode’ this film, it is essential
and vital not to ‘see’ it in a ‘superficial flick’, but
to decode it as one would decode a literary piece, which
contains a lot of symbolic language. It is crucial to
depict that in the aforementioned media text, exists four
very essential ‘narrative stories’ that occur as
33
previously mentioned; two of these stories are narrated
by the Grandmother, who has the role of Rosaleen’s (the
female protagonist) protector. As children were
traditionally presented as being in need of protection,
the other two of the stories that are narrated, are
narrated by Rosaleen herself. In these stories that are
being narrated, the viewers are being illustrated how an
innocent child loses her childhood innocence, and how she
becomes ‘corrupted’ as she enters the world of
adolescence. The ‘corruption’ of adolescence is further
demonstrated by the sexual, aggressive, bestiality in
men, and how this ‘evil’ in men also exist in women, thus
this demonstrates a construction of female and male
sexuality. These ideas in the film reflect on dominant
ideas of childhood, femininity and sexuality.
Bibliography Badley, Linda (1995) Film, Horror, and the Body Fantastic
[Online].Available from URL:http://books.google.com/books?id=PD1CZfa5wicC&pg=PA104&dq=anti+feminism+in+company+of+wolves#PP P11,M1
34
[Accessed November 2008]
Beckett, Sandra (2002) Recycling Red Riding Hood [Online].Available from URL:http://books.google.com/books?
id=LapMimSid7kC&pg=PA147&dq=decoding+little+red+riding+hood#PPR17,M1
[Accessed November 2008]
Bettelheim, Bruno (1991) The uses of enchantment: the meaning and importance of fairy tales. London: Penguin.
Cartmell, Deborah et al. (1998) Sisterhoods:[Online].Available fromURL:http://books.google.com/books?id=MM7lkyefGisC&pg=PA48&dq=analysis+of+company+of+wolves#PPA1,M1
[Accessed November 2008]
Carter, Angela (1940-1992) Come unto these yellow sands. -Newcastle upon Tyne : Bloodaxe
Carter, Angela(1984) The Company of Wolves [OnlineImage].Available from: URLhttp://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://thisdistractedglobe.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/06/Wolves4.jpg&imgrefurl=http://thisdistractedglobe.com/2006/03/09/the-company-of-wolves-1984/&usg=__eRuvH9x8t5d4UnT20GUkeuXWQx0=&h=208&w=160&sz=9&hl=en&start=61&tbnid=ZqsfBG6QRXpTRM:&tbnh=105&tbnw=81&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dthe%2Bcompany%2Bof%2Bwolves%26start%3D60%26gbv%3D2%26ndsp%3D20%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DN
[Accessed December 2008]Carter, Angela (1984) The Company of Wolves [Online
Image].Available from: URLhttp://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://www.bombsite.com/images/attachments/0001/5525/
Carter_01_body.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.bombsite.com/issues/17/articles/
821&usg=__diToOuqmIanw_NqGmFgKrpDbyR4=&h=557&w=548&sz=166&hl=en&start=96&tbnid=6CP4sSNS7EreiM:&tbnh=133&tbnw
35
=131&prev=/images%3Fq%3D%2527a%2Bcompany%2Bof%2Bwolves%2527%26start%3D80%26gbv%3D2%26ndsp%3D20%26hl%3Den
%26sa%3DN[Accessed December 2008]
Cooper, Patricia& Dancyger, Ken (2000) Writing The Short Film, [Online]. Available from: URL
http://books.google.com/books?id=rRmcrT5JL-4C&pg=PA187&dq=Writing+the+Short+Film+By+Patricia+Cooper,+Ken+Dancyger+company+of+wolves
[Accessed December 2008]
Giroux, Henry (2001) The Mouse That Roared [Online]. Available from: URLhttp://books.google.com/books?id=y4JIvzl547UC&pg=PA92&dq=analyzing+disney%27s+beauty%26the+beast#PPA96,M1
[Accessed December 2008] Hyldreth, Damon (2008) The Company of Wolves [Online].
Available from URL:http://www.damonart.com/myth_wolves.html
[Accessed November 2008] Hyldreth, Damon (2008) The Company of Wolves [Online
Image]. Available from URL:http://www.damonart.com/myth_wolves.html
[Accessed November 2008]
Jackson, S. (1984) ‘ Chapter 3: ‘The Nature of Childhood’ in Childhood and sexuality Oxford & New York: Blackwell pp.22-46
Jenkins, Henry (1998) The Children’s Culture Reader. New York University Press, New York and London
Kirkland, Ewan (2008) ‘Overview` [Online]. Available from: URL
http://lms.king.ac.uk/webapps/portal/frameset.jsp?tab_id=_2_1&url=%2fwebapps%2fblackboard%2fexecute%2flauncher%3ftype%3dCourse%26id%3d_5795447_1%26url%3d
[Accessed December 2008]
36
Mills, J and Mills, R (2000) Childhood Studies: a Reader in Perspectives of Childhood. London: Routledge
The Company of Wolves (2007) [Online]. Available from URL:
http://www.geocities.com/za5tar/thecompanyofwolves.html
[Accessed November 2008]
The Company of Wolves (1984) Directed by, Neil Jordan[DVD], Shepperton Studios, Shepperton, Surrey,England, UK
Zipes, Jack (2006) Fairy Tales and the Art of Subversion,[Online]. Available fromURL:http://books.google.com/books?id=Z89TEYxprOoC&printsec=frontcover&dq=Fairy+tales+and+the+art+of+subversion+:+the+classical+genre+for+children+and#PPP1,M1
[Accessed November 2008]
37