Kiat masuk jurnal internasional berindex scopus
-
Upload
yeffry-handoko -
Category
Education
-
view
396 -
download
8
Transcript of Kiat masuk jurnal internasional berindex scopus
Kiat-Kiat masuk Jurnal Berindex
ScopusScopus
Dr. Yeffry Handoko Putra, M.TDiberikan sebagai Bahan Diskusi antar Dosen
Di Fakultas Teknik dan Ilmu Komputer
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
1
Dr. Yeffry Handoko Putra, M.TKetua Prodi Magister Sistem Informasi
UNIKOM
Sertifikasi :
• Ir (Insinyur Pendidik/Madya) Persatuan Insinyur
Indonesia, 13/03/2010
E-mail : [email protected]
Indonesia, 13/03/2010
• CISA: ISACA Norwich Chapter UK
27/09/2009
Trainer di bidang Audit Sistem
Informasi (CISA), dan Tata Kelola Sistem Informasi
(CGEIT), Lean Six Sigma, Agile Management
Magister Sistem
Informasi
UNIKOM2
Rekam Jejak Pembicara
Journal of Bionic
Engineering, Vol 6
Issue (3)264-269 2009
Cina
ISSN:16726529
Distributor: Elsevier
Indian Journal of Marine
Sciences Vol 38(3) ,2009,
308-315 India
http://nopr.niscair.res.in/ha
ndle/123456789/6207
International Journal
of Applied Business &
Economic Research,
Vol. 15 (2017)
India, Serial
Publication
2009 2009 2017
Distributor: Elsevier
DOI: 10.1016/S1672-
6529(08)60120-1
http://jbe.jlu.edu.cn/EN/Y2
009/V6/I3/264
H-index:27
8 bulanWaktu penyelesaian
3 x revisi:
ndle/123456789/6207
ISSN: 0975-1033 (Online);
0379-5136 (Print)
Hindex:24
Publication
ISSN: 0972-7302
H-Index :2
2 mingguWaktu penyelesaian :
Tanpa revisi (serial
publication Tidak
diakui DIKTI)
1 tahunWaktu penyelesaian
6 x revisi3
Garis Besar Presentasi
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional
� Publikasi
� Sitasi
� Penilaian
� Rangking� Rangking
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus
� Komponen Keberhasilan Publikasi Internasional
� Pengecekan keunikan dan plagiat, tulisan sebelum dipublikasi
� Mencari Jurnal yang sesuai (bereputasi, bukan predator, terindeks)
� Memilih H-Index yang sesuai
4
Part
Kehidupan Jurnal Internasional
5
Part A:
Kehidupan Jurnal Internasional
Dinilai/Analisa
Rangking
KelahiranJurnalInternasional
Publikasi
Sitasi
AnalisaMetriks Sitasi
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 6
A. Proses Publikasi Jurnal
� Semua jurnal harus dapat ditelusurionline
� Jurnal di unggah
� Jurnal non online sebelum 2011 diunggah di halaman kopertis, portal garuda, academia.edugaruda, academia.edu
� Istilah Jurnal nasional terakreditasijadi jurnal nasional saja
� Jurnal nasional, penulisnya berasaldari dua institusi yang berbeda
� OJS (Open Journal System) untukjurnal online
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 7
A. Proses Publikasi Jurnal
� Jurnal Internasional memiliki template yang
berbeda. General Template untuk scopus:
https://www.elsevier.com/solutions/scopus
/content
� Alamat web dapat dicari dari penelurusan
google atau keterangan pada
Contoh open journal yang terdaftar
dalam DOAJ:
TELKOMNIKA : Indonesian Journal of
Electrical Engineering (Universitas
Ahmad Dahlan)
Indonesian Journal of Biotechnology
(UGM)
Jurnal Teknik Industri (Universitas google atau keterangan pada
www.scimagojr.com
� Jurnal bisa berupa jurnal online atau
tercetak dengan ISSN berbeda
� Jurnal bisa berbayar atau tidak
� Jurnal online (OJS) yang tidak masuk dalam
Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)
memiliki nilai 25% dari acuan penelaian
kumulatif
Jurnal Teknik Industri (Universitas
Kristen Petra)
International Journal of Science and
Engineering (UNDIP)
Indonesian Journal of Electrical
Engineering and Computer Science
(Universitas Ahmad Dahlan
& Institute of Advanced Engineering
and Science (IAES) )
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 8
Penilaian berdasarkan
Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)
https://doaj.org/
• Kalau masuk DOAJ– List jurnal Indonesia bernilai 15
– List Jurnal Inggris bernilai 20
– Contoh : • TELKOMNIKA : Indonesian Journal of Electrical Engineering
(Universitas Ahmad Dahlan)(Universitas Ahmad Dahlan)
• Indonesian Journal of Biotechnology (UGM)
• Jurnal Teknik Industri (Universitas Kristen Petra)
• International Journal of Science and Engineering (UNDIP)
• Indonesian Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (Universitas Ahmad Dahlan & Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science (IAES) )
• Kalau tidak masuk DOAJ.org nilai 25% dari nilai acuan
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 9
B. Proses Sitasi:Citation Analysis di Dunia
• Web of Science:– Web of Science provides citation counts for
articles indexed within it. It indexes over 10,000 journals in the arts, humanities, sciences, and social sciences.
• Scopus– Scopus provide citation counts for articles indexed
within it (limited to article written in 1996 and after). It indexes over 15,000 journals from over
Why Scopus be
the most
popular?after). It indexes over 15,000 journals from over 4,000 international publishers across the disciplines.
• Google Scholar– Google Scholar provides citation counts for
articles found within Google Scholar. Depending on the discipline and cited article, it may find more cited references than Web of Science or Scopus because overall, Google Scholar is indexing more journals and more publication types than other databases.
popular?
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 10
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 11
B. Proses Sitasi: Citation Analysis di Indonesia
• Indonesian Scientific Journal Database
(ISJD)
• Indonesian Publication Index (IPI)
• Crossref DOI (Digital Object Identifier)
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 12
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi
• H index:
– an author-level metric that attempts to measure both the productivity and
citation impact of the publications of a scientist or scholar. The index is based
on the set of the scientist's most cited papers and the number of citations that
they have received in other publications.
• i10-Index:• i10-Index:
– the number of publications with at least 10 citations. This very simple measure
is only used by Google Scholar, and is another way to help gauge the
productivity of a scholar. Advantages of i10-Index. Very simple and
straightforward to calculate.
• JCR dari Web Science
Source: wikipedia.com Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 13
• SCImago Journal Rank (SJR):
– a measure of scientific influence of scholarly journals that accounts for both the number
of citations received by a journal and the importance or prestige of the journals where
such citations come from. The SJR indicator is a variant of the eigenvector centrality
measure used in network theory
• Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP )
– Created by Professor Henk Moed at CTWS, University of Leiden, Source Normalized
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi (2)
– Created by Professor Henk Moed at CTWS, University of Leiden, Source Normalized
Impact per Paper (SNIP) measures contextual citation impact by weighting citations
based on the total number of citations in a subject field. The impact of a single citation is
given higher value in subject areas where citations are less likely, and vice versa
• Impact per Publication (IPP).
Source: www.journalmetrics.com
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 14
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Mengenali H-index
• Journal h-index is one measure of the quality of a journal and can be
calculated using data from Web of Science, Scopus or Google Scholar. As
with the impact factor, journal h-index does not take into account differing
citation practices of fields (unlike the weighted SJR and SNIP) and so is
best used to compare journals within a field.
• While JCR's impact factor offers calculations based on windows • While JCR's impact factor offers calculations based on windows
of two and five years, and SJR and SNIP are based on three years, the h-
index publication window can be selected to best suit the citation
practices of a discipline.
– Web of Science:
– Scopus
– Google Scholar
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 15
• For physical sciences: ~12 tenured associate prof, ~18
full prof, ~45 member of national academy of science
• Few biases:
– Does not care where author appears on paper and total
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Mengenali H-index
–
number of authors on papers
– Advantage for older, alive scientists and sustained
productivity
– Ignore context (wrong
results)
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 16
• Hirsch, PNAS 2005
• Simultaneously measures productivity and impact of a scientist
• A scholar with an index
of h has published h
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Mengenali H-index
of h has published h
papers each of which
has been cited by others
at least h times
• Check citation from scholar.google.com
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 17
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Impact Factor (Google Scholar)
• 5 year impact factor
• Eigenfactor Score™ (see West et al., 2008)
• H-index (see Hirsch, 2005 in References)
• Calculations that may make sense in science, • Calculations that may make sense in science,
don’t seem relevant in social science.
– Cited half life
– Immedicacy
– H-factor
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 18
• Calculation for 2013 impact factorA = total cites to published articles in 2011-2012B = 2013 cites to published articles in 2011-2012C = number of published articles in 2011-2012D = B/C = 2013 impact factor
Please get take a look at (here)A = 925*
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Impact Factor (Google Scholar)
A = 925*B = 482*C = 164D = B/C = 482/164 = 2.939
• Citation indices
• h-index : 15i10-index : 32
• Citations to TELKOMNIKA *update: 2 May 2014
• 2013 cites to published articles in 2011-2012 = 482
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 19
C. Proses Penilaian dengan Metriks Sitasi :
Impact Factor (Google Scholar) –cont’d
20
D. Proses Rangking
• Based on H-Index � SJR (Scimago Journal Rangking)
Dikelola oleh Scopus
• Based on Impact Factor � Quartile Rangking
Dikelola oleh Thomson Reuter
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 21
D. Proses Rangking dengan :
Quartile Rangking (Q)• Based on Impact Factor (IF) data, the Journal Citation Reports published
by Thomson Reuters provides yearly rankings of science and social science journals, in the subject categories relevant for the journal (in fact, there may be more than one).
• Quartile rankings are therefore derived for each journal in each of its subject categories according to which quartile of the IF distribution the journal occupies for that subject category. Q1 denotes the top 25% of the journal occupies for that subject category. Q1 denotes the top 25% of the IF distribution, Q2 for middle-high position (between top 50% and top 25%), Q3 middle-low position (top 75% to top 50%), and Q4 the lowest position (bottom 25% of the IF distribution).
• For example, the 2009 Impact Factor for the ACM TRANSACTIONS ON
SENSOR NETWORKS is 1.938. Thus, the journal ranks 32-nd (out of 116 journals, Q2 quartile) in the subject category COMPUTER SCIENCE,
INFORMATION SYSTEMS, while it ranks 11-th (out of 76 journals, Q1 quartile) in the subject categoryTELECOMMUNICATIONS.
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 22
Google Scholar
• Scholar.google.com
• Set preference to access open source and Harvard Lib:
http://scholar.google.com/scholar_preferences?hl=en
• Where is a paper cited
• Get free pdf without subscription• Get free pdf without subscription
• Get H-index
• “My Citations”
– Manually update papers after the initial creation
Part A Part A DaurDaur KehidupanKehidupan JurnalJurnal InternasionalInternasional 23
Part
Kiat-kiat Publikasi pada jurnal
berindeks Scopus
24
Komponen Keberhasilan Publikasi
Keterbaruan Daftar Pustaka
Kesesuaian aturan penulisan
Ketepatan memilih jurnal
Keterbaruan Topik
Keunikan Isi Tulisan
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Kenal dengan mitrabestari
Jumlah publikasi penulis
Penulis dari minimal 2 institusi
Kesesuaian isi dengan kategori
Kemampuan Bahasa Inggris
Keterbaruan Daftar Pustaka
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus25
Kiat-kiat Publikasi pada jurnal berindeks Scopus
Keunikan Tulisan
Keterbaruan Topik
Pemilihan Jurnal
Pengecekan keunikan pada situs plagiarisma.net
Keterbaruan referensi, gunakan ‘Mendeley’ Reference Manager
Topik berada pada top rate roadmap research environment
• Cek di scimagojr.com
• Jurnal masih aktif (cek ulang di researchgate.net)• Jurnal masih aktif (cek ulang di researchgate.net)
• Pilih jurnal atau proseding
• H-index sesuai (dibawah 10 lebih mudah lolos tapi
biaya lebih mahal, di atas 10 bisa gratis))
• Pastikan SJR
• Negara Penerbit India, Cina lebih cepat responnya
• Pastikan bukan predator
Sesuaikan dengan aturan penulisan
Mengkoreksi beyond revision dari mitrabestari
Koreksi , cek and recek
26
Kiat-kiat Publikasi pada jurnal berindeks Scopus
Isu pentingdalam
publikasi
Originalitas
Topik berada
KeunikanTulisan
Pengecekankeunikan pada
situsplagiarisma.net
Keterbaruan
PemilihanJurnal
Cek discimagojr.com
Jurnal masih aktif
(cek ulang diresearchgate.net)
Pastikan kategori
Koreksi , cek and recek
Sesuaikan denganaturan penulisan
Metoda Penelitianyang valid
Topik beradapada top rate
roadmap research
environment
Kolaborasipeneliti dankemitraan
Bebas fraud dankonflik
kepentingan
Keterbaruanreferensi, gunakan
‘Mendeley’ Reference Manager
Tidak ada ReferensiPalsu cek di
scholarlyoa.com
Pastikan kategorijurnal atauproseding
H-index sesuai(dibawah 10 lebih mudah
lolos tapibiaya lebih mahal, di atas
10 bisa gratis)
Pastikan SJR > 0,1
Negara Penerbit India, Cina lebihcepat responnya
Pastikan bukanpredator
Mengkoreksibeyond revision dari
mitrabestari
Gambar, tabel jelassumbernya
27
Pengecekan keunikan dan plagiat, tulisan sebelum
dipublikasi
• Free Plagiarism Software online:
– http://plagiarisma.net/
– http://www.duplichecker.com/
• Premium Plagiarism Software online:• Premium Plagiarism Software online:
– http://www.ithenticate.com/
• For Institution :
– Turnitin (http://turnitin.com)
– Unplag(https://unplag.com)
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus28
29
Alat Bantu keterbaruan referensi
• Mendeley
(https://www.elsevier.com/solutions/mendeley)
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus30
Easy way to find SCOPUS Journals
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus31
Mencari dan memilih jurnal yang terbaik
menggunakan www.scimagojr.com
H-index
Journal
H-index
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus32
How do you read that???
� Q1 indicates highest quality, while Q4 is the lowest.
� US & European countries tend to be more selective
� ASEAN based and African journals tend to LOOK for articles
(less-selective).
� Read Q1 articles and try to write for Q4 journals
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus33
If you want to see whether a journal is
Scopus-indexed or not, use JOURNAL SEARCH
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus34
Mencari Jurnal berdasarkan negara
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus35
Mencari Jurnal dari daftar Penerbit
• Elsevier
• IEEE
• Mencari dengan Harzing's Publish or Perish • Mencari dengan Harzing's Publish or Perish
Tool http://www.harzing.com/pop.htm
• Mencari di ISI Thomson Reuter
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus36
Indonesian International Journals?
• 1. ITB Journal of Engineering Science, ISSN: 19783051, Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB) http://journal.itb.ac.id/2. ITB Journal of Science, ISSN: 19783043, Institute for Research and Community Services, InstitutTeknologi Bandung http://journal.itb.ac.id/3. Indonesian Journal of Geography, ISSN: 00249521, Gadjah Mada University http://i-lib.ugm.ac.id/jurnal/tipe_jurnal.php?jrlrId=73
• 4. Bulletin of Chemical Reaction Engineering and Catalysis, ISSN: 19782993, UNDIP http://bcrec.undip.ac.id/5. Acta medical Indonesia ISSN: 01259326, Indonesian Society of Internal Medicine http://www.inaactamedica.org/http://www.inaactamedica.org/
• 6. Critical Care and Shock ISSN: 14107767, Indonesian Society of Critical Care Medicine http://www.criticalcareshock.org/issues7. Indonesian Quarterly, ISSN: 03042170, Centre for Strategic and International Studies http://www.csis.or.id/PublicationJournalDetail.php?id=18. Nutrition Bulletin, ISSN: 02169363, Persatuan Ahli Gizi IndonesiaNutrition Bulletin, ISSN: 02169363, Persatuan Ahli Gizi Indonesia9. Jurnal IJEEI (International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Informatics)dengan EIC Prof. Dr. Suwarno (Dekan FT ITB) sdh masuk SCOPUS juga pada tahun 2011 ini.
Thio, N. (2011). Daftar nama jurnal Indonesia yang bereputasi jurnal internasional, downloaded from http://www.kopertis12.or.id/2011/12/13/13047.html , Published 13 December 2011.
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus37
Contoh Proceeding Berindex Scopus
• Procedia Engineering, ISSN: 18777058,
H Index: 23
• Proceedings of the IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer Vision
and Pattern Recognition, H index: 150
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus38
Memastikan Reputasi Jurnal
Tiga alasan pengecekan reputasi jurnal
• Memastikan jurnal masih ada
• Memastikan reputasi jurnal
• Memastikan jurnal bukan dikelola oleh
‘predator’ � Jeffrey Beall‘predator’ � Jeffrey Beall
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus39
Jurnal yang sudah tidak ada lagi di
scopus
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus40
Memastikan reputasi jurnal melalui:
Daftar Ranking Jurnal Bereputasi
• http://www.scimagojr.com/
– Kalau sebelum 2013 ada sjr 0.1 � Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi
– Setelah 2014 ada sjr 0.1 � Jurnal Internasional saja
• Microsoft Academic Search
(http://academic.research.microsoft.com/)(http://academic.research.microsoft.com/)
• Thomson ISI Journal :
http://ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/cgi-
bin/jrnlst/jloptions.cgi?PC=master
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus41
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus42
Memastikan Jurnal bukan Jurnal
Predator melalui Daftar Jeffrey Beall• Predator Journal :
https://scholarlyoa.com/2016/01/05/bealls
-list-of-predatory-publishers-2016/
https://scholarlyoa.com/2017/01/03/bealls
-list-of-predatory-publishers-2017/
• Open Access Predator Publisher:
https://scholarlyoa.com/publishers/
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus43
Daftar Jurnal yang tidak bisa dijadikan
kenaikan pangkat dapat dilihat di:• Penilaian Angka Kredit DIKTI (http://pak.dikti.go.id/)
– Temuan Jurnal Internasional (1803 downloads)
(http://pak.dikti.go.id/portal?download=422)
– Investigasi Jurnal Man in India (1466 downloads)
(http://pak.dikti.go.id/portal?download=418)
• Penelusuran Rekam jejak Chief Editor melalui scimagojr.com ,
Thomson Reutor dan Beall’s DirectoryThomson Reutor dan Beall’s Directory
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus44
Contoh Temuan: International Journal
of Pharmacy and Technology (India)
• Ditemukan Fakta: • SJR 0.13 • Jumlah artikel tiap issue terbitan tidak konsistenContoh: Volume 8 issue 1, Maret tahun 2016 terbit 121 artikelVolume 8 issue 2, Juni tahun 2016 terbit 297 artikelVolume 8 issue 3, September tahun 2016 terbit 493 artikelVolume 8 issue 3, September tahun 2016 terbit 493 artikel
• Artikel yang diterbitkan isinya diluar cakupan bidang ilmu yang tertulis pada ‘subject area and category’
• Pada setiap Volume terbitan, bulan waktu penerbitan setiapissue terbitan tidak konsisten
• Termasuk dalam ‘predatory journal’: List of standalone journals.
Part B Part B PublikasiPublikasi padapada jurnaljurnal berindeksberindeks ScopusScopus45
Just for fan, generating Report Paper in 1 minute
• Scigen:
https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/archive/scigen/
46