How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The...

21
HOW TO PERFORM A PEER REVIEW An Academic presentation by Dr. Nancy Agens, Head, Technical Operations, Phdassistance Group www.phdassistance.com Email: [email protected] GIVE A STEP BY STEP PROCEDURE FOR NEW RESEARCHERS IN REVIEWING THE MANUSCRIPT

description

PhD Manuscript Pre-Submission Peer Review allows the students writing to clarify their ideas in the content. PhD peer reviewing services exists to validate academic work and helps to increases networking possibilities within research communities by improving the quality of published research. Making the writing process collaborative through peer review helps students to gain experience to learn from one side and to think carefully about the research writing. Peer review is the process that involves various aspects in the manuscript that deem the necessary element for publication. The PhD peer-review process ensures the manuscript is easy to comprehend, do not have any gaps. Manuscript Writing Help determines the reliability and validity of research findings. The reviewer should check for scientific merits its methods and research misconduct. PhD Assistance is a Best Academic Dissertation Writing Service & Consulting Support Company established in 2001. Learn More: https://bit.ly/3o3TrwG Contact Us: Website: https://www.phdassistance.com/ UK NO: +44–1143520021 India No: +91–4448137070 Email: [email protected]

Transcript of How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The...

Page 1: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

HOW TO PERFORM A PEER REVIEW

An Academic presentation byDr. Nancy Agens, Head, Technical Operations, PhdassistanceGroup  www.phdassistance.comEmail: [email protected]

GIVE A STEP BY STEP PROCEDURE FORNEW RESEARCHERS INREVIEWING THE MANUSCRIPT

Page 2: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

In-Brief

Introduction

Overview of the Report Format

First Read-Through

What are the considerations in the first read

Spotting potential major flaws

Outline

TODAY'S DISCUSSION

Concluding the first reading

Rejection after the first reading

To save time and review

Carry out the second review

Conclusion

Page 3: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

In-Brief

PhD Manuscript Pre-Submission Peer Review allows the students writing to clarify theirideas in the content. PhD peer reviewing services exists to validate academic work

and helps to increases networking possibilities within research communities byimproving the quality of published research. Making the writing process collaborativethrough peer review helps students to gain experience to learn from one side and to

think carefully about the research writing.

Page 4: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Peer review is the process that involves variousaspects in the manuscript that deem the necessaryelement for publication.

The PhD peer-review process ensures the manuscriptis easy to comprehend, do not have any gaps.

Manuscript Writing Help determines the reliability andvalidity of research findings.

The reviewer should check for scientific merits itsmethods and research misconduct.

Introduction

Page 5: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

The structuring of the report varies based on thejournal.

Some follow the informal structure, while othershave a formal approach.

PhD Manuscript Peer Review Process carried outbased on the journal submission guidelines and therequirements of the researchers.

Overviewof theReportFormat

Page 6: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Most of the journals do not provide strict criteria forsubmission.

In this case, you have a look at the other articlespublished in the journal to get an idea of structuring.

So, you should gain some knowledge aboutstructuring to rely on your evolving style or get helpfrom PhD Manuscript Peer Reviewing experts tohave a quality document.

InformalStructure

Page 7: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Other journals require a formal approach and followstrict submission guidelines.

It is an important stage when there is a presence ofsubmission guidelines because they will ask you toaddress a specific format to research questions.

You need to go on your own to check the submissionguidelines.

So when you want to submit your paper to the specificjournal, there are formal guidelines, and that directsthe structure of your review.

FormalStructure

Page 8: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

The first read-through is the skim read which will helpyou to form an initial impression of the paper and getthe sense of what is an eventual recommendation madein the paper that decides the acceptance or rejection.

Professional Pre-Submission Peer Review Help you towork with the rejected document and gain strength topaper for publication.

First Read-Through

Page 9: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Peer Review Service for Manuscripts check for thecentral question addressed in writing is relevant to thestudy and interesting.

Peer review of the thesis is to evaluate the topic noveltyand check for what it does add to the subject areacompared with other published material.

Check whether the conclusions consist of evidence andargument from standard articles and also check for therelevance.

Do this paper include tables, figures and to checkwhether they add significance to the paper.

What aretheConsiderat-ions in theFirst Read

Contd..

Page 10: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com
Page 11: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

It was all about spotting the major flaws thatdecrease the quality of the document.

Check for mistakes in the methodology part,which is the main part of the whole writing.

Check for the information gathered whether thisinformation provides enough knowledge to thereaders.

SpottingPotentialMajorFlaws

Contd..

Page 12: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Insufficient data

Statistically non-significant variants

Unclear data tables and structures

Data that disagree with your conclusion

Including data that adds arguments little weak

Manuscript Peer Review a Guide check if there is a presence of a critical flaw in themanuscript and help yo correct it on the early stage, flaws such as,

Page 13: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

After completing the initial reads, consider all thosemajor flaws you found.

Write a rough draft of paragraph you came toknown from evaluating the paper make the roughdraft as two paragraphs.

First summarises the research question, secondaddress the contribution of work.

It will be helpful if the journal has prescribed thereport format.

Concludingthe FirstReading

Contd..

Page 14: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

It helps to draft to compose your thoughts.

After reviewing the manuscript, you have to decide whether the manuscriptis seriously flawed or it is publishable.

Page 15: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

If you come to an opinion that the article hasserious flaws, make sure you read the wholecontent.

It is mandatory because you may find somepositive aspect that communicated withother authors.

That could help you with future submission.

Rejectionafter theFirstReading

Page 16: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

While writing does not rely on uninteresting comment onthe manuscript document.

Try to the group based on the requirement.

Check whether the line number text upon, this will helpyou define items again and also aids your review.

Do keep images, graph and tables in a clear view whilewriting itself. It will help you evaluate easily.

To SaveTime andReview

Page 17: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

One of the reasons for the rejection of the Manuscriptby the Journal is a language issue.

Not every submission is well written in the right format.

If the article is difficult to understand, you should workwith the document.

However, if the language is poor but the centralmessage is delivered well see if you can improve thedocument and fix the problem immediately.

Carry Outthe SecondReview

Contd..

1. Check the Language

Page 18: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Check whether the cited article is central to theauthor's argument.

It will help you to find errors from different areasthan before.

There is a need to check to reference for accuracy,adequacy and balance.

2. Go through Section by Section

Contd..

Page 19: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

If you are writing a formal report, remember to followthe guidelines.

It will always comprise of a range of questions followedby comments.

If you're following an informal report format, youcould structure your report in three sections: summary,major issues, minor issues.

3. How to Structure your Report

Page 20: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

PhD Manuscript Writing Peer review provides aprofessional experience for students writing.

Peer review is needed to minimize last-minutedrafting and to cut down common lower-levelwriting errors.

Conclusion

Page 21: How to Perform a Peer Review? Give a Step by Step Procedure for New Researchers in Reviewing The Manuscript - Phdassistance.com

Contact Us

+44-1143520021UNITED KINGDOM

INDIA+91-4448137070

[email protected]