Dody Firmanda 2012 - Pemanfaatan Evidence-based Medicine dalam mendukung Clinical Pathways, Padang...

7/30/2019 Dody Firmanda 2012 - Pemanfaatan Evidence-based Medicine dalam mendukung Clinical Pathways, Padang 23 N

1/41


2/41

3

^ècgacc}cg @qkm`gj`%dcz`m E`mkjkg` "@DE+ mcfce

E`gmpopgl Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z *

Mim{ AktecgmcO`}pc Oiek}` E`mko

TZP^ Ac}ec|c}k& Hcoct}c'

^`gmcbpfpcg

M`glcg }`tdk}g{c Pgmcgl Pgmcgl T`~pdfko Kgmig`zkc Gieit 4= ]cbpg 4>33 }`g}cgl

Dcmcg ^`g{`f`gllctc Hcekgcg Zizkcf "DH^Z+3' Z`zpck m`glcg cecgc} ~`tpgmcglcg

}`tz`dp} ~`tc}ptcg e`gl`gck ~`fcozcgccg D^HZ O`z`bc}cg bctpz }`fcb cmc ~cfkgl fcec

}cgllcf 40 Giqèd t 4>34 "3 }cbpg mctk mkpgmcglocgg{c+4

mcg zpmcb bctpz epfck

d`ti~`tczk ~cmc }cgllcf 3 Hcgpctk 4>3=:

z t}c pg}po D^HZ O z`bc}cg=

}kmco

mkz`f`gllctcocg fclk if`b Oè`g}`tkcg O`z`bc}cg0' ^`t}cg{ccg {cgl }kedpf cmcfcb

dclckecgc zkz}è D^HZ O`z`bc}cg }`tz`dp}9

Mcfce Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4; ]cbpg 4>>= }`g}cgl ^tco}ko O`mio}`tcg ~cmc ~czcf

=0 e`g`tcglocg }`g}cgl o`|chkdcg e`g{`f`gllctcocg o`gmcfk ep}p mcg o`gmcfk

dkc{c'1 ^cmc Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit == ]cbpg 4>3> }`g}cgl Tpecb Zcok} ~cmc ~czcf

:: e`g`tcglocg }`g}cgl itlcgkzczk tpecb zcok} {cgl àò}ka& àkzk`g& mcg copg}cd`f'>0 }`g}cgl ^`gl`fifccg O`pcglcg Dcmcg

Fc{cgcg Pepe mcg ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk Mcfce G`l`tk Gieit 13 ]cbpg 4>>< }`g}cgl

^`miecg ]ògkz ^`gl`fifccg O`pcglcg Dcmcg Fc{cgcg Pepe Mc`tcb ~cmc ~czcf 3 c{c}

3 e`g{`dp}ocg pg}po eèd`tkocg ~`fc{cgcg o`~cmc ecz{ctcoc} d`tp~c ~`g{`mkccg

*Mkzce~ckocg ~cmc \itozbi~ Cjctc Zèkgct Gczkigcf Ke~fè g}czk Kgmig`zkc Jcz dcz m

Ltip~ "KGC JDL+ mcfce e`gmpopgl ^`fcozcgccg Pgkq`tzcf Jiq`tcl` 4>3= mk Kgmig`zkcmkz`f`gllctcocg if`b Acopf}cz O`z`bc}cg Ecz{ctcoc} Pgkq`tzk}cz Cgmcfcz mk Bi}`f E`tjpt`& Hf'

^ptpz KQ& ^cmcgl& Zpec}`tc Dctc} 4:4= Giqèd`t 4>34'3 Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4= ]cbpg 4>33 }`g}cgl Dcmcg ^`g{`f`gllctc Hcekgcg Zizkcf4 Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gi'4= ]cbpg 4>33 ^czcf c{c} c': Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gi'4= ]cbpg 4>33 ^czcf 1> c{c} "3+'= Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gi'4= ]cbpg 4>33 ^czcf 0 c{c} "4+c'0 Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gi'4= ]cbpg 4>33 ^czcf 1> c{c} "4+c'1 Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4; ]cbpg 4>>= }`g}cgl ^tco}ko O`mio}`tcg< Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit == ]cbpg 4>3> }`g}cgl Tpecb Zcok}


3/41

4

dctcgl mcg)c}cp hczc {cgl mkhpcf }cg~c e`glp}cecocg e`gjctk o`pg}pglcg mcg mcfce

e`fcopocg o`lkc}cgg{c mkmczctocg ~cmc ~tkgzk~ àkzk`gzk mcg ~timpo}kqk}cz'2&;

Mcfce e`fcopocg `qcfpczk o`dkhcocg mcg zkz}è fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg "b`cf}bjct` z{z}è

cgm ~ifkjk z `qcfpc}kig+ cmc : otk}`tkc opgjk {cogk otk}`tkc àò}kak}cz& àkzk`gzk& mcg

o`d`tcmkfcg)òpk}k " aa`j}kq`g`zz& àakjk`gj{ cgm `spk}{+3>

{cgl e tp~cocg zpc}p

tcglockcg zkz}èc}ko mcfce zpc}p zkz}è' E`fcopocg zpc}p cgcfkzkz òigiek mcfce

~`fc{cgcg o`mio}`tcg ~tia`zk cmcfcb }kmco epmcb& e`glkglc} dcg{co aco}it {cgl bctpz

mk~ t}kedcglocg mctk d`tdclck mke`gzk }`teczpo jctc ~`gmòc}cg mctk h`gkz cgcfkzkz

òigiek {cgl cocg mklpgcocg& dc}czcg }`tekgifilk òigiek k}p z`gmktk e`gl`gckp}kfkxc}kig& ~timpj}kqk}{& d`g ak}& àakjk`gj{& àa j}kq`g`zz& qcfp` ait eig`{& o`dkhcocg

akzocf mcg }kgloc} kgafc}kig tc}` {cgl z`tkgl ocfk d`tpdcb' Mkzce~kgl o`}`tdc}czcg zped`t

mc{c mcg o`dkhcocg òigiek {cgl mk~`glctpbk ~ifk}kz& z`bkgllc }kmco hctcgl ,t`ziptj`z,

}`tz`dp} }`fcb mk~clp e`ghcmk ,akr`m,'33

Z`mcglocg mk zkzk mke`gzk fckg ~tia`zk k}p z`gmktk mk}pg}p} pg}po e`gkgloc}ocg ep}p

~`fc{cgcgg{c mcg o`~tia`zkcgg{c mcfce oitkmit `}kozizkidpmc{c z`t}c d`tdclck

~`tc}ptcg mcg ~`tpgmcglcg bpope'>='33 Aktecgmc M' C~fkoczk kg}`ltczk zkg`tlkz cg}ctc @qkm`gq`%dcz`m E`mkjkg`& @qkm`gj`%dcz`m B`cf}bjct` mcg

@qkm`gj`%dcz`m îfkj{ mcfce zc}p zkz}è ~`gkgloc}cg ep}p ~`fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg mcg o`mio}`tcg

"Jfkgkjcf Liq`tgcgj`+8 zpc}p }cg}cglcg ~tia`zk KMCK mk eczc e`gmc}cgl'KK'Jiz} @aa`j}kq`g`zz Cgcf{z`z

"J@C+ Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg E`mkz "ZÊ+ O`z`bc}cg Cgco KMCK Mkzce~ckocg ~cmc Cjctc ^`t}èpcg

^`tbke~pgcg Itlcgkzczk ^tia`zk m`glcg Mk}h`g [cg E`mko M`~o`z TK mk Dilit Z`~}èd`t 4>>0'

b}}~8))|||'zjtkdm'jie)mij)3424>0>=4C~fkoczkkg}`ltczkzkg`tlkz

@qkm`gq`dcz`mE`mkjkg`@qkm`gj`dcz`mB`cf}bjct`mcg@qkm`gj`dcz`mîfkj{mcfceJfkgkjcfLiq`


4/41

:

àkzk`gzk cfioc}ka "cffijc}kq`)zijk`}cf àakjk`gj{+ }`teczpo mkmcfceg{c dkmcgl ecto`} mcg

o`z`bc}cg'1&34

"]cd`f 3+

]cd`f 3' D`tdclck màkgkzk mce mke`gzk }kgloc} cgcfkzkz }`g}cgl àò}kak}cz& àk`gzk mcg

o`d`tcmkfcg)òpk}k'34

@qifpzk zkz}è fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg mk zctcgc o`z`bc}cg "tpecb zcok}+ z`jctc ~tkgzk~g{c

epfck mctk {cgl d`tjktkocg mikgl }bkglz jb`c~`t mcfce bcf kgk àakjk`gj{ ~cmc }cbpg

3;cg ~cmc |co}p otkzkz o`pcglcg mcg l`hifco I^@J& oèpmkcg òigiek epfck ~pfkb

mcg ecz{ctcoc} e`gpg}p} fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg d`tjktkocg mikgl }bkglz d`}}`t mcfce bcf

34 Aktecgmc M' ^`gl`gmcfkcg ep}p mcg àkzk`gzk ~èdkc{ccg fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg' Mkzce~ckocg mcfce

tcgloc `qcfpczk ^tiltce ^`fc{cgcg Czo`z ]`t~cmp Tpecb Zcok} "^^C]TZ+ mkz`f`gllctcocg if`b Ocg}it

^pzc} ^] Czo`z "^`tz ti+ mk Bi}`f ^cgitcec Dc}ce 3> M`zèd`t 4>>2'

b}}~8))|||'zjtkdm'jie)mij);2>>2>2^`gl`gmcfkcgEp}pMcg@akzk`gzkDkc{cTZ

3>M`zèd`t4>>2


5/41

=

kgk spcfk}{ ke~tiqè`g}' Z`fcec mpc mòcm` }`tz`dp} ecgchè`g d`tjitco mikgl }bkglz

tklb} "mko`gcf z`dclck kgjt`czkgl àa`j}kq`g`zz+ {cgl e`tp~cocg oiedkgczk mikgl

}bkglz jb`c~`t mcg mikgl }bkglz d`}}`t' ]`tg{c}c ~tkgzk~ mikgl }bkglz tklb} }kmco

eècmck e`glkop}k ~`toèdcglcg oèchpcg }ògifilk ecp~pg }pg}p}cg ecz{ctcoc}

{cgl zècokg otk}kz? mcg ~tkgzk~ ecgchè`g mikgl }bkglz tklb} }`tz`dp} }`fcb

o`}kgllcfcg xcecg mcg mkcgllc~ z`dclck ~tkgzk~ mcg jctc ecgchè`g opgi' ^cmc cdcm 43

kgk eczc `tc lfidcfkzczk mkdp}pbocg }kmco bcg{c mikgl }bkglz tklb}& cocg }`}c~k hplc

mk~`tfpocg ~tkgzk~ ecgchè`g mikgl }b` tklb} }bkglz z`bkgllc oiedkgczk o`mpcg{c

mkz`dp} z`dclck ~tkgzk~ ecgchè`g fc{cgcg eim`tg mikgl }b` tklb} }bkglz tklb}'3:

Zcfcb zc}p oie~ig`g fc}ct d`fcocgl mctk }phpcg mkfcopocgg{c zpc}p ~`g fk}kcg cmcfcb

t`f`qcgzk ~`g`fk}kcg }`tz`dp} }`tbcmc~ oèchpcg kfep ~`gl`}cbpcg& eèdpc} o`dkhcocg

"~ifkj{+ ofkgkz mcfce ~`gc}cfcozcgccg ~czk`g z`jctc kgmkqkmp c}cp~pg o`fie~io z`t}c

o`dkhcocg o`z`bc}cg z`jctc f`dkb fpcz mcfce zpc}p zkz}è }kgloc} kgz}k}pzk ~`g{`f`gllctc

o`z`bc}cg dcko }kgloc} tpecb zcok} "z}cgmctm ia ~tij`mpt`z+ ecp~pg gczkigcf

"lpkm`fkg`z+' Z`jctc tkglocz& c~cocb bczkf ~`g fk}kcg }`tz`dp} mc~c} e`glpdcb&

eè~`tdckok mcg e`gkgloc}ocg z}c}pz m`tchc} o`z`bc}cg& }kgloc} àkzk gzk mcg àò}kqk}cz

~ècgacc}cg zped`t mc{c z`jctc i~}kec 9

@qkm`gj`%dcz`m E`mkjkg`

@qkm`gj`%dcz`m E`mkjkg` "@DE+ mcg @qkm`gj`%dcz`m B`cf}b Jct` "@DBJ+ cmcfcb

jctc ~`gmòc}cg pg}po e`glcedkf o`~p}pzcg mcfce ~`gc}cfcozcgccg ~czk g "mcg c}cp

~`g{`f`gllctccg ~`fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg + z`jctc òz~fkzk} mcg zkz}èc}kz d`tmczctocg dpo}k

~`g`fk}kcg }`tcobkt {cgl zcbkm "qcfkm+ mcg d`tecgacc}'

Mcfce ~`gl`fifccg zpc}p zctcgc o`z`bc}cg "tpecb zcok} ecp~pg ofkgko+ zìtcgl ecgch`t

ecp~pg mio}`t cocg "dcbocg bctpz+ eèdpc} zpc}p o`~p}pzcg mcfce ~`g{`f`gllctccg

tpecb zcok})ofkgko }`tz`dp} ecp~pg mcfce ~`gc}cfcozcgccg ~czk`g z`dclck kgmkqkmp

3: Aktecgmc M' ^`tcg @aò}kak}cz Ofkgkz mcfce tcgloc e`|phpmocg o`z`fcec}cg)o`cecgcg "zca`}{+ mcg

d`titk`g}czk o`~cmc ~czk`g "~c}k`g} j`g}t`mg`zz+'Mkzce~ckocg ~cmc Biz~k}cf Ecgclè`g} : {cgl

mkz`f`gllctcocg if`b ^pzc} Ochkcg Cmekgkz}tczk mcg O`dkhcocg O`z`bc}cg AOE PK mk Ltcgm Cgloczc

Bi}`f Kg}`tgc}kigcf& E`mcg 33 Clpz}pz 4>>2' b}}~8))|||'zjtkdm'jie)mij);23:333)Mim{Aktecgmc4>>2

^`tcg@aò}kqk}czOfkgkzMcfce^C]B


6/41

0

ecp~pg o`fie~io' O`~p}pzcg }`tz`dp} cocg eè~pg{ck mce~co& }`tbcmc~ ~czk`g k}p

z`gmktk mcg fkglopglcgg{c "mcfce bcf kgk o`fpctlc& ecz{ctcoc} mcg ~`g{cgmcgl mcgc c}cp

czptcgzk+ z`t}c fkglopglcg mkecgc ~ fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg } tz`dp} mkd tkocg)

mkz`f`gllctcocg "mctk z`lk mke`gzk }è~c}8 ~ifkofkgko tc|c} hcfcg& tpcgl lc|c} mctptc}&

tc|c} kgc~& tpcgl ~`tc|c}cg kg}`gzka& tpcgl i~`tczk mcg fckg fckg? z`mcglocg mctk z`lk

mke`gzk apglzk8 cocg e`gll tcocg)p}kfkzczk epfck mctk t`lkz}tczk pgk} tòce e`mkz&

~`gpghcgl fcditc}itkpe& acteczk& dcgo mctcb& pgk} lkxk& fcpgmtk& ~`g{`mkccg ckt&

~`g`tcglcg fkz}tko mcg z`dclckg{c zce~ck ~tiz`z ~czk`g k}p ~pfcgl zèdpb mcg oèdcfk

oig}tif c}cp oèdcfk o`~cmc ~`tphpo czcf c}cp o`fpct tpecb zcok} e`fcfpk ocect h`gcxcb+

mcg ~`g{`f`zckcg cmekgkz}tczk o`pcglcg' Kgk cmcfcb zc}p ~tiz`z mcfce zc}p zkz}è zctcgc~`fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg {cgl d`tfcglzpgl z`jctc zkepf}cg mcg d`tptp}cg c}cz oigzòp`gzk

o`~p}pzcg mkc}cz' Dkc{c c}cp mcgc pg}po }`gclc e`mkz "mio}`t+ bcg{c zòk}ct 4>% mctk

z`fptpb cgllctcg {cgl mko`fpctocg if`b zc}p zctcgc ~`g{`f`gllctc o`z`bc}cg "tpecb

zcok}+& z`mcglocg 2>% fckgg{c zcglc} d`tbpdpglcg m`glcg o`~p}pzcg mio}`t }`tz`dp}'

Z`dclckecgc mkz`dp}ocg mkc}cz dcb|c ~`glcedkfcg o`~p}pzcg zcglc} ~`g}kgl mcg

z`jctc fcglzpgl cocg eè~`glctpbk zkz}è ~`g{`f`gllctccg zctcgc o`z`bc}cg ecp~pg

~`gc}cfcozcgccg ~czk`g z`jctc kgmkqkmp ecp~pg o`fie~io' Cmc~pg ~`glcedkfcg

o`~p}pzcg cocg mk~`glctpbk if`b d`tdclck aco}it "Lcedct 3+'

Lcedct 3' Aco}it {cgl eè~`glctpbk ~`glcedkfcg o`~p}pzcg

D@qkm`gj` Qcfp`z

T`ziptj`z


7/41

1

O`zcfcbcg mkcokdc}ocg if`b aco}it ecgpzkc bcg{c zòk}ct 3>4>%& z`f`dkbg{c "2>%+

mkoct`gcocg if`b zkz}è& o`dkhcocg "~ifkj{+ mcg ~tiz`mpt {cgl }kmco h`fcz z`t}c }kmco

oigzkz} g' If b oct gc k}p mcfce p~c{c e`gjc~ck bczkf {cgl i~}kec mcfce

~`g{`f`gllctccg ~`fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg }`tbcmc~ ~czk`g dcko z`jctc kgmkqkmp ecp~pg

o`fie~io z`t}c àkzk`g mcg d`tcxcz ecgacc}& ecoc mk~ tfpocg zpc}p o`~p}pzcg {cgl

dcko mcg }`~c} mkmcfce zkz}è {cgl h`fcz mcg oigzkz}`g' Bcf kgk cocg }`t|phpm dkfc

eè~pg{ck hk|c o`~èke~kgcg "f`cm`tzbk~+ {cgl qkzkig`t& zptqkqcfkz} mcg oigzòp`g'

Zkz}è k}p z`gmktk }`tmktk mctk }klc oie~ig`g {cogk z}tpo}pt& ~tiz`z mcg bczkf "ip}jie`+

{cgl zcec ~`g}kglg{c z`t}c zcfkgl d`tbpdpglcg mcg zcfkgl eè~`glctpbk'

E`glbcmc~k `tc lfidcfkzczk kgk& mcfce dkmcgl o`mio}`tcg)o`z`bc}cg eè`tfpocg mio}`t

{cgl eè~pg{ck z`fckg z~ zkcfkzczk)zpd z~`zkcfkzczk o`cbfkcg hplc e`glpczck cocg

e`mkjcf ecgclè`g}& e`mkjcf `~kmèkifil{ mcg e`mkjcf dki`glkg``tkgl "}`teczpo

}ògifilk o`mio} tcg)o`z`bc}cg+' [cgl ecgc o }klc dkmcgl } tz`dp} gcg}kg{c cocg

d`tepctc z`dclck zcfcb zc}p kgmkoc}it bczkf)ip}jie` mctk ep}p ~`fc{cgcg mcg c}cp

~`gmkmkocg o`z`bc}cg)o`mio}`tcg {cgl dcko mcg oigzkz}`g' If`b oct`gc k}p& cfcglocb

dckog{c dkfc mcfce optkopfpe ^`gmkmkocg O`mio}`tcg Pepe mcg Z~`zkcfkz ~cmc }cbc~

~`glc{ccg mk~`to`gcfocg cocg o`}klc dkmcgl mkc}cz z`dclck dczkj `zz`g}kcf `fè`g}z

mcg mk~`tmcfce fclk ~cmc zcc} }cbc~ oie~t`b`gzka cobkt z`d`fpe z`f`zck e`ghcmk mio}`t

pepe ecp~pg mio}`t z~`zkcfkz mcfce tcgloc cg}kzk~czk mcg pg}po eè~`tzkc~ocg mio}`t

~ctk~ptgc mcg bcgmcf& eè~pg{ck |c|czcg f`cm`tzbk~ {cgl dcko z`t}c mkbctc~ocg

gcg}kg{c cocg ece~p eèdpc} o`~p}pzcg {cgl }`~c} }c}ocfc e`glbcmc~k }cg}cglcg

lfidcfkzczk mcg }òcgcg epf}k%gc}kigcf jie~cg{ mk eczc e`gmc}cgl' Dpocgocb

z`dclckecgc mkp}ctcocg mkc}cz& e`zok~pg mio}`t bcg{c eè~pg{ck cgmkf 4>%& cocg

}`}c~k o`~p}pzcg {cgl cocg mkcedkf mio}`t }`tz`dp} cocg eè~`glctpbk 2>% fckgg{c'

E`zok~pg ~`fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg zcglc} d`tqctkczk mctk mcg mcfce zc}p g`lctc& ~ti~kgzk

ecp~pg mc`tcb mk g`lctc echp)kgmpz}tk ecp~pg mpgkc o`}klc' Cocg }`}c~k jktk mcg zkac}

eczcfcb }`tz`dp} }kmco hcpb d`td`mc zc}p zcec fckgg{c mcfce bcf {cgl e`gmczct {cogk

zècokg e`gkgloc}g{c hpefcb ~i~pfczk pzkc fcghp} "~`tpdcbcg mèiltcak+& }pg}p}cg mcg


8/41

3>


11/41

3>

Lcedct 4' Tkgloczcg ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit 3:=2)E@GO@Z)^@T)KR)4>3> }`g}cgl Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg ^GÔ& ZÎ mcg ^Ô'

^tiz`z z`fcghp}g{c z`}`fcb e`g{pzpg ^cgmpcg ^tco}ko Ofkgkz "^Ô+ Tpecb Zcok} cmcfcb

eèdpc} Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`dclck zcfcb zc}p oie~ig`g mctk Zkz}è Jczèkr "KGC

JDL+ {cgl zcc} kgk mk~`tlpgcocg pg}po Hcekgcg ^è`fkbctccg O`z`bc}cg "Hceo`zecz+

mk tpecb zcok} ecoc KGC JDL cocg f`dkb mkzè~ptgcocg m`glcg e`glbk}pgl MTL

T`fc}kq` \`klb} mcg Jczèkr Kgm`r z`t}c Dcz` Tc}` z`}kc~ ~`gl fie~ioocg h`gkz

~`g{cok} mcg z`fcghp}g{c mc~c} eèdcgmkglocg "d`gjbectokgl+ jiz} àakjk`gj{ cg}ct

tpecb zcok} mcfce eèd`tkocg fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg d`tmczctocg o`cmccg z`d`gctg{c

mkd`tkocg e`fcfpk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z'


12/41

33

Zkz}è Jczèkr cmcfcb zpc}p jctc e`gl`fifc zped`t mc{c tpecb zcok} z`àò}ka epglokg

mcfce eèd`tkocg fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg {cgl }`thcglocp o`~cmc ecz{ctcoc} d`tmczctocg

~`gl`fie~ioocg z~ò}tpe mkclgizkz ~`g{cok} {cgl bieil`g mcg ~tiz`mpt }kgmcocg

{cgl mkd`tkocg z`jctc tkgloczg{c }`tmktk mctk : oie~ig`g p}cec {cogk oimàkoczk

mkclgizkz "KJM 3>+ mcg ~tiz`mpt }kgmcocg "KJM ; JE+& ~èdkc{ccg "jiz}kgl+ {cgl mc~c}

d`tp~c }i~%mi|g c~~ticjb& cj}kqk}{ dcz`m jiz}kgl mcg c}cp oiedkgczk o`mpcg{c& mcg

e`fcfpk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z'30&31&3 pg}po mkclgizkz mcg KJM ; JE pg}po ~tiz`mpt }kgmcocg z`t}c dkc{c d`tmczctocg

}ctka {cgl d`tfcop ~cmc |co}p }`tz`dp}' P~c{c }`tz`dp} eècgl d`fpe zè~ptgc mcg

d`fpe e`gj`tekgocg t`cfk}cz o`cmccg z`fptpb ~`fizio }cgcb ckt gcepg z`dclck }k}ko

}igllco c|cf& bcf }`tz`dp} e`tp~cocg zpc}p o`d`tbczkfcg mcfce eèdpc} zpc}p zkz}è

~èdkc{ccg fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg tpecb zcok} mcg pzcbc dcko e`gphp o`~cz}kcg mcg mc~c}

mk~`tdckok z`t}c mk}kgloc}ocg opcfk}cz ecp~pg qcfkmk}cz mc}cg{c {cgl t`~t`z`g}c}ka pg}po

Kgmig`zkc' Z`dclck zkz}è {cgl dctp fcbkt KGCMTL cocg }`tpz d`tlpfkt mcg d`toèdcgl

z`zpck }pg}p}cg ~`toèdcglcg fc{cgcg o`z`bc}cg dcko gczkigcf ecp~pg t`lkigcf'4>

M`glcg d`tcobktg{c fkz gzk ltip~ t KGCMTL }`tbk}pgl }cgllcf :> Z`~} ed`t 4>3>&

ecoc gcec zk}è Jczèkr KGCMTL d`tpdcb e`ghcmk KGCJDL43

'

30 Lifmecg F' Jiz}@aa`j}kq`g`zz kg c afc} |itfm Jcg KJMz b`f~ }b` Pgk}`m Z}c}`z l`} tb{}be9 G @glf

H E`m4>>0?:0:"3= +8303:0'31 Mcgc D Epoce` MD& X|cgxkl`t H& Dce`xck C' Biz~k}cf jie~`}k}kig& t`ziptj` cffijc}kig cgm

spcfk}{ ia jct`' DEJ B`cf}b Z`tqkj`z T`z`ctjb 4>>4? 4"3>+8 3=>='3; Jczèkr Pgk} M`~ct}e`g} ia B`cf}b cgm Jbkfmt`g' Jczèkr E`czptè`g} kg Ktkzb Biz~k}cfz'

Kt`fcgm M`~ct}e`g} ia B`cf}b& 4>>0'4> Aktecgmc M' Cgcfkzkz ^èdc{ctcg o`~cmc ^èd`tk Fc{cgcg O`z`bc}cg "^Ô+ e`gllpgcocg KGCJDL

e`gmòc}k bctc~cg zèpc ~kbco z`zpck Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z' Mkzce~ckocg ~cmc \itozbi~ Ke~fè`g}czk

KGCJDL ^`tj`~c}cg ]tcgzaiteczk mk Tpecb Zcok} Mc`tcb "TZM+ mkz`f`gllctcocg if`b Czizkczk

Tpecb Zcok} Mc`tcb Z`fptpb Kgmig`zkc "CTZCMC+ Hc|c Dctc} mk Bi}`f Cz}ig ]ti~kjcgc Dcgmpgl& 4:

Hpgk 4>33'43 Zptc} @mctcg Mktò}pt H`gm`tcf Dkgc ^`fc{cgcg E`mko Oè`g}`tkcg O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit KT'>:'>3)

K)0 ]cgllcf 32 Io}id`t 4>3>'


13/41

34

^4HO Oè`g}`tkcg O`z`bc}cg TK } fcb e`glcmcocg ~`t} epcg m`glcg z fptpb

~`tbke~pgcg ~tia`zk mcg oif`lkpe mk M`g~czct Dcfk ~cmc }cgllcf 4: Giqèd`t 4>>; mcg

e`glbczkfocg o`~p}pzcg z`dclck d`tkop}8

3' O`z`~coc}cg mcg oiek}e`g d`tzcec z`fptpb ~`tbke~pgcg ~tia zk mcg Oif`lkpe

z`}kc~ ~`tbke~pgcg ~tia`zk eèdpc} 3> ~`g{cok} }`tdcg{co Z}cgmct)^`miecg

^`fc{cgcg E`mkz "Z)^Ê+ mcg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z pg}po e`f`gloc~k KGCMTL

mcfce ^tiltce Hcekgcg O`z`bc}cg'

4' ^ t}èpcg z fcghp}g{c }cgllcf 44 Hcgpctk 4>3> mkz`f`gllctcocg if`b ^pzc}

^èdkc{ccg mcg Hcekgcg O`z`bc}cg "^4HO+ Zòt`}ctkc} H`gm`tcf M`~o`z TK eèdcbcz z`fptpb ZÊ mcg J^'

T`gjcgc ~`t}èpcg fcghp}cg }cgllcf 44 Hcgpctk 4>3> mkpgmpt mcg }`t`cfkzczk ~cmc }cgllcf

3> mk Dc}ce m`glcg ~èdcbczcg oèdcfk e`gl gck Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg

O`mio} tcg z`}kc~ ~`tbke~pgcg ~tia`zk' Mctk ~`t}èpcg mkbctc~ocg mkbczkfocg zpc}p

Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg }kgloc} gczkigcf {cgl mkz`dp} ^cgmpcg Gczkigcf ^tco}ko

O`mio} tcg "^GÔ+ z`dclckecgc {cgl mkbctc~ocg mctk ^`tc}ptcg E`g} tk O`z bc}cg

Gieit 3=:2)E@GO@Z)^@T)KR)4>3> }`g}cgl Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg {cgl cocg

e`ghcmk cjpcg ~tia`zk mk tpecb zcok} pg}po eèdpc} ^cgmpcg ^tco}ko Ofkgkz "^Ô+

eczkgl eczkgl'

Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg44

cmcfcb ~`miecg {cgl bctpz mkkop}k if`b mio}`t mcfce

e`g{`f`gllctcocg ~tco}ko o`mio} tcg4: mcg zcfcb zc}p }kgmco fcghp} mctk ~`tpgmcglcg

{cgl }`fcb mk}`tdk}ocg `gce }cbpg {cgl fcfp'4=

Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg }`tmktk

mctk ^`miecg Gczkigcf ^ fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg "^GÔ+ mcg Z}cgmct ^tiz`mptcf

I~`tczkigcf "ZÎ+'40

44 ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit 3=:2)KR)4>3> }`g}cgl Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg'

b}}~8))|||'zjtkdm'jie)mij)=:>3>^`te`go`zGi3=:2E@GO@Z^@TKR

4>3>Z}cgmct^`fc{cgcgO`mio}`tcg4: ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit 3=:2)KR)4>3> }`g}cgl Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg

^czcf 3 c{c} 3'4= Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4; ]cbpg 4>>= ^czcf == c{c} :'40 ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit 3=:2)KR)4>3> }`g}cgl Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg

^czcf : c{c} 3'


14/41

3:

^`tcg Oiek}` E`mko cmcfcb e`gloitmkgczkocg ~`g{pzpgcg ^cgmpcg ^tco}ko Ofkgkz

"^Ô+ {cgl mkdpc} if`b "o`fie~io+ z}ca e`mkz41

mcg e`glcjp o`~cmc ^`miecg Gczkigcf

^`fc{cgcg O`mio}`tcg "^GÔ+ {cgl mkdpc} if`b itlcgkzczk ~tia`zk4>0&TZP^ Bczcg Zcmkokg Dcgmpgl 4: M`zèd`t 4>>0 mcg @qcfpczk ^`g{pzpgcg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mcfce

tcgloc ~`g{è~ptgccg ^`miecg MTLz Jczèkr M`~o`z TK& Bi}`f Ltcgm Jè~coc Hcoct}c 4;

M`zèd`t 4>>0':< Aktecgmc M& ^tc}k|k Cgmc{cgk& Gptckgk Ktec Zpzcg}k& Ztk` @gllct OM moo' Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

O`z`bc}cg Cgco mcfce tcgloc ke~fè`g}czk Zkz}è MTLz Jczèkr mk TZ Ac}ec|c}k& Hcoct}c 4>>1'


20/41

3;

Lcedct =' Jig}ib bczkf ~`g`fk}kcg ke~f`e`g}czk zcfcb zc}p Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z pg}po oczpz ~g`peigkc


21/41

4>

Lcedct 0' Jig}ib cgcfkzkz bczkf ke~f`e`g}czk zcfcb zc}p Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z ~cmc

}cbpg 4>>1 pg}po oczpz ~g`peigkc


22/41

43

]`g}cgl jctc fcglocb fcglocb ~`tbk}pglcg jiz} |`klb}& jcz`ekr kgm`r& dcz` tc}`

tpecb zcok} mcg cfioczk cgllctcg mc~c} mkfkbc} mcfce Lcedct 1 d`tkop}'

Lcedct 1' Jig}ib ~`tbk}pglcg d`tmczctocg mc}c bczkf ke~f`e`g}czk Jfkgkjcf

^c}b|c{z mcfce e`gjctk T`fc}kq` \`klb} "jiz} |`klb}+& Jcz` Ekr Kgm`r mcg Dcz`

Tc}`'


23/41

44

Clct }kmco }pe~cgl }kgmkb z`t}c zkg`tlkz m`glcg o`g{c}ccg mk fc~cglcg "tpecb

zcok}+& ecoc ke~fè`g}czk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`dckog{c }`t~cmp m`glcg }c}co fifc

oit~itczk "jit~itc}` liq`tgcgj`+ mcg }c}co fifc ofkgkz "jfkgkjcf liq`tgcgj`+ {cgl

}`fcb d`tfcop z`zpck ekzk tpecb zcok} mcfce dkmcgl ~`fc{cgcg& ~`gmkmkocg mcg

~`g`fk}kcg'

]`tf`~cz mctk o`gmcfc ~`gllpgccg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`dclck ~`f`gloc~ KGC

JDL? ke~fè`g}czk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z zcglc} d`tecgacc} dclk ~tia`zk mcfce

eèd`tkocg ~`fc{cgcg& ~`gmkmkocg ecp~pg ~`g`fk}kcg mk tpecb zcok}

z`dclckecgc mc~c} mkfkbc} mcfce Lcedct < zce~ck ; d`tkop}'


24/41

4:

Lcedct


25/41

4=

Lcedct 2' Ke~f`e`g}czk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z pg}po ~`g`fk}kcg mk tpecb zcok}'


26/41

40

Lcedct ;' Ke~f`e`g}czk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mkock}cg m`glcg cz`ze`g ~`gkfckcgpg}po ~`z`t}c mkmko ecbczkz|c mcg ~`z`t}c ~tiltce mio}`t z~`zkcfkz mk tpecb zcok}ecp~pg tpecb zcok} h`hctkgl ~`gmkmkocg'


27/41

41

Oigz`~' oigz}tpozk ecp~pg eim`f ke~fè`g}czk Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`jctc }kmco

fcglzpgl z`dclckecgc mkp}ctcocg mkc}cz dcb|c8

Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`dclck kgz}tpe`g ~`fc{cgcg d`taiopz o`~cmc ~czk`g

"~c}k`g}%aijpz`m jct`+& }`tkg}`ltczk& d`to`zkgcedpglcg mctk ~czk`g

eczpo mktc|c} zce~ck ~pfcgl zèdpb "jig}kgpipz jct`+& h`fcz cocg

mio}`t)~`tc|c} ~`gcgllpgl hc|cd ~czk`g "M^H^)^^H + z`dclck mp}{ ia

jct`& p}kfk}cz ~è`tkozccg ~`gpghcgl& ~`gllpgccg idc} idc}cg }`teczpo

cg}kdki}koc& ~tiz`mpt }kgmcocg i~`tczk& cg}kzk~czk oèpglokgcg }`thcmkg{c

e`mkjcf `ttitz "fc}`g mcg co}ka& g{ctkz } thcmk ecp~pg o`hcmkcg }kmco

mkbctc~ocg)O]M+ mcg ~`gj`lcbcg oèpglokgcg j`m`tc "bctez+ z`t}c

kga ozk gizioiekcf mcfce tcgloc o`z`fcec}cg ~czk`g "~c}k g} zca`}{+&

e`gm }òzk mkgk }k}ko }k}ko ~i} gzkcf d`tkzkoi z fcec ~tiz z fc{cgcg

~`tc|c}cg ~czk`g "}tcj`tz e`}bimifil{+ mcfce tcgloc ecgchè`g tkzkoi

"tkzoz ecgclè`g}+& t`gjcgc ~èpfcglcg ~czk`g "~c}k g} mkzjbctl`+ &

p~c{c ~`gkgloc}cg ep}p fc{cgcg d`to`zkgcedpglcg "jig}kgpipz spcfk}{

ke~tiqè`g}+ dcko m`glcg ~`gmòc}cg }`bgko ]IJ "]bìt{ ia Jigz}tckg}z+

pg}po zkz}è ecp~pg kgmkqkmp ~tia`zk& ~`gpfpzptcg okg`thc "~`taitecgj`+

kgmkqkmp ~tia`zk ecp~pg o`fie~io"}`ce%|ito+'

E`tp~cocg zpc}p tcglockcg zkz}è {cgl mc~c} mk~`tlpgcocg z`dclck kgz}tpe`g

pg}po eè`gpbk ~`tz{ctc}cg ~`gkfckcg Cot`mk}czk mctk Oiek}` Cot`mk}czk Tpecb

Zcok} "OCTZ+ q`tzk dctp ecp~pg mctk Hikg} Jieekzzkig Kg}`tgc}kigcf ait

Biz~k}cf "HJK+ q`tzk 4>33 pg}po z}cgmct z}cgmct mcfce Z`j}kig K' ^c}k`g} J`g}`t`m

Z}cgmctm ecp~pg mcfce Z`j}kig KK' B`cf}bjct` Itlcgkxc}kig Ecgclè`g}Z}cgmctmz`dclckecgc kfpz}tczk Lcedct 3> zce~ck 34 d`tkop}'


28/41

4' Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mcg q`tzk HJK 4>33 Cjjt`mk}c}kig Z}cgmctmz


29/41

42

Lcedct 33' Zkz}`ec}koc mcfce q`tzk HJK 4>33 Biz~k}cf Z}cgmctmz mcg^`gkfckcgg{c

Gi}

E`}


30/41

4;

Lcedct 34' Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mcg }`bgko ]tcj`t E`}bimifil{ {cgl mklpgcocg

if`b zptq`kit mcfce tcgloc Cot`mk}czk q`tzk HJK 4>33


31/41

:>

^tkgzk~ ~tkgzk~ mcfce e`g{pzpg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z "J + cmcfcb zpc}p oigz`~ ~`t`gjcgccg ~`fc{cgcg }`t~cmp

{cgl e`tcglope z`}kc~ fcglocb {cgl mkd`tkocg o`~cmc ~czk`g d`tmczctocg

z}cgmct ~`fc{cgcg e`mkz mcg czpbcg o`~`tc|c}cg {cgl d`tdczkz dpo}k m`glcg

bczkf {cgl }`tpopt mcg mcfce hcgloc |co}p }`t}`g}p z`fcec mk tpecb zcok}':2&:;&=>

Mcfce eèdpc} Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z ~`gcglcgcg oczpz ~czk`g tc|c} kgc~ mk tpecb

zcok} bctpz d`tzkac}8

c' Z`fptpb o`lkc}cg ~`fc{cgcg {cgl mkd`tkocg bctpz z`jctc }`t~cmp)kg}`ltczk

mcg d`titk`g}czk aiopz }`tbcmc~ ~czk`g "^c}k`g} Aijpz`m Jct`+ z`t}c

d`to`zkgcedpglcg "jig}kgpipz ia jct`+

d' E`fkdc}ocg z`fptpb ~tia`zk "mio}`t& ~`tc|c})dkmcg& ~`gc}c& fcditc}itkz mcg

acteczkz+

j' Mcfce dc}czcg |co}p {cgl } fcb mk}`g}pocg z zpck m`glcg o`cmccg

~`thcfcgcg ~`g{cok} ~czk`g mcg mkjc}c} mcfce d`g}po ~`tkim` bctkcg "pg}po

oczpz tc|c} kgc~+ c}cp hce "pg}po oczpz lc|c} mctptc} mk pgk} è`tl`gzk+'

m' ^`gjc}c}cg J^ z`fptpb o`lkc}cg ~`fc{cgcg {cgl mkd`tkocg o`~cmc ~czk`g

z`jctc }`t~cmp mcg d`to`zkgcedpglcg }`tz`dp} mcfce d`g}po miope`g

{cgl e`tp~cocg dclkcg mctk Tòce E`mkz'

`' Z`}kc~ ~`g{ke~cglcg fcglocb mcfce ~`g`tc~cg J^ mkjc}c} z`dclck qctkcgz

mcg mkfcopocg ochkcg cgcfkzkz mcfce d`g}po cpmk}'

a' Qctkcgz }`tz`dp} mc~c} oct`gc oigmkzk ~`thcfcgcg ~`g{cok}& ~`g{cok}

~`g{`t}c c}cp oie~fkoczk ecp~pg o`zcfcbcg e`mkz "e`mkjcf `ttitz+'

:2 Aktecgmc M' ^`miecg ^`g{pzpgcg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mcfce tcgloc ke~fè`g}czk Zkz}è MTLz

Jczèkr mk tpecb zcok}' Mkzce~ckocg mcfce Zkmcgl ^f`gi Oiek}` E`mko TZ Ac}ec|c}k& Hcoct}c

< Io}id`t 4>>0':; Aktecgmc M' Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z8 ^`tcg ~tia`zk e`mkz mcfce tcgloc e`g{pzpg Zkz}è MTLz

Jczèkr mk tpecb zcok}' Mkzce~cocg ~cmc opghpglcg fc~cglcg o` TZP^ Cmce Ecfko E`mcg

44 M`zèd`t 4>>0& TZP^ Bczcg Zcmkokg Dcgmpgl 4: M`zèd`t 4>>0 mcg @qcfpczk ^`g{pzpgcg

Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mcfce tcgloc ~`g{è~ptgccg ^`miecg MTLz Jczèkr M`~o`z TK& Bi}`f

Ltcgm Jè~coc Hcoct}c 4; M`zèd`t 4>>0'=> Aktecgmc M& ^tc}k|k Cgmc{cgk& Gptckgk Ktec Zpzcg}k& Ztk` @gllct OM moo' Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

O`z`bc}cg Cgco mcfce tcgloc ke~fè`g}czk Zkz}è MTLz Jczèkr mk TZ Ac}ec|c}k& Hcoct}c

4>>1'


32/41

:3

l' Qctkcgz }`tz`dp} mk~`tlpgcocg z dclck zcfcb zc}p ~ctce`}`t mcfce tcgloc

eè~`t}cbcgocg mcg e`gkgloc}ocg ep}p ~`fc{cgcg'

Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z }`tz`dp} mc~c} e`tp~cocg zpc}p Z}cgmct ^tiz`mpt I~`tczkigcf

{cgl e`tcglope8

c' ^tia`zk e`mkz8 Z}cgmct ^ fc{cgcg E`mkz mctk z }kc~ O fie~io Z}ca

E`mkz)Z}ca E`mkz Apglzkigcf "ZEA+ ofkgkz mcg ~`gpghcgl'

d' ^tia`zk o`~`tc|c}cg8 Czpbcg O`~`tc|c}cg

j' ^tia`zk acteczk8 Pgk} Miz` Mckf{ mcg Z}i~ Itm`tkgl

m' Cfpt ^`fc{cgcg ^czk`g Tc|c} Kgc~ mcg I~`tczk mctk Zkz}è O`fie~io Z}ca

E`mkz)Z}ca E`mkz Apglzkigcf "ZEA+& Kgz}cfczk mcg Zkz}è Ecgchè`g

Tpecb Zcok}'

Fcglocb fcglocb ~`g{pzpgcg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

Fcglocb fcglocb mcfce e`g{pzpg Aitec} Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z {cgl bctpz

mk~`tbc}kocg8

3' Oie~ig`g {cgl bctpz mkjcop~ z`dclckecgc màkgkzk mctk Jfkgkjcf

^c}b|c{z

4' Ecgacc}ocg mc}c {cgl }`fcb cmc mk fc~cglcg tpecb zcok} mcg oigmkzk

z`}è~c}=3

z`~`t}k mc}c Fc~itcg TF4 "Mc}c O`cmccg Eitdkmk}cz ^czk`g+

{cgl mkdpc} z`}kc~ tpecb zcok} d`tmczctocg Dpop ^`}pghpo ^`glkzkcg&

^`glifcbcg mcg ^`g{chkcg Mc}c Tpecb Zcok}=4

mcg z`gzpz bctkcg pg}po8

c' ^`g`}c~cg hpmpf)}i~koJfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z {cgl cocg mkdpc}'

d' ^`g`}c~cg fcec bctk tc|c}'

=3 Aktecgmc M' Oimàkoczk KJM 3> mcg KJM ; JE8 kgmkoc}it ep}p tòce e`mko mcfce tcgloc

e`gkgloc}ocg ep}p ~`fc{cgcg tpecb zcok}' Mkzce~ckocg ~cmc Zizkcfkzczk îfc Zkz}è

Kgaiteczk

Ecgchè`g Tpecb Zcok}' Mkz f`gllctcocg if`b Mktò}itc} H`gm tcf Dkgc ^`fc{cgcg E`mko

M`~o`z TK

mk Bi}`f ^cglb`lct Dcgmpgl 3%: Hpgk 4>>1'=4 M`~ct}è`g O`z`bc}cg TK' Dpop ^`}pghpo ^`glkzkcg& ^`glifcbcg mcg ^`g{chkcg Mc}c Tpecb

Zcok}' Mktò}itc} H`gm`tcf Dkgc ^`fc{cgcg E`mko M`~o`z TK& Hcoct}c 4>>0'


33/41

:4

:' Pg}po qctkcd`f }kgmcocg mcg idc} idc}cg e`glcjp o`~cmc Z}cgmct

^ fc{cgcg E`mkz& Z}cgmct ^tiz`mpt I~`tczkigcf mcg Mca}ct Z}cgmct

Aitepfctkpe {cgl }`fcb cmc mk tpecb zcok} z`}è~c}& Dkfc ~`tfp z}cgmct

z}cgmct }`tz`dp} mc~c} mkfcopocg t`qkzk z`zpck o`z`~coc}cg z`}è~c}'

=' ^`tlpgcocg Dpop KJM 3> pg}po bcf oimàkoczk mkclgizkz mcg KJM ; JE

pg}po bcf }kgmcocg ~tiz`mpt z`zpck m`glcg ~tia`zk)ZEA eczkgl eczkgl'41

^`tzkc~cg mcfce ~`g{pzpgcg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

Clct mcfce e`g{pzpg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z }`tctcb mcg e`gjc~ck zczctcg z`t}c

àkzk`g |co}p& ecoc mk~`tfpocg o`thczcec mcg oiitmkgczk cg}ct ~tia`zk mk ZEA&

Kgz}cfczk Tc|c} Kgc~ "epfck mctk lc|c} mctptc}& tpcglcg tc|c} kgc~& tpcglcg

}kgmcocg& kgz}cfczk d`mcb& KJP)^KJP)GKJP+ mcg zctcgc ~`gpghcgl "kgz}cfczk lkxk&

acteczk& tòce e`mko& copg}czk o`pcglcg& tcmkifilk mcg z`dclckg{c+'

3' ^tia`zk E`mkz eè~`tzkc~ocg Z}cgmct ^`fc{cgcg E`mkz c}cp ^cgmpcg

^tco}ko Ofkgkz mcg z}cgmct ~tiz`mpt i~`tczkigcf "ZÊ)^Ô)ZÎ+ z`zpck

m`glcg dkmcgl o`cbfkcgg{c' ^tia`zk E`mkz mctk z`}kc~ mkqkzk d`tmczctocg

mc}c mctk tòce e`mkz mkc}cz eè~`tzkc~ocg ZÊ)^Ô)ZÎ& dkfc d`fpecmc mc~c} e`g{pzpg mpfp ZÊ)^Ô)ZÎg{c z`zpck o`z`~coc}cg'

4' ^tia`zk Tòce E`mkz)Oim`t eè~`tzkc~ocg dpop KJM 3> mcg KJM ;JE& Fc~itcg TF3 zce~ck m`glcg 1 "}`tp}cec TF4+' ^tia`zk Tòce E`mkz

eèdpc} mca}ct 0 3> ~`g{cok} p}cec mcg }`tz`tkgl mctk z`}kc~ mkqkzk

ZEA)Kgz}cfczk m`glcg oim` KJM 3> z t}c t tc}c fcec bctk tc|c}

d`tmczctocg mc}c fc~itcg eitdkmk}cz TF4'

:' ^tia zk ^`tc|c} eè~`tzkc~ocg Czpbcg O`~`tc|c}cg'

=' ^tia`zk Acteczk eè~`tzkc~ocg Mca}ct Aitepfctkpe& zkz}è pgk} miz`mcg z}i~ itm`tkgl'

0' ^tia zk Copg}czk)O`pcglcg eè~`tzkc~ocg Mca}ct ]ctka tpecb zcok}

Z`}kc~ qctkcgz {cgl mkmc~c}ocg cocg mkfcopocg }kgmco fcghp} mcfce d`g}po~`fcozcgccg cpmk} e`mkz z`dclckecgc {cgl mkcghptocg mcfce Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK

Gieit 4; ]cbpg 4>>= mcg ^`tc}ptcg E`g}`tk O`z`bc}cg TK Gieit

33'


34/41

::

O``zke~pfcg8

Mctk ptckcg zkgloc} mkc}cz m`glcg bcg{c z fèdct Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z

e`tp~cocg zpc}p kgz}tpe`g {cgl oie~t`b`gzka e`tcglope z`jctc }`t~cmp dkmcgl

~`fc{cgcg& ~`gmkmkocg mcg ~`g fk}kcg ecp~pg cot`mk}czk z`t}c dkfc mk}kghcp

mctk z`lk òigiek o`z`bc}cg mc~c} e`fcozcgcocg àkzk`gzk ~èdkc{ccg m`glcg

eècgacc}ocg zì~}kecf epglokg bctk tc|c} ~czk`g& e`gl`fkekgczk ~è`tkozccg

~`gpghcgl)fcditc}itkpe)}kgmcocg {cgl }kmco mk~`tfpocg& e`gllpgcocg idc}

idc}ccg "}`tp}cec cg}kdki}ko+ z`zpck `qkm`gj`%dcz`m? z`bkgllc ~`fc{cgcg àò}ka

mkzce~kgl }kmco eèd`mcocg fc}ct d`fcocgl ~czk`g oct`gc aiopz o`~cmc ~czk`g

mcg ~`g{cok}g{c "o`d`tcmkfcg)òpk}k+ mcg zòcfklpz eè`gpbk z`fptpb }klc}phpcg mctk Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4; ]cbpg 4>>= mcg è~c} }phpcg

Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit == ]cbpg 4>>;'

Mèkokcg ~pfc dclk Tpecb Zcok} ^`gmkmkocg& Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z mc~c}

mk~`tlpgcocg z`dclck kgz}tpe`g mcfce E`mkjcf @mpjc}kig Czz`zze`g}z }kgloc}

ofkgkz mcfce d`g}po \ito~fcj`%dcz`m Czz`zze`g} "\DC+ pg}po Fildiio& Ekgk

J@R& MI^Z& JdM& :1>m`lt ` Czz`zze`g} "Ekgk C]+& ît}aifki mcg Zjtk~}

Jigjitmcgj` ]`z} "ZJ]+ {cgl zpmcb e`tp~cocg oie~ig`g mcfce Cot`mk}czk

Z}cgmct ^`gmkmkocg Mio}`t mcg Mio}`t Z~`zkcfkz mk Kgmig`zkc'

Dcbocg dkfc mkfcozcgcocg Jfkgkjcf ^c}b|c{z z`jctc oigzkz}`g mkecgc cocg

mkmc~c}ocg mc}c mc}c jiz}%|`klb}& jczèkr kgm`r mcg dcz`%tc}` z`jctc f`gloc~

"pg}poekjti%z{z}è+ cocg mc~c} mkzpzpg zpc}p Gc}kigcf B`cf}b Cjjipg}z z`bkgllc

Pgkq`tzcf Jiq`tcl` cocg f`dkb epmcb }`tjk~}c mcg Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit

=> ]cbpg 4>>= z`t}c Pgmcgl Pgmcgl TK Gieit 4= ]cbpg 4>33 pg}po dkmcgl

o`z`bc}cg }`t|phpm "z`jctc ecjti%z{z}è+'

]`tkec oczkb& zèilc d`tecgacc}'^cmcgl& 4: Giqèd`t 4>34

Mim{ Aktecgmc

O`}pc Oiek}` E`mko

TZP^ Ac}ec|c}k Hcoct}c'

b}}~8))|||'zjtkdm'jie)Oiek}`%4>E`mko


35/41

:=

FCE^KTCG8

^cgmpcg ^tco}ko Ofkgkz

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

M`~ct}è`g)Dclkcg)ZEA 8

Tpecb Zcok}8 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

4>34 4>3=

''''''''''''''''''''''''

3' ^`gl`t}kcg "Màkgkzk+ ''

4' Cgceg`zkz ''''

''

''

''

:' ^è`tkozccg Akzko ''''

''

''

''

''

'

=' Otk}`tkc Mkclgizkz 3' '4'

:'

=' ''

0' '''''''''''''''''''''''''

0' Mkclgizkz '

1' Mkclgizkz Dcgmkgl 3' '4' '

:'


36/41

:0

2' ]`tc~k 3' 4'

:'

='

0' ''''''''

;' @mpoczk 3' 4'

:'

='

0' ''''''''

3>' ^tilgizkz Cm qk}ce 8 mpdkc cm digce)ecfce

Cm zcgc}kigce 8 mpdkc cm digce)ecfceCm apelzkigce 8 mpdkc cm digce)ecfce

33' ]kgloc} @qkm`gz K)KK)KKK)KQ

34' ]kgloc} T`oie`gmczk C)D)J

3:' ^`g`fccb Otk}kz 3' 4'

:'

='

3=' Kgmkoc}it E`mkz ''

''

30' O`~pz}coccg 3' 4'

:'

='

0' ''''''''

'''''''''''''''''''& '4>34

O }pc Oiek}` E`mko O }pc ZEA'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

Mkt`o}pt Tpecb Zcok} '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''


37/41

:1

JFKGKJCF ^C]B\C[Z

TPECB ZCOK]

''

Gcec ^czk`g8

Pept8

D`tc} Dcmcg8''ol

]kgllk Dcmcg8''je

Gieit Tòce E`mkz8'

Mkclgizkz C|cf8 ' Oim` KJM 3> 8 T`gjcgc tc|c} 8 bctk

Co}kqk}cz ^`fc{cgcgT' Tc|c}

'

]lf)Hce eczpo8'

]lf)Hce o`fpct8'

Fcec T|}''' bctk

O`fcz8''

]ctka)bt "T~+8'

Dkc{c "T~+

BT 3 BT 4 BT : BT = BT 0 BT 1 BT < BT 2 BT ; BT3>

BT33

BT34

BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ '' BZ ''

Mkclgizkz8

^`g{cok} P}cec ^`g{cok} ^`g{`t}c

Oie~fkoczk

Cz`zze`g Ofkgkz8 ^è`tkozccg mio}`t ''

Oigzpf}czk ''

^è`tkozccg ^`gpghcgl8

''

]kgmcocg8 ''

Idc} idc}cg8

''

Gp}tkzk8 ''

Eidkfkzczk8 ''

Bczkf "Ip}jie`+8 ''

''

''

^`gmkmkocg)T`gjcgc^èpfcglcg8

Qctkcgz8

Hpefcb Dkc{c ''

^`tc|c} "^^H^+

Mkclgizkz Cobkt8 Oim` KJM 3> H`gkz ]kgmcocg8 Oim` KJM ; JE

M^H^8

P}cec '' '

M^H^ I~`tczk8

^`g{`t}c '' '

M^H^ Cg`z}`zk'''''''''''''''''''''''

' '' ' '' '

Q`tkakoc}it8

Oie~fkoczk '' ' '' '


38/41

: 8 T`gjcgc tc|c} 8 bctk


'

]lf)Hce eczpo8'

]lf)Hce o`fpct8'

Fcec T|}''' bctk

O`fcz8''

]ctka)bt "T~+8'

Dkc{c "T~+

BT3

BT4

BT:

BT=

BT0

BT1

BT

BT33

BT34

BT3:

BT3=

BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ BZ

Mkclgizkz8 ^`g{cok} P}cec

^`g{cok} ^`g{`t}c

Oie~fkoczk

Cz`zze`g Ofkgkz8

^è`tkozccg mio}`t ''

Oigzpf}czk ''

^è`tkozccg ^`gpghcgl8 ''

]kgmcocg8 ''

Idc} idc}cg8

''

Gp}tkzk8 ''

Eidkfkzczk8 ''

Bczkf "Ip}jie`+8

''

''

''

^`gmkmkocg)T`gjcgc^èpfcglcg8Qctkcgz8

Hpefcb Dkc{c ''^`tc|c} "^^H^+


M^H^8

P}cec '' '

M^H^ I~`tczk8

^`g{`t}c '' '

M^H^ Cg`z}`zk'''''''''''''''''''''''

' '' '

'' 'Q`tkakoc}it8

Oie~fkoczk '' '

'' '


39/41

:2

JFKGKJCF ^C]B\C[Z

TPECB ZCOK]

''

Gcec ^czk`g8

Pept8

D`tc} Dcmcg8''ol

]kgllk Dcmcg8''je

Gieit Tòce E`mkz8'



'

]lf)Hce eczpo8'

]lf)Hce o`fpct8'

Fcec T|}''' bctk

O`fcz8''

]ctka)bt "T~+8'

Dkc{c "T~+

Bctk Tc|c} 3 Bctk Tc|c} 4 Bctk Tc|c} : Bctk Tc|c} = Bctk Tc|c} 0Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8

Mkclgizkz8

^`g{cok} P}cec '

^`g{cok} ^`g{`t}c '

Oie~fkoczk '

Cz`zze`g Ofkgkz8 ^è`tkozccg mio}`t ' ''

Oigzpf}czk ' ''

^è`tkozccg ^`gpghcgl8 ' ''

]kgmcocg8 ' ''

Idc} idc}cg8 ''

'

'

'

''''''

''''''

''''''

''''''

Gp}tkzk8 ' ''Eidkfkzczk8 ' ''

Bczkf "Ip}jie`+8

'' '

'' '

'' '


'

Qctkcgz8 '

Hpefcb Dkc{c ''

^`tc|c} "^^H^+


M^H^8

P}cec '' '

M^H^ I~`tczk8

^`g{`t}c '' '

M^H^ Cg`z}`zk'''''''''''''''''''''''

' '' '

'' 'Q`tkakoc}it8

Oie~fkoczk '' '

'' '


40/41

:;

JFKGKJCF ^C]B\C[Z

TPECB ZCOK]

''

Gcec ^czk`g8

Pept8

D`tc} Dcmcg8''ol

]kgllk Dcmcg8''je

Gieit Tòce E`mkz8'



'

]lf)Hce eczpo8'

]lf)Hce o`fpct8'

Fcec T|}''' bctk

O`fcz8''

]ctka)bt "T~+8'

Dkc{c "T~+

Bctk Tc|c} 3 Bctk Tc|c} 4 Bctk Tc|c} : Bctk Tc|c} = Bctk Tc|c} 0 Bctk Tc|c} 1Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8 Bctk Zcok}8

Mkclgizkz8

^`g{cok} P}cec

^`g{cok} ^`g{`t}c

Oie~fkoczk

Cz`zze`g Ofkgkz8 ^è`tkozccg mio}`t ''

Oigzpf}czk ''

^è`tkozccg ^`gpghcgl8

''

]kgmcocg8 ''

Idc} idc}cg8

''

'

'Gp}tkzk8 ''

Eidkfkzczk8 ''

Bczkf "Ip}jie`+8

''

''

''


Qctkcgz8

Hpefcb Dkc{c ''

^`tc|c} "^^H^+ Mkclgizkz Cobkt8 Oim` KJM 3> H`gkz ]kgmcocg8 Oim` KJM ; JE

M^H^8

P}cec '' '

M^H^ I~`tczk8

^`g{`t}c '' '

M^H^ Cg`z}`zk'''''''''''''''''''''''

' '' ' '' '

Q`tkakoc}it''

Oie~fkoczk '' '

'' '


41/41

JFKGKJCF ^C]B\C[Z

TPECB ZCOK]

''

Gcec ^czk`g8

Pept8

D`tc} Dcmcg8''ol

]kgllk Dcmcg8''je

Gieit T`oce E`mkz8'



'

]lf)Hce eczpo8'

]lf)Hce o`fpct8'

Fcec T|}''' bctk

O`fcz8''

]ctka)bt "T~+8'

Dkc{c "T~+

Bctk Tc|c}3

Bctk Tc|c}4

Bctk Tc|c}:

Bctk Tc|c}=

Bctk Tc|c}0

Bctk Tc|c}1

Bctk Tc|c} H`gkz ]kgmcocg8 Oim` KJM ; JE

M^H^88

P}cec '' '

M^H^ I~`tctczk8

^`g{`t}c '' '

M^H^ Cg`z}`zk8'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

' '' '

Q`tkakoc}it8

Oie~fkoczk '' '' '' '

Dody Firmanda 2012 - Pemanfaatan Evidence-based Medicine dalam mendukung Clinical Pathways, Padang...

Documents

Transcript of Dody Firmanda 2012 - Pemanfaatan Evidence-based Medicine dalam mendukung Clinical Pathways, Padang...