Post on 16-Jan-2023
6DOHP�:LWFKFUDIW��)DFWLRQDOLVP��DQG�6RFLDO�&KDQJH�5HFRQVLGHUHG��:HUH�6DOHPV�:LWFK�+XQWHUV0RGHUQL]DWLRQV�)DLOXUHV"$XWKRU�V���5LFKDUG�/DWQHU6RXUFH��7KH�:LOOLDP�DQG�0DU\�4XDUWHUO\��7KLUG�6HULHV��9RO������1R�����-XO����������SS���������3XEOLVKHG�E\��2PRKXQGUR�,QVWLWXWH�RI�(DUO\�$PHULFDQ�+LVWRU\�DQG�&XOWXUH6WDEOH�85/��http://www.jstor.org/stable/25096806 .$FFHVVHG������������������
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
.
Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserveand extend access to The William and Mary Quarterly.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
6DOHP�:LWFKFUDIW�� )DFWLRQDOLVP�� DQG�
6RFLDO� &KDQJH� 5HFRQVLGHUHG�� :HUH� 6DOHPV�
:LWFK�+XQWHUV� 0RGHUQL]DWLRQV� )DLOXUHV"�
5LFKDUG� /DWQHU�
7+(� �����6DOHP�ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN� KDV� KDG� DQ� HQGXULQJ� FDSDFLW\�IRU� DWWUDFWLQJ� SRSXODU� DQG� VFKRODUO\� DWWHQWLRQ�� ,W� FRPELQHV� D� FRP�
SHOOLQJ� DQG� VRPHWLPHV� KHURLF� QDUUDWLYH�ZLWK� WKH�GDUN� DOOXUH� RI�
VXEYHUWLQJ� $PHULFDQ� H[FHSWLRQDOLVW� DVVXPSWLRQV� RI� WROHUDQFH�� FRPSUR�
PLVH�� FRQFLOLDWLRQ�� DQG� KDUPRQ\�� 5LFKO\� FRPSOH[� DQG� OD\HUHG�� LW� LV� FRQ�
WLQXRXVO\� DPHQDEOH� WR�IUHVK� LQYHVWLJDWLRQ�� 7KXV�� WKRXJK� WKH�KDUYHVW� RI�ERRNV� DQG� DUWLFOHV� RQ� 6DOHP� PD\� GHWHU� UHVHDUFKHUV� IURP� WKLV� ZHOO�WURGGHQ�
WHUUDLQ�� DPSOH� UHZDUGV� PD\� UHVXOW� QRW� RQO\� IURP� IRUPXODWLQJ�QHZ� LQWHU�
SUHWDWLRQV� EXW� DOVR� IURP� UHH[DPLQLQJ� SUHYDLOLQJ� FRQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQV��5HFHQW� 6DOHP� VFKRODUVKLS� KDV�PRYHG� VLJQLILFDQWO\�EH\RQG� WKH�WUDGL�
WLRQDO� DFFRXQWV� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� &KDUOHV� :�� 8SKDP� DQG�0DULRQ� /��
6WDUNH\�� ZKR� YLHZHG� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN� DV� DQ�H[FHSWLRQDO� \HW� DOO�
WRR�XQGHUVWDQGDEOH� PDQLIHVWDWLRQ� RI� 3XULWDQLVP� LQ� DQ��DJH� RI� VXSHUVWL�
WLRQ��� 6LQFH� WKH� ����V� VFKRODUV� KDYH� DSSOLHG� VRFLDO� DQG� FXOWXUDO� KLVWRU\��JHRJUDSK\�� DQWKURSRORJ\�� DQG� JHQGHU� VWXGLHV� WR� UHYHDO� 6DOHP� QRW� RQO\� DV�
DQ� LQWULFDWH� WDOH� RI� ZRH� EXW� DOVR� DV� DQ�LQWHJUDO� SDUW� RI� WKH� ODQGVFDSH� RI�
HDUO\�$PHULFDQ� KLVWRU\�� 6WXGLHV� RI�ZLWFKFUDIW�� PDJLF�� DQG� UHOLJLRQ� KDYH�GHPRQVWUDWHG� WKH�ZLGHVSUHDG� QDWXUH� RI�PDJLFDO� EHOLHIV� DQG� SUDFWLFHV� LQ�
HDUO\� PRGHUQ� $PHULFD� DQG� (QJODQG�� 2WKHU� DFFRXQWV�� IRFXVLQJ�RQ�
ZRPHQV� SUHHPLQHQW� UROH� DV� ZLWFKFUDIWV� YLFWLPV�� FRQIHVVRUV�� DQG�
DIIOLFWHG�� KDYH� DSSOLHG� SV\FKRORJLFDO� LQVLJKWV� WR� LOOXPLQDWH� WKH� VRFLDO�VWUXFWXUDO� FRQWH[W� RI� ZLWFKFUDIW� LQ�1HZ� (QJODQG�� 0HDQZKLOH� D� FRP�
PHQGDEOH� ELRJUDSK\� RI� 6DPXHO� 3DUULV�� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� PLQLVWHU� DW� WKH�WLPH� RI� WKH� RXWEUHDN�� DQG� WKH�SXEOLFDWLRQ� RI� 3DUULVV� VHUPRQV� KDYH�ORFDWHG� 6DOHP� PRUH� SUHFLVHO\� ZLWKLQ� WKH� HUDV� UHOLJLRXV� GHYHORSPHQWV��FRPSOHPHQWLQJ� UHVHDUFK� WKDW�KDV� XQGHUVFRUHG� WKH�GLVWLQFWLYH� UHOLJLRXV��
5LFKDUG� /DWQHU� LV� D� SURIHVVRU� RI� KLVWRU\� DW�7XODQH� 8QLYHUVLW\�� )RU� WKHLU� FRP�PHQWV� DQG� FRQVWUXFWLYH� VXJJHVWLRQV�� KH� WKDQNV� 'DYLG� $OOPHQGLQJHU�� -RKQ� 'LHP��
/DUU\� *UDJJ�� -DQHW� +XJKHV�� -RKQ� /LXNNRQHQ�� .HQQHWK� /RFNULGJH�� 6WHYHQ� 0LQW]��
%HQMDPLQ� 5D\�� DQG� %HUQDUG� 5RVHQWKDO� DV�ZHOO� DV� WKH� DQRQ\PRXV� UHDGHUV� IRU� WKH�:LOOLDP� DQG�0DU\� 4XDUWHUO\��
:LOOLDP� DQG�0DU\� 4XDUWHUO\�� �G� 6HULHV�� 9ROXPH� /;9�� 1XPEHU� ���-XO\� �����
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
GHPRJUDSKLF�� DQG� JHRJUDSKLF� SDWWHUQV� RI� VHWWOHPHQW� LQ�6DOHP� 7RZQ� DQG�
9LOODJH�� 0DU\� %HWK�1RUWRQ� KDV� ILWWHG� WKH�6DOHP� RXWEUHDN� LQWR�D� �EURDGHU�FULVLV� WKDW� SURGXFHG� WKH� WULDOV��� FRQWHQGLQJ� WKDW� ZLWKRXW� DQ�
RQJRLQJ�IURQWLHU� EDWWOH� EHWZHHQ� FRORQLVWV� DQG� 1DWLYH� $PHULFDQV�� WKH� �(VVH[�
&RXQW\� ZLWFKFUDIW� FULVLV� RI� ����� ZRXOG� QRW� KDYH� RFFXUUHG��� 6DOHP� ZLWFK�
FUDIW�� DQ� HSLVRGH� WKDW� HPLQHQW� FRORQLDO� 1HZ� (QJODQG� KLVWRULDQ� 3HUU\�0LOOHU� ODEHOHG� �SHULSKHUDO�� DQG� GLVFRXQWHG� DV�KDYLQJ� �QR� HIIHFW��RQ�1HZ�
(QJODQGV� HFFOHVLDVWLFDO�� SROLWLFDO�� LQVWLWXWLRQDO�� RU� LGHRORJLFDO� GHYHORS�PHQW�� FRQWLQXHV� WR� EH� D� FDVH� VWXG\� LQ� FUHDWLYH� KLVWRULFDO� LQYHVWLJDWLRQ���
:LWKLQ� WKLV� VHHPLQJO\� LQH[KDXVWLEOH� ZRUOG� RI�PRGHUQ� 6DOHP� VFKRO�
DUVKLS�� RQH� VWXG\�KROGV� D� VSHFLDO� SODFH� DQG� FRQWLQXHV� WR� LQIOXHQFH� DQG�
VKDSH� WKH�GLVFXVVLRQ� RI� 6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW�� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ�1LVVHQEDXPV� ����� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� UHYLWDOL]HG� 1HZ� (QJODQG� ZLWFKFUDIW�VWXGLHV� DQG�ZRQ� WKH�$PHULFDQ� +LVWRULFDO� $VVRFLDWLRQV� -RKQ�+�� 'XQQLQJ�3UL]H�� $� GHFDGH� ODWHU�� LQ�KLV� KLVWRULRJUDSKLFDO� DVVHVVPHQW� RI�ZLWFKFUDIW�
VWXGLHV�� 'DYLG� '�� +DOO� FODLPHG� WKDW�ZLWFKFUDIW� LQYHVWLJDWLRQV� KDG��HQWHUHG� D� QHZ�
SKDVH�� ZLWK� WKLV� ZRUN� DQG� WKDW� WKH� ERRNV� DUJXPHQW� ZDV�
�WRR� ZHOO� NQRZQ� WR� QHHG� UHVWDWLQJ� LQ� GHWDLO��� DQRWKHU� SURPLQHQW� ZLWFK�
FUDIW� KLVWRULDQ� XSKROGV� LWV� DXWKRULWDWLYH� VWDWXV� DV� WKH� �PRVW� DPELWLRXV�
PRGHUQ� DWWHPSW� WR�H[SODLQ� WKH� 6DOHP� HSLVRGH����
��&KDUOHV� :�� 8SKDP�� 6DOHP� :LWFKFUDIW�� :LWK� DQ�$FFRXQW� RI�6DOHP� 9LOODJH� DQG� D�
+LVWRU\� RI�2SLQLRQV� RQ�:LWFKFUDIW� DQG� .LQGUHG� 6XEMHFWV� ������� UHSU���1HZ� <RUN�� ������������ ��DJH� RI� VXSHUVWLWLRQ���� ��� �������� 0DU\� %HWK� 1RUWRQ�� ,Q� WKH�'HYLOV� 6QDUH�� 7KH�6DOHP� :LWFKFUDIW� &ULVLV� RI������ �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� �� ��EURDGHU� FULVLV���� ���� ��(VVH[�
&RXQW\� ZLWFKFUDIW���� 3HUU\�0LOOHU�� 7KH�1HZ� (QJODQG� 0LQG�� )URP� &RORQ\� WR�3URYLQFH�
�&DPEULGJH�� 0DVV��� ������� ���� ��SHULSKHUDO���� ���� ��QR� HIIHFW���� 0DULRQ� /�� 6WDUNH\�GHSLFWHG� WKH� 6DOHP� RXWEUHDN� DV� D� �FDSLWXODWLRQ� RI� UHDVRQ�� E\� �D� SHRSOH� ZKRVH� QDWXUDO�
LPSXOVHV� KDG� ORQJ� EHHQ� UHSUHVVHG� E\� WKH� VHYHULW\� RI� WKHLU� EHOLHI��� 6HH� 6WDUNH\�� 7KH�'HYLO� LQ�0DVVDFKXVHWWV�� $�0RGHUQ� ,QTXLU\� LQWR� WKH�6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV� �1HZ� <RUN��������� ������ �TXRWDWLRQ�� �������� (VSHFLDOO\� QRWHZRUWK\� ZRUNV� WKDW� RIIHU� GLIIHUHQW�
SHUVSHFWLYHV� RQ� ZLWFKFUDIW� DQG� 6DOHP� LQFOXGH� $ODQ� 0DFIDUODQH�� :LWFKFUDIW� LQ�7XGRU�DQG� 6WXDUW� (QJODQG�� $� 5HJLRQDO� DQG� &RPSDUDWLYH� 6WXG\� �/RQGRQ�� ������� .HLWK�
7KRPDV�� 5HOLJLRQ� DQG� WKH�'HFOLQH� RI�0DJLF� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� -RKQ� 3XWQDP� 'HPRV��
(QWHUWDLQLQJ� 6DWDQ�� :LWFKFUDIW� DQG� WKH�&XOWXUH� RI�(DUO\� 1HZ� (QJODQG� �1HZ� <RUN��
������� &DURO� )�� .DUOVHQ�� 7KH� 'HYLO� LQ� WKH�6KDSH� RI�D�:RPDQ�� :LWFKFUDIW� LQ�&RORQLDO�1HZ� (QJODQG� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� -RQ� %XWOHU�� $ZDVK� LQ� D� 6HD� RI�)DLWK�� &KULVWLDQL]LQJ�WKH�$PHULFDQ� 3HRSOH� �&DPEULGJH�� 0DVV��� ������� /DUU\� *UDJJ�� $� 4XHVW� IRU� 6HFXULW\�� 7KH�
/LIH� RI�6DPXHO� 3DUULV�� ���������� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� 5LFKDUG� *RGEHHU�� 7KH� 'HYLOV�'RPLQLRQ�� 0DJLF� DQG� 5HOLJLRQ� LQ�(DUO\� 1HZ� (QJODQG� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� -DPHV� )��
&RRSHU� -U�� DQG� .HQQHWK� 3��0LQNHPD�� HGV��� 7KH� 6HUPRQ� 1RWHERRN� RI�6DPXHO� 3DUULV��
����"����� �%RVWRQ�� ������� &HGULF� %�� &RZLQJ�� 7KH� 6DYLQJ� 5HPQDQW�� 5HOLJLRQ� DQG� WKH�
6HWWOLQJ� RI�1HZ� (QJODQG� �8UEDQD�� ���������������'DYLG� '�� +DOO�� �:LWFKFUDIW� DQG� WKH� /LPLWV� RI� ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ��� 1HZ� (QJODQG�
4XDUWHUO\� ���� QR�� �� �-XQH� ������� ������� ��HQWHUHG� D� QHZ� SKDVH��� ������ %HUQDUG�
5RVHQWKDO�� 6DOHP� 6WRU\�� 5HDGLQJ� WKH�:LWFK� 7ULDOV� RI������ �&DPEULGJH�� ������� �� ��PRVW�DPELWLRXV� PRGHUQ� DWWHPSW���� 6WDQOH\� 1�� .DW]� DQG� -RKQ� 0�� 0XUULQ� QRWH� WKDW� LQ�
DSSO\LQJ� �WR� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� WKH� WHFKQLTXHV� RI� FRPPXQLW\� VWXG\� WKDW�ZHUH� DOUHDG\�WUDQVIRUPLQJ� WKH� VRFLDO� KLVWRU\� RI� HDUO\� 1HZ� (QJODQG��� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
0LQLPL]LQJ� WKH� VLQJXODULW\� RI� WKH� 6DOHP� ZLWFK� KXQW�� %R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� JURXQGHG� WKH�RXWEUHDN� LQ� WKH� �SURVDLF�� HYHU\GD\� OLYHV� RI�REVFXUH� DQG� LQDUWLFXODWH� PHQ� DQG� ZRPHQ�� ZKRVH� �OLYHV� ZHUH�
EHLQJ�
VKDSHG� E\�SRZHUIXO� IRUFHV� RI�KLVWRULFDO� FKDQJH��� 7KH� VSHFLILF� QDWXUH� RI�WKLV�KLVWRULFDO� FKDQJH� ZDV� QRWKLQJ� OHVV� WKDQ� WKH� LQH[RUDEOH� PRYHPHQW�WRZDUG� FRPPHUFH� DQG� FDSLWDOLVP� HPERGLHG� LQ�WKH� LQFUHDVHG� EXVWOH� DQG�
SURPLQHQFH� RI� 6DOHP� 7RZQ�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� GHIWO\� VXEVXPHG� WKH�SHWW\�SHUVRQDO� TXDUUHOV� IHDWXUHG� LQ�PDQ\� HDUO\� DFFRXQWV� LQWR� DQ�
DUFKHW\SDO�FODVK� EHWZHHQ� WKH� DJULFXOWXUDO� KLQWHUODQG� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� DQ� DUHD�
JURXQGHG� LQ� �SUH�FDSLWDOLVWLF� SDWWHUQV� RI� YLOODJH� H[LVWHQFH��� DQG� LWV� HYHU�
PRUH� FRVPRSROLWDQ� QHLJKERU�� 6DOHP� 7RZQ�� &RQVWUDLQHG� E\�GLPLQLVKHG�ODQG� DYDLODELOLW\�� WKH�YLOODJHV� HFRQRP\� ZDV�� DW� EHVW�� KROGLQJ� LWV�RZQ��UHODWLYH� WR�WKH� LQFUHDVHG�ZHDOWK� RI�6DOHP�7RZQ�� LW�ZDV� IDOOLQJ�EHKLQG���
2QH� RI� WKH�H[FLWHPHQWV� RI� WKH�ERRN� ZDV� LWV�LFRQRFODVWLF� UHYLVLRQ� RI�WKH� SRSXODU� LGHD� WKDW� ZLWFK�KXQWHUV� DWWDFNHG� WKH� ZHDN�� YXOQHUDEOH�� DQG�
SRZHUOHVV�� ,QVWHDG�� DFFRUGLQJ�WR� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� LW�ZDV� WKH�
ZLWFK�KXQWHUV� ZKR� ZHUH�DFWXDOO\� LQ� UHWUHDW��
2XWVWULSSHG� E\� WKHLU� ULYDOV��
WKH\� ODXQFKHG� D��IOHHWLQJ� RIIHQVLYH"FRXQWHU�RIIHQVLYH�� UHDOO\"LQ� WKH�
PLGVW� RI� D�JHQHUDO� DQG� VXVWDLQHG� UHWUHDW��� /LNH� *HUPDQ� WURRSV� DW� WKH�
%DWWOH� RI� WKH�%XOJH�� WKH� WUDGLWLRQDOLVWV� DGYDQFH� ZDV� RQO\� WHPSRUDULO\�VXFFHVVIXO�� VRRQ�� WKH\� DQG� WKHLU� VRFLHW\� ZHUH� VZHSW� WR� GHIHDW���
%R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� PDUVKDOHG� DQ� DUUD\� RI� HYLGHQFH� WR� VXSSRUW�WKHLU�EDVLF� FRQWHQWLRQ�� LQFOXGLQJ� SRUWUDLWV� RI� OHDGLQJ� SDUWLFLSDQWV� LQ�WKH�6DOHP� DIIDLU��VXFK� DV� WKH� ULYDO�3RUWHU� DQG� 3XWQDP� IDPLOLHV�� 7KH\� ZHUH�DEOH� WR� UHFRQVWUXFW� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� IDFWLRQDOLVP� LQ�DVWRQLVKLQJ� GHWDLO��
SULPDULO\� WKURXJK� FKXUFK� DQG� YLOODJH� UHFRUGV�� 7KLV� IDFWLRQDOLVP� SUH�FHGHG� DQG� SUHFLSLWDWHG� WKH�HYHQWV� RI� ������7KRXJK� URRWHG� LQ�DQ� RYHU�
DUFKLQJ� HFRQRPLF� WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ�� IDFWLRQDOLVP� UHYHDOHG� LWVHOI� LQ� WKH�
1LVVHQEDXP� �GUDPDWLFDOO\� VKLIWHG� WKH� WHUPV� RI� WKH� GHEDWH�� RYHU� 6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW��6HH� .DW]� DQG� 0XUULQ�� HGV��� &RORQLDO� $PHULFD�� (VVD\V� LQ� 3ROLWLFV� DQG� 6RFLDO�
'HYHORSPHQW�� �G� HG�� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� �����0DU\� %HWK� 1RUWRQ�� DOPRVW� WKLUW\� \HDUV�ODWHU�� VWLOO� UHIHUV� WR� �WKH� LQIOXHQWLDO� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��� 6HH� 1RUWRQ�� ,Q� WKH�'HYLOV� 6QDUH����� $Q� H[DPLQDWLRQ� RI� OHDGLQJ� SXEOLFDWLRQV� DERXW� WKH� 6DOHP� RXWEUHDN� VKRZV� WKDW�ZKDWHYHU� WKHLU� UHVHUYDWLRQV�� KLVWRULDQV� FRQWLQXH� WR� FRQVXOW� DQG� HYHQ� UHO\� RQ� %R\HU�DQG� 1LVVHQEDXPV� VWXG\�� )RU� H[DPSOH� WKH� H[FHOOHQW� V\QWKHVLV� E\� %U\DQ� )�� /H� %HDX�GUDZV� GLUHFWO\� RQ� WKHLU� GLVFXVVLRQ� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� IDFWLRQDOLVP� DQG� UHSULQWV� WKHLU�
PDS� ORFDWLQJ� DFFXVHUV�� ZLWFKHV�� DQG� GHIHQGHUV� LQ� WKH�YLOODJH�� 6HH� /H� %HDX�� 7KH� 6WRU\�RI�WKH�6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV�� �:H�:DONHG� ,Q� &ORXGV� DQG� &RXOG� 1RW� 6HH� 2XU� :D\�� �8SSHU�6DGGOH� 5LYHU�� 1�-��� ������� ������� %\� LQVSLULQJ� QHZ� UHVHDUFK�� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�DOVR� JHQHUDWHG� FULWLTXHV� DQG� FRQIOLFWLQJ� LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV����3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� 7KH� 6RFLDO� 2ULJLQV� RI�:LWFKFUDIW� �&DPEULGJH�� 0DVV��� ������� [LL� ��SURVDLF�� HYHU\GD\� OLYHV���� ������ ��SUH�FDSLWDOLVWLF� SDWWHUQV��� �����
��,ELG��� [LLL��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
YLOODJHV� GHHS� GLYLVLRQ� RYHU� LWV�FKXUFK� DQG� 3DUULVV�PLQLVWU\� HYHQ� EHIRUH�
FKDUJHV� RI�ZLWFKFUDIW� EHJDQ�� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� XQFRYHUHG� WZR� SHWL�WLRQV� RI� SDUWLFXODU� YDOXH� GDWLQJ� IURP� ������ WKUHH� \HDUV� DIWHU� WKH� WULDOV�� RQH�
VLJQHG� E\� D�JURXS� XUJLQJ� WKH�GLVPLVVDO� RI�3DUULV� DQG� WKH�RWKHU�� D� ODUJHU�RQH�� GHIHQGLQJ� WKH�PLQLVWHU�� 7KH� QXPEHU� RI�PHQ� DQG�ZRPHQ� VLJQLQJ�WKHVH� OLVWV�WRWDOHG� ����DQG� FRQVWLWXWHG�� LQ�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXPV� ZRUGV��D� �VWULNLQJO\�KLJK�� QXPEHU� RI� WKH�YLOODJHV� HVWLPDWHG� ����DGXOWV��� %\� OLQN�
LQJ� SHWLWLRQ�QDPHV� ZLWK� FKXUFK� DQG� WD[� UHFRUGV�� WKH� DXWKRUV� ZHUH� DEOH� WR�
RIIHU�LQIRUPDWLRQ� DERXW� RUGLQDU\�PHPEHUV� RI� WKH�FRPPXQLW\� DV�ZHOO� DV�
OHDGHUV� DQG� WR� H[DPLQH� KRZ� IDFWLRQDO� DIILOLDWLRQ� ZDV� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK�FKXUFK�PHPEHUVKLS�� ZHDOWK�� DQG� JHRJUDSKLF� ORFDWLRQ��
7KHLU� DQDO\VLV� UHYHDOHG� WKDW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� ZDV� PRUH�VWURQJO\�
OLQNHG� WR�PHPEHUVKLS� LQ�WKH�YLOODJH� FKXUFK� DQG�ZDV� GLVWLQFWO\� OHVV�DIIOX�HQW� WKDQ� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� RSSRVLWLRQ�� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� ZHDOWKLHVW� UHVLGHQWV�
RSSRVHG� WKH� PLQLVWHU� WZR� WR� RQH�� DQG� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV�
JURXS�ZDV� ��� SHUFHQW� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKDW�RI� WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ��0RUHRYHU�WKH�SUR�3DUULV� FRQWLQJHQW� OLYHG� DZD\� IURP� WKH�FRPPHUFLDOLVP� RI�6DOHP�
7RZQ�� LQ� D�PRUH�ZHVWHUO\� GLUHFWLRQ�� ZKHUHDV� 3DUULVV� HQHPLHV� ZHUH� FRQ�
FHQWUDWHG� LQ� WKH� YLOODJHV�HDVWHUQ� VHFWLRQ� DGMDFHQW�
WR� 6DOHP� 7RZQ�� WR�
ZKLFK� WKH\�ZHUH� HFRQRPLFDOO\� DQG� SROLWLFDOO\� WLHG��7KRXJK� WKH�SUR�� DQG�DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQV� FLUFXODWHG� \HDUV� DIWHU� WKH� FRQFOXVLRQ� RI� WKH� WULDOV��
%R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� FRQWHQGHG� WKDW� WKH� VWUXFWXUH� RI� YLOODJH� IDFWLRQDO�
LVP� ZDV� FRQWLQXRXV� WKURXJKRXW� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� HUD�� FRQWULEXWLQJ�WR� LWV�
RXWEUHDN� DQG� SHUVLVWLQJ� DIWHUZDUG�� 6LJQLQJ� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� ZDV�WKHUHIRUH� LQGLFDWLYH� RI� VXSSRUW� IRU�3DUULV� EHIRUH� DQG� GXULQJ� WKH� WULDOV��
ZKHUHDV� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� ZDV� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� HDUOLHU� RSSRVLWLRQ� WR�
3DUULV� DQG� WKH� ZLWFK� SURVHFXWLRQV�� 7R� GHPRQVWUDWH� WKH� FRQWLQXLW\� RI�
6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� GLVVHQVLRQ�� WKH� DXWKRUV� LGHQWLILHG� IRUW\�VHYHQ� SHWLWLRQ�VLJQHUV�ZKR� WRRN� D� SRVLWLRQ� GXULQJ� WKH� WULDOV��HLWKHU� E\� VXSSO\LQJ� HYL�GHQFH� DJDLQVW� DQ� DFFXVHG� ZLWFK� RU�E\�RIIHULQJ�VRPH�NLQG� RI�GHIHQVH� RI�DQ�DFFXVHG� SHUVRQ�� WKH\� IRXQG� D� FOHDU�FXW� DVVRFLDWLRQ� EHWZHHQ� VXSSRUW� IRU�
WKH� WULDOV� DQG� VLJQLQJ� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� DQG� YLFH� YHUVD���
��,ELG��� ��� Q�� �����,ELG��� ���� ������� ���� ����� ����� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXPV� FRQ�
WHQWLRQ� WKDW� WKH� WZR� SHWLWLRQV� VXSSO\� HYLGHQFH� RI�SUHZLWFKFUDIW� IDFWLRQDOLVP� LQ�6DOHP�
9LOODJH� LV�SUREOHPDWLF�� $� SHWLWLRQHUV� VWDQG� UHJDUGLQJ� 6DPXHO� 3DUULV� LQ� ����� GRHV� QRW�
QHFHVVDULO\� LQGLFDWH� D�SRVLWLRQ� SULRU� WR�RU� GXULQJ� ������0\� RZQ� UHH[DPLQDWLRQ� RI� WKH�
SHWLWLRQ� OLVWV�� KRZHYHU�� FRQILUPV� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXPV� FODLP�� 2I� WKH� ����PDOH�DQG� IHPDOH� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� RQO\� ��� H[SUHVVHG� DQ\� UHVHUYDWLRQV�DERXW� WKH� WULDOV� LQ� ����� E\� GHIHQGLQJ� DQ� DFFXVHG� SHUVRQ�� DQG� �� RI� WKHVH� ��� DOVR� SUH�VHQWHG� WHVWLPRQ\� DJDLQVW� DQ� DFFXVHG� ZLWFK�� $W� WKH� VDPH� WLPH�� ��� RI� WKHVH� VLJQHUV�DLGHG� WKH� SURVHFXWLRQ� RI�ZLWFKHV� LQ� VRPH� ZD\�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� LV�DOVR� UHSOHWH�ZLWK� QDPHV� RI� WKH� YLOODJH� FKXUFKV� OHDGHUV� DQG� WKHLU� UHODWLYHV�� 3DUULVV� SULQFLSDO� VXS�SRUW� LQ� WKH� FRPPXQLW\�� $V� IRU� WKH� �M� DGXOWV� ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
7KRXJK� LQQRYDWLYH�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� KDG� OLPLWDWLRQV� DQG� SUREOHPV�WKDW� EHFDPH� DSSDUHQW� RYHU� WLPH�� ,WV� HPSKDVLV�
RQ� IDFWLRQDO� FRQIOLFW�
URRWHG� LQ� HFRQRPLF� WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ� GLG� OLWWOH� WR� H[SODLQ� ZRPHQV� VSHFLDO�
SURPLQHQFH� LQ�6DOHP� DQG�1HZ� (QJODQG� ZLWFKFUDIW� LQFLGHQWV��$QG� OLWWOH�ZDV� VDLG� DERXW� HYHQWV� EH\RQG� 6DOHP�� 'LG� WKH�JHRJUDSKLF� DQG� HFRQRPLF�FRQGLWLRQV� UHYHDOHG�ZLWKLQ� 6DOHP� RSHUDWH� LQ�$QGRYHU� RU� WKH�PRUH� WKDQ�
WZHQW\� RWKHU�0DVVDFKXVHWWV� FRPPXQLWLHV� WKDW� SDUWLFLSDWHG� LQ� ����"�
3HUKDSV� WKHVH� FRPPXQLWLHV�� WRR�� ZHUH� LQYROYHG� LQ� WKH� WXUPRLO� SURYRNHG�
E\� FRPPHUFLDO� FDSLWDOLVP�� LI�VR��%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� SUHVHQWHG� QR�
HYLGHQFH���
&ULWLFV� DOVR� IDXOWHG� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� IRU� LPSRVLQJ� DQ� DUWLILFLDO�PRGHO�RI�VRFLDO� GHYHORSPHQW� RQ� D�PRUH� FRPSOH[� KLVWRULFDO� UHDOLW\��,W�GHSLFWHG� D�
VRFLHW\� PRYLQJ� IURP� D� FRYHQDQW� FRPPXQLW\� RI� VXEVLVWHQFH� DJULFXOWXUH�WR�
RQH� EDVHG� RQ�PHUFKDQW� FDSLWDOLVP�� %XW� DV�&KULVWLQH� $OLFH� <RXQJ� KDV�
QRWHG�� 6DOHP� 7RZQ� GLG� QRW� VKRZ� D� VPRRWK� GHYHORSPHQWDO� FRQWLQXXP��IURP� VLPSOH�
WR�FRPSOH[�� KRPRJHQHRXV�
WR�KHWHURJHQHRXV�� KRUL]RQWDO� WR�
YHUWLFDO��� 7KH� WRZQ� ZDV� GLYHUVLILHG� IURP� WKH� RXWVHW�� DQG� PHUFKDQWV��
UDWKHU� WKDQ� FRQVWLWXWLQJ�D� FRUURVLYH� HOHPHQW� WR� VRFLDO� KDUPRQ\�� DFWHG� DV�
�WKH�PRVW� VLJQLILFDQW� XQLI\LQJ� IRUFH� IRU�WKLV�HDUO\�1HZ� (QJODQG� WRZQ���
3HUKDSV�� WKHQ�� LW�VKRXOG� QRW� EH� VXUSULVLQJ� WKDW�GXULQJ� WKH� ����� WULDOV�
PDJLVWUDWHV� DQG� MXGJHV� VXFK� DV� -RKQ�+DWKRUQH�� -RQDWKDQ� &RUZLQ�� DQG�%DUWKRORPHZ� *HGQH\�� ZKR� XSKHOG�
D�VWDXQFKO\� FRQVHUYDWLYH� LQWHUSUHWD�
WLRQ� RI� VSHFWUDO� HYLGHQFH� DQG� WKH� SRZHUV� RI�ZLWFKHV�� ZHUH� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK�
PHUFDQWLOH� DFWLYLW\� DQG� ZLWK� 6DOHP� 7RZQ�� QRW� WKH� DJULFXOWXUDO� KLQWHUODQG�
RI�6DOHP�9LOODJH�� $V� RQH� KLVWRULDQ� QRWHV� RI�+DWKRUQH�� LW�ZDV� SRVVLEOH� LQ�
RQO\� �� RIIHUHG� VXSSRUW� IRU� DFFXVDWLRQV� DJDLQVW� ZLWFKHV�� DQG� ��RI� WKHVH� �� DOVR� GHIHQGHG�DQ� DFFXVHG� ZLWFK�� 2WKHUV� PDGH� DFFXVDWLRQV� RQO\� DW� WKH� RXWVHW� RI� WKH� HSLVRGH� EXW� WKHQ�FHDVHG� WR� SDUWLFLSDWH�� )XUWKHUPRUH�� ��� DGGLWLRQDO� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� GHIHQGHG� DQ�
DFFXVHG� ZLWFK�� DQG� �� IRXQG� HLWKHU� WKHPVHOYHV� RU� WKHLU� VSRXVHV� DFFXVHG�� 0RVW� VLJQLIL�FDQWO\�� HYHU\� OHDGLQJ� RSSRQHQW� RI� 3DUULVV� PLQLVWU\� SULRU� WR� ����� ODWHU� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� 0DQ\� RWKHUV� RQ� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� ZHUH� FORVH� UHODWLYHV� RI� WKHVH�PHQ�� ,Q� VKRUW� WKH� ����� SHWLWLRQV� DUH� LPSHUIHFW� \HW� GHIHQVLEOH� HYLGHQFH� RI� 6DOHP�
9LOODJHV� SUH������ IDFWLRQDO� GLYLVLRQV�� 6HH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� HGV��� 7KH� 6DOHP�
:LWFKFUDIW� 3DSHUV�� 9HUEDWLP� 7UDQVFULSWV� RI�WKH�/HJDO� 'RFXPHQWV� RI� WKH�6DOHP� :LWFKFUDIW�2XWEUHDN� RI������� ��YROV�� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� %HQMDPLQ� &�� 5D\�� �6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV��
'RFXPHQWDU\� $UFKLYH� DQG� 7UDQVFULSWLRQ� 3URMHFW��� KWWS���HWH[W�YLUJLQLD�HGX�VDOHP��ZLWFKFUDIW�WH[WV�WUDQVFULSWV�KWPO��
��&HGULF� %�� &RZLQJ�� UHYLHZ� RI� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� E\� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP��$PHULFDQ� +LVWRULFDO� 5HYLHZ� ���� QR�� �� �'HFHPEHU� ������� ��������� &KDGZLFN� +DQVHQ���$QGRYHU� :LWFKFUDIW� DQG� WKH�&DXVHV� RI� WKH� 6DOHP�:LWFKFUDIW� 7ULDOV��� LQ�7KH� 2FFXOW� LQ�$PHULFD�� 1HZ� +LVWRULFDO� 3HUVSHFWLYHV�� HG��+RZDUG� .HUU� DQG� &KDUOHV� /�� &URZ� �8UEDQD�������� ������� ������� (OL]DEHWK� 5HLV�� 'DPQHG� :RPHQ�� 6LQQHUV� DQG� :LWFKHV� LQ�3XULWDQ�
1HZ� (QJODQG� �,WKDFD�� 1�<��� ������� ����� 0DU\� %HWK� 1RUWRQ�� �)LQGLQJ� WKH�'HYLO� LQ�WKH�'HWDLOV� RI� WKH� 6DOHP� :LWFKFUDIW� 7ULDOV��� &KURQLFOH� RI�+LJKHU� (GXFDWLRQ�� -DQ�� ���������� %��%��� $Q� H[FHOOHQW� FULWLTXH� R"� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� LV�IRXQG� LQ�+DOO�� 1HZ� (QJODQG�4XDUWHUO\� ���� ��������
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
VHYHQWHHQWK�FHQWXU\� 0DVVDFKXVHWWV� WR� VLPXOWDQHRXVO\� EH� D�PHUFKDQW� DQG�
�D� OHDGHU�RI� WKH�RUWKRGR[�� DQWLFRPPHUFLDO� SDUW\� LQ�FRORQLDO� SROLWLFV����6LPLODUO\�� WKH�GHSLFWLRQ� RI�6DOHP�9LOODJH� DV� D� VLPSOH� DJUDULDQ� VRFLHW\�
LQVXIILFLHQWO\� DFFRXQWHG� IRU� WKH� YLOODJH�DV� D�
IDVW�JURZLQJ�FHQWHU� RI� FRP�
PHUFLDO� DJULFXOWXUH�ZLWK� SRUWLRQV� RI� LWV�IDUPODQG� RZQHG� E\� WRZQVSHRSOH��,QGHHG� WKH�PRYHPHQW� RI� IDUPHUV� DZD\� IURP� WRZQ� FHQWHUV� LQ� VHYHQWHHQWK�
FHQWXU\�1HZ� (QJODQG� ZDV� LQFUHDVLQJO\� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� D�GHFOLQH� RI� WUDGL�WLRQDO� YDOXHV� DQG� D� WKUHDW� WR� FRKHVLYH� LQVWLWXWLRQV� VXFK� DV� WKH� FKXUFK��
�2XWOLYHUV��� WKRVH� ZKR� PRYHG� EH\RQG� WRZQ� FHQWHUV�� ZHUH� RIWHQ�
UHSURDFKHG� IRU�SODFLQJ� ODQG� DQG�PDWHULDO� UHZDUGV� DERYH� *RG� DQG� FRP�
PXQLW\�� 7KRXJK� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� LGHQWLILHG� WKH� RXWOLYHUV� RI�6DOHP� 9LOODJH� ZLWK� DQWLFRPPHUFLDO� YDOXHV�� WKH\� ZHUH� QRW� QHFHVVDULO\�
FRQ�
VLGHUHG� WKDW� ZD\� LQ� ODWH�VHYHQWHHQWK�FHQWXU\� 0DVVDFKXVHWWV���
7R� GDWH�� KRZHYHU�� QR� RQH� KDV� FKDOOHQJHG� WKH� HFRQRPLF� GDWD� WKDW� %R\HU�DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� VXSSOLHG� WR� VXSSRUW� WKHLU�FODLP� RI� WKH�ULVLQJ�HFRQRPLF�IRUWXQHV� RI� WKH�ZLWFK� KXQWV� RSSRQHQWV� DQG� WKH�GHFOLQLQJ� FRQGLWLRQ� RI�6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� UHVROXWH� VXSSRUWHUV� RI�3DUULV� DQG� WKH� WULDOV��7KRXJK� DQ�
LQYHVWLJDWLRQ� LQWR� WKLV�RQH� HYLGHQWLDU\� EXLOGLQJ� EORFN�PD\� VHHP� RI�PDU�
JLQDO� YDOXH�� WKH� GDWD� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� XVHG� DUH� FULWLFDO� WR� WKHLU� PRG�
HUQL]DWLRQ� DUJXPHQW� DERXW� WKH�RULJLQV� RI�6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW�� &KDOOHQJLQJ�WKHLU� HFRQRPLF� LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ�� WKHUHIRUH�� HQFRXUDJHV� D� VHDUFK� IRU� DOWHUQD�
WLYH�� EHWWHU� H[SODQDWLRQV�� 0RUHRYHU� D� UHH[DPLQDWLRQ� RI� WKHLU� HYLGHQFH� RIIHUV�
D� QHFHVVDU\� DQG� XVHIXO� UHPLQGHU� WKDW� EDVLF� TXDQWLWDWLYH� UHDVRQLQJ"QRW�
QHFHVVDULO\� H[SHUWLVH"UHPDLQV�DQ� HVVHQWLDO� WRRO� IRU� KLVWRULFDO� GLVFRXUVH��
7R� GHPRQVWUDWH� WKH� �FRPSDUDWLYH� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� RI� WKH� WZR� IDF�
WLRQV�� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH�� %R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� SULPDULO\� UHOLHG�RQ� D� WD[�DVVHVVPHQW� XQGHUWDNHQ� E\� WKH� YLOODJH� LQ�'HFHPEHU� ������ /LQNLQJ� WKH� QDPHV�
RI�YLOODJHUV�ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH� �����SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV�SHWLWLRQV� WR� WKLV�WD[�
UHFRUG�� WKH\� IRXQG� WKDW� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKRVH� IDYRULQJ� 3DUULV� ZDV� �����
VKLOOLQJV� ZKHUHDV� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� KLV� RSSRQHQWV� ZDV� VXEVWDQWLDOO\� KLJKHU��
�����VKLOOLQJV��$W� WKH�XSSHU� HQG� RI� WKH�HFRQRPLF� VFDOH�� HLJKW�RI� WKH�WZHOYH�
KLJKHVW� WD[SD\HUV� VLJQHG� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV�SHWLWLRQ�ZKHUHDV� RQO\� IRXU�EDFNHG�KLP��7KH� ERWWRP� RI�WKH�HFRQRPLF� VFDOH� UHYHDOHG� WKH�UHODWLYH� ODFN�RI�ZHDOWK�RI� WKH� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� WUDGLWLRQDOLVWV�� WKH� �SRRUHU�PHQ� RI� WKH�9LOODJH��DSSURYHG� RI� WKH�PLQLVWHUV� FRQGXFW� E\� D�
PDUJLQ� RI� WZR� WR� RQH����
��&KULVWLQH� $OLFH� <RXQJ�� )URP� �*RRG� 2UGHU�� WR�*ORULRXV� 5HYROXWLRQ�� 6DOHP��0DVVDFKXVHWWV�� ���������� �$QQ� $UERU�� 0LFK��� ������� �� ��IURP� VLPSOH� WR� FRPSOH[�������� 5LFKDUG� 3�� *LOGULH�� 6DOHP�� 0DVVDFKXVHWWV�� ����������� $� &RYHQDQW� &RPPXQLW\��&KDUORWWHVYLOOH�� 9D��� ������� ���� ��OHDGHU� RI� WKH�RUWKRGR[����
��&KDUOHV� (�� +DPEULFN�6WRZH�� 7KH� 3UDFWLFH� RI�3LHW\�� 3XULWDQ� 'HYRWLRQDO�
'LVFLSOLQHV� LQ�6HYHQWHHQWK�&HQWXU\� 1HZ� (QJODQG� �&KDSHO� +LOO�� 1�&��� ������� �������
��2XWOLYHUV��� ������ <RXQJ�� )URP� �*RRG� 2UGHU�� WR�*ORULRXV� 5HYROXWLRQ�� ��������%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� ������ �TXRWDWLRQV�� ����� ��������
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
%XW� FDQ� RQH� WD[� OLVW�EHDU� WKH�ZHLJKW� RI� WKLV�VZHHSLQJ� WKHVLV�RI� ULVLQJ�DQG� IDOOLQJ� HFRQRPLF� JURXSV"� (YHQ� LI�WKH� ����� WD[�"VW� VKRZV� GLVSDULWLHV�EHWZHHQ� 3DUULVV� VXSSRUWHUV� DQG� RSSRQHQWV�� LW� FDQQRW� DGGUHVV� FKDQJHV�RYHU� WLPH�� IRU� LQVWDQFH� ZKHWKHU� RQH�
JURXSV� ZHDOWK� ZDV�ULVLQJ� ZKLOH� WKH�
RWKHUV� ZDV�IDOOLQJ�� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXPV� FRQFOXVLRQ� ZDV� GLDFKURQLF��
WKHLU� HYLGHQFH�� V\QFKURQLH�� &OHDUO\�� LW�ZRXOG� EH� PRUH�DSSURSULDWH� WR� XVH�
PXOWLSOH�WD[� OLVWV� UDWKHU� WKDQ� RQH� WR�PHDVXUH� WKH� HFRQRPLF� PRELOLW\� RI�
LQGLYLGXDOV� DQG� JURXSV� LQ�6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� )RUWXQDWHO\�� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�%RRN� RI�5HFRUG� FRQWDLQV�� LQ� DGGLWLRQ� WR� WKH� ����� OLVW�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� XVHG�� D� QXPEHU� RI� WD[� DVVHVVPHQWV� IRU� \HDUV� SUHFHGLQJ� DQG�
IROORZLQJ� WKH� ����� RXWEUHDN�� 6SHFLILFDOO\�� WKH�YLOODJH� UHFRUGHG� DVVHVV�PHQWV� IRU� WKH� \HDUV� ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ DQG� �����Q�
7KH� ����� WD[� OLVW�LV�HVSHFLDOO\� VLJQLILFDQW��2ULJLQDOO\� DGRSWHG� IRU�WKH�
\HDU� -XO\� ��� �����-XO\� ��� ������ WKH� UDWHV� ZHUH� UHDXWKRUL]HG� LQ� -XO\� �����
DQG� UHPDLQHG� LQ�HIIHFW�XQWLO� -XO\������� OHVV� WKDQ� D�\HDU� EHIRUH� WKH�ILUVW�IRUPDO� DFFXVDWLRQ� RI� WKH� RXWEUHDN� RFFXUUHG�� DW� WKH� HQG� RI� )HEUXDU\� ������
6LQFH� WKHUH� ZDV� QR� DVVHVVPHQW� IRU� ������ ZKHQ� YLUWXDOO\� WKH� HQWLUH� ZLWFK�
FUDIW�HSLVRGH� WRRN�SODFH�� WKLV�UROO� VXSSOLHV� WKH�FORVHVW� DSSUR[LPDWLRQ� RI�WKH� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV�
DW� WKDW� WLPH����
���7KH� DVVHVVPHQWV�� ZKLFK� H[WHQG� EH\RQG� ������ KDYH� EHHQ� SXEOLVKHG� LQ� WKH�
+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV� RI�WKH�'DQYHUV� +LVWRULFDO� 6RFLHW\�� 6RPH� EXW� QRW� DOO� DSSHDU� LQ�3DXO�
%R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXPV� VSOHQGLGO\� HGLWHG� GRFXPHQW� FROOHFWLRQ�� 6DOHP�
9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW�� $� 'RFXPHQWDU\� 5HFRUG� RI�/RFDO� &RQIOLFW� LQ�&RORQLDO� 1HZ� (QJODQG��%HOPRQW�� &DOLI��� ������� %HJLQQLQJ� LQ� ����� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� PDLQWDLQHG� LWV�RZQ� PLQLV�WHU��7KRXJK� WKH� YLOODJH� VWLOO� FRQVWLWXWHG�� LQ� HIIHFW�� D� SDULVK� RI� WKH� WRZQ� XQWLO� ������ LW�
SRVVHVVHG� WKH�SRZHU� WR� WD[� LQKDELWDQWV� IRU� WKHLU� FKXUFK�� (DFK� \HDU� WKH� YLOODJH� HOHFWHG�D� ILYH�PHPEHU� FRPPLWWHH� WKDW� GHWHUPLQHG� WKH� FRVW� RI�PDLQWDLQLQJ� WKH�PLQLVWU\� DQG�DVVHVVHG� WKH� LQKDELWDQWV� DFFRUGLQJ� WR� WKHLU� GHYHORSHG� DQG� XQGHYHORSHG� ODQGKROGLQJV�DQG� RWKHU� SURSHUW\�� 7KH� EDVLV� IRU� WD[DWLRQ� GLG� QRW� FKDQJH� GXULQJ� WKLV� SHULRG�� 6HH� �$�
%RRN� RI� 5HFRUG� RI� WKH� 6HYHUDOO� 3XEOLTXH� 7UDQVDFWLRQV� RI� WKH� ,QKDELWDQWV� RI�
6DOH>P@� 9LOODJH� 9XOJDUO\� &DOOHG� WKH� )DUPH>V@��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV� RI�WKH�'DQYHUV�+LVWRULFDO� 6RFLHW\� �6DOHP�� 0DVV��� ��������� ���������� ���� �������� HVS�� ���� �������� ����
������� HV3�� [��� ������� �����"� ���� ������� HVS�� ���� ������� ���� �������� HVS�� ���� �������������� .HQQHWK� $�� /RFNULGJH�� $� 1HZ� (QJODQG� 7RZQ�� 7KH� )LUVW� +XQGUHG� <HDUV��
'HGKDP�� 0DVVDFKXVHWWV�� ���������� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� ������� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP��
6DOHP�9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW�� �������� ����� �������� �������� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP�
3RVVHVVHG�� ������� <RXQJ�� )URP� �*RRG� 2UGHU�� WR�*ORULRXV� 5HYROXWLRQ�� ���� 7KH� RULJLQDO�GRFXPHQWV� LQ� SKRWRFRS\� IRUP� DUH� DYDLODEOH� LQ� WKH� 'DQYHUV� $UFKLYDO� &HQWHU��
3HDERG\� ,QVWLWXWH� /LEUDU\�� 'DQYHUV�� 0DVV�����7KH� DVVHVVPHQW� IRU� WKH�\HDU� EHJLQQLQJ� -XO\� ��������� DQG� HQGLQJ� -XO\� ��� ������
ZDV� HQWHUHG� LQ� WKH� %RRN� RI�5HFRUG� IROORZLQJ� HQWULHV� IRU�'HF�� ���� ������ DQG� -DQ�� ���
������ EXW� WKH�ZRUGV� SUHFHGLQJ� WKH� WD[� OLVW� HVWDEOLVK� WKDW� WKLV� DVVHVVPHQW� ZDV� PDGH� IRU�WKH� �������� WD[� \HDU�� WKRXJK� WKH� LQIRUPDWLRQ� ZDV� DSSDUHQWO\� QRW� LQVHUWHG� LQ� WKH�%RRN� RI�5HFRUG� DW� WKDW� WLPH�� ,PPHGLDWHO\� IROORZLQJ� WKH� UHJLVWHU� RI� WD[SD\HUV� LV� WKLV�QRWDWLRQ�� �7KLV� 5DWWH� ZDV� PDGH� IRU� WKH�PDLWHQDQFH� RI�0U�� 3DULVH� IRU� WKH� \HDUH�
EHJLQQLQJ� -XOH\� WKH� ILUVW� ������� LQGLFDWLQJ� WKDW� WKH� UDWH� UHPDLQHG� LQ� HIIHFW� XQWLO� DW�
OHDVW� -XO\� ��� ������ RQO\� DERXW� VHYHQ� PRQWKV� EHIRUH� WKH� ILUVW� DIIOLFWLRQV� EURNH� RXW� LQ�
6DPXHO� 3DUULVV� KRPH�� 6HH� �%RRN� RI�5HFRUG��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV�� ���� �������
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
8VLQJ� WKHVH� WD[� UHFRUGV�� LW� LV� SRVVLEOH�WR� FUHDWH� D� GDWD� VHW�
FRQWDLQLQJ�WKH�QDPHV� RI� DOO� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� IURP� ����� WR� �����ZLWK� WKHLU�DVVHVVPHQW� RQ� HDFK� WD[� OLVW� DQG� ZKHWKHU� WKH\� VLJQHG� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� RU�
DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ���� 2QH� KXQGUHG� ILYH� YLOODJHUV� VLJQHG� WKH�SUR�3DUULV�SHWLWLRQ�� ILIW\�IRXU�ZHUH� HLWKHU�DGXOW�PDOH� KRXVHKROGHUV� RU� FKXUFK�PHP�
EHUV�ZKR� ZHUH� TXDOLILHG� WR�SD\� YLOODJH� WD[HV� IRU� WKH�PLQLVWU\�� 2I� WKH�
HLJKW\�IRXU� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� VLJQHUV�� IRUW\� ZHUH� DGXOW� KRXVHKROGHUV� RU�
FKXUFK� PHPEHUV�� $Q� DGGLWLRQDO� VHYHQWHHQ� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH� ����� DQWL�3DUULV�
SHWLWLRQ�ZHUH� VL[WHHQ�\HDU�ROG� PHQ�� WRR� \RXQJ� WR� EH� DVVHVVHG� LQ� WKH�
SHULRG� RI�WKH�RXWEUHDN��7ZR� KXQGUHG� WD[SD\HUV� DSSHDUHG�
RQ� RQH� RU�PRUH� RI� WKH� VHYHQ� DVVHVV�
PHQWV� WDNHQ�GXULQJ� WKH� WZR�GHFDGHV�� )LIW\�WKUHH�RI� WKH�ILIW\�IRXU�DGXOW�PDOH� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� DSSHDUHG�
RQ� WKH� WD[� UROOV� DW� VRPH�
WLPH��2I� WKH�RSSRVLWLRQ� JURXS�� WKLUW\�VHYHQ�RI� WKH�IRUW\�DGXOW�PDOH� SHWL�WLRQHUV�DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH�UROOV�DW� VRPH� SRLQW�� ,Q�DGGLWLRQ� RQH�ZLGRZ� RI�D�
PDOH� SHWLWLRQHU� DQG� VHYHQ� RI� WKH� VHYHQWHHQ� DQWL�3DUULV� \RXQJ� PHQ�
VKRZHG� XS� RQ� WKH�UDWHV�EHJLQQLQJ� LQ���������7KHUH� DUH� D� QXPEHU� RI� FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� WR� NHHS� LQ�PLQG� DERXW� WKHVH�
GDWD�� 7KH\� VXSSO\� LQIRUPDWLRQ� RQO\� DERXW� 6DOHP�9LOODJH� WD[SD\HUV��7KH�DVVHVVPHQWV� DUH� DOVR� RQO\� DQ�
DSSUR[LPDWLRQ� RI�ZHDOWK�� WKH� GRFXPHQWV� DUH�
LPSUHFLVH�DERXW�ZKHWKHU� WKH�UDWHV�UHIOHFWHG�DOO�FRPSRQHQWV� RI�ZHDOWK�� VXFK�DV�SHUVRQDO� SURSHUW\�RU�DQ\�SURSHUW\�KHOG� RXWVLGH� WKH�YLOODJH��0RUHRYHU� WD[�DVVHVVPHQWV� LQ� JHQHUDO�
FDQ� EH� PLVOHDGLQJ�� $� ORZ� UDWH�PD\� VLJQDO� KXPEOH� RU�
PRGHVW� FLUFXPVWDQFHV�� \HW� LW� FRXOG� DOVR� PHDQ� WKDW� WKH� WD[SD\HU� ZDV� WKH�
\RXQJ� VRQ� RI� D�ZHOO�WR�GR� UHVLGHQW� ZKR� VWRRG� WR� LQKHULW� FRQVLGHUDEOH� SURS�
HUW\�LQ�WKH�QHDU� IXWXUH��6LPLODUO\��DQ� DGXOW�ZLWK� D�KLJK� DVVHVVPHQW� RQ� RQH�WD[� OLVW� EXW� ZKRVH� SRVLWLRQ� SOXPPHWHG� LQ� WKH� QH[W� UHFRUG� PD\� KDYH� JUDQWHG�
SRUWLRQV� RI�KLV� HVWDWH� WR�KLV� FKLOGUHQ� DQG�� WKRXJK�KROGLQJ� OHVV�ODQG�KLPVHOI��UHWDLQHG� WKH�DELOLW\� WR�WDS�WKH�UHVRXUFHV�RI�KLV�IDPLO\����
���$� FRPPRQ� SUREOHP� ZLWK� TXDQWLWDWLYH� GDWD� LV� WKH� SURSHU� OLQNLQJ� RI� D� QDPH�ZLWK� LWV�DVVRFLDWHG� YDULDEOHV�� &RQVWUXFWLQJ� WKH� 6DOHP� GDWD� VHW� LV�QR� H[FHSWLRQ�� 7KHUH�DUH�� KRZHYHU�� WRR� IHZ� XQFHUWDLQ� FDVHV� WR� DIIHFW� WKH� DQDO\VLV�� 7KLV� GDWD� VHW� DQG� WKH�
DQDO\VLV� WKDW� IROORZV� DUH� SDUW� RI� D� ODUJHU�:HE� VLWH� SURMHFW� WKDW�ZLOO� PDNH�WKHVH� GDWD�DYDLODEOH� WR� UHVHDUFKHUV� DQG� VWXGHQWV� DQG� SUHVHQW� DQ� LQWHUDFWLYH� LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ� RI� YDUL�RXV� JHRJUDSKLF� DQG� VRFLRHFRQRPLF� GLPHQVLRQV� RI� 6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW��
���5HEHFFD� 3UHVWRQ�� ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� ZDV� DVVHVVHG� DV�7KRPDV�3UHVWRQV� ZLGRZ� RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW� DIWHU� KHU� KXVEDQG� GLHG�� ,�KDYH� WUHDWHG� 7KRPDV� DQG�5HEHFFD� 3UHVWRQV� WD[HV� DV� D� FRQWLQXRXV� VHULHV�� VLQFH� ERWK� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWL�WLRQ�� )LYH� IHPDOH� WD[SD\HUV� LQ�DOO� DSSHDUHG� DW� RQH� WLPH� RU� DQRWKHU� RQ� WKHVH� WD[� OLVWV��DOO� ZHUH� ZLGRZV�� )RXU� DSSHDUHG� RQ� RQO\� D� VLQJOH� \HDUV� OLVW�� DQG� RQO\� WKH�ZLGRZ�3UHVWRQ� VLJQHG� D� SHWLWLRQ�� 0DU\� 3XWQDP�� PRWKHU� RI� DQWL�3DUULV� OHDGHU� -RVHSK�3XWQDP�� UDD\� KDYH� V\PSDWKL]HG� ZLWK� KHU� VRQV� FDXVH�� \HW� XQOLNH� KHU� VRQ� VKH� GLG� QRW�
VLJQ� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� 6KH� SDLG� WD[HV� LQ� WKH� ����� DQG� ����� DVVHVVPHQWV� EXW� QRW�LQ� ������ WKH�ILUVW� DVVHVVPHQW� IROORZLQJ� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� HSLVRGH��
���'LVWULEXWLQJ� SURSHUW\� WR� D� VRQ� FRXOG� UHVXOW� LQ�D� ORZHU� WD[� UDWH� DQG� HFRQRPLF�
UDQNLQJ�� WKRXJK� QRW� DOZD\V�� )DWKHUV� PLJKW�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� DFTXLUH� QHZ� ODQG� WR� GLV�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
)LQDOO\�� WR� FRPSDUH� WD[� OHYHOV� DFURVV� \HDUV�� UHDGHUV� PXVW� UHFDOO� WKDW�
WKH�WRWDO� WD[� OHYLHG�E\�6DOHP�9LOODJH� RQ� WKH�FRPPXQLW\� IOXFWXDWHG� IURP�
\HDU� WR� \HDU� DV� WKH�PLQLVWU\V� H[SHQVHV� FKDQJHG�� 7KXV� YDULDWLRQV� LQ� D� WD[�
SD\HUV� DVVHVVPHQW� IURP� RQH� \HDU� WR� DQRWKHU� GR� QRW� QHFHVVDULO\� VLJQLI\�
FKDQJHV� LQ�HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ�� LW�PD\� VLPSO\� LQGLFDWH� WKDW�GLIIHUHQW�DPRXQWV� RI� PRQH\� ZHUH�
UHTXLUHG� E\� WKH� FRPPXQLW\� LQ� GLIIHUHQW� \HDUV��
7KHUHIRUH� D�SHUVRQV� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ�
PXVW� EH� PHDVXUHG� UHODWLYH� WR�
RWKHUV� RQ� WKH�VDPH� WD[� OLVW��6XFK� FKDQJHV� LQ�UHODWLYH�ZHDOWK� LQGLFDWH� KRZ�PHPEHUV� RI� WKH�YLOODJHV� WZR� IDFWLRQV� IDUHG� RYHU� WLPH� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK�HDFK� RWKHU����
'HVSLWH� LQWHUSUHWLYH�DQG�PHWKRGRORJLFDO� GLIILFXOWLHV�� WKH�UDWHV�6DOHP�
9LOODJHV� FRPPLWWHH� HVWDEOLVKHG� UHPDLQ� D� YDOXDEOH� PHDQV� IRU� DVFHUWDLQLQJ�WKH� UHODWLYH� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� RI� WKH� YLOODJHV� SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV� IDF�
WLRQV� RYHU� WLPH�� $� ILUVW� VWHS� LV� WR� WUDFH� WKHLU� PRYHPHQW� LQ� WKH� \HDUV�
EHIRUH� �����E\�FRPSDULQJ� LQIRUPDWLRQ� IURP�WKH�WD[� OLVW�RI� ������ WKH�UDWH�PRVW� SUR[LPDWH� WR� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN�� ZLWK� WKH� DVVHVVPHQW� RI� ������
WKH� HDUOLHVW� H[WDQW� UHFRUGLQJ� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH�WD[HV�� 7KHVH� WZR� UHFRUGV�
FRYHU� WKH� HQWLUH� GHFDGH� SULRU� WR� WKH� RXWEUHDN�� 7KH� UHVXOWV� RI� XVLQJ� D� YDUL�
HW\�RI�PHDVXUHPHQWV� SDLQW� D� GLIIHUHQW�SLFWXUH� RI� IDFWLRQDO� PRELOLW\� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH� IURP�WKDW�SRUWUD\HG� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��7KRXJK� %R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� DUJXHG� WKDW� WKH� PLQLVWHUV� WUDGLWLRQDOLVW� VXSSRUWHUV� ZHUH�
IDOOLQJ� EHKLQG� WKHLU�PRGHUQL]LQJ� RSSRQHQWV�� WKH� WD[� UHFRUGV� UHYHDO�DOPRVW� WKH� UHYHUVH�� WKH� PDLQVWD\V� RI� WKH� FKXUFK� ZHUH� WKH� RQHV� ZKR�
LPSURYHG� WKHLU� VWDQGLQJ�ZKLOH� WKRVH�ZKR� RSSRVHG� WKH�PLQLVWU\� EDUHO\�KHOG� WKHLU�RZQ� DQG�� LQGHHG��PD\�ZHOO� KDYH� GHFOLQHG� LQ�VWDQGLQJ��
7KH� PRVW� GLUHFW� ZD\� WR� FRPSDUH� WKH� H[SHULHQFHV� RI� WKH� PHPEHUV� RI�
WKH� SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQV� LV� WR� LGHQWLI\� WKRVH� ZKR� ZHUH� SHUVLVWHUV��GHILQHG� DV� WD[SD\HUV�ZKR� DSSHDUHG� RQ� ERWK� WD[�OLVWV�DQG� DOVR� VLJQHG�RQH� RI�WKH������SHWLWLRQV�� &DOFXODWLQJ� WKH�UHODWLYH�SRVLWLRQ� RI�WKHVH�SDUWLVDQV� GXU�
LQJ�D�GHFDGH� IXUQLVKHV� HYLGHQFH� DERXW� ZKHWKHU� DV� LQGLYLGXDOV� DQG� DV� D�
JURXS� WKHLU� VWDQGLQJ� LPSURYHG�� GHFOLQHG�� RU� UHPDLQHG� VWDEOH�� )LIW\�
WULEXWH� WR� D� VRQ� VR� WKDW�ZKHQ� WKH� VRQ� ILUVW� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� WD[� OLVW�� WKH� IDWKHUV� WD[�UDWH� UHPDLQHG� UHODWLYHO\� FRQVWDQW�� -RKQ� %X[WRQ�� ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ��DSSHDUHG� RQ� HDFK� YLOODJH� WD[� OLVW�IURP� ����� WR� ������ +LV� UDQN� DPRQJ� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�UDQJHG� IURP� WKH� WRS� HLJKW\�HLJKWK� SHUFHQWLOH� WR� WKH� QLQHW\�ILUVW� SHUFHQWLOH�� +LV� VRQ�
-RKQ� -U���ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� XQGHU� WKH� FDWHJRU\� RI� �\RXQJ� PHQ� ���
\HDUV� ROG��� ILUVW� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� YLOODJH� WD[� UROOV� LQ� ������ SD\LQJ� D� WD[� IRU� ODQG� WKDW�
SODFHG� KLP� LQ� WKH� ERWWRP� ���SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� UROO��+LV� IDWKHUV� UDQNLQJ� GLG� QRW� VLJQLIL�FDQWO\� FKDQJH� LQ� WKDW� \HDU��0DQ\� RWKHU� FDVHV�� VXFK� DV� WKH� )XOOHU� IDPLO\� DQG� WKH� IDPLO\�RI� 6DPXHO� 1XUVH�� VKRZHG� D� VLPLODU� ODFN� RI� HIIHFW� RQ� D� IDWKHUV� HFRQRPLF� UDQN�ZKHQ�VRQV� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� WD[� UROOV� IRU� WKH�ILUVW� WLPH��
���&KDQJHV� LQ� D� YLOODJHUV� UHODWLYH� VWDQGLQJ� GR� QRW� QHFHVVDULO\� GHQRWH� FKDQJHV� LQ�
DEVROXWH� ZHDOWK�� $� GHFOLQLQJ� FRPPXQLW\�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� FRXOG� ORZHU� HYHU\RQHV� HFR�QRPLF� FRQGLWLRQ�� WKRXJK� D�SHUVRQV� UHODWLYH� SRVLWLRQ� LPSURYHG��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
YLOODJHUV�ZHUH� DVVHVVHG� WD[HV� LQ� ����� DQG� ������ RI�ZKRP� IRUW\�ILYH� VLJQHG�
RQH� RI� WKH� SHWLWLRQV�� WKXV� TXDOLI\LQJ� WKHP� DV� SHUVLVWHUV�� 7KHVH� IRUW\�ILYH�
SHUVLVWHUV� UHSUHVHQW� DOPRVW� KDOI� WKH�DGXOW�PDOHV� ZKR� VLJQHG� SHWLWLRQV� LQ�
������ 7KH� WZHQW\�IRXU� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKR� HYHQWXDOO\� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV�
SHWLWLRQ� FRQVWLWXWHG� DQ� HVSHFLDOO\� LPSUHVVLYH� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� DGXOW�PDOH� VLJQHUV� RI� WKDW� SHWLWLRQ�� 7KH� WZHQW\�RQH� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKR� HYHQWXDOO\�
VLJQHG� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� RQ� WKH�RWKHU� KDQG�� FRQVWLWXWHG� RQO\� ���SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� DGXOW� PDOH� VLJQHUV����
2QH� ZD\� WR�GHWHUPLQH� SHUVLVWHUV� HFRQRPLF� PRELOLW\� GXULQJ� WKH�����V� LV� WR� ORFDWH� DQG� FRPSDUH� HDFK� WD[SD\HUV� UDQNLQJ�
RQ� WKH� WZR� WD[�
OLVWV� WKURXJK� D� UDQN� DQG� SHUFHQWLOH� DQDO\VLV�� 7KLV� WHFKQLTXH� UHYHDOV�ZKHWKHU� SHUVLVWHUV� FKDQJHG� WKHLU�VWDQGLQJ� LQ�WKH�FRPPXQLW\� GXULQJ� WKH�
����V��PRYLQJ�� IRU�H[DPSOH�� IURP� WKH�PLGGOLQJ� VL[W\�ILIWK�SHUFHQWLOH� RI�
WD[SD\HUV� WR� WKH� HOLWH� QLQHWLHWK� SHUFHQWLOH�� ,I� RQH� VHOHFWV� D�PLQLPXP� RI�
��� SHUFHQW� FKDQJH� LQ� UDQNLQJ�DV� D� VWDQGDUG� E\� ZKLFK� WR� PHDVXUH� WKH�
PRYHPHQW� RI� D�SHUVLVWHU�� WKH� UHVXOWV� VKRZ� OLWWOH� HYLGHQFH� WKDW� WKRVH� DVVR�
FLDWHG� ZLWK� RSSRVLWLRQ� WR� WKH� 3DUULV� PLQLVWU\� ZHUH�DGYDQFLQJ� UHODWLYH� WR�
RWKHUV� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH� GXULQJ� WKH�����V��2I� WKH�WZHQW\�IRXU�DQWL�3DUULV�
SHUVLVWHUV�� DOPRVW� ���SHUFHQW� �VHYHQ� RI� WZHQW\�IRXU��GHFOLQHG� DW� OHDVW� ���
SHUFHQW� LQ� WKHLU�SHUFHQWLOH� UDQNLQJ� GXULQJ� WKH�GHFDGH�� 0RUH� WKDQ� RQH�WKLUG� �IRXU�RI� HOHYHQ�� RI� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH�GHFDGH�LQ�WKH�WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI�YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�H[SHULHQFHG� D�GHFOLQH� RI�DW� OHDVW� ���
SHUFHQW� LQ� WKHLU� SHUFHQWLOH� UDQNLQJ�� (YHQ� PRUH�FRPSHOOLQJ�� WKUHH� RI� WKHVH�
DIIOXHQW�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�GURSSHG� IURP� WKH�WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV�LQWR�WKH�PLGGOH� UDQNV��GHILQHG� DV� WKH�WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� �UDQJLQJ�IURP�WKH�WZHQW\�ILIWK�WR� WKH�VHYHQW\�ILIWK�SHUFHQWLOHV�� RI�YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�GXU�
LQJ� WKLV� SHULRG�� QRW� D�VLQJOH� PLGGOLQJ� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU� URVH� WR� WKH� WRS�
TXDUWLOH� RI�YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� GXULQJ� WKH�GHFDGH�� 'HFOLQHV� LQ�SHUFHQWLOH�UDQNLQJ� RIWHQ� WUDQVODWHG� LQWR� QRWLFHDEOH� GURSV�
RQ� WKH� WD[SD\HU� UROO��
-RVHSK�+ROWRQ� 6U���RQH� RI� WKRVH�ZKR� IHOO�IURP� WKH� WRS�TXDUWLOH�� UDQNHG�ILIWHHQWK�DPRQJ� WD[SD\HUV� LQ� �����EXW� RQO\�ILIWLHWK� LQ� ������$QG� -RVHSK�+HUULFN� 6U��GURSSHG� IURP�HLJKWHHQWK� WR�WKLUW\�QLQWK�E\� ��������
���6LQFH� QRW� DOO� DGXOW� PDOH� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH� ����� SHWLWLRQV� DSSHDUHG� RQ� 6DOHP�
9LOODJH� WD[� OLVWV�� WKH� SHUFHQWDJH� RI� SHUVLVWHUV� LQ� ERWK� JURXSV� VRPHZKDW� XQGHUVWDWHV�WKHLU� UHODWLRQVKLS� WR� WKH� SHWLWLRQHUV� IRU�ZKRP� WKHUH� LV� WD[� GDWD�� 7KHUH� ZHUH� QLQHW\�IRXU� WD[SD\HUV� RQ� WKH� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� OLVW� IRU� ����� DQG� RQH� KXQGUHG� WD[SD\HUV� RQ� WKH�
����� OLVW�����7KH� JURXSV� RI� SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� DUH� WRR� VPDOO� IRU� WKHVH� FKDQJHV�
WR�EH� VWDWLVWLFDOO\� VLJQLILFDQW�� (YHQ� VR� WKH�GDWD� UHIOHFW� WKH� H[SHULHQFH� RI� DFWXDO� SHRSOH��DQG� WKH� FKDQJHV� LQ� WKHLU� UDQNLQJ�� ZKHWKHU� VWDWLVWLFDOO\� VLJQLILFDQW� RU� QRW�� GR� QRW� VXS�SRUW� WKH� DUJXPHQW� PDGH� E\� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXP� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��,�ZRXOG� OLNH� WR� WKDQN� 3URIHVVRU� -DQHW�0�� +XJKHV�� DFWLQJ� FKDLU� RI� WKH�'HSDUWPHQW� RI�%LRVWDWLVWLFV� RI�7XODQH� 8QLYHUVLW\V� 6FKRRO� RI� 3XEOLF� +HDOWK� DQG� 7URSLFDO� 0HGLFLQH��IRU� VWDWLVWLFDO� DVVLVWDQFH��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
$� FORVH� H[DPLQDWLRQ� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKRVH� UDQNLQJ�
GURSSHG� GXULQJ� WKH�����V� HYHQ� VXJJHVWV� WKH�SRVVLELOLW\� WKDW�WKHLU�GHFOLQH�ZDV� SDUWO\� GXH� WR� DOORFDWLRQV� RI� ODQG� WR� WKHLU� VRQV�� WKH�NLQG� RI� ODQG�
VFDUFLW\� WKDW� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� DWWULEXWHG� WR� WKHLU� RSSRQHQWV��
+HQU\� .HQQH\� 6U��� IRU� H[DPSOH�� UDQNHG� LQ� WKH� VL[W\�VHYHQWK� SHUFHQWLOH� RI�
WD[SD\HUV� LQ� �����EXW� RQO\� LQ�WKH� WZHQW\�ILUVW�SHUFHQWLOH� D�GHFDGH� ODWHU��ZKLFK� FRLQFLGHG� ZLWK� WKH�DSSHDUDQFH� RI�KLV� VRQ�+HQU\� .HQQH\� -U��RQ� WKH�WD[� UROOV�RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW��7KH� VRQ�� OLNHO\�ZLWK� VRPH� ODQGHG� DVVLVWDQFH�IURP�KLV� IDWKHU��ZDV� LQ�WKH�IRUWLHWK�SHUFHQWLOH�� $� VLPLODU� VWRU\�KROGV� IRU�WKH�ZHDOWKLHU� -RE�6ZLQQHUWRQ�� ZKRVH� UDQNLQJ� IHOO�IURP� WKH�HLJKW\�QLQWK�SHUFHQWLOH� WR�WKH�VHYHQW\�HLJKWK�SHUFHQWLOH� GXULQJ� WKH�����V�� 6ZLQQHUWRQV�WZR� VRQV� -DVSHU� DQG� -RVHSK� �ERUQ� LQ� ����� DQG� ������ UHVSHFWLYHO\�� ILUVW�
DSSHDU� RQ� WKH������ WD[� OLVW��%RWK� KHOG� RQO\� HQRXJK� SURSHUW\� WR�EH� LQ�WKH�
WZHQW\�ILIWK�SHUFHQWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV�� ,I��DV�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� FRQ�
WHQGHG�� ODQG� VFDUFLW\� DQG� WKH�GLYLVLRQ� RI� HVWDWHV� FRQWULEXWHG� WR�DQ� HFR�
QRPLF� VTXHH]H� LQ�6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� WKHUH� LV�HYLGHQFH� WKDW� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV�
JURXS� IHOW� LWV� HIIHFW� PRUH� WKDQ� WKH�PLQLVWHUV� VXSSRUWHUV����7KH� SHUFHQWDJH� UDQNLQJ� RI� PRVW� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� GLG� QRW�
GHFOLQH�� DQG� VHYHQ� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� LPSURYHG� WKHLU� HFRQRPLF� UDQN�
LQJ� DW� OHDVW� ��� SHUFHQW�� WKH� VDPH� QXPEHU� DV� WKRVH� ZKR� GHFOLQHG�� %XW�
VXFK�XSZDUG�PRYHPHQW� FRQFHQWUDWHG� ZLWKLQ� WKH�WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� RI�
WD[SD\HUV��$OO� EXW� WZR�RI� WKH�VHYHQ� VWDUWHG� WKH�GHFDGH� LQ�WKH�ORZHU� UDQJH�RI�PLGGOLQJ� WD[SD\HUV�� LQLWLDOO\� UDQNLQJ� IURP� WKH� WZHQW\�ILIWK� WR� WKH�ILIWLHWK�SHUFHQWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� LQ�������DQG� QRQH� URVH� LQWR� WKH�WRS�TXDU�WLOH�RI� WD[SD\HUV�E\� ������7KH� ODUJHVW�JURXS� RI�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� FRQ�
VLVWLQJ�RI� WHQ�SHRSOH�� UHPDLQHG� VWDEOH�GXULQJ� WKH�GHFDGH�� PRYLQJ� QHLWKHU�
XS� QRU� GRZQ� DW� OHDVW� ��� SHUFHQW� LQ� WKH� UDQNLQJ� RI� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV��7KHVH� WHQ�� FRQVWLWXWLQJ� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� KDUGO\� VXSSO\�HYLGHQFH� RI� D� JURXS� RQ� WKH� OHDGLQJ� HGJH� RI� HFRQRPLF� FKDQJH�� ,QGHHG��
JLYHQ� WKDW� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� HLWKHU� UHPDLQHG� VWDEOH�
RU�GHFOLQHG� LQ�UDQN�GXULQJ� WKH� ����V�� WKHUH� LV� OLWWOH�HYLGHQFH� RI�XSZDUG�PRELOLW\� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� SULRU�
WR� ������
7KH� IRUWXQHV� RI� WKH� WZHQW\�RQH� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKR� ODWHU� VLJQHG� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�SHWLWLRQ� DOVR� GR� QRW� FRQIRUP� WR� WKHLU�GHSLFWLRQ� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��7KHUH� LV�OLWWOH�HYLGHQFH� WKDW�PHPEHUV� RI�WKLV�JURXS�ZHUH� GHFOLQLQJ� UHODWLYH�
���6LGQH\� 3HUOH\�� 7KH�+LVWRU\� RI�6DOHP�0DVVDFKXVHWWV� �6DOHP�� 0DVV��� ������� ��������
YLHZHG� DW� 5D\�� �6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV��� KWWS���HWH[W�YLUJLQLD�HGX�VDOHP�ZLWFKFUDIW��3HUOH\�YROL�LPDJHV�SL�����KWPO�� 1RQH� RI� WKH� IRXU� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKRVH� VWDQG�
LQJ� VLJQLILFDQWO\� GHFOLQHG� GXULQJ� WKH� ����V� KDG� VRQV�ZKR� PDGH� WKHLU� ILUVW� DSSHDUDQFH�RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW��7KH� WD[� OLVW� VXSSOLHV� RQO\� LQGLUHFW� HYLGHQFH� DERXW� ODQG� VXFFHVVLRQ�DQG� FDQ� RQO\� EH� VXJJHVWLYH� RI� ODQG� GLVWULEXWLRQV� HIIHFWV�ZLWKLQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� IDPL�OLHV�� ,Q� DQ\� HYHQW� WKHVH� FDVHV� LQYROYH� D� VPDOO� QXPEHU� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV��WKXV�PLQLPL]LQJ� WKH� H[SODQDWRU\� HIIHFW� RI� ODQG� DOORFDWLRQ� RQ�PRELOLW\��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
WR�RWKHU� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV� LQ�WKH�GHFDGH� SUHFHGLQJ� WKH�RXWEUHDN�� 2QO\� ���
SHUFHQW� �IRXU�RI� WZHQW\�RQH�� RI� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� GHFOLQHG� DW� OHDVW���� SHUFHQW� LQ� WKHLU� UDQNLQJ� DPRQJ� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� GXULQJ� WKH� ����V��
FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� DOPRVW� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� 0RUH� LPSUHV�VLYH� LV�WKH�QXPEHU� RI�SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�ZKR� LPSURYHG� WKHLU�VWDQGLQJ�RU� UHPDLQHG� VWDEOH�� )RUW\�WKUHH� SHUFHQW� �QLQH� RI� WZHQW\�RQH�� LPSURYHG�WKHLU�UDQNLQJ� DW� OHDVW� ���SHUFHQW�� DQG� HLJKW� RWKHUV� QHLWKHU� URVH�QRU� IHOO��
7KHUHIRUH�� PRUH� WKDQ� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� �VHYHQWHHQ�
RI� WZHQW\�RQH�� VKRZHG� QR� GHFOLQH�� HLWKHU� ULVLQJ� RU� UHPDLQLQJ� VWDEOH��
6LJQLILFDQWO\�� QRW� D� VLQJOH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU�ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH�GHFDGH� LQ�
WKH� WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� IHOO�RXW� RI� WKDW� UDQN�� RI� WKHLU�DGYHUVDULHV��WKUHH�GURSSHG� LQWR� WKH�WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� E\�GHFDGHV� HQG�� (YHQ�PRUH�
LPSUHVVLYH�� ILYH� RI� WKH� VHYHQ� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH� GHFDGH�
LQ�WKHVH�PLGGOH� UDQNV�RI� WD[SD\HUV� DQG� LPSURYHG� WKHLU�SRVLWLRQ� DW� OHDVW�WHQ�SHUFHQWDJH� SRLQWV� ILQLVKHG� WKH�GHFDGH� LQ� WKH� WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI�YLOODJH�WD[SD\HUV��1R� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU� VKRZHG� D� VLPLODU� OHDS� LQWR� WKH�YLOODJHV�XSSHU� HFKHORQ�� 7KURXJKRXW� WKH� ����V� DOPRVW� DOO� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�VKRZHG� QR� GHFOLQH� LQ� WKHLU�SRVLWLRQ� LQ�6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� 7KH� ZHDOWKLHVW�
SUR�3DUULV�PHQ� DW� WKH� GHFDGHV� EHJLQQLQJ�
ZHUH� QRW�VTXHH]HG�
RXW� RI� WKH�
WRS� UDQNV�RI�YLOODJH� VRFLHW\��HLWKHU�E\� ODQG� VFDUFLW\�RU�RWKHU�PHDQV�� $QG�
E\�GHFDGHV� HQG� WKH\�ZHUH� MRLQHG� DW� WKH�XSSHU� HQG� RI� WKH�VFDOH� E\�RWKHUV�ZKR� KDG� EHJXQ� LQ�PRUH� PRGHVW� FLUFXPVWDQFHV����
���$V� ZLWK� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� WKHVH� FKDQJHV� LQ�SHUFHQWLOH� UDQNLQJ� E\� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� RIWHQ� WUDQVODWHG� LQWR�PDUNHG� VKLIWV� LQ� D� WD[SD\HUV� QXPHULFDO� VWDQG�
LQJ��7ZR� PHPEHUV� RI� WKH� 3XWQDP� IDPLO\�� (GZDUG� DQG� -RQDWKDQ�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� EHJDQ�WKH� L��RV� UDQNHG� WKLUW\�HLJKWK� DQG� WKLUW\�QLQWK�� UHVSHFWLYHO\�� 7KH\� EHJDQ� WKH� QH[W�
GHFDGH� UDQNHG� HLJKWHHQWK� DQG� ILIWHHQWK�� ERWK� LQ� WKH� WRS� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV�� 8VLQJ�D� ORZHU� SHUFHQWLOH� VWDQGDUG� DFFHQWXDWHV� WKHVH�PRYHPHQWV� ZKHUHDV� D� KLJKHU� VWDQGDUG�PXWHV� WKHP�� ,I� D� FKDQJH� LQ� UDQN� RUGHU� RI� RQO\� ��SHUFHQW� LV� DGRSWHG�� WKH� XSZDUG�PRELOLW\� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� LV�PRUH� HYLGHQW�� XVLQJ� D� ��� SHUFHQW� VWDQGDUG�
HPSKDVL]HV� WKH� VWDELOLW\� RI� WKH�JURXS�� (YLGHQFH� WKDW� WKH�PLQLVWU\V� OR\DOLVWV� ZHUH� QRW�
LQ�GHFOLQH� GRHV� QRW� GLUHFWO\� DGGUHVV� WKH� FRQWHQWLRQ� WKDW� WKH\�ZHUH� WUDGLWLRQDO� DJUDUL�DQV� ORFNHG� LQ� FRQIOLFW� ZLWK� WKRVH� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� DQ� HPHUJLQJ� FDSLWDOLVWLF� RUGHU�� %XW�LW�HQFRXUDJHV� D�PRUH� VNHSWLFDO� ORRN� DW� WKH� HYLGHQFH� WKDW� VXFK� D� FRQIOLFW� H[LVWHG�� (YHQ�LQ�3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXPV� RZQ� DFFRXQW�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� 3XWQDP�
IDPLO\�� PRVW� RI�ZKRP� ZHUH� SURPLQHQW� VXSSRUWHUV� RI� WKH�PLQLVWU\�� HQJDJHG� LQ� FRP�PHUFH� DQG� PDQXIDFWXULQJ�� WKRXJK� WKH\� GLG� VR� XQVXFFHVVIXOO\�� DQG� 7KRPDV� 3XWQDP�
-U���ZKRVH� KRXVH� ZDV� WKH� HSLFHQWHU� RI�ZLWFKFUDIW� HQWKXVLDVP�� �KDG� HYHU\� KRSH����� RI�
PDNLQJ� KLV�ZD\� �� �� ��LQWR� �� �� �� >WKH@� YDULHG� FRPPHUFLDO� DFWLYLWLHV�� RI�KLV�ZLIHV� IDPLO\��6HH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� �������� �����7KH� 3XWQDP� IDUPODQG�LQFOXGHG� H[WHQVLYH� DSSOH� RUFKDUGV�� VXLWDEOH� IRU� FRPPHUFLDO� DFWLYLW\�� DQG� 7KRPDV�3XWQDP� 6U�V� ZLOO� RI� ����� UHIHUUHG� WR� KLV� �PLOO� VWRQH� DQG� FLGHU� PLOO� DQG� DSSXUWH�QDQFHV��� 6HH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP�9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW�� ����� +DUROG� 3XWQDP��7KH� 3XWQDPV� RI�6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� ,QFOXGLQJ� DQ� /QGH[� RI�3XWQDP� 'HHGV� DQG�:LOOV� IURP� �����WR������ �5RFNODQG�� 0DLQH�� ������� ���� 6DPXHO� 3DUULV� KDG� EHHQ� D�PHUFKDQW� EHIRUH� WXUQ�
LQJ� WR� WKH�PLQLVWU\�� ,Q� VKRUW� WKHUH� DUH� UHDVRQV� DVLGH� IURP� WKH� WD[� GDWD� WR� TXHVWLRQ� D�
WKHVLV� WKDW� LGHQWLILHV� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� IDUPHUV� DQG� FKXUFK� VXSSRUWHUV� ZLWK� UHVLVWDQFH�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
2WKHU� HYLGHQFH�� VXFK� DV� WKH� DYHUDJH� �PHDQ�� DQG� PHGLDQ� WD[HV� RI� SHU�
VLVWHUV� DV� D� JURXS�� FRQILUPV� WKH� LGHD� WKDW� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� IDFWLRQV� ZHUH�
QRW� H[SHULHQFLQJ� WKH�SDWWHUQ� RI�PRELOLW\� SUHVHQWHG� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��%HFDXVH� WKH� DPRXQW� RI� UHYHQXH� UHTXLUHG� IRU� PDLQWDLQLQJ� WKH� YLOODJHV�
PLQLVWU\� ZDV� QRW� FRQVWDQW� DQG� WKH� QXPEHU� RI� WD[SD\HUV� DOVR� YDULHG� IURP�
OLVW� WR� OLVW�� D� FKDQJH� LQ�D� SHUVRQV� DVVHVVPHQW� PD\� UHIOHFW�KLJKHU� �RU�ORZHU�� FKDUJHV� DSSOLFDEOH� WR�DOO� WD[SD\HUV� UDWKHU�WKDQ�DQ� DFWXDO� FKDQJH� LQ�KLV� DVVHVVHG� ZHDOWK�� 2QH� FDQ� FRQWURO� IRU� VXFK� YDULDWLRQV� LQ� WKH� JHQHUDO�WD[�EXUGHQ� E\�HVWDEOLVKLQJ� D� UDWLR�RI� WD[HV�SDLG� E\� WKH�PHPEHUV� RI�HDFK�IDFWLRQ� UHODWLYH� WR� WKH� HQWLUH� YLOODJH�
WD[� OLVW�� ,Q� FRPSDULQJ� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[�
RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZLWK� WKH� DYHUDJH� IRU� WKH� HQWLUH� YLOODJH�WD[� UROO��
IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� UDWLR� ����ZRXOG� PHDQ� WKDW� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�
ZDV� ���� WLPHV� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKH� YLOODJH� DYHUDJH�� 6LPLODUO\��WKH�UHODWLYH�SRVLWLRQ� RI�RQH� IDFWLRQ� WR�DQRWKHU� LV�HVWDEOLVKHG� E\�D� UDWLR�RI�WKH�PHPEHUV� WD[HV�� ,I� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[�
SDLG� E\� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�
JURXS� UHODWLYH� WR� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKHLU� ULYDOV� LQFUHDVHG� RYHU� WLPH�� IRU�
LQVWDQFH�� WKH� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� ZRXOG� KDYH�
LPSURYHG� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS����,QIRUPDWLRQ� JOHDQHG� IURP�WKH�DYHUDJH� DQG�PHGLDQ� WD[HV�SDLG� E\� WKH�
WZR� SHUVLVWHU� JURXSV� SULRU� WR� ����� VXSSRUWV� WKH� QRWLRQ� RI� LPSURYHPHQW�
E\� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� GXULQJ� WKH�GHFDGH� EHIRUH� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� RXW�EUHDN�� 'XULQJ� WKH� ����V� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�
SHUVLVWHUV� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKDW� RI� WKH� HQWLUH� YLOODJH� LQFUHDVHG� IURP� ���� WR�
����� 7KH� PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� RQ� DYHUDJH� ZDV� QRW� MXVW� EHWWHU� RII� WKDQ� 6DOHP�
9LOODJHUV� LQ� JHQHUDO� EXW� EHFDPH� VRPHZKDW� PRUH� VR�� 2Q� WKH� RWKHU� KDQG��
WKH� WZHQW\�IRXU� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� GLG� QRW� GR� DV�ZHOO� GXULQJ� WKLV�
SHULRG�� 7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKHLU� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW� DFWXDOO\� GHFOLQHG� FRPSDUHG�
WR� FRPPHUFH� DQG� FDSLWDOLVP�� 3HUKDSV� DZDUH� RI� WKLV� FRQIOLFWLQJ� HYLGHQFH�� WKH� DXWKRUV�
DGMXVW� WKHLU� WKHVLV� DW� YDULRXV� SRLQWV� E\� DUJXLQJ� WKDW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� YLOODJHUV� ZHUH�
EHLQJ� �OXUH>G@�� DQG� �WUDQVIRUP>HG@�� E\� WKH� IRUFHV� WKH\� UHVLVWHG�� 7KXV� WKH\�ZHUH� �DW�ZDU� ZLWK� WKHPVHOYHV�� DV�ZHOO� DV�ZLWK� WKH� IRUFHV� DQG� UHSUHVHQWDWLYHV� RI�PRGHUQL]DWLRQ��6HH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� ����� �������� $VLGH� IURP� LWV� VSHFXODWLRQ�DERXW� WKH� SV\FKRORJLFDO� VWDWH� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS�� WKH� GLYLGHG�PLQG� DUJXPHQW�XQGHUFXWV� WKH�PDLQ� WKHVLV� RI� D� EDWWOH� EHWZHHQ� WUDGLWLRQDO� DJUDULDQV� DQG� FRPPHUFLDO�
FDSLWDOLVWV�� :LWKLQ� LWV�RZQ� H[SODQDWRU\� IUDPHZRUN�� WKH� HYLGHQFH� PLJKW� EHWWHU� ILW� DQ�
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ� WKDW� WHQVLRQ� H[LVWHG� EHWZHHQ� GLIIHUHQW� IRUPV� RI� FDSLWDOLVP�� DQ�
DJUDULDQ�EDVHG� FDSLWDOLVP� UHSUHVHQWHG� E\� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IRUFHV� DQG� D� FRPPHUFLDO�
FDSLWDOLVP� UHSUHVHQWHG� E\� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS�����0HDQV� �RU� DYHUDJHV�� DQG� PHGLDQV� FDSWXUH� VRPHZKDW� GLIIHUHQW� DVSHFWV� RI� D�
JURXSV� FHQWUDO� WHQGHQF\�� 7KH� DYHUDJH� LV� VXEMHFW� WR� H[WUHPH� YDOXHV�� ZKHUHDV� WKH�PHGLDQ� EHWWHU� UHSUHVHQWV� WKH� FHQWUDO� WHQGHQF\� RI� D� JURXS�� (DFK� WRRO�� KRZHYHU�� IXU�QLVKHV� XVHIXO� LQIRUPDWLRQ� WR� VXSSOHPHQW� WKH� UDQN� DQG� SHUFHQWLOH� ILQGLQJV� IRU� LQGL�YLGXDOV�� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXP� SUHVHQWHG� RQO\� WD[� DYHUDJHV� ZKHQ�
FRPSDULQJ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� WZR� IDFWLRQV��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
ZLWK� WKDW� RI� WKH� YLOODJH� IURP� ���� WR� ����� $V� D� UHVXOW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLV�WHUV�� ZKRVH� DYHUDJH� WD[� ZDV� RQO\� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKDW� RI� WKHLU� DQWL�3DUULV�
QHLJKERUV� DW� WKH�EHJLQQLQJ� RI� WKH� ����V�� HVWDEOLVKHG� WKHPVHOYHV� DV� WKHLU�
HTXDOV� VKRUWO\�EHIRUH� WKH�RQVHW� RI�ZLWFKFUDIW� DFFXVDWLRQV�� WKH�UDWLR�RI� WKH�WZR�
JURXSV�PHDQ� WD[� LQ� ����� ZDV� ����� $� FRPSDULVRQ� RI� WKH� WZR�
JURXSV�PHGLDQ� WD[� RIIHUV� HYHQ� PRUH�
FRPSHOOLQJ� HYLGHQFH�� 7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� SUR�
3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU� PHGLDQ� WD[� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH� YLOODJHV� PHGLDQ� WD[� URVH�
IURP� ���� WR� ���� GXULQJ� WKH� ����V� ZKLOH� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLV�WHU�PHGLDQ� WD[� WR� WKH� PHGLDQ� YLOODJH�
WD[� URVH� OHVV�� IURP� ���� WR� ����� $V� D�
UHVXOW� WKH�SUR�3DUULV�PHGLDQ� WD[��ZKLFK� KDG� EHHQ� RQO\� ���SHUFHQW� RI� WKH�PHGLDQ� WD[� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� LQ� ������ DFWXDOO\� H[FHHGHG� WKH� DQWL�
3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[� E\� ������ ,W�ZDV� ���� WLPHV� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKDW� RI� WKH� DQWL�
3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� 7KH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� UHPDLQHG� EHWWHU� RII� WKDQ� 6DOHP�
9LOODJHUV� LQ�JHQHUDO�� \HW� WKH\�ZHUH� QRW� RXWSDFLQJ� WKHLU�ULYDOV��PRUH� OLNHO\��WKH\�ZHUH�ZDWFKLQJ� WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� JDLQ� DQG� SHUKDSV� VXUSDVV� WKHP�
�7DEOH� ,�����
$GPLWWHGO\�� RQH� PXVW� SURIIHU� WKHVH� FRQFOXVLRQV� ZLWK� DQ� DEXQGDQFH�
RI� FDXWLRQ�� 7KH� QXPEHUV� LQYROYHG� DUH� VPDOO� DQG� WKH� SHUVLVWHUV� FRQVWL�
WXWHG� OHVV�WKDQ�KDOI� WKH�DGXOW�PDOHV� ZKR� VLJQHG� WKH�SHWLWLRQV� LQ�������%XW�
LQFRUSRUDWLQJ� WKH�QDPHV� RI�PHPEHUV� RI�6DOHP�9LOODJHV� IDFWLRQV�ZKR� GLG�QRW� DSSHDU� RQ� ERWK� WKH� ����� DQG� ����� WD[� UHFRUGV� VWUHQJWKHQV� WKHVH� GDWD��
:LWK� RQH� H[FHSWLRQ� WKLV� DGGLWLRQ� LQYROYHV� QHZ� WD[SD\HUV� ZKR� ILUVW�
DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH������ WD[� OLVW�DQG� HYHQWXDOO\� VLJQHG� RQH� RI� WKH�SHWLWLRQV��&RPELQLQJ� WKHVH�QDPHV� ZLWK� WKRVH� RI� WKH�SHUVLVWHUV� KDV� GUDZEDFNV� LQ�WKDW� GLVVLPLODU� JURXSV� DUH�
EHLQJ� FRPSDUHG�� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� FRQWLQJHQW�QRZ� IRXQG� RQ� WKH� ����� UROO�� IRU�H[DPSOH�� LV�QRW� LGHQWLFDO� WR� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� RQ� WKH� ����� UROO��1HYHUWKHOHVV� LGHQWLI\LQJ� DOO� SHWLWLRQHUV�DSSHDULQJ� RQ� HLWKHU� WD[� OLVW�\LHOGV� D� FROOHFWLRQ� RI�QDPHV� WKDW� LV�D� ODUJHU�UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ� RI� WKH� WZR� IDFWLRQV�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� QRZ� LQFOXGHV�
WZHQW\�WZR� WD[SD\HUV� DSSHDULQJ�RQ� WKH� ����� DVVHVVPHQW� DQG� WKLUW\�HLJKW�
RQ� WKH� ����� UROO�� 7KH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� QRZ� FRQVLVWV� RI� WKH� WZHQW\�IRXU�DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW� �DOO� RI�ZKRP�� LQFLGHQWDOO\�� UH�
DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH������ OLVW��DQG� WKLUW\�IRXU�WD[SD\HUV�RQ� WKH������ UROO��
&RPSDULQJ� WKH� FKDUDFWHULVWLFV� RI� WKHVH� H[SDQGHG� JURXSV� JHQHUDOO\�VXEVWDQWLDWHV� WKH� LGHD� WKDW� 3DUULVV� VXSSRUWHUV� ZHUH� QRW�
RXWVWULSSLQJ� WKHLU�
ULYDOV� SULRU� WR� WKH� RXWEUHDN�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[�FRPSDUHG� ZLWK�
WKH�YLOODJH� DYHUDJH� WD[�GHFOLQHG� IURP� �����WR������� IURP�D� UDWLR�RI� ����WR�
����� \HW� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW� GHFOLQHG� HYHQ� PRUH�� IURP� ����WR� ����� %RWK� IDFWLRQV� UHPDLQHG� VRPHZKDW� EHWWHU� RII�� RQ� DYHUDJH�� WKDQ�
���7KDW� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[�� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV��GHFOLQHG� ZKHUHDV� WKH�JURXSV� PHGLDQ� UDWLR� URVH�PD\� EH� SDUWO\� H[SODLQHG� E\� WKH�GDPS�HQLQJ� HIIHFW� RI� WKRVH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH� GHFDGH� RI� WKH� ����V� LQ� WKH�
WRS� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� EXW� IHOO� LQWR� WKH� WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� RI� WD[SD\HUV� E\� LWV�HQG��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
7DEOH� ,�3HUVLVWHU� 7D[� 5DWLRV�
����� �����
SUR�3DUULV� DQWL�3DUULV� SUR�3DUULV� DQWL�3DUULV�
0HDQ� WD[�
�VKLOOLQJV�� ������ ������ ������������5DWLR� ����� �����
0HGLDQ� WD[�
�VKLOOLQJV�� ������ ������ ������������5DWLR� ����� �����
1RWHV�� :LWK� SUR�3DUULV� WD[� UDWLRV��1 �L� IRU� �����DQG� ������ZLWK� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[� UDWLRV��
1 ��� IRU������DQG� ������6RXUFHV�� �$� %RRN� RI� 5HFRUG� RI� WKH� 6HYHUDOO� 3XEOLTXH� 7UDQVDFWLRQV� RI� WKH�
,QKDELWDQWV� RI� 6DOH>P@� 9LOODJH� 9XOJDUO\� &DOOHG� WKH�)DUPH>V@��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV� RI�WKH�'DQYHUV� +LVWRULFDO� 6RFLHW\� �6DOHP�� 0DVV��� ���������� ������������ ���� ������� 3DXO� %R\HU�DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP�9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW�� $� 'RFXPHQWDU\� 5HFRUG� RI�/RFDO�
&RQIOLFW� LQ�&RORQLDO� 1HZ� (QJODQG� �%HOPRQW�� &DOLI�� ������� ��������
6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV� LQ� JHQHUDO�� EXW� WKH� PLQLVWHUV� VXSSRUWHUV� ZHUH�FDWFKLQJ�
XS� WR� WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV� WKURXJKRXW� WKH� ����V��7KHLU� DGYDQFH� LV�UHDGLO\�VHHQ� E\�GLUHFWO\� FRPSDULQJ� WKH� WZR� JURXSV�� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH�SUR�3DUULV�DYHUDJH� WD[� WR� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[�� ZKLFK� VWRRG� DW� ����� LQ� ������
FOLPEHG� WR������ LQ�������7KXV� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� QDUURZHG� WKH�JDS� LQ�ZHDOWK� GXULQJ� WKH� ����V� VR� WKDW� DV� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN� DSSURDFKHG��WKHLU� DYHUDJH� WD[�ZDV� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKHLU� RSSRQHQWV� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW��
7KH� PHGLDQ� GDWD�� ZKLFK� VPRRWKV� RXW� WKH� HIIHFW� RI� H[WUHPH� FDVHV��
SUHVHQW� EHWWHU� HYLGHQFH� WKDW� 3DUULVV� VXSSRUWHUV� ZHUH� QRW�GHFOLQLQJ� UHOD�
WLYH� WR� WKHLU�SRVLWLRQ� LQ� WKH�YLOODJH� RU� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKHLU� ULYDOV��7KH�
SUR�3DUULV�PHGLDQ� WD[�FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKDW�RI�6DOHP� 9LOODJH� URVH�IURP�D�UDWLR� RI� ���� WR� ���� GXULQJ� WKH� GHFDGH�� LQGLFDWLQJ� WKDW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS�ZDV� LPSURYLQJ� LWV�HFRQRPLF� SRVLWLRQ� LQ�6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� 6LQFH� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� DVVHVVPHQW� LQFUHDVHG� PRUH�
PRGHVWO\� LQ� WKH� VDPH�SHULRG�
IURP� ���� WR� ����� ZKHQ� WKH� WZR� JURXSV� DUH�FRPSDUHG� GLUHFWO\�� WKH� UDWLR� RI�
SUR�� WR� DQWL�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� DVVHVVPHQWV� ZHQW� IURP� ���� WR� ����� 7KXV�� E\�WKH� WLPH�RI� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN�� WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� KDG� DFKLHYHG�YLUWXDO� SDULW\�ZLWK� 3DUULVV�RSSRVLWLRQ�� )DU� IURP�EHLQJ� RXWFODVVHG�� WKH�VR�FDOOHG� WUDGLWLRQDOLVWV� FHQWHUHG� DURXQG� WKH�YLOODJH� FKXUFK�ZHUH� RXWSDFLQJ�WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� �7DEOH� ,,�����
���2QH� FDQ� DWWULEXWH� GLIIHUHQFHV� EHWZHHQ� WKH�PHDQ� DQG� PHGLDQ� WUHQGV� IRU� WKH�
SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQV� LQ�SDUW� WR� WKH� DGGLWLRQDO� WD[SD\HUV� ZKR� FRPSRVH� WKH�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
7DEOH� ,,�*URXS� 7D[� 5DWLRV�
����� L�"R�
SUR�3DUULV� DQWL�3DUULV� SUR�3DUULV� DQWL�3DUULV�
0HDQ� WD[�
�VKLOOLQJV�� ������ ������ ������������5DWLR� ����� �����
0HGLDQ� WD[�
�VKLOOLQJV�� ������ ������ ������������5DWLR� ����� �����
1RWHV�� :LWK� SUR�3DUULV� WD[� UDWLRV��1 ��� IRU� ������1 ��� IRU� ������ ZLWK� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[�
UDWLRV��1 ��� IRU�������1 ��� IRU� ������6RXUFHV�� �%RRN� RI�5HFRUG��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV�� ������������ ���� ������� %R\HU� DQG�
1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP�9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW�� ��������
6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� WD[� UHFRUGV� IRU� WKH�SHULRG� EHIRUH� ������ WKHQ��SODFH�WKH�VWDUN�HFRQRPLF� GLVSDULWLHV� IRXQG� E\�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� LQ�D�GLI�IHUHQW� OLJKW�� ,Q� ������ WKRXJK� WKH�DYHUDJH�ZHDOWK� RI� WKH� WKLUW\�HLJKW�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� ZDV� VRPHZKDW� ORZHU� WKDQ� WKDW� RI� WKH� WKLUW\�IRXU�DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV�� WKH� GLVFUHSDQF\�
ZDV� QRW�JODULQJ�� )LYH� \HDUV� ODWHU��
KRZHYHU�� ZKHQ� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� PHDVXUHG� LW�� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI�
WKH�WKLUW\�VL[�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� KDG� GURSSHG� IURP���� WR�RQO\� ���SHU�FHQW� RI� WKH� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW� RI� WKH� ILIW\�WZR� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV��
6LPLODUO\�� ZKHUHDV� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[� LQ� ����� HTXDOHG� WKDW�RI�WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV�� ILYH�\HDUV� ODWHU�WKH�ILJXUH�KDG� GURSSHG� WR�RQO\� ���SHU�FHQW�� $QG� WKRXJK� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� IRXQG� WKDW� WKH� WZHOYH� PRVW�
SURVSHURXV� SHWLWLRQHUV� �WD[HG� DW�PRUH� WKDQ� WZHQW\�VKLOOLQJV�� VLGHG� RYHU�
ZKHOPLQJO\� DJDLQVW� 3DUULV� LQ� ������ZLWK� HLJKW� RSSRVLQJ� DQG� RQO\� IRXU�
VXSSRUWLQJ� KLP�� WKH� HTXLYDOHQW� HOHYHQ� PRVW� SURVSHURXV� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV�LQ������ZHUH� DOPRVW� HYHQO\�GLYLGHG�� ZLWK� VL[�RSSRVLQJ� DQG� ILYH� VXSSRUW�LQJ� 3DUULV�� +DG� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� FRQVLGHUHG� WKH� HFRQRPLF� VWUXF�
WXUH�RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� EDVHG� RQ� WKH� WD[� OLVW�FORVHVW� WR� WKH� WLPH� RI� WKH�
WZR� DVVHVVPHQWV�� $V� QHZ� DQG� OLNHO\� \RXQJHU� WD[SD\HUV�� WKHLU� DVVHVVPHQWV� ZHUH� RIWHQ�RQ� WKH� ORZHU� HQG� RI� WKH� VFDOH�� 7KH� VHYHQWHHQ� SUR�3DUULV� WD[SD\HUV� ZKR� DSSHDUHG� IRU�WKH� ILUVW� WLPH� RQ� WKH� ����� UROO�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� FDPH� DOPRVW� H[FOXVLYHO\� IURP� WKH� ORZHU�DQG� PLGGOH� UDQNV�� 7KHLU� LQFOXVLRQ� PXWHV� WKH� GLVWRUWLQJ� HIIHFW� RI� D� VPDOO� QXPEHU� RI�ZHOO�WR�GR� SUR�3DUULV� WD[SD\HUV�� 7KH� ODUJHU� GURS� LQ� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV�IDFWLRQ� LV� OLNHO\� DWWULEXWDEOH� WR� D�GHFOLQH� LQ� UDQNLQJ� E\� D�QXPEHU� RI�ZHDOWK\� PHPEHUV�RI� WKLV� IDFWLRQ� DV�ZHOO� DV� WR� WKH� DGGLWLRQ� RIWHQ� QHZ� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[SD\HUV�� RQO\� RQH� RI�ZKRP� ZDV� LQ� WKH� WRS� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� DQG� WZR� RI�ZKRP� ZHUH� LQ� WKH� ERWWRP� ��
SHUFHQW� RI� WD[SD\HUV�� ZKLFK� ZRXOG� ORZHU� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� DQG� DOORZ� WKH�PHGLDQ� WR�ULVH� VOLJKWO\��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
ZLWFKFUDIW� WULDOV��WKH\�ZRXOG� KDYH� IRXQG� WKH�GLVSDULWLHV� EHWZHHQ� WKH�IDF�WLRQV�FRQVLGHUDEO\� OHVV�VKDUS��7KH� �����GDWD� %R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� XVHG�
VWURQJO\� VXJJHVW� WKDW� EHWZHHQ� WKH� ����� DQG� ����� OLVWV�� WKH� IRUZDUG�
SURJUHVV� RI� WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� ZDV� WKURZQ� LQWR� UHYHUVH�� OHDYLQJ� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�JURXS� GLVWLQFWO\� GLVDGYDQWDJHG� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV�� $W�WKH� VDPH� WLPH�� D� FORVHU� ORRN� UHYHDOV� WKDW� WKHLU� VHWEDFN�� VR�
SURPLQHQW�D�
IHDWXUH� LQ� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� ZDV� QRW� DV� VHYHUH� DV� WKH� ����� GDWD� LQGLFDWH��
3HUKDSV� PRUH� LPSRUWDQW�� LW�ZDV� QRW� SHUPDQHQW����7KHUH� LV� OLWWOH�TXHVWLRQ� WKDW� WKH� UHODWLYH� SRVLWLRQ� RI� WKH�SUR�3DUULV�
IDFWLRQ� GHFOLQHG� SHUFHSWLEO\� DIWHU�WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� HSLVRGH�� 2QH� FDQ� WUDFH�WKH� IRUWXQHV� RI� WKLUW\�VHYHQ� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH�
����� DQG� WKH������ WD[� OLVWV����2QO\� ���SHUFHQW� RI� WKLV�JURXS� RI�SUR�3DUULV�SHUVLVWHUV� �VL[�RI� WKLUW\�VHYHQ�� LPSURYHG� WKHLU�SHUFHQWLOH� UDQN� LQ�WKH�FRP�
PXQLW\� E\� ���SHUFHQW� RU�PRUH� GXULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG�� D�GLVWLQFW� FKDQJH� IURP�
���3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXPV� GDWD� IRU� WKH� ����� DVVHVVPHQW� DUH� FORVH�WR�PLQH�� 7KH\� LGHQWLILHG� ILIW\�RQH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� RQ� WKDW� WD[� UROO�ZKR� ZHUH�WD[HG� DQ� DYHUDJH� RI� ����� VKLOOLQJV�� 0\� DQDO\VLV� IRXQG� ILIW\�WZR� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV�RQ� WKH� UROO� WD[HG� DW� WKH� VDPH� DYHUDJH� UDWH�� )RU� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS�� WKH\� FRQVLGHUHG�
WKLUW\�ILYH� SHWLWLRQHUV� RQ� WKH� ����� UROO� DVVHVVHG� DW� DQ� DYHUDJH� RI� ����� VKLOOLQJV� FRP�
SDUHG� ZLWK� P\� FRXQW� RI� WKLUW\�VL[� SHWLWLRQHUV� DVVHVVHG� DW� DQ� DYHUDJH� RI� ����� VKLOOLQJV��7KHLU� UDWLR� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[� VWDQGV� DW�
������ P\� FDOFXODWLRQ� LV� ������ 7KH� DGYDQWDJH� RI� XVLQJ� WKH� ����� WD[� UROO� LV� WKDW� LW�LQFOXGHV� D� ODUJHU� QXPEHU� RI� SHWLWLRQHUV� WKDQ� WKDW� RI� ������ SDUWLFXODUO\� IRU� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ�� %XW� LW�DOVR� UHJLVWHUV� HFRQRPLF� VKLIWV� WKDW� IROORZHG� ������ 6HH� %R\HU� DQG�
1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� ������� 7KH� SRVVLELOLW\� H[LVWV� WKDW� FKDQJHV� LQ� WD[SD\HUV�DVVHVVPHQWV� PD\� KDYH� UHVXOWHG� QRW� IURP� WKHLU� FKDQJLQJ� HFRQRPLF� FLUFXPVWDQFHV� EXW�IURP� WKH� GLIIHUHQW� SDUWLVDQ� DOLJQPHQWV� RI� WKH� FRPPLWWHHV� LQ� FKDUJH� RI� DVVHVVPHQWV��
7KRXJK� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� PDLQWDLQHG� FRQVLVWHQW� FULWHULD� IRU� WD[LQJ� SURSHUW\�� WKH� SHU�VRQQHO� RI� WKH� FRPPLWWHH� WKDW� RYHUVDZ� WD[DWLRQ� FKDQJHG� DQQXDOO\�� :HUH� WKH� UHODWLYHO\�ORZ� UDWHV� SDLG� E\� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� LQ� ������ IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� UHVXOW� RI� D� SDUWLVDQ�FRPPLWWHH� WKDW� OHYLHG� KLJKHU� WD[HV� RQ� 6DPXHO� 3DUULVV� RSSRQHQWV"� $Q� DUJXPHQW� FDQ�EH�PDGH� IRU� WKLV� FRQWHQWLRQ�� IRXU� RI� WKH�ILYH�PHPEHUV� RI� WKH� ����� FRPPLWWHH� VLJQHG�WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� RQH� PHPEHU� GLG� QRW� VLJQ� HLWKHU� SHWLWLRQ�� 2WKHU� HYLGHQFH��KRZHYHU�� VWURQJO\� VXJJHVWV� WKDW� SDUWLVDQVKLS� SOD\HG� OLWWOH� RU� QR� UROH� LQ�YLOODJH� DVVHVV�PHQWV�� 2I� WKH� ILYH� WD[� UROOV� FRQVXOWHG� IRU� WKLV� DUWLFOH�� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWL�WLRQ� FRQVWLWXWHG� D�PDMRULW\� RQ� IRXU� FRPPLWWHHV� DQG� KDG� HTXDO� UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ� RQ� WKH�
UHPDLQLQJ� RQH�� 7KH� ����� DQG� ����� FRPPLWWHHV�� ZKLFK� SURGXFHG� WKH� ����� WD[� OLVW��KDG� WKUHH� SUR�3DUULV� PHPEHUV�� WKH� ����� FRPPLWWHH�� ZKLFK� SODFHG� WKH� WZR� IDFWLRQV�RQ� D�PRUH� HTXDO� IRRWLQJ� WKDQ� LQ� ������ ILOOHG� DOO� ILYH� SRVLWLRQV� ZLWK� SUR�3DUULV� VLJQHUV��7KH� ����� FRPPLWWHH� FRQWDLQHG� IRXU� SUR�3DUULV� VLJQHUV� DQG� RQH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWL�WLRQHU�� 7KH� ����� FRPPLWWHH� KDG� WZR�PHPEHUV� ZKR� ODWHU� VLJQHG� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHWL�WLRQ�� WZR�PHPEHUV� ZKR� ODWHU� VLJQHG� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ�� DQG� RQH� QRQVLJQHU��
:KHQ� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� WRRN� ILUP� FRQWURO� RI� WKH� WD[LQJ� FRPPLWWHH� LQ� ������ LWV�
UHVSRQVH� ZDV� QRW� WR�PDQLSXODWH� WKH� WD[� V\VWHP� WR� SXQLVK� LWV� HQHPLHV�� ,QVWHDG� WKH�
PHHWLQJ� WKDW� HOHFWHG� WKLV� JURXS� VLPSO\� YRWHG� QRW� WR� OHY\� DQ\� WD[HV� WR� VXSSRUW� WKH�
PLQLVWU\�� 3DUULV� ODWHU� VXHG� WKH� YLOODJH� WR� UHFRYHU� KLV� VDODU\�� 6HH� �%RRN� RI�5HFRUG��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQ�� ���� ������� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP�9LOODJH� :LWFKFUDIW������� ����� ����� ������ � ����� ����� ����� �����
���2QH� KXQGUHG� ILYH� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� ����� WD[� OLVW��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
WKH� SUHYLRXV� GHFDGH� ZKHQ� PRUH� WKDQ� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� SHUVLVWHUV�
LPSURYHG� WKHLU� VWDQGLQJ�� ,Q� FRQWUDVW� PRUH� WKDQ� RQH�TXDUWHU� RI� WKH� SHU�
VLVWHUV� �WHQ� RI� WKLUW\�VHYHQ�� PRYHG� GRZQZDUG� DW� OHDVW� ��� SHUFHQW�� 2QH�
PHPEHU� RI� WKLV�JURXS� GURSSHG� RXW� RI� WKH�WRS�TXDUWLOH� LQWR� WKH�WZR�PLG�GOH� TXDUWLOHV�� EXW� WKH� SULPDU\� FDVXDOWLHV� FDPH� IURP� WKH� QLQH� 3DUULV� VXS�
SRUWHUV� ZKRVH� DVVHVVPHQWV� OD\� ZLWKLQ� WKH� IRUWLHWK� WR� VHYHQW\�ILIWK�
SHUFHQWLOHV� RI�YLOODJHUV� LQ� ������7ZR� RI� WKHVH�PHQ� IHOO� LQWR� WKH�ERWWRP�
TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� E\� ����� DQG� IRXU� RWKHUV� EDUHO\� HVFDSHG� WKDW�IDWH��
IDOOLQJ� LQWR�WKH������ SHUFHQWLOH��7KHVH� ORVVHV��KRZHYHU��ZHUH� RIIVHW�WR�D�GHJUHH� E\�WKH� ODUJH�QXPEHU� RI�
SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� ZKRVH� VLWXDWLRQ� UHPDLQHG� VWDEOH�� 0RUH� WKDQ� RQH�
KDOI� �WZHQW\�RQH� RI� WKLUW\�VHYHQ�� UHWDLQHG� WKHLU�UDQNLQJ� LQ�WKH�FRPPX�
QLW\�� PRYLQJ� QHLWKHU� XS� QRU� GRZQ� ��� SHUFHQW�� 0RUHRYHU� WZR� SHUVLVWHUV�DGYDQFHG� LQWR� WKH� WRS� TXDUWLOH� RI�YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� GXULQJ� WKHVH�\HDUV��7KH� WZR� PHQ� ZHUH�
WKLUG�JHQHUDWLRQ� PHPEHUV� RI� WKH� 3XWQDP� IDPLO\�� D�
FODQ� WKDW�ZDV� SURPLQHQW� LQ�WKH�YLOODJH� FKXUFK� DQG� LQ�SXUVXLQJ� ZLWFKHV��RQH� URVH� LQWR� WKH�WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� IURP�WKH�PLGGOLQJ� UDQNV�� WKH�RWKHU� HPHUJHG� IURP� WKH�ERWWRP� TXDUWLOH�� 7KH� HFRQRPLF� DQG� SROLWLFDO�HOLWH� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ�� PHQ� VXFK� DV� 7KRPDV� DQG� (GZDUG�
3XWQDP�� HVFDSHG� ODUJHO\� XQVFDWKHG�� (OHYHQ� RI� WKH� WKLUWHHQ� SUR�3DUULV�
SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH�GHFDGH� LQ� WKH� WRS� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV�UHPDLQHG� LQ� WKLV� JURXS� ILYH�\HDUV� ODWHU�� DQG� RQH� H[SHULHQFHG� RQO\� D�
PLQRU� GRZQZDUG� PRYHPHQW�� UHPDLQLQJ� LQ� WKH� WRS� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WD[�
SD\HUV� LQ�������
'HVSLWH� WKHVH� VWDEOH� HOHPHQWV�� WKH�\HDUV� IROORZLQJ� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW�RXWEUHDN� KDOWHG�� DQG� OLNHO\� UHYHUVHG�� WKH� UHODWLYH�SURJUHVV�PDGH� E\� WKH�
PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH� GXULQJ� WKH�����V��7KRXJK� WKHVH�SHUVLV�WHUV� UHPDLQHG� VRPHZKDW� ZHDOWKLHU� WKDQ� WKH� YLOODJH�
DV� D�ZKROH�� WKHLU� DYHU�
DJH� WD[� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKDW� RI� WKH�YLOODJH� RQO\� KHOG� VWHDG\� DW� �����D�UHYHUVDO� IURP� WKH� SUHYLRXV� GHFDGH�� ZKHQ� WKHLU� DYHUDJH� LQFRPH� LQFUHDVHG�
FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKDW�RI� WKH�YLOODJH��0RUHRYHU� WKH�GLVWLQFW� SRVVLELOLW\� WKDW�WKHLU� VLWXDWLRQ� GHWHULRUDWHG� DIWHU� ����� DSSHDUV� LQ� WKHLU� PHGLDQ� WD[��
ZKLFK�� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH� YLOODJH� UDWH�� GHFOLQHG� IURP� ���� WR� ���� LQ� ������
$V� D� UHVXOW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�ZHUH� QR�
ORQJHU� FORVH� WR� WKHLU� ULYDOV� E\�
������&RPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� LQ�WKLV�SHULRG�� WKH�UDWLR�RI�WKHLU� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW� IHOO� IURP� ����� LQ� ����� WR������ LQ� ������ WKH�PHGLDQ� UDWLR� IHOO� HYHQ� PRUH�
SUHFLSLWRXVO\� IURP� ����� WR� ��������
���7KH� FRPSRVLWLRQ� RI� SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU� JURXSV� IRU� WKH� ��������
SHULRG� LV�QRW� WKH� VDPH� DV� WKH� SHUVLVWHU� JURXSV� IRU� WKH� �������� SHULRG�� $� SUR�3DUULV�SHUVLVWHU�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� ZKR� DSSHDUHG� RQ� ERWK� WKH� ����� DQG� ����� WD[� OLVWV�PLJKW� QRW�
KDYH� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� ����� DQG� ����� WD[� OLVWV�EHFDXVH� KH�ZDV� DEVHQW� IURP� WKH� ����� OLVW��7KHUHIRUH� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHU� JURXS� LQ� ����� GLIIHUV� GHSHQGLQJ�RQ� ZKHWKHU� RQH� LV� FRQVLGHULQJ� WKH� �������� SHUVLVWHUV� RU� WKH� �������� SHUVLVWHUV��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
)XUWKHU� HYLGHQFH� RI� D� SUR�3DUULV� UHYHUVDO� DIWHU� ����� HPHUJHV� ZKHQ�
LQYHVWLJDWLQJ� DOO�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR� DSSHDUHG� RQ� HLWKHU� WKH� �����RU� ����� WD[� UROOV�� 7KLV� DQDO\VLV� H[SDQGV� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� WR� WKLUW\�
HLJKW� VLJQHUV�RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW�DQG� ILIW\�WZR�IRU�WKH������DVVHVVPHQW�� 7KH�
SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� DVVHVVPHQW� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKDW�RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� IHOO�IURP� ���� LQ� ����� WR� ����� LQ� ������ SODFLQJ� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� EHORZ�
WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[� RI� WKH� YLOODJH�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[�� PRUH� UHIOHFWLYH�
RI� WKH�JURXSV� JHQHUDO� FRQGLWLRQ�� DOVR� IHOO�SHUFHSWLEO\� IURP� ����WR� ����E\������� LQGLFDWLQJ� WKDW� LWV�PHGLDQ� ZDV� QRZ� QR� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKH�YLOODJHV�� %\������ WKH� PLQLVWU\� VXSSRUWHUV� FRXOG� QR�
ORQJHU� FODLP� WKH\� ZHUH� DQ� HFR�
QRPLFDOO\� DGYDQWDJHG� JURXS� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH��:KHUHDV� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� VHWEDFN� LV� HYLGHQW�� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� H[SHULHQFH�
GXULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG� LV�KDUGHU� WR�HVWDEOLVK�� )URP� ����� WR� ������PDQ\�PRUH�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� LPSURYHG� WKHLU� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK�
WKRVH�ZKRVH� IRUWXQHV� GHFOLQHG�� %XW� WKLV�DGYDQFH� ZDV� ODUJHO\� OLPLWHG� WR�WKRVH� ZKR� ZHUH� OHVV� ZHOO�WR�GR� DW� WKH� VWDUW� RI� WKH� GHFDGH�� DQG� WKHUH� DUH�
VXJJHVWLYH� LQGLFDWLRQV� WKDW� PDQ\� PHPEHUV� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ�
DFWXDOO\� H[SHULHQFHG� VRPH� GHWHULRUDWLRQ� LQ� WKHLU� VWDQGLQJ�� WKRXJK� OHVV�WKDQ� 3DUULVV� VXSSRUWHUV��
7KLUW\�WKUHH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� VLJQHUV� DSSHDUHG� RQ� ERWK� WKH� �����DQG� �����WD[�OLVWV��$OPRVW� ���SHUFHQW� �WHQ�RI� WKLUW\�WKUHH�� LPSURYHG� WKHLU�
UDQNLQJ�E\�DW� OHDVW� ���SHUFHQW�� D� FRQVLGHUDEO\� KLJKHU� ILJXUH� WKDQ� WKDW�RI�WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV�� 0XFK� RI� WKLV� LPSURYHPHQW� FDPH� WR�WKRVH� DW� WKH� ORZHVW�HQG� RI� WKH� WD[� UROO�� )LYH� RI� WKH� WHQ� WD[SD\HUV� ZKRVH� DVVHVVPHQWV�
SODFHG�WKHP� LQ� WKH�ERWWRP� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� LQ� ����� QRW� RQO\� LPSURYHG�WKHLU� UDQNLQJ� E\� DW� OHDVW� ���SHUFHQW� EXW� DOVR�ZHUH� VHFXUHO\� SRVLWLRQHG�ZLWKLQ� WKH�PLGGOLQJ� UDQNV�RI� WD[SD\HUV� LQ�������
1HYHUWKHOHVV� LPSURYHPHQW� ZDV�KDUGO\� D� SURQRXQFHG� FKDUDFWHULVWLF�
DPRQJ� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� 7KRXJK�WZR� ZKR� EHJDQ� WKH� GHFDGH� LQ�
WKH�WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� RI� WD[SD\HUV� MRLQHG� WKH�WRS� ���SHUFHQW� LQ�������WZR�RWKHUV�KHDGHG� LQ�WKH�RSSRVLWH� GLUHFWLRQ� DQG� HQGHG� XS� LQ�WKH�ERWWRP�
TXDUWLOH�� 2QH� DGGLWLRQDO� PLGGOLQJ� SHUVLVWHU� QDUURZO\� HVFDSHG� WKH� VDPH�
IDWH��HQGLQJ� XS� MXVW�DERYH� WKDW�PDUN� ������ SHUFHQW��� $QG� WKRXJK� WKH�WHQ�ZHDOWKLHVW� RSSRQHQWV� RI�3DUULV�� WKRVH� LQ�WKH�WRS�TXDUWLOH� RI� WKH� ����� WD[�OLVW� ���������� SHUFHQW��� JHQHUDOO\� ZHDWKHUHG� WKLV� WXPXOWXRXV� SHULRG�ZLWKRXW� GDPDJH�� WZR�GHFOLQHG� DW� OHDVW� ���SHUFHQW� DQG� IRXQG� WKHPVHOYHV�LQ�WKH�WZR�PLGGOH� TXDUWLOHV� RI� WD[SD\HUV� LQ�������:LWK� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV� HLWKHU�KROGLQJ� WKHLU�SRVLWLRQ� RU� IDOOLQJ� ���SHUFHQW�DPRQJ� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�� WKHUH� LV�OLWWOH�HYLGHQFH� RI�PDUNHG� LPSURYHPHQW�GXULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG��
'HVSLWH� WKH� FKDQJLQJ� FRPSRVLWLRQ� RI� WKHVH� JURXSV�� WKH� UHOHYDQW� FRPSDULVRQV� DUH�FRQVLVWHQW� ZLWKLQ� HDFK� WLPH� VSDQ��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
*URXS� FKDUDFWHULVWLFV� FRQILUP� WKH� ODFN�RI�QRWLFHDEOH� DGYDQFHPHQW� E\�DQWL�3DUULV� SHUVLVWHUV�� 7KRXJK� WKHLU� PHDQ� WD[� UDWLR� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH�
HQWLUH� YLOODJH� LQFUHDVHG� GXULQJ� WKLV� SHULRG� IURP� ���� WR� ����� WKH� PRUH� UHS�UHVHQWDWLYH� PHGLDQ� UDWLR� GHFOLQHG� IURP� ���� WR� ����� 7KH� RQO\� JRRG�
QHZV�
IRU� WKHP� ZDV� WKDW� WKHLU� DGYHUVDULHV� PLVIRUWXQHV� ZHUH� JUHDWHU��
([SDQGLQJ� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� WR� LQFOXGH� DOO� WKH�SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR�
DSSHDUHG� RQ� HLWKHU� WKH� ����� RU� ����� WD[� OLVW�FRQILUPV� WKHVH� ILQGLQJV��7KH� PRGHVWO\� HQODUJHG� JURXS� QRZ� FRQVLVWV� RI� WKLUW\�IRXU�VLJQHUV�RI� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� IRU������ DQG� WKLUW\�VL[�VLJQHUV� IRU�������7KRXJK� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� UDWLR� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH� HQWLUH� YLOODJH� DJDLQ� URVH��
WKLV� WLPH�PRUH� VOLJKWO\� �IURP� ���� LQ������ WR� ���� LQ�������� WKH� OLNHOLKRRG�WKDW�PDQ\� PHPEHUV� RI� WKLV� IDFWLRQ� H[SHULHQFHG� GLIILFXOWLHV� LV�HYLGHQW�IURP� WKH� QRWLFHDEOH� GHFOLQH� LQ� WKHLU� PHGLDQ� WD[� UDWLR�� IURP� ���� LQ� �����WR� ���� LQ� ������ %\� ERWK� PHDVXUHV� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQV� SRVLWLRQ�ZLWKLQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� LQ� �����ZDV� OHVV� IDYRUDEOH� WKDQ� LW�KDG� EHHQ� LQ�������7KH� PLQLVWU\� RSSRQHQWV� UHPDLQHG� DQ� DIIOXHQW� JURXS�� \HW� WKHLU�
DYHUDJH� DQG� PHGLDQ� WD[HV� ZHUH� QRZ� EHORZ� WKH� SRLQW� DW�ZKLFK� WKH� JURXS�VWRRG� ILIWHHQ�\HDUV� HDUOLHU�� ,Q�DEVROXWH� WHUPV�WKH\�PD\� KDYH� EHHQ� HTXDOO\�ZHOO� RII�EXW�� UHODWLYH� WR� WKH� UHVW�RI� WKH�FRPPXQLW\�� WKHLU� VLWXDWLRQ� KDG�GHWHULRUDWHG����
3DUULVV� GHIHQGHUV� FRXOG� LOO� DIIRUG� WR� FKHHU�� 7KHLU� RSSRQHQWV�UHPDLQHG� ZHDOWKLHU� WKDQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHUV� DQG��PRUH� WR� WKH�SRLQW�� ZHUH�QRZ� PXFK� EHWWHU� RII� WKDQ� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH�WD[�� ZKLFK� KDG� UHDFKHG� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� MXVW�
SULRU� WR� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN�� QRZ� IHOO� WR� RQO\� ��� SHUFHQW�� 6LPLODUO\��WKH�SUR�3DUULV�PHGLDQ� WD[��ZKLFK� KDG� UHDFKHG� HTXDOLW\�ZLWK� WKDW�RI� WKHLU�
RSSRQHQWV� LQ� ������ QRZ� SOXPPHWHG� WR� ������ 7KXV� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DVFHQ�
GDQF\� WKDW�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� IRXQG� E\� H[DPLQLQJ� WKH� ����� WD[� OLVW�UHIOHFWV�WKH�UHODWLYH� VWDQGLQJ� RI�6DOHP�9LOODJHV� IDFWLRQV� LQ�WKDW�\HDU��%XW�WKH� VLWXDWLRQ� GLG� QRW� UHVXOW� IURP� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXSV� ULVLQJ� IRUWXQHV� DV�
PXFK� DV�IURP�WKH�UHFHQW�GLPLQLVKHG� FLUFXPVWDQFHV� RI� WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV��7KH� VKDUS� HFRQRPLF� GLVSDULWLHV� RI� �����ZHUH� JHQXLQH� EXW� QRW� W\SL�
FDO�� 7KDW� \HDU� ZDV�VRPHWKLQJ� RI� DQ� DQRPDO\�� QR� RWKHU� YLOODJH�
WD[� UROO�
UHYHDOV� VXFK� D�ZLGH� JDS� EHWZHHQ� WKH� JURXSV�� /HVV� H[WUHPH� GLVWLQFWLRQV�
DUH� HYLGHQW� QRW� RQO\� IRU� WKH�DVVHVVPHQW� OHYLHG� LQ� ����� EXW� DOVR� IRU� WKH�
����� DVVHVVPHQW��
���7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� WR� WKDW� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� VWRRG� DW� ���� LQ�
������ LQ� ������ LW�KDG� GURSSHG� WR� �����7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKH�PHGLDQ� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[� WR� WKDW� RI�WKH�YLOODJH� VWRRG� DW� ���� LQ� ����� EXW� RQO\� ���� LQ� ������7KH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS� UHWDLQHG� LWV�ZHDOWKLHU� VWDWXV� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH� YLOODJH� DV� D�ZKROH�� \HW� WKLV� HYLGHQFH� GXULQJ� D�
ILIWHHQ�\HDU� SHULRG� GRHV� QRW� VXSSRUW� 3DXO� %R\HU� DQG� 6WHSKHQ� 1LVVHQEDXPV� FRQ�WHQWLRQ� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG� RI� UHODWLYH� HFRQRPLF� DGYDQFHPHQW��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
7KH� ����� WD[� OLVW�DFWXDOO\� VXSSOLHV� WKH�IXOOHVW�UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ� RI�6DOHP�
9LOODJHV� IDFWLRQV�� ,W�FRQWDLQV� WKH� VDPH� WRWDO�QXPEHU� RI�YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�������DQG� WKH�VDPH�QXPEHU� RI�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� ����� DV� WKH�IROORZLQJ�\HDU�� \HW� LW� LQFOXGHV� RQH� PRUH� DQWL�3DUULV� PHPEHU�� WKLUW\�VHYHQ� FRPSDUHG�ZLWK� WKLUW\�VL[� RQ� WKH� ����� OLVW��7KH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQV� PHGLDQ� WD[�
�FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� WKH�HQWLUH�YLOODJH�� LQ������ZDV� WKH�VDPH� DV� WKH�IROORZLQJ�\HDU� ������� FRQILUPLQJ� WKH� OLNHOLKRRG� RI�D�GRZQWXUQ� DIWHU������� ,WV�DYHU�
DJH� WD[� UDWLR� VWRRG� DW� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� YLOODJH� DYHUDJH� LQ� ������ ORZHU�
WKDQ� LQ� ����� EXW� VRPHZKDW� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKH�IROORZLQJ� \HDU�� LQGLFDWLQJ�WKDW������UHSUHVHQWHG� LWV�ZHDNHVW� SRVLWLRQ� LQ�WKH�FRPPXQLW\��0HDQZKLOH�WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXSV�
PHDQ� DQG� PHGLDQ� UDWLRV� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� 6DOHP�
9LOODJHUV� ZHUH� ORZHU� LQ� ����� WKDQ� LQ�������ZKLFK� DFFRXQWV� IRU�WKH� OHVV�HQHG� GLIIHUHQFH� EHWZHHQ� WKH� WZR� IDFWLRQV� RQ� WKH� ����� WD[� UROO�� 7KH� DQWL�
3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� VLJQHUV� GUDPDWLF� GURS� LQ� WKHLU�PHGLDQ� WD[�IURP� ���� LQ�
����� WR� ���� LQ� ����� VXSSRUWV� WKH�QRWLRQ� WKDW� WKH\��WRR�� VXIIHUHG� LQ� WKH�DIWHUPDWK�RI� WKH�WULDOV��7KRXJK� WKHLU�PHGLDQ� WD[�UDWLR� URVH� WR�����WKH�IRO�
ORZLQJ�\HDU�� LW�VWLOO�UHPDLQHG� EHORZ� WKH�ILJXUH�IRU���������7KH� VDPH� VWRU\� KROGV� WUXH� IRU� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXPV� FODLP� WKDW�
6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�PRVW� DIIOXHQW� FLWL]HQV� RSSRVHG� 3DUULV�� 7KH� FODLP� ZDV� WUXH�
IRU� WKH� ����� OLVW�EXW�� DV� LQ� ������ LQ� ����� LW�ZDV� OHVV� HYLGHQW�� 2I� WKH�ZHDOWKLHVW� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� YLOODJHUV� LQ� ����� �WKRVH� DVVHVVHG� DW�
WZHQW\�IRXU�
VKLOOLQJV� RU�PRUH��� ILYH�RSSRVHG� 3DUULV� DQG� IRXU� VXSSRUWHG� KLP��2Q� WKH�
����� DVVHVVPHQW�� WKH� JDS� ZDV�FRQVLGHUDEO\� ZLGHU�� VHYHQ� DQWL�3DUULV� SDUWL�
VDQV� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� RQO\� WKUHH�RI�3DUULVV� IULHQGV� DSSHDUHG� DPRQJ� WKH�
YLOODJHV� HOLWH� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WD[SD\HUV�� -XVW� DV� ZDV� WKH� FDVH� IRU� ������ KDG�
%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� UHOLHG�RQ� WKH������ OLVW�UDWKHU�WKDQ� WKH������� WKHLU�FODLPV� DERXW� WKH� UHODWLRQVKLS� EHWZHHQ� ZHDOWK� DQG� IDFWLRQDO� DIILOLDWLRQ�
ZRXOG� KDYH� EHHQ� PRUH� PRGHVW����
,W� LV� QRW� WKLV� DUWLFOHV� SXUSRVH� WR� H[SODLQ� WKH� DSSDUHQW� FKDQJLQJ� IRU�
WXQHV�� HVSHFLDOO\� RI� WKH� PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ�� LQ� WKH� SRVW������ SHULRG�� 1R�
GRXEW� PDQ\� HYHQWV� LQ� WKH� ODWH� ����V� DQG� HDUO\� ����V� SRVHG� FKDOOHQJHV�WR�
6DOHP� 9LOODJH� DQG�PD\� KDYH� GLIIHUHQWLDOO\� DIIHFWHG� LWV�UHVLGHQWV�� 7KH�
���7KH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� LQ� ����� UHPDLQHG� WKH� VDPH� ZLWKLQ� WKH� YLOODJH�FRPSDUHG� ZLWK� ������ LWV� UDWLR� VWRRG� DW� ���� LQ�ERWK� \HDUV�� ,W� URVH�PRGHVWO\� LQ� ����� WR�
����� /LNH� WKH� ����� WD[� UROO�� WKDW� RI� ����� GRHV� QRW� SRLQW� WR� DQ\� VXEVWDQWLDO� HFRQRPLF�DGYDQFHPHQW� IROORZLQJ� ������ WKRXJK� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� FRQWLQJHQW� UHPDLQHG� PRUH�
DIIOXHQW� WKDQ� LWV� ULYDOV� DQG� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� JHQHUDOO\� LQ� WKH� SHULRG� IROORZLQJ�WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� WULDOV��
���6LQFH� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� PDGH� QR� DVVHVVPHQWV� IRU� WKH�SHULRG� -XO\� �����-XO\� ������ LW�LV�WKHRUHWLFDOO\� SRVVLEOH� WKDW�� LQ� WKH�\HDUV� IURP� ����� WR� ������ WKH� UHODWLYH� VWDQGLQJ� RI� WKH�
SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� DGYDQFHG� ZKLOH� WKDW� RI� WKH�PLQLVWHUV� RSSRQHQWV� IHOO� DQG� WKDW� WKHVH�UHVXOWV� ZHUH� VXGGHQO\� UHYHUVHG� DIWHU� ����� VR� WKDW� E\� ����� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� ZDV�ZRUVH� RII� WKDQ� LQ� ������ DQG� YLFH� YHUVD� IRU� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS�� 7KHUH� LV�QR� HYLGHQFH��KRZHYHU�� WR�DVVXPH� VXFK� DQ� H[WUHPH� DQG� VXGGHQ� UHYHUVDO� RI� IRUWXQHV� DIWHU� ������
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
SHULRG� VXUURXQGLQJ� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN� ZDV� XQVHWWOHG�� 7KHUH� ZHUH�
FRQWLQXLQJ� ,QGLDQ� ZDUV� DV�ZHOO� DV� WXUPRLO� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� WKH� UHYRFDWLRQ�
RI� WKH� FKDUWHU� RI�0DVVDFKXVHWWV�� WKH� LPSRVLWLRQ� DQG� IDOO� RI� WKH�'RPLQLRQ� RI�1HZ� (QJODQG�� DQG� WKH�HVWDEOLVKPHQW� RI�D�QHZ� UR\DO�JRY�HUQPHQW��7KH� JHQHUDO� GLVWUDFWLRQ� DQG� HFRQRPLF� GLVUXSWLRQ� RI� WKH�ZLWFK�FUDIW� HYHQWV� RI� ����� DOVR� FRQWULEXWHG� WR� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� HFRQRPLF�WURXEOHV�� 7KDW� WKHVH� HOHPHQWV� VHHPHG� WR�
ZHLJK�PRUH�
KHDYLO\�RQ� WKH� SUR�
3DUULV� FRQWLQJHQW� SUHVHQWV� D� WZLVW� WR� WKH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP� WKHVLV��
WKH�IDFWLRQ� WKH\� LGHQWLILHG� DV� KDYLQJ� WULHG� WR� WKZDUW� WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV�HFRQRPLF� DGYDQFHPHQW� E\� ODXQFKLQJ�
D�ZLWFK� KXQW� IRXQG� WKHLU� RZQ� HFR�
QRPLF� SURJUHVV� DUUHVWHG����
,Q� DQ\� HYHQW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� GRZQWXUQ� ZDV� WHPSRUDU\�� 7D[� DVVHVV�
PHQWV� PDGH� WKURXJKRXW� WKH� ODWHU�����V� GLVFORVH� WKDW�E\� ����� D� UHERXQG�
E\� 3DUULVV� VXSSRUWHUV� ZDV� ZHOO� XQGHU� ZD\� DV� WKH\� DJDLQ� EHJDQ�WR� DGYDQFH�
WKHLU� VWDQGLQJ� UHODWLYH� WR� WKHLU� RSSRQHQWV�� 7KH� YLOODJH�WD[� UDWH� IRU� �����
UHYHDOV� WKDW� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� JURXS� KDG� UHJDLQHG� VXEVWDQWLDOO\� WKH� VDPH�
SRVLWLRQ� LW�KDG� DFKLHYHG� E\� ������'XULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG� WKH�HFRQRPLF� SRVL�WLRQ� RI� LWV� RSSRQHQWV� UHPDLQHG� ODUJHO\� VWDWLF����
���$� QXPEHU� RI�KLVWRULDQV� KDYH� OLQNHG� WKH� �����ZLWFKFUDIW� HSLVRGH� WR� FRQWHPSR�UDU\�FRQGLWLRQV� LQ�1HZ� (QJODQG�� PRVW� UHFHQWO\� 1RUWRQ�� ,Q� WKH�'HYLOV� 6QDUH�� 6HH� DOVR�
-DPHV� (�� .HQFHV�� �6RPH� 8QH[SORUHG� 5HODWLRQVKLSV� RI� (VVH[� &RXQW\� :LWFKFUDIW� WR�
WKH� ,QGLDQ� :DUV� RI� ����� DQG� ������� (VVH[� ,QVWLWXWH� +LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV� ����� QR�� ��
�-XO\� ������� ��������� *RGEHHU�� 'HYLOV� 'RPLQLRQ�� �������� /DUU\� *UDJJ�� 7KH� 6DOHP�:LWFK� &ULVLV� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������� ������� /H� %HDX�� 6WRU\� RI� WKH�6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV��
������� 7KH� KLVWRULFDO� UHFRUG� LQGLFDWHV� WKDW� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN� FRQWULEXWHG� WR� D�
SHULRG� RI� HFRQRPLF� GLIILFXOW\� LQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� DQG� LQ�0DVVDFKXVHWWV� JHQHUDOO\��*RYHUQRU� :LOOLDP� 3KLSV�� DV� D� MXVWLILFDWLRQ� IRU�KLV� VKXWWLQJ� GRZQ� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� WUL�
DOV�� UHSRUWHG� WKDW� WKHLU� �GLVPDOO� HIIHFWV� WRXFKHG� WKH� OLYHV� DQG� HVWDWHV� RI�PDQ\� RI� WKHLU�0DWLHV� 6XEMHFWV�� DQG� �FORJJHG� DQG� LQWHUUXSWHG� WKHLU�0DWLHV� DIIDLUHV��� 6HH� *HRUJH�/LQFROQ� %XUU�� HG��� 1DUUDWLYHV� RI� WKH�:LWFKFUDIW� &DVHV�� ���������� �1HZ� <RUN�� ������������ $W� WKH� FORVH� RI� ������ WKH�0DVVDFKXVHWWV� *HQHUDO� &RXUW� FDOOHG� IRU� D�GD\� RI� IDVWLQJ�DQG� SUD\HU� LQ� UHSHQWDQFH� IRU� DFWLRQV� WDNHQ� GXULQJ� WKH� �ODWH� 7UDJHG\�� UDLVHG� DPRQJ� XV�
E\� 6DWDQ� DQG� KLV� ,QVWUXPHQWV�� �LELG��� ������ 3URPLQHQW� DPRQJ� WKH� HYLGHQFH� WKDW� �WKH�
$QJHU� RI�*RG�� UHTXLUHG� VXFK� D�KXPEOLQJ� RI� WKH�SHRSOH� ZDV� WKDW� �*RG� LV�SOHDVHG� VWLOO�WR�JR� RQ� LQ�GLPLQLVKLQJ� RXU�� 6XEVWDQFH�� FXWWLQJ� VKRUW� RXU� +DUYHVW�� >DQG@� EODVWLQJ� RXU�
PRVW� SURPLVLQJ� XQGHUWDNLQJV� PRUH� ZD\V� WKDQ� RQH�� �LELG��� ������ &KDUOHV� :�� 8SKDPV�FODVVLF� QLQHWHHQWK�FHQWXU\� KLVWRU\� RI� WKH� 6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW� FULVLV� FDOOHG� WKH� RXWEUHDNV�HIIHFWV� �GLVDVWURXV� �� �� ��7KH� PDWHULDO� LQWHUHVWV� RI� WKH� SHRSOH� ORQJ� IHOW� LWV�EOLJKW��� +H�
FRQWLQXHG�� �)LHOGV� ZHUH� QHJOHFWHG��� D� VFDUFLW\� RI� IRRG� �DPRXQWLQJ� DOPRVW� WR� D�
IDPLQH�� SHUVLVWHG� IRU� D� WLPH�� IDUPV� ZHUH� PRUWJDJHG� RU� ORVW�� EXUGHQVRPH� GHEWV�
LQFXUUHG�� DQG� SHRSOH� GLVSHUVHG�� 6HH� 8SKDP�� 6DOHP� :LWFKFUDIW�� ��� ���� �TXRWDWLRQV����������� 0RUH� UHFHQWO\�� /DUU\� *UDJJ� DVVHUWHG� WKDW� �WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� WULDOV� FOHDUO\� LQWHU�
UXSWHG� WKH�QRUPDO� ZRUN� URXWLQH� RI�PDQ\� YLOODJHUV��� 6HH� *UDJJ�� 4XHVW� IRU� 6HFXULW\�� ����Q�� ���
���)RU� UHDVRQV� RI� HFRQRP\�� ,�ZLOO� IRFXV� RQO\� RQ� WKH� JURXS� FKDUDFWHULVWLFV� IRU� DOO�
SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� WD[� UROO� IRU� WKH� \HDU� ������ 'HWDLOHG� DQDO\VHV��ZKHWKHU� RI� LQGLYLGXDO� WD[SD\HUV� RU� SHUVLVWHUV� IRU� WKH� DVVHVVPHQWV� RI� ����� DQ�O� ������ZRXOG� QRW� FKDQJH� WKLV� DQDO\VLV�� %\� ����� 6DPXHO� 3DUULV� ZDV� QR� ORQJHU� PLQLVWHU� RI�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
7KLUW\�HLJKW� VLJQHUV� RI� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQ� VWLOO� DSSHDUHG� RQ�6DOHP�9LOODJHV� WD[�UROOV� LQ���������7KRXJK� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[�KDG�
SOXQJHG� EHORZ� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[�SDLG� E\� DOO� YLOODJH� WD[SD\HUV� DIWHU� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� RXWEUHDN�� E\� ����� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� WD[� ZDV�
DJDLQ� KLJKHU�WKDQ� WKH� DYHUDJH� YLOODJH� WD[�� MXVW� DV� LW�KDG� EHHQ� EHIRUH� WKH�RXWEUHDN��,QGHHG� WKH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�
PHDQ� WD[� WR� WKH� PHDQ�YLOODJH�
WD[� QRZ�
VWRRG� DW� �����KLJKHU� WKDQ� LW�KDG� EHHQ� LQ� ����� ������� 6LPLODUO\�� WKH�SUR�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[�� ZKLFK� ZDV�
HTXDO�WR� WKH�PHGLDQ� YLOODJH�
WD[� RQ� WKH� �����DQG� ����� OLVWV��ZDV� QRZ� KLJKHU� WKDQ� WKH�PHGLDQ� YLOODJH� WD[� �������7KH�
PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ�KDG� FOHDUO\� LPSURYHG� LWV�SRVLWLRQ� IURP� WKH�PRUH� LPPH�GLDWH� SRVWZLWFKFUDIW� \HDUV�� E\� ������ LW�ZDV�� DV� LW�KDG� EHHQ� EHIRUH� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� FULVLV�� PRUH� DIIOXHQW� WKDQ� WKH� YLOODJH� DYHUDJH��
7KH� FRQGLWLRQ� RI� WKH� IRUW\�RQH� DQWL�3DUULV� SHWLWLRQHUV� ZKR� SDLG� WD[HV�
LQ������ VKRZHG� OLWWOH�FKDQJH� IURP������DQG� QR� LQGLFDWLRQ� RI�DQ\�XSZDUG�PRYHPHQW� IURP� ������ 7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKHLU� PHDQ� WD[� LQ� ����� FRPSDUHG� ZLWK�
WKH�HQWLUH�YLOODJH� VWRRG� DW� �����PRGHVWO\� GRZQ� IURP������DQG� WKH�VDPH� DV�LQ������ DQG� ������7KH� UDWLR�RI� WKHLU�PHGLDQ� WD[� LQ������ FRPSDUHG� ZLWK�WKH� YLOODJH� PHDVXUHG� ����� DOVR� VRPHZKDW� ORZHU� WKDQ� LQ� ������ ZKHQ� WKHLU�
PHGLDQ� UDWH� ZDV� ����� EXW� QRWLFHDEO\� ORZHU� WKDQ� LQ� ������ ZKHQ� WKH� DQWL�
3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[�ZDV� DOPRVW� WZLFH� WKDW� RI� WKH� YLOODJH� �������
$V� D� UHVXOW� RI� WKHVH� YDU\LQJ� WUDMHFWRULHV�� WKH� ����� WD[� UROO� VKRZV� WKDW�
WKH�PLQLVWU\� JURXS� KDG� RQFH� DJDLQ� QDUURZHG� WKH�ZHDOWK� JDS�� MXVW�DV� WKH\�KDG� GRQH� LQ�WKH�GHFDGH� SUHFHGLQJ� WKH�ZLWFK� WULDOV��7KH� DYHUDJH� WD[�RI�WKH�
SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ�� ZKLFK� ZDV� RQO\� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� LWV� RSSRQHQWV� LQ� ������
UHDFKHG� ��� SHUFHQW� LQ�������$QG� WKH�SUR�3DUULV�PHGLDQ� LQ������ HTXDOHG�WKDW�RI� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� JURXS�� MXVW� DV� LW�KDG� LQ� ������7KXV�� HLJKW� \HDUV�DIWHU� WKH� ZLWFKFUDIW� GLVWXUEDQFH�� WKH� YLOODJHV� UHPDLQLQJ� SUR�3DUULV� SHWL�WLRQHUV� ZHUH�� DV� D� JURXS�� VLPLODUO\� VLWXDWHG� UHODWLYH� WR� WKH� YLOODJH� DQG� WR�
WKHLU�RSSRQHQWV� DV� WKH\�KDG� EHHQ� MXVW�SULRU� WR� WKH�RXWEUHDN���� )URP� WKH�
6DOHP� 9LOODJH�� +H� KDG� VWHSSHG� GRZQ� IURP� KLV� SRVLWLRQ� ZKHQ� KLV� FRQWUDFW� H[SLUHG� LQ�WKH�PLGGOH� RI� ������ $� QHZ� PLQLVWHU�� -RVHSK� *UHHQ�� ZDV� KLUHG� LQ� ODWH� ����� WR� UHSODFH�KLP��:LWK� 3DUULVV� GHSDUWXUH� DQG� WKH� IDGLQJ� RI� FRQWHQWLRQ� RYHU� WKH� YLOODJH� FKXUFK�� LW�EHFRPHV� DQDFKURQLVWLF� WR�XVH� WHUPV� VXFK� DV� SUR�� DQG� DQWL�3DUULV�� H[FHSW� UHJDUGLQJ� WKH�
SRVLWLRQV� WDNHQ� HDUOLHU�� 6HH� �%RRN� RI�5HFRUG��� LQ�+LVWRULFDO� &ROOHFWLRQV�� ���� �������
%R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�� 6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG�� ����� *UDJJ�� 4XHVW� IRU� 6HFXULW\�� �����������2QH� KXQGUHG� IRXUWHHQ� WD[SD\HUV� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� ����� WD[� OLVW�����7KH� IRUW\�RQH� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[SD\HUV� LQ� ����� LQFOXGHG� VHYHQ� PHQ� ZKR� KDG�
VLJQHG� WKH� ����� SHWLWLRQ� DV� �\RXQJ� PHQ"VL[WHHQ� \HDUV� ROG�� EXW� ZHUH� QRW� DVVHVVHG�WD[HV� LQ� WKDW� \HDU�� 7KH\� DSSHDUHG� RQ� WKH� YLOODJH� WD[� UROOV� LQ� ������ 6LQFH� VL[� RI� WKH�VHYHQ� �\RXQJ� PHQ�� ZHUH� LQ� WKH�ERWWRP� TXDUWLOH� RI� WD[SD\HUV� LQ� ������ LQFOXGLQJ� WKHP�LQ� WKH� OLVW� RI� DQWL�3DUULV� WD[SD\HUV� VRPHZKDW� VXSSUHVVHV� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� DYHUDJH� DQG�
PHGLDQ� UDWHV� DQG� PD\� WKHUHIRUHXQGHUVWDWH� WKLV� IDFWLRQV� HFRQRPLF� VWDQGLQJ� LQ� ������%XW� H[FOXGLQJ� WKHP� IURP� WKH� FDOFXODWLRQ� ZRXOG� QRW� FKDQJH� WKH�JHQHUDO� ILQGLQJV� WKDW�WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� ZDV� QRW� RXWSDFLQJ� WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� E\� GHFDGHV� HQG� DQG�WKDW�� LI�DQ\WKLQJ�� WKH� UHYHUVH� KHOG� WUXH�� ([FOXGLQJ� WKH� VHYHQ� \RXQJ� PHQ�� WKH� UHVXOWV�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
EURDGHU� FKURQRORJLFDO� SHUVSHFWLYH� RI� WKH� WZHQW\�\HDU�SHULRG� �����������LW�EHFRPHV� HYLGHQW� WKDW� WKRVH� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV� PLQLVWU\�IDFWLRQ� ZHUH� QRW� XQGHUJRLQJ�
D�ORQJ�WHUP� GHFOLQH�� DW� OHDVW� UHODWLYH� WR� WKHLU�
RSSRQHQWV�� ,QVWHDG� WKLV� JURXS� H[SHULHQFHG�D� ZDYHOLNH� PRYHPHQW��
DGYDQFHPHQW� XQWLO� WKH�ZLWFKFUDIW� FULVLV� HUXSWHG�� IROORZHG� E\� DQ� DOPRVW�FHUWDLQ� UHODWLYH� GHWHULRUDWLRQ� LQ� WKHLU� SRVLWLRQ�� DQG� ILQDOO\�
D� UHWXUQ� WR�
XSZDUG�PRPHQWXP� WKDW� OHIW�WKHP�FORVH� WR�ZKHUH� WKH\�KDG� VWRRG� LQ�WKH�
YLOODJH� LQ� ������ ,Q� ������ DV� LQ� ������ WKH\� FRXOG� FODLP� WR� EH� DQ� HFRQRPL�
FDOO\�DGYDQWDJHG� JURXS� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH� �)LJXUH� ,���
(TXDOO\� VWULNLQJ�ZDV� WKH�DQWLPLQLVWU\� JURXSV� IDLOXUH� WR�GHPRQVWUDWH�
DQ\� QRWHZRUWK\� XSZDUG�PRYHPHQW��
&RPSDUHG� ZLWK� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�WD[�
SD\HUV�� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� DFWXDOO\� GHFOLQHG� GXULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG�� ,Q������ LWV� DYHUDJH� WD[�ZDV� ���� WLPHV� JUHDWHU� WKDQ� WKH� YLOODJH� DYHUDJH�� 7ZHQW\�
\HDUV� ODWHU� LW�ZDV� RQO\� ���� WLPHV� JUHDWHU�� 7KH� JURXSV� PHGLDQ� WD[�UHJLV�
WHUHG�WKH�VDPH�GHFOLQH�� GURSSLQJ� IURP�����WR�����WLPHV� WKH�YLOODJH�PHGLDQ�WD[��$V� D� UHVXOW� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� QRW� RQO\� IDLOHG� WR� VXUJH� DKHDG� RI�WKH�PLQLVWU\� IDFWLRQ� GXULQJ� WKLV�SHULRG�� DV�%R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXP� FRQ�
WHQGHG�� EXW� DOVR� ORVW� JURXQG�WR� 3DUULV� VXSSRUWHUV�� 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� PHGLDQ�
WD[� LQ������KDG� EHHQ� RQO\� ���SHUFHQW� RI� WKH�DQWL�3DUULV� WD[��EXW� E\� �����WKH� PHGLDQ� WD[HV� ZHUH� HTXDO�� 7KH� UDWLR� RI� WKH� DYHUDJH� WD[�� ZKLFK� KDG�
VWRRG� DW� ����� LQ� ������ URVH� WR� ����� WZHQW\� \HDUV� ODWHU��
7KHUH� DUH� OLPLWDWLRQV� WR�ZKDW� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�WD[� OLVWV� FDQ� VD\� DERXW�
WKH� DFWXDO� ZHDOWK� RI� LWV� LQKDELWDQWV�� OHW�DORQH� KRZ� WKH\�GHULYHG� WKHLU�ZHDOWK�� (YHQ� GLVFRXQWLQJ� WKH�PHWKRGRORJLFDO� SUREOHPV� RI� WUDFLQJ� WKH�IRUWXQHV�RI�YLOODJHUV�ZKR� PRYHG� LQ�DQG� RXW� RI� WKH�WD[�UROOV�� WKH� OLVWV�FDQ�QRW� GHOLQHDWH� ZLWK� FHUWDLQW\�ZKHWKHU� LQKDELWDQWV� DFWXDOO\� LPSURYHG� WKHLU�VWDQGDUG� RI� OLYLQJ� RU� IHOO� RQ� KDUG� WLPHV� GXULQJ� WKHVH� WZHQW\� \HDUV��
0RUHRYHU� WKH� WD[� UROOV� FDQQRW� DGGUHVV� D�SHUVRQV� LQYROYHPHQW� LQ� RU� SV\�
FKRORJLFDO� UHODWLRQVKLS� WR� FDSLWDOLVP� RU� D�PDUNHW� HFRQRP\��
'HVSLWH� WKHVH�GUDZEDFNV� WKH� UHFRUGV� DUH�YDOXDEOH� LQGLFDWLRQV� RI� WKH�UHODWLYH�VWDQGLQJ� RI�6DOHP�9LOODJH� WD[SD\HUV�GXULQJ� WZR�GHFDGHV�� $QG� E\�D�
YDULHW\� RI� DSSURDFKHV� DQG� PHDVXUHPHQWV�� ZKHWKHU� IRFXVLQJ�RQ� LQGLYLGXDO�
RU� JURXS� FKDUDFWHULVWLFV�� WKH� GDWD� XQGHUPLQH� WKH� %R\HU� DQG� 1LVVHQEDXP�
WKHVLV� DW� YLUWXDOO\� HYHU\� SRLQW�� ,I� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� IRUFHV� ZHUH� DW� WKH� IRUH�
IURQW� RI�PHUFDQWLOH� FDSLWDOLVP�� WKH\� ZHUH� QRW�JDLQLQJ� DQ\� VSHFLDO� DGYDQ�
WDJH��0RUH� VLJQLILFDQWO\�� WKHLU� LQLWLDO� FOHDU�FXW� HGJH� RYHU� 3DUULVV�
VXSSRUWHUV� HURGHG� DV� WKDW�JURXS� LPSURYHG� LWV�UHODWLYH� HFRQRPLF� SRVLWLRQ�RYHU� WLPH�� 7KH� WD[� UROOV� GR� QRW� VXSSRUW� WKH� FODLP� WKDW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV�
VWLOO� VKRZ� WKDW� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� IDFWLRQ� ZDV� FDWFKLQJ� XS��:KHUH� WKH� SUR�3DUULV� JURXSV�DYHUDJH� WD[�ZDV� ��� SHUFHQW� RI� WKH� DQWL�3DUULV� JURXSV� WD[� LQ� ������ LW�VWRRG� DW� ��� SHU�FHQW� LQ� ������ 7KH� SUR�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[�KDG� JDLQHG� DV�ZHOO�� DGYDQFLQJ� IURP� ��� WR� ���SHUFHQW� RI� LWV�ULYDOV��
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
:(5(�:,7&+�+817(56� 02'(51,=$7,216� )$,/85(6"� ����
����
����
����
����
����
����
YWI!;� YW" !� YW" � [W" � ?"���
)LJXUH� ,�
7KH� UDWLR� RI� SUR�� WR� DQWL�3DUULV� PHGLDQ� WD[HV�GXULQJ� WZHQW\� \HDUV� GHPRQ�
VWUDWHV� WKH� RVFLOODWLQJ� VWDQGLQJ� RI� WKH�PLQLVWHUV� VXSSRUWHUV� LQ� UHODWLRQVKLS� WR�
KLV� RSSRQHQWV��
JURXS� ODVKHG� RXW� LQ�UHVHQWPHQW� LQ� ����� DJDLQVW� WKRVH�ZKR� UHSUHVHQWHG�WKH� VXSHULRU� IRUFHV�RI�PRGHUQL]DWLRQ�� ,I�DQ\� JURXS� KDG� UHDVRQ� WR�FRP�
SODLQ�� LW�ZDV� WKH�PLQLVWHUV� RSSRQHQWV����
���8VLQJ� JHRJUDSKLF� LQIRUPDWLRQ� V\VWHPV� WHFKQRORJ\�� %HQMDPLQ� &�� 5D\� IDLOHG� WR�
ILQG� D� JHRJUDSKLF� GLYLVLRQ� LQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� VHSDUDWLQJ� D� SRRUHU� ZHVWHUQ� DUHD� IURP�
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
���� :,//,$0� $1'�0$5<�48$57(5/<�
7KRXJK� %R\HU� DQG�1LVVHQEDXPV� LGHQWLILFDWLRQ� RI� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�IDFWLRQDO� GLYLVLRQV� UHPDLQV� RQH� RI� WKHLU� ODVWLQJ� FRQWULEXWLRQV� WR� WKH�
VFKRODUVKLS� RI� 6DOHP� ZLWFKFUDIW�� WKHLU� UHOLDQFH� RQ� WKH� DQRPDORXV� ����� WD[�
DVVHVVPHQW�H[DJJHUDWHG� WKH� YLOODJHV� FODVV� GLYLVLRQV� DQG� VXJJHVWHG�
D�
EURDGHU� HFRQRPLF� G\QDPLF� WKDW� LV�QRW� VXSSRUWHG� E\� WKH� HYLGHQFH��
([SODLQLQJ� ZKDW� KDSSHQHG� LQ�6DOHP�9LOODJH� LQ������ZLOO� WDNH�D�GLIIHUHQW�VRUW�RI� WKHVLV� IURP� WKDW�RIIHUHG� LQ�6DOHP� 3RVVHVVHG��0RVW� FHUWDLQO\�� LW�VKRXOG� QRW�PDNH� WKH�PLVWDNH� RI�DVVXPLQJ� WKDW�WKRVH� DVVRFLDWHG� ZLWK� UHOL�
JLRQ�� VXFK� DV� WKH� VXSSRUWHUV� RI� 3DUULVV� FKXUFK�� ZHUH�QHFHVVDULO\� HQJDJHG�
LQ� D� EDWWOH� DJDLQVW� HFRQRPLF� LPSURYHPHQW�� WKH�PDUNHW�� RU�PRGHUQLW\����
WKH�ZHDOWKLHU� HDVW� WKDW� ERUGHUHG� WKH� FRPPHUFLDO� 6DOHP� 7RZQ�� ,QVWHDG� ZHDOWK� ZDV�
GLVWULEXWHG� �IDLUO\� KRPRJHQHRXVO\� DFURVV� WKH� FRPPXQLW\��� 6HH� 5D\�� �7HDFKLQJ� WKH�6DOHP� :LWFK� 7ULDOV��� LQ�3DVW� 7LPH�� 3DVW� 3ODFH�� *,6� IRU� +LVWRU\�� HG�� $QQH� .HOO\�.QRZOHV� �5HGODQGV�� &DOLI��� ������� ������ �TXRWDWLRQ�� �����
��� ,�KDYH� VXJJHVWHG� HOVHZKHUH� WKDW� UHOLJLRXV� GLVFRUG� FRQFHUQLQJ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJHV�FKXUFK� EHWWHU� H[SODLQV� WKH� YLOODJHV� IDFWLRQDOLVP� DQG� LWV�FRQWULEXWLRQ� WR� WKH� HYHQWV� RI�
����� DQG� WKDW� WKH� JHRJUDSKLF� DQG� FKURQRORJLFDO� SDWWHUQ� RI� DFFXVDWLRQV� LQ� ����� LV�EHVW�
H[SODLQHG� E\� WKH� SHUVLVWHQFH� RI� WUDGLWLRQDO� ZLWFKFUDIW� EHOLHIV� UDWKHU� WKDQ� FRQIOLFWV�
VWHPPLQJ� IURP� FDSLWDOLVPV� DGYDQFH�� 6HH� 5LFKDUG� /DWQHU�� �+HUH� $UH� 1R� 1HZWHUV��:LWFKFUDIW� DQG� 5HOLJLRXV� 'LVFRUG� LQ� 6DOHP� 9LOODJH� DQG� $QGRYHU��� 1HZ� (QJODQG�4XDUWHUO\� ���� QR�� �� �0DUFK� ������� �������� /DWQHU�� �7KH� /RQJ� DQG� 6KRUW� RI� 6DOHP�:LWFKFUDIW�� &KURQRORJ\� DQG� &ROOHFWLYH� 9LROHQFH� LQ� ������� -RXUQDO� RI�6RFLDO� +LVWRU\���� �IRUWKFRPLQJ���
This content downloaded from 146.96.128.36 on Wed, 22 Jan 2014 14:30:32 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions